W01. Policy dismantling: linking processes and impacts
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
In the last decade, the study of policy dismantling has expanded. From being mostly about social policy termination in developed countries, the literature has looked at new countries and sectors. The literature on policy dismantling, for the most part, has explained the process of dismantling, the factors, and motivations behind it, as well as the approaches taken to dismantle policies (Bauer and Knill, 2014; Jordan, 2013). From different perspectives, the disciplines of political science, public administration, and public policy have provided explanations as to why and when politicians terminate policies, along with how they execute the act of dismantling (such as whether they do so transparently or attempt to shift blame). Nonetheless, a distinct aspect has been widely disregarded: the effects of policy dismantling. The purpose of this workshop is to connect the current research on the process of policy dismantling with an examination of its consequences. Just like any other type of policy change, policy dismantling affects the groups it aims to target, can cause organizational and institutional changes, and may set off feedback loops. Policy dismantling refers to the termination of policy interventions and the reduction of policy benefits or the number of beneficiaries. Bauer and Knill (2012) propose two dimensions that define policy dismantling: policy density, which refers to the number of policies and instruments used in a certain policy area, and policy intensity, which refers to the strictness and/or generosity of policies. Based on this distinction, Jordan et al. (2013) define policy dismantling as a policy change that reduces the number of policies and instruments, or lowers their intensity in a particular area. The dismantling of policies has become a topic of great interest in recent years. The effects of this process have been studied extensively and offer a fruitful research agenda. The literature on termination grew in the late 2000s due to the financial crisis, which led to austerity policies being implemented worldwide. These policies included budget cuts, deregulation, reductions in public services, rollbacks of benefits, and decreases in policy coverage (Jordan et al., 2013). Environmental policies have also been dismantled in both developed and developing countries, leading to discussions about the methods used to do so (Pollex and Lenchow, 2020; Goulart-Menezes and Barbosa, 2021). Recent analyses of scholars interested in populist or new authoritarian regimes have looked at policy changes that reduce policy capacities in central governments and put limits on welfare or environmental policies (Moynihan and Roberts, 2021; Dussauge, 2021). The dismantling of policies has also been studied at the supranational level (Gravey and Jordan, 2016) and the subnational level (Volden, 2016).
POLICY TOPICS
W03. Analyzing and conceptualizing international public policies: towards a sociology of the policy process approach
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Since the 1990s the attention of public policy scholars has increasingly shifted from the national (and European) level to the international and global levels of public policy (Knill and Tosun, 2013: 223). With the second globalization, associated to growing economic and technological interdependency between states, so as to the acceleration of international transport and communication possibilities, public policies are more and more analyzed beyond the Nation State. This shift of the attention from national (and local) levels to supranational levels has triggered two evolutions in the literature. The first one is the development of “global policies” studies, as the creation of journals dedicated to these new policy levels illustrates (Global Policy, Global Social Policy…). Global public policies can be defined as: “the processes of transnational cooperation and conflict, involving both state and non-state (domestic and international) agents, by which policies are produced to problems related to the global scale” (Porto de Oliveira, 2022: 63). The focus is on the role of transnational actors and interactions in the global circulation of policy ideas and policy instruments. It encompasses different supranational dimensions of a public policy. The making of public policy in a context of globalization is subject to circulations, transfers and adaptations according to dominant accounts of 'best practices'. While the intensification of these flows is widely acknowledged and public policy and administration studies have developed sound comparative approaches, relatively less attention is being paid to the analysis and conceptualization of international public policy-making by states but also international public administrations and their bureaucracies, transnational corporations and their forms of transnational mobilization, as well as transnational NGOs and citizen grassroots organizations and their transnational reach. This is why this workshop is more focused on the second perspective: the analysis of international public policies, combining public policy and international relations perspectives. Even if the difference and boundaries with global public policies is not always clear and the overlaps are important, the notion of international public policy is more specifically focused on the role of international (intergovernmental) organizations in the tackling of policy issues historically developed at local and national levels. Our specific objective is to foreground sociological analyses of international policy-making and policy processes (notably issue framing, agenda setting, policy formulation, decision-making and implementation). The development of international public policies has started with the shaping of the first international organizations in the second half of the 19th century for transport, trade, communication and public health issues. This trend has been strengthened with the creation of new international organizations after WWII, in relation with the United Nations, especially for refugees (HCR), health (WHO), food and agriculture issues (FAO), and for global economic governance with the Bretton Woods institutions. The scope of public policies tackled by international organizations has widened at the end of the 20th century with the creation of the UNEP (1972) and the WTO (1994). International organizations have become a classical dimension of international relations, yet they are still marginal in the public policy field which has more developed the analysis of transnational actors, especially transnational expertise, based on the notion of “epistemic communities” (Haas, 1992). In international relations perspectives the role of international organizations has been notably analyzed with the notion of “international regimes” (Krasner, 1983), which has been adapted to public policies issues (especially international trade) and not only to issues linked to war and peace. The starting point of this workshop is the analysis of the shaping and development of international public policy regimes combining the four dimensions of a public policy (Hassenteufel, 2021): -a dominant orientation, based on the framing of the key policy issues, in relation with the use of knowledge and values; -international and transnational actors structured around these issues: international organizations, NGOs, think tanks, multinational companies, foundations, epistemic communities…; -institutionalized rules of interactions between international, national and transnational policy actors; -policy instruments: not only regulatory also financial, fiscal, economic… The aim of the workshop is to discuss methodological and conceptual issues related to international public policy regimes in various policy fields: health, migrations, environment, food and agriculture, trade, energy, economic development, education, social policies, financial and monetary regulation… From a methodological point of view, the focus of the workshop is on the sociological analysis of these international and transnational policy actors at the different stages of international public policy processes: -Problem framing by various actors and agenda setting in international organizations and arenas; -Policy formulation, focusing on the role of international and transnational expertise in the shaping of international policy instruments; -Policy decision, based on international negotiations on policy issues, including geopolitical and political dimensions for the understanding of the position and strategies of the participating states; -Policy implementation in a multi-level perspective, considering that most of the international public policy instruments are not compulsory (soft law, incentives…), what gives more room to national and local actors involved in the implementation than at other policy levels. Therefore, the main methodological issues raised by this workshop are: -the internal analysis of international organizations and of transnational actors with qualitative methods (ethnography, observation…), used in public administration and international relations (Ege, Bauer, 2013), also in sociology of mobilization and sociology of interest groups perspectives; -the interactions between the different policy actors acting in international arenas (also between international organizations which often compete on the same policy issues, between states with different political and geopolitical orientations, between transnational actors who are often structured in coalitions…) by using qualitative (interviews, observation…) and quantitative methods (especially network analysis); -the empirical analysis of the implementation of international policy instruments at national and local levels. Our workshop thus seeks to bring together contributions from a wide range of sectors, across different levels of analysis, and in relation to different categories of actors in order to nourish collective discussions around the making and implementation of international public policies. To illustrate these points through a few emblematic examples, we can mention key international actors in the fields of health, migration and the environment, such as the WHO, the IOM and the UNFCC. While these three thematic issues arguably undergo an intensification of internationalization by being increasingly constructed as a ‘global issue’, the corresponding international regimes raise different, yet complementary, conceptual questions. While international health regulations of the World Health Organization (WHO) date back to 1969, the organization has since then developed a series of global policy tools. It has for instance encouraged the creation of ‘public health emergency operations centers’ at national levels for the dissemination of best practices and it has built a global network around them. This IO has also established in 2011 the ‘Pandemic Influenza Preparedness Framework’ to facilitate creation and access of influenza vaccines, supporting hence international convergence in health-related public policies. More recently, the elaboration of the ‘Covid-19 Strategic Preparedness and Response Plan’ has foregrounded the organization’s global policy reach. While the WHO represents a key actor for health-related international public policies, notably through the establishment of global health standards, the deployment of capacity-building programs and the implementation of global public awareness campaigns, it is facing criticism regarding transparency in policy formulation and decision which foregrounds the broader question of legitimacy and constituency for the policy cycle of international public policies. In the field of migration governance, a stronghold of sovereign power, the past decades have also seen the development of supranational instruments, notably following the 2016 New York declaration for migrants and refugees, adopted by the UN General Assembly, that acknowledged the need for more international cooperation and paved the way for the 2018 Global Compact for Safe, Orderly and Regular Migration. While the Compact is not legally binding and has thus been critiqued as to its limited policy implementation potential, the inclusive process that led to its adoption, with an active role played by NGOs and civil society organizations at different preparatory stages, sustains the instrument’s relevance to migration-related public policies and the international arenas thus created carve out space for enhanced policy transfers. Our third example, policies and instruments under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change amount by now to a UN climate change regime with a complex and continuously developing governance. The 2015 Paris Agreement represent for instance a global and legally binding treaty articulated with national public policies through climate action plans that determine countries’ state-level contributions. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) constitutes furthermore a primary example of a transnational epistemic community holding an institutionalized role in setting an agenda for the making of international climate policies (De Pryck, 2022). Overall, the aim of this workshop is to go a step further in the conceptualization of the development of international public policies by combining different analytical perspectives analyzing sociologically international relations and policy processes : sociology of internal organizations, the role of international and transnational policy communities in the framing of policy issues, analysis of multilevel negotiations, the structuration of instrument constituencies, the mobilization and structuration of transnational policy actors…
POLICY TOPICS
W04. Parliaments as policy-making institutions
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This panel is oriented to increase our understanding regarding the role of parliaments as policy-making institutions covering a wide spectrum of legislative activities. Parliaments have been for long conceptualized as irrelevant institutions, tasked with approving policies negotiated elsewhere (Olson 1994, Kreppel 2014, Andersen and Burns, 1996; Russell and Cowley 2015). The executive is considered to control the agenda and the policy making process, and the opposition parliamentary groups are depicted as being passive and permissive, leading to high levels of parliamentary consensus. This literature has mainly conceptualized parliamentary groups as a unitary actor (focusing on the government vs opposition dichotomy) and relied on the analysis of formal rules and structures to draw conclusions and to develop opposition typologies (e.g. Sartori, 1966, Dahl 1966; Oberreuter, 1975; Blondel, 1997; Gelman, 2005; Kaiser, 2008, 2009, Norton 2008).The study of parliamentary opposition is also connected to the broader analysis of the strength and weakness of legislatures. Also conceived as unitary actors, the literature has explored the role of legislatures regarding two main questions (e.g. Mezey 1970, 1979; Polsby 1975; Olson and Norton 1996; Morgenstern 1998; Laver 1999). First, legislatures’ capacity: potential for action (what parliaments can do) based on the analysis of the opportunity structure defined by constitutional rules and internal organization and procedures. Second, legislatures’ efficiency: actual performance (what parliaments do) based on the analysis of parliaments bill’s production. From this literature, a number of typologies of legislatures have emerged, for example “transformative” or “talking” legislatures (Polsby 1975), “reactive” legislatures (Mezey, 1979), “policy-making” or “policy-influencing” legislatures (Baldwin 2004). However, the picture of weak legislatures and oppositions has been challenged by recent literature signaling that both government success and opposition failure might have been overstated (e.g. Russel et al 2017; Cowley 2016). On the one hand, the euro crisis and the rise of new radical parties ended the consensual politics that characterized the legislative process in most European parliaments (DeGiorgi and Ilonszky 2018). On the other hand, conclusions on executive preponderance have relied disproportionately on the study of visible influence, with a focus on early or late stages of the policy-making process: the success rate of bills or the final vote on legislation (Russell and Cowley, 2016). In other words, the capacity of parliamentary groups to influence policy making along the legislative process is a question largely ignored by existing research. Many stages of the parliamentary process allow legislators to participate in policy making. The amendatory process is one where research is in its infancy. Defined as the “black hole” of the legislative process (Capano and Vignati 2008:35) we know very little regarding legislators’ incentives for introducing amendments, and also regarding their capacity for having these amendments passed (see Damgaard and Jensen 2006; Shepard and Carney 2005; Griffith 1994; Russel and Cowley 2016; Russel et al. 2016). Amendments are examined and discussed in parliamentary committees oriented, among other aspects, to provide expert evaluation regarding the pros and cons associated to different policy-making alternatives. Recent research show that legislators respond to variations in both governmental factors and bargaining dynamics. Palau et al (2023) have demonstrated, for instance, that amending activity reacts to attention allocation dynamics – mediatised bills receive more amendments. But still, we need more research to understand better when and why amendments are policymaking tools or if there are other political and contextual variables that explain which amendments are more successful than others. In addition to considering the legislative activity of parliamentary groups, one of the objectives of this panel is to better understand their interaction with civil society, more specifically with interest groups that interact with parliamentarians throughout the legislative process through formal and informal channels (Lisi and Muñoz, 2019). Conventional wisdom is that core compromises with interest organizations on legislation are negotiated during the pre-parliamentary phase. Nonetheless, parliaments and parliamentary groups are not isolated from the interaction with extra parliamentary actors, such as interest groups. Ideally, parliamentary groups should not be responsive to interest groups, as they serve the interests of the majority of citizens and not of specific organized interests (Lohmann 1993). Yet, research on interest groups highlights that they work as transmission belts of citizens' concerns (Albareda and Braun, 2018). They provide policy makers useful policy information and simultaneously aggregate and represent diverse constituency interests (Berkhout et al., 2017a; Kohler-Koch and Quittkat, 2013). However, scarce research has been done, on this topic. We know that interest groups are invited to parliamentary hearings to highlight governmental failures during minority governments and to legitimize highly conflictive issues during majority governments (Chaqués and Muñoz, 2016). This means parliamentary groups and interest groups follow a partisan and contingent logic though constrained by formal institutional rules. Also we know, that hey provide policy makers useful policy information and simultaneously aggregate and represent diverse constituency interests (Berkhout et al., 2017a; Kohler-Koch and Quittkat, 2013).There is some evidence that interest groups policy advising and thus transfer information -both in the pre-parliamentary stage and during the legislative procedure- is mainly driven by few interest groups that concentrate most of the interaction with government and parliamentary committees. This is specially the case of NGOs, while hundreds of them are part of governmental advisory bodies and hearings in parliament, only few are invited more than once (Muñoz and Orué, 2021). However, there are still a number of unanswered questions: what types of groups interact most with parliamentary groups? What does this interaction depend on - media issues (media attention paid to laws discussed in parliament), the power that interest groups have in particular sectors, the type of government? To what extent are the testimonies of interest groups during hearings taken into account when laws are amended? In sum, the interest on the functioning of parliamentary committees has increased but we still have little empirical information regarding their actual role as policymaking institutions. In sum, the interest on the functioning of parliamentary committees has increased but we still have little empirical information regarding their actual role as policymaking institutions. This panel seeks to answer such questions by focusing on the behaviour of parliamentary groups and their legislative activity, as well as their interaction with interest groups.
POLICY TOPICS
W05. Policymaking from theory and practice: Latin American-driven debates.
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The field of public policy has experienced significant growth and has attracted considerable scholarly attention. Within this discipline, various theories have emerged with the aim of comprehensively understanding and elucidating the complex process of public decision-making. The analysis of this subject matter entails an examination of the social construct, necessitating a comprehension of its construction and the specific dynamics of the state-society relationship within a certain sector. Various methods of experiencing, observing, and researching the nature of reality give rise to diverse theoretical and methodological views aimed at providing explanations. The availability of diverse analytical techniques for examining public policies has contributed to the exploration of alternative paradigms and theoretical frameworks that address the wide-ranging elements encompassed within the policy process. These elements include individuals, institutions, ideas, discourses and narratives, governance, and levels of action. The discussed concepts have originated from the global north, and their applicability to other locations has demonstrated their limitations in analyzing divergent realities characterized by "hybrid cultures" (Canclini, 1987). Latin American reality is characterized by a weak level of development in the discipline. This progress is hindered by several factors. Firstly, the historical heritage, the challenge posed by language barriers when engaging in multilevel debates. This language barrier also extends to the educational level, impeding access to recent studies, which are predominantly in English, as well as the cost associated with accessing a large number of publications. While this situation may have resulted in a dearth of theoretical underpinnings, analytical frameworks, concepts, and methodologies tailored to the Latin American context, it has nonetheless shaped a modus operandi characterized by a combination of diverse perspectives and the utilization of "distinct" public policy experiences that could contribute to discussions at the national, regional, and international levels. In light of this scenario, it is crucial to acknowledge the significance of comprehending both the empirical knowledge that can be derived from specific cases within the region and the current situation of the development of the theories of policy process (Sabatier & Weible, 2014) in Latin America to understand how to advance and improve from these two dimensions. From the theories of the policy process dimension, this proposition aims to assess how we are using mainstream theories, what they bring to us, whether they need to be adjusted to the context. Second, from the critical and interpretative approaches, highlighting their differential contributions compared to mainstream approaches. Third, we want to highlight homegrown contributions, whether at the level of theories or concepts or key contextual factors for understanding the realities of the Region. We are particularly interested in how our own contributions dialogue with the approaches of the global North. Then the following questions are suggested: What characteristics distinguish policy analysis in the region? What is the current situation of policy process theory development? How are their comprehended and utilized? What concrete contributions have been made to the study of Latin American public policies?. Such insights can greatly contribute to the ongoing discourse around the examination of public policies and further enrich our comprehension of the prevailing theories pertaining to the policy process both at the regional and worldwide levels. From the empirical dimension, this panel seeks to promote a regional debate on public policy by highlighting the region's unique characteristics and contributions to policy-making. Thus, it encourages papers that discuss policy contributions to problem-solving with a specific case, such as cash transfers programs, participatory budget initiatives, bus rapid transit programs, metropolitan governance, infant industry development policies, and anti-corruption policies, among others. Additionally, it encourages propositions to debate empirical insights into issues from the theories of policy process when they apply to examine Latin American cases. These topics should serve only as an indication of the type of discussion the panel intends to prompt. Theoretical and factual knowledge are vital to policy studies; indeed, public policies are defined from these two theoretical and empirical perspectives. In this regard, Engeli and Rothmayr (2014) stress, for example, that "the field of public policy analysis comprises broadly two different, related, and equally valuable scholarly enterprises: to provide knowledge and policy expertise in and for policymaking [...] and to develop general theories and frameworks of the policy process explaining and predicting the policy-making process" (p. 2). Fontaine (2015), from the Latin American level, states that "public policy analysis has a scientific function (to improve knowledge) and a political function (to improve action and decision-making)." (p. 6). The objective is to begin a long-lasting discussion about policy studies in LA in order to recognize more fully and transparently what the region has offered and how the field can proliferate in our region. As part of the objective, the panel will attempt to seek and arrive at an editorial project. Studies and students of public policy have proliferated around the globe. Arguably, the field of research may have reached a point where regional contributions are now part of the mainstream of studies. Despite the richness in scope and breadth of the studies about public policy, further ways to push the knowledge frontiers of this field are still to be explored. Then, this panel aims to promote a regional debate in public policy, looking for the particularities and contributions of this region to public policy analyses. This panel invites authors to engage with the question about the Latin American regional contribution to the field. As in many other fields of knowledge, authors in the region may have offered key developments, either on the grounds of theory, methodology, or even further, in terms of an innovative epistemological approach. However, such voices may have been eclipsed or overseen somehow due to a recurrent centralization of knowledge production, placing greater emphasis on authors and ideas that are able to publish in the US and Europe. The panel offers a unique opportunity to discuss the region's advancements and contributions to the study of public policy. Papers with the following topics are welcome: · Well-established contributions that were allegedly developed first in LA or by an author in the region, alluding to cases of LA · Specific policies in LA that have been regarded as worldwide valuable ideas or international contributions (ex. participatory budgets, cash-transfer programs, bus rapid transport, · Applications of theories of the policy process (country or in a comparative way) in the LA context that have raised questions, prompted revisions, or placed key critiques on the mainstream approaches within the policy studies. Or in other words: What are the specific theoretical contributions from the Latin America? How do they contrast with Global North theories? What insights do they provide about the policy processes? How do they represent the development countries particularities? · How have “mainstream” or “alternatives” theories of the Global North been applied, and what have we learned about the theories and the region? · Methodological innovations in the field that have been initiated in LA may be part of the peculiar features that researchers face in the region (or due to some other reason). · Specific features of and within policies in LA that have been shaped by the political regime, culture, or other socio-political traits available in the region.
POLICY TOPICS
W06. Towards a Third Wave of Policy Advice and Policy Advisory System (PAS) Thinking: Re-envisioning Policy Advisory Dynamics and Quality
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Policy advice is a critical function in current polities. Over the past four decades, the study of its creation, diffusion and use has evolved dramatically from the original idea that policy advice existed in a relatively straightforward space where three communities of suppliers, brokers and consumers of policy advice existed in a more or less linear relationship (Manwaring 2019). As more actors were progressively incorporated into notions of advice systems, the interactions among the actors (Maloney, Jordan, and McLaughlin 1994), the potential complexity of the dynamics among actors increased. This led to efforts to better describe and categorize actually existing advisory systems and to a new literature grappling with these issues. As the literature tried to make sense of differences among advisors it famously looked at dimensions such as where they ‘resided’ (inside or outside of government) and how much control governments had on the activities would allow us to rank their impact on policy advice (Halligan 1995). The notion of Policy Advisory Systems (PAS) grew around this work and developed a significant comparative aspect. While, evidently, in terms of impact it matters where advisors are located and if they are proximate or peripheral actors and it is clear that these relationships vary by jurisdiction and sector (Howlett 2014), this research has grappled with but not yet succeeded in addressing several other important questions. These include, for example, the impact of changes in government and governance styles on advisory systems, the specific links which exist in such systems between different actors and how these are important, the links, if any, between types of ideas and types of actors, and the general question of how advisory systems change and develop over time. Some work suggests, for example, that advisory systems have changed over the last several decades in terms of their increased politicization and the general growth of external sources of advice and suggests these two dimensions are interconnected and interrelated and that they overlap, influence, multiple other characteristics of the PAS, such as but not limited to policy capacity, the role of elected policy-makers as well as of administrators, the nature of policy issue faced, and others. Much of this work has been conducted on only a few countries, however, mainly in the OECD and especially in Anglo-American or Westminister systems and some evidence of contrary movements in other jurisdictions exists (CITE Belyaeva 2019, Howlett 2019. Notions that, for example, abstract advice about policy goals and preferences is generally the precinct of non-governmental outsiders and insiders while suggestions about instrument selection and operational matters are usually in the realm of insiders and core actors, remain alluring but unproven (Page 2010). Recently, a ‘third wave’ of PAS studies has emerged, growing upon this base of first generation description and 2nd generation comparative work (Craft and Wilder 2017). Building on the advances made in PAS studies to date, two areas have increasingly appeared in recent studies of Policy Advisory Systems relate to the dynamics of PAS and the quality of the advice provided. New 3rd generation work examines a wide range of questions, including for example, how PAS dynamics are affected by their management (Marciano and Craft 2023) and how their quality can be measured and enhanced (Migone and Howlett 2023). The workshop is particularly interested in papers which address multiple questions related to how the policy sciences literature can advance its capacity to understand both policy advice dynamics, the quality of policy advice and other ‘third wave’ issues. Bibliography: Craft, Jonathan, and Matt Wilder. 2017. “Catching a Second Wave: Context and Compatibility in Advisory System Dynamics: Policy Advisory System Dynamics.” Policy Studies Journal 45(1): 215–39. Halligan, John. 1995. “Policy Advice and the Public Sector.” In Governance in a Changing Environment, eds. B Guy Peters and Donald J. Savoie. Montréal and Kingston: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 138–72. Howlett, Michael. 2014. “Policy Design: What, Who, How and Why?” In L’instrumentation de l’action Publique: Controverses, Résistances, Effets, eds. Charlotte Halpern, Pierre Lascoumes, and Patrick Le Galès. Paris: Presses de Sciences Po, 281–316. Maloney, William A., Grant Jordan, and Andrew M. McLaughlin. 1994. “Interest Groups and Public Policy: The Insider/Outsider Model Revisited.” Journal of Public Policy 14(1): 17–38. Manwaring, Rob. 2019. “Political Demand and Policy Advice: A Framework for Analysis.” Policy Studies 40(3–4): 270–86. Marciano, Reut, and Jonathan Craft. 2023. “Theorising Policy Advisory System Management: Approaches and Practice.” Journal of Public Policy 43(3): 490–511. Migone, Andrea, and Michael Howlett. 2023. “Hirschman 2.0 or What Makes a Good Policy Advice System? A Theory of Policy Advice System Quality & Capacity.” https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=4554870 (August 29, 2023). Page, Edward C. 2010. “Bureaucrats and Expertise: Elucidating a Problematic Relationship in Three Tableaux and Six Jurisdictions.” Sociologie du travail 52(2): 255–73.
POLICY TOPICS
W08. How moral emotions affect the policy process
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
There is a long tradition in social science of downplaying the role of emotions and, more specifically, viewing an emotional approach toward politics as extreme and unreasonable (Beichelt 2022: 13). However, recently, the role of emotions in defining or influencing behaviour has been acknowledged, as illustrated by concepts like “Homo sentimentalis” (Illouz 2015), “Homo sapiens emotionalis” (Ciompi and Endert 2011) or simply “Homo emotionalis” (Beichelt 2022). Some argue that values, identities and emotions have indeed become more important in today’s societies (Scharfbillig et al 2021) and in behavioural and cognitive sciences we can even talk about “the era of affectivism”, as it has become increasingly difficult to deny that “emotions, feelings, motivations, moods, and other affective processes (...) are not only linked to our well-being but also shape our behaviour and drive key cognitive mechanisms such as attention, learning, memory, and decision-making” (Dukes et al. 2021: 816). This era is marked by a fast growth in terms of emotions-related research and publications, especially in the field of behavioural and cognitive sciences. It seems that social sciences, including political science, are somewhat lagging behind this trend. While in the past decade the importance of studying emotions has been recognised in political science as well, it seems too early to talk about a well-established field of research or a coherent research programme (Beichelt, 2022: 5). We lack solid empirical evidence as well as widely accepted theoretical models on the role of emotions, and especially moral emotions, in almost all aspects of politics. Conceptual and methodological problems abound, e.g.: How to define, categorise and measure political emotions? What kind of emotions play the most important role in politics? What is the process leading from moral emotions to the construction of identities that create target populations or constituencies for policy change? How to analyse the interplay of emotions with other political variables, like values and beliefs? What is the analytical model that grasps the best the role of emotions in political action: should we consider them dependent, independent variables; or both? What type of methods and indicators are the most useful for studying the political role of emotions? (See Lynggaard 2019.) What is true for political science as such holds even more for the field of policy studies. It has been recognized that emotions play a significant role in the public policy process, influencing agenda setting, decision-making, policy formulation, and implementation (Leong, 2016). Emotions can shape public opinion, mobilize support or opposition, interact with policy advise, affect the acceptance of implementation, in short, impact the overall policy landscape. However, while there is a growing scholarship in the field, the above listed conceptual as well as methodological dilemmas are still pressing. Emotions also play an under-researched role in evidence-based policy tools, such as consultation and more generally stakeholders’ engagement in rulemaking and policy formulation. Does the presence of emotions hinder consultation or can it foster the participation of otherwise silenced actors (see: https://www.hiljaisettoimijat.fi/?lang=en)? Does emotional reasoning help or disrupt the overall evidential reasoning in the practice of regulatory impact assessment (Rantala et al. 2023)? Cairney and Weible (2017: 623) describe three primary ways that emotion is used in policy process research: attention to public problems; to persuade and influence judgements about target populations; and to mobilise coalitions of policy actors. Attention to public problems is a key element in agenda setting and according to punctuated equilibrium theory (PET), emotional arousal can increase attention to public problems: “Emotion is the gateway to selective attention: when emotion is roused, attention follows” (Jones and Baumgartner, 2005: 16). Emotional framing can be used by policy entrepreneurs not only to illicit attention, but also to undermine the legitimacy of dominant policy images and create enthusiasm for new ideas and images. Emotions are present in the Multiple Streams Framework (MSF) as well: Zahariadis (2015) argues that changes in the national mood can open an agenda window in the politics stream; and national mood is conceptualized as a collective emotion felt by the public. However, emotions can support stability instead of change: Zahariadis (2015) describes how a focusing event triggered fear among the public and how a fearful nation supported policy continuity rather than a policy change promoted by a policy entrepreneur. Under which conditions can emotions lead to either policy change or stability is one of the puzzles of the field. Studies have shown that negative emotions, such as fear and disgust, can lead to a negative evaluation of policies and make them less attractive to stakeholders (Leong, 2016). Conversely, positive emotions can drive public support and engagement, leading to constructive feedback and policy improvement (Yang & Su, 2020). But in other instances negative emotions can trigger change: fear is one of the powerful emotions which are often exploited by policy entrepreneurs (see Jenneing et al, 2017). Renström and Bäck (2021) studying COVID-related policies argue that different emotions elicit support for different kinds of measures: fear and anger predict support for restrictive policies to limit the spread of the virus, while anxiety predicts support for economic policies. Therefore, addressing the issue of emotional valence of policies, how to measure it, and how it affects the support of governmental measures are relevant research questions. Concerning the role of emotions in influencing judgements about target populations, according to both the narrative policy framework (NPF) (Shanahan et al, 2018) and the theory of social construction (Schneider and Ingram, 1997), policy actors frame characters and target populations using positive and negative emotions: those positively framed are either victims or heroes, and those negatively framed are villains. Emotions concerning target populations can affect the support of punitive measures in penal policy, of social benefits in social policy as well as of other proposals including gay marriage, and restrictions in immigration policy. According to Cairney and Weible (2017: 623) emotions are also important in mobilising coalitions for policy change. Both the Advocacy Coalition Framework and the NPF hypothesize that in political conflicts policy actors will experience angel and devil shifts: in an angel shift, policy actors perceive their allies as benevolent and powerful, while in the devil shift, opponents are perceived as powerful but also malicious (Pierce, 2021). However, apart from focusing attention, affecting judgements about target populations and mobilising policy coalitions, emotions are obviously present in every stage of the policy process. Emotions can impact the deliberation process, as public officials may find it challenging to handle emotions in the context of policy deliberation (Fink et al, 2023), and emotions influence policy formulation and policy design through their interactions with expert discourses (Durnová and Hejzlarová, 2017, 2022). The problem with the use of strong moral-emotional discourses in politics and policy is that they make more difficult, or even impossible, to have meaningful dialogue on these issues, and instead of solving social problems, which should be the ultimate goal of policy making, they make them worse and may even create new ones. While disregarding emotions in policy practice may lead to adverse policy outcomes (Borén et al, 2020) and public discontent concerning policy measures (see the example of COVID-19 related policies), ‘overemotionalisation’ may cause considerable difficulties in conducting policy deliberation and designing policies. The above said apply to emotions in general. The study of moral emotions in policy making may raise further questions. Moral emotions are associated with a society’s norms and values and the interests or welfare of persons or groups, beyond the concerns of the actor (Haidt 2003). That is, moral emotions are the affective signals of prosocial behaviour and play a central role in influencing group-oriented thoughts and attitudes (Halperin and Schori-Eyal 2019). In other words, moral emotions embody an interaction between moral, pro-social attitudes and emotions; and they have a vast potential both to unite and divide people through forming political identities. With some exemptions (e.g., Rees et al. 2015, Roeser, 2012, Liang et al 2019) both policy studies as a disciplinary field and the practice of policy making have been neglecting the role of moral emotions in policy change, policy support and implementation. We assume that the interaction of moral considerations with emotions may amplify the above described effects of emotions on the policy process while, at the same time, raise specific challenges which are related to their identity-forming potential. The very general research question behind this workshop proposal refers exactly to this issue: Does the analysis of policy-related moral emotions need new analytical frameworks, and how can it build on the burgeoning scholarship of emotions and policy making? In conclusion, emotions in general, and moral emotions in particular, have a significant impact on the public policy process. They shape public perception, influence decision-making, affect power dynamics, and can be mobilized to drive public engagement and support. Understanding the role of moral emotions in the policy process is crucial for policymakers and scholars alike, as it provides insights into how emotions can be harnessed or managed to achieve desired policy outcomes. References Beichelt, T. (2022). Homo Emotionalis. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden. Borén, T., Grzyś, P., & Young, C. (2020). Policy-making as an emotionally-charged arena: the emotional geographies of urban cultural policy-making. International Journal of Cultural Policy, 27(4), 449-462. Cairney, P. and Weible, C.M. (2017). The new policy sciences: combining the cognitive science of choice, multiple theories of context, and basic and applied analysis, Policy Sciences, 50(4): 619–27. Ciompi, L., & Endert, E. (2011). Gefühle machen Geschichte: Die Wirkung kollektiver Emotionen–von Hitler bis Obama. Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht. Dukes, D. et al. (2021). The rise of affectivism. Nature Human Behaviour, 5(7), 816–820 Durnová, A. and Hejzlarová, E. (2017). framing policy designs through contradictory emotions: the case of czech single mothers. public policy and Administration, 33(4), 409-427. https://doi.org/10.1177/0952076717709524 Durnová, A. and Hejzlarová, E. (2022). Navigating the role of emotions in expertise: public framing of expertise in the czech public controversy on birth care. policy Sciences, 56(3), 549-571. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-022-09471-5 Fink, S., Ruffing, E., Burst, T., & Chinnow, S. (2023). Emotional citizens, detached interest groups? The use of emotional language in public policy consultations. Policy Sciences, 56(3), 469-497. Haidt, J. (2003). The moral emotions. In R. J. Davidson, K. R. Scherer, & H. H. Goldsmith (Eds.), Handbook of affective sciences (pp. 852–870). Oxford University Press. Halperin, E., & Schori-Eyal, N. (2019). Moral emotions in political decision making. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics, 1395–1404. Jennings, W., Farrall, S., Gray, E., & Hay, C. (2017). Moral panics and punctuated equilibrium in public policy: an analysis of the criminal justice policy agenda in Britain. Policy Studies Journal, 48(1), 207-234. Jones, B.D. and Baumgartner, F.R. (2005). The Politics of Attention: How Government Prioritizes Problems, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Leong, C. (2016). The role of emotions in drinking recycled water. Water, 8(11), 548. Liang, D., Hou, C., Jo, M. S., & Sarigöllü, E. (2019). Pollution avoidance and green purchase: The role of moral emotions. Journal of cleaner production, 210, 1301-1310. Lynggaard, K. (2019). Methodological challenges in the study of emotions in politics and how to deal with them. Political Psychology, 40(6), 1201-1215. Nabi, R., Gustafson, A., & Jensen, R. (2018). Framing climate change: exploring the role of emotion in generating advocacy behavior. Science Communication, 40(4), 442-468. Pierce, J. (2021). Emotions and the policy process: enthusiasm, anger and fear. Policy & Politics, 49(4), 595-614. Rantala, K., Alasuutari, N. and Kuorikoski, J. (2023), The logic of regulatory impact assessment: From evidence to evidential reasoning. Regulation & Governance. Rees, J. H., Klug, S., & Bamberg, S. (2015). Guilty conscience: motivating pro-environmental behavior by inducing negative moral emotions. Climatic change, 130, 439-452. Renström, E. A., & Bäck, H. (2021). Emotions during the Covid‐19 pandemic: Fear, anxiety, and anger as mediators between threats and policy support and political actions. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 51(8), 861-877. Rodríguez-Sánchez, C., Schuitema, G., Claudy, M., & Esper, F. (2018). How trust and emotions influence policy acceptance: the case of the Irish water charges. British Journal of Social Psychology, 57(3), 610-629. Roeser, S. (2012). Moral Emotions as Guide to Acceptable Risk. In: Roeser, S., Hillerbrand, R., Sandin, P., Peterson, M. (eds) Handbook of Risk Theory. Springer, Dordrecht Shanahan, E.A., Jones, M.D., McBeth, M.K. and Radaelli, C.M. (2018). The narrative policy framework, in C.M. Weible and P.A. Sabatier (eds) Theories of the Policy Process, 4th edition, Boulder, CO: Westview Press, pp 173–213. Scharfbillig, M. et al. (2021). Values and Identities - a policymaker’s guide, Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union. Schneider, A.L. and Ingram, H.M. (1997). Policy Design for Democracy, Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas. Yang, Y., & Su, Y. (2020). Public voice via social media: Role in cooperative governance during public health emergency. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(18), 6840. Zahariadis, N. (2015) The shield of Heracles: multiple streams and the emotional endowment effect, European Journal of Political Research, 54(3): 466–81.
POLICY TOPICS
W10. Innovation Policies in the Digital Era: Trends and Challenges
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
To address the challenges imposed by social, economic, environmental, and technological dynamics, innovations, particularly those related to digital transformation, have become a strategic cornerstone in processes, services, and policies within the public sector over the past two decades. Consequently, the concept of digital government has permeated various spheres and government sectors, affirming the perception that this trend is no longer just a novelty but has indeed become the new normal in public management. Digital transformation refers to the process of enhancing organizational performance through the utilization of information and communication technology resources[1]. This concept integrates the application of technology into conventional problem-solving strategies, which is now prevalent in numerous domains such as government, finance, labor market, education, medicine, the arts, science, global communication, and more. Its primary goal is to contribute value in terms of transparency, accountability, efficiency, effectiveness, customer experience, and service delivery for both businesses and public organizations. In the realm of the public sector, digital transformation, often referred to as digital government or Govtech, encompasses a wide array of innovations that have been embraced and implemented over the past few decades, marking a significant shift from analog to digital government practices (OECD, 2020). This transformative process not only introduced a digital mindset into policy design but also led to a redefinition of the government's structure, functions and its interaction with citizens in policymaking. The transition to digital government comprises a series of strategies aimed at modernizing government operations to yield benefits for society. As highlighted by the OECD (2014), this transformation is pivotal as it: “emphasizes the crucial contribution of technology as a strategic driver to create open, innovative, participatory and trustworthy public sectors, to improve social inclusiveness and government accountability, and to bring together government and non-government actors to contribute to national development and long-term sustainable growth.” The adoption of digital technologies as a framework for the public sector has become a global phenomenon, extending to both developed and emerging countries, including a vast range of digital innovations based on a complex legal framework and guided by principles of networking. In brief, it is evident that digital transformation is a process that empowers governments to harness technology's potential to reinforce fiscal transparency and accountability, boost the effectiveness of public expenditure, and enhance outcomes in education, healthcare service delivery, and social welfare. This represents a foundational shift in how governments function, utilizing technology to streamline operations, facilitate decision-making, manage data, engage with society, and provide better citizens’ experience. This transformation is achieved through the development of modern digital platforms and the adoption of innovative technologies, including machine learning, artificial intelligence (AI), blockchain, the internet of things (IoT), and others. Indeed, despite the well-known benefits, not everything is rosy. Digital transformation has ushered in a host of intricate challenges, risks, and setbacks for governments, society, and businesses alike. The roster of cyber-related crimes and issues is extensive and continually expanding, encompassing: 1. National security risks; 2. Dilemmas concerning political participation; 3. Challenges related to money laundering and tax evasion policies; 4. Safeguarding of private data and privacy 5. The potential emergence of digital dictatorships. Furthermore, two other issues pose substantial threats to the government's ability to deliver public services effectively, transparently, and equitably: digital divide or exclusion and algorithmic discrimination. The digital divide represents a phenomenon that entails disparities in access, utilization, and outcomes related to information and communications technology among various population groups[2]. This can lead to their disproportionate participation in public processes and exclusion from the majority of Govtech service benefits. On the other hand, algorithmic discrimination or bias refers to systematic and repeatable errors in a computer system that produce unfair outcomes, such as favoring one category over another in ways that deviate from the algorithm's intended purpose. This bias can have wide-ranging consequences, ranging from unintentional breaches of privacy to the reinforcement of social biases related to race, gender, sexuality, age, and ethnicity. Discriminatory algorithms are found in both the public and private sectors, predominantly within the realm of artificial intelligence and machine learning, in which decisions rely on a dataset of inputs and other learning and decision-making techniques. Consequently, this issue has raised significant concerns regarding the fairness, justice, and transparency of criteria and automated decision-making, as well as the dehumanization of services. These concerns have led to negative impacts on the quality-of-service provision and the promotion of diversity. Hence, digital transformation is undeniably a positive and largely irreversible paradigm. Nevertheless, it is equally evident that the outcomes of these innovations, particularly concerning the digital divide and the indiscriminate deployment of algorithms, are not always foreseeable and can have adverse effects on the effectiveness of processes and services, the safeguarding of citizens' rights, and the levels of public trust in government. In this context, this workshop focuses on exploring the trends and challenges of policy innovation in the Digital Era observed worldwide. The workshop welcomes papers with various approaches - theoretical, methodological, and empirical - that: i) analyze initiatives leveraging digital transformation to enhance public sector performance; ii) Present case studies highlighting setbacks or risks associated with digital innovation in the public policy; iii) examine how governments worldwide are designing transparency and accountability instruments to adapt to the impacts of digital transformation. These efforts should align with ethical and integrity standards, as well as the participatory and inclusive principles valued by society.
POLICY TOPICS
W11. The Politics of Governing Crises: Understanding the Complex Linkage between Crises and Policy Processes
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
In recent years, various governments have confronted a multitude of complex, elusive and intertwining crises (COVID-19, the war in Ukraine, financial crises, migration crises and the dramatic effects of climate change); at the same time, a multitude of exceptional public policy responses have been put into place (e.g. lockdowns, increasing debt, etc.). These crises seem to have been a persistent dimension of politics and policy-making in our time and have led to an observation that we live under the risk of poly-crises (Morin and Kern, 1993) and in structurally turbulent times (Ansell et al., 2017; Denford et al., 2022). However, it is interesting that even though the concept of ‘crisis’ has been used for a long time and has been the object of huge scholarly attention, it continues to be conceptually undeveloped, especially with respect to the politics and policy dimensions of policy making. Despite the significant amount of literature on this concept, both in the social sciences and in the humanities, the definition of ‘crisis’ is still challenging, and it risks being a catch-all word[1]. It is not the case that many highly reputable scholars have underlined this conceptual problem. Edgar Morin (Morin 1976)) explained that ‘this notion, [which] as it has become generalized, has been emptied of its meaning’, while Colin Hay underlined that crisis ‘is one of the most underdeveloped concepts in state theory’, calling it a ubiquitous term that is characterised by its ‘notorious imprecision’ (1999, p .317). Allan McConnell (2020) claimed that ‘crisis is an “umbrella,” under which resides a multitude of terms such as accidents, emergencies, fiascos, disasters and catastrophes, as well as variations such as natural disasters, transboundary crises, and mega-crises’. Paul Ricoeur (1988) noted that ‘the concept of crisis is a “suitcase” concept’. In policy studies, the concept of ‘crisis’ has also largely been observed from different perspectives (Maor, 2020). The initial classical approach involves grasping ‘crisis’ as an ‘exceptional’, ‘unusual’ or ‘focusing’ event that perturbates the mediatic and governmental agenda (Resodihardjo, 2021; Kuipers & Welsh, 2017) and that can open the doors to various political and policy effects. All in all, there is a lack of a conceptualisation of crises in this policy perspective; crises are usually treated as drivers of effects in the policy process (and thus on the related policy outputs) and as a potential activator of various types of change (Kingdon, 1984; Baumgartner & Jones, 1993), or potentially critical junctures (Capoccia & Kelemen 2007). Furthermore, even in streams of public policy literature that have focused on policy design (Peters & Fontaine, 2022; Howlett & Mukherjee, 2018) or on governance and/or policy capacities (Howlett & Ramesh, 2016; Wu et al., 2018), crises are never specifically focused on. Only recently have a few attempts to read crises from a policy perspective been proposed that focus on robust design against crises (Ansell et al., 2021; Capano & Toth, 2023; Howlett & Ramesh, 2023) or on the different effects of crises over time (Capano et al., 2022). The second perspective focuses more specifically on the definitional dimension of crisis as for the problem definition to understand how politicians and policy makers name it and define crisis as ‘social construction’ ( Boin and 't Hart, P. 2003; Spector 2022; Boin at al. 2005, 2021)). For example, McConnell explained that ‘the sheer diversity and frequent ambiguity among terms reflects the ‘politics’ of how societies and political actors seek to cope with and address extreme events, which often pose a mixture of threat and opportunity’ (McConnell 2020). All in all, from this perspective, crises are not only events that need to be objectively treated for recovery—they can create opportunities for political and policy change according to how they are framed and capitalised on by policy-makers. Scholars of crisis management have clarified this point well: ‘As underlined in crisis management studies: “crisis opens up semantic and political space for actors to redefine issues, propose new policies, foster public reflection, or simply to gain popularity and strike at opponents. Typically, such opportunism rides on the wave of crisis-induced processes of accountability and learning.” (Boin et al. 2008, 284). Beyond the debates between the different approaches to public policy, it is clear that these approaches have two points in common. First, they generally consider a ‘crisis’ as an external event that disrupts the policy process. Second, most policy scholars, despite their belonging to either a constructivist or a positivist epistemology, are all fascinated by the double dimension of crises: crises are ‘objective’ because they are linked to real facts and events, but crises are also ‘subjective’ because what they depend on how they are framed according to existing political and policy dynamics and to the socio-cultural characteristics of the contexts in which crises occur (Hofstede, 2001; Douglas & Wildavsky 2010; Voltolini et al., 2020). In this workshop, instead of exploring crisis and policy processes separately, we would like to shed light on new perspectives through the complex dialectic between crises and political/policy dynamics by focusing on the way in which crises are defined or re-defined by policy-makers as they formulate their proposal, define their role, claim their legitimacy and show effectiveness in their policy. Thus, we would like to deepen the link between how policy-makers try to shape the meaning of crises and how they design their policies as responses to these crises. For example, ‘crisis’ can interestingly be observed as an epistemic challenge to the classical capacity of a state to define and tame public problems —thus pushing policy makers to criticise their previous framing—or as a decisional challenge that involves the policy makers’ capacity to govern society. References Ansell, C. K., Trondal, J., & Øgård, M. (2017). Governance in turbulent times. Oxford University Press. Ansell, C., Sørensen, E., & Torfing, J. (2021). The COVID-19 pandemic as a game changer for public administration and leadership? The need for robust governance responses to turbulent problems. Public Management Review, 23(7), 949–960. Baumgartner, F. R., and B. D. Jones. 1993. Agendas and Instability in American Politics. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Boin, A., & ‘t Hart, P. (2003). Public leadership in times of crisis: mission impossible?. Public Administration Review, 63(5), 544-553. Boin, A., McConnell, A., & ‘t Hart, P. (2008). Conclusions: the politics of crisis exploitation. In: A. Boin, A. McConnell, and P. ‘t Hart (eds.), Governing After Crisis, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp. 285-316. Boin, A., McConnell, A., & ‘t Hart, P. (2021). Governing the pandemic: The politics of navigating a mega-crisis. Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan. Boin, A., Stern, E., & Sundelius, B. (2005). The Politics of Crisis Management: Public Leadership under Pressure. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. Capano, G., & Toth, F. (2023). Thinking outside the box, improvisation, and fast learning: designing policy robustness to deal with what cannot be foreseen. Public Administration, 101(1), 90-105. Capano, G., Howlett, M., Jarvis, D. S. L., & Ramesh, M. (2022). Long-term policy impacts of the coronavirus: Normalization, adaptation, and acceleration in the post-COVID state. Policy and Society, 41(1), 1–12. Capoccia, G., & Keleman, D. (2007). The study of critical junctures: Theory, narrative and counterfactuals in historical institutionalism. World Politics, 59, 341-69. Denford, J. S., Dawson, G. S., Desouza, K. C., & Manoharan, A. P. (2022). Assessing the relevance of governmental characteristics to address wicked problems in turbulent times. Public Management Review, 1–22. Early view 25 September. Douglas, M. and Wildavsky, A. (1983). Risk and Culture. Berkely: University of California Press. Hay, C. (1999). Crisis and the structural transformation of the state: interrogating the process of change. The British Journal of Politics & International Relations, 1: 317-344 Hofstede, G. (2001). Culture’s Consequences: Comparing Values, Behaviors, Institutions and Organizations Across Nations, 2nd ed., Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA. Howlett, M., & Ramesh, M. (2016). Achilles’ heels of governance: Critical capacity deficits and their role in governance failures: The Achilles heel of governance. Regulation & Governance, 10(4), 301–313. Howlett, M. and, Mukherjee, I. (eds.) (2018). Routledge Handbook of Policy Design. London: Routledge Howlett, M., & Ramesh, M. (2023). Designing for adaptation: Static and dynamic robustness in policy-making. Public Administration, 101( 1), 23– 35. Kingdon, J. W. (1984)). Agenda, Alternatives and Public Policies. Glenview Ill: Scott Foresman and Co. Morin, E., and Kern, A. (1993). Terre-Patrie. Paris. Le Seuil. Peters, G., and Fontaine, G. (eds). (2022). Research Handbook of Policy Design. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. Voltolini, B., Natorski, M., & Hay, C. (2020). Introduction: The politicization of permanent crisis in Europe. Journal of European Integration, 42(5), 609–624. Wu, X., Howlett, M., & Ramesh, M. (eds). (2018). Policy Capacity and Governance: Assessing Governmental Competences and Capabilities in Theory and Practice. Springer International Publishing. Kuipers, Sanneke, et Nicholas H. Welsh. 2017. « Taxonomy of the crisis and disaster literature: Themes and types in 34 years of research ». Risk, Hazards & Crisis in Public Policy 8 (4): 272‑83. Maor, Moshe. 2020. « A Disproportionate Policy Perspective on the Politics of Crisis Management ». In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.1513. McConnell, Allan. 2020. « The Politics of Crisis Terminology ». In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.1590. Morin, Edgar. 1976. « Pour une crisologie ». Communications 25 (1): 149‑63. https://doi.org/10.3406/comm.1976.1388. Resodihardjo, Sandra L. 2021. « The Agenda-Setting Process and Crises: Toward a Conceptual Framework ». In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.1594. Ricoeur, Paul. 1988. « La crise, un phénomène spécifiquement moderne ? » , Revue de théologie et de Philosophie, vol. 120 (1), 1-19 Spector, Bert. 2022. « Constructivist Perspectives in Crisis Studies ». In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.2036. [1] For example, the last Oxford Encyclopedia of Management Crisis (2021) proposed more than 100 chapters on this topic
POLICY TOPICS
W01. Climate Democracy: Can Democracies Tackle Super Wicked Problems?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This workshop deals with the capacity of democracies to tackle climate change. In genral, contemporary governments are facing a number of extremely complex and interrelated challenges–climate change, immigration, and artificial intelligence to name but a few. While all governments have difficulty with these “wicked problems”, democratic governments have particular problems because of the pressures of electoral cycles, and the dangers to stability if public discontent grows over policies that impose costs on citizens. Climate change is a physical change that could be amplified by inadapted governance and democracy confronted to the 'tragedy' is that of 'super wicked problems', notably because 'time is running out' (Levin & al., 2012) because of the complexity of climate governance and to make collective ‘tragic choices’. This workshop wants thus : i) Establishing an empirical inventory about two crucial, but relatively uninformed, questions : · To what extend democratic quality of policy processes (transparency of action and information, accountability and arbitration capacity of elected officials are irremovable principles of good democratic functioning, strengthens the capacity to face the climate challenge to ensure trust in democracy ? · To what extent are the political responses made to tackle climate challenge the result of processes that are procedurally organized to be pluralist, competitive, polyarchic and enable polycentric governance in networks that include the diversity of individuals, ideas and social interests involved? What institutional innovations could amplify this democratic openness of climate policies? ii) Describing examples of democratic innovations. The issue here is therefore to identify innovative procedural instruments for improving the democratic governance of climate policies. provide democratic solutions to the climate challenge.
POLICY TOPICS
W02. Wicked Problems in Public Policy: Definitions, Methods, Ethics and Uncertainty in Decision-Making
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Co-chairs: Raul Pacheco-Vega, FLACSO Mexico Fausto Amador-Cid, FLACSO Mexico Camila Sanchez-Sandoval, FLACSO Mexico 1. Research Question This workshop seeks to examine the underlying challenges of using wicked problems in public policy scholarship. What do we know about wickedness, wicked problems and the use of wicked problems scholarship in policy studies? What is left to study? Which potential avenues for further research do we have? We propose examining this research question through four different avenues of inquiry: a) How do we define wicked problems? Which parameters, characteristics, and elements define wicked, wickedness and a wicked problem? b) What types of methods can be used to understand wicked problems from a public policy perspective? How can we merge qualitative, quantitative, spatial, relational and other types of research methods to better understand wicked problems? c) Which ethical challenges exist when examining public policy issues through the wicked problems framework? d) How does uncertainty affect wicked-problem-solving across different policy contexts? 2. Context Public policy issues can always be framed through a wicked problems framework. However, despite recent efforts to make this scholarship more visible and relevant (Head, 2019, 2023; Peters, 2017; Peters & Tarpey, 2019), global challenges such as the COVID19 pandemic, the increase in violence against women, the growth in applications of large scale language models (LLMs, also known as artificial intelligence) have made it clear that policy issues can definitely be wicked problems. It is in this context that we seek to advance literature and make substantive contributions to the wicked problems literature. 3. State of the Art Wicked problems are complex, multifaceted, intractable and often ill-formulated (Crowley & Head, 2017; Head, 2022). Scholarship around the world has evolved over the past 60 years to use the conceptual lens of wicked problems to examine challenging issues of urban planning, sustainable development, water governance, human development and social justice. Though the term “wicked problems” emerged from the urban and regional planning literature (Peters, 2017), it has become widely used across multiple disciplines, sub-fields and areas of study (Clark et al., 2022; Hannigan & Coffey, 2011; Herrington & Horndeski, 2023; Smith et al., 2000). Though there are fair and substantive critiques of the concept (Termeer et al., 2019), there are also important and relevant avenues to expand the current body of academic works on wicked problems in public policy, building on these critiques (Peters, 2017; Peters & Tarpey, 2019). Both from an area issues perspective as well as a disciplinary viewpoint, there are clearly multiple spaces where one could contribute to our understanding of the definitional challenges of wicked problems in public policy. One of the biggest challenges facing scholarly literature on wicked problems is definitional. Peters makes three core assertions about this body of scholarly works: firstly, that relatively few problems facing governments are actually wicked in the way we define wicked problems. Secondly, that many ordinary policy problems could also be characterized as wicked, And thirdly, that wicked problems as a theoretical construct has been converted from an explanatory framework to a normative approach to policy design (Peters, 2017). While there are multiple angles of analysis for wicked problems, four main avenues emerge from a cursory literature review. Firstly, the definitional problems that emerge from trying to discern which public affairs can or cannot be framed as wicked problems (Alford & Head, 2017; Head, 2022; Peters & Tarpey, 2019; Termeer et al., 2019). There is a very strong variation in the types of issues that can be examined through wicked problems scholarship, from homelessness (Clark et al., 2022) to wellbeing (Bache et al., 2016) to urban stream restoration (Herrington & Horndeski, 2023) to air pollution sustainable development and land title regularization (Pipkin, 2023). There is still substantive space for additional efforts to define wicked problems and advance scholarship on wickedness in public policy. Secondly, there are substantial methodological challenges that come with attempting to understand and solve wicked problems. A clear gap in the literature is a systematic examination of different methodologies that can be used to better understand public policy issues through the wicked problems framing. Though there is substantial work on the definitional elements that make a public policy issue a wicked problem (Alford & Head, 2017; Crowley & Head, 2017; Head, 2019; Lönngren & van Poeck, 2021; Turnbull & Hoppe, 2019), there is less work on applications of qualitative, quantitative, social network analysis, spatial analysis to the study of wicked problems. Certainly, understanding policy issues requires specific skill sets and methodological tools. For example, to understand mental health as a wicked problem (Pipkin, 2023) we would need ethnographic approaches. The same could be said of homelessness (Clark et al., 2022). Studying land titles’ regularization (Pipkin, 2023) most certainly would necessitate spatial analysis and geographical information systems. Thirdly, there is a need for additional work on the ethical implications of examining public policy issues through a wicked problems framework (Wexler, 2009). Given the normative nature of the wicked problems literature, we need to exercise caution when examining policy challenges through this theoretical lens, as it is likely that we may fall into a blind spot and make the problem even more wicked than it was before our analysis. The entire notion of wicked problems implies that there is a certain “wickedness” that needs to be tamed. One important challenge is the ethical decision to choose certain policy options over others when addressing a wicked problem (Wexler, 2009). The scholarly literature on ethics in wicked problems has therefore several potential avenues for additional research. Fourthly, there is substantial uncertainty within the specific wicked problem we might be attempting to address. We may frequently find scholarly research papers that address a policy issue attempting to tackle one of its causes without actually addressing all of them. These uncertainties can be associated with the specific policy issue (Kirschke & Kosow, 2022), or with the types of stakeholders that are involved in decision-making (Esposito & Terlizzi, 2023; Hudon & Floricel, 2023) or the specific processes used to make decisions around a specific wicked problem (Bache et al., 2016; Kirschke & Kosow, 2022). Given that wicked problems are also political (McConnell, 2018), there is ample opportunity for further investigation of the politics of uncertainty in wicked problems scholarship. Wicked problems are substantially different in root causes, policy instruments that can be designed and implemented, temporal horizons and target populations. While this workshop proposes an examination of wicked problems in public policy scholarly literature and case studies in four specific areas, it is clear that there are other potential avenues worthy of research that can be examined. We welcome papers that examine specific case studies, a broader range of public policy areas, or take a comparative perspective. 4. Hypotheses This workshop does not follow a hypothesis-testing strategy. We examine research questions as posited above. 5. Papers We have abstracts for at least 5 papers already prepared, and we will be seeking additional submissions. We welcome theoretical, empirical and methodological papers and will organize them accordingly. 6. Agenda The workshop will take place over 3 days. Depending on the number of participants and papers, we will devote 1-1.5 up to 2 days to presenting and discussing the papers in a traditional roundtable (chair, presenters, discussant) format. We then will devote the remainder of the workshop (1-1.5 days) to discuss a publication strategy and offer some time for participants to edit their papers for publication. We will explore research questions along the four avenues indicated and produce four sets of papers that can be then published in a series of special issues. 7. Paper titles and authors (to be updated with additional participants emerging from the call for participants) Raul Pacheco-Vega (FLACSO Mexico) “Elder Care Policy as a Wicked Problem: An Intersectional Approach to Understanding Policies for Older Persons”. Fausto Amador-Cid (FLACSO Mexico) “Methods for Studying Wicked Public Policy Problems in the Context of Homelessness: A Case Study in Mexico” Camila Sanchez-Sandoval (FLACSO Mexico) “Religious Freedom Expansion as a Wicked Problem: A Comparative Public Policy Approach” Jeraldine del Cid and Gloria del Castillo (FLACSO Mexico) Problem Definition in the Agenda-Setting Process for the Decriminalization of Abortion in Central America: A Very Wicked Problem Two additional authors have been identified: Ulises Flores Llanos Guillaume Fontaine 8. Bibliography Alford, J., & Head, B. W. (2017). Wicked and less wicked problems: A typology and a contingency framework. Policy and Society, 36(3), 397–413. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2017.1361634 Bache, I., Reardon, L., & Anand, P. (2016). Wellbeing as a Wicked Problem: Navigating the Arguments for the Role of Government. Journal of Happiness Studies, 17(3), 893–912. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10902-015-9623-y Clark, M., Cornes, M., Whiteford, M., Aldridge, R., Biswell, E., Byng, R., Foster, G., Fuller, J. S., Hayward, A., Hewett, N., Kilminster, A., Manthorpe, J., Neale, J., & Tinelli, M. (2022). Homelessness and integrated care: an application of integrated care knowledge to understanding services for wicked issues. Journal of Integrated Care, 30(1), 3–19. https://doi.org/10.1108/JICA-03-2021-0012 Crowley, K., & Head, B. W. (2017). The enduring challenge of ‘wicked problems’: revisiting Rittel and Webber. Policy Sciences, 50(4), 539–547. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-017-9302-4 Esposito, G., & Terlizzi, A. (2023). Governing wickedness in megaprojects: discursive and institutional perspectives. Policy and Society, 42(2), 131–147. https://doi.org/10.1093/polsoc/puad002 Hannigan, B., & Coffey, M. (2011). Where the wicked problems are: The case of mental health. Health Policy, 101(3), 220–227. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.healthpol.2010.11.002 Head, B. W. (2019). Forty years of wicked problems literature: forging closer links to policy studies. Policy and Society, 38(2), 180–197. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2018.1488797 Head, B. W. (2022). Wicked Problems in Public Policy: Understanding and Responding to Complex Challenges. Palgrave Macmillan. Head, B. W. (2023). Wicked Problems in Public Policy. Encyclopedia of Public Policy, 3(2), 101–108. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-90434-0_43-1 Herrington, C. S., & Horndeski, K. (2023). Is urban stream restoration really a wicked problem? Urban Ecosystems, 26(2), 479–491. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11252-022-01307-7 Hudon, P.-A., & Floricel, S. (2023). The development of large public infrastructure projects: integrating policy and project studies models. Policy and Society, 42(2), 148–163. https://doi.org/10.1093/polsoc/puad004 Kirschke, S., & Kosow, H. (2022). Designing policy mixes for emerging wicked problems. The case of pharmaceutical residues in freshwaters. Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 24(5), 486–497. https://doi.org/10.1080/1523908X.2021.1960808 Lönngren, J., & van Poeck, K. (2021). Wicked problems: a mapping review of the literature. International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology, 28(6), 481–502. https://doi.org/10.1080/13504509.2020.1859415 McConnell, A. (2018). Rethinking wicked problems as political problems and policy problems. Policy and Politics, 46(1), 165–180. https://doi.org/10.1332/030557317X15072085902640 Peters, B. G. (2017). What is so wicked about wicked problems? A conceptual analysis and a research program. Policy and Society, 36(3), 385–396. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2017.1361633 Peters, B. G., & Tarpey, M. (2019). Are wicked problems really so wicked? Perceptions of policy problems. Policy and Society, 38(2), 218–236. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2019.1626595 Pipkin, S. (2023). Dissolving “Wicked” Problems: Beyond Institutionalist and Participatory Approaches to Land Title Regularization. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 43(1), 94–105. https://doi.org/10.1177/0739456X19856066 Smith, P. C., Nutley, S. M., & Davies, H. T. O. (2000). Urban policy: addressing wicked problems. What Works?: Evidence-Based Policy and Practice in Public Services, 383. Termeer, C. J. A. M., Dewulf, A., & Biesbroek, R. (2019). A critical assessment of the wicked problem concept: relevance and usefulness for policy science and practice. Policy and Society, 38(2), 167–179. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2019.1617971 Turnbull, N., & Hoppe, R. (2019). Problematizing ‘wickedness’: a critique of the wicked problems concept, from philosophy to practice. Policy and Society, 38(2), 315–337. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2018.1488796 Wexler, M. N. (2009). Exploring the moral dimension of wicked problems. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 29, 531–542. https://doi.org/10.1108/01443330910986306
POLICY TOPICS
W01. Decentralization, state capacities and public policies: what is new to discover?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
In decentralized countries the subnational governments have become the central units for implementing and providing public policies, which has increased their responsibilities and powers. These new responsibilities were followed by greater political, administrative and financial autonomy. In this sense, the requirements to qualify the subnational administration and governance were expanded to respond to its new roles both at the local level and in intergovernmental relations. Considering that, the research question of the workshop is: how does decentralization affect subnational state capacities and the implementation and provision of public policies? Many countries have implemented the decentralization since the 1980’s, especially the Latin American federations (Argentina, Brazil, Mexico) and unitary countries (Colombia, Ecuador, Costa Rica, Uruguay, among others). This process also has characterized European countries such as Germany, Spain, and Switzerland, and dual federations such as United States and Canada. India in Asia is also a relevant case, as Australia in Oceania and Nigeria, Ethiopia, and South Africa in Africa. There are many different routes to decentralization and each national case does not have the same and political, administrative, and financial designs. The demands imposed by the new responsibilities to the subnational level as a result of decentralized public policies has induced the creation, building and/or strengthening of their state capacities. In this sense, capabilities have become a key element to build and consolidate the autonomy attributed to subnational governments within the framework of decentralizing models. Therefore, the decentralization process requires more capacities in subnational governments. However, the comparative literature on decentralization lacks a more systematic approach linking this process and its effects on subnational state capacities and public policies. This is theoretical and empirical problem still asks more research. This analytical gap of the decentralization takes on greater relevance after the COVID-19 pandemic because subnational governments were the main sphere responsible for formulating and implementing many public policies. The workshop is proposed in the context of the rapid changes in public administration and territorial governance provoked by the pandemic as a complex intergovernmental problem (Paquet and Schertzer, 2020). Investigating how subnational governments managed to provide service and public policies in this scenario is also linked to the historical design of decentralization in each country with its political, financial, and administrative dimensions. The context of the pandemic crisis is a hallmark for assessing whether subnational state capacities have contributed to improve the public administration and public policies. In this context, the research question is relevant to allow understanding whether national cases of decentralization have been implemented, considering the need to strengthen subnational state capacities as core inputs to implement public policies. This goal is even more challenging when the problems require high levels of multilevel governance was the case with the COVID-19 pandemic. The complexity and novelty of this problem, considering its spillover effects, challenged countries to develop new intergovernmental policy capacities, especially the subnational units. It is also important to highlight the importance of subnational governments in the 2030 Agenda (Lee, 2023). In short, analyzing decentralization and its effects on subnational governments and their state capacities and public policies, the context after the pandemic and the implementation of the SDGs updates the research question. The research question is scientifically relevant because decentralization has become a dynamic process through which many federative and unitary countries, at least in the last four decades, have built instruments to delegate responsibilities for public policies to regions and cities. Although, in many cases, the decentralization was not an organized process it stimulated the development of local and/or regional bureaucracies focused on implementing different public policies for many groups of citizens. Somehow, subnational state capacities were developed, but we know little about this side of the decentralization and the consequences in the implementation of public policies. The research question is also relevant because the effort to approach the literature on decentralization to and the variance of subnational state capacity is more recent, seeking to address their effects on public policies at the territorial level (Luna and Soifer, 2017; Meza, 2021). In general, decentralization promised better democratic governance, more efficiency for the public administration and public policies more adjusted to needs of citizens. However, over time, many problems and challenges still persist, such as territorial inequality, poor quality of life, corruption, poor performance in providing services to citizens, reduced own-source revenues, and weak democratic governance, at least in less developed countries. These issues have become even more important after the pandemic because changes in the economic and social context have hit affected the people’s lives in the territories harder (Peters, Grin, and Abrucio, 2021). This state-of-the-art seeks to approach two strands of literature based on the assumption that subnational administrative, technical, institutional, and political state capacities are pivotal for a sustainable decentralization and good public policies at the territorial level (Andrews, Pritchett, and Woolcock, 2017; OECD, 2019). Considering this current debate, the contributions expected from workshop participants are focused on connecting these three topics – decentralization, state capacity, and public policies (Smith, 2023). We hope that participants from federations and unitary countries will contribute to deepening the knowledge around these issues, both theoretically and empirically, to advance the understanding of this research topic. This workshop builds on existing research considering the need to approach the three theorical strands. There are many works that addresses decentralization and public policies, as well as a literature that analyzes state capacities and public policies. However, to advance scientific knowledge of the decentralization process it would be important to consider state capacity as an additional theoretical. The post-COVID-19 pandemic has made this discussion even more relevant, and we hope that this workshop can contribute in this regard. The main hypotheses that the workshop seek to explore are: 1. The development and variance of subnational state capabilities in decentralization contexts affects the territorial equality and the performance of public policies. 2. The design and quality of democratic governance in territories are affected by the level of development of subnational state capacities. 3. The development of subnational state capabilities in decentralization contexts is related to the quality of public administration in combating corruption, increasing own revenues and the performance of bureaucracies. 4. The development of subnational state capacities affects their role in the multilevel arrangements. These three hypotheses are original, as they: a) highlight the importance of using the literature on state capabilities to analyze their variance in subnational governments and their effects on public policies and territorial inequality; b) allow analyzing whether the performance of democratic governance in the territories is related to the quality of subnational state capabilities; c) allow us to analyze whether subnational state capabilities helped local governments fulfill key promises of decentralization (less corruption, greater administrative and bureaucratic efficiency and greater potential for generating their own revenue) that would boost better public policies and quality of life in the territories. This workshop is open to receive papers focused on developing theoretical, methodological and analytical models that address decentralization, state capacities, and public policies, empirical works both discussing national cases or in a comparative way. We welcome both quantitative or qualitative papers that explore different dimensions of the decentralization (administrative, financial, and political), and different dimensions of state capacity (administrative, technical, institutional, and political). The papers could address sectoral policies or even analyze decentralization in a more general way. The workshop is open to a variety of different types of papers in order to contribute to improve the knowledge on this research topic. The sessions will be organized this way. Each author will present their paper in 15 minutes. The discussant will provide feedback and the author will respond. If necessary, the chair and co-chairs may also contribute with additional comments. Next, the discussion will open to participants who will also be asked to read the works, as a way of qualifying comments, questions and the discussion as whole. We hope that each session can contribute to improve the papers aiming at organizing a Special Issue to be submitted to a well-ranked journal. Thus, the chair and co-chair will follow-up the papers in order to contribute with their theoretical, methodological, and empirical research before submitting to the journal. References Andrew, M.; L. Prtichett, and M. Woolcock (2017). Building State Capability: Evidence, Analysis, Action. Oxford University Press. Lee, H. (2023). Strategic types, implementation, and capabilities: Sustainability policies of local governments. Public Administration, first published online. Luna, J. P. and D. H. Soifer (2017). Capturing Subnational Variation in State Capacity: A Survey-Based Approach. American Behavioral Scientist, 61 (8): 887-907. Meza, O. (2021). Punctuated equilibrium in multilevel contexts: How federal and state level forces feedback into shaping the local policy agenda in Mexico. Policy Studies Journal, 2 (50): 575-594. OECD (2019). Making Decentralisation Work. A Handbook for Policy-Makers. OECD PublishingPaquet, M., & Schertzer, R. (2020). COVID-19 as a Complex Intergovernmental Problem. Canadian Journal of Political Science, 53(2), 1-5. Peters, B. G.; Grin, E. J. & Abrucio, F. L. (2021). American federal systems and covid-19. Responses to a Complex Intergovernmental Problem. Emerald Publishing. Smith, B. C. (2023). Decentralization: The Territorial Dimension of the State. Routledge.
POLICY TOPICS
W01. Defining Policy Success and Failure as Evaluation Challenges. Focusing on outcomes: Blessing or a curse for policymakers?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Introduction Outcome measures are designed to assess the contribution of public policies and programs to the improvement of social issues. Outcomes identification and measurement serve to assess the policy and program’s effectiveness and to improve its implementation and accountability. As far as effectiveness, public interventions are scrutinized not only for performance but also in their capacity to ‘make a difference’ or ‘drive a change’ concerning the issues to be tackled (Chen, 1990; Davies, 2004). As far as accountability, evaluation has been widely acknowledged as a means for empowering citizens (Dahlher-Larson, 2011), when it makes available to decision-makers and citizens reliable knowledge on which to build their judgments and choices. The focus on the ‘end’ results of public policy and programs challenges policy makers and civil servants to understand the achievement of performance results to the value and purposiveness of public action. In other words, the outcomes perspective entails a judgement of success or failure of public programs (Bovens et al. 2001; Compton & t’Hart, eds., 2019; McConnel et al. 2020). This perspective requires greater clarity regarding the intervention’s logic, design, conduct and implementation as well as the goals to be achieved. The payment by results are examples of instruments, especially popular in Anglo-Saxon countries, that seek to armour the achievement of social outcomes, with the application (e.g., to health and judicial policies) (Farrar et al., 2009; Fox and Albertson, 2011). In Europe, both the Cohesion Funds and the post-Covid ‘Next Generation EU’ program, have intensified the linkages between funded programs and well-defined outcomes to be achieved: the NGEU will reimburse the member states’ expenses only after the realisation of specific outcomes. Within this framework, the appropriate identification of the results to be achieved and of the method of measurement becomes of paramount importance. The transition towards outcomes has been welcomed by the evaluation community. Notwithstanding, shortcomings emerge in the day-to-day evaluation practice, making the role of policy advice challenging, as well as communication with stakeholder groups. The appreciation of outcomes initially established could be unsatisfactory or even misplaced, for instance: in case of poor or conflicting policy design (Compton et al. 2021); uneven design and implementation processes (Shepherd, 2011); change in the political mood; unexpected conflicts, or external events (Covid pandemic, Russia-Ukraine war, etc) that substantially changed the salience of the intervention or the resources available at the beginning (McConnell, 2010). The process of determining and measuring policy success or failure is moreover challenged when public interventions are either inconsistent or complex (e.g., in the case of multilevel governance, where responsibility for policy planning and implementation is dispersed between different levels of administration). These may include different policies to solve crosscutting issues or wicked problems (Bailie et al., 2022; Paparini et al., 2020; Daviter, 2017). Various authors have noted that a linear and entirely predictable policy design is not suitable for the more complex and challenging policy domains. Theory-based evaluations (Chen, 1990; Weiss, 1997; Chen, 2012; Mayne, 2015) and realist designs based on the CMO or the CIMO configuration (Pawson & and Tilley, 1997; Pawson, 2006; Pedersen and Rieper, 2008; Punton et al., 2020), suffer from the tendency to represent oversimplified policy processes, without adequately considering the complexity of these processes and positive and negative, expected and unexpected outcomes. The advocates of ‘formative’ evaluations (Scriven, 1991, 1996; Stame, 2004) have underlined the shortcomings of evaluating complex policies and programs, and the consequent need for more open-ended evaluation designs, that in turn could be less able to synthesize clear-cut judgements about the program’s ultimate results. On their side, the quasi-experimental and formal evaluation advocates – or as they have been called, the ‘truth-seeking’ or positivist stream of evaluation theory (Shadish et al., 1991) - struggle to take into consideration the implementation process and its reasons for particular designs (Cook et al., 1979), thus risking an adequate interpretative framework for evaluation findings, or sometimes not focusing on the most relevant outcomes in the eyes of beneficiaries. In the case of payment by results tools, the push on outcomes could trigger a ‘creaming and parking mechanism’ (the process in which providers select job-ready clients for services and neglect clients more distant from the achievement of the goals (Greer et al., 2018). In this case, an evaluation design too fixated on pre-defined outcomes could provide opaque and incomplete findings, and not serve the scope of empowering citizens' decisions – at least not in an acceptable way. Starting from the public policy debate on policy success and failure, we underline the need to bridge policy evaluation with policy process studies that tend to focus almost exclusively on goals. Aims of the workshop & main questions The workshop aims to gather contributions and experiences of public policy evaluation scholars who have addressed critical issues about the relationships between programmes, the evaluation of policy success and failures, and the capacity of evaluation to provide relevant policy advice with useful information to citizens and stakeholder groups. In particular, the panel will raise the following research questions: · How does policy coherence (or the lack thereof) affect policy implementation in complex governance structures? · What are the risks inherent in understanding policy outcomes that focus mainly on policy aims at the expense of implementation? · What are the consequences of evaluation-policy process dysfunctions in terms of methodological choices, evaluation policy process, and relevance of evaluation findings for citizens and other stakeholder groups? · Are there epistemological questions, approaches and solutions to cope with these challenges? · Are there evaluation strategies and tools, including AI-based analytical instruments, able to mitigate or strengthen these relationships and challenges? · How do policy makers and policy advisors take into account and overcome these challenges? Are there systemic approaches being considered over episodic ones? Expected Impact of the Workshop The workshop findings would allow not only the evaluation scholars but the larger ICPP community to understand the main challenges in the way policy and programs are designed (i.e., goals, implementation features, incentives and other mechanisms, communication strategies); the capabilities of determining policy success and failure; and, in providing citizens and other stakeholder groups with valuable information deriving from the evaluation process. The workshop’s findings would be suitable for a special journal issue or for an edited book. Possible articles: · Giancarlo Vecchi and Erica Melloni (Politecnico di Milano). Was it a success or a failure? Methodological and conceptual challenges of evaluating justice sector innovation programmes. The case of justice reform in Italy was funded by the NGEU. · Simone Busetti (Università di Teramo). Discovering policy outcomes: effectiveness, extrapolation and policy transfer. · Dominika Wojtowicz (Kozminski University), Challenges of evaluation of incoherent policy. Assessing policy of Polish cities toward integration of refugees from Ukraine. · Robert Shepherd (Carleton). Moving the Canadian, UK and Australian federal evaluation systems from focusing on expenditure management to informing sound policy choices. References Bailie, J.; Cunningham, F.; Abimbola, S.; Laycock, A.; Bainbridge, R.; Bailie, R.; Conte, K.; Passey, M. & Peiris, D. (2022) Methodological pluralism for better evaluations of complex interventions: lessons from evaluating an innovation platform in Australia. Health Research Policy & Systems. Vol. 20(1): 1-14. Bovens M., P. ‘T Hart & G.B. Peters. Eds.(2001). Success and Failure in Public Governance. A Comparative Analysis. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. Chen H.-T. (1990) Theory-driven evaluations. Sage, Newbury Park, Calif. Chen H. T. (2012) Theory-driven evaluation: Conceptual framework, application and advancement. Springer. Compton M.E., J. Luetjens & P. ‘t Hart (2019). "Designing for Policy Success." International Review of Public Policy 1(2): 119-146. Compton M.E. & P. ‘t Hart. eds. (2019). Great Policy Success. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Cook T. D., Campbell D. T. and Day A. (1979) Quasi-experimentation: Design & analysis issues for field settings. Houghton Mifflin, Boston. Dahler-Larsen P. (2011) The evaluation society. Stanford University Press. Farrar S., Yi D., Sutton M., Chalkley M., Sussex J. And Scott A. (2009) Has payment by results affected the way that English hospitals provide care? Difference-in-differences analysis, Bmj 339. Fox C. And Albertson K. (2011) Payment by results and social impact bonds in the criminal justice sector: New challenges for the concept of evidence-based policy?, Criminology & Criminal Justice 11, 395-413. Greer I., Schulte L. and Symon G. (2018) Creaming and parking in marketized employment services: An Anglo-German comparison, human relations 71, 1427-53. Mayne J. (2015) Useful theory of change models, Canadian Journal of Program Evaluation 30. Pawson R. (2006) Evidence-Based Policy : A Realist Perspective. Sage, London. Pawson R. and Tilley N. (1997) Realistic evaluation. Sage. Pedersen L. H. and Rieper O. (2008) Is realist evaluation a realistic approach for complex reforms?, Evaluation 14, 271-93. Punton M., Isabel V., Leavy J., Michaelis C. and Boydell E. (2020) Reality bites: Making realist evaluation useful in the real world, CDI Practice Paper 22. Scriven M. (1991) Prose and cons about goal-free evaluation, Evaluation Practice 12, 55-62. Scriven M. (1996) Types of evaluation and types of evaluator, Evaluation Practice 17, 151-61. Shadish W. R., Cook T. D. And Leviton L. C. (1991) Foundations of program evaluation: Theories of practice. Sage. Shepherd, R. (2011). “In search of a balanced Canadian federal evaluation function: Getting to relevance.” Canadian Journal of Program Evaluation, 26(2), 1-45. Stame N. (2004) Theory-Based Evaluation and Types of Complexity, Evaluation 10, 58-76. Weiss C. H. (1997) How can theory-based evaluation make greater headway?, Evaluation review 21, 501-24.
POLICY TOPICS
W02. Managing Uncertainty in Policy Design: Policy Tools and Capacities
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Dealing with uncertainty is a central challenge for policy designers and design studies. Recent events, including polycrises, public health emergencies, and the rapid proliferation of new technologies such as artificial intelligence, have underscored the critical importance of addressing uncertainty in policy design. The central question this workshop engages with is how to address and manage uncertainty in policy design. Our goal is to categorize these uncertainties and explore strategies for their effective management. A lot of the discussion around uncertainty in the context of policy design has focussed on what are described as 'ill-structured' problems, marked by a lack of clarity about the issue's nature and limited knowledge about solutions. Extensive literature over six decades categorizes types of uncertainty faced by policymakers, including in 'complex,' 'complicated,' 'wicked,' 'super wicked,' and 'tame' problems (see Peters, 2018 and Head 2022 for a review). Janicke and Jorgens (1999), Koppenjan and Klijn, (2004) and Nair and Howlett (2017) have described different forms of uncertainties that can undermine policy designs. Policymakers often deal with limited information, asymmetric knowledge, or an inability to grasp a problem's root causes within time constraints (Koppenjan and Klijn, 2004; Howlett, 2024). This differs from debates involving contested problem definitions, as seen in climate change or health reform discussions (Sovacool, Brown and Valentine, 2016; Ramesh and Bali, 2021). Uncertainties in goals, objectives, and policy tools can stem from decision-makers' awareness and the nature of the issue (Howlett, 2024). Uncertainty also surrounds the effectiveness of policy tools and their combinations, particularly over time. That is, are interventions made at time t likely to be effective at time t + 1 (Howlett and Leong, 2021). There are also uncertainties associated with the accuracy of specific settings of policy tools, such as tax rates or subsidy levels, which tend to resist change despite calls for flexibility. Further, policymakers also grapple with overarching uncertainties in the political environment and resource availability (Howlett, 2024), which are interconnected in unfathomable ways which make policymaking difficult. To understand how policy designers deal with these different types of uncertainty and manage them, this workshop looks at two interconnected issues: a) specific tools used to deal with uncertainty in policy designs, and b) the role of policy capacity. The twin focus on tools, and the capacities of policymakers to effectively deploy are central to the new design orientation in the policy sciences (Howlett and Lejano, 2013; Mukherjee and Bali, 2018). Policy tools or instruments are specific means that are used to realise policy objectives. Recent studies in policy design have focussed on how multiple tools are assembled in ‘policy mixes’ to include substantive and procedural elements, and primary and secondary elements (Bali et al 2021). The choice of tools and their effective deployment is also a function of the capacities of policymakers and implementing agencies (Wu et al 2015). That is, the skills and competencies of public actors to be able to understand these uncertainties, develop processes, and choose tools to manage them. The workshop will bring together scholars that advance conceptual as well as empirical case studies. All papers will include a discussion that develops strategies or offers insights for policy designers in dealing with uncertainty. Questions specific papers will focus on include: 1) How designers deal with problems or challenges in the context of uncertainty (in the understanding of the issue or lack of an appropriate knowledge base such)? (see for e.g. Head, 2019; 2023; Cairney 2016; 2) How designers set policy goals and objectives in an environment characterised by uncertainty? 3) How designers use policy tools and mixes to address uncertainty in policy designs (Howlett and Ramesh, 2023; Fowler, 2021;)? 4) How designers adjust policy settings in the context of uncertainty in targets (Capano and Woo, 2018)? 5) The role policy capacity plays in managing uncertainty during the design process? Are certain types of capacities more critical in dealing with uncertainty? (Wu, Ramesh and Howlett, 2015; Mukherjee and Bali, 2018) 6) How lessons/best practices in dealing with uncertainty are institutionalised (Stark and van der Erend, 2023; Nair and Howlett, 2017; Dunlop and Radaelli 2017)? Engaging with these questions will advance scholarly debate and discussion within the policy sciences around the efficacy of policy designs, as well as contribute to policy practice by developing strategies/best practices for the effective management of uncertainty.
POLICY TOPICS
W03. Application of recent advances in Natural Language Processing for Public Policy Research
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Over the last decade, interest in using text-as-data approaches in the social sciences has dramatically increased. Large amounts of data, increased computational power, and major advancements in language models such as GPT-4 have allowed, for the first time, to work on text data at scale (Grimmer et al., 2022). This has led to the increasing use of Natural Language Processing (NLP), which includes methods for processing large quantities of text. NLP offers a plethora of opportunities for public policy. It has provided new insights on pressing policy issues, such as climate change (Biesbroek et al., 2020; Mallick et al., 2023), and on sectoral policies such as science and technology (Arts et al., 2021). It enables scaling up qualitative research strategies (such as expert coding or content analysis) that otherwise would not be possible (Biesbroek et al., 2020; Crowston et al., 2012), encourages novel research designs (Jones et al., 2022; Lubell et al., 2022) and opens the door to support systems for decision making in policy contexts (Ku & Leroy, 2014; Neumann et al., 2022). This, by applying novel techniques using text-as-data in a variety of documents ranging from legislative or administrative documents to discourses, social media, and news articles. Even though NLP has gained prominence in disciplines adjacent to public policy—such as political science and communication science— its application in our discipline remains limited. The majority of applications use NLP as an exploratory technique to study policy domains, particularly through topic modeling (Capano et al., 2020; Kowalski et al., 2020). However, we are convinced that NLP-based methods have considerable potential for research into public policy concepts and theories, and that the methodological toolkit for public policy researchers might change substantially as a result. While applications of NLP in public policy research have remained inductive and exploratory, theory-driven applications of these methods are what holds most promise. Many public policy concepts and theories rely strongly on textual data sources for empirical research, including a variety of different types of local, national, and international policy documents, but also social media posts, media articles or interest group websites. NLP has the potential to innovate methods for researching concepts and theories, including agenda setting (Zahariadis, 2016), policy integration (Biesbroek et al., 2020), policy framing (Van Hulst & Yanow, 2014), or policy diffusion (Linder et al., 2020), to name just a few examples. Recent NLP developments promise innovative approaches for these concepts and theories: for instance, they have been used to identify public values in text data (Pelaez et al., 2023), to retrieve context-specific values (Liscio et al., 2021), to extract arguments from opinions (van der Meer et al., 2022), to identify and extract argumentative structures (Lawrence & Reed, 2019), and to automate manual coding of texts (Zhou, 2018). Such developments offer a great potential of innovative ways to approach public policy research. Considering the recent NLP advances and their potential in public policy research, we propose this workshop. It has two aims. First, to bring together policy researchers using NLP techniques. Until now, there have been limited venues for public policy researchers using NLP and has limited the establishment of a network of collaborators. We believe this has been detrimental to its adoption in public policy research. Second, the workshop invites to discuss how can NLP approaches be applied to study public policy concepts and theories. In doing so, we invite researchers to present innovative work that go beyond the dominant approach of using NLP for exploratory purposes. The guiding questions of this workshop are: How can Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques be used to research public policy concepts and theories? Which new research directions does NLP allow policy scholars to pursue? This workshop strongly encourages the submission of empirical research using NLP. Our call for papers particularly invites contributions linking such techniques with the advancement of public policy concepts and theories. The intended format of this workshop is paper sessions. A session will consist of several paper presentations, each having two discussants. We will propose a first discussant based on their knowledge of the research topic (e.g., a sectoral policy, a policy theory) and a second discussant based on their familiarity to the NLP technique used in the presentation. Thus, a contributor is expected to give one presentation and comment on two papers. We will finish each session with a brief Q&A round for other participants to engage. We also intend to organize, in the final session, an open discussion with the workshop participants on how we can structure the emerging field of NLP for public policy research and discuss ways to go forward. We will propose to the participants a follow-up session in the next IPPA general conference, but also consider other forms of engagement and collaboration. Regarding contributors, the chairs of this workshop have already identified potential participants, as the chairs are currently working with researchers using NLP for policy in diverse universities in the Netherlands and abroad. They have expressed interest in participating in this workshop, and we believe our call for papers is of interest to the researchers working with NLP in the IPPA.
POLICY TOPICS
W03. Decolonizing Public Policy: struggles, ideas and experiences from the Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
In this workshop, we will delve into the ways in which decolonial and feminist perspectives can critically enhance analytical frameworks in public policy studies. Our objective is to identify the unique assets and advantages that these approaches offer in understanding and explaining public policy phenomena, with particular attention paid to the arguments and values that underlie struggles, ideas, and experiences. During the workshop, we will explore some recent works that have attempted to bridge the gap between these perspectives, mapping their efforts. However, we will focus on two different directions. The first direction focuses on epistemological pluriversity and the circumstances in which policy interactions occur. It is closely related to the idea of coloniality of knowledge, which is a central aspect of the broader category of coloniality of power, as proposed by Quijano (2005). Together, these concepts enable us to examine the dominant positivist paradigm in mainstream science critically, and to recognize the extent to which our post-positivist, non-mainstream ideas of science are also colonized. While we may acknowledge other epistemological frameworks and rationalities, we must ask ourselves to what extent we truly engage with them. Epistemological pluriversity can also help us to recognize alternative modes of thinking from other regions, which carry with them different references, experiences, and memories. The concept of coloniality of knowledge can assist us in questioning our critical epistemological structures, allowing us to name social phenomena, categories, processes, and places - echoing Spivak's question (1988) whether the subaltern can speak. Reflecting on the limitations of epistemological systems, Oyèrónkẹ Oyěwùmí (1997) reminds us that any process of categorizing the social other can involve distortions, linguistic and meaning mystifications, or even a total lack of understanding. Valentin-Yves Mudimbe (1988) warned us that the very construction of the idea of Africa involved both the reduced and oppressive Western images of this vast and plural continent, as well as the use of models of analysis supported by an "order of Western epistemology" (1988, p.10). These movements can generate a type of violence known as epistemic oppression (Dotson, 2014), epistemic violence, epistemic racism, or epistemicide, as Suely Carneiro (2005) stated. According to Walter Mignolo (2002), knowledge is never abstract and delocalized, although modernity has forced this vision. In this sense, Edgardo Lander (2005) explores different expressions of epistemic violence in the social sciences from the cultural dimension of neoliberalism as a hegemonic expression of civilization. These paths of inquiry enable us to deeply reconsider the production and validation of our epistemological worldviews, particularly when we begin to think in terms of border epistemologies—those that are constructed in new spaces and respect pluriversity, in line with Catherine Walsh's (2009) concept of interculturality. Where are these border areas, and how can we create spaces for them within critical studies in public policies? These zones can emerge in our thematic choices, objects of study, frameworks of analysis, methodological paths, and normative frameworks, but only when we take the time to thoroughly examine them. The concept of decolonizing knowledge offers a second direction of inquiry. Decolonizing knowledge is a political concept that presents itself as a counter-hegemonic alternative, situated within a broader context of domination. The recognition of subordination is a crucial first step towards political liberation. The strength of decolonizing knowledge comes from the realization that the domain of subjectivities is one of the main mechanisms of colonialism. This mechanism was well articulated by the Congolese scholar Valentin Mudimbe (1988), who argued that the “reform of native minds” was one of the most forceful and violent actions of colonial modernity. Here, we are referring to the domain of subjectivities as the disintegration between body and reason, and between nature and society. The colonized body was understood as lacking agency, subjectivity, and voice, as explained by the American scholar bell hooks (1984). Therefore, bringing back the body is an essential part of decolonizing knowledge, since colonialism also regulates otherness, gender, sexuality, nature, and its resources. The American scholar Patricia Hill Collins (2018) refers to a decolonial black feminist epistemology that has two crucial pillars: the ethics of care and personal responsibility in research. Collins emphasizes individual uniqueness, the role of emotions in dialogue, and the power of empathy as practical avenues of investigation. These approaches can enable social subjects who are often overlooked in scientific research to gain biopolitical visibility, with their own voices, discursive structures, sensory and cultural references. Expanding the dimensions of investigation of social realities and identities is related to the necessary efforts at intersectionality, as Kimberle Crenshaw (1991, 2019) has taught us, along with other important women authors. Gender, race, class, ability, sexual orientation, religion, caste, age, geolocation, and other identity markers are organized in multiple and simultaneous dimensions, and are all relevant for understanding the processes of exclusion, silencing, and violence against social bodies that have historically been denied recognition in their experiences of doing, feeling, and living. The Brazilian scholar Lélia Gonzales (2020) proposes the concept of Amefricanity as a political-cultural category, while the Argentinian scholar Zulma Palermo (2018) discusses the place of knowledge as a methodological proposal for the recognition of knowledge that is built in common and shared and Rosana Boullosa (2019) talks about the concept of multiactoriality. All these movements are, to some extent, connected with the idea of decolonizing knowledge, which highlights the non-neutrality of knowledge and points to the naturalized systems of oppression and domination of subjectivities. They also creatively bring to scientific research other social subjects, their bodies, their experiences, their knowledge, and their internal processes of validating the construction of the self and the other. Both directions help expose and question how our cognitive perspectives, subjectivities, and material and intersubjective experiences are colonized. References Boullosa, Rosana (2019). Mirando ao Revés as políticas públicas: os desenvolvimentos de uma abordagem crítica e reflexiva para o estudo das políticas públicas. Publicações da Escola da AGU, v. 11, p. 89-106 Carneiro, Suely. (2005). A construção do outro como não-ser como fundamento do ser (Tese (Doutorado). Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo. Collins, Patrícia Hill. (2018). Epistemologia feminista negra. In: Bernardino-Costa, JOaze; Maldonato-Torres, Nelson & Grosfoguel, Ramón. Decolonialidade e Pensamento Afrodiaspórico. Belo Horizonte, Autêntica. Crenshaw, Kimberle. (1991). Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Color. Stanford Law Review, 43(6), 1241–1299. https://doi.org/10.2307/1229039. Dussel, Enrique. Lima Loch 2018 Quili(1994). El encubrimiento del Outro: hacia el origen del "mito de la Modernidad". La Paz: Plural, 1994. Fanon, Frantz. (1952). Peau noire, masques blancs, Paris: Éditions du Seuil, 1952 Gonzales, Lélia. (2020). Por um feminismo afro-latino-americano. Rio de Janeiro: Zahar. hook, bell. (1984). Feminist Theory: From Margin to Center. South End Press. 1984. Lugone, Mama. (2005). “Multiculturalismo radical y feminismos de mujeres de color”. In: Revista Internacional de Filosofía política, (25), p. 61-76. Mignolo, Walter. (2002). “The geopolitics of knowledge and the colonial difference”. The South Atlantic Quarterly, v. 101, n. 1, p. 57-95. Mudimbe, Valentin. (1988). The Invention of Africa. Gnosis, Philosophy, and the Order of Knowledge, Bloomington, Indiana University Press. Oyěwùmí, Oyèrónkẹ. (1997). The Invention of Women: Making an African Sense of Western Gender Discourses. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1997. (ISBN 978-0-8166-2441-6). Palermo, Zulma. (2018). Lugarizando saberes. IN: Cadernos de estudos culturais, Campo Grande, MS, v. 2, p. 149-160, jul./dez. Quijano, Anibal. (2005). Colonialidade do poder, eurocentrismo e América Latina. In.: Edgardo Lander (Org.). A colonialidade do saber: Eurocentrismo e ciências sociais - Perspectivas latinoamericanas. Colección Sur Sur, CLACSO: Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires, 2005. p. 107-126. Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty (1988). Can the Subaltern Speak? Die Philosophin 14 (27):42-58. Walsh, Catherine. (2009). Interculturalidad, Estado, Sociedad. Luchas (de) coloniales de nuestra época. Quito: Ed. Abya Yala.
POLICY TOPICS
W04. The Paradox of AntiCorruption Policy Formulation, Adoption, and Implementation in Contexts of Systemic Corruption
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Policies demanding change from those same actors that implement them incur in a problematic situation of a special kind. Governments in such situations are said to face a super wicked problem (Peters, 2017). Anti-corruption policies among other types of policies, such as State power checks & balances, lie behind this label of problems. Characteristics of these problems include high political controversy and high cognitive challenges (Alford & Head, 2017). The former is needed to grant legitimacy to make a State-level intervention, and the latter is needed to understand how to solve a problem. A persuasive but technically sound narrative makes for effective policies (Giandomenico, 1989), but super-wicked problems are posed to solve an impossible conundrum: one where those who need to change may not be willing to be effective, and those who oversee policies’ design and implementation might like to open the possibility of failure. This is the case of anti-corruption policies in contexts of systemic corruption (Mungiu-Pippidi, 2006; Marquette & Peiffer, 2018; Persson, Rothstein & Teorell, 2013; Meza, Pérez-Chiqués, & Hernández, 2023), or corruption that has become pervasive, is normalized and socially and politically accepted, and that is sustained by cultural understandings and informal institutions (Arellano-Gault, 2018; Marquette & Peiffer, 2018; Rothstein, 2011. Under conditions where systemic corruption exists, promises to address this problem fall under a special kind of policy paradox (Stone, 2001). This workshop aims to provide some light into the fundamental question of why and how polities where corruption is the rule establish anti-corruption policies? Hypotheses in the literature have brought forward some reasons -signaling, fire-alarm or insurance- (Schnell, 2018). However, these points of departure still offer ample room to explain the phenomenon for developing countries and the global south under policy theoretical lenses and/or neo-institutionalist perspectives (Fritzen, 2005). At the same time, the answers to the question will advance theoretical frameworks by looking at the particularities of a kind of policy/problem where a special kind of paradox persists. To name few examples: The wickedness of problems may be closest related to the institutional capacity of the State, rather than its inherent wickedness. For instance, in the drug policy frameworks, the degree of wickedness of the problem is a result of the government structure and its institutional (in)capacity (Meza, Guerra & Corona, 2018). A theoretical proposition behind the design, structure, and form of anti-corruption policies is shaped by the extant capacity to address the political controversy and the cognitive challenge of solving problems.Policy studies can also contribute to understanding the form of anti-corruption policies. In a policy subsystem, amid a policy debate, the timing of a series of corruption scandals --in this case an “endogenous” shock-- could jeopardize the stalemate between antagonist actors, rebalancing the equilibrium in favor of a coalition that produces a policy change or the adoption and implementation of a certain set of anti-corruption policies.Scandals could serve as triggering events with positive feedback that, in line with the Punctuated Equilibrium Theory, could break the stability of policies by producing change. Long-lasting equilibriums being breached by episodes in history, bringing sudden change, are explained by both the force of the uprising event combined with the inherent friction of the system; friction that is associated with its organizational features and capacities (Breunig & Koski, 2006; Flink, 2017).Who is the policy target where corruption is systemic? How have the polities socially constructed the policy target (Schneider & Ingram 1993) of anti-corruption policies? In places where corruption is endorsed by the system, corruption becomes the main and most important form of social advancement; it is actually a peer-accepted strategy. Therefore, the cultural notion of “those who do not cheat do not advance” is brain-wired as a sound formal institution. What happens if such a cognitive appraisal of corruption is modified to allow people to revisit themselves as victims of these acts? A possibility to mitigate systemic corruption could pass through the social manipulation of the construction of policy targets, but is there any evidence of it in the real world? Answers to the question around the reasons, extent, and implications of governments adopting anti-corruption policies is conditional to many factors that the workshop is hoping to contribute. References Alford, J., & Head, B.W. (2017). Wicked and Less Wicked Problems: A Typology and a Contingency Framework. Policy and Society, 36(3), 397-413.Arellano-Gault, D. (2018). ¿Podemos Reducir la Corrupción en México? Límites y Posibilidades de los Instrumentos a Nuestro Alcance, 2da edición, Ciudad de México: CIDE. Breunig, C., & Koski, C. (2006). Punctuated Equilibria and Budgets in the American States. Policy Studies Journal, 34(3), 363–379. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1541-0072.2006.00177.x Flink, C. M. (2017). Rethinking Punctuated Equilibrium Theory: A Public Administration Approach to Budgetary Changes. Policy Studies Journal, 45(1), 101–120. https://doi.org/10.1111/psj.12114 Fritzen, S. (2005). Beyond “Political Will”: How Institutional Context Shapes the Implementation of Anti-Corruption Policies, Policy and Society, 24:3, 79-96, DOI:10.1016/S1449-4035(05)70061-8 Majone, G., 1989. Evidence, Argument, and Persuasion in the Policy Process. Yale University Press. Marquette, H., & Peiffer, C. (2018). Grappling with the “Real Politics” of Systemic Corruption: Theoretical Debates versus “Real-World” functions. Governance, 31(3), 499–514. Meza, O., Guerra, E., & Corona, G. (2018). Las Políticas de Drogas y el Estado: Una Aproximación para una Política de Mitigación de Riesgos. Boletim de Análise Político-Institucional Diciembre, 18, 19–29. Meza, O., Pérez-Chiqués, E., & Martínez-Hernández, A. A. (2023). Framework to understand and address the systemic corruption in local governments. Revista de Administração Pública, 57, e2022-0346. Mungiu-Pippidi, A. (2006). Corruption: Diagnosis and Treatment. Journal of Democracy, 17(3), 86–99. Persson, A., Rothstein, B., & Teorell, J. (2013). Why Anticorruption Reforms Fail–Systemic Corruption as a Collective Action Problem. Governance, 26(3), 449–471. Peters, B. G. (2017). What is so Wicked about Wicked Problems? A Conceptual Analysis and a Research Program. Policy and Society, 36(3), 385–396. Rothstein, B. (2011). The Quality of Government: Corruption, Social Trust, and Inequality in International Perspective. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Schneider, A., & Ingram, H. (1993). Social Construction of Target Populations: Implications for Politics and Policy. The American Political Science Review, 87(2), 334–347. Schnell, S. (2018). Cheap Talk or Incredible Commitment?(Mis) Calculating Transparency and Anti‐Corruption. Governance, 31(3), 415–430. Stone, D. (2001). Policy Paradox: The Art of Political Decision Making. New York and London.
POLICY TOPICS
W05. Shaping Policymaking from the Ground Up: Activism and Governance in Multi-Level Institutional Settings
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Social movements often mobilise to produce or prevent policy change. The question of their power is ever more relevant in today’s divided societies. With political contention on the rise, fresh forms of activism have emerged around the defining issues of our time, such as climate change, immigration, race, social welfare, and LGBTQ+ rights. These highly politicised policy domains, moreover, stretch across multiple geographical scales and government levels, urging both activists and policymakers to navigate opportunities and constraints in complex, fragmented, and uneven institutional landscapes. The aim of this workshop is to understand when, why, and how activism can shape policymaking processes in multi-level institutional settings. This question has animated extensive research in the fields of public policy analysis, social movement studies, and political geography, giving rise to a vibrant yet siloed debate. Bringing together experts and insights from these different scholarships, the workshop will make a path-breaking contribution to the study of public policy in times of political polarisation and institutional rescaling. Scholarship on multi-level governance and federalism offers important insights on the policy consequences of activism. Over the past decades, the devolution of policymaking powers to assorted sites of authority has led to a greater involvement of grassroots organisations in the production of public goods, sometimes transforming institutions into “laboratories of democracies” (e.g. Pierre and Peters 2020; Alcantara and Nelles 2014; Kleider and Toubeau 2022). Besides these collaborative forms of governance, however, rescaling trends have also bred contentious dynamics, offering notable opportunities for protestors who seek to change policies from below. These actors have more chances to access policy venues that are hospitable to their demands when authority is dispersed across multiple government tiers (e.g. Caiani and Graziano 2018; Sapotichne and Jones 2012; Pralle 2003). Venue-shopping is indeed the typical tactical option adopted by policy losers, disadvantaged groups, or outsiders (Fischer et al. 2015). Another consequence of government decentralisation is that policymakers operating at different spatial scales may have diverse, sometimes contrasting agendas, in a way that is conducive to multi-level policy conflicts (e.g. Verhoeven 2021; Wolf 2021; Scholten 2013). Collectively, this scholarship thus highlights how a panoply of actors in- and outside of government interact with one another—in collaborative or confrontational ways—to shape policymaking processes (Berglund et al. 2022; Méndez 2020). Social movement scholars have also grappled with the question of activists’ political power (Bosi, Giugni, and Uba 2016). They emphasise that grassroots demands are more likely to make political headway when sympathetic office holders work as access points to the institutional space (e.g. della Porta 2022; Soule and King 2006). Policymakers, in turn, might be incentivised to be responsive because activists can provide crucial material, cognitive, and human resources to enact public policies (de Graauw 2016), while possibly energising government’s agenda from the bottom up (Bazurli 2019; Holdo 2016; Hutter, Kriesi, and Lorenzini 2019). Put differently, social movements can affect policymaking by altering elites’ calculation, i.e. seeking to be perceived as potentially facilitating or disruptive for institutional goals (Amenta, Andrews, and Caren 2019). Their victories, however, are hardly set in stone. For instance, protestors might succeed to set the public debate on urgent problems the electorate cares about, but their demands are often watered down as the policy process proceeds (Jasper et al. 2022). Every social movement that hopes to leave some institutional traces must grapple with uneasy dilemmas that expose the fragility of its own political power (e.g. Lipsky 1970). In all, despite their important contribution, scholars of social movements often see mobilisation as constrained within jurisdictional containers, thus failing to recognise how policymaking unfolds across geographical and institutional scales. The question of scale is instead crucial for geographers and urban scholars interested in contentious politics and governance dynamics. This strand of research highlights that cities are strategic sites for the mobilisation of marginalised groups (e.g. Nicholls, Gnes, and Vermeulen 2021; Lacomba 2021; Briata, Colomb, and Mayer 2020). The peculiar qualities of urban spaces—notably, the availability of dense relational networks extended over an array of geographical scales—allow them to create bonds of solidarity, forge alliances, and ultimately turn into vocal political subjects (Nicholls 2016). In this way urban social movements can upscale their mobilisation and access political arenas at the regional, national, or supra-national level, possibly producing policy outcomes far beyond the immediate local contexts in which activism originated. Moreover, scholarship on urban governance and municipalism emphasises how institutional rescaling offers opportunities to experiment with radical innovations, tackle inequalities, and revamp democracy (e.g. Ruth, Russel, and Thompson 2023; Bianchi 2022; McGuirk et al. 2022). Decentralisation allows marginalised residents to benefit from new, more proximate access points to the institutional space—sometimes driving inspirational innovations that spread worldwide, as in the case of participatory budgeting in Latin American cities (e.g. Halvorsen 2019). Yet this scholarship also warns that local policymaking is not necessarily coordinated (e.g. Borraz and Le Galès 2010) nor conducive to inclusive social change (e.g. Varsanyi 2010; Purcell 2006). Building on these efforts, the workshop will lay the groundwork for a fresh theorisation of activism’s impacts on policymaking in multi-level jurisdictional contexts. We will explore the opportunities and constraints that authority dispersal across multiple policy venues offer to those mobilising from the periphery of power relations. The role of institutional allies will also be analysed, and notably their ambivalent role in empowering social movements while possibly twisting them to their own ends. We will also shine a light on the spatial dimension of governance, assessing how the urban scale can be harnessed by activists to produce far-reaching policy changes, and what dilemmas they face along the way. Bridging insights from complementary yet so-far disconnected theoretical perspectives, the workshop will push the boundaries of the scholarly debate on policymaking and activism. References Alcantara, C., & Nelles, J. (2014). Indigenous Peoples and the State in Settler Societies: Toward a More Robust Definition of Multilevel Governance. Publius: The Journal of Federalism, 44(1), 183-204. Amenta, E., Andrews, K. T., & Caren, N. (2019). The Political Institutions, Processes, and Outcomes Movements Seek to Influence. In The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Social Movements, edited by Snow, D. A., Soule, S. A., Kriesi, H., & McCammon, H. J. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley-Blackwell. Bazurli, R. (2019). Local Governments and Social Movements in the ‘Refugee Crisis’: Milan and Barcelona as ‘Cities of Welcome’. South European Society and Politics, 24(3), 343-370. Berglund, O., Dunlop, C. A., Koebele, E. A., & Weible, C. M. (2022). Transformational Change through Public Policy. Policy & Politics, 50(3), 302-322. Borraz, O., & Le Galès, P. (2010). Urban Governance in Europe: The Government of What?. Pôle Sud, (1), 137-151. Bosi, L., Giugni, M., & Uba, K. (Eds.). (2016). The Consequences of Social Movements. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Bianchi, I. (2022). The Local State’s Repertoires of Governance Strategies for the Urban Commons: Nuancing Current Perspectives. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space, 40(8), 1784-1800. Briata, P., Colomb, C., & Mayer, M. (2020). Bridging Across Difference in Contemporary (Urban) Social Movements: Territory as a Catalyst. Territory, Politics, Governance, 8(4), 451-460. Caiani, M., & Graziano, P. (2018). Europeanisation and Social Movements: The Case of the Stop TTIP Campaign. European Journal of Political Research, 57(4), 1031-1055. de Graauw, E. (2016). Making Immigrant Rights Real: Nonprofits and the Politics of Integration in San Francisco. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. della Porta, D. 2022. “Political Opportunity/Political Opportunity Structure.” In The Wiley-Blackwell Encyclopaedia of Social and Political Movements (2nd Edition), edited by David A. Snow, Donatella della Porta, Doug McAdam, and Bert Klandermans. London: Wiley-Blackwell. Fischer, M., Ingold, K., Sciarini, P., & Varone, F. (2016). Dealing with Bad Guys: Actor-and Process-Level Determinants of the “Devil Shift” in Policy Making. Journal of Public Policy, 36(2), 309-334. Halvorsen, S. (2019). The Political Opportunities of Urban Decentralisation: Mobilising Local Governance in Buenos Aires. Political Geography, 74, 102038. Holdo, M. (2016). Reasons of Power: Explaining Non‐Cooptation in Participatory Budgeting. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 40(2), 378-394. Hutter, S., Kriesi, H. & Lorenzini, J. (2019) ‘Social Movements in Interaction with Political Parties’, In The Wiley Blackwell Companion to Social Movements, D. A. Snow, S. A. Soule, H. Kriesi & H (Eds.), pp. 322-337. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell. Jasper, J. M., Elliott-Negri, L., Jabola-Carolus, I., Kagan, M., Mahlbacher, J., Weisskircher, M., & Zhelnina, A. (2022). Gains and Losses: How Protestors Win and Lose. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Kleider, H., & Toubeau, S. (2022). Public Policy in Multi-level Systems: A New Research Agenda for the Study of Regional-Level Policy. Regional & Federal Studies, 32(3), 277-305. Lacomba, C. (2021). Bridging City Environments: A Contextual Approach to the Mobilisation of Immigrant Groups. Urban Studies, 58(9), 1940-1956. Lipsky, M. (1970). Protest in City Politics: Rent Strikes, Housing, and the Power of the Poor. Rand McNally. McGuirk, P., Baker, T., Sisson, A., Dowling, R., & Maalsen, S. (2022). Innovating Urban Governance: A Research Agenda. Progress in Human Geography, 46(6), 1391-1412. Méndez, M. (2020). Climate Change from the Streets: How Conflict and Collaboration Strengthen the Environmental Justice Movement. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. Nicholls, W. (2016). Politicizing Undocumented Immigrants One Corner at a Time: How Day Laborers became a Politically Contentious Group. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 40(2), 299-320. Nicholls, W., Gnes, D., & Vermeulen, F. (2021). Local Path Dependency and Scale Shift in Social Movements: The Case of the US Immigrant Rights Movement. Geographical Review, 111(2), 269-286. Pierre, J., & Peters, B. G. (2020). Governance, Politics and the State. London: Bloomsbury Publishing. Pralle, S. B. (2003). Venue Shopping, Political Strategy, and Policy Change: The Internationalization of Canadian Forest Advocacy. Journal of Public Policy, 23(3), 233-260. Purcell, M. (2006). Urban Democracy and the Local Trap. Urban Studies, 43(11), 1921-1941. Roth, L., Russell, B., & Thompson, M. (2023). Politicising Proximity: Radical Municipalism as a Strategy in Crisis. Urban Studies, OnlineFirst. Sapotichne, J., & Jones, B. D. (2012). Setting City Agendas: Power and Policy Change, In The Oxford Handbook of Urban Politics, K. Mossberger, S. E. Clarke & P. John (Eds.), pp. 442-467. New York, NY: Oxford University Press. Scholten, P. W. (2013). Agenda Dynamics and the Multi-Level Governance of Intractable Policy Controversies: The Case of Migrant Integration Policies in the Netherlands. Policy Sciences, 46(3), 217-236. Soule, S. A., & King, B. G. (2006). The Stages of the Policy Process and the Equal Rights Amendment, 1972–1982. American Journal of Sociology, 111(6), 1871-1909. Varsanyi, M.W. (2010). Taking Local Control: Immigration Policy Activism in US Cities and States. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Verhoeven, I. (2021). Contentious Governance around Climate Change Measures in the Netherlands. Environmental Politics, 30(3), 376-398. Wolf, E. E. A. (2021). Dismissing the “Vocal Minority”: How Policy Conflict Escalates when Policymakers Label Resisting Citizens. Policy Studies Journal, 49(2), 640-663.
POLICY TOPICS
W06. TEST SOF IWPP JALISCO
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Hello, welcome to Guadalajara, Jalisco, home of WBC World Champion
POLICY TOPICS
W02. Policy Implementation Studies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This workshop combines "The merits and demerits of the third paradigm in policy implementation research and beyond: assessment and prospects" and "Learning about implementation through realistic evaluation and design recovery case studies" constituting this new working group. Learning about implementation through realistic evaluation and design recovery case studies: Ever since public policies became systematic objects of scientific research, by the middle of the 20th Century, the investigation of what happened between design and outcomes, of how did a policy worked (or not) has occupied a central interest in both fields (Pressman and Wildavsky). Implementation studies, single or multiple, were the cradle of policy analysis and public administration research (Lasswell) and, as we shall argue, should continue to be their meeting point. Yet policy analysis and public administration have often failed to share or interact. The label “implementation” is more often than not found within the field of policy analysis. But there is good reason to think this is because implementation is often considered a dependent variable in research projects, both because it is naturally uncomfortable to investigate, and because linking design with outcome is perhaps more dramatic and thus fashionable. Studies that provide in-depth understanding of such link is uncommon. On the public administration side, specialization made implementation studies the exclusive playground of evaluation. A myriad of highly specific tools to frame and study policy, with a legitimate pretention to be “scientific”, are used to answer the classical normative, often prescriptive questions of the field. But evaluations, as it is been known for some time (McLaughlin), generally privilege the study of outcomes, relating them directly to design, and failing to grasp the realization process explaining the links. In this proposed workshop we seek to combine two traditions that, we shall argue, could greatly benefit of dialogue, and eventually crossings over: public management (when possible, design-oriented) case studies and (when possible, process-oriented) realistic evaluations. Case studies derive from a commonsense way to draw lessons from experience. But, as suggested by Ragin or Yin, they grew to become a sophisticated tool in political science, as they part from the celebration and diffusion of best practices toward in-depth, qualitative knowledge on the “how” of phenomena. Recently, Michael’s Barzelay design-oriented case study methods provide a way forward for this perspective. Embedded in a venerable tradition of understanding public organizations as purposeful phenomena –artificial organisms, or “artifacts”– Barzelay draws a genealogy aligning Herbert Simon’s artificial organisms, Henry Mintzberg’s organizational configurations, Eugene Bardach’s smart practices and Mark Moore’s public-value oriented strategic management. The blend produced a compelling array of “questions to asks” and “answers to find” when understanding the role of design in why and how public management artifacts –organizations, campaigns, systems— became “working phenomena” or “functioning wholes”. Realistic evaluation, as in Pawson and Tilley, is an applied form of scientific research aimed at identifying “the worth and the value” of policy, and to inform it to decision-makers and practitioners. It should seek -at least that is the way it is conceptually presented- the best method for each peculiar circumstance, framing it as a program and condensing results in terms of mechanisms-context-outcomes popularly known today as “theory of change”. Implementation (Love) or process evaluation studies aim at identifying and isolating the causal power of implementation issues as something distinct from design issues. The point of choosing realistic evaluation as a “partner” to design-oriented case studies is their outstanding sharing (a) the importance of theory-based phenomena analysis (as opposed to solely evidence-based analysis) and (b) the backbone formula for explanation: mechanisms + context = outcome, and (c) the goal of producing “transferable” detailed answers to the questions about why programs worked, for whom, and under what circumstances. The merits and demerits of the third paradigm in policy implementation research and beyond: assessment and prospects This workshop provides an arena to discuss and assess the merits and demerits of the so-called third generation of policy implementation research. Policy implementation is a long-standing concern in public policy and administration research. Over the decades, the study of implementation dynamics, the main implementation arrangements and role of implementation in the policy-making process has continued to attract the attention of policy analysts and public administration scholars (see, among others: Sager and Gofen 2022; Casula and Steinebach 2023; Knill et al. 2023). Current scholarship is increasingly interested in understanding the link between implementation and other stages of the policy process (in particular the dynamic policy design/implementation link and its effects in terms of problem solution), as well as in advanced research designs including neighbouring disciplines such as economics and organization studies. Goggin famously divided the evolution of policy implementation research in three generations. The first generation emerged during the 1970s and was characterized by an explorative, and a-theoretical character, a single case focus, and the use of qualitative methods and approaches; the second generation emerged during the 1980s and it had the merits of proposing the first analytical-theoretical frameworks for the study of policy implementation. Goggin was the promoter of the third-generation research paradigm. In the scale between relevance and rigor, Goggin clearly stood at the rigor-pole. His “third paradigm” claims the rigorous research designs considered insufficient in the first two generations. Goggin et al. (1990, 19) defined the main trait of this third-generation research paradigm in the following way: - Key concepts and related variables must be clearly defined and operationalized;- Hypotheses derived from theoretical constructs should guide empirical analysis;- More use of statistical analysis using quantitative data to supplement qualitative analysis;- More comparison across different units of analysis within the same policy sector; - More comparison across different policy sectors;- More longitudinal research design (i.e., research time frame of at least 5 to 10 years). After more than 30 years, implementation studies following the third-generation research paradigm clearly highlighted the difficulty (and perhaps impossibility) of arriving at a shared theory of implementation. According to Winter (2012), in fact, implementation studies will improve by: (1) Accepting theoretical diversity rather than looking for one common theoretical framework; (2) Developing and testing partial theories and hypotheses rather than trying to reach for utopia in constructing a general implementation theory. The aim of this workshop is to provide an assessment of how implementation studies still follow the claims of the third paradigm, how they have changed, and in which direction they are heading today. The aims are twofold: 1) to reflect on the potentials and pitfalls of the key elements of this paradigm (Goggin 1986; Goggin et al. 1990) when doing implementation research; and 2) to discuss how policy implementation can improve (if it needs to improve) towards overcoming the limits of the third generation research paradigm. To achieve these aims, we will provide an arena to discuss and assess the merits and demerits of the so-called third generation of policy implementation research requesting analytic rigour in the study of implementation when it comes to theory and research design (Goggin et al. 1990, 19). Doing so, this workshop will be an opportunity to present and discuss contributions able, from a theoretical, analytical or empirical point of view, to show show the study of different implementation dynamics in multiple institutional and organizational setting is changing in modern societies within the third-generation research paradigm, and beyond.
POLICY TOPICS
W03. Implementing Inequities – Street-Level Bureaucracy in the Weak Institutions
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
What laws formally guarantee, politicians promise, and public policies aim to achieve needs to be materialized in our daily interactions with public organizations. There, we often encounter street-level bureaucrats, low-ranking public servants, or frontline workers who process our applications for a social benefit, provide access to public services such as health care or education, and enforce traffic and safety regulations. The academic literature has established a common ground in understanding these civil servants. It is well-documented, for instance, that street-level bureaucrats, or frontline workers, shape policies and public services rather than merely implement them (Lipsky, 1980; Maynard-Moody & Musheno, 2003). They do not simply apply formal rules to individual cases. Instead, a hospital’s emergency staff decides which patients to attend to first, police officers on the street decide whom to pull over and how to treat each specific case, and social workers negotiate with their clients about treatment plans. Although the specific organizational and work context matters, street-level bureaucrats always have some form of discretion in the way they interpret, apply, or bend the rules and deal with citizens (Hupe & Hill, 2007; Evans, 2011). What happens in street-level bureaucracies, however, when basic resources are not provided or are simply non-existing? Or when adverse working conditions limit the extent to which job expectations and client demands can be met? For example, in many places, nurses and medics face a lack of basic materials to provide health care. Police officers are expected to enforce rules in violent urban contexts or remote rural areas. Desk clerks have to make decisions in the absence of clear formal guidelines. And many social workers lack the means to attend to the problems of highly marginalized communities. This panel is about those street-level bureaucrats and seeks to contribute to understanding how structurally adverse working conditions affect bureaucrats’ decisions and behavior and how these impact policy implementation and citizen-state interactions. Rather than understanding street-level bureaucratic behavior and decision-making as a “collection of isolated individual actions” (Gofen, 2014: 485), we tap into a strand of research that highlights the way organizational contexts (May & Winter, 2009; Brodkin, 2012), societal expectations (Sandfort, 2000; Møller & Stensøta, 2019), formal rule systems and accountability regimes (Hupe & Hill, 2007), and professional networks and deliberation (Møller, 2021) shape frontline work. More specifically, this panel builds upon studies that draw attention to contexts where street-level bureaucrats commonly face adverse social and working conditions, such as precarity, instability, and endemic violence or corruption (Peeters & Campos, 2022). Most research on street-level bureaucracy has historically been conducted in countries characterized by high levels of administrative capacity, professional bureaucracies, stable rules of law, and in industrialized and often democratic societies (Bertelli et al., 2020). However, most of the world’s street-level bureaucrats work under very different institutional conditions. Politicized bureaucracies, low social trust in government, systemic corruption, precarious labor conditions, and limited state capacities are common traits of bureaucracies in developing countries and post-authoritarian regimes (Lotta et al., 2021). This panel contributes to decolonizing studies on street-level bureaucracy by questioning assumptions about the nature of North and South bureaucracies and the way weak state capacities, patchy service provision, contested state legitimacy, and social inequalities play out in street-level interactions between citizens and the state (Eiró & Lotta, 2023). The panel seeks to further our understanding of the way social inequalities fundamentally affect state-citizen relationships and how the street-level bureaucracies reflect and often reproduce these inequalities (Eiró & Lotta, 2023). Specific topics of relevance include – but are not limited to – the variety of strategies street-level bureaucrats develop to cope with extreme “public service gaps” (Hupe & Buffat, 2014), how territorial differences in policy implementation produce “fragmented stateness” (Perelmiter, 2021), the informalization of street-level interactions in the form of petty corruption (Blundo, 2006), the consequences of street-level bureaucrats’ embeddedness in the communities they serve (Bhavnani & Lee, 2018; Mangla, 2022), and the brokerage function of street-level bureaucrats in “relational states” (Peake & Forsyth, 2022). We hope that bringing forward research on these topics will prove key to decolonizing studies of street-level bureaucracy and to understanding citizen-state encounters across the globe. We welcome papers of all kinds of methods and approaches (public administration, ethnography, political science, etc.) in this panel. Although we aim primarily for scholars studying the Global South, we explicitly do not exclude papers presenting relevant research from other parts of the world. Paper submissions may be theoretical, methodological, or empirical. Relevant topics for this panel include: - Street-level bureaucracy and social inequality - Comparative studies of street-level bureaucracy - Street-level bureaucracy in the Global South - Contested citizen-bureaucrat interactions - Political influences on street-level bureaucracy - State and administrative capacity / institutional weakness and street-level bureaucracy - Decolonial approaches to street-level bureaucracy The panel is part of a broader community of scholars working on topics of street-level bureaucracy and frontline work in the Global South, particularly Latin America. During the IWPP 2024, we intend to present the findings from a book project (currently in production with Policy Press: https://policy.bristoluniversitypress.co.uk/street-level-bureaucracy-in-weak-state-institutions) as well as report on initial findings from the Working Group on ‘Street-Level Bureaucracy and Inequalities in Latin America’ of the Latin American Council of Social Sciences (CLACSO - https://www.clacso.org/burocracia-a-nivel-de-calle-y-desigualdades/). We will actively pursue publication strategies for papers presented at the IWPP 2024. To promote feedback and facilitate community building, all contributing authors to the panel will be asked to prepare comments on one of the other submitted papers to the IWPP 2024. References Bertelli, A.M., Hassan, M., Honig, D., Rogger, D., & Williams, M.J. (2020). An Agenda for the Study of Public Administration in Developing Countries. Governance, 33(4), 735-748. Bhavnani, R.R., & Lee, A. (2018). Local Embeddedness and Bureaucratic Performance: Evidence from India. The Journal of Politics, 80(1), 71–87. Blundo, G. (2006). Dealing With the Local State: The Informal Privatization of Street-Level Bureaucracies in Senegal. Development And Change, 37(4): 799–819. Brodkin, E. Z. (2012). Reflections on Street-Level Bureaucracy: Past, Present, and Future. Public Administration Review, 72(6), 940-949. Eiró, F. & Lotta, G. (2023). On the frontline of global inequalities: A decolonial approach to the study of street-level bureaucracies, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/muad019. Evans, T. (2011). Professionals, Managers and Discretion: Critiquing Street-Level Bureaucracy. British Journal of Social Work, 41(2), 368–386. Gofen, A. (2014). Mind the Gap: Dimensions and Influence of Street-Level Divergence. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 24(2), 473-493. Hupe, P., & Buffat, A. (2014). A Public Service Gap: Capturing Contexts in a Comparative Approach of Street-Level Bureaucracy. Public Management Review, 16(4), 548–569. Hupe, P., & Hill, M. (2007). Street-Level Bureaucracy and Public Accountability. Public Administration, 85(2), 279–299. Lipsky, M. (1980 [2010]). Street-Level Bureaucracy. Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services [30th Anniversary Expanded Edition]. New York, U.S.A.: Russell Sage Foundation. Lotta, G., Lima-Silva, F., & Favareto, A. (2021). Dealing with violence: Varied reactions from frontline workers acting in highly vulnerable territories. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space, 23996544211031560. Mangla, A. (2022). Making Bureaucracy Work: Norms, Education and Public Service Delivery in Rural India. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. May, P. & Winter, S. (2009). Politicians, managers, and street-level bureaucrats: Influences on policy implementation. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 19(3), 453-476. Maynard-Moody, S.W. & Musheno, M. C. (2003). Cops, Teachers, Counselors: Stories from the Front Lines of Public Service. University of Michigan Press. Møller, A.M. (2021). Deliberation and Deliberative Organizational Routines in Frontline Decision-Making, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 31(3), 471–488. Møller, M.Ø., & Stensöta, H.O. (2019). Welfare state regimes and caseworkers’ problem explanation. Administration & Society, 51(9), 1425-1454. Peake, G., & Forsyth, M. (2022). Street-level bureaucrats in a relational state: The case of Bougainville. Public Administration and Development, 42(1), 12‑21. https://doi.org/10.1002/pad.1911 Peeters, R. & Campos, S.A. (2022). Street-level bureaucracy in weak state institutions: a systematic review of the literature. International Review of Administrative Sciences. https://doi.org/10.1177/00208523221103196. Perelmiter, L. (2021). “Fairness” in an unequal society: Welfare workers, labor inspectors and the embedded moralities of street-level bureaucracy in Argentina. Public Administration and Development, 1– 10. https://doi.org/10.1002/pad.1954. Sandfort, J.R. (2000). Moving Beyond Discretion and Outcomes: Examining Public Management from the Front Lines of the Welfare System. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 10(4), 729-756.
POLICY TOPICS
W01. CURRENT CONDITIONS, POLICY CHALLENGES AND ORGANIZATIONAL MODELS IN LATIN AMERICAN HIGHER EDUCATION
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
CURRENT CONDITIONS, POLICY CHALLENGES AND ORGANIZATIONAL MODELS IN LATIN AMERICAN HIGHER EDUCATION Research Questions. This IPPA workshop aims at answering four main research questions, which are: 1) Are there any common features in the current state of Latin American universities, especially public ones, in aspects such as access, funding, infrastructure, curriculum, teaching and research capabilities, institutional visions and leadership models? 2) If some common features can be identified, What would be the main challenges facing Latin American universities? 3) What higher education models and public policies have been or could be implemented to face such challenges? And 4) What results or prospects may derive from such models and policies? Context. Latin American universities play a pivotal role in shaping the region's socio-economic development, driving innovation, and fostering educational and intellectual growth. This workshop would aim at arguing that there are some common conditions and challenges facing higher education institutions in the region. As coverage has increased from 23% in 2000, to 41% in 2010 and 52% in 2018, higher education increasingly brings many benefits for the development of people and countries in the region (UNESCO-IESALC, 2020). However, access remains highly unequal, as certain population attributes (particularly socioeconomic status and gender, but also geographical location, ethnicity and race, as well as disability) have led to an important gap in access to higher education (ECLAC, 2016). Most probably the COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated the unequal access to higher education. On the other hand, Latin American universities grapple with challenges such as limited funding, outdated infrastructure, and a brain drain phenomenon where talented academics seek opportunities abroad. Furthermore, Latin American universities seem to face some common challenges related to research and teaching, which hinder their ability to contribute significantly to global knowledge. As of research, it is often impeded by scarce resources. Additionally, limited collaboration between academia and industry restricts the practical application of research findings. Teaching, in turn, often faces challenges related to large class sizes, outdated curricula, and a scarcity of well-trained educators. Moreover, diverse student body comes from different cultural backgrounds, necessitating innovative teaching methods. One of the major problems in Latin American higher education is the high percentage of students who do not graduate. In the mid-2010s, a regional average of one third of university students completed their courses on time, and among students between 25 and 29 years of age who had enrolled, only 46% had graduated, 22% had dropped out and 32% were still studying. Although in general low, the graduation rate varies a lot within the region: While in Mexico and Peru it was 65%, in Honduras, Bolivia and Costa Rica it was under 40% (Haimovich, 2017). On the other hand, it is true that higher education leads to better paid and more stable jobs. The average income of university graduates in the region puts them in the top 10 to 20% of the highest earners in their respective countries. Those who complete higher education can expect, on average, a 104% return compared with those who have only completed secondary school (Ferreyra et al, 2017). However, behind these results there is wide variation, which depends on the type of provider (university, vocational institute or technical center), the course and subject area, and the quality or reputation of the institution (Urzúa, 2017). In many cases, unfortunately universities are not providing the skills needed in the job market. Understanding the challenges faced by Latin American universities is crucial for the overall development of the region. By studying these challenges, this research aims at providing valuable insights for policymakers and educators, so that universities in the region improve the access as well as the quality of education, foster innovation, and contribute more effectively to social development and global knowledge. Finally, it is essential to join efforts to find innovative solutions that counteract the effects of the various problems present on the quality of education and thus assure the improvement of institutional performance. State of the art, main issues addressed and contribution to research in the field. In relation to the questions posed, organizational theory offers a valuable perspective to enhance institutional performance by analyzing institutions in terms of their structure, policies, financial resources, and technology. Higher education institutions, due to their complexities, require a focus on governance, management, and leadership to achieve their academic objectives and serve a diverse audience. The centralization of resources, whether from the public or private sector, is also a significant factor, and this approach can provide tools to understand how these institutions operate and improve their performance (Marulandia et al. 2013). Denison (2019) proposes analyzing organizational culture as a crucial element to impact the quality of education by enhancing institutional performance. In this regard, organizational culture can be pivotal in achieving objectives, developing a shared vision, and establishing institutional policies from the perspective of all stakeholders. Furthermore, Schein (1992) emphasizes the importance of focusing on culture to positively influence individual behavior and achieve successful strategic results. In this context, universities need to focus their efforts on improving their performance to meet the demands of a globalized and ever-changing world. Moreover, higher education institutions face critical challenges in transitioning to online education and must adapt technologically. The consequences of this new model will affect various stakeholders, including students, faculty, administrative staff, authorities, and research centers. Thus, as a working hypothesis, we would like to explore the idea that organizational structure, management, culture and leadership play a key role in the current conditions as well as the possible transformation and improvement of higher education in Latin America. This workshop will aim at advancing knowledge in this field by discussing the extent to which these arguments hold in Latin American context, and with what consequences for the capacity of states in the region to adequately face the challenges facing higher education, especially public universities. Papers and research agenda. This workshop would be mainly interested in receiving papers which address the workshop´s research questions, arguments and hypothesis, adopting an empirical approach in the format of either country cases or comparative studies. Such cases or studies are expected to be based on the revision of primary and secondary bibliographic sources as well as interviews whenever possible. The workshop will involve on site presentations of the written papers received, and their discussion aiming at reaching answers to the research questions as well as the gathering of empirical evidence in favor or against the general arguments and the working hypothesis of the workshop. We plan to organize a second meeting in 2025 to discuss the revisions made to the papers, which could take place on site or on line. One possibility for that would be proposing some panels for ICPP-7. The organizers of the workshop would be following up the revisions of the papers, providing feedback and communicating the calendar of meetings. We expect to be able to present a book proposal to an editor at the end of 2025. Although so far we do not have specific participants confirmed, we know a good number of researchers within the IPPA Latin American Policy Network and the several Latin American networks related to higher education --which involve hundreds of researchers--, many of which quite likely would be interested in participating in the workshop. References Denison Consulting. (2019). Corporate culture and organizational effectiveness. Downloaded from https://www.denisonconsulting.com/culture-surveys/ ECLAC (2016), The social inequality matrix in Latin America. Santiago, Chile, ECLAC. Ferreyra, M.M. et al (2017), At a Crossroads: Higher Education in Latin America and the Caribbean. Directions in Development. Washington, DC, World Bank. Haimovich, F. (2017), “Equity, Quality, and Variety of Higher Education”, in M.M. Ferreyra et al, At a crossroads: Higher Education in Latin America and the Caribbean. Directions in Development. Washington, DC, World Bank. Marulandia, C. E., López, M. T., & Mejía, M. G. (2013). Análisis de la Gestión del Conocimiento en PYMES de Colombia. Gerencia, Tecnología e Información GTI, 12(33), 33-43. Schein, E. (1992). Organizational Culture an Leadership. Jossey Bass. UNESCO-IESALC (2020), Hacia el acceso universal a la educación superior: tendencias Internacionales. París, Francia, UNESCO-IESALC. Urzúa, S. (2017), “The Economic Impact of Higher Education”, in M.M. Ferreyra et al, At a Crossroads: Higher Education in Latin America and the Caribbean. Directions in Development. Washington, DC, World Bank.
POLICY TOPICS
W02. The Role of Public Policy in Fostering Social Innovation within Ecosystems
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Scientific Description - Context of the Topic The idea that innovative social action can create social value beyond the capability of existing systems (Adams and Hess, 2010) has become an object of huge policy interest in all parts of the world. As far back as the 1990s, state interventions have recognized social innovation as an option for simultaneously creating social benefits and economic opportunities. In recent years, social innovation has become an increasingly prominent concept employed by political leaders and administrations across the world. For instance, in 2003, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) supported a range of initiatives to promote inclusive entrepreneurship and improve social cohesion through the identification and dissemination of local innovations. In 2009, President Barack Obama established the Office of Social Innovation and Civic Participation to support cross-sectoral, bottom-up solutions to social problems in the USA. In Europe, social innovation has been equally conspicuous in European Union strategies and domestic policies (Nicholls and Edmiston, 2018). Despite this growing awareness and recognition that social innovations respond to societal needs that are not sufficiently addressed by market forces and governments, the social innovation sector continues to face significant challenges globally (Thurner, 2014). Schwab and Miner (2011) emphasize the institutional, legal, regulatory, and educational impediments that social innovators face in disseminating their approaches and solutions. Vasin (2017) asserts the need to develop new approaches for involving the public in solving social problems through collaboration and cooperation. Furthermore, Howaldt and Schwarz (2011) argue that social innovations are becoming increasingly important in the transition to a knowledge and service society, but they are often overlooked in discussions on national and regional innovation systems. In addition to the challenges faced by the sector, social innovators themselves are saddled with institutional, marketplace place, and educational impediments. Girling (2013) emphasizes the need for social innovators to meet evolving marketplace demands in addition to their social impact focus and Schwab (2007) concurs. Additionally, Vilarinho (2018) points out the lack of understanding and involvement of citizens in social innovation. Silva-Flores (2022) also points out that the biggest factors hindering social innovation and innovators are the lack of critical mass, fragmentation of efforts, and limited citizen participation in social change efforts. Overall, the social innovation sector faces challenges related to market dynamics, institutional barriers, and limited citizen engagement. Moreover, social innovation theorizes the process of innovation within the context of social relations, involving interaction between multiple players such as social entrepreneurs, civil society, government, enterprises, and research institutes (Vercher, 2022). According to Howaldt and Schröder (2016), two key factors are relevant to the effective action of social innovators. Firstly, the agency or personal capacity of individuals to take action and transform existing institutions and social systems. Secondly, the recognition that the agency is embedded in social structures and power relations that limit or encourage, to a greater or lesser extent, the possibilities to act and the scope of actions. This draws attention to the multi-actor perspective to building an entrepreneurial economy that Grimm (2009) posits and the importance of an ecosystem approach to resolving challenges, mobilizing support, and promoting collaboration among social innovation actors. Nonetheless, it is noteworthy that the ecosystems for social innovation are in different stages of development in various regions of the world. Similarly, though social innovations pop up in many areas and in many disguises, the conditions under which they emerge, develop, flourish, get sustained and finally lead to social change or social service reform are not yet fully understood in both academic and practice-oriented circles. This workshop aims to provide a platform for academics and practitioners to present their research on the role of public policy in fostering social innovation within existing ecosystems. Scope The geographical scope of this workshop will be global as it aims to present the state of the art on the topic. Hence, no geographical parameters will be set. Contextually, the intersectionality of the topic of social innovation and public policy and related concepts of social entrepreneurship, innovation management, the economics of social innovation, entrepreneurial ecosystems, social movements, social economy, and social networks will be explored. Research Questions How do social movements influence political processes? How can social innovation ecosystems strengthen state-society relations?What is the role of public policy in institutionalizing social enterprises in various countries? What is the relationship between social innovation ecosystems and the welfare state?What lessons can welfare states draw from social innovation ecosystems?Under what conditions do social innovations emerge from social movements and advocacy coalitions? To what extent have movement-led social innovations led to changes in public policy in the past and recent times? Objectives Primary: To present the state-of-the-art on the role of public policy in fostering social innovation. Secondary: To understand how social movements influence political processes in various parts of the world and draw learnings from various contexts.To share learnings on how social innovation ecosystems can strengthen state-society relations.To collate lessons learned on the conditions under which social innovations emerged from social movements and advocacy coalitions.To explore the extent to which movement-led social innovations have led to public policy changes in various parts of the world. Relevance of Social Innovation to Public Policy Research and Practice These papers collectively highlight the relevance of social innovation to public policy research and practice. Firstly, Ostling (2017) emphasizes that social innovation, characterized by civic engagement and novel interactions between government and citizens, can improve transparency and civic participation in the production and monitoring of public services. Adams (2010) argues that social innovation creates social benefit and economic opportunity, making it a significant option for addressing social challenges. Moulaert et al (2012) discuss the growing interest in social innovation among policy practitioners and the need for governments to support and foster social entrepreneurs and enterprises. Adams (2008) further explores social innovation as a strategy for public administration, emphasizing its potential for transformative thinking and action. Overall, the link between social innovation and public policy is a growing research field with increasing interest and publications (Weerakoon et al, 2016) as both are primarily concerned with addressing social problems and meeting social aspirations References Adams, D., & Hess, M. (2010). Social innovation and why it has policy significance. The Economic and Labour Relations Review, 21(2), 139-155.Girling, R. (2013). Global innovators: How open innovation serves humanity. In Small and Medium Enterprises: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications (pp. 1276-1292). IGI Global.Grimm, H. (2009). Creating an entrepreneurial economy: The role of public policy. Entrepreneurship, growth, and public policy, 299-318.Howaldt, J., & Schwarz, M. (2011). Social innovation–social challenges and future research fields. In Enabling Innovation: Innovative Capability-German and International Views (pp. 203-223). Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg.Howaldt, J., Kaletka, C., & Schröder, A. (2016). Social entrepreneurs: Important actors within an ecosystem of social innovation. European Public & Social Innovation Review, 1(2).Moulaert, F., MacCallum, D., Mehmood, A., & Hamdouch, A. (2013). General introduction: the return of social innovation as a scientific concept and a social practice. The international handbook on social innovation: Collective action, social learning and transdisciplinary research, 1, 1-6.Nicholls, A., & Edmiston, D. (2018). Social innovation policy in the European Union. Policy Design in the European Union: An Empire of Shopkeepers in the Making?, 161-190.Ostling, A. (2017). Social innovation in practice: opportunities for citizens and governments. En, A. Paulin, LG Anthopoulus y CG Reddick, Beyond Bureaucracy.Schwab, A. (2007). Incremental organizational learning from multilevel information sources: Evidence for cross-level interactions. Organization Science, 18(2), 233-251.Silva-Flores, M. L., & Murillo, D. (2022). Ecosystems of Innovation: Factors of Social Innovation and its Role in Public Policies. Innovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research, 35(4), 569-588.Thurner, T. W. (2014). Challenge social innovation: potential for business, social entrepreneurship, welfare and civil society.Vasin, S. M., Gamidullaeva, L. A., & Rostovskaya, T. K. (2017). The challenge of social innovation: Approaches and key mechanisms of development.Vercher, N. (2022). The role of actors in social innovation in rural areas. Land, 11(5), 710.Vilarinho, T., Floch, J., Oliveira, M., Dinant, I., Pappas, I. O., & Mora, S. (2018). Developing a social innovation methodology in the Web 2.0 era. In Internet Science: INSCI 2017 International Workshops, IFIN, DATA ECONOMY, DSI, and CONVERSATIONS, Thessaloniki, Greece, November 22, 2017, Revised Selected Papers 4 (pp. 168-183). Springer International Publishing.Weerakoon, C., McMurray, A., Rametse, N., & Douglas, H. (2016). A preliminary bibliographic analysis of the social innovation literature. In Proceedings of the 3rd Social Innovation and Entrepreneurship Conference (SIERC 2016) (pp. 345-360). New Zealand Social Innovation and Entrepreneurship Research Centre. Prospects for Publication Springer Nature Journal of Entrepreneurship and Public Policy (Emerald Publishing)
POLICY TOPICS
W03. Policies for Quality Education in Sustainable Development
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
Quality education is at the heart of the global commitment to achieve sustainable development, as outlined in the fourth Sustainable Development Goal (SDG4) under the Agenda 2030 for Sustainable Development. This commitment emphasizes the need for inclusive, equitable, and quality education as a fundamental component of the broader sustainable development agenda. The traditional approach to education, guided by national policies and strategies, has evolved to encompass a shared responsibility among individuals, educational institutions, and governments (Amin et al, 2023). Furthermore, education for sustainable development has transcended national boundaries, engaging a multitude of stakeholders and educational spaces at community, national, and international levels. The intricate interplay between these stakeholders and levels in shaping educational policies for sustainable development demands in-depth exploration and understanding. This workshop aims to delineate the overarching objectives, scope, and methodologies and will deliberate on policies designed at various scales to address educational challenges and innovate in the realm of education for sustainable development. The workshop's approach is multidisciplinary, inviting studies utilizing diverse research methodologies, including surveys, interviews, experimental designs, focus groups, document analysis, and presentations of pilot studies. While traditional educational policies have been primarily formulated at the national level, the evolving landscape of education for sustainable development necessitates the engagement of a broader array of stakeholders across different levels. At the community level, local organizations and communities play a vital role in shaping educational experiences. At the national level, governments and educational institutions provide the framework and resources for education (Hamwy et al, 2023). Internationally, organizations like UNESCO are instrumental in promoting global cooperation in the field of education for sustainable development. Despite the growing recognition of the importance of education for sustainable development and the increasing involvement of various stakeholders, there remains a gap in our understanding of the policy dynamics that shape educational policies for sustainable development in particular, and multi-scalar policy making in general. This workshop aims to address these gaps by facilitating discussions and research on how policies are formulated, implemented, and evaluated across different levels and by various stakeholders. The overarching objectives of the workshop are to: 1. Discuss policies designed at multiple scales (local, national, and international) to address educational challenges. 2. Investigate innovative educational policies that can contribute to sustainable development. Scope of the Workshop The workshop will encompass a wide array of topics related to educational policies for sustainable development, including but not limited to: 1. National Education Policies: Examination of how national policies promote or hinder sustainable development through education.2. Local Community Initiatives: Case studies on the role of local communities and organizations in shaping educational experiences.3. South-South Cooperation: Exploration of global collaborations and initiatives to enhance education for sustainable development.4. Policy Implementation: Analysis of the challenges and successes in implementing sustainable development policies at different levels.5. Evaluation and Impact Assessment: Studies on assessing the effectiveness and impact of various policies on sustainable development goals. Academic Sources To enrich the discussions and research during the workshop, the following academic sources are recommended: 1. Amin, H., Zaman, A. & Tok, E. (2023). "Education for sustainable development and global citizenship education in the GCC: a systematic literature review." Globalisation, Societies and Education. DOI: 10.1080/14767724.2023.2265846. 2. Hamwy, N., Bruder, J., Sellami, A., & Romanowski, M. H. (2023). "Challenges to Teachers Implementing Sustainable Development Goals Frameworks in Qatar." Sustainability, 15(15), 11479. 3. Cochrane, L. and Al-Hababi, R. (2023). Sustainable Qatar: Social, Political and Environmental Perspectives. Springer: Singapore. Open source: https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-981-19-7398-7
POLICY TOPICS
W04. Policy Science Amidst Uncertainty: Navigating Crises in a World of Inequality
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
The intersection of uncertainty and multifaceted crises, as manifested by climate change, COVID-19, and food shortages, has become a central concern in policy sciences (Weible et al., 2020). The literature on public policy highlights the challenges in governing complex issues, especially given that prevailing institutions tend to prioritize short-term, stable perspectives, sometimes to the detriment of effectively addressing these dynamic concerns (Auld et al., 2021; Levin et al., 2012). Such challenges are intensified by an evolving and sometimes contested knowledge base, owing to conflicting values or to the instability of rapid change. Moreover, scholars emphasize the inherent debates in problem-framing and the disagreements over issues and solutions. In democratic contexts, the idealized view of a policy process rooted in rationality often clashes with political dynamics, disputes, and ambiguity (Head, 2022). As an illustration, climate variability has ushered in significant uncertainties in water policy. These challenges include ensuring democratic governance during droughts and floods, as well as addressing water availability, quality, and related disputes (Milhorance et al., 2022). The COVID-19 pandemic prompted food system stakeholders globally to reconfigure their strategies, focusing on food security and support for the most vulnerable (Béné, 2020). Additionally, the rapid transformation of tropical forest landscapes, driven by intense land use change and climate change, necessitates enhanced alignment between global value chains, scientific insights, and local knowledge in policy formulation and implementation. These dynamic and rapidly evolving processes have challenged policy actors to adapt their approaches, fostering new modes of operation, enhanced flexibility, and novel forms of collaboration. Consequently, the notion of "wicked" or intractable policy problems, first introduced in the 1970s by Rittel and Webber, has resurfaced. Their 1973 paper critiqued the tendency to address broad societal problems with scientific data analysis or simplistic ideology. They contended that "wicked" social problems could not be resolved solely through technical expertise; rather, they necessitated participatory engagement that acknowledged the diverse values inherent in a pluralist society (Rittel & Webber, 1973). Recent literature on these issues spans various concepts, from adaptive governance (Folke et al., 2010; Pahl-Wostl, 2009) to crisis management (Ansell et al., 2016), coping strategies (Head, 2022), policy resilience and robustness (Capano & Woo, 2017), and thermostatic institutions (Auld et al., 2021). Specifically, in environmental governance, the adaptive governance concept advocates for polycentric, local-level decision-making (Folke et al., 2005). This notion underscores iterative changes, leveraging on-the-ground 'learning by doing' (Brunner, 2010). Central to this is institutional flexibility, which supports environmental monitoring and adaptable learning to respond to shifts. Additionally, trust and social networks emerge as vital in addressing rapid changes (Folke et al., 2005; Olsson et al., 2004; Pahl-Wostl et al., 2007). While these studies often focus on community institutions and apolitical local experimentation spreading through organized networks (Brunner, 2010) Cleaver and Whaley (2018) offer a holistic view on institutions, which encompasses both formal rules and power dynamics. Other analysts also recognize the importance of flexible policy designs. Concepts like policy resilience and robustness highlight an institution's capacity to evolve and sustain functionality amidst uncertainty (Capano & Woo, 2017; Howlett & Ramesh, 2022). Such studies suggest policies can adjust without overhauling institutions or overarching directives (Cashore & Howlett, 2007). However, these studies often prioritize governance efficiency, aiming for a balance between policy rigidity and adaptability, sidelining political aspects (Sørensen & Ansell, 2021). In contrast, other authors highlight policy instruments may emerge as a dynamic sociopolitical process in which people experiment with new routines to address challenges, solve problems, or perform their everyday activities (Cleaver, 2012; Mayaux et al., 2022). Moreover, the literature on policy mix and policy integration has frequently addressed complex and cross-sectorial policy issues. While these fields have seen significant theoretical advancements, their practical application has been limited to date (Trein et al., 2020). Despite their theoretical differences, these studies often emphasize the need for institutions that balance long-term goals with immediate responses to fast-paced changes. Furthermore, they suggest that mere scientific or technical solutions are insufficient, as core value differences demand political discourse and deliberation. Nevertheless, this literature has been insufficiently developed in regions marked by pronounced power imbalances, political instability, and social inequities, notably in parts of the Global South. In these contexts, some proposed policy interventions may inadvertently deepen conflicts and inequalities. For example, while digital innovation in agriculture presents opportunities for climate adaptation and sustainable transitions, ill-conceived policy integration can exacerbate digital divides, fuel competition between large-scale agribusinesses and family-run farms, and heighten the exploitation of natural resources (Bronson & Knezevic, 2019; Bühler et al., 2022). Therefore, this workshop addresses the challenge highlighted in policy literature of navigating overlapping crises, uncertainty, and adaptability, especially in contexts characterized by social inequality and power imbalances. Research questions guiding this workshop include: 1. How are events like climate change, COVID-19, food and environmental crises shaping new frontiers in policy research? Specifically, how can policy research theories and methods more effectively integrate uncertainty and complexity? 2. How can the literature on "wicked problems" more effectively integrate power dynamics, socio-economic disparities, coalition politics, and related narratives? How could this literature better inform governance models and regulatory frameworks? 3. How can policy design and implementation enhance adaptability while acknowledging the existing institutional settings, power imbalances, and deeply rooted knowledge and values? Additionally, what opportunities and constraints exist for policy learning in these contexts? 4. What insights can policymakers and policy research derive from resilience strategies and political reconfigurations following crises? We invite submissions based on policy process theories and constructivist approaches, with a particular interest in expanding these theoretical boundaries to encompass contexts in the Global South. We welcome explorations of various facets, including coalition politics and narratives, institutional design and change, policy implementation and instruments, the interplay between policy and science, and the perspectives on governance and stewardship of traditional communities. Our workshop emphasizes studies that explore theorical aspects, case-based policy processes and comparative analyses. It also seeks to bridge academic research with practical application. Contributions and publication: The Public Policy and Rural Development Network in Latin America and the Caribbean (Red PP-AL) will co-chair this workshop. We strongly encourage members of this network to submit papers, and support might be available to facilitate their in-person attendance. While we expect participation from Latin American countries, members of the wider international IPPA community and their research contributions are warmly welcomed. The workshop will be guided by a publication project for a special edition. Thus, the selection of papers will prioritize diversity in contexts and approaches. The workshop's structure aims to foster dialogue and ensure coherence among the contributions. References: Ansell, C., Boin, A., & Kuipers, S. (2016). Institutional crisis and the policy agenda. Handbook of Public Policy Agenda Setting, 415–432. Auld, G., Bernstein, S., Cashore, B., & Levin, K. (2021). Managing pandemics as super wicked problems: Lessons from, and for, COVID-19 and the climate crisis. Policy Sciences. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-021-09442-2 Bronson, K., & Knezevic, I. (2019). The Digital Divide and How It Matters for Canadian Food System Equity. Canadian Journal of Communication, 44(2), PP-63-PP-68. https://doi.org/10.22230/cjc.2019v44n2a3489 Bühler, È. A., Gautreau, P., & Lúcio de Oliveira, V. (2022). La revanche de l’agrobusiness brésilien. Études rurales, 209, Artigo 209. https://doi.org/10.4000/etudesrurales.29568 Capano, G., & Woo, J. J. (2017). Resilience and robustness in policy design: A critical appraisal. Policy Sci, 29. Folke, C., Carpenter, S. R., Walker, B., Scheffer, M., Chapin, T., & Rockström, J. (2010). Resilience Thinking: Integrating Resilience, Adaptability and Transformability. Ecology and Society, 15(4). https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-03610-150420 Head, B. W. (2022). Coping with wicked problems in policy design. Em Research Handbook of Policy Design (p. 155–175). Edward Elgar Publishing. https://www.elgaronline.com/display/edcoll/9781839106590/9781839106590.00018.xml Levin, K., Cashore, B., Bernstein, S., & Auld, G. (2012). Overcoming the tragedy of super wicked problems: Constraining our future selves to ameliorate global climate change. Policy Sciences, 45(2), 123–152. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-012-9151-0 Milhorance, C., Lazarotto de Andrade, M., Le Coq, J.-F., & Sabourin, E. (2022). Democratic public action in times of crises: Examining the resilience of Brazil’s food and water policies. Pahl-Wostl, C. (2009). A conceptual framework for analysing adaptive capacity and multi-level learning processes in resource governance regimes. Global Environmental Change, 19(3), 354–365. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2009.06.001 Rittel, H. W. J., & Webber, M. M. (1973). Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Policy Sciences, 4(2), 155–169. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01405730 Trein, P., Biesbroek, R., Bolognesi, T., Cejudo, G. M., Duffy, R., Hustedt, T., & Meyer, I. (2020). Policy Coordination and Integration: A Research Agenda: Policy Coordination and Integration: A Research Agenda. Public Administration Review. https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.13180 Weible, C. M., Nohrstedt, D., Cairney, P., Carter, D. P., Crow, D. A., Durnová, A. P., Heikkila, T., Ingold, K., McConnell, A., & Stone, D. (2020). COVID-19 and the policy sciences: Initial reactions and perspectives. Policy Sciences, 53(2), 225–241. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-020-09381-4
POLICY TOPICS
W01. The utilization of public policy knowledge and advice
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
ABSTRACT
This workshop is about how scientific knowledge and advice produced in the field of public policy – the common home field of scholars affiliated to the IPPA – are used by practitioners involved in the policy process, and what are the conditions at work. By scientific knowledge and advice on public policy we mean all fundamental and applied research in our domain, including political science, public administration and public policy. Practitioners involved in the policy process can work in two spheres. The first is that of practitioners in organizations with formal responsibility for public policy, such as the branches of government and agencies. The second sphere consists of actors trying to influence the policy process, such as stakeholders engaging in lobbying, advocacy or public affairs, and think tanks. These spheres involved in the policy process form two major categories of the ‘information professions’ (Abbott, 1988), a concept that covers all fields of practice where the production of information and its use are the main currency of the trade and add significant value. How do these types of information professions recognize and utilize scientific knowledge and advice on public policy, and what are the conditions for it? While there are several bodies of knowledge and literature connecting to this central question, the timeliness of the workshop theme is that still little is known about how the knowledge produced in our common field gets incorporated into politics and the policy-making process. Who uses scientific public policy knowledge, in which stage, with what purpose and function? What are the factors determining the utilization of public policy knowledge and advice by the two categories of information professions in the policy process? This underexplored territory includes the sources and providers of public policy knowledge, types of knowledge producing institutions such as universities, research centers, advisory bodies, think tanks, etc.. It also includes types of knowledge and the features of these types, such as fundamental or applied research, theory-driven or problem-driven, and commissioned or non-commissioned research. What we know from the general body of knowledge on ‘policy advisory systems’ is that scientific advice can flow from multiple sources, and also can be in competition. Here, research has focused on the policy advisory system at large or on specific activities of actors involved in advising. Influence in such systems comes from proximity to policymakers and control of the advice delivered (Halligan, 1995). Influence also is contingent to content and to the extent to which advice is ’cold’, long term and anticipatory, or ’hot’, short term and reactive (Craft and Howlett, 2012). Furthermore, a factor at play is whether advice produces problem-solving statements (Hassenteufel and Zittoun, 2017). Next to this, the literature on knowledge utilization focuses on the ‘boundary work’ at the science-policy nexus (Wittrock, 1991), and research in this corner has shifted from a linear and direct model of knowledge utilization towards more dispersed and symbolic forms of knowledge utilization (Weiss, 1979; Blum and Brans, 2017). What distinguishes our workshop proposal is that it focuses entirely on scientific knowledge on public policy, and goes further in addressing the conditions and behavior of actors who obtain, demand, select and utilize or deliberately discard this knowledge and advice based on it. It extends a recent major international research project on the Professionalization and Social Impact of European Political Science (PROSEPS) which has resulted in a comparative volume on the advisory roles of political science scholars in Europe (Brans and Timmermans, 2022). In this study, political science is broadly defined and includes public policy and public administration. The survey conducted for empirical analysis of advisory and related roles of academics comprised nearly 12,500 academics working at universities in 39 countries. The geographical scope in this project included all countries in Europe and some outside it, and at a panel at the ICPP5 in Barcelona in 2021 this scope was extended further. The main conclusion from this recent study on advisory roles is that academics in our field do engage: with a varying frequency and intensity they take advisory, opinionizing or advocacy roles. The study also shows that recipients of knowledge in our field range from domestic central or decentral branches of government to international organizations, from political parties to media, and from civil society groups and NGOs to businesses and branch organizations seeking access and influence on the policy process. This workshop proposal shifts the perspective to these types of users of academic knowledge and advice on public policy, on the side of policymakers and on the side of organizations or groups engaging in lobbying and public affairs or acting as a think tank. It thus specifies the knowledge utilization to scientific knowledge and advice produced in our field. What factors determine the recognition and utilization of knowledge on an object of study by those actors that often themselves are part of this object of study? The demarcation of scientific public policy knowledge is not limited to political and administrative structures, players and processes, but includes also more substantive policy domain knowledge as for example on international and EU affairs, social policy, economic policy, environment, civil rights, and immigration. On these and other major topics, specific public policy communities exist and for them questions about knowledge utilization are pertinent as the research work often done happens in proximity and at the boundary of science and practice, for example in official advisory bodies. Likewise, scholars on agenda setting, implementation, policy evaluation and administrative or democratic and electoral reform face knowledge utilization questions as the emphasis on social and other impact of their work becomes more pronounced (Eisfeld and Flinders, 2021). At the same time, science and advice have come under pressure because of politicization (Weingart, 1999) and populist tendencies of disqualification of academics and advisors and their work. Thus the main objective of this workshop is to better understand the utilization in practice of knowledge and advice on public policy and the conditions for this. The workshop seeks to unravel whether and how differences between types of users lead to different utilization patterns, and whether organizations where public policy knowledge is used develop and apply standards and competencies for professional use of this knowledge. Another objective is draw lessons from patterns observed, and get in this way an informed view of directions of further development of public policy as a relevant field of research and education. Given that in a growing number of areas of science, politicization is leading to a reversal of Wildavsky’s phrase ‘speaking truth to power’ into ‘speaking power to truth’, this is particularly important for the field that studies power itself. References Abbott, A. (1988). The System of Professions. An Essay on the Division of Expert Labor. Chicago, University of Chicago Press. Blum, S. and Brans, M. (2017). Academic policy analysis and research utilization for policymaking. In Brans, M., Geva-May, I. and M. Howlett (Eds.) Handbook of Comparative Policy Analysis. London: Routledge, 341-359. Brans, M. and Timmermans, A. (Eds.) (2022). The Advisory Roles of Political Scientists in Europe. Houndmills, Palgrave Macmillan. Craft, J. and Howlett, M. (2012). Policy formulation, governance shifts and policy influence: location and content in policy advisory systems. Journal of Public Policy, 22, part 2, August 2012. Eisfeld, R. and Flinders. M. (Eds.) (2021). Political Science in the Shadow of the State: Research, Relevance & Deference. London: Macmillan. Halligan J. (1995). Policy Advice and the Public Sector. In Peters G.B. and Savoie D. T. (eds.) Governance in a Changing Environment. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 138–172. Hassenteufel, P. and Zittoun, P. (2017). From Policy Analytical Styles to Policymaking Styles. In Brans, M., Geva-May, I. and M. Howlett (eds.) Handbook of Comparative Policy Analysis. London: Routledge, 56-69. Weingart, P. (1999). Scientific expertise and political accountability. Paradoxes of science in politics, Science and Public Policy, 26(3), 151-161. Weiss, C.H. (1979). The many meanings of research utilization. Public Administration Review, 39(5), 426-431. Wittrock, B. (1991). Social knowledge and public policy. Eight models of interaction. In Wagner, P., Weiss, C.H., Wittrock, B. and Wollmann, H. (Eds.). Social Sciences and Modern States: National Experiences and Theoretical Crossroads. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: 337- 339.