CATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
To address the challenges imposed by social, economic, environmental, and technological dynamics, innovations, particularly those related to digital transformation, have become a strategic cornerstone in processes, services, and policies within the public sector over the past two decades. Consequently, the concept of digital government has permeated various spheres and government sectors, affirming the perception that this trend is no longer just a novelty but has indeed become the new normal in public management.
Digital transformation refers to the process of enhancing organizational performance through the utilization of information and communication technology resources[1]. This concept integrates the application of technology into conventional problem-solving strategies, which is now prevalent in numerous domains such as government, finance, labor market, education, medicine, the arts, science, global communication, and more. Its primary goal is to contribute value in terms of transparency, accountability, efficiency, effectiveness, customer experience, and service delivery for both businesses and public organizations.
In the realm of the public sector, digital transformation, often referred to as digital government or Govtech, encompasses a wide array of innovations that have been embraced and implemented over the past few decades, marking a significant shift from analog to digital government practices (OECD, 2020). This transformative process not only introduced a digital mindset into policy design but also led to a redefinition of the government's structure, functions and its interaction with citizens in policymaking.
The transition to digital government comprises a series of strategies aimed at modernizing government operations to yield benefits for society. As highlighted by the OECD (2014), this transformation is pivotal as it: “emphasizes the crucial contribution of technology as a strategic driver to create open, innovative, participatory and trustworthy public sectors, to improve social inclusiveness and government accountability, and to bring together government and non-government actors to contribute to national development and long-term sustainable growth.”
The adoption of digital technologies as a framework for the public sector has become a global phenomenon, extending to both developed and emerging countries, including a vast range of digital innovations based on a complex legal framework and guided by principles of networking. In brief, it is evident that digital transformation is a process that empowers governments to harness technology's potential to reinforce fiscal transparency and accountability, boost the effectiveness of public expenditure, and enhance outcomes in education, healthcare service delivery, and social welfare. This represents a foundational shift in how governments function, utilizing technology to streamline operations, facilitate decision-making, manage data, engage with society, and provide better citizens’ experience. This transformation is achieved through the development of modern digital platforms and the adoption of innovative technologies, including machine learning, artificial intelligence (AI), blockchain, the internet of things (IoT), and others.
Indeed, despite the well-known benefits, not everything is rosy. Digital transformation has ushered in a host of intricate challenges, risks, and setbacks for governments, society, and businesses alike. The roster of cyber-related crimes and issues is extensive and continually expanding, encompassing:
1. National security risks;
2. Dilemmas concerning political participation;
3. Challenges related to money laundering and tax evasion policies;
4. Safeguarding of private data and privacy
5. The potential emergence of digital dictatorships.
Furthermore, two other issues pose substantial threats to the government's ability to deliver public services effectively, transparently, and equitably: digital divide or exclusion and algorithmic discrimination. The digital divide represents a phenomenon that entails disparities in access, utilization, and outcomes related to information and communications technology among various population groups[2]. This can lead to their disproportionate participation in public processes and exclusion from the majority of Govtech service benefits. On the other hand, algorithmic discrimination or bias refers to systematic and repeatable errors in a computer system that produce unfair outcomes, such as favoring one category over another in ways that deviate from the algorithm's intended purpose. This bias can have wide-ranging consequences, ranging from unintentional breaches of privacy to the reinforcement of social biases related to race, gender, sexuality, age, and ethnicity. Discriminatory algorithms are found in both the public and private sectors, predominantly within the realm of artificial intelligence and machine learning, in which decisions rely on a dataset of inputs and other learning and decision-making techniques. Consequently, this issue has raised significant concerns regarding the fairness, justice, and transparency of criteria and automated decision-making, as well as the dehumanization of services. These concerns have led to negative impacts on the quality-of-service provision and the promotion of diversity.
Hence, digital transformation is undeniably a positive and largely irreversible paradigm. Nevertheless, it is equally evident that the outcomes of these innovations, particularly concerning the digital divide and the indiscriminate deployment of algorithms, are not always foreseeable and can have adverse effects on the effectiveness of processes and services, the safeguarding of citizens' rights, and the levels of public trust in government.
In this context, this workshop focuses on exploring the trends and challenges of policy innovation in the Digital Era observed worldwide. The workshop welcomes papers with various approaches - theoretical, methodological, and empirical - that: i) analyze initiatives leveraging digital transformation to enhance public sector performance; ii) Present case studies highlighting setbacks or risks associated with digital innovation in the public policy; iii) examine how governments worldwide are designing transparency and accountability instruments to adapt to the impacts of digital transformation. These efforts should align with ethical and integrity standards, as well as the participatory and inclusive principles valued by society.
CALL FOR PAPERS
To address the challenges imposed by social, economic, environmental, and technological dynamics, innovations, particularly those related to digital transformation, have become a strategic cornerstone in processes, services, and policies within the public sector over the past two decades. Consequently, the concept of digital government has permeated various spheres and government sectors, affirming the perception that this trend is no longer just a novelty but has indeed become the new normal in public management.
The adoption of digital technologies as a framework for the public sector has become a global phenomenon, extending to both developed and emerging countries, including a vast range of digital innovations based on a complex legal framework and guided by principles of networking. In brief, it is evident that digital transformation is a process that empowers governments to harness technology's potential to reinforce fiscal transparency and accountability, boost the effectiveness of public expenditure, and enhance outcomes in education, healthcare service delivery, and social welfare. This represents a foundational shift in how governments function, utilizing technology to streamline operations, facilitate decision-making, manage data, engage with society, and provide better citizens’ experience. This transformation is achieved through the development of modern digital platforms and the adoption of innovative technologies, including machine learning, artificial intelligence (AI), blockchain, the internet of things (IoT), and others.
Indeed, despite the well-known benefits, not everything is rosy. Digital transformation has ushered in a host of intricate challenges, risks, and setbacks for governments, society, and businesses alike. The roster of cyber-related crimes and issues is extensive and continually expanding. Moreover, two issues pose substantial threats to the government's ability to deliver public services effectively, transparently, and equitably: digital divide or exclusion and algorithmic discrimination.
Hence, digital transformation is undeniably a positive and largely irreversible paradigm. Nevertheless, it is equally evident that the outcomes of these innovations, particularly concerning the digital divide and the indiscriminate deployment of algorithms, are not always foreseeable and can have adverse effects on the effectiveness of processes and services, the safeguarding of citizens' rights, and the levels of public trust in government.
In this context, this workshop focuses on exploring the trends and challenges of policy innovation in the Digital Era observed worldwide. The workshop welcomes papers with various approaches - theoretical, methodological, and empirical - that: i) analyze initiatives leveraging digital transformation to enhance public sector performance; ii) Present case studies highlighting setbacks or risks associated with digital innovation in the public policy; iii) examine how governments worldwide are designing transparency and accountability instruments to adapt to the impacts of digital transformation. These efforts should align with ethical and integrity standards, as well as the participatory and inclusive principles valued by society.
ABSTRACT
The adoption of digital technologies as a guideline for the public sector has become a global phenomenon, extending to both developed and emerging countries, including a vast range of digital innovations based on a complex legal framework and guided by principles of networking. Despite the well-known benefits, not everything is rosy. Digital transformation has ushered in a host of intricate challenges, risks, and setbacks for governments, society, and businesses alike.
Digital transformation is undeniably a positive and largely irreversible paradigm. Nevertheless, it is equally evident that the outcomes of these innovations, particularly concerning the digital divide and the indiscriminate deployment of algorithms, are not always foreseeable and can have adverse effects on the effectiveness of processes and services, the safeguarding of citizens' rights, and the levels of public trust in government.
In this context, this workshop focuses on exploring the trends and challenges of policy innovation in the Digital Era observed worldwide. The workshop welcomes papers with various approaches - theoretical, methodological, and empirical - that: i) analyze initiatives leveraging digital transformation to enhance public sector performance; ii) Present case studies highlighting setbacks or risks associated with digital innovation in the public policy; iii) examine how governments worldwide are designing transparency and accountability instruments to adapt to the impacts of digital transformation. These efforts should align with ethical and integrity standards, as well as the participatory and inclusive principles valued by society.
BIOGRAPHICAL PRESENTATION
Pedro Cavalcante is a Professor of the Masters/Doctorate in Public Administration at the National School of Public Administration (Enap) and the Brazilian Institute of Education, Development and Research (IDP). Collaborating Professor at UnB, FDC and FGV. PhD in Political Science (UnB). Visiting Professor at the School of Global Policy and Strategy at the University of California (2022). Visiting researcher at Columbia University (2016). Government Manager since 2004, he is currently a Special Advisor to the CGU. Coordinator of the Public Policy GT of the Brazilian Society of Public Administration (SBAP). He has published six books and collections of scientific articles in the areas of public administration, governance, innovation, development and public policy.
Fernando Filgueiras is an associate professor at the School of Social Science, Federal University of Goiás (UFG). Professor of PHD Professional Program in Public Policy at the National School of Public Administration (ENAP). Affiliate faculty at Ostrom Workshop on Political Theory and Policy Analysis, Indiana University. Researcher at the National Institute of Science and Technology (INCT)–Digital Democracy, Federal University of Bahia (UFBA). Fellow of the National Council of Scientific and Technology Development (CNPq). Filgueiras has a Ph.D. in Political Science from the University Research Institute of Rio de Janeiro (Iuperj).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
E-governance holds profound promise to transform governance in developing countries, yet many initiatives fail mid implementation. This underscores the need to examine drivers of e-governance adoption within public agencies. Integrating the Technology Acceptance Model and Diffusion of Innovations Theory, this quantitative study will survey 300 officials engaged in e-governance projects across government levels in Pakistan. Structural equation modeling will analyze how performance benefits, effort expectancy, social influence and resource availability shape adoption intentions. Moderating effects of gender and experience will also be tested. Findings will advance theory validation while equipping policymakers with evidence based strategies to successfully steer e-governance for enhanced transparency, efficiency and public participation. This timely study will catalyze social innovation by illuminating pathways to harness the transformational potential of e-governance in uplifting marginalized communities. It constitutes a critical first step in bridging theory and practice to promote impactful technology enabled innovation in governance.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Digital transformation is a process that empowers governments to harness technology's potential to reinforce fiscal transparency and accountability, boost the effectiveness of public expenditure, and enhance outcomes in education, healthcare service delivery, and social welfare. The case of AI is particularly noteworthy as it has developed into a global trend that significantly influences governments' policy decisions and implementation.
Despite the good purposes and benefits, not everything is rosy since AI has also ushered in a host of intricate challenges, risks, and setbacks for governments, society, and businesses alike, such as safeguarding private data and privacy. Furthermore, two other issues threaten the government's ability to deliver public services effectively, transparently, and equitably: digital divide or exclusion and algorithmic discrimination.
Therefore, this paper aims to analyze the effects of the widespread adoption of AI, examining the potential risks it presents to service quality, equity, and transparency. Furthermore, it aims to shed light on ongoing global initiatives that foster accountability in artificial intelligence. In this sense, the policy paper delves into this subject to contribute to the debate on algorithmic accountability. To achieve this, it first discusses AI use's positive and negative effects, providing global examples of algorithmic discrimination. Then, the article presents how the Brazilian public sector has structured and implemented its AI governance strategy and highlights the AI bill's critical points currently under discussion in the nation's parliament. Next, the study scrutinizes how governments worldwide are designing transparency and accountability mechanisms to address the repercussions of AI while aligning them with ethical and integrity standards, as well as participatory and inclusive principles valued by society. Based on these insights, some insights are offered for advancing the design and implementation of practical initiatives within the Brazilian public sector.
Although Brazil has being part of the growing adoption of artificial intelligence, especially in public services, the country has yet to make progress in strengthening the accountability aspect of its AI governance strategy. State initiatives have been relatively shy and lagging behind the prevailing trend of algorithmic accountability embraced by many other nations, as described in the previous section. Compared with other countries in Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC), Brazil finds itself in the second tier of capacities. The good news comes from the Legislative branch, which has advanced the debate on AI regulation through a bill in the Federal Senate to establish a framework for responsible artificial intelligence governance.
In summary, for AI governance to accomplish its comprehensive goals, it must recognize the intricate interplay between technology and society when setting priorities. This approach is essential for fostering responsible, trustworthy, democratic, inclusive, and human-centered AI implementation in both civil service and business domains. In essence, crafting a robust governance framework for AI focusing on algorithmic accountability is a challenging process of learning, adaptation, and experimentation, marked by progress and setbacks.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the digital era, data has become the lifeblood of smart cities, driving innovation and reshaping urban governance. As data emerges as a crucial element in political and administrative decision-making, its significant impact on modern urban governance becomes increasingly important to understand. This paper thus examines the instrumental role of data in urban governance, particularly through urban crowdsourcing, which aims to harness the collective intelligence of the “crowd” to address urban challenges.
Specifically, this study investigates digital fault reporting platforms as a prominent form of urban crowdsourcing globally. These platforms enable citizens to report issues related to urban infrastructure, services, or public spaces to the concerned municipal authorities. The central research question explores the governance of public spaces in the context of such data becoming vital in urban infrastructure management. A comparative case study is hence conducted on the implementation and use of digital fault reporting platforms in four Western European cities: FixMyStreet in Bristol (UK), Zuri Wie Neu in Zurich (Switzerland), Nantes dans ma Poche in Nantes (France), and Felanmalan in Malmo (Sweden).
Utilizing the Actor-Network Theory (ANT), this research uncovers the sociotechnical networks underlying the development and appropriation of these platforms across those four middle-sized municipalities. By examining the concept of 'translation' surrounding digital fault reporting platforms, in the sense of how actors (both human and non-human) interact, negotiate, and align their interests to form networks, the study aims to reveal the -often invisible- politics of urban data shaping the governance of modern cities.
The findings depict a complex governance landscape where citizens have become integral part of the management of urban spaces, whether as political dissenters or as external collaborators. The integration of reporting data into urban management is indeed a double-edged sword: it represents a valuable resource for municipalities to enhance their public image, yet also a platform that also an open door to criticisms.
This data-driven turn in urban administration thus does not necessarily depoliticize issues of urban maintenance and public space management. Instead, it introduces new layers of conflict and politicization, simultaneously fostering mixed feelings of resentment and empathy among citizens towards both municipal administrations and local elected officials.
Finally, the hybrid nature of digital fault reporting platforms at the crossroad between an asset management system and a customer relationship management tool compels municipalities to adapt their administrative and political structures to manage the influx of crowdsourced data. This often positions them reactively to civic reports, hinting at the potential development of new forms of public space governance. It points towards a governance model where the geography of public intervention is likely to be significantly influenced by the intervention of the most engaged users on the platforms, and marked by a gradual replacement of civil engineers with communication experts, best suited to swiftly respond to civic reports.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Public Administrations must move towards the formulation and implementation of public policies based on data and evidence, from their design to the evaluation of their results. For this transition, the use and implementation of technologies associated with what is called “Digital Transformation” is essential, such as information monitoring and control systems for the provision of public services, with orientation to the generation, analysis, and use of those data to establish a “Data-based Policy Making”. Public Administrations require resources and capabilities related to technologies associated with Digital Transformation, such as the Internet of Things (IoT), Big Data (Smart Data), Cloud Computing. and models based on Artificial Intelligence such as Machine Learning.
The great challenge for Digital Transformation projects in Public Administration is to generate valuable information that they can convert into knowledge for the formulation of evidence-based public policies. The papers talk about 2 specific examples of technological deployments based on an identified need and with a strategic vision of two Public Dependencies of the Government of Jalisco, both developed in the Guadalajara Metropolitan Area (GMA). The projects required the articulation of Government Agencies and 2 institutions of the academic-technological community of Jalisco, CIATEQ Advanced Technology Center and the Institute of Technology and Higher Studies of Monterrey, Guadalajara Campus.
One project was the AIOT Platform for the generation of the epidemiological risk index based on environmental and health variables in the southern zone of the GMA. In this project the Secretariat of Environment and Territorial Development of Jalisco (SEMADET) identified the need to develop a digital transformation project that would allow it to carry out real-time measurement of air and water pollution variables, through the deployment of monitoring stations using different IoT devices. Once the data is collected, the application of algorithms was needed to predict the risks and try to reduce and avoid them with joint actions between the different actors in society and the government. Different Machine Learning and Deep Learning algorithms were developed to generate future projections generated by short-term predictive models of air quality. In the project, an AIoT platform was generated in accordance with NOM-172-SEMARNAT-2019, mandatory for state or municipal governments responsible for monitoring air quality.
The second project was an AIoT platform to monitor explosive levels in the drainage system of the Intermunicipal System of Drinking Water and Sewage Services of the GMA (SIAPA), in this project the combination of the prevention and control of accidents in pipelines with digital transformation technologies such as IoT, Artificial Intelligence and Smart Data, can achieve the prevention of urban disasters. A platform for real-time monitoring harmful sewer gases as well as explosive levels to provide alarm or alert signals in emergency conditions was developed. With the help of IoT and Artificial Intelligence, which generated robustness to the system by integrating the existing measurement points, as well as the development of a new measurement point, with local technology, that will allow SIAPA to expand in the future the platform with low costs, high precision and easy operation.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
1.Research question
With breakthrough in algorithms, advancement in computing power, and the acquisition of massive data in the field of information technology, artificial intelligence is rapidly developing and becoming increasingly deeply embedded in various fields of human society, promoting its revolutionary change. While acknowledge the potential benefit that artificial intelligence has for the human civilization, we must also be wary of its hidden risks. As an advocate and regulator of emerging technologies, governments need to balance the future benefits and high risks of artificial intelligence, how to deal with the Collingridge Dilemma has become a public policy issue that governments around the world need to solve urgently. From the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in 2016 to the Artificial Intelligence Act (AIA) in 2023, the EU has established a world-leading artificial intelligence risk management framework. This paper aims to study the political logic of artificial intelligence risk management in the European Union, that is, to think about how different political actors such as EU public policy agencies, multinational technology companies, non-governmental organizations, and citizens perceive the risk factors of artificial intelligence technology, and how to interact with each other under guidance of different risk perception frameworks, and what kind of artificial intelligence risk management framework is constructed during above political interaction process.
2.Methodology
This paper will use epistemic network analysis (ENA) and NVivo to conduct an in-depth text analysis of policy documents in the EU's artificial intelligence risk management framework. Since policy documents are the carrier of information transmission and reflect the publisher's intentions, goals, commitments, expectations, and reactions to external events, therefore studying policy documents can help us understand the risk perception frameworks and role positioning of various political actors in EU AI risk governance.
3.How it fits with the workshops' research questions
Traditional risk management tools, including risk analysis, precautionary principle and liability, are incapable of providing adequate governance of emerging technologies, mainly because the high uncertainty of their realistic risks. Therefore the policy innovation, instigated by governments, are urgent in the digital era. This paper study how heterogeneous political actors within the EU form bridging social capital and linking social capital through political interaction, to deal with AI’s risks with a innovative, tentative and resilient governance framework. It has important implications for other governments’ policy innovation in the field of new technologies.
4.I will present the paper online.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Artificial intelligence (AI) is an innovation with significant potential to bring immense benefits to humanity, but it also poses considerable risks. A statement organized by the Center for AI Safety in May 2003 emphasized that mitigating the risk of AI-induced extinction should be a global priority, akin to addressing other societal-scale risks like pandemics and nuclear war. This declaration garnered support from over 500 prominent academics and industry leaders (The Time online, October 24th, 2023).
When queried about the primary social risks of its development, ChatGPT identified key concerns, including Job Displacement, Inequality, Bias and Discrimination, Privacy Concerns, Security Threats, Loss of Control, Social Isolation, Unemployment in Specific Sectors, and Lack of Accountability. Additionally, it underscored the importance of addressing these risks through a combination of ethical guidelines, regulations, and collaborative efforts involving policymakers, technologists, and society at large, as of January 28th, 2024.
One of the major challenges in regulating AI lies in the necessity for a global framework; without it, effectiveness is compromised. However, AI is a central arena for technological competition among global players, and these entities may resist measures that could hinder their innovative capabilities.
In response to these challenges, the Council requested a proposal from the Commission in 2019. The Commission, in February 2020, published a White Paper on the subject. By April 2021, the European Union Commission proposed the first regulation on AI within the Union. This proposal aims to establish a technology-neutral definition of AI systems in EU law and a classification system based on a 'risk-based approach' (EP, EU legislation in progress, June 2023). The suggested AI governance includes national and European-level authorities comprised of experts from member states. These authorities would be empowered to take corrective measures, including prohibition, restriction, withdrawal, or recall of AI systems not complying with the AI act or those presenting risks to health, safety, fundamental rights, or other public interests (Ibidem).
Since June 2020, the European Parliament established a Special Committee on Artificial Intelligence (AIDA), which conducted numerous studies, hearings, and sought expert advice. In May 2022, AIDA issued a Final Report. The European Parliament faces renewal in June 2024, raising uncertainties about the joint approval of AI regulation with the Council before that time.
This paper will narrate the story of this proposal, examining the underlying issues, the evidence considered, and the policy choices that could shape the approach to AI regulation at the European level. (Text corrected by ChatGTP)
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Governments around the world introduce reforms to improve the performance of public sector. Introduction of innovative practices and digitalization of services is another way these reforms are introduced in the public sector. Innovative e-governance strategies are adopted by the developed countries followed by the developing world. The literature suggests a shift from the traditional theoretical perspectives of Public Administration to the new Public Service Logic through value creation in the e-government practices. In this regard, this study is conducted to explore the reforms in the practices of Police services in Pakistan. Following a qualitative approach to unearth the shift from a typical police station to a model modern police Khidmat Markaz in Punjab province of Pakistan, this study is conducted by studying the case of Police Khidmat Markaz in Lahore. Semi structured interviews, content analysis of the online reviews, and participant observation were the data collection tools for this study. The results are based on the opinion of first-hand users and citizens which highlight the value creation and innovation introduced through the digitalization of services of Punjab Police. The study is explained through the lens of Public Service Logic Perspective in the developing countries.
Keywords: Public service logic, value creation, innovation, e-governance, Police
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Against the backdrop of the current digital era, the development of health big data is flourishing, bringing tremendous opportunities and challenges to China's healthcare industry. Therefore, it is particularly important to conduct in-depth analysis of the policy environment for the development of health big data in China and explore the trends and challenges of innovation policies in the digital age. The purpose of this study is to provide theoretical basis for decision-making and improvement in China's healthcare industry and provide guidance for the high-quality development of the health big data industry. This study adopts the method of text mining, primarily relying on official websites of government departments such as the National Health Commission of the People's Republic of China as the main source of information. By conducting keyword searches such as "health big data," "medical big data," and "healthcare big data," the study aims to analyze policy trends and grasp the government's guidance. In terms of policy text mining analysis, the RostCM6.0 and VOSviewer software were used to conduct in-depth mining and analysis of policy texts related to health big data in China, obtaining high-frequency vocabulary and constructing a high-frequency word network. In addition, the Policy-Making Cycle (PMC) index model was used for policy evaluation. Based on the existing model, this study constructed a PMC index model that suits the characteristics of health big data in China for the evaluation of relevant policies. Expert consultations were also conducted, including the Delphi method. Based on the high-frequency vocabulary obtained through text mining, a questionnaire was developed and Delphi expert consultations were conducted to evaluate the selection and scoring of indicators in the indicator system. The expert consultation evaluation of indicators was divided into two parts: quantitative scoring of indicators based on importance, obtainability, and sensitivity, and qualitative evaluation of the connotation and attributes of indicators. The research results show that China has a total of nine policies related to health big data, with an average PMC index value of 4.72. Among them, two policies performed well, while seven policies passed the evaluation. Overall, the quality of national-level health big data policies in China is good, but there is still room for improvement. In summary, China's management policies for health big data are generally sound, with clear nature and functions of the policies. This study focuses on specific analysis from three aspects: policy content, incentive constraints, and lifecycle, and provides improvement suggestions to address the trends and challenges faced by innovation policies in the digital age.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Rapid technological advances are driving public sector transformation worldwide through digital government initiatives prioritizing online service delivery, data-driven governance, and technological innovation. However, digital maturity varies substantially across regions influenced by economic, social, and policy environments. The Middle East and North Africa (MENA) context remains under-explored in existing literature that tends to focus on Western e-governance models, despite the region’s nascent yet accelerating adoption of emerging technologies. This study therefore analyzes the contemporary trends, persistent challenges, and potential solutions for digital government transformation specifically in the MENA region using mixed methods integrating computational analysis of regional e-governance databases with semi-structured expert elite interviews.
The technology-organization-environment (TOE) theoretical framework structures the investigation of technological, institutional, and contextual factors influencing the adoption and impacts of digital government. TOE provides a holistic lens encompassing barriers related to digital divides, data protection, algorithmic transparency, and participation. Meanwhile, the principles of value-sensitive design (VSD) guide the ethical policy recommendations centered on inclusion, justice, welfare, accountability, and human rights. Integrating both perspectives allows for examination of complex regional challenges alongside targeted, ethical solutions tailored to public sector contexts.
Trend analysis reveals steady adoption of e-government services and smart city technologies across MENA, with higher penetration rates in the Gulf countries. Yet utilization continues lagging among vulnerable demographic segments. Technological innovation has outpaced development of oversight mechanisms with minimal auditing of automated decision-systems and limited progress on open data policies restrictive data localization requirements persist in many countries.
The study reveals uneven digital government advancement influenced by wealth, education, and technological capacity differences at the regional and national levels. Gulf countries grapple more with emerging risks related data privacy, surveillance, and automation bias given their advanced technical infrastructure. Meanwhile non-Gulf countries continue struggling with basic digital divide challenges, skills shortages, and cybersecurity threats.
Findings suggest digital government transformation remains mostly government-centric and technology-driven without sufficient public consultation and participation in tech governance. Adoption of emerging technologies appears poorly aligned with social, ethical and value considerations for human rights, inclusion non-discrimination – as evident in the widening digital accessibility divide.
Recommendations include adopting human-centric design principles for citizen-centric e-services, enacting algorithmic transparency standards, boosting data literacy programs focusing on vulnerable groups, targeted capacity-building for non-Gulf countries through regional cooperation, developing comprehensive data protection legislation, embedding ethics in public procurement frameworks and establishing centers of excellence guiding evidence-based governance of emerging technologies.
By highlighting trends and barriers influenced by technological, institutional and contextual dimensions factors through an integrated TOE-VSD lens alongside actionable policy solutions, this study delivers both theoretical and practical value. It provides a novel perspective on the distinct opportunities and risks of digital government specifically in the MENA region for researchers and decisions-makers aiming to equitably leverage technology’s potential.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The theme of AI used in public security is one of the most discussed topics in the field of public policy studies nowadays. One of the reasons for that is the observed risks to democracy arising from its use, especially when carried out indiscriminately, without concerns for the right to privacy or the protection of personal data. The situation becomes even more critical when the algorithm is not auditable and, therefore, not subject to social control.
The goal of this article is to analyze the construction of public action instruments for the formulation of data-driven policies that exert control over the population through algorithmic governance. The initiatives related to public security implemented by the Brazilian federal government and the risks to democracy arising from their implementation will be examined.
The theoretical framework is based on Science and Technology Studies (STS) applied to digital and algorithmic governance, in addition to fundamental concepts that form the basis of critical studies in public policies. The studies conducted from this theoretical framework analyze not only institutionalized mechanisms but also informal political and micro-political practices. Also of importance is to analyze the mechanisms of constructing public action instruments mediated by technological-informational resources, such as algorithms. These instruments are consensually agreed upon and legitimized for the coordination of actors, groups, and institutions. To understand this context, it is also fundamental to consider the decolonizing AI theory that has been developed recently (CAVE; DIHAL, 2020).
The tensions and challenges posed to the contemporary democratic state are discussed, such as the implications of data-driven social policies in the political sphere and public management; government surveillance; human rights violations; and the reproduction of inequalities through public action instruments mediated by algorithms.
The research used primary and secondary data related to AI initiatives for public security in the Brazilian federal government until the year of 2023. Bibliographic research and document analysis were conducted to understand the political and sociotechnical mechanisms involved.
An algorithm was used to extract all documents mentioning the term "artificial intelligence" and related terms from the four main federal government websites (leg.br; jus.br; gov.br; mp.br). A total of 9,435 elements were found. Within this universe, we searched for terms associated with public security, reaching a total of 249 terms linked to federal government initiatives in the field of public security. In-depth analyses were then carried out within this universe of 249 terms to identify the public action instruments that are actually being implemented for subsequent evaluation of their implications.
It was observed that inequalities previously identified in AI-developed programs, especially regarding race and gender, continue to be reproduced by the governance mechanisms developed, especially in the field of public security and justice. The databases used to feed AI have embedded in them the mark of racial discriminations perpetuated by individuals and institutions. Other risks to democracy observed include the indiscriminate use of AI without concerns for privacy rights and the protection of personal data. The absence of auditable algorithms, susceptible to social control, raises additional concerns.
Bibliography
CALLON, M., LASCOUMES, P. & BARTHE, Y. (2001). Agir dans un monde incertain. Essai sur la démocratie technique, Paris: Seuil.
CAVE, S., & DIHAL, K. The Whiteness of AI. Philosophy and Technology, 2020. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13347-020-00415-6.
COLEMAN, Stephen; FREELON, Deen. Handbook of Digital Politics. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd, 2015.
MENDONÇA, R., ALMEIDA, V.; FILGUEIRAS, F. Algorithmic institutionalism: the changing rules of social and political life. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2023.
MOROZOV, E. Big Tech: A ascensão dos dados e a morte da política, 2018.
ZUBOFF, S. The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power. New York: Public Affairs, 2019.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Problem Statement
The potential of e-commerce to improve agriculture profits and farmers’ income has aroused the attention of the Chinese government. The National Rural E-Commerce Comprehensive Demonstration Project (RECD) has been put forward to promote e-commerce expansion in rural areas of China since 2014. The project is aimed to increase rural income levels and alleviate poverty. Although many studies suggest that promoting e-commerce increases rural households’ income and reduces poverty, other researchers are worried that the exacerbating digital gap may lead to worse income inequality. Whether and to what extent do government-led rural e-commerce expansion projects affect rural income inequality? What underlying mechanisms and complementary interventions are necessary for program implementation? The RECD in China provides a unique opportunity to estimate the impacts of a government-led large-scale e-commerce expansion policy on income inequality in the countryside of a developing country, which is essential for both academia and policymakers.
Conceptual Framework
According to the implementation guidelines for the RECD, we expect that the project may reduce rural household income inequality through the more prominent effects for rural households that initially have lower income levels. Possible channels: 1) by reducing the cost of logistics, transportation, and information search; 2) by providing e-commerce training for farmers to increase their e-commerce knowledge and skills; 3) by providing formal financial credit.
Data Sources
The database combines three sources: the China Family Panel Studies (CFPS) 2010-2022, the 2010 National Census data by county, and the 2013 China County Statistical Yearbook. Specifically, our micro household data are five rounds of follow-up CFPS data from 2010 to 2018 covering 162 counties in 25 provinces of China, of which 46 counties are RECD counties. The baseline survey was conducted in 2010, and the target sample size was 16,000 households.
Estimation Strategy
First, we excluded the effect of other critical concurrent policies (the construction of the national-level E-commerce Demonstration Cities and the Information Technology into Villages project) launched after 2010. Then, we simulate the inequality index results of the RECD counties if they were not selected in the project and compare them with the real indexes of both RECD counties and ordinary counties to see whether the project affects income inequality. Second, we employ the DID method to examine the causal relationship between the project and the income inequality indexes. Third, we employ the Shapley value decomposition based on regression to calculate the distribution of the project on household income inequality and identify the key mechanism of the three channels mentioned above.
Potential for Generating Discussion
Given that the overall scale of China’s e-commerce is the world’s largest, this paper can provide credible evidence of the effectiveness of an e-commerce promotion project implemented by a central government. Since many developing countries have also implemented policies to encourage the development of rural e-commerce growth, aiming to alleviate poverty and reduce inequality, what is the implication that the evidence from China provides for the development of e-commerce in developing countries? Can the experience be expanded?
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
National digital health platforms (also known as electronic health records (EHR)) are key enablers for health data interoperability at the national level. It enables hospitals and other facilities to engage in consent-based sharing of health data to improve patient experience as they navigate the care continuum. It is generally believed that improved access to health data can lead to innovations that can enhance the efficiency of care delivery and lead to better patient treatment outcomes. Currently, there is limited research exploring how national digital health platforms shape digital health innovation at a national level, especially in the context of Asia. The paper explores this question across five Asian countries including China, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore. The aim is to understand how national digital health platforms affect digital health innovation at a country level. The study is based on qualitative analysis of 38 interviews conducted across healthcare sector in the respective countries. The research fits well with the intent of the workshop since it analyses existing national initiatives to digitally transform healthcare which in turn has potentially positive effects for healthcare outcomes. Secondly, the paper aims to analyse the drivers and barriers of this process, which also includes the evolving data privacy and cybersecurity issues that governments have to constantly grapple with to enable innovation in the sector. And lastly, the paper also captures the role of regulations to better enable the translation of health data sharing to innovation which generally requires governments to carefully balance the need to protect data privacy with the need to encourage more innovation in the sector.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Digital transformation of public authority legislative spaces for policy and evidence systems in the Kenyan legislative outcomes.
Abstract
By
Japheth Ondiek and Gedion Onyango
Globally, digital transformation is rapidly transforming the operations and duties of public agencies, notably legislative bodies. Kenya, a country with a thriving democracy and a strong legislative system, is also undergoing significant changes in the way its legislative processes are carried out. As a concept, digital transformation refers to the incorporation of digital technologies into many sectors of governance and public administration.
Equally, in the current proliferation of digital forms of communication and involvement of digital means for citizen engagement across major platform, we explore the succinct transmissions of evidence supply, it utilization and it effect in the final decision making organ. It is not only important to look at the actors, their involvement, use of digital technologies, digital connectivity, digital skills, access to digital transmission of evidence but equally important is the perception of digital citizenship on supplied evidence affects the final policy decisions outcome. This research is exploring the process of research, evidence and policy decision through electronic transformations including understanding how actors’ supplies evidence to the relevant legislative institutions. Equally, in the current proliferation of digital forms of communication and involvement of digital means for citizen engagement across major platform, we explore the succinct transmissions of evidence supply, it utilization and it effect in the final decision making organ. It is not only important to look at the actors, their involvement, use of digital technologies, digital connectivity, digital skills, access to digital transmission of evidence but equally important is the perception of digital citizenship on supplied evidence affects the final policy decisions outcome.
This transition has an impact on legislative bodies because it improves efficiency, openness, and accountability. (McGetrick) 2017 conducted a major study that addresses global trends in digital transformation in legislative areas and highlights the possible benefits and challenges related to this change. The purpose of this study is to investigate and explore the potential benefits of digital transformation for Kenyan legislative spaces, policy and evidence systems, and legislative outcomes. Collectively, the study provides insights into the digital transformation of public authority legislative spaces for policy and evidence systems in Kenyan legislative results. The study will involve conducting interviews from legislatures, parliamentary drafters and researchers and the civil society networks to understand the eceosystem of digital transformation of evidence presentation in the Kenyan Parliament and derive further policy recommendations for the study.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This article undertakes a comprehensive inquiry into Citizen Identity Management in Bangladesh, with a specific focus on elucidating grassroots dynamics as discerned through an implemented piloting project. Set against the backdrop of Bangladesh's ambitious initiatives, encompassing the Bangladesh National Digital Architecture (BNDA) Framework, the Smart National Identification Card program, and the National Identity Registration Act 2023, the manuscript critically assesses the challenges and opportunities intrinsic to these endeavors. In light of the escalating trajectory towards digitalization, the article accentuates the paramount significance of secure and privacy-conscious management of citizen information. The overarching research question guiding this study centers on how the insights gleaned from the piloting project can contribute to a nuanced comprehension of Citizen Identity Management at the grassroots level in Bangladesh. The study's primary objective is to conduct a critical assessment of the challenges and opportunities embedded in Bangladesh's Citizen Identity Management initiatives, with a particular emphasis on the grassroots dynamics within the Union Parishad framework. Drawing upon insights derived from the piloting project, the aim is to furnish valuable perspectives for policymakers and practitioners engaged in the domains of digital governance and identity systems. The study advocates for a holistic and integrated approach to amplify service delivery and governance processes at the grassroots level in Bangladesh. This research contends, based on its findings, that the current identity management structure is excessively centralized for effective service delivery within the local context. Simultaneously, the study acknowledges the existing limitations within local government capacities to manage digital identities, especially in ensuring security. Despite this, the article posits that local government entities can play a pivotal role, asserting that decentralized identity management employing contemporary technologies can yield efficient outcomes. Consequently, the article advocates for an integrative approach, underscored by the strategic utilization of extant databases, the adoption of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs), and proactive citizen engagement.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The introduction of Artificial Intelligence (AI) at the government level presents a series of multifaceted challenges, covering technical, ethical, regulatory and cultural aspects, at the same time as a great opportunity to enhance the state's capacity to increase the quality of public services offered to the population.
The insertion of these new technologies in society leads to a dense debate on ethical and privacy issues, which is even greater when considering that their use by the government can deepen the use of discriminatory views and access to personal information. The need to ensure transparency, fairness and the protection of individual rights places additional demands on implementing ethical systems and complying with strict ethical standards.
Other issues such as regulatory aspects, the gap between technological evolution and legislation that can create legal uncertainties, internal cultural and institutional resistance are a critical factor. This impacts cybersecurity, which emerges as a pressing concern. The increased use of technologies and exposes AI systems to potential malicious attacks, highlighting the importance of robust security measures to protect sensitive data.
Despite the risks and difficulties, artificial intelligence is capable of increasing the efficiency, effectiveness and productivity of society. Examples of the use of AI in government present solutions for reducing queues and better application of public resources in government programs.
The innovative aspect that accompanies a specific part of artificial intelligence brings opportunities to the public sector, although the impact is uncertain. To explore the possibilities offered by AI, the alignment between the government's entrepreneurial capacity to promote through financing and credit, in addition to the provision of technical resources and the private entrepreneurial spirit are important.
The impact of introducing new technologies in government is not only aimed at increasing the state's capacity to deliver value to society, but also guarantees the promotion of the creation of new markets that can bring practical applications to private clients.
This article offers the opportunity to deepen the debate on the need for an entrepreneurial State to introduce new technologies, focusing on the challenges of using AI within the government agenda. To achieve this, an empirical approach to the Brazilian government will be used, with an approach to using open innovation to connect private innovative entrepreneurship and the State to solve public problems with AI.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper aims to contribute to the debate on the appropriation and use of data by civil society, analyzing the intersections between the right to the city and digital justice. With the development of forms of popular participation and accountability, largely due to better access to public data, the question of data’s appropriation and navigation becomes crucial for popular initiatives. Popular movements, based on new notions of diversity, then seek to act in the communicative sphere to create narratives based on the reappropriation of data.
In the city of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, the context of urban conflicts and violence entered a new phase after the major events (Olympic Games and World Cup, between 2014 and 2016), aggravated by the conservative social and economic policies of local and national governments in the last 8 years. However, we have also observed an important movement in the production or appropriation of data within local communities, with the aim of providing new evidence for public policies and promoting citizen action. In this sense, the objective of the project in which this proposal is inserted is to understand new perspectives and tools forged by popular action for overcoming the current urban crisis, transforming territories of war (brought by the UPPs* as imposed and now bankrupt territories of peace), into communicative and productive territories.
Demands for urban justice have been updated with the popular use and appropriation of data, which become a new arena of dispute in the construction of a more just city. In this sense, we will present a mapping of civic and popular initiatives developed in the city of Rio de Janeiro that aim to generate data to improve urban justice. Based on this mapping, we will present two specific cases: data_labe, linked to the Observatório das Favelas, which calls itself a "data and narrative laboratory" in Favela da Maré, bringing together residents of popular territories. The project disseminates data on studies of issues such as basic sanitation and security, and offers training in data analysis. The second case refers to the Instituto data favela, an initiative that aims to collect data on favelas in Rio de Janeiro and propose indicators to the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE).
We will show that these cases allow us to rethink public policies in three aspects: 1) they intend not only to monitor but also to produce new logics of public policies, based on the direct participation of citizens in the production of data; 2) they contribute to rethinking imaginaries of segregated territories through the reappropriation of data, building new narratives of these territories; 3) they contribute to reactivate local solidarities and expand the possibilities of urban common goods.
*UPPs were a result of a security policy established during the big events, adopting a “pacifying” police that was installed in popular areas in Brazil. They ended short after the big events.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Various local communities throughout Mexico have experienced the pervasive influence of narco-violence and machismo under criminal governance, which has left an indelible, negative impact on numerous families. Facing threats from the prevalence of narco-violence and at times the lack of official security services, women in various states in Mexico have initiated and participated in organizations to find their missing families and friends. The most recent case is a march in August 2023 by a group of women commemorating the International Day of Victims of Forced Disappearances. A poignant but evoking question arises: how do civilian women strategically navigate their non-violent social movements in response to the harrowing phenomenon of family disappearances in the context of narco-violence?
This paper analyzes civilian women’s strategic use of social media for their activism from the case of the “Madres Buscadoras (Searching Mothers)” in the metropolitan areas of Mexico, in the 2020s. Referring to the theory of civilian women’s agency in armed conflicts, particularly under narco-violence, we argue that these civilian women strategically utilize social media platforms to secure their safety and promote their movements through trans-local networks. We conduct 20 semi-structured interviews with activists and residents in anonymous cities and municipalities as well as online research on social media, including Facebook and Twitter. Through qualitative analyses of these sources, we demonstrate that these women use social media to inform families and the public of real situations not covered by traditional media and to organize trans-local networks for mutual support. Specifically, the activists utilize social media as a database where the organization and families mutually share information collected by themselves; families share photographs and information about their missing relatives, while the organization publishes those about individuals found in their searches. They also share information published by different state governmental institutions such as Comision de Busqueda de Personas (Person Search Commission). Their efforts extend to organizing search groups in perilous areas and raising public awareness through social media campaigns.
This research theoretically and empirically expands the literature on civilian women’s participation in non-violent social movements under narco-violence with a focus on their agency and multifaceted strategies. Previous studies examined the motivations and strategies of women’s activism for missing families in Latin America by focusing on womanhood and motherhood. However, there has been little attention to the utilization of social media in their networked movements. Filling the gaps in research, we examine women’s strategies to fight against narco-violence by examining their trans-local network through online social media. Our findings encapsulate the complex convergence of gender, activism, and the socio-political conditions shaped by narco-violence. Furthermore, this research brings new empirical findings by collecting original qualitative data that has been relatively less investigated.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
As technology continues to revolutionize the healthcare system, it presents new challenges to health technology governance. This paper explores the intersection of innovation policy, smart and connected health (SCH) technologies, and the importance of fostering health equity within this eHealth ecosystem. SCH has shown promising potential to improve health outcomes by managing chronic conditions, accessing real-time health information, accelerating treatment and testing procedures, and delivering remote health services to marginalized communities in resource-constrained settings. From mission- and system-oriented perspectives, technical and human resources play a significant part in developing SCH technologies during the early stages of the innovation process. As SCH becomes increasingly essential to healthcare organizations and medically underserved communities, individuals in leadership roles and digital health developers need to recognize and understand how digital determinants and design processes could impact health equity. For instance, the availability and accessibility to digital technologies and their related health services could create a “digital divide” that may affect health outcomes and contribute to further health inequality at the population level. Therefore, we must carefully consider the challenges that digital technologies present and ensure that we are not inadvertently exacerbating existing health disparities. To address health equity within SCH system, we need to recognize the issues with transaction costs (TC), which are an integral part of the development and implementation of digital health technologies in health services organizations. Some of the issues and challenges associated with TC in this context include complex integration into existing healthcare systems, engagement with multiple stakeholders and service providers, regulatory compliance, investment in training programs, data privacy and ownership, and risk and uncertainty. Using the framework of Transaction Costs Economics (TCE) grounded in neo-institutionalism, this paper applies TCE fundamental constructs and implicit assumptions to analyze digitally-mediated TC and the complexities of implementation. A narrative case study is presented to provide some understanding of practical challenges and opportunities in optimizing health equity within the SCH ecosystem. This study will offer strategic approaches to navigating the intricate landscape of eHealth and leveraging digital health solutions effectively to deliver health services while ensuring equitable access, quality, and safety for users.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
E-governance holds profound promise to transform governance in developing countries, yet many initiatives fail mid implementation. This underscores the need to examine drivers of e-governance adoption within public agencies. Integrating the Technology Acceptance Model and Diffusion of Innovations Theory, this quantitative study will survey 300 officials engaged in e-governance projects across government levels in Pakistan. Structural equation modeling will analyze how performance benefits, effort expectancy, social influence and resource availability shape adoption intentions. Moderating effects of gender and experience will also be tested. Findings will advance theory validation while equipping policymakers with evidence based strategies to successfully steer e-governance for enhanced transparency, efficiency and public participation. This timely study will catalyze social innovation by illuminating pathways to harness the transformational potential of e-governance in uplifting marginalized communities. It constitutes a critical first step in bridging theory and practice to promote impactful technology enabled innovation in governance.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Digital transformation is a process that empowers governments to harness technology's potential to reinforce fiscal transparency and accountability, boost the effectiveness of public expenditure, and enhance outcomes in education, healthcare service delivery, and social welfare. The case of AI is particularly noteworthy as it has developed into a global trend that significantly influences governments' policy decisions and implementation.
Despite the good purposes and benefits, not everything is rosy since AI has also ushered in a host of intricate challenges, risks, and setbacks for governments, society, and businesses alike, such as safeguarding private data and privacy. Furthermore, two other issues threaten the government's ability to deliver public services effectively, transparently, and equitably: digital divide or exclusion and algorithmic discrimination.
Therefore, this paper aims to analyze the effects of the widespread adoption of AI, examining the potential risks it presents to service quality, equity, and transparency. Furthermore, it aims to shed light on ongoing global initiatives that foster accountability in artificial intelligence. In this sense, the policy paper delves into this subject to contribute to the debate on algorithmic accountability. To achieve this, it first discusses AI use's positive and negative effects, providing global examples of algorithmic discrimination. Then, the article presents how the Brazilian public sector has structured and implemented its AI governance strategy and highlights the AI bill's critical points currently under discussion in the nation's parliament. Next, the study scrutinizes how governments worldwide are designing transparency and accountability mechanisms to address the repercussions of AI while aligning them with ethical and integrity standards, as well as participatory and inclusive principles valued by society. Based on these insights, some insights are offered for advancing the design and implementation of practical initiatives within the Brazilian public sector.
Although Brazil has being part of the growing adoption of artificial intelligence, especially in public services, the country has yet to make progress in strengthening the accountability aspect of its AI governance strategy. State initiatives have been relatively shy and lagging behind the prevailing trend of algorithmic accountability embraced by many other nations, as described in the previous section. Compared with other countries in Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC), Brazil finds itself in the second tier of capacities. The good news comes from the Legislative branch, which has advanced the debate on AI regulation through a bill in the Federal Senate to establish a framework for responsible artificial intelligence governance.
In summary, for AI governance to accomplish its comprehensive goals, it must recognize the intricate interplay between technology and society when setting priorities. This approach is essential for fostering responsible, trustworthy, democratic, inclusive, and human-centered AI implementation in both civil service and business domains. In essence, crafting a robust governance framework for AI focusing on algorithmic accountability is a challenging process of learning, adaptation, and experimentation, marked by progress and setbacks.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the digital era, data has become the lifeblood of smart cities, driving innovation and reshaping urban governance. As data emerges as a crucial element in political and administrative decision-making, its significant impact on modern urban governance becomes increasingly important to understand. This paper thus examines the instrumental role of data in urban governance, particularly through urban crowdsourcing, which aims to harness the collective intelligence of the “crowd” to address urban challenges.
Specifically, this study investigates digital fault reporting platforms as a prominent form of urban crowdsourcing globally. These platforms enable citizens to report issues related to urban infrastructure, services, or public spaces to the concerned municipal authorities. The central research question explores the governance of public spaces in the context of such data becoming vital in urban infrastructure management. A comparative case study is hence conducted on the implementation and use of digital fault reporting platforms in four Western European cities: FixMyStreet in Bristol (UK), Zuri Wie Neu in Zurich (Switzerland), Nantes dans ma Poche in Nantes (France), and Felanmalan in Malmo (Sweden).
Utilizing the Actor-Network Theory (ANT), this research uncovers the sociotechnical networks underlying the development and appropriation of these platforms across those four middle-sized municipalities. By examining the concept of 'translation' surrounding digital fault reporting platforms, in the sense of how actors (both human and non-human) interact, negotiate, and align their interests to form networks, the study aims to reveal the -often invisible- politics of urban data shaping the governance of modern cities.
The findings depict a complex governance landscape where citizens have become integral part of the management of urban spaces, whether as political dissenters or as external collaborators. The integration of reporting data into urban management is indeed a double-edged sword: it represents a valuable resource for municipalities to enhance their public image, yet also a platform that also an open door to criticisms.
This data-driven turn in urban administration thus does not necessarily depoliticize issues of urban maintenance and public space management. Instead, it introduces new layers of conflict and politicization, simultaneously fostering mixed feelings of resentment and empathy among citizens towards both municipal administrations and local elected officials.
Finally, the hybrid nature of digital fault reporting platforms at the crossroad between an asset management system and a customer relationship management tool compels municipalities to adapt their administrative and political structures to manage the influx of crowdsourced data. This often positions them reactively to civic reports, hinting at the potential development of new forms of public space governance. It points towards a governance model where the geography of public intervention is likely to be significantly influenced by the intervention of the most engaged users on the platforms, and marked by a gradual replacement of civil engineers with communication experts, best suited to swiftly respond to civic reports.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Public Administrations must move towards the formulation and implementation of public policies based on data and evidence, from their design to the evaluation of their results. For this transition, the use and implementation of technologies associated with what is called “Digital Transformation” is essential, such as information monitoring and control systems for the provision of public services, with orientation to the generation, analysis, and use of those data to establish a “Data-based Policy Making”. Public Administrations require resources and capabilities related to technologies associated with Digital Transformation, such as the Internet of Things (IoT), Big Data (Smart Data), Cloud Computing. and models based on Artificial Intelligence such as Machine Learning.
The great challenge for Digital Transformation projects in Public Administration is to generate valuable information that they can convert into knowledge for the formulation of evidence-based public policies. The papers talk about 2 specific examples of technological deployments based on an identified need and with a strategic vision of two Public Dependencies of the Government of Jalisco, both developed in the Guadalajara Metropolitan Area (GMA). The projects required the articulation of Government Agencies and 2 institutions of the academic-technological community of Jalisco, CIATEQ Advanced Technology Center and the Institute of Technology and Higher Studies of Monterrey, Guadalajara Campus.
One project was the AIOT Platform for the generation of the epidemiological risk index based on environmental and health variables in the southern zone of the GMA. In this project the Secretariat of Environment and Territorial Development of Jalisco (SEMADET) identified the need to develop a digital transformation project that would allow it to carry out real-time measurement of air and water pollution variables, through the deployment of monitoring stations using different IoT devices. Once the data is collected, the application of algorithms was needed to predict the risks and try to reduce and avoid them with joint actions between the different actors in society and the government. Different Machine Learning and Deep Learning algorithms were developed to generate future projections generated by short-term predictive models of air quality. In the project, an AIoT platform was generated in accordance with NOM-172-SEMARNAT-2019, mandatory for state or municipal governments responsible for monitoring air quality.
The second project was an AIoT platform to monitor explosive levels in the drainage system of the Intermunicipal System of Drinking Water and Sewage Services of the GMA (SIAPA), in this project the combination of the prevention and control of accidents in pipelines with digital transformation technologies such as IoT, Artificial Intelligence and Smart Data, can achieve the prevention of urban disasters. A platform for real-time monitoring harmful sewer gases as well as explosive levels to provide alarm or alert signals in emergency conditions was developed. With the help of IoT and Artificial Intelligence, which generated robustness to the system by integrating the existing measurement points, as well as the development of a new measurement point, with local technology, that will allow SIAPA to expand in the future the platform with low costs, high precision and easy operation.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
1.Research question
With breakthrough in algorithms, advancement in computing power, and the acquisition of massive data in the field of information technology, artificial intelligence is rapidly developing and becoming increasingly deeply embedded in various fields of human society, promoting its revolutionary change. While acknowledge the potential benefit that artificial intelligence has for the human civilization, we must also be wary of its hidden risks. As an advocate and regulator of emerging technologies, governments need to balance the future benefits and high risks of artificial intelligence, how to deal with the Collingridge Dilemma has become a public policy issue that governments around the world need to solve urgently. From the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in 2016 to the Artificial Intelligence Act (AIA) in 2023, the EU has established a world-leading artificial intelligence risk management framework. This paper aims to study the political logic of artificial intelligence risk management in the European Union, that is, to think about how different political actors such as EU public policy agencies, multinational technology companies, non-governmental organizations, and citizens perceive the risk factors of artificial intelligence technology, and how to interact with each other under guidance of different risk perception frameworks, and what kind of artificial intelligence risk management framework is constructed during above political interaction process.
2.Methodology
This paper will use epistemic network analysis (ENA) and NVivo to conduct an in-depth text analysis of policy documents in the EU's artificial intelligence risk management framework. Since policy documents are the carrier of information transmission and reflect the publisher's intentions, goals, commitments, expectations, and reactions to external events, therefore studying policy documents can help us understand the risk perception frameworks and role positioning of various political actors in EU AI risk governance.
3.How it fits with the workshops' research questions
Traditional risk management tools, including risk analysis, precautionary principle and liability, are incapable of providing adequate governance of emerging technologies, mainly because the high uncertainty of their realistic risks. Therefore the policy innovation, instigated by governments, are urgent in the digital era. This paper study how heterogeneous political actors within the EU form bridging social capital and linking social capital through political interaction, to deal with AI’s risks with a innovative, tentative and resilient governance framework. It has important implications for other governments’ policy innovation in the field of new technologies.
4.I will present the paper online.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Artificial intelligence (AI) is an innovation with significant potential to bring immense benefits to humanity, but it also poses considerable risks. A statement organized by the Center for AI Safety in May 2003 emphasized that mitigating the risk of AI-induced extinction should be a global priority, akin to addressing other societal-scale risks like pandemics and nuclear war. This declaration garnered support from over 500 prominent academics and industry leaders (The Time online, October 24th, 2023).
When queried about the primary social risks of its development, ChatGPT identified key concerns, including Job Displacement, Inequality, Bias and Discrimination, Privacy Concerns, Security Threats, Loss of Control, Social Isolation, Unemployment in Specific Sectors, and Lack of Accountability. Additionally, it underscored the importance of addressing these risks through a combination of ethical guidelines, regulations, and collaborative efforts involving policymakers, technologists, and society at large, as of January 28th, 2024.
One of the major challenges in regulating AI lies in the necessity for a global framework; without it, effectiveness is compromised. However, AI is a central arena for technological competition among global players, and these entities may resist measures that could hinder their innovative capabilities.
In response to these challenges, the Council requested a proposal from the Commission in 2019. The Commission, in February 2020, published a White Paper on the subject. By April 2021, the European Union Commission proposed the first regulation on AI within the Union. This proposal aims to establish a technology-neutral definition of AI systems in EU law and a classification system based on a 'risk-based approach' (EP, EU legislation in progress, June 2023). The suggested AI governance includes national and European-level authorities comprised of experts from member states. These authorities would be empowered to take corrective measures, including prohibition, restriction, withdrawal, or recall of AI systems not complying with the AI act or those presenting risks to health, safety, fundamental rights, or other public interests (Ibidem).
Since June 2020, the European Parliament established a Special Committee on Artificial Intelligence (AIDA), which conducted numerous studies, hearings, and sought expert advice. In May 2022, AIDA issued a Final Report. The European Parliament faces renewal in June 2024, raising uncertainties about the joint approval of AI regulation with the Council before that time.
This paper will narrate the story of this proposal, examining the underlying issues, the evidence considered, and the policy choices that could shape the approach to AI regulation at the European level. (Text corrected by ChatGTP)
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Governments around the world introduce reforms to improve the performance of public sector. Introduction of innovative practices and digitalization of services is another way these reforms are introduced in the public sector. Innovative e-governance strategies are adopted by the developed countries followed by the developing world. The literature suggests a shift from the traditional theoretical perspectives of Public Administration to the new Public Service Logic through value creation in the e-government practices. In this regard, this study is conducted to explore the reforms in the practices of Police services in Pakistan. Following a qualitative approach to unearth the shift from a typical police station to a model modern police Khidmat Markaz in Punjab province of Pakistan, this study is conducted by studying the case of Police Khidmat Markaz in Lahore. Semi structured interviews, content analysis of the online reviews, and participant observation were the data collection tools for this study. The results are based on the opinion of first-hand users and citizens which highlight the value creation and innovation introduced through the digitalization of services of Punjab Police. The study is explained through the lens of Public Service Logic Perspective in the developing countries.
Keywords: Public service logic, value creation, innovation, e-governance, Police
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Against the backdrop of the current digital era, the development of health big data is flourishing, bringing tremendous opportunities and challenges to China's healthcare industry. Therefore, it is particularly important to conduct in-depth analysis of the policy environment for the development of health big data in China and explore the trends and challenges of innovation policies in the digital age. The purpose of this study is to provide theoretical basis for decision-making and improvement in China's healthcare industry and provide guidance for the high-quality development of the health big data industry. This study adopts the method of text mining, primarily relying on official websites of government departments such as the National Health Commission of the People's Republic of China as the main source of information. By conducting keyword searches such as "health big data," "medical big data," and "healthcare big data," the study aims to analyze policy trends and grasp the government's guidance. In terms of policy text mining analysis, the RostCM6.0 and VOSviewer software were used to conduct in-depth mining and analysis of policy texts related to health big data in China, obtaining high-frequency vocabulary and constructing a high-frequency word network. In addition, the Policy-Making Cycle (PMC) index model was used for policy evaluation. Based on the existing model, this study constructed a PMC index model that suits the characteristics of health big data in China for the evaluation of relevant policies. Expert consultations were also conducted, including the Delphi method. Based on the high-frequency vocabulary obtained through text mining, a questionnaire was developed and Delphi expert consultations were conducted to evaluate the selection and scoring of indicators in the indicator system. The expert consultation evaluation of indicators was divided into two parts: quantitative scoring of indicators based on importance, obtainability, and sensitivity, and qualitative evaluation of the connotation and attributes of indicators. The research results show that China has a total of nine policies related to health big data, with an average PMC index value of 4.72. Among them, two policies performed well, while seven policies passed the evaluation. Overall, the quality of national-level health big data policies in China is good, but there is still room for improvement. In summary, China's management policies for health big data are generally sound, with clear nature and functions of the policies. This study focuses on specific analysis from three aspects: policy content, incentive constraints, and lifecycle, and provides improvement suggestions to address the trends and challenges faced by innovation policies in the digital age.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Rapid technological advances are driving public sector transformation worldwide through digital government initiatives prioritizing online service delivery, data-driven governance, and technological innovation. However, digital maturity varies substantially across regions influenced by economic, social, and policy environments. The Middle East and North Africa (MENA) context remains under-explored in existing literature that tends to focus on Western e-governance models, despite the region’s nascent yet accelerating adoption of emerging technologies. This study therefore analyzes the contemporary trends, persistent challenges, and potential solutions for digital government transformation specifically in the MENA region using mixed methods integrating computational analysis of regional e-governance databases with semi-structured expert elite interviews.
The technology-organization-environment (TOE) theoretical framework structures the investigation of technological, institutional, and contextual factors influencing the adoption and impacts of digital government. TOE provides a holistic lens encompassing barriers related to digital divides, data protection, algorithmic transparency, and participation. Meanwhile, the principles of value-sensitive design (VSD) guide the ethical policy recommendations centered on inclusion, justice, welfare, accountability, and human rights. Integrating both perspectives allows for examination of complex regional challenges alongside targeted, ethical solutions tailored to public sector contexts.
Trend analysis reveals steady adoption of e-government services and smart city technologies across MENA, with higher penetration rates in the Gulf countries. Yet utilization continues lagging among vulnerable demographic segments. Technological innovation has outpaced development of oversight mechanisms with minimal auditing of automated decision-systems and limited progress on open data policies restrictive data localization requirements persist in many countries.
The study reveals uneven digital government advancement influenced by wealth, education, and technological capacity differences at the regional and national levels. Gulf countries grapple more with emerging risks related data privacy, surveillance, and automation bias given their advanced technical infrastructure. Meanwhile non-Gulf countries continue struggling with basic digital divide challenges, skills shortages, and cybersecurity threats.
Findings suggest digital government transformation remains mostly government-centric and technology-driven without sufficient public consultation and participation in tech governance. Adoption of emerging technologies appears poorly aligned with social, ethical and value considerations for human rights, inclusion non-discrimination – as evident in the widening digital accessibility divide.
Recommendations include adopting human-centric design principles for citizen-centric e-services, enacting algorithmic transparency standards, boosting data literacy programs focusing on vulnerable groups, targeted capacity-building for non-Gulf countries through regional cooperation, developing comprehensive data protection legislation, embedding ethics in public procurement frameworks and establishing centers of excellence guiding evidence-based governance of emerging technologies.
By highlighting trends and barriers influenced by technological, institutional and contextual dimensions factors through an integrated TOE-VSD lens alongside actionable policy solutions, this study delivers both theoretical and practical value. It provides a novel perspective on the distinct opportunities and risks of digital government specifically in the MENA region for researchers and decisions-makers aiming to equitably leverage technology’s potential.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The theme of AI used in public security is one of the most discussed topics in the field of public policy studies nowadays. One of the reasons for that is the observed risks to democracy arising from its use, especially when carried out indiscriminately, without concerns for the right to privacy or the protection of personal data. The situation becomes even more critical when the algorithm is not auditable and, therefore, not subject to social control.
The goal of this article is to analyze the construction of public action instruments for the formulation of data-driven policies that exert control over the population through algorithmic governance. The initiatives related to public security implemented by the Brazilian federal government and the risks to democracy arising from their implementation will be examined.
The theoretical framework is based on Science and Technology Studies (STS) applied to digital and algorithmic governance, in addition to fundamental concepts that form the basis of critical studies in public policies. The studies conducted from this theoretical framework analyze not only institutionalized mechanisms but also informal political and micro-political practices. Also of importance is to analyze the mechanisms of constructing public action instruments mediated by technological-informational resources, such as algorithms. These instruments are consensually agreed upon and legitimized for the coordination of actors, groups, and institutions. To understand this context, it is also fundamental to consider the decolonizing AI theory that has been developed recently (CAVE; DIHAL, 2020).
The tensions and challenges posed to the contemporary democratic state are discussed, such as the implications of data-driven social policies in the political sphere and public management; government surveillance; human rights violations; and the reproduction of inequalities through public action instruments mediated by algorithms.
The research used primary and secondary data related to AI initiatives for public security in the Brazilian federal government until the year of 2023. Bibliographic research and document analysis were conducted to understand the political and sociotechnical mechanisms involved.
An algorithm was used to extract all documents mentioning the term "artificial intelligence" and related terms from the four main federal government websites (leg.br; jus.br; gov.br; mp.br). A total of 9,435 elements were found. Within this universe, we searched for terms associated with public security, reaching a total of 249 terms linked to federal government initiatives in the field of public security. In-depth analyses were then carried out within this universe of 249 terms to identify the public action instruments that are actually being implemented for subsequent evaluation of their implications.
It was observed that inequalities previously identified in AI-developed programs, especially regarding race and gender, continue to be reproduced by the governance mechanisms developed, especially in the field of public security and justice. The databases used to feed AI have embedded in them the mark of racial discriminations perpetuated by individuals and institutions. Other risks to democracy observed include the indiscriminate use of AI without concerns for privacy rights and the protection of personal data. The absence of auditable algorithms, susceptible to social control, raises additional concerns.
Bibliography
CALLON, M., LASCOUMES, P. & BARTHE, Y. (2001). Agir dans un monde incertain. Essai sur la démocratie technique, Paris: Seuil.
CAVE, S., & DIHAL, K. The Whiteness of AI. Philosophy and Technology, 2020. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13347-020-00415-6.
COLEMAN, Stephen; FREELON, Deen. Handbook of Digital Politics. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd, 2015.
MENDONÇA, R., ALMEIDA, V.; FILGUEIRAS, F. Algorithmic institutionalism: the changing rules of social and political life. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2023.
MOROZOV, E. Big Tech: A ascensão dos dados e a morte da política, 2018.
ZUBOFF, S. The Age of Surveillance Capitalism: The Fight for a Human Future at the New Frontier of Power. New York: Public Affairs, 2019.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Problem Statement
The potential of e-commerce to improve agriculture profits and farmers’ income has aroused the attention of the Chinese government. The National Rural E-Commerce Comprehensive Demonstration Project (RECD) has been put forward to promote e-commerce expansion in rural areas of China since 2014. The project is aimed to increase rural income levels and alleviate poverty. Although many studies suggest that promoting e-commerce increases rural households’ income and reduces poverty, other researchers are worried that the exacerbating digital gap may lead to worse income inequality. Whether and to what extent do government-led rural e-commerce expansion projects affect rural income inequality? What underlying mechanisms and complementary interventions are necessary for program implementation? The RECD in China provides a unique opportunity to estimate the impacts of a government-led large-scale e-commerce expansion policy on income inequality in the countryside of a developing country, which is essential for both academia and policymakers.
Conceptual Framework
According to the implementation guidelines for the RECD, we expect that the project may reduce rural household income inequality through the more prominent effects for rural households that initially have lower income levels. Possible channels: 1) by reducing the cost of logistics, transportation, and information search; 2) by providing e-commerce training for farmers to increase their e-commerce knowledge and skills; 3) by providing formal financial credit.
Data Sources
The database combines three sources: the China Family Panel Studies (CFPS) 2010-2022, the 2010 National Census data by county, and the 2013 China County Statistical Yearbook. Specifically, our micro household data are five rounds of follow-up CFPS data from 2010 to 2018 covering 162 counties in 25 provinces of China, of which 46 counties are RECD counties. The baseline survey was conducted in 2010, and the target sample size was 16,000 households.
Estimation Strategy
First, we excluded the effect of other critical concurrent policies (the construction of the national-level E-commerce Demonstration Cities and the Information Technology into Villages project) launched after 2010. Then, we simulate the inequality index results of the RECD counties if they were not selected in the project and compare them with the real indexes of both RECD counties and ordinary counties to see whether the project affects income inequality. Second, we employ the DID method to examine the causal relationship between the project and the income inequality indexes. Third, we employ the Shapley value decomposition based on regression to calculate the distribution of the project on household income inequality and identify the key mechanism of the three channels mentioned above.
Potential for Generating Discussion
Given that the overall scale of China’s e-commerce is the world’s largest, this paper can provide credible evidence of the effectiveness of an e-commerce promotion project implemented by a central government. Since many developing countries have also implemented policies to encourage the development of rural e-commerce growth, aiming to alleviate poverty and reduce inequality, what is the implication that the evidence from China provides for the development of e-commerce in developing countries? Can the experience be expanded?
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
National digital health platforms (also known as electronic health records (EHR)) are key enablers for health data interoperability at the national level. It enables hospitals and other facilities to engage in consent-based sharing of health data to improve patient experience as they navigate the care continuum. It is generally believed that improved access to health data can lead to innovations that can enhance the efficiency of care delivery and lead to better patient treatment outcomes. Currently, there is limited research exploring how national digital health platforms shape digital health innovation at a national level, especially in the context of Asia. The paper explores this question across five Asian countries including China, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore. The aim is to understand how national digital health platforms affect digital health innovation at a country level. The study is based on qualitative analysis of 38 interviews conducted across healthcare sector in the respective countries. The research fits well with the intent of the workshop since it analyses existing national initiatives to digitally transform healthcare which in turn has potentially positive effects for healthcare outcomes. Secondly, the paper aims to analyse the drivers and barriers of this process, which also includes the evolving data privacy and cybersecurity issues that governments have to constantly grapple with to enable innovation in the sector. And lastly, the paper also captures the role of regulations to better enable the translation of health data sharing to innovation which generally requires governments to carefully balance the need to protect data privacy with the need to encourage more innovation in the sector.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Digital transformation of public authority legislative spaces for policy and evidence systems in the Kenyan legislative outcomes.
Abstract
By
Japheth Ondiek and Gedion Onyango
Globally, digital transformation is rapidly transforming the operations and duties of public agencies, notably legislative bodies. Kenya, a country with a thriving democracy and a strong legislative system, is also undergoing significant changes in the way its legislative processes are carried out. As a concept, digital transformation refers to the incorporation of digital technologies into many sectors of governance and public administration.
Equally, in the current proliferation of digital forms of communication and involvement of digital means for citizen engagement across major platform, we explore the succinct transmissions of evidence supply, it utilization and it effect in the final decision making organ. It is not only important to look at the actors, their involvement, use of digital technologies, digital connectivity, digital skills, access to digital transmission of evidence but equally important is the perception of digital citizenship on supplied evidence affects the final policy decisions outcome. This research is exploring the process of research, evidence and policy decision through electronic transformations including understanding how actors’ supplies evidence to the relevant legislative institutions. Equally, in the current proliferation of digital forms of communication and involvement of digital means for citizen engagement across major platform, we explore the succinct transmissions of evidence supply, it utilization and it effect in the final decision making organ. It is not only important to look at the actors, their involvement, use of digital technologies, digital connectivity, digital skills, access to digital transmission of evidence but equally important is the perception of digital citizenship on supplied evidence affects the final policy decisions outcome.
This transition has an impact on legislative bodies because it improves efficiency, openness, and accountability. (McGetrick) 2017 conducted a major study that addresses global trends in digital transformation in legislative areas and highlights the possible benefits and challenges related to this change. The purpose of this study is to investigate and explore the potential benefits of digital transformation for Kenyan legislative spaces, policy and evidence systems, and legislative outcomes. Collectively, the study provides insights into the digital transformation of public authority legislative spaces for policy and evidence systems in Kenyan legislative results. The study will involve conducting interviews from legislatures, parliamentary drafters and researchers and the civil society networks to understand the eceosystem of digital transformation of evidence presentation in the Kenyan Parliament and derive further policy recommendations for the study.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This article undertakes a comprehensive inquiry into Citizen Identity Management in Bangladesh, with a specific focus on elucidating grassroots dynamics as discerned through an implemented piloting project. Set against the backdrop of Bangladesh's ambitious initiatives, encompassing the Bangladesh National Digital Architecture (BNDA) Framework, the Smart National Identification Card program, and the National Identity Registration Act 2023, the manuscript critically assesses the challenges and opportunities intrinsic to these endeavors. In light of the escalating trajectory towards digitalization, the article accentuates the paramount significance of secure and privacy-conscious management of citizen information. The overarching research question guiding this study centers on how the insights gleaned from the piloting project can contribute to a nuanced comprehension of Citizen Identity Management at the grassroots level in Bangladesh. The study's primary objective is to conduct a critical assessment of the challenges and opportunities embedded in Bangladesh's Citizen Identity Management initiatives, with a particular emphasis on the grassroots dynamics within the Union Parishad framework. Drawing upon insights derived from the piloting project, the aim is to furnish valuable perspectives for policymakers and practitioners engaged in the domains of digital governance and identity systems. The study advocates for a holistic and integrated approach to amplify service delivery and governance processes at the grassroots level in Bangladesh. This research contends, based on its findings, that the current identity management structure is excessively centralized for effective service delivery within the local context. Simultaneously, the study acknowledges the existing limitations within local government capacities to manage digital identities, especially in ensuring security. Despite this, the article posits that local government entities can play a pivotal role, asserting that decentralized identity management employing contemporary technologies can yield efficient outcomes. Consequently, the article advocates for an integrative approach, underscored by the strategic utilization of extant databases, the adoption of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs), and proactive citizen engagement.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The introduction of Artificial Intelligence (AI) at the government level presents a series of multifaceted challenges, covering technical, ethical, regulatory and cultural aspects, at the same time as a great opportunity to enhance the state's capacity to increase the quality of public services offered to the population.
The insertion of these new technologies in society leads to a dense debate on ethical and privacy issues, which is even greater when considering that their use by the government can deepen the use of discriminatory views and access to personal information. The need to ensure transparency, fairness and the protection of individual rights places additional demands on implementing ethical systems and complying with strict ethical standards.
Other issues such as regulatory aspects, the gap between technological evolution and legislation that can create legal uncertainties, internal cultural and institutional resistance are a critical factor. This impacts cybersecurity, which emerges as a pressing concern. The increased use of technologies and exposes AI systems to potential malicious attacks, highlighting the importance of robust security measures to protect sensitive data.
Despite the risks and difficulties, artificial intelligence is capable of increasing the efficiency, effectiveness and productivity of society. Examples of the use of AI in government present solutions for reducing queues and better application of public resources in government programs.
The innovative aspect that accompanies a specific part of artificial intelligence brings opportunities to the public sector, although the impact is uncertain. To explore the possibilities offered by AI, the alignment between the government's entrepreneurial capacity to promote through financing and credit, in addition to the provision of technical resources and the private entrepreneurial spirit are important.
The impact of introducing new technologies in government is not only aimed at increasing the state's capacity to deliver value to society, but also guarantees the promotion of the creation of new markets that can bring practical applications to private clients.
This article offers the opportunity to deepen the debate on the need for an entrepreneurial State to introduce new technologies, focusing on the challenges of using AI within the government agenda. To achieve this, an empirical approach to the Brazilian government will be used, with an approach to using open innovation to connect private innovative entrepreneurship and the State to solve public problems with AI.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper aims to contribute to the debate on the appropriation and use of data by civil society, analyzing the intersections between the right to the city and digital justice. With the development of forms of popular participation and accountability, largely due to better access to public data, the question of data’s appropriation and navigation becomes crucial for popular initiatives. Popular movements, based on new notions of diversity, then seek to act in the communicative sphere to create narratives based on the reappropriation of data.
In the city of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, the context of urban conflicts and violence entered a new phase after the major events (Olympic Games and World Cup, between 2014 and 2016), aggravated by the conservative social and economic policies of local and national governments in the last 8 years. However, we have also observed an important movement in the production or appropriation of data within local communities, with the aim of providing new evidence for public policies and promoting citizen action. In this sense, the objective of the project in which this proposal is inserted is to understand new perspectives and tools forged by popular action for overcoming the current urban crisis, transforming territories of war (brought by the UPPs* as imposed and now bankrupt territories of peace), into communicative and productive territories.
Demands for urban justice have been updated with the popular use and appropriation of data, which become a new arena of dispute in the construction of a more just city. In this sense, we will present a mapping of civic and popular initiatives developed in the city of Rio de Janeiro that aim to generate data to improve urban justice. Based on this mapping, we will present two specific cases: data_labe, linked to the Observatório das Favelas, which calls itself a "data and narrative laboratory" in Favela da Maré, bringing together residents of popular territories. The project disseminates data on studies of issues such as basic sanitation and security, and offers training in data analysis. The second case refers to the Instituto data favela, an initiative that aims to collect data on favelas in Rio de Janeiro and propose indicators to the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE).
We will show that these cases allow us to rethink public policies in three aspects: 1) they intend not only to monitor but also to produce new logics of public policies, based on the direct participation of citizens in the production of data; 2) they contribute to rethinking imaginaries of segregated territories through the reappropriation of data, building new narratives of these territories; 3) they contribute to reactivate local solidarities and expand the possibilities of urban common goods.
*UPPs were a result of a security policy established during the big events, adopting a “pacifying” police that was installed in popular areas in Brazil. They ended short after the big events.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Various local communities throughout Mexico have experienced the pervasive influence of narco-violence and machismo under criminal governance, which has left an indelible, negative impact on numerous families. Facing threats from the prevalence of narco-violence and at times the lack of official security services, women in various states in Mexico have initiated and participated in organizations to find their missing families and friends. The most recent case is a march in August 2023 by a group of women commemorating the International Day of Victims of Forced Disappearances. A poignant but evoking question arises: how do civilian women strategically navigate their non-violent social movements in response to the harrowing phenomenon of family disappearances in the context of narco-violence?
This paper analyzes civilian women’s strategic use of social media for their activism from the case of the “Madres Buscadoras (Searching Mothers)” in the metropolitan areas of Mexico, in the 2020s. Referring to the theory of civilian women’s agency in armed conflicts, particularly under narco-violence, we argue that these civilian women strategically utilize social media platforms to secure their safety and promote their movements through trans-local networks. We conduct 20 semi-structured interviews with activists and residents in anonymous cities and municipalities as well as online research on social media, including Facebook and Twitter. Through qualitative analyses of these sources, we demonstrate that these women use social media to inform families and the public of real situations not covered by traditional media and to organize trans-local networks for mutual support. Specifically, the activists utilize social media as a database where the organization and families mutually share information collected by themselves; families share photographs and information about their missing relatives, while the organization publishes those about individuals found in their searches. They also share information published by different state governmental institutions such as Comision de Busqueda de Personas (Person Search Commission). Their efforts extend to organizing search groups in perilous areas and raising public awareness through social media campaigns.
This research theoretically and empirically expands the literature on civilian women’s participation in non-violent social movements under narco-violence with a focus on their agency and multifaceted strategies. Previous studies examined the motivations and strategies of women’s activism for missing families in Latin America by focusing on womanhood and motherhood. However, there has been little attention to the utilization of social media in their networked movements. Filling the gaps in research, we examine women’s strategies to fight against narco-violence by examining their trans-local network through online social media. Our findings encapsulate the complex convergence of gender, activism, and the socio-political conditions shaped by narco-violence. Furthermore, this research brings new empirical findings by collecting original qualitative data that has been relatively less investigated.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
As technology continues to revolutionize the healthcare system, it presents new challenges to health technology governance. This paper explores the intersection of innovation policy, smart and connected health (SCH) technologies, and the importance of fostering health equity within this eHealth ecosystem. SCH has shown promising potential to improve health outcomes by managing chronic conditions, accessing real-time health information, accelerating treatment and testing procedures, and delivering remote health services to marginalized communities in resource-constrained settings. From mission- and system-oriented perspectives, technical and human resources play a significant part in developing SCH technologies during the early stages of the innovation process. As SCH becomes increasingly essential to healthcare organizations and medically underserved communities, individuals in leadership roles and digital health developers need to recognize and understand how digital determinants and design processes could impact health equity. For instance, the availability and accessibility to digital technologies and their related health services could create a “digital divide” that may affect health outcomes and contribute to further health inequality at the population level. Therefore, we must carefully consider the challenges that digital technologies present and ensure that we are not inadvertently exacerbating existing health disparities. To address health equity within SCH system, we need to recognize the issues with transaction costs (TC), which are an integral part of the development and implementation of digital health technologies in health services organizations. Some of the issues and challenges associated with TC in this context include complex integration into existing healthcare systems, engagement with multiple stakeholders and service providers, regulatory compliance, investment in training programs, data privacy and ownership, and risk and uncertainty. Using the framework of Transaction Costs Economics (TCE) grounded in neo-institutionalism, this paper applies TCE fundamental constructs and implicit assumptions to analyze digitally-mediated TC and the complexities of implementation. A narrative case study is presented to provide some understanding of practical challenges and opportunities in optimizing health equity within the SCH ecosystem. This study will offer strategic approaches to navigating the intricate landscape of eHealth and leveraging digital health solutions effectively to deliver health services while ensuring equitable access, quality, and safety for users.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)