CATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
There is a long tradition in social science of downplaying the role of emotions and, more specifically, viewing an emotional approach toward politics as extreme and unreasonable (Beichelt 2022: 13). However, recently, the role of emotions in defining or influencing behaviour has been acknowledged, as illustrated by concepts like “Homo sentimentalis” (Illouz 2015), “Homo sapiens emotionalis” (Ciompi and Endert 2011) or simply “Homo emotionalis” (Beichelt 2022). Some argue that values, identities and emotions have indeed become more important in today’s societies (Scharfbillig et al 2021) and in behavioural and cognitive sciences we can even talk about “the era of affectivism”, as it has become increasingly difficult to deny that “emotions, feelings, motivations, moods, and other affective processes (...) are not only linked to our well-being but also shape our behaviour and drive key cognitive mechanisms such as attention, learning, memory, and decision-making” (Dukes et al. 2021: 816). This era is marked by a fast growth in terms of emotions-related research and publications, especially in the field of behavioural and cognitive sciences. It seems that social sciences, including political science, are somewhat lagging behind this trend. While in the past decade the importance of studying emotions has been recognised in political science as well, it seems too early to talk about a well-established field of research or a coherent research programme (Beichelt, 2022: 5). We lack solid empirical evidence as well as widely accepted theoretical models on the role of emotions, and especially moral emotions, in almost all aspects of politics. Conceptual and methodological problems abound, e.g.: How to define, categorise and measure political emotions? What kind of emotions play the most important role in politics? What is the process leading from moral emotions to the construction of identities that create target populations or constituencies for policy change? How to analyse the interplay of emotions with other political variables, like values and beliefs? What is the analytical model that grasps the best the role of emotions in political action: should we consider them dependent, independent variables; or both? What type of methods and indicators are the most useful for studying the political role of emotions? (See Lynggaard 2019.)
What is true for political science as such holds even more for the field of policy studies. It has been recognized that emotions play a significant role in the public policy process, influencing agenda setting, decision-making, policy formulation, and implementation (Leong, 2016). Emotions can shape public opinion, mobilize support or opposition, interact with policy advise, affect the acceptance of implementation, in short, impact the overall policy landscape. However, while there is a growing scholarship in the field, the above listed conceptual as well as methodological dilemmas are still pressing. Emotions also play an under-researched role in evidence-based policy tools, such as consultation and more generally stakeholders’ engagement in rulemaking and policy formulation. Does the presence of emotions hinder consultation or can it foster the participation of otherwise silenced actors (see: https://www.hiljaisettoimijat.fi/?lang=en)? Does emotional reasoning help or disrupt the overall evidential reasoning in the practice of regulatory impact assessment (Rantala et al. 2023)?
Cairney and Weible (2017: 623) describe three primary ways that emotion is used in policy process research: attention to public problems; to persuade and influence judgements about target populations; and to mobilise coalitions of policy actors.
Attention to public problems is a key element in agenda setting and according to punctuated equilibrium theory (PET), emotional arousal can increase attention to public problems: “Emotion is the gateway to selective attention: when emotion is roused, attention follows” (Jones and Baumgartner, 2005: 16). Emotional framing can be used by policy entrepreneurs not only to illicit attention, but also to undermine the legitimacy of dominant policy images and create enthusiasm for new ideas and images. Emotions are present in the Multiple Streams Framework (MSF) as well: Zahariadis (2015) argues that changes in the national mood can open an agenda window in the politics stream; and national mood is conceptualized as a collective emotion felt by the public. However, emotions can support stability instead of change: Zahariadis (2015) describes how a focusing event triggered fear among the public and how a fearful nation supported policy continuity rather than a policy change promoted by a policy entrepreneur. Under which conditions can emotions lead to either policy change or stability is one of the puzzles of the field.
Studies have shown that negative emotions, such as fear and disgust, can lead to a negative evaluation of policies and make them less attractive to stakeholders (Leong, 2016). Conversely, positive emotions can drive public support and engagement, leading to constructive feedback and policy improvement (Yang & Su, 2020). But in other instances negative emotions can trigger change: fear is one of the powerful emotions which are often exploited by policy entrepreneurs (see Jenneing et al, 2017). Renström and Bäck (2021) studying COVID-related policies argue that different emotions elicit support for different kinds of measures: fear and anger predict support for restrictive policies to limit the spread of the virus, while anxiety predicts support for economic policies. Therefore, addressing the issue of emotional valence of policies, how to measure it, and how it affects the support of governmental measures are relevant research questions.
Concerning the role of emotions in influencing judgements about target populations, according to both the narrative policy framework (NPF) (Shanahan et al, 2018) and the theory of social construction (Schneider and Ingram, 1997), policy actors frame characters and target populations using positive and negative emotions: those positively framed are either victims or heroes, and those negatively framed are villains. Emotions concerning target populations can affect the support of punitive measures in penal policy, of social benefits in social policy as well as of other proposals including gay marriage, and restrictions in immigration policy.
According to Cairney and Weible (2017: 623) emotions are also important in mobilising coalitions for policy change. Both the Advocacy Coalition Framework and the NPF hypothesize that in political conflicts policy actors will experience angel and devil shifts: in an angel shift, policy actors perceive their allies as benevolent and powerful, while in the devil shift, opponents are perceived as powerful but also malicious (Pierce, 2021).
However, apart from focusing attention, affecting judgements about target populations and mobilising policy coalitions, emotions are obviously present in every stage of the policy process. Emotions can impact the deliberation process, as public officials may find it challenging to handle emotions in the context of policy deliberation (Fink et al, 2023), and emotions influence policy formulation and policy design through their interactions with expert discourses (Durnová and Hejzlarová, 2017, 2022). The problem with the use of strong moral-emotional discourses in politics and policy is that they make more difficult, or even impossible, to have meaningful dialogue on these issues, and instead of solving social problems, which should be the ultimate goal of policy making, they make them worse and may even create new ones. While disregarding emotions in policy practice may lead to adverse policy outcomes (Borén et al, 2020) and public discontent concerning policy measures (see the example of COVID-19 related policies), ‘overemotionalisation’ may cause considerable difficulties in conducting policy deliberation and designing policies.
The above said apply to emotions in general. The study of moral emotions in policy making may raise further questions. Moral emotions are associated with a society’s norms and values and the interests or welfare of persons or groups, beyond the concerns of the actor (Haidt 2003). That is, moral emotions are the affective signals of prosocial behaviour and play a central role in influencing group-oriented thoughts and attitudes (Halperin and Schori-Eyal 2019). In other words, moral emotions embody an interaction between moral, pro-social attitudes and emotions; and they have a vast potential both to unite and divide people through forming political identities. With some exemptions (e.g., Rees et al. 2015, Roeser, 2012, Liang et al 2019) both policy studies as a disciplinary field and the practice of policy making have been neglecting the role of moral emotions in policy change, policy support and implementation. We assume that the interaction of moral considerations with emotions may amplify the above described effects of emotions on the policy process while, at the same time, raise specific challenges which are related to their identity-forming potential. The very general research question behind this workshop proposal refers exactly to this issue: Does the analysis of policy-related moral emotions need new analytical frameworks, and how can it build on the burgeoning scholarship of emotions and policy making?
In conclusion, emotions in general, and moral emotions in particular, have a significant impact on the public policy process. They shape public perception, influence decision-making, affect power dynamics, and can be mobilized to drive public engagement and support. Understanding the role of moral emotions in the policy process is crucial for policymakers and scholars alike, as it provides insights into how emotions can be harnessed or managed to achieve desired policy outcomes.
References
Beichelt, T. (2022). Homo Emotionalis. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Borén, T., Grzyś, P., & Young, C. (2020). Policy-making as an emotionally-charged arena: the emotional geographies of urban cultural policy-making. International Journal of Cultural Policy, 27(4), 449-462.
Cairney, P. and Weible, C.M. (2017). The new policy sciences: combining the cognitive science of choice, multiple theories of context, and basic and applied analysis, Policy Sciences, 50(4): 619–27.
Ciompi, L., & Endert, E. (2011). Gefühle machen Geschichte: Die Wirkung kollektiver Emotionen–von Hitler bis Obama. Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
Dukes, D. et al. (2021). The rise of affectivism. Nature Human Behaviour, 5(7), 816–820
Durnová, A. and Hejzlarová, E. (2017). framing policy designs through contradictory emotions: the case of czech single mothers. public policy and Administration, 33(4), 409-427. https://doi.org/10.1177/0952076717709524
Durnová, A. and Hejzlarová, E. (2022). Navigating the role of emotions in expertise: public framing of expertise in the czech public controversy on birth care. policy Sciences, 56(3), 549-571. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-022-09471-5
Fink, S., Ruffing, E., Burst, T., & Chinnow, S. (2023). Emotional citizens, detached interest groups? The use of emotional language in public policy consultations. Policy Sciences, 56(3), 469-497.
Haidt, J. (2003). The moral emotions. In R. J. Davidson, K. R. Scherer, & H. H. Goldsmith (Eds.), Handbook of affective sciences (pp. 852–870). Oxford University Press.
Halperin, E., & Schori-Eyal, N. (2019). Moral emotions in political decision making. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics, 1395–1404.
Jennings, W., Farrall, S., Gray, E., & Hay, C. (2017). Moral panics and punctuated equilibrium in public policy: an analysis of the criminal justice policy agenda in Britain. Policy Studies Journal, 48(1), 207-234.
Jones, B.D. and Baumgartner, F.R. (2005). The Politics of Attention: How Government Prioritizes Problems, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Leong, C. (2016). The role of emotions in drinking recycled water. Water, 8(11), 548.
Liang, D., Hou, C., Jo, M. S., & Sarigöllü, E. (2019). Pollution avoidance and green purchase: The role of moral emotions. Journal of cleaner production, 210, 1301-1310.
Lynggaard, K. (2019). Methodological challenges in the study of emotions in politics and how to deal with them. Political Psychology, 40(6), 1201-1215.
Nabi, R., Gustafson, A., & Jensen, R. (2018). Framing climate change: exploring the role of emotion in generating advocacy behavior. Science Communication, 40(4), 442-468.
Pierce, J. (2021). Emotions and the policy process: enthusiasm, anger and fear. Policy & Politics, 49(4), 595-614.
Rantala, K., Alasuutari, N. and Kuorikoski, J. (2023), The logic of regulatory impact assessment: From evidence to evidential reasoning. Regulation & Governance.
Rees, J. H., Klug, S., & Bamberg, S. (2015). Guilty conscience: motivating pro-environmental behavior by inducing negative moral emotions. Climatic change, 130, 439-452.
Renström, E. A., & Bäck, H. (2021). Emotions during the Covid‐19 pandemic: Fear, anxiety, and anger as mediators between threats and policy support and political actions. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 51(8), 861-877.
Rodríguez-Sánchez, C., Schuitema, G., Claudy, M., & Esper, F. (2018). How trust and emotions influence policy acceptance: the case of the Irish water charges. British Journal of Social Psychology, 57(3), 610-629.
Roeser, S. (2012). Moral Emotions as Guide to Acceptable Risk. In: Roeser, S., Hillerbrand, R., Sandin, P., Peterson, M. (eds) Handbook of Risk Theory. Springer, Dordrecht
Shanahan, E.A., Jones, M.D., McBeth, M.K. and Radaelli, C.M. (2018). The narrative policy framework, in C.M. Weible and P.A. Sabatier (eds) Theories of the Policy Process, 4th edition, Boulder, CO: Westview Press, pp 173–213.
Scharfbillig, M. et al. (2021). Values and Identities - a policymaker’s guide, Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
Schneider, A.L. and Ingram, H.M. (1997). Policy Design for Democracy, Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas.
Yang, Y., & Su, Y. (2020). Public voice via social media: Role in cooperative governance during public health emergency. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(18), 6840.
Zahariadis, N. (2015) The shield of Heracles: multiple streams and the emotional endowment effect, European Journal of Political Research, 54(3): 466–81.
CALL FOR PAPERS
Emotions play a significant role in the public policy process, influencing agenda setting, decision-making, policy formulation, and implementation. Emotions often shape public opinion, mobilize support or opposition, interact with policy advise, affect the acceptance of implementation, in short, impact the overall policy landscape. This is especially true for policies on abortion, end-of-life decisions, LGBTQ+ issues, immigration, genetic engineering, climate change, just to name a few, which raise serious moral questions and may trigger strong emotions. The link with moral questions makes some issues controversial because of moral emotions. By this we mean emotions that one feels about the other or about a decision because that position or decision is morally correct or wrong. These emotions contribute to identity formation, thus creating constituencies for or against policies.
The workshop invites empirical papers with both quantitative and qualitative methods that investigate the nexus between moral emotions and the different stages of the public policy process. Listed below are some questions to illustrate possible topics for papers. These questions are not exhaustive or comprehensive, and we welcome any other lines of investigations that address emotional aspects of public policies.
- How do moral emotions affect public support for policies? What kind of policies are supported by specific emotions?
- How to measure the moral emotional valence of certain policies?
- What is the role of policy entrepreneurs in (moral) emotional framing of policies? What makes emotional framing successful?
- What is the role of populist and radical politics in the emotionalization of policy issues?
- How are emotions integrated into policy discourses and policy narratives?
- What is the role of moral emotions in public consultations? How to deal with emotions in these settings?
- How to reconcile value laden and emotionally loaded discourses with expert knowledge?
- How do technocratic discourses that mute emotions affect policy design?
- What is the role of moral emotions in public acceptance of policies and the success of implementation?
ABSTRACT
Emotions play a significant role in the public policy process, influencing agenda setting, decision-making, policy formulation, and implementation. Emotions often shape public opinion, mobilize support or opposition, interact with policy advise, affect the acceptance of implementation, in short, impact the overall policy landscape. This is especially true for policies on abortion, end-of-life decisions, LGBTQ+ issues, immigration, genetic engineering, climate change, just to name a few, which raise serious moral questions and may trigger strong emotions. The link with moral questions makes some issues controversial because of moral emotions. By this we mean emotions that one feels about the other or about a decision because that position or decision is morally correct or wrong. These emotions contribute to identity formation, thus creating constituencies for or against policies.
It is a real challenge for democratic governance to pursue deliberation on these issues and elaborate evidence-informed policy solutions while dealing with the clash of values, identities and (moral) emotions. Also, some political actors may capitalise on these issues and use them to whip up emotions and reinforce political identities. The policy practice of populist politicians and illiberal governments provide abundant examples, but the role and political use of emotions has been recognized in liberal democracies as well. At the same time, technocratic discourse point to muting emotions, burying them under the surface of “rational” decision-making.
The workshop addresses the topic under a wide angle and invite both conceptual and empirical papers, with preference for empirical project. We wish to discuss both quantitative and qualitative work, that deals with the effect of emotions on the different stages of the policy process addressing questions like: How do emotional frames affect the public support of policies? What is the role of emotions in public consultations? How to reconcile emotionally loaded discourses with expert knowledge? How emotions affect policy design? Can technocratic discourse mute emotions? What is the role of emotions in public acceptance of policies and the success of implementation? A planned outcome of the workshop is a special issue proposal or an edited volume.
BIOGRAPHICAL PRESENTATION
Zsolt BODA (MA in Economic, PhD and DSc in Political science) is Research Professor and Director General of the HUN-REN Centre for Social Sciences as well as part-time professor of political science at the ELTE University of Budapest. His academic work focuses on the problems of governance, public policy, as well as institutional trust, its social roots and its consequences for policy effectiveness. He is the co-leader of the Hungarian Comparative Agendas Project, which is part of the international CAP network. His co-edited volume Policy Agendas in Autocracy, and Hybrid Regimes – The Case of Hungary was published by Palgrave in 2021. He is the principal investigator of MORES – Moral emotions in politics: how they unite, how they divide, a consortial Horizon project.
Claudio RADAELLI (BA in Economics and Social Sciences, PhD in political science) is Professor of Comparative Public Policy at the School of Transnational Governance, European University Institute, and Professor of Public Policy at University College London. Claudio is Editor of the International Review of Public Policy, and sits on the Boards of several academic journals. In the MORES consortium he works on moral emotions and public policy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
There is increasing recognition that policy design and practice need to consider the role of emotions. However, the way emotions are expressed, understood, and valued continues to be dominated by rationalistic perspectives on policy, human behaviour and technology. The English social housing sector exemplifies this paradox. It is amidst regulatory reform emphasising empowering tenants through tools such national league tables and complaints processes. Within the sector, there is interest in emotionally informed fields such as trauma-informed design informing practice. While commendable, more research is needed to explore emotionally informed concepts in social housing policy and practice.
This study investigates well-being conceptions by asking 'how can social landlords connect with tenants' understanding of home-based well-being?'. The paper employs an interdisciplinary framework weaving together insights from behavioural public policy and relational perspectives rooted in geographical studies of the home. The interdisciplinary framework has two aims: to disrupt landlords’ conceptualisation of well-being as a social value that can be produced through bureaucratic processes and rational assumptions of human behaviour. Second, to explore how the framework can elucidate the nuanced ways in which tenants experience their homes, particularly with respect to emotional complexities, and how this may introduce an emotional accent to policy and practice around home-based well-being. The study includes 42 interviews and two focus groups with practitioners, consultants, and tenants. Additionally, the research draws on the author's autoethnographic reflections from her role as a consultant to the social housing sector.
The paper argues that an interdisciplinary framework, informed by rational and emotional insights, can produce a shared subjectivity between tenants and landlords that can underpin dialogue to reimagine home-based well-being. This contributes to the emotions in policy literature by exploring how emotional knowledge can shape the ‘doings’ of practice. This draws attention to the first workshop question: how do technocratic discourses that mute emotions affect policy design? The interdisciplinary framework has its roots in the scrutiny of behavioural public policy, a domain subject to significant critique for its inherent technocratic tendencies. I argue that there are compatibilities with some behavioural insights into the experience of poverty and relational perspectives grounded in an appreciation of the emotional complexity inherent in the concept and experiences of home. Drawing out the compatibilities between the technocratic and the emotional provides a new way of thinking about housing well-being and produces a foundational shared subjectivity for the redesign of services. Thus, this paper contributes to explorations of how emotions can contribute to reshaping policy and practice in housing while remaining sensitive to the cultural dominance of technocracy and the risks of pathologising tenants through practitioner preference to utilise insights to effect normative change rather than understand tenants' circumstances and collectively explore what an emotionally informed conception of well-being may look like in social housing.
I aim to deliver on-site. I am an early career researcher and am undertaking a second emotionally informed piece of research concerning how tenants and landlords encounter each other in the space of the tenants' home.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
As many countries struggle to increase their revenue and balance their fiscal budgets, increasing tax revenues and reducing tax evasion continue to be an important opportunity for most governments. This is especially key when countries face recessions and accompanied fiscal deficits. Hence the importance of understanding potential unique factors associated with change in tax morale, as a lever to increasing tax compliance.
The research question of this paper is to assess if the unique factors of a recession in terms of severity of economic impact and the governments' related policy response to the recession influences citizens’ tax morale. Tax morale refers to citizens’ attitude towards paying taxes, which earlier research showed to be a useful proxy for tax compliance.
To answers this research question, a rich secondary data set was constructed across 29 states from various US government sources and the World Value Survey in the period around the great recession (i.e., 2006-2011), as input to a quantitative empirical analysis using linear regressions.
This analysis contributes to the existing literature in three main ways. First, in addition to the economic impact and other demographic control variables typically covered in tax morale literature, the proposed theoretical framework considers the potential effect of the size and nature of the stimulus packages. Second, the topic of tax morale during recessions is rarely covered in existing literature. As governments around the world seek to increase their revenue after going through recessions caused by climate change, pandemics, war, or poor government policies, understanding levers related to tax morale during a recession is becoming increasingly important. Third, this paper constructs a rich set of data collected from a variety of government sources, in addition to the world value survey (WVS) data, to identify change in GDP, unemployment rate, and foreclosures per state during the tax morale. This data set also includes the amounts and areas of allocation of stimulus packages per US state during the recession in addition to tax policy changes and average welfare spending per state.
The empirical analysis of tax morale across 29 states implies that state level change in unemployment rates, GDP growth and foreclosures do not seem to influence individual tax morale. Furthermore, the total size of stimulus packages in each state does not seem to have a statistically significant association with tax morale, when controlling for the change in the individual states’ tax policies. Direct stimulus, i.e., household transfers, has a small negative effect on tax morale.
This paper fits with the workshop in investigating the role of citizens emotions towards the severity of the financial crisis and how their respective government response to the financial crisis may have shaped public opinion and in turn influenced their tax morale.
Please note that I plan to present this paper in person, if it is accepted.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The National Health Service in the UK was envisaged and promoted by its creator as a moral project for the nation, not merely a healthcare delivery mechanism. Today, it retains an unusual cultural and affective salience, demonstrated in events that recently included a grassroots poster campaign of visible gratitude during the COVID-19 pandemic, and increasingly elaborate ‘birthday’ celebrations marking the NHS’s creation. It also, though, is frequently seen as ‘in crisis’ amidst this atmosphere of loyalty and gratitude. The political limitations of healthcare funding in a tax-based system imposes constant pressure on spending. Especially in periods of austerity, waiting lists grow and healthcare provision often becomes more basic and less person-centred.
This paper explores the way that fundraising appeals within the NHS navigate this, often contradictory, affective terrain. Pre-existing traditions of philanthropy in and around hospitals have endured over the decades of the NHS, and expanded into a substantial, though highly uneven, network of professionalised charitable organisations since the 1980s. The resulting NHS charities are a distinctive category of organisations which display hybrid ‘state’ and ‘charitable’ institutional logics (Stewart & Dodworth, 2023). Within these organisations, entrepreneurial staff have expanded the aims and scope of charitable fundraising, crafting emotional appeals to provide ‘add-ons’ or ‘extras’ not funded through government budgets, and, in some cases, to pay for medical equipment, buildings, and non-medical staff.
This paper draws on ethnographic research on three charitable fundraising appeals in the NHS, including participant observation, interviews with staff, fundraisers and volunteers, and document and web analysis. We explore the emotional repertoires used by charitable entrepreneurs in their efforts to expand fundraising appeals within the NHS, identifying how these have often emphasised the moral value of healthcare, via tropes that include the heroism of the workforce and the vulnerability and virtue of particular patient groups. However, not least due to the governance limitations of NHS charities, these appeals also mute other plausible responses to scarcity and pressure in the NHS; notably anger and activism. We argue that fundraising appeals thus contribute to a cultural intensification of the NHS as a discretionary moral project, more than as a public service, and reflect on the implications of this framing for the future of UK healthcare and health policy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Emotional entrepreneurs— actors whose key goal is to manipulate emotions and emotional bonds, selectively or non-selectively, in the pursuit of their political and policy goals—are one of the fundamental factors behind fluctuations in politics and policy. Current literature still lacks clarity and consistency regarding how emotional entrepreneurs think, decide, and reason. Building on literature from political science and psychology, the paper outlines three missing areas in the study of emotional entrepreneurs, which were selected on the premise that emotional manipulation is an attempt at switching information dynamics away from information sensitivity related to the political candidate or policy being promoted, and toward information insensitivity regarding these objects. Put bluntly, emotional entrepreneurs are successful so long as the target population whose emotions have been manipulated make little or no effort to search and produce accurate information about the candidate or policy being promoted. The three areas include (i) skillful vs. conventional entrepreneurs; (ii) “textbook formula” vs. step-by-step strategic emotional manipulation; and (iii) the relationship between emotions and emotional entrepreneurs’ motivations, intentions, opportunity evaluation, behavior, memory and learning, and the relationship between emotional entrepreneurs and contextual factors. The paper develops a robust research agenda regarding the dynamics in each of these areas and encourages further research of its implications for the efficiency of emotional entrepreneurs in matching the intensity of their emotional manipulation tools to the challenge they face over the short or long run, their effectiveness, and the consequences for democratic politics and democratic resilience.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The research explores the crucial role of emotional intelligence in public administration managers and its impact on public policy-making. Emotional intelligence, defined as the ability to identify, understand, and manage emotions, is vital in the emotionally driven sphere of public policy, particularly in areas eliciting strong moral emotions like social justice, public health, and environmental issues. This study focuses on public administration managers in Poland, examining how their emotional intelligence influences their approach to policy areas that are often at the center of emotional and moral debates.
The relevance of emotional intelligence in public policy is rooted in its capacity to enhance interpersonal relationship management and self-regulation, elements critical in the realm of public administration. The research aims to assess the connection between the emotional intelligence of managers and their work engagement in the public sector, measuring factors such as Inclusion of Managers in Decision-Making; Degree to Which Managers Can Express Their Ideas and Suggestions; Ability of Managers to Define Their Work.
The PKIE questionnaire is employed for emotional intelligence assessment, coupled with engagement surveys to analyze the work engagement in the managerial domain.
Preliminary insights from the study indicate a promising correlation between high emotional intelligence and increased work engagement among managers, suggesting that emotional intelligence is a key predictor of professional success in various fields. This aligns with existing research, highlighting the potential of emotional intelligence in enhancing management practices and shaping public opinion in policy debates.
While awaiting more comprehensive results, the research recognizes the need for further studies with larger sample sizes to validate these findings fully. The study is expected to conclude that fostering emotional intelligence and social competencies in management, especially in the public administrative sector, is essential. This development is anticipated to improve not only individual managerial effectiveness but also overall organizational performance, making a significant contribution to the understanding of emotional intelligence as a critical element in public administrative management. The study's implications extend to various sectors, underscoring the broad applications of emotional intelligence in public policy-making.
Keywords: emotional intelligence, work engagement, managers, public administrative sector.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The paper seeks to make a contribution on better understanding the policy making characteristics of populist governance. The analytical framework of the analysis is provided by the model of populist policy making (developed by the author with his colleagues, see Bartha, A., Boda, Zs. and Szikra, D.: When populist leaders govern. Conceptualising populism in policy making. Politics and Governance, 2020 8 (3), 71-81), and more specifically, the dimension of emotionally loaded policy discourses of the model. Following the model, the paper argues that, first, the high emotionality of policy discourses is a typical feature of populist policy making and, second, that policy making is sometimes used as a means to spur strong political emotions in citizens. The paper suggests that the case when policy making has no instrumental goal in terms of solving or mitigating social problems, on the contrary, it aims at creating new ones, should be considered as a disruptive use of policies. The paper argues that this kind of policy making is present specifically in populist governance and illustrates the point through examining the case of the “child protection law” of Hungary. In 2022 the Hungarian Parliament passed a law on “child protection”. While it stipulates some new measures against paedophilia, the law’s most controversial parts aim at limiting the alleged “LGBTQ+ propaganda” and framing homosexuality as a potential threat to the development of children. Moreover, the law and its implementation use a somewhat vague language leaving stakeholders and authorities wonder what the law really meant. The argument of the paper is that this vagueness and the confusion stirred by the wording of the law and the accompanying political discourses are part of the disruptive policy practice, as they contribute to the normative framing of a new problem and regulating collective emotions related to the problem. In this case the new problem which is sought to be established in the society is the alleged influence of the “LGBTQ+ propaganda” on children, while the emotions linked to this threat are fear, disgust and anger.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Studies of morality policies and issues (such as, abortion, drug and alcohol consumption, stem cell research or gambling) framing are rather popular in media and political communication studies (see, for example, some recent studies Studlar, Burns, 2015; Mucciaroni, Ferraiolo, Rubado, 2019). However, morality and moral considerations underlie various political attitudes, values, identities and debates, more generally (Clifford, Jerit, 2013). Therefore, morality framing is among the most important frames in political and media discourse (Boydstun, Glazier, Pietryka, 2013; Card et al., 2015). Moreover, policies and policy issues become “moralized” and “demoralized” over time (Kreitzer, Kane, Mooney, 2019) and there are certain actors that are more inclined to “moralize” policy issues that others (Kreitzer, Kane, Mooney, 2019). Still, there are little studies that analyze morality framing of policy issues from temporal and comparative perspective.
In this paper we aim to investigate how morality framing was used by Lithuanian politicians in legislative debates. First, we develop a dictionary-based content analytic approach (Young, Soroka, 2012; Hart, 2020; Wahlström, Törnberg, Ekbrand, 2021) for identifying morality frames within Lithuanian political discourse using manually coded texts retrieved from the political campaign debates and parliamentary floor debates. Then, we apply it to the legislative debates of the Lithuanian parliament (the Seimas) starting from 1992 and spanning to 2022. We investigate three major aspects of morality framing: 1) which political actors (governmental vs. opposition, populist vs. mainstream parties) use the morality frame more frequently, 2) which policy issues (just “morality policies” or other issues, too) are framed more frequently with the morality frame, and 3) how (if) morality framing changes over time (whether there are issues that are always framed with the morality frame when they get on the agenda of the Parliament (like “morality policies”), or the use of the morality frame fluctuates over time).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In numerous countries, particularly in the Global South, violence perpetrated by criminal groups consistently shapes the social and political landscape (Magaloni et al. 2020). In Europe, nearly 20% of the population recognizes organized crime as the primary global concern for the continent's future (Eurobarometer 2021). Meanwhile, in Latin America, approximately 26 million individuals are impacted by organized crime groups (Lessing et al. 2019). Violence serves as a crucial tool for these groups to uphold the status quo by instilling fear and intimidation in both civil society and authorities (Moya 2018; Moya and Carter 2019). Through the strategic use of violence, criminal organizations establish dominance, deter resistance, and silence opposition. This atmosphere of fear ensures compliance within local communities, impedes witness cooperation with law enforcement, and undermines the effectiveness of legal institutions and policy changes aimed at curbing criminal activities. The impact of organized crime activities, marked by violent shocks, has been observed to influence distinctive traits within communities. This includes how individuals react to the fear and insecurity that inevitably ensue when organized crime groups establish themselves in the area (Justino 2012; Moya 2018;Rolla & Justino 2022). Additionally, it affects the inclination of individuals and families to invest in social capital, particularly directed towards individuals beyond their immediate group (Aghajanian et al. 2020; Rolla & Justino 2022).
By leveraging violence, criminal groups dramatically affect also policy response, by weaponizing negative emotions within the community, such as fear and insecurity, leading to people’s frustration, thereby making policy change less attractive to both stakeholders and citizens (Moya and Carter 2019). However, emotions triggered by violent events are still processed through cognitive mechanisms that might explain people’s acquiescence toward this status quo (Bandura et al. 1996; Sholtz 2008). Schedler (2016), for instance, found that framing criminal violence as a self-contained war among criminals ("bounded violence") can erode the attitudinal foundation of citizen solidarity and sympathy with the same victims, especially if they are wrongly perceived as colluded.
Utilizing a novel dataset encompassing assassination attempts on elected officials perpetrated by mafia groups at local and national levels between 1980 and 2010 in Italy, the study exploits the inherent unpredictability in the success or failure of such attempts to discern the repercussions of criminal violence on people’s support for antimafia policies and institutions. The analysis permits an assessment of the extent to which emotions triggered by political assassinations perpetrated by criminal groups are contingent on the framing of the targets, as colluded or not with mafias. This expands on studies that have already addressed the impact of moral emotions on policymaking, particularly Zahariadis (2015), by assessing under which conditions events triggering fear among the public lead to either policy continuity or change.
This research highlights criminal groups' role as contemporary catalysts for institutional change, contributes to the understanding of cognitive mechanisms that process people’s emotions, and underscores how seemingly minor, random events can significantly impact trajectories of policymaking and policy implementation.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Intellectual humility can be described as the recognition of one’s own limitations, openness to new ideas, a tendency to low defensiveness, and recognizing the merits of others and their ideas (Porter et al, 2022). Research supports that idea that humility involves emotional features; an individual’s sense of intellectual humility informs their reaction when confronted with information that is contrary to their beliefs. Social scientists and pundits lament the absence of intellectual humility among elected policymakers. Yet others find new entrants to policymaking spaces bring with them policy deliberative processes informed by intellectual humility that helps center and move to the top of the agenda key policy priorities (Martinez, 2023, 2022a, 2022b). The literature clearly suggests that policy deliberation is directly affected by the participants’ willingness to keep an open mind (Barabas, 2004). Barabas also argues that diversity of messages “increases knowledge and altered opinions” (p. 687). What is key is that diversity of ideas and keeping an open mind are “hallmarks of democratic dialogue, [which] can help citizens transform potentially unreflective preferences into enlightened deliberative judgments” (p. 699).
The heterogeneous landscape of policy-making spaces is currently undergoing a re-construction. Governments around the world are experiencing a more diverse composition of their official bodies. In 2019 Nevada became the first female-majority legislature in the United States. As the composition of these legislative bodies changes to become more inclusive and representative of its constituents, so do the experiences that officials bring to the table. These new individuals bring different interpretations and emotional responses from those studied before. Furthermore, they bring new meanings and meaning-making around the use of emotions, humility, and purpose to the policy-making process.
Researchers of policy analysis have argued that many analysts operate as if knowledge was generated in a vacuum, ignoring the subjectivity of their own experiences and the emotional landscape of these experiences. By turning a focus on a legislative community and their emotional responses, I examine how meaning is systemically accepted or rejected within policy-making. The goal of this paper is to understand the role of emotions by examining how a female-majority legislative community embodied, through their discursive practices, an intellectually humble frame to policy making. Despite having a majority, power dynamics in legislative practices do not suddenly shift. The way in which legislators communicate is a key entry point to understanding the power dynamics, the use of emotions to legitimize or delegitimatize policy knowledge.
In analyzing how a female-majority legislature in Nevada operated, I posit that this community of legislators employed inclusive and positive emotion practices that emphasized the importance of a subjective experience, individual and community, throughout the policy-process. I argue that these important practices can be traced to intellectual humility in policymaking. In this paper, I present how the constructs of intellectual humility provide a comprehensive approach to the study of policy process. I propose five aspects: reflexivity, other directed, epistemic communities, micro and macro structures, and situational. I introduce a novel pragmatist approach strengthened by the literature of intellectual humility.
Barabas, J. (2004). How deliberation affects policy opinions. American political science review, 98(4), 687-701.
Martinez, M. (2023). Keeping the higher education “promise” in Nevada: Latina/o legislators policy ways of knowing. Journal of Hispanic Higher Education, 22(1), 94-107.
Martinez, M. (2022a). US Black women state legislators: intersectional identities and education policies. Race Ethnicity and Education, 1-19.
Martínez, M. (2022b). " The Future is Latina": Feminist Borderlands and Latina Legislators. Frontiers: A Journal of Women Studies, 43(2), 1-27.
Porter, T., Baldwin, C. R., Warren, M. T., Murray, E. D., Cotton Bronk, K., Forgeard, M. J., ... & Jayawickreme, E. (2022). Clarifying the content of intellectual humility: A systematic review and integrative framework. Journal of personality assessment, 104(5), 573-585.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Ukrainian crisis of 2022, resulting in one of the largest migration crises in Europe’s recent history, placed Poland in an unprecedented situation. As a neighboring country, Poland became a haven for over 2.5 million Ukrainian refugees in the early months of the conflict. This paper aims to analyze the emotional journey of the Polish public and the government’s response, from initial acts of massive aid to growing resentment and hostility. The paper examines the transformation of public sentiment in Poland towards Ukrainian refugees, from initial widespread support to increasing hostility. It explores the unique challenges posed by the sudden influx of over 2.5 million refugees in the wake of the Russian aggression against Ukraine in 2022 and the subsequent emotional and policy responses in Poland.
We conducted qualitative study based on interviews with Polish citizens, Ukrainians refugees, NGO representatives, and public officials. It analyzes the emotional responses to the refugee crisis, focusing on the evolution from initial empathy and enthusiasm to subsequent feelings of competition and hostility.
The research initially highlights the remarkable solidarity and compassion shown by Poles, who provided extensive support to refugees despite the absence of prior experience in handling such a crisis. It then delves into the emotional shift as the public began perceiving refugees as competitors for jobs, healthcare, and educational resources. This section discusses how these perceptions fed into a growing sense of hostility and the implications for public policy and social cohesion.
The study highlights the complex role of emotions in public policy, especially in the context of an unprecedented humanitarian crisis. It underscores the need for adaptive policy responses that consider the emotional dynamics of societies facing sudden demographic changes.
Our research provides an empirical examination of the role of emotions in public policy during a major humanitarian crisis. It offers insights into the emotional evolution of a society in response to a large-scale refugee influx, contributing to the understanding of how moral emotions influence policy support, formulation, and implementation in extraordinary circumstances.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The emotional turn is prominent among the many turns which characterize policy research. A strong body of interdisciplinary research has put center-stage the homo emotionalis. Although research on emotions has spread to many different policy domains, such as migration, climate change, and civil rights, we still miss a systematic account of the literature exploring the emotions/policy nexus. Our review starts from 1300 items/scholarly contributions, then reduced to 300 after filtering for relevance. The key criterion for the retention of the entries is the presence of a clear link between emotions (also positive and negative emotions broadly construed) and policy. We analyze contributions which investigate: how emotions influence policy preferences and behavior; what specific emotions are mobilized in narratives and policy discourse; and the presence of emotions in policies that connect citizens and the bureaucracy, like filling forms and ‘red tape’. We also discuss the research methods, such as experiments and big data, in the corpus of 300 entries. Overall, this body of literature highlights noticeable theoretical and methodological eclecticism and alertness to technological innovation in data generation and analysis. Research for this paper is supported by the MORES project funded by the Horizon program.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
There is increasing recognition that policy design and practice need to consider the role of emotions. However, the way emotions are expressed, understood, and valued continues to be dominated by rationalistic perspectives on policy, human behaviour and technology. The English social housing sector exemplifies this paradox. It is amidst regulatory reform emphasising empowering tenants through tools such national league tables and complaints processes. Within the sector, there is interest in emotionally informed fields such as trauma-informed design informing practice. While commendable, more research is needed to explore emotionally informed concepts in social housing policy and practice.
This study investigates well-being conceptions by asking 'how can social landlords connect with tenants' understanding of home-based well-being?'. The paper employs an interdisciplinary framework weaving together insights from behavioural public policy and relational perspectives rooted in geographical studies of the home. The interdisciplinary framework has two aims: to disrupt landlords’ conceptualisation of well-being as a social value that can be produced through bureaucratic processes and rational assumptions of human behaviour. Second, to explore how the framework can elucidate the nuanced ways in which tenants experience their homes, particularly with respect to emotional complexities, and how this may introduce an emotional accent to policy and practice around home-based well-being. The study includes 42 interviews and two focus groups with practitioners, consultants, and tenants. Additionally, the research draws on the author's autoethnographic reflections from her role as a consultant to the social housing sector.
The paper argues that an interdisciplinary framework, informed by rational and emotional insights, can produce a shared subjectivity between tenants and landlords that can underpin dialogue to reimagine home-based well-being. This contributes to the emotions in policy literature by exploring how emotional knowledge can shape the ‘doings’ of practice. This draws attention to the first workshop question: how do technocratic discourses that mute emotions affect policy design? The interdisciplinary framework has its roots in the scrutiny of behavioural public policy, a domain subject to significant critique for its inherent technocratic tendencies. I argue that there are compatibilities with some behavioural insights into the experience of poverty and relational perspectives grounded in an appreciation of the emotional complexity inherent in the concept and experiences of home. Drawing out the compatibilities between the technocratic and the emotional provides a new way of thinking about housing well-being and produces a foundational shared subjectivity for the redesign of services. Thus, this paper contributes to explorations of how emotions can contribute to reshaping policy and practice in housing while remaining sensitive to the cultural dominance of technocracy and the risks of pathologising tenants through practitioner preference to utilise insights to effect normative change rather than understand tenants' circumstances and collectively explore what an emotionally informed conception of well-being may look like in social housing.
I aim to deliver on-site. I am an early career researcher and am undertaking a second emotionally informed piece of research concerning how tenants and landlords encounter each other in the space of the tenants' home.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
As many countries struggle to increase their revenue and balance their fiscal budgets, increasing tax revenues and reducing tax evasion continue to be an important opportunity for most governments. This is especially key when countries face recessions and accompanied fiscal deficits. Hence the importance of understanding potential unique factors associated with change in tax morale, as a lever to increasing tax compliance.
The research question of this paper is to assess if the unique factors of a recession in terms of severity of economic impact and the governments' related policy response to the recession influences citizens’ tax morale. Tax morale refers to citizens’ attitude towards paying taxes, which earlier research showed to be a useful proxy for tax compliance.
To answers this research question, a rich secondary data set was constructed across 29 states from various US government sources and the World Value Survey in the period around the great recession (i.e., 2006-2011), as input to a quantitative empirical analysis using linear regressions.
This analysis contributes to the existing literature in three main ways. First, in addition to the economic impact and other demographic control variables typically covered in tax morale literature, the proposed theoretical framework considers the potential effect of the size and nature of the stimulus packages. Second, the topic of tax morale during recessions is rarely covered in existing literature. As governments around the world seek to increase their revenue after going through recessions caused by climate change, pandemics, war, or poor government policies, understanding levers related to tax morale during a recession is becoming increasingly important. Third, this paper constructs a rich set of data collected from a variety of government sources, in addition to the world value survey (WVS) data, to identify change in GDP, unemployment rate, and foreclosures per state during the tax morale. This data set also includes the amounts and areas of allocation of stimulus packages per US state during the recession in addition to tax policy changes and average welfare spending per state.
The empirical analysis of tax morale across 29 states implies that state level change in unemployment rates, GDP growth and foreclosures do not seem to influence individual tax morale. Furthermore, the total size of stimulus packages in each state does not seem to have a statistically significant association with tax morale, when controlling for the change in the individual states’ tax policies. Direct stimulus, i.e., household transfers, has a small negative effect on tax morale.
This paper fits with the workshop in investigating the role of citizens emotions towards the severity of the financial crisis and how their respective government response to the financial crisis may have shaped public opinion and in turn influenced their tax morale.
Please note that I plan to present this paper in person, if it is accepted.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The National Health Service in the UK was envisaged and promoted by its creator as a moral project for the nation, not merely a healthcare delivery mechanism. Today, it retains an unusual cultural and affective salience, demonstrated in events that recently included a grassroots poster campaign of visible gratitude during the COVID-19 pandemic, and increasingly elaborate ‘birthday’ celebrations marking the NHS’s creation. It also, though, is frequently seen as ‘in crisis’ amidst this atmosphere of loyalty and gratitude. The political limitations of healthcare funding in a tax-based system imposes constant pressure on spending. Especially in periods of austerity, waiting lists grow and healthcare provision often becomes more basic and less person-centred.
This paper explores the way that fundraising appeals within the NHS navigate this, often contradictory, affective terrain. Pre-existing traditions of philanthropy in and around hospitals have endured over the decades of the NHS, and expanded into a substantial, though highly uneven, network of professionalised charitable organisations since the 1980s. The resulting NHS charities are a distinctive category of organisations which display hybrid ‘state’ and ‘charitable’ institutional logics (Stewart & Dodworth, 2023). Within these organisations, entrepreneurial staff have expanded the aims and scope of charitable fundraising, crafting emotional appeals to provide ‘add-ons’ or ‘extras’ not funded through government budgets, and, in some cases, to pay for medical equipment, buildings, and non-medical staff.
This paper draws on ethnographic research on three charitable fundraising appeals in the NHS, including participant observation, interviews with staff, fundraisers and volunteers, and document and web analysis. We explore the emotional repertoires used by charitable entrepreneurs in their efforts to expand fundraising appeals within the NHS, identifying how these have often emphasised the moral value of healthcare, via tropes that include the heroism of the workforce and the vulnerability and virtue of particular patient groups. However, not least due to the governance limitations of NHS charities, these appeals also mute other plausible responses to scarcity and pressure in the NHS; notably anger and activism. We argue that fundraising appeals thus contribute to a cultural intensification of the NHS as a discretionary moral project, more than as a public service, and reflect on the implications of this framing for the future of UK healthcare and health policy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Emotional entrepreneurs— actors whose key goal is to manipulate emotions and emotional bonds, selectively or non-selectively, in the pursuit of their political and policy goals—are one of the fundamental factors behind fluctuations in politics and policy. Current literature still lacks clarity and consistency regarding how emotional entrepreneurs think, decide, and reason. Building on literature from political science and psychology, the paper outlines three missing areas in the study of emotional entrepreneurs, which were selected on the premise that emotional manipulation is an attempt at switching information dynamics away from information sensitivity related to the political candidate or policy being promoted, and toward information insensitivity regarding these objects. Put bluntly, emotional entrepreneurs are successful so long as the target population whose emotions have been manipulated make little or no effort to search and produce accurate information about the candidate or policy being promoted. The three areas include (i) skillful vs. conventional entrepreneurs; (ii) “textbook formula” vs. step-by-step strategic emotional manipulation; and (iii) the relationship between emotions and emotional entrepreneurs’ motivations, intentions, opportunity evaluation, behavior, memory and learning, and the relationship between emotional entrepreneurs and contextual factors. The paper develops a robust research agenda regarding the dynamics in each of these areas and encourages further research of its implications for the efficiency of emotional entrepreneurs in matching the intensity of their emotional manipulation tools to the challenge they face over the short or long run, their effectiveness, and the consequences for democratic politics and democratic resilience.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The research explores the crucial role of emotional intelligence in public administration managers and its impact on public policy-making. Emotional intelligence, defined as the ability to identify, understand, and manage emotions, is vital in the emotionally driven sphere of public policy, particularly in areas eliciting strong moral emotions like social justice, public health, and environmental issues. This study focuses on public administration managers in Poland, examining how their emotional intelligence influences their approach to policy areas that are often at the center of emotional and moral debates.
The relevance of emotional intelligence in public policy is rooted in its capacity to enhance interpersonal relationship management and self-regulation, elements critical in the realm of public administration. The research aims to assess the connection between the emotional intelligence of managers and their work engagement in the public sector, measuring factors such as Inclusion of Managers in Decision-Making; Degree to Which Managers Can Express Their Ideas and Suggestions; Ability of Managers to Define Their Work.
The PKIE questionnaire is employed for emotional intelligence assessment, coupled with engagement surveys to analyze the work engagement in the managerial domain.
Preliminary insights from the study indicate a promising correlation between high emotional intelligence and increased work engagement among managers, suggesting that emotional intelligence is a key predictor of professional success in various fields. This aligns with existing research, highlighting the potential of emotional intelligence in enhancing management practices and shaping public opinion in policy debates.
While awaiting more comprehensive results, the research recognizes the need for further studies with larger sample sizes to validate these findings fully. The study is expected to conclude that fostering emotional intelligence and social competencies in management, especially in the public administrative sector, is essential. This development is anticipated to improve not only individual managerial effectiveness but also overall organizational performance, making a significant contribution to the understanding of emotional intelligence as a critical element in public administrative management. The study's implications extend to various sectors, underscoring the broad applications of emotional intelligence in public policy-making.
Keywords: emotional intelligence, work engagement, managers, public administrative sector.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The paper seeks to make a contribution on better understanding the policy making characteristics of populist governance. The analytical framework of the analysis is provided by the model of populist policy making (developed by the author with his colleagues, see Bartha, A., Boda, Zs. and Szikra, D.: When populist leaders govern. Conceptualising populism in policy making. Politics and Governance, 2020 8 (3), 71-81), and more specifically, the dimension of emotionally loaded policy discourses of the model. Following the model, the paper argues that, first, the high emotionality of policy discourses is a typical feature of populist policy making and, second, that policy making is sometimes used as a means to spur strong political emotions in citizens. The paper suggests that the case when policy making has no instrumental goal in terms of solving or mitigating social problems, on the contrary, it aims at creating new ones, should be considered as a disruptive use of policies. The paper argues that this kind of policy making is present specifically in populist governance and illustrates the point through examining the case of the “child protection law” of Hungary. In 2022 the Hungarian Parliament passed a law on “child protection”. While it stipulates some new measures against paedophilia, the law’s most controversial parts aim at limiting the alleged “LGBTQ+ propaganda” and framing homosexuality as a potential threat to the development of children. Moreover, the law and its implementation use a somewhat vague language leaving stakeholders and authorities wonder what the law really meant. The argument of the paper is that this vagueness and the confusion stirred by the wording of the law and the accompanying political discourses are part of the disruptive policy practice, as they contribute to the normative framing of a new problem and regulating collective emotions related to the problem. In this case the new problem which is sought to be established in the society is the alleged influence of the “LGBTQ+ propaganda” on children, while the emotions linked to this threat are fear, disgust and anger.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Studies of morality policies and issues (such as, abortion, drug and alcohol consumption, stem cell research or gambling) framing are rather popular in media and political communication studies (see, for example, some recent studies Studlar, Burns, 2015; Mucciaroni, Ferraiolo, Rubado, 2019). However, morality and moral considerations underlie various political attitudes, values, identities and debates, more generally (Clifford, Jerit, 2013). Therefore, morality framing is among the most important frames in political and media discourse (Boydstun, Glazier, Pietryka, 2013; Card et al., 2015). Moreover, policies and policy issues become “moralized” and “demoralized” over time (Kreitzer, Kane, Mooney, 2019) and there are certain actors that are more inclined to “moralize” policy issues that others (Kreitzer, Kane, Mooney, 2019). Still, there are little studies that analyze morality framing of policy issues from temporal and comparative perspective.
In this paper we aim to investigate how morality framing was used by Lithuanian politicians in legislative debates. First, we develop a dictionary-based content analytic approach (Young, Soroka, 2012; Hart, 2020; Wahlström, Törnberg, Ekbrand, 2021) for identifying morality frames within Lithuanian political discourse using manually coded texts retrieved from the political campaign debates and parliamentary floor debates. Then, we apply it to the legislative debates of the Lithuanian parliament (the Seimas) starting from 1992 and spanning to 2022. We investigate three major aspects of morality framing: 1) which political actors (governmental vs. opposition, populist vs. mainstream parties) use the morality frame more frequently, 2) which policy issues (just “morality policies” or other issues, too) are framed more frequently with the morality frame, and 3) how (if) morality framing changes over time (whether there are issues that are always framed with the morality frame when they get on the agenda of the Parliament (like “morality policies”), or the use of the morality frame fluctuates over time).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In numerous countries, particularly in the Global South, violence perpetrated by criminal groups consistently shapes the social and political landscape (Magaloni et al. 2020). In Europe, nearly 20% of the population recognizes organized crime as the primary global concern for the continent's future (Eurobarometer 2021). Meanwhile, in Latin America, approximately 26 million individuals are impacted by organized crime groups (Lessing et al. 2019). Violence serves as a crucial tool for these groups to uphold the status quo by instilling fear and intimidation in both civil society and authorities (Moya 2018; Moya and Carter 2019). Through the strategic use of violence, criminal organizations establish dominance, deter resistance, and silence opposition. This atmosphere of fear ensures compliance within local communities, impedes witness cooperation with law enforcement, and undermines the effectiveness of legal institutions and policy changes aimed at curbing criminal activities. The impact of organized crime activities, marked by violent shocks, has been observed to influence distinctive traits within communities. This includes how individuals react to the fear and insecurity that inevitably ensue when organized crime groups establish themselves in the area (Justino 2012; Moya 2018;Rolla & Justino 2022). Additionally, it affects the inclination of individuals and families to invest in social capital, particularly directed towards individuals beyond their immediate group (Aghajanian et al. 2020; Rolla & Justino 2022).
By leveraging violence, criminal groups dramatically affect also policy response, by weaponizing negative emotions within the community, such as fear and insecurity, leading to people’s frustration, thereby making policy change less attractive to both stakeholders and citizens (Moya and Carter 2019). However, emotions triggered by violent events are still processed through cognitive mechanisms that might explain people’s acquiescence toward this status quo (Bandura et al. 1996; Sholtz 2008). Schedler (2016), for instance, found that framing criminal violence as a self-contained war among criminals ("bounded violence") can erode the attitudinal foundation of citizen solidarity and sympathy with the same victims, especially if they are wrongly perceived as colluded.
Utilizing a novel dataset encompassing assassination attempts on elected officials perpetrated by mafia groups at local and national levels between 1980 and 2010 in Italy, the study exploits the inherent unpredictability in the success or failure of such attempts to discern the repercussions of criminal violence on people’s support for antimafia policies and institutions. The analysis permits an assessment of the extent to which emotions triggered by political assassinations perpetrated by criminal groups are contingent on the framing of the targets, as colluded or not with mafias. This expands on studies that have already addressed the impact of moral emotions on policymaking, particularly Zahariadis (2015), by assessing under which conditions events triggering fear among the public lead to either policy continuity or change.
This research highlights criminal groups' role as contemporary catalysts for institutional change, contributes to the understanding of cognitive mechanisms that process people’s emotions, and underscores how seemingly minor, random events can significantly impact trajectories of policymaking and policy implementation.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Intellectual humility can be described as the recognition of one’s own limitations, openness to new ideas, a tendency to low defensiveness, and recognizing the merits of others and their ideas (Porter et al, 2022). Research supports that idea that humility involves emotional features; an individual’s sense of intellectual humility informs their reaction when confronted with information that is contrary to their beliefs. Social scientists and pundits lament the absence of intellectual humility among elected policymakers. Yet others find new entrants to policymaking spaces bring with them policy deliberative processes informed by intellectual humility that helps center and move to the top of the agenda key policy priorities (Martinez, 2023, 2022a, 2022b). The literature clearly suggests that policy deliberation is directly affected by the participants’ willingness to keep an open mind (Barabas, 2004). Barabas also argues that diversity of messages “increases knowledge and altered opinions” (p. 687). What is key is that diversity of ideas and keeping an open mind are “hallmarks of democratic dialogue, [which] can help citizens transform potentially unreflective preferences into enlightened deliberative judgments” (p. 699).
The heterogeneous landscape of policy-making spaces is currently undergoing a re-construction. Governments around the world are experiencing a more diverse composition of their official bodies. In 2019 Nevada became the first female-majority legislature in the United States. As the composition of these legislative bodies changes to become more inclusive and representative of its constituents, so do the experiences that officials bring to the table. These new individuals bring different interpretations and emotional responses from those studied before. Furthermore, they bring new meanings and meaning-making around the use of emotions, humility, and purpose to the policy-making process.
Researchers of policy analysis have argued that many analysts operate as if knowledge was generated in a vacuum, ignoring the subjectivity of their own experiences and the emotional landscape of these experiences. By turning a focus on a legislative community and their emotional responses, I examine how meaning is systemically accepted or rejected within policy-making. The goal of this paper is to understand the role of emotions by examining how a female-majority legislative community embodied, through their discursive practices, an intellectually humble frame to policy making. Despite having a majority, power dynamics in legislative practices do not suddenly shift. The way in which legislators communicate is a key entry point to understanding the power dynamics, the use of emotions to legitimize or delegitimatize policy knowledge.
In analyzing how a female-majority legislature in Nevada operated, I posit that this community of legislators employed inclusive and positive emotion practices that emphasized the importance of a subjective experience, individual and community, throughout the policy-process. I argue that these important practices can be traced to intellectual humility in policymaking. In this paper, I present how the constructs of intellectual humility provide a comprehensive approach to the study of policy process. I propose five aspects: reflexivity, other directed, epistemic communities, micro and macro structures, and situational. I introduce a novel pragmatist approach strengthened by the literature of intellectual humility.
Barabas, J. (2004). How deliberation affects policy opinions. American political science review, 98(4), 687-701.
Martinez, M. (2023). Keeping the higher education “promise” in Nevada: Latina/o legislators policy ways of knowing. Journal of Hispanic Higher Education, 22(1), 94-107.
Martinez, M. (2022a). US Black women state legislators: intersectional identities and education policies. Race Ethnicity and Education, 1-19.
Martínez, M. (2022b). " The Future is Latina": Feminist Borderlands and Latina Legislators. Frontiers: A Journal of Women Studies, 43(2), 1-27.
Porter, T., Baldwin, C. R., Warren, M. T., Murray, E. D., Cotton Bronk, K., Forgeard, M. J., ... & Jayawickreme, E. (2022). Clarifying the content of intellectual humility: A systematic review and integrative framework. Journal of personality assessment, 104(5), 573-585.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Ukrainian crisis of 2022, resulting in one of the largest migration crises in Europe’s recent history, placed Poland in an unprecedented situation. As a neighboring country, Poland became a haven for over 2.5 million Ukrainian refugees in the early months of the conflict. This paper aims to analyze the emotional journey of the Polish public and the government’s response, from initial acts of massive aid to growing resentment and hostility. The paper examines the transformation of public sentiment in Poland towards Ukrainian refugees, from initial widespread support to increasing hostility. It explores the unique challenges posed by the sudden influx of over 2.5 million refugees in the wake of the Russian aggression against Ukraine in 2022 and the subsequent emotional and policy responses in Poland.
We conducted qualitative study based on interviews with Polish citizens, Ukrainians refugees, NGO representatives, and public officials. It analyzes the emotional responses to the refugee crisis, focusing on the evolution from initial empathy and enthusiasm to subsequent feelings of competition and hostility.
The research initially highlights the remarkable solidarity and compassion shown by Poles, who provided extensive support to refugees despite the absence of prior experience in handling such a crisis. It then delves into the emotional shift as the public began perceiving refugees as competitors for jobs, healthcare, and educational resources. This section discusses how these perceptions fed into a growing sense of hostility and the implications for public policy and social cohesion.
The study highlights the complex role of emotions in public policy, especially in the context of an unprecedented humanitarian crisis. It underscores the need for adaptive policy responses that consider the emotional dynamics of societies facing sudden demographic changes.
Our research provides an empirical examination of the role of emotions in public policy during a major humanitarian crisis. It offers insights into the emotional evolution of a society in response to a large-scale refugee influx, contributing to the understanding of how moral emotions influence policy support, formulation, and implementation in extraordinary circumstances.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The emotional turn is prominent among the many turns which characterize policy research. A strong body of interdisciplinary research has put center-stage the homo emotionalis. Although research on emotions has spread to many different policy domains, such as migration, climate change, and civil rights, we still miss a systematic account of the literature exploring the emotions/policy nexus. Our review starts from 1300 items/scholarly contributions, then reduced to 300 after filtering for relevance. The key criterion for the retention of the entries is the presence of a clear link between emotions (also positive and negative emotions broadly construed) and policy. We analyze contributions which investigate: how emotions influence policy preferences and behavior; what specific emotions are mobilized in narratives and policy discourse; and the presence of emotions in policies that connect citizens and the bureaucracy, like filling forms and ‘red tape’. We also discuss the research methods, such as experiments and big data, in the corpus of 300 entries. Overall, this body of literature highlights noticeable theoretical and methodological eclecticism and alertness to technological innovation in data generation and analysis. Research for this paper is supported by the MORES project funded by the Horizon program.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)