CATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
This panel is oriented to increase our understanding regarding the role of parliaments as policy-making institutions covering a wide spectrum of legislative activities. Parliaments have been for long conceptualized as irrelevant institutions, tasked with approving policies negotiated elsewhere (Olson 1994, Kreppel 2014, Andersen and Burns, 1996; Russell and Cowley 2015). The executive is considered to control the agenda and the policy making process, and the opposition parliamentary groups are depicted as being passive and permissive, leading to high levels of parliamentary consensus. This literature has mainly conceptualized parliamentary groups as a unitary actor (focusing on the government vs opposition dichotomy) and relied on the analysis of formal rules and structures to draw conclusions and to develop opposition typologies (e.g. Sartori, 1966, Dahl 1966; Oberreuter, 1975; Blondel, 1997; Gelman, 2005; Kaiser, 2008, 2009, Norton 2008).
The study of parliamentary opposition is also connected to the broader analysis of the strength and weakness of legislatures. Also conceived as unitary actors, the literature has explored the role of legislatures regarding two main questions (e.g. Mezey 1970, 1979; Polsby 1975; Olson and Norton 1996; Morgenstern 1998; Laver 1999). First, legislatures’ capacity: potential for action (what parliaments can do) based on the analysis of the opportunity structure defined by constitutional rules and internal organization and procedures. Second, legislatures’ efficiency: actual performance (what parliaments do) based on the analysis of parliaments bill’s production. From this literature, a number of typologies of legislatures have emerged, for example “transformative” or “talking” legislatures (Polsby 1975), “reactive” legislatures (Mezey, 1979), “policy-making” or “policy-influencing” legislatures (Baldwin 2004).
However, the picture of weak legislatures and oppositions has been challenged by recent literature signaling that both government success and opposition failure might have been overstated (e.g. Russel et al 2017; Cowley 2016). On the one hand, the euro crisis and the rise of new radical parties ended the consensual politics that characterized the legislative process in most European parliaments (DeGiorgi and Ilonszky 2018). On the other hand, conclusions on executive preponderance have relied disproportionately on the study of visible influence, with a focus on early or late stages of the policy-making process: the success rate of bills or the final vote on legislation (Russell and Cowley, 2016). In other words, the capacity of parliamentary groups to influence policy making along the legislative process is a question largely ignored by existing research.
Many stages of the parliamentary process allow legislators to participate in policy making. The amendatory process is one where research is in its infancy. Defined as the “black hole” of the legislative process (Capano and Vignati 2008:35) we know very little regarding legislators’ incentives for introducing amendments, and also regarding their capacity for having these amendments passed (see Damgaard and Jensen 2006; Shepard and Carney 2005; Griffith 1994; Russel and Cowley 2016; Russel et al. 2016). Amendments are examined and discussed in parliamentary committees oriented, among other aspects, to provide expert evaluation regarding the pros and cons associated to different policy-making alternatives. Recent research show that legislators respond to variations in both governmental factors and bargaining dynamics. Palau et al (2023) have demonstrated, for instance, that amending activity reacts to attention allocation dynamics – mediatised bills receive more amendments. But still, we need more research to understand better when and why amendments are policymaking tools or if there are other political and contextual variables that explain which amendments are more successful than others.
In addition to considering the legislative activity of parliamentary groups, one of the objectives of this panel is to better understand their interaction with civil society, more specifically with interest groups that interact with parliamentarians throughout the legislative process through formal and informal channels (Lisi and Muñoz, 2019). Conventional wisdom is that core compromises with interest organizations on legislation are negotiated during the pre-parliamentary phase. Nonetheless, parliaments and parliamentary groups are not isolated from the interaction with extra parliamentary actors, such as interest groups. Ideally, parliamentary groups should not be responsive to interest groups, as they serve the interests of the majority of citizens and not of specific organized interests (Lohmann 1993). Yet, research on interest groups highlights that they work as transmission belts of citizens' concerns (Albareda and Braun, 2018). They provide policy makers useful policy information and simultaneously aggregate and represent diverse constituency interests (Berkhout et al., 2017a; Kohler-Koch and Quittkat, 2013).
However, scarce research has been done, on this topic. We know that interest groups are invited to parliamentary hearings to highlight governmental failures during minority governments and to legitimize highly conflictive issues during majority governments (Chaqués and Muñoz, 2016). This means parliamentary groups and interest groups follow a partisan and contingent logic though constrained by formal institutional rules. Also we know, that hey provide policy makers useful policy information and simultaneously aggregate and represent diverse constituency interests (Berkhout et al., 2017a; Kohler-Koch and Quittkat, 2013).
There is some evidence that interest groups policy advising and thus transfer information -both in the pre-parliamentary stage and during the legislative procedure- is mainly driven by few interest groups that concentrate most of the interaction with government and parliamentary committees. This is specially the case of NGOs, while hundreds of them are part of governmental advisory bodies and hearings in parliament, only few are invited more than once (Muñoz and Orué, 2021). However, there are still a number of unanswered questions: what types of groups interact most with parliamentary groups? What does this interaction depend on - media issues (media attention paid to laws discussed in parliament), the power that interest groups have in particular sectors, the type of government? To what extent are the testimonies of interest groups during hearings taken into account when laws are amended? In sum, the interest on the functioning of parliamentary committees has increased but we still have little empirical information regarding their actual role as policymaking institutions. In sum, the interest on the functioning of parliamentary committees has increased but we still have little empirical information regarding their actual role as policymaking institutions. This panel seeks to answer such questions by focusing on the behaviour of parliamentary groups and their legislative activity, as well as their interaction with interest groups.
CALL FOR PAPERS
In an attempt to shed new light on the role of parliaments as policy-making institutions, this panel welcomes papers oriented to explore any of the following aspects. First, the role of parliaments along the legislative process, including analysis oriented to explain legislators’ motivations for proposing new legislation, legislative amendments on executive bills, and/or the likelihood of these amendments to be incorporated into the final text of laws. Second, we are interested on papers analysing under what circumstances legislative committees are capable of creating independent knowledge on policy problems and the role of internal or external resources in the process. Of special interests is the analysis of the participation of interest groups, public officials or authorities in the process. The goal is to explore committee’s motivation for inviting different types of actors but also their actual contribution, namely, what particular information they provide to policy makers, on the basis of what arguments and with what consequences. Methodologically, the panel welcomes all types of qualitative and quantitative research on case studies, comparative research across countries and/or different territorial levels (including the European parliament, national or regional parliaments). Theoretically, we are open to conceptual frameworks oriented to explore causality taking into consideration the macro level (such as the characteristics of bills, the type of government, coalition agreements, committee structure, the impact of the electoral cycle or the politicization of issues), but also the micro level (actors’ gender, preferences and resources, including past parliamentary experience, specialization and/or expertise).
ABSTRACT
This panel is oriented to increase our understanding regarding the role of parliaments as policy-making institutions, covering a wide spectrum of legislative activities. The general question addressed in this panel, will be under what circumstances parliaments are capable of creating independent knowledge on policy problems and the role of internal or external resources in the process. In an attempt to shed new light on the role of parliaments in the design and analysis of public policies, this panel welcomes papers oriented to explore any of the following aspects. First, papers oriented to explain legislators’ motivations for proposing new legislation, legislative amendments on executive bills and/or the likelihood of these amendments to be incorporated into the final text of laws. The panel welcomes also papers oriented to explore the role of parliamentary committees, regarding the discussion of amendments along the legislative process but also more generally, concerning their functioning and influence. Of special interests is the analysis of the participation of interest groups, public officials or authorities along the legislative process. Methodologically, the panel welcomes all types of qualitative and quantitative research on case studies, comparative research across countries and/or different territorial levels (including the European parliament, national or regional parliaments).
BIOGRAPHICAL PRESENTATION
Luz Muñoz
Associate Professor of Political Science at the University of Barcelona. She has been researcher also at the University of Washington (USA, in 2009 and later in 2017) and the University of Newcastle (UK, 2013). Her research focuses on interest groups politics, advocacy and legal mobilization. She also is interested on legislative studies and courts. She is member of the research group “Quality of Democracy” (www.Q-dem.com), aimed to analyse the role of institution, the policy process and interest groups in democratic countries. Together with Q-dem members, she has developed the construction of several databases on interest groups access to the governmental and the parliamentary arena, as well as datasets on legislative activities such as bills, voting and amendments. Within this line of research, she has paid specially attention to the study of NGOs as policy actors, going beyond the analysis of their access to parliament and government to analyse their mobilisation in the courts. Her research has been published in the Journal of Public Policy, Representation, West European Politics, Voluntas The Journal of Nonprofit Sector, The Journal of Legislative Studies and Interest Groups and Advocacy, among others.
Anna Palau
Serra Húnter Associate Professor at the University of Barcelona (Department of Political Science). She conducted post-graduate studies at the University of Essex (UK) where she got an MA in Politics (with distinction) and received her PhD from the University of Barcelona. She has been researcher also at the University of Washington (USA) and Sciences Po (Bordeaux). Her research focuses on the analysis of parliamentary behavior and public policy, with a focus on agenda setting dynamics. She is author of two books, Agenda Dynamics in Spain (with Laura Chaqués & Frank Baumgartner) and Cataluña en Europa: Límites y Oportunidades del Proceso de Integración. She has also published a number of articles in national and international journals, among others European Union Politics, Parliamentary Affairs, Legislative Studies, Journalism Studies, Comparative Political Studies, West European Politics, Representation or Journal of Legislative Studies.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The focus of this study is the innovative practices in legislation in the fight against corruption in Kenya. The overarching problem in this study is the realization that despite enacting several anti-corruption laws, the vice of corruption is still prevalent. Corruption is presumably as old as organized society, at least as old as the time when organized society first established public institutions for its preservation and development. The study demonstrates that while the Government has pursued anti-corruption programs since the mid-1990s, the malpractice has persisted and, in some cases, intensified, suggesting that the remedial measures have not been significantly effective. The general objective of the study is to investigate the innovative practices in legislation in the fight against corruption. It also examines the relevance of the national and county assemblies in the fight against corruption. Hence, this study explores other anti-corruption methods and strategies outside the law to change the prevalent cultures and beliefs through public education and awareness campaigns on the dangers of corruption. A series of measures, including transparency in the funding of political parties and election campaigns, a code of conduct, and scrutiny of the sources of income and possible conflicts of interest of the legislature. The study uses a longitudinal research design with the target population being legislative officers. Primary data was collected through interviews and secondary data was collected from the national and county assemblies' library. Data collected was analyzed using Statistical Package for the Social Sciences for multiple regression analysis. Findings from the study interpreted the extent of the relationship among the variables. The study makes recommendations for more effective future legal and policy initiatives to entrench honesty and integrity in the Kenyan public service through the legislative arm of the Government. The paper concludes with some recommendations for addressing the issues raised in the research. KEYWORDS: Corruption, legislative, oversight, fight, Innovative.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the last decade, Parliament in Brazil took advantage of several political crisis and took over a major part of the public federal budget. The resources defined by the deputys and senators in the Annual Budget Law reached a level never seen in history. How this movement interfered in planning and executing public policies? What to expect in years to go? This article aim to offer some insights to investigate If Parliament is really driving public policies in Brazil and to explore chalenges involving Legislative and Executive Branches in promoting better policy-making.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The capacity of legislatures to review the budget law is an essential part of the democratic process. However, their involvement rises efficiency concerns as well as criticisms based on legislators’ short-term goals or tendency to favor specific constituencies based on electoral considerations. In this vein, in multilevel democracies like Spain, it is particularly interesting to explore to what extent parties’ preferences regarding the allocation of resources responds to the interest of specific territories. This paper explores this question based on the analysis of amendments proposed to budget bills. We could expect that regionalist parties propose amendments to influence budget sections that touch the interests of their regions to maximize what their territories get from the state-budget. However, statewide parties might also have interests for maximizing budget allocations to specific constituencies. Are regionalist parties the only proposing disproportionate budget allocation to specific territories? The paper explores also to what extent parties’ preferences on budget distribution has been influenced by the unprecedented politicization of the territorial question occurred in Spain during the last decade. The analysis relies on a new and comprehensive database including all the amendments proposed by legislators to the budget law in eleven legislatures.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper analyses the impact of the Abstract Review (Recurso de Inconstitucionalidad for the Spanish case) mechanism on the legislative process. The objective is to investigate the extent to which Abstract Review contributes to moderating the government's policy positions and under what circumstances. Theoretical models posit that much of the effect of having a constitutional court is anticipatory. However, less has been said from an empirical standpoint. This paper contributes to the literature by empirically analysing the so called autolimitation behaviour (modification of the legislative texts driven by the fear of being overturned). Using data on legislative amendments and policy shifts, I gauge the influence of the court's ideology on the government's policy modifications within the Spanish context. I also analyse the influence of the relevance of the issue and the electoral cycle on the government autolimitation . The results indicate that the government has strong incentives to avoid being overturned, regardless of the issue's relevance. They also appear to be influenced by the electoral cycle, leading them to accommodate opposition demands. Ultimately, this research adds to the debate on the role that constitutional courts play as checks and balances within a democracy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Previous research showed that business groups have fewer incentives to embrace outside lobbying in trade policy. We put forward an alternative explanation. Business lobbies are more likely to: approach journalists, participate in interviews, social media, press releases and op-eds when policymakers are not responsible to them, and their long-term interests embedded in a model of trade are potentially threatened. We test our argument with the case of Chile and the gridlock around the CPTPP ratification process. Our results support the hypothesis but the effect is conditional to salience.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Elections provide an important opportunity to advance democratization and political liberalization. However, there’s no concrete model or theory relating to holding of free fair and credible election. The literature and scholarly views such as; the rational choice and public choice theory however, have been mentioned for theoretical and conceptual classification to analyze voting behavior. Public choice economists make the same assumption—that although people acting in the political market place have some concern for others, their main motive, whether they are voters, politicians, lobbyists, or bureaucrats’ was self-interest.
A country cannot be truly democratic until its citizens have the opportunity to choose their representatives through elections that are free and fair. This is certain civil liberties, such as the freedoms of speech, association and assembly, are required. Electoral processes offer political parties and civic groups an opportunity to mobilize and organize supporters and share alternative platforms with the public. Elections also serve to encourage political debate and public dialogue.
Codes of Conduct can contribute to fairness and to the appearance of fairness in the administration of an election. Codes supplement rules, 'light touch regulatory styles that do not stress commands. The provisions of any code will necessarily depend upon the particular political and social context, and on the needs that must be met; in general, however, a code's content will be determined by reference to whether it furthers an acceptable result in terms of the criteria for free and fair elections. Election Code of Conduct viewed as a tool which contributes to freedom and fairness; to effective choice; to a representative and credible process; to transparency and accountability; to inclusive practices; to reducing adversarial relationships; and to the emergence and consolidation of a democratic political culture. Code of Conduct will promote rule of law, political parties and funding, fair campaign activities, responsible press and media, administration of election poll, rule of domestic and international observers, and system for dispute resolution. This will include consultation and discussion across party lines, in the interests of a 'good' election, but also more generally in promoting confidence among the participants and expectations within the electorates.
The research will employ a mixed-methods approach, combining both quantitative and qualitative data collection and analysis methods. This will involve the use of surveys, interviews, and documentary analysis to gather relevant data. A stratified random sampling technique will be used to ensure representation from various demographic groups and geographical regions within the selected country. Quantitative data will be analyzed using statistical methods to identify patterns and trends in voter behavior and perceptions. Qualitative data will be thematically analyzed to extract key themes and insights from the interviews. The research will adhere to ethical principles, including informed consent, confidentiality, and the responsible handling of sensitive data. To ensure the validity and reliability of the findings, triangulation of data from multiple sources and member checking will be employed to verify the accuracy of the interpretations.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Studies that seek to understand the process of public policy formulation have minimized the role of the legislative branch, and have instead concentrated on studying the relationships that the executive branch has with various interest groups. According to the theory of public choice (Stiglitz & Rosengard, 2015) and interest groups (Chaqués, 2020), it is argued that the latter influence the legislative process in at least three ways: 1) they incentivize public support in favor of a legislator; 2) provide information to the legislator regarding voters' preferences; and 3) directly or indirectly bribe legislators. Likewise, ignorance of these mechanisms has serious consequences, such as the fact that legislators respond to a greater extent to interest groups than the general population, as well as an ineffectiveness in the potential of public policies that can be derived from the different legislative products. This article seeks to contribute to the understanding of the role of the legislative branch in the policy-making process, by answering: what type of interest groups influence the legislative process with the potential for policy creation or modification? It is based on the hypothesis that the legislative branch favors interest groups by blocking laws that can promote the implementation of policies adverse to their interests, as well as that legislators promote laws that favor various groups. To this end, a case study approach is used, in which the Congress of Jalisco is analyzed for the five school years from 2018 to 2023, consisting of the documentary review of the explanatory memorandum of the main legislative initiatives and reforms submitted to the plenary, as well as the creation or modifications of policies based on these initiatives published in the “Periódico Oficial del Estado de Jalisco” [Official Newspaper of the State of Jalisco].
References
Chaqués, L. (2020). Interest groups and political representation. In M. Cotta, & F. Russo, Research Hanbook on Political Representation. Edward Elg.
Stiglitz, J. E., & Rosengard, J. K. (2015). La economía del sector público (4th ed.). Published by Antoni Bosch, editor.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
To what extent do interest groups align with partisan policy positions in legislative decisions? Research on interest-group lobbying has mixed evidence on the effect of interest group lobbying on legislative party polarization. This paper contributes to this debate by analysing the policy positions of interest groups and the degree to which these align with party positions. Computational text analysis is used to measure semantic similarity between interest groups and parties based on an original dataset on hearings in the Spanish parliament from the 1990s to the present day. This analytical approach offers a nuanced perspective that supplements extant evidence derived from lobbying reports, campaign contributions, and roll-call voting, while also facilitating a longitudinal analysis. Evidence from the changeover of the Spanish political system after a long period of imperfect bipartisanship shows how the type of interest groups and the timing of their interventions are relevant in explaining party-group alignments and their contextual determinants. Insights from the dynamics between interest groups and parties in the legislative process are relevant in the study of pluralism and interest representation and their role in societal transformation.
Keywords: Interest groups, Parliament, Political pluralism, Natural Language Processing, Computational text analysis
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The pursuit of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development requires active engagement from diverse stakeholders beyond government entities. Parliaments are recognized as pivotal contributors to the agenda, with their traditional functions, including legislation, oversight, budget approval, and representation, emphasized. The COVID-19 crisis in 2020 globally disrupted sustainable development efforts, prompting a critical examination of economic systems and crisis management mechanisms. The pandemic raised questions about the equitable provision of public services, the roles of governments, parliaments, and municipalities during crises, and the maintenance of democratic governance and citizen rights. Responses to the crisis required a reevaluation of risk management strategies beyond government. Parliamentarians played a crucial role, in ensuring policies aligned with pandemic containment, addressing economic and social impacts, and safeguarding the interests of constituents, especially vulnerable groups. Their responsibility in overseeing executive authority and scrutinizing public fund utilization is vital in upholding democratic values during crises, legislating as needed, and preserving citizens' rights.
This paper proposes focusing on the actions of parliaments in the Arab region during the COVID-19 crisis, aiming to illuminate strengths, good practices, gaps, and challenges. The paper shall include an overview of the economic, social, and health consequences in the region, addressing parliament's continued functionality, flexibility in adapting to quarantine measures, and information acquisition methods. Examining the four parliamentary functions, the paper proposes to analyze the cases of Egypt, Tunisia, Lebanon, Morocco, and Iraq, highlighting diverse responses to the crisis while maintaining legislative activities.
The paper seeks to answer these questions, Did Arab parliaments effectively fulfill their representative functions amid the COVID-19 crisis, and is there a correlation between this performance and the degree of openness or closure of the public sphere? To what extent can the implementation of the separation of powers, exemplified by the distinct delineation of legislative and executive powers, contribute to an improved crisis response? Furthermore, did parliaments play a significant role in prioritizing the interests of citizens and in achieving equal rights to health for all, or did their involvement remain limited in scope? Additionally, how did the interaction between parliaments and local authorities manifest during the crisis, and what role did parliamentary representatives play within municipalities in addressing the challenges posed by the pandemic?
The research paper will adopt a qualitative methodology, leveraging an approach that is rooted in a comprehensive literature review and extensive desk research. This methodology entails a meticulous examination and synthesis of existing scholarly works and relevant literature to form a robust foundation for the research. The desk research component involves a thorough analysis of various sources, including academic journals, books, and other authoritative publications, to gather in-depth insights and information about the subject matter.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since the 1990’s, Brazilian policy on land regularization of urban and rural informal settlements has involved the so-called “full regularization approach” which treated the policy as a bundle of rights, especially for low-income families. Thus, according to this approach, a land regularization policy would include different elements besides the guarantee of the legal tenancy of the land, such as the access to public services and improvement on housing and local infrastructure, alongside with intervention seeking the integration between these settlements and the environment on its surroundings. However, in December 2016, the then-president Michel Temer published Provisional Measure 759, significantly changing the land regularization policy approach, primarily emphasizing the provision of individual private property titles to residents of informal settlements. The Measure also proposed allowing the conversion of State property into private property, and to make it easier to regularize settlements in environmentally protected areas, including in the Amazon rainforest region. These possibilities were extended to medium and high-income settlements, raising questions from political parties opposing the Temer government, who viewed the Measure as part of a series of actions promoting a neoliberal agenda in Brazil. Following its publication, the Measure was sent to the Congress, becoming a bill that ultimately gave origin to the Federal Law 13.465/2017. The literature on urban policy is overall focused on the impacts of this law on the Brazilian land regularization policy’s design and implementation. Yet, little has been investigated about the discussions that made it be approved, the interest groups that took part on it and their roles on the final outcome. Thus, this paper addresses the following research question: how was the involvement of interest groups in the parliamentary discussion on the Provisional Measure 759 in Brazil? In order to answer this question, we examined what groups took part in parliamentary discussions aligned with the government and what groups did so aligned with the opposition. Additionally, we analyzed the arguments that interest groups on both sides mobilized to defend their positions. Qualitative data was collected from the stenographic and video records from the Brazilian Chamber of Deputies discussions tagged as referring to the Provisional Measure 759/2016. Complementary data was gathered from social media, particularly X/Twitter and Facebook, by the search of content published during the first semester of 2017, when the bill was under parliamentary discussion, containing keywords associated with the Measure 759/2016. Preliminary results show that, while groups associated with large rural landowners and urban real-estate developers were aligned with the government, environmentalist and worker organizations were aligned with the opposition. While the first interest group argued that the Measure promoted economic and social development by streamlining land regularization processes, the second group argued that the Measure would facilitate urban gentrification and authorize illegal land occupation in the Amazon. Although backed up by academic institutions, the opposition interest groups seemed to have little impact on the final outcome.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The proposed paper develops the theoretical framework and research design for studying co-sponsorship
networks in authoritarian legislatures. There are still gaps in understanding MP's cooperation in an
authoritarian context. Although co-sponsorship network analysis is widely implemented in research on parliaments in democracies.
Additionally, many scholars agree that parliaments in most authoritarian regimes do not play a decisive role in
politics. In recent years, however, there has been a growing interest in uncovering the role of parliaments in
authoritarian regimes. Despite their lesser role in representing public interests, legislative bodies may serve
authoritarian elites in several ways. Essentially, they legitimize autocratic policies and serve as normative
actions. Furthermore, the ongoing research projects in several authoritarian states reveal these legislatures' different impacts on policy processes despite the constraints imposed by authoritarian regimes.
The developed approach that includes both exploratory and inferential co-sponsorship network analysis showed that MPs in the Russian parliament may pursue their political strategies apart from being just the "soldiers of legitimation". Although the window of opportunity for policy development and lobbying is still not very big for them they collaborate with other MPs to obtain social capital, develop political careers, get access to rent, and at the same time follow the ideological principles of their parties and to some extent even play the role of representatives of the voters like in democratic settings. Nevertheless, the incentives of the MPs to have close ties with the voters are opaque in authoritarian settings. I use the game theoretic model where the strategies of the MPs are seen as networking actions. For instance, many MPs in the Russian parliament tend to increase their betweenness centrality (BC) and closeness centrality (CC). To succeed they co-sponsor the bills developed by those MPs who hold the administrative positions within parliament (leaders of factions, heads of committees, etc.). In this regard, I suggest two hypotheses:
(H1) MPs co-sponsor bills of the most central actors (with higher rates of BC and CC) to acquire political capital and then get positions in the executive branch of power.
(H2) MPs co-sponsor bills of the most central actors (with higher rates of BC and CC) to ensure reciprocal actions when they need support for their bills.
I focus on coordination games and bargaining, and strategies of ego-network formation and apply two types of models: (1) the Majority game, and (2) the Best-shot public goods game.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Is it important for ministers to maintain an intense public agenda? Studies on the profiles of cabinet members paid attention to the academic and social background of the ministers, as well as their partisan ties, to strengthen their leadership and position within the government. Even the technocratic and expert profile of the ministers who occupy the areas that manage economic and labor affairs is valued. However, in a changing world in which electoral volatility is increasing and fake news has become a real problem for Western democracies, it seems that governments need to explain themselves and connect with citizens to guarantee their political action.
Thus, this paper aims to examine the public profile of the Spanish government during the years 2020 and 2023, which corresponds to the coalition government between the socialist party and Unidas Podemos under the presidency of Pedro Sánchez. With an original database from government agendas, this paper examines interviews on television and radio, attendance at events organized by groups and entities, as well as meetings with interest groups, in addition to incorporating other data about the political and partisan career of each of the ministers. The objective is to know which ministries are most exposed to the media, which ministerial profiles (technocratic, expert, party leaders) maintain greater public activity, and which government areas need to communicate more actively with representatives of interest groups.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The focus of this study is the innovative practices in legislation in the fight against corruption in Kenya. The overarching problem in this study is the realization that despite enacting several anti-corruption laws, the vice of corruption is still prevalent. Corruption is presumably as old as organized society, at least as old as the time when organized society first established public institutions for its preservation and development. The study demonstrates that while the Government has pursued anti-corruption programs since the mid-1990s, the malpractice has persisted and, in some cases, intensified, suggesting that the remedial measures have not been significantly effective. The general objective of the study is to investigate the innovative practices in legislation in the fight against corruption. It also examines the relevance of the national and county assemblies in the fight against corruption. Hence, this study explores other anti-corruption methods and strategies outside the law to change the prevalent cultures and beliefs through public education and awareness campaigns on the dangers of corruption. A series of measures, including transparency in the funding of political parties and election campaigns, a code of conduct, and scrutiny of the sources of income and possible conflicts of interest of the legislature. The study uses a longitudinal research design with the target population being legislative officers. Primary data was collected through interviews and secondary data was collected from the national and county assemblies' library. Data collected was analyzed using Statistical Package for the Social Sciences for multiple regression analysis. Findings from the study interpreted the extent of the relationship among the variables. The study makes recommendations for more effective future legal and policy initiatives to entrench honesty and integrity in the Kenyan public service through the legislative arm of the Government. The paper concludes with some recommendations for addressing the issues raised in the research. KEYWORDS: Corruption, legislative, oversight, fight, Innovative.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the last decade, Parliament in Brazil took advantage of several political crisis and took over a major part of the public federal budget. The resources defined by the deputys and senators in the Annual Budget Law reached a level never seen in history. How this movement interfered in planning and executing public policies? What to expect in years to go? This article aim to offer some insights to investigate If Parliament is really driving public policies in Brazil and to explore chalenges involving Legislative and Executive Branches in promoting better policy-making.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The capacity of legislatures to review the budget law is an essential part of the democratic process. However, their involvement rises efficiency concerns as well as criticisms based on legislators’ short-term goals or tendency to favor specific constituencies based on electoral considerations. In this vein, in multilevel democracies like Spain, it is particularly interesting to explore to what extent parties’ preferences regarding the allocation of resources responds to the interest of specific territories. This paper explores this question based on the analysis of amendments proposed to budget bills. We could expect that regionalist parties propose amendments to influence budget sections that touch the interests of their regions to maximize what their territories get from the state-budget. However, statewide parties might also have interests for maximizing budget allocations to specific constituencies. Are regionalist parties the only proposing disproportionate budget allocation to specific territories? The paper explores also to what extent parties’ preferences on budget distribution has been influenced by the unprecedented politicization of the territorial question occurred in Spain during the last decade. The analysis relies on a new and comprehensive database including all the amendments proposed by legislators to the budget law in eleven legislatures.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper analyses the impact of the Abstract Review (Recurso de Inconstitucionalidad for the Spanish case) mechanism on the legislative process. The objective is to investigate the extent to which Abstract Review contributes to moderating the government's policy positions and under what circumstances. Theoretical models posit that much of the effect of having a constitutional court is anticipatory. However, less has been said from an empirical standpoint. This paper contributes to the literature by empirically analysing the so called autolimitation behaviour (modification of the legislative texts driven by the fear of being overturned). Using data on legislative amendments and policy shifts, I gauge the influence of the court's ideology on the government's policy modifications within the Spanish context. I also analyse the influence of the relevance of the issue and the electoral cycle on the government autolimitation . The results indicate that the government has strong incentives to avoid being overturned, regardless of the issue's relevance. They also appear to be influenced by the electoral cycle, leading them to accommodate opposition demands. Ultimately, this research adds to the debate on the role that constitutional courts play as checks and balances within a democracy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Previous research showed that business groups have fewer incentives to embrace outside lobbying in trade policy. We put forward an alternative explanation. Business lobbies are more likely to: approach journalists, participate in interviews, social media, press releases and op-eds when policymakers are not responsible to them, and their long-term interests embedded in a model of trade are potentially threatened. We test our argument with the case of Chile and the gridlock around the CPTPP ratification process. Our results support the hypothesis but the effect is conditional to salience.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Elections provide an important opportunity to advance democratization and political liberalization. However, there’s no concrete model or theory relating to holding of free fair and credible election. The literature and scholarly views such as; the rational choice and public choice theory however, have been mentioned for theoretical and conceptual classification to analyze voting behavior. Public choice economists make the same assumption—that although people acting in the political market place have some concern for others, their main motive, whether they are voters, politicians, lobbyists, or bureaucrats’ was self-interest.
A country cannot be truly democratic until its citizens have the opportunity to choose their representatives through elections that are free and fair. This is certain civil liberties, such as the freedoms of speech, association and assembly, are required. Electoral processes offer political parties and civic groups an opportunity to mobilize and organize supporters and share alternative platforms with the public. Elections also serve to encourage political debate and public dialogue.
Codes of Conduct can contribute to fairness and to the appearance of fairness in the administration of an election. Codes supplement rules, 'light touch regulatory styles that do not stress commands. The provisions of any code will necessarily depend upon the particular political and social context, and on the needs that must be met; in general, however, a code's content will be determined by reference to whether it furthers an acceptable result in terms of the criteria for free and fair elections. Election Code of Conduct viewed as a tool which contributes to freedom and fairness; to effective choice; to a representative and credible process; to transparency and accountability; to inclusive practices; to reducing adversarial relationships; and to the emergence and consolidation of a democratic political culture. Code of Conduct will promote rule of law, political parties and funding, fair campaign activities, responsible press and media, administration of election poll, rule of domestic and international observers, and system for dispute resolution. This will include consultation and discussion across party lines, in the interests of a 'good' election, but also more generally in promoting confidence among the participants and expectations within the electorates.
The research will employ a mixed-methods approach, combining both quantitative and qualitative data collection and analysis methods. This will involve the use of surveys, interviews, and documentary analysis to gather relevant data. A stratified random sampling technique will be used to ensure representation from various demographic groups and geographical regions within the selected country. Quantitative data will be analyzed using statistical methods to identify patterns and trends in voter behavior and perceptions. Qualitative data will be thematically analyzed to extract key themes and insights from the interviews. The research will adhere to ethical principles, including informed consent, confidentiality, and the responsible handling of sensitive data. To ensure the validity and reliability of the findings, triangulation of data from multiple sources and member checking will be employed to verify the accuracy of the interpretations.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Studies that seek to understand the process of public policy formulation have minimized the role of the legislative branch, and have instead concentrated on studying the relationships that the executive branch has with various interest groups. According to the theory of public choice (Stiglitz & Rosengard, 2015) and interest groups (Chaqués, 2020), it is argued that the latter influence the legislative process in at least three ways: 1) they incentivize public support in favor of a legislator; 2) provide information to the legislator regarding voters' preferences; and 3) directly or indirectly bribe legislators. Likewise, ignorance of these mechanisms has serious consequences, such as the fact that legislators respond to a greater extent to interest groups than the general population, as well as an ineffectiveness in the potential of public policies that can be derived from the different legislative products. This article seeks to contribute to the understanding of the role of the legislative branch in the policy-making process, by answering: what type of interest groups influence the legislative process with the potential for policy creation or modification? It is based on the hypothesis that the legislative branch favors interest groups by blocking laws that can promote the implementation of policies adverse to their interests, as well as that legislators promote laws that favor various groups. To this end, a case study approach is used, in which the Congress of Jalisco is analyzed for the five school years from 2018 to 2023, consisting of the documentary review of the explanatory memorandum of the main legislative initiatives and reforms submitted to the plenary, as well as the creation or modifications of policies based on these initiatives published in the “Periódico Oficial del Estado de Jalisco” [Official Newspaper of the State of Jalisco].
References
Chaqués, L. (2020). Interest groups and political representation. In M. Cotta, & F. Russo, Research Hanbook on Political Representation. Edward Elg.
Stiglitz, J. E., & Rosengard, J. K. (2015). La economía del sector público (4th ed.). Published by Antoni Bosch, editor.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
To what extent do interest groups align with partisan policy positions in legislative decisions? Research on interest-group lobbying has mixed evidence on the effect of interest group lobbying on legislative party polarization. This paper contributes to this debate by analysing the policy positions of interest groups and the degree to which these align with party positions. Computational text analysis is used to measure semantic similarity between interest groups and parties based on an original dataset on hearings in the Spanish parliament from the 1990s to the present day. This analytical approach offers a nuanced perspective that supplements extant evidence derived from lobbying reports, campaign contributions, and roll-call voting, while also facilitating a longitudinal analysis. Evidence from the changeover of the Spanish political system after a long period of imperfect bipartisanship shows how the type of interest groups and the timing of their interventions are relevant in explaining party-group alignments and their contextual determinants. Insights from the dynamics between interest groups and parties in the legislative process are relevant in the study of pluralism and interest representation and their role in societal transformation.
Keywords: Interest groups, Parliament, Political pluralism, Natural Language Processing, Computational text analysis
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The pursuit of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development requires active engagement from diverse stakeholders beyond government entities. Parliaments are recognized as pivotal contributors to the agenda, with their traditional functions, including legislation, oversight, budget approval, and representation, emphasized. The COVID-19 crisis in 2020 globally disrupted sustainable development efforts, prompting a critical examination of economic systems and crisis management mechanisms. The pandemic raised questions about the equitable provision of public services, the roles of governments, parliaments, and municipalities during crises, and the maintenance of democratic governance and citizen rights. Responses to the crisis required a reevaluation of risk management strategies beyond government. Parliamentarians played a crucial role, in ensuring policies aligned with pandemic containment, addressing economic and social impacts, and safeguarding the interests of constituents, especially vulnerable groups. Their responsibility in overseeing executive authority and scrutinizing public fund utilization is vital in upholding democratic values during crises, legislating as needed, and preserving citizens' rights.
This paper proposes focusing on the actions of parliaments in the Arab region during the COVID-19 crisis, aiming to illuminate strengths, good practices, gaps, and challenges. The paper shall include an overview of the economic, social, and health consequences in the region, addressing parliament's continued functionality, flexibility in adapting to quarantine measures, and information acquisition methods. Examining the four parliamentary functions, the paper proposes to analyze the cases of Egypt, Tunisia, Lebanon, Morocco, and Iraq, highlighting diverse responses to the crisis while maintaining legislative activities.
The paper seeks to answer these questions, Did Arab parliaments effectively fulfill their representative functions amid the COVID-19 crisis, and is there a correlation between this performance and the degree of openness or closure of the public sphere? To what extent can the implementation of the separation of powers, exemplified by the distinct delineation of legislative and executive powers, contribute to an improved crisis response? Furthermore, did parliaments play a significant role in prioritizing the interests of citizens and in achieving equal rights to health for all, or did their involvement remain limited in scope? Additionally, how did the interaction between parliaments and local authorities manifest during the crisis, and what role did parliamentary representatives play within municipalities in addressing the challenges posed by the pandemic?
The research paper will adopt a qualitative methodology, leveraging an approach that is rooted in a comprehensive literature review and extensive desk research. This methodology entails a meticulous examination and synthesis of existing scholarly works and relevant literature to form a robust foundation for the research. The desk research component involves a thorough analysis of various sources, including academic journals, books, and other authoritative publications, to gather in-depth insights and information about the subject matter.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since the 1990’s, Brazilian policy on land regularization of urban and rural informal settlements has involved the so-called “full regularization approach” which treated the policy as a bundle of rights, especially for low-income families. Thus, according to this approach, a land regularization policy would include different elements besides the guarantee of the legal tenancy of the land, such as the access to public services and improvement on housing and local infrastructure, alongside with intervention seeking the integration between these settlements and the environment on its surroundings. However, in December 2016, the then-president Michel Temer published Provisional Measure 759, significantly changing the land regularization policy approach, primarily emphasizing the provision of individual private property titles to residents of informal settlements. The Measure also proposed allowing the conversion of State property into private property, and to make it easier to regularize settlements in environmentally protected areas, including in the Amazon rainforest region. These possibilities were extended to medium and high-income settlements, raising questions from political parties opposing the Temer government, who viewed the Measure as part of a series of actions promoting a neoliberal agenda in Brazil. Following its publication, the Measure was sent to the Congress, becoming a bill that ultimately gave origin to the Federal Law 13.465/2017. The literature on urban policy is overall focused on the impacts of this law on the Brazilian land regularization policy’s design and implementation. Yet, little has been investigated about the discussions that made it be approved, the interest groups that took part on it and their roles on the final outcome. Thus, this paper addresses the following research question: how was the involvement of interest groups in the parliamentary discussion on the Provisional Measure 759 in Brazil? In order to answer this question, we examined what groups took part in parliamentary discussions aligned with the government and what groups did so aligned with the opposition. Additionally, we analyzed the arguments that interest groups on both sides mobilized to defend their positions. Qualitative data was collected from the stenographic and video records from the Brazilian Chamber of Deputies discussions tagged as referring to the Provisional Measure 759/2016. Complementary data was gathered from social media, particularly X/Twitter and Facebook, by the search of content published during the first semester of 2017, when the bill was under parliamentary discussion, containing keywords associated with the Measure 759/2016. Preliminary results show that, while groups associated with large rural landowners and urban real-estate developers were aligned with the government, environmentalist and worker organizations were aligned with the opposition. While the first interest group argued that the Measure promoted economic and social development by streamlining land regularization processes, the second group argued that the Measure would facilitate urban gentrification and authorize illegal land occupation in the Amazon. Although backed up by academic institutions, the opposition interest groups seemed to have little impact on the final outcome.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The proposed paper develops the theoretical framework and research design for studying co-sponsorship
networks in authoritarian legislatures. There are still gaps in understanding MP's cooperation in an
authoritarian context. Although co-sponsorship network analysis is widely implemented in research on parliaments in democracies.
Additionally, many scholars agree that parliaments in most authoritarian regimes do not play a decisive role in
politics. In recent years, however, there has been a growing interest in uncovering the role of parliaments in
authoritarian regimes. Despite their lesser role in representing public interests, legislative bodies may serve
authoritarian elites in several ways. Essentially, they legitimize autocratic policies and serve as normative
actions. Furthermore, the ongoing research projects in several authoritarian states reveal these legislatures' different impacts on policy processes despite the constraints imposed by authoritarian regimes.
The developed approach that includes both exploratory and inferential co-sponsorship network analysis showed that MPs in the Russian parliament may pursue their political strategies apart from being just the "soldiers of legitimation". Although the window of opportunity for policy development and lobbying is still not very big for them they collaborate with other MPs to obtain social capital, develop political careers, get access to rent, and at the same time follow the ideological principles of their parties and to some extent even play the role of representatives of the voters like in democratic settings. Nevertheless, the incentives of the MPs to have close ties with the voters are opaque in authoritarian settings. I use the game theoretic model where the strategies of the MPs are seen as networking actions. For instance, many MPs in the Russian parliament tend to increase their betweenness centrality (BC) and closeness centrality (CC). To succeed they co-sponsor the bills developed by those MPs who hold the administrative positions within parliament (leaders of factions, heads of committees, etc.). In this regard, I suggest two hypotheses:
(H1) MPs co-sponsor bills of the most central actors (with higher rates of BC and CC) to acquire political capital and then get positions in the executive branch of power.
(H2) MPs co-sponsor bills of the most central actors (with higher rates of BC and CC) to ensure reciprocal actions when they need support for their bills.
I focus on coordination games and bargaining, and strategies of ego-network formation and apply two types of models: (1) the Majority game, and (2) the Best-shot public goods game.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Is it important for ministers to maintain an intense public agenda? Studies on the profiles of cabinet members paid attention to the academic and social background of the ministers, as well as their partisan ties, to strengthen their leadership and position within the government. Even the technocratic and expert profile of the ministers who occupy the areas that manage economic and labor affairs is valued. However, in a changing world in which electoral volatility is increasing and fake news has become a real problem for Western democracies, it seems that governments need to explain themselves and connect with citizens to guarantee their political action.
Thus, this paper aims to examine the public profile of the Spanish government during the years 2020 and 2023, which corresponds to the coalition government between the socialist party and Unidas Podemos under the presidency of Pedro Sánchez. With an original database from government agendas, this paper examines interviews on television and radio, attendance at events organized by groups and entities, as well as meetings with interest groups, in addition to incorporating other data about the political and partisan career of each of the ministers. The objective is to know which ministries are most exposed to the media, which ministerial profiles (technocratic, expert, party leaders) maintain greater public activity, and which government areas need to communicate more actively with representatives of interest groups.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)