Format

W05. Policymaking from theory and practice: Latin American-driven debates.

Policy Process, Policy Making
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Norma Munoz del Campo
Chile
Main chair
Juan Guillermo Vieira Silva
Universidad EAFIT
Second chair
Melina de Souza Rocha Lukic
York University
Third chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
Policy Process, Policy Making
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

The field of public policy has experienced significant growth and has attracted considerable scholarly attention. Within this discipline, various theories have emerged with the aim of comprehensively understanding and elucidating the complex process of public decision-making. The analysis of this subject matter entails an examination of the social construct, necessitating a comprehension of its construction and the specific dynamics of the state-society relationship within a certain sector. Various methods of experiencing, observing, and researching the nature of reality give rise to diverse theoretical and methodological views aimed at providing explanations. The availability of diverse analytical techniques for examining public policies has contributed to the exploration of alternative paradigms and theoretical frameworks that address the wide-ranging elements encompassed within the policy process. These elements include individuals, institutions, ideas, discourses and narratives, governance, and levels of action. The discussed concepts have originated from the global north, and their applicability to other locations has demonstrated their limitations in analyzing divergent realities characterized by "hybrid cultures" (Canclini, 1987).

Latin American reality is characterized by a weak level of development in the discipline. This progress is hindered by several factors. Firstly, the historical heritage, the challenge posed by language barriers when engaging in multilevel debates. This language barrier also extends to the educational level, impeding access to recent studies, which are predominantly in English, as well as the cost associated with accessing a large number of publications. While this situation may have resulted in a dearth of theoretical underpinnings, analytical frameworks, concepts, and methodologies tailored to the Latin American context, it has nonetheless shaped a modus operandi characterized by a combination of diverse perspectives and the utilization of "distinct" public policy experiences that could contribute to discussions at the national, regional, and international levels.

In light of this scenario, it is crucial to acknowledge the significance of comprehending both the empirical knowledge that can be derived from specific cases within the region and the current situation of the development of the theories of policy process (Sabatier & Weible, 2014) in Latin America to understand how to advance and improve from these two dimensions.

From the theories of the policy process dimension,  this proposition aims to assess how we are using mainstream theories, what they bring to us, whether they need to be adjusted to the context. Second, from the critical and interpretative approaches, highlighting their differential contributions compared to mainstream approaches. Third, we want to highlight homegrown contributions, whether at the level of theories or concepts or key contextual factors for understanding the realities of the Region. We are particularly interested in how our own contributions dialogue with the approaches of the global North. Then the following questions are suggested: What characteristics distinguish policy analysis in the region? What is the current situation of policy process theory development? How are their comprehended and utilized? What concrete contributions have been made to the study of Latin American public policies?. Such insights can greatly contribute to the ongoing discourse around the examination of public policies and further enrich our comprehension of the prevailing theories pertaining to the policy process both at the regional and worldwide levels. 

From the empirical dimension, this panel seeks to promote a regional debate on public policy by highlighting the region's unique characteristics and contributions to policy-making. Thus, it encourages papers that discuss policy contributions to problem-solving with a specific case, such as cash transfers programs, participatory budget initiatives, bus rapid transit programs, metropolitan governance, infant industry development policies, and anti-corruption policies, among others. Additionally, it encourages propositions to debate empirical insights into issues from the theories of policy process when they apply to examine Latin American cases. These topics should serve only as an indication of the type of discussion the panel intends to prompt.

Theoretical and factual knowledge are vital to policy studies; indeed, public policies are defined from these two theoretical and empirical perspectives. In this regard, Engeli and Rothmayr (2014) stress, for example, that "the field of public policy analysis comprises broadly two different, related, and equally valuable scholarly enterprises: to provide knowledge and policy expertise in and for policymaking [...] and to develop general theories and frameworks of the policy process explaining and predicting the policy-making process" (p. 2). Fontaine (2015), from the Latin American level, states that "public policy analysis has a scientific function (to improve knowledge) and a political function (to improve action and decision-making)." (p. 6).

The objective is to begin a long-lasting discussion about policy studies in LA in order to recognize more fully and transparently what the region has offered and how the field can proliferate in our region. As part of the objective, the panel will attempt to seek and arrive at an editorial project.

Studies and students of public policy have proliferated around the globe. Arguably, the field of research may have reached a point where regional contributions are now part of the mainstream of studies. Despite the richness in scope and breadth of the studies about public policy, further ways to push the knowledge frontiers of this field are still to be explored. Then, this panel aims to promote a regional debate in public policy, looking for the particularities and contributions of this region to public policy analyses.

This panel invites authors to engage with the question about the Latin American regional contribution to the field. As in many other fields of knowledge, authors in the region may have offered key developments, either on the grounds of theory, methodology, or even further, in terms of an innovative epistemological approach. However, such voices may have been eclipsed or overseen somehow due to a recurrent centralization of knowledge production, placing greater emphasis on authors and ideas that are able to publish in the US and Europe. 

The panel offers a unique opportunity to discuss the region's advancements and contributions to the study of public policy. Papers with the following topics are welcome: 

 

·         Well-established contributions that were allegedly developed first in LA or by an author in the region, alluding to cases of LA

·         Specific policies in LA that have been regarded as worldwide valuable ideas or international contributions (ex. participatory budgets, cash-transfer programs, bus rapid transport,

·         Applications of theories of the policy process (country or in a comparative way) in the LA context that have raised questions, prompted revisions, or placed key critiques on the mainstream approaches within the policy studies. Or in other words: What are the specific theoretical contributions from the Latin America? How do they contrast with Global North theories? What insights do they provide about the policy processes? How do they represent the development countries particularities?

·         How have “mainstream” or “alternatives” theories of the Global North been applied, and what have we learned about the theories and the region?

·         Methodological innovations in the field that have been initiated in LA may be part of the peculiar features that researchers face in the region (or due to some other reason).

 

·         Specific features of and within policies in LA that have been shaped by the political regime, culture, or other socio-political traits available in the region.

CALL FOR PAPERS

This panel seeks to promote a regional debate on public policy by highlighting the region's unique characteristics and contributions to public policy analyses. Thus, it encourages papers that discuss policy contributions to problem-solving with a specific case, such as cash transfers programs, participatory budget initiatives, bus rapid transit programs, metropolitan governance, infant industry development policies, and anti-corruption policies, among others. Additionally, it encourages propositions to debate empirical insights into issues from the theories of policy process when they apply to examine Latin American cases.

The previous topics should serve only as an indication of the type of discussion the panel intends to prompt. The objective is to begin a long-lasting discussion about policy studies in LA in order to recognize more fully and transparently what the region has offered and how the field can proliferate in our region. As part of the objective, the panel will attempt to seek and arrive at an editorial project.

This panel invites authors to engage with the question about the Latin American regional contribution to the field. As in many other fields of knowledge, authors in the region may have offered key developments to the field, either on the grounds of theory, methodology, or even further, in terms of an innovative epistemological approach. However, such voices may have been eclipsed or overseen somehow due to a recurrent centralization of knowledge production, placing greater emphasis on authors and ideas that are able to publish in the US and Europe. 

The panel offers a unique opportunity to discuss the region's advancements and contributions to the study of public policy. Papers with the following topics are welcome: 

·                     Well-established contributions that were allegedly developed first in LA or by an author in the region, alluding to cases of LA

·                     Specific policies in LA that have been regarded as worldwide valuable ideas or international contributions (ex. participatory budgets, cash-transfer programs, bus rapid transport,

·                     Applications of theories of the policy process (country or in a comparative way) in the LA context that have raised questions, prompted revisions, or placed key critiques on the mainstream approaches within the policy studies. Or in other words: What are the specific theoretical contributions from the Latin America? How do they contrast with Global North theories? What insights do they provide about the policy processes? How do they represent the development countries particularities?

·                     How have “mainstream” or “alternatives” theories of the Global North been applied, and what have we learned about the theories and the region?

·                     Methodological innovations in the field that have been initiated in LA may be part of the peculiar features that researchers face in the region (or due to some other reason).

 

·                     Specific features of and within policies in LA that have been shaped by the political regime, culture, or other socio-political traits available in the region

ABSTRACT

This panel seeks to promote a regional debate on public policy by highlighting the region's unique characteristics and contributions to public policy analyses from empirical and theoretical views. Thus, it encourages papers that discuss policy contributions to problem-solving with a specific case, such as cash transfers programs, participatory budget initiatives, bus rapid transit programs, metropolitan governance, infant industry development policies, and anti-corruption policies, among others. In addition, it encourages the formulation of hypotheses to assess the applicability of policy process theories to Latin American cases. The previous topics should serve only as an indication of the type of discussion the panel intends to prompt. The objective is to begin a long-lasting discussion about policy studies in LA in order to recognize more fully and transparently what the region has offered and how the field can proliferate in our region. As part of the objective, the panel will attempt to seek and arrive at an editorial project.

BIOGRAPHICAL PRESENTATION

Norma Muñoz del Campo

Associate Professor in the Department of Public Policy, Universidad de Santiago. Specialized in public policy analysis. My lines of research have been developed based on the intersection of cognitive and institutional approaches in order to study the reforms that have taken place in Chile since the transition to democracy to date. I am also interested in current debates on teaching-learning processes and their application to the teaching of public policy. My work has been published in Latin American Policy, Teaching Public Administration, Cahiers des Amériques Latines; Estado Gobierno y Gestión Pública; Cambridge Scholars Publishing; Routledge; Edward Elgar Publishing.

 

Juan Guillermo Vieira Silva.

Assistant professor of government and public policy at the Universidad EAFIT, Medellín, Colombia. PhD in Political Studies and International Relations, and Master in Comparative Public Policy. His main academic interests are: policy process research, applied policy analysis, policy theory, and political institutions (presidency and congress). He is currently creating the Colombian Political Agendas Project (COL-PAP), which is the Colombian chapter of the Comparative Agendas Project. His most recent publication is García-Tejeda & Vieira-Silva (2023) “La diversidad de las agendas políticas locales durante la covid-19: una comparación de los estados mexicanos” in Íconos. Revista de Ciencias Sociales.

 

Melina Rocha

Course Director in the Political Science Program at York University – Glendon Campus. She obtained her doctorate in political science at Université Paris 3 – Sorbonne Nouvelle in 2013. Her thesis ‘La crise de la fiscalité au Brésil (1988-2010) : un changement de paradigme inachevé’, under the supervision by Prof. Yves Surel, was published by L’Harmattan editions in 2017. She worked as an associate professor in the Law School at Fundação Getulio Vargas (2011–2018), Visiting Scholar at the University of Toronto (2017–2018) and short-term consultant at the World Bank (2019). Her areas of research are taxation and fiscal policy, federalism and comparative public policies.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - Collective Action Strategies in Tourism Policy in Florianopolis, Brazil: an analysis using the Advocacy Coalition Framework
Thiago De Chaves (Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina)
CO-AUTHORS
Leonardo Secchi (Universidade do Estado de Santa Catarina)
ABSTRACT

The objective of this article was to analyze how collective action strategies within tourism advocacy coalitions contribute to policymaking in Florianopolis, capital of Santa Catarina, in Brazil. This research used the advocacy coalition framework (ACF), as put forward by Sabatier and Jenkins (1993) and as developed, more critically, by Schlager (1995), observed through the theoretical lenses of Olson’s (1999) logic of collective action. The research's epistemological framework was designed supported by the sociology of action (BOUDON, 1995), encompassing bibliographic and documentary research and semi-structured interviews with 31 local policy actors specialized in tourism policy. The study adopted a qualitative approach (PATTON, 2002); (DENZIN; LINCOLN, 2000), analyzing the municipality of Florianopolis through a single case study (YIN, 2010). Data collected was treated using Bardin’s (2010) protocol and data triangulation as described by Triviños (1987) and Denzin (2005). The results indicated that the "glue" binding actors and their convictions (deep core and political core beliefs) is insufficient to ensure coalition stability. It suggests that they need converging interests to encourage network coordination, especially in the short term. Finally, the findings pointed out the need to structure collective activities through a regional integrated tourism plan, as gathering different segments around actions with shared benefits.

 

Keywords: Public Policy; Advocacy Coalition Framework; Tourism; Collective Action, Brazil.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Public Policy Design Theory and Practice in the Global South: The case of Colombian National Planning Department and its failed push for a top-down territorial planning policy.
Johann Julio Estrada (Universidad Externado de Colombia )
CO-AUTHORS
Maria Monica Salazar Tamayo (Universitat Autónoma de Barcelona)
ABSTRACT

Even in the presence of the best scenarios for policy implementation, governments can grapple with complex problems environments in which they must deal with different actors, ideas and interests, where well design policies have a better chance to accomplish goals than non-design ones (Howlett; Muckherjee, 2014, Howlett et al, 2015; Howlett; Muckherjee, 2018; Siddiki, 2018).  In these scenario, national policies with vertical design contexts requires great levels of administrative coordination, calibrated policy subsystems and legit governance modes to achieve policy goals through policy means (Howlett, 2009; McConnel, 2010; Howlett; Ramesh, 2014).  
 
An integrated model that can serves to analyze the consistency of policy design through policy implementation styles and execution feedback was proposed by Tosun and Treib (2018). In this model the link between policy design and implementation can help explain the occurrence of policy failure through aspects related to governance's modes. In this context, this paper seeks to assess the model applicability to government national policies in the global south. A case of special interest emerges in Colombia, where policy design has been around since 1990s, closely tied to development planning and adopted as a flagship in the public sector by the National Planning Department (DNP). However, and until this day, some policy design elements seem to be underattended in most national policies, which leads to the research question this paper intents to answer: If policy design is based in a grounded theory, provided by a national planning agency, why implementation gaps happened and more over can derive in a massive policy failure? 
 
To answer this question, we will focus in understanding the development of the spatial planning policy in Colombia. This policy emerged to address local governments capacities on territorial planning. Since 1998 Colombia, through the expeditions of Law 388 of 1997 and Law 1454 of 2011, has developed comprehensive legislation and regulatory policy guidelines that govern urban planning and spatial development in the country. The main results of this approach were the implementation of a spatial planning instrument developed by local governments in every city in the country, regulating the main issues around land management and use.  However, this planning instrument efficiency has been questioned because 88% of them need to be updated. In this context, and intending to update them, the Colombian national government developed the Modern Territorial Plans Program. 
 
This article aims to apply Tosun and Treib model to Colombia´s policy design in order to analyze the relationship between policy design, implementation structure and governance modes in the main stages of the policy process, also it seeks to understand how effective a top-down policy can be in improving local planning capacities in the context of the subnational government's autonomy, complex competencies distribution, and the pressure to achieve more sustainable and resilient urban settlements. The paper will contribute to the debate around the contradictions that a country faces when top-down policies are implemented without considering the stakeholders' demands, capacities, and powers, and more over how the institutional design and the political interplay impact the policy design. 

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Regulation Way After Delegation: an empirical inquiry from Latin America
Bruno Cunha (IPEA)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

After three decades of regulatory reforms in Latin America, the extent of the diffusion of regulatory agencies across the region is well documented. The ongoing challenges concerning stability, credibility and modernization are also largely mapped. Ideas on how to address these foundational challenges have equally been articulated. However, as previous studies featuring Global North countries have described, the post-delegation (or post-agencification) phase unveils new developments from the perspective of regulatory agencies and the regulatory state. It includes coordination within government and across policy fields, the mobilization, production and provision of regulatory and sectoral evidence and knowledge, new trust and legitimacy challenges and so on. The paper seeks to look into regulatory agencies’ trajectory in Latin America by linking theoretical and empirical inputs to make sense of current regionwide issues as well as relevant particularities that speak to the main post-delegation themes, opportunities and concerns. We rely on already completed in-depth semi-structured interviews with a set of regulatory agencies from Latin American countries that belong to the OECD Network of Economic Regulators to offer novel conclusions on the present state of the regulatory agency model in nations that share important administrative, political and cultural similarities. The paper contributes to the literature on regulatory policy and diffusion, as well as on comparative public administration and policy, by providing new empirical evidence from Latin America, a region in the Global South that has firmly embraced the regulatory state model over the last decades.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Anti-poverty policy and policy analysis in Mexico
Ricardo Velázquez Leyer (Universidad Iberoamericana)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Public Policy studies have acquired a central space in contemporary Political Science. Advantages like the focus on the orientation of government action towards the solution of public problems, a process perspective with discernible phases that can serve to analyse complex political phenomena, multidisciplinary and multimethodic approaches that incorporate tools from different social sciences, and an emphasis on the need of  considering the role of non-government actors in public debates and decision-making, are all factors that explain the growing popularity of policy studies around the world. Yet, most theories, models and analytical tools that can be found in the academic literature originated from case studies in North America and Northern Europe, namely countries from the capitalist core, with little contributions from other regions. The present paper shows the importance and relevance of applying Public Policy tools to Latin America. The case study that is analysed is the development of anti-poverty policy in Mexico between the 1990s and 2020s. During this period, the policy to fight poverty passed from one based on communitarian actions in the early 1990s, to programmes of conditional cash transfers from 1997 until 2018, to programmes of unconditional cash transfers after that year. The analysis that is presented in the paper applies different policy theories to explain this evolution and to identify its failures and achievements. In particular, the case study reveals, on the one hand, the usefulness of applying ideational perspectives to understand the outcomes of agenda-setting and policy formulation processes, with reinterpretations of the causes of social problems by policy entrepreneurs triggering proposals for changes, and on the other, the strong influence that street-level bureaucrats, institutional weaknesses and political clientelism can have on policy implementation, the last two issues being practically ignored in the existing theoretical framework of Policy Analysis, but that may actually shape policy development in many contexts. The paper demonstrates how policy research on a case from Latin America can represent a significant contribution to the Public Policy field, offering valuable insights to refine existing theoretical concepts and to incorporate new concepts that are currently neglected.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - The Disputes over State Capacities for Promoting Food and Nutrition Security in Brazil
Ricardo Duarte (Universidade Federal de São Carlos)
CO-AUTHORS
Alexandre Faria (FGV EBAPE – Brazilian School of Public and Business Administration)
ABSTRACT

The aim of this working paper is to analyze the configuration of state capacities as a process of disputes over the material and symbolic resources of the State. An important part of the literature on public policies involves understanding a public policy by identifying the actors involved in its definition and reconstructing the structure of relationships that unite them (Dubois, 2023). Among diverse notions for such analysis, the field approach of Bourdieu (1989) emerges as a powerful analytical tool. Based on that, it would be possible to avoid the dichotomy present in regarding the State as a holder or not of autonomy, framing it as a complex web of relationships without pre-defined immutable boundaries.

 Associated with this idea of autonomy, the multidimensional concept of State Capacity emerged in the literature. Initially, "classic" studies highlighted the importance of Weberian bureaucracies as a key element in the state's ability to pursue "official objectives" (Rueschemeyer & Evans, 1985) but more recently, state capacity has also been related to the idea of governance, opening a path for deploying categories such as technical-administrative and political-relational capacities (Pires & Gomide, 2016). These elements are placed as conditions for governments to produce public policies and deliverables. Nonetheless, considering that the discussion on state capacities tends to undervalue the issue of power (Lindvall & Teorell, 2016), we assume that state capacities should be read as the accumulation of material and symbolic powers to socially authorize the solution of public problems (Moretti & Mello, 2017). The aim is to advance the framework on the configuration of state capacities as a result of disputes that happen in the exchanges between the political-bureaucratic space in a certain public domain and its corresponding field. So, we ask: “how take place the disputes over the configuration of state capacities aimed at promoting Food and Nutrition Security (FNS) in Brazil?”

Methodologically, as a starting point, the analysis was limited to the Federal Executive, taking the National Secretariat for Food Security as a hard core in which the FNS policy occurs. Without neglecting other elements of the field's historical reconstruction, the focus will be between 2011-2022, understood as a period capable of encompassing the moment when the state's FNS capacities went through a series of reconfiguration processes. Primary and secondary data from multiple sources were analyzed using techniques such as Content Analysis and Multiple Correspondence Analysis. 

The preliminary results allow to indicate how the different stages of the power relations that involve the political-bureaucratic space of a public domain and its corresponding field are related to different arrangements of material and symbolic resources directed towards tackling a public problem. We consider this proposal suitable for the Workshop T01/W05 because even though it mobilizes two theoretical approaches from the Global North, it provides an approximation between them that are conceived in Latin America, opening reflections about parallels and contrasts. Also, it is done to shed light on an empirical problem typical of our continent, from which Latin America provided significant international contributions. (We consider on-site presentation).

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - The challenges of urban policy: the case of the Urban Development Program of Morelia, Mexico
Joanna Margarita Moreno Manzo (Municipal Planning Institute, Morelia)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Urban development poses significant challenges for municipal governments worldwide, with a particular emphasis on Latin America. The rapid urbanization fueled by migration from rural areas exacerbates issues such as housing and public service provision.

 

This paper seeks to delineate the challenges inherent in urban development, focusing primarily on the transition from urban planning theory to practical implementation. The central research inquiry guiding this study is: To what extent do the complexities of Latin American cities hinder the establishment of urban development zones and regulations?

 

Various variables will undergo analysis to elucidate municipal urban challenges, including demographic factors such as population growth rates and land requirements, as well as phenomena like land speculation, disparities in housing prices relative to worker incomes, irregular human settlements, agrarian regulations, impediments in public service delivery, environmental concerns, irregular constructions, and deficiencies in urban regulatory enforcement.

 

This study will employ a case study methodology to scrutinize urban challenges, aiming to underscore the primary obstacles confronting urban policy formulation, which must be designed with medium to long-term considerations in mind.

 

The Municipal Urban Development Program of Morelia, Mexico, will serve as the primary case study, highlighting policy challenges. This selection is motivated by the necessity to navigate demographic and land analyses, processes often circumvented in Latin American cities due to the prevalence of irregular settlements. A Municipal Urban Development Program delineates, through zoning maps, future urban areas within the municipality, the regulatory frameworks governing their development, and, importantly, identifies environmentally sensitive zones unsuitable for urbanization.


This paper will enrich workshop analyses by fostering discussions on urban policy, recognizing the challenges inherent in the policymaking process and the realities of implementation, especially considering the distinctive characteristics of Latin American cities.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Explaining work-family policy expansion in Chile: Framing to consensus
Shiao Wang (Tsinghua University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Since the late 1990s, Latin American countries have taken an increasing interest in social policy, but the post-retrenchment expansion is difficult. Chile is a country where neoliberal resilience has made social policy expansion hard to occur. While pro-welfare reforms staged in traditional arenas like pension or healthcare insurance, work-family policies as the provision of childcare and early education and parental leave policies have been adopted or expanded in Chile since the early 2000s thanks to a gradual process of policy change with transversal political support. How was this possible? This article intends to explain the puzzling case of Chilean work-family policy change by discussing the policy framing strategy adopted by policy entrepreneurs which successfully disentangled the problem definition from welfare burden to social investment. This article contributes to discussions about policy change driven by ideas by focusing on the childcare service program implemented under the socialist president Michelle Bachelet’s government (2006-2010) and the extension/adoption of parental leave during right-wing government under Sebastian Piñera(2010-2014). The analysis is based on an array of data sources including semi-structural interviews with key actors, newspaper reports, and legislative proceedings.

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Refoundation, charisma, and expertise: The educational reform of Ecuadorian radical populism (2007 – 2017)
Jorge Segovia (Universidad Diego Portales)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This research focuses on investigating the generation and sustainability of curricular educational reforms during periods of populist leadership. To address this issue, the case of Ecuador between 2007 and 2017 is examined, during the tenure of the political movement "Revolución Ciudadana" led by Rafael Correa, characterized in the literature as a technopopulist leader (De la Torre 2013b; Bickerton and Inverizzi 2021). This characterization is grounded in both his rhetoric, which pitted the people against the elites, and his public policy ideas advocating for the presence of the most qualified individuals in the State to make optimal decisions for the country.

During this period, a constitutional transformation took place, strengthening the executive power and establishing a technocratic apparatus for the reform and management of social areas, including health and education. In the educational realm, the veto power of teachers' unions and indigenous movements was eliminated by creating a state teachers' guild that supported the political decisions formulated by the Ministry of Education (Granda Merchán 2018; Ortiz Crespo 2021). As part of this process, the educational curriculum was completely redefined, proposing an expansion of civic education through three subjects: History, Citizenship Education, and Philosophy.

The objective of this research is to analyze the articulation of networks of experts involved in the curricular reform to understand the nature of civic education promoted during this government, evaluating it based on categories such as maximalist, minimalist, liberal or republican citizenship, support for elite democracy, or reinforcement of participatory democracy (Walzer 2001; Cox et al. 2018). Furthermore, the research seeks to understand why this reform has endured after the departure of the populist leader in 2017, even with the arrival of presidents with opposing ideologies. Two hypotheses are proposed: a) The durability of the reform is attributed to the specific design, execution, and promotion, facilitated by a highly skilled technical bureaucratic body (technocrats) that has persisted over time due to the new state configuration of centralization and planning of social services; b) The curriculum is likely supported by various actors due to its technical-pedagogical content but may be contested in terms of its political-ideological content.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Social Game Theory: Towards a Latin American Theory of the Public Policy Process
Juan Guillermo Vieira Silva (Universidad EAFIT)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In a previous paper (Vieira, 2017), I wondered whether Carlos Matus' social game theory, elaborated to support his proposals for the sciences and techniques of government and situational strategic planning, could be considered a public policy process theory, perhaps the first in Latin America. I first analysed whether it fitted the definition of theory, and then the definition of public policy process theories in the tradition of Sabatier and Weible (2017, 2023), both of which I found no buts. Finally, I exploratively reviewed whether traditional explanatory factors of public policy theories, such as actors, institutions, ideas, networks, socio-economic factors and focal events, had a place in their conceptual framework. I found that in principle all these elements could be part of social game theory as policy process theory. The 2017 exploration is an important advance, it shows the potential of a theory, starting from its conceptual framework, but it does not advance in specifying social game theory as policy process theory, what dimensions of the process it explains, with what hypotheses and through what methods it operationalises its concepts. In this paper, I explore these aspects and advance their specification with a view to outlining the formulation of a proposal for analysis, the first empirical test of a policy in the light of social game theory as an explanatory framework for the dynamics of public policy in Latin America.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - "My body is not public!": Reflections on combating gender-based violence in urban public transportation.
Raissa Medeiros (Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In Latin American cities, episodes of gender-based violence against women in public transportation are routine, with countless cases of men touching their bodies without consent, taking advantage of the overcrowding of buses and trains during peak hours. Moving freely in stops, terminals, buses, train cars, and stations, fully enjoying the right to the city, is still not a reality for many women. The purpose of this research in the field of Sociology of Law and Public Policy was to empirically discuss the existence and effectiveness of policies combating gender-based violence against women using urban public transportation to actualize  the right to the city. The research aimed to answer the question: Which measures have been taken in place to fight gender violence in public transportation in the context of the metropolitan area of Porto Alegre? The first stage of the investigation was a literature review that aimed at discussing research in social sciences involving the three axes that guided this research: right to the city, gender-based violence and urban mobility. The subsequent research phase included an empirical study on the measures effectively used in the metropolitan region of the capital of Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil, to combat this type of violence. Two case studies were conducted: a) the case of urban bus lines in Porto Alegre, covering vehicles, stops, and terminals regulated by EPTC; b) the case of Trensurb lines, involving train cars and stations that are part of the metropolitan urban train line in the metropolitan region of Porto Alegre. The case studies involved documentary research, direct observations, and semi-structured interviews with company employees. As a complement, a review on news published by local media was made. Finally, the research identified the existence of educational measures, segregative measures, criminalization measures, and situational prevention measures. Besides, it was verified that gender issues are not put as a motivational element on the formulation of public policy and that the major part of the measures that eventually come up in favor of women weren't put in order in public transportation for their safety, but aiming the confrontation of other issues.

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - Model for Analysis and Diagnosis of Public Policies (MADPP): A New Tool for Managing Policy Portfolios in Latin America
santiago leyva (Universidad EAFIT)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The challenges in Latin American societies are intricate, necessitating continuous adjustments to public policies by national and local governments to alleviate them. In this regard, designing public policies based on technical guidelines rather than ambiguous or overly political criteria is crucial for enhancing the quality of life in the region. Although there has been a surge in policy formulation, the management of local and national government policy portfolios has made less progress. The concept of 'policy portfolio' extends the analysis beyond individual policies to encompass multiple policies, as proposed by Howlett and Rayner (2013) and Howlett and del Río (2015). We extend the concept to the entirety of policies of a single entity or government level. This perspective allows us to analyze fundamental issues, such as the number of public problems a governmental entity can address to build manageable public policy portfolios, as well as the quality of the formulation of each policy in the portfolio. This analysis identifies design and non-design issues in policies.

 

Although the policy portfolio concept in Howlett and colleagues' work has been valuable, it lacks an empirical methodology for systematically evaluating the entire policy portfolio of a single government unit, such as a state government or department. To address this gap, we created the Model for Analysis and Diagnosis of Public Policies (MADPP), a rubric that measures the quality of policy design. This methodology is the result of fifteen years of continuous applied research and consulting by EAFIT University across different administrations and levels of government. The rubric evaluates 7 dimensions of policy design using 45 criteria and four performance levels - optimal, considerable, basic, and insufficient - providing a comprehensive view of the status of any public policy. This tool enables the improvement of the policy portfolio by addressing policies that are poorly designed, lack technical merit, or are developed in response to short-term political pressures. By identifying and rectifying these issues, we can create a more effective portfolio of policies that align with long-term goals and objectives.

 

To demonstrate the usefulness of this tool, we applied it to the policy portfolio of the government of Antioquia, Colombia, composed of 43 policies developed during the last 23 years, about a wide range of topics, including environmental protection, early childhood, indigenous issues, mental health, and risk management. However, the rapid growth of policies in Colombia has resulted in them being developed in a fragmented manner, with varying levels of quality.

The implementation of our methodology enabled the Antioquia Government to overcome its policy-by-policy approach, which was fragmented. Our MADPP methodology not only allowed the Government to assess the current state of public policies' design quality and identify non-design problems but also provided a unified perspective on managing the policy portfolio and improving design processes and protocols.

ACCEPTED
Format
12 - Who could stay (at home)? Similar policy responses to COVID-19 pandemic in the first six months, yet different results: a Latin American and European comparison
Manuel Torres Lajo (Universidad Complutense de Madrid)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Early COVID-19 responses in many parts of the world were quite similar: just to name a few, people were ordered to remain at home to avoid contagion, and only essential businesses stayed open. It seemed like a coordinated global response, irrespective of the particularities of the countries. In Latin America, for example, most countries shut down their economies in an attempt to protect their health systems, just like their European counterparts did. Notwithstanding the noble purpose, key characteristics of the region were not considered, which might have prevented an important part of its population to comply with policies such as staying home. These include, but are not limited to, the mostly informal nature of their economies (with workers living day-to-day) or the unsuitable housing infrastructure where people were supposed to remain to protect themselves from the virus. In comparison, the safety nets already in place in most European countries potentially allowed its population to comply with a certain ease.

 

This article aims at establishing a comparison between the policy responses to the COVID-19 pandemic and the results yielded by those (in terms of economic impact and health indicators) in the first semester of 2020 in a sample of Latin American and European countries. Most of the data analysed will be extracted from the CoronaNet dataset, a Technical University of Munich-based project that collected policy response data from around the world. The results of the comparison are set to provide an explanation on why not considering the particularities of Latin American countries might have been counterproductive in the goal of preventing contagions. The population might have wanted to comply, but the cruel dilemma—protecting themselves from the virus and not earning money, or vice versa— they were put into, called for a different policy response that considers those realities.

 

By highlighting the importance of considering the particularities of Latin America when designing public policy responses, it is expected to provide suggestions for policymakers to consider in the design of policies in future emergency scenarios. One particularity the article focuses on are solidarity networks. These are a way of organisation of civil society by coming together to try to tackle some of the shortcomings of their countries’ policymakers. These include the provision and distribution of food, medicine, or even personal services. Their experience with extreme situations even before the pandemic might have helped to avoid a worse scenario in some Latin American countries and its understanding could be useful to comprehend the need for considering the local particularities for policy making.
 
The article will initially focus on Peru and Spain, two countries that had a similar response at the same time. Given that this is a work in progress, other countries are intended to be included in the final version, such as Italy and Argentina, and Germany and Chile. Presentation would be suitable for either format.

ACCEPTED
Format
13 - A Substantivist Conception of the Economy in Public Policy. Insights from Public Procurement for Solidarity Economy in Ecuador
María José Ruiz-Rivera (Université Catholique de Louvain)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Ecuador has constitutionally acknowledged a plural economy comprising private capitalistic and public statist forms of economic organization as well as a solidarity economy (SE) sector. SE organizations are collective initiatives undertaking the production of goods and services whose aim is not to maximize profit but to sustain the livelihoods of their members or the community and enhance democratization (Hillenkamp et al., 2013). They have emerged through historically particular institutional paths: the cooperative tradition, associations supported by the Catholic Church and development-oriented NGOs, and more recent expressions embedded in social movements (Ruiz-Rivera & Lemaître, 2019).

 

The incorporation of the Buen Vivir paradigm in the constitution has led to debates on its operationalization, especially in public procurement programs—a flagship policy for Buen Vivir. The Buen Vivir discourse stands as a beacon of holistic development, emphasizing the well-being of individuals and communities over mere economic output (Caria & Domínguez, 2016). Despite the constitutional commitment to a substantive economy (Polanyi, 1977), policy implementation relies on formal indicators, revealing a tension between innovative constitutional principles and pragmatic governance.

 

This paper aims to analyze public procurement programs in Ecuador as a prominent policy for SE promotion in Latin America. In particular, we elucidate the underlying economic rationales and normative references behind the evaluation criteria (i.e., technification, localization, formalization, and positive discrimination) underpinning public procurement and whether these criteria are rooted in a substantive understanding of the economy or a more conventional interpretation, according to Polanyi (1977). Through an inductive approach (8 months of ethnographic fieldwork, e.g., 36 semi-structured interviews and 6 focus groups conducted with government officials and SE organization members), our study explores discursive repertoires used by state authorities and practitioners' perceptions.

 

Our findings reveal contradictions between SE organizations' ideals and policy foundations, leading to tensions within organizations and their institutional environment. A formal vision of the economy tends to overlook particular features within SE organizations. For instance, capacity assessments in public procurement programs focus on technification and professionalization, favouring modern technology over traditional knowledge and practices. Likewise, the emphasis on economic consolidation through specialization implies a minimalist view of organizations centred on production function efficiency over social aims.

 

By combining macro-institutional (based on context analysis) and meso-level analyses, this research contributes to the debate on policy implementation in Latin America by advancing empirical research in the Ecuador of Buen Vivir paradigm. Our study highlights the tensions between a substantive approach to the economy and formal indicators in policy implementation and provides insights into the challenges in translating constitutional ideals into practical governance.

 

References:

 

Caria, S., & Domínguez, R. (2016). Ecuador’s Buen vivir: A New Ideology for Development. Latin American Perspectives, 43(206), 18–33. https://doi.org/10.1177/0094582X15611126

 

Hillenkamp, I., Lapeyre, F., & Lemaître, A. (Eds.). (2013). Securing livelihoods: Informal economy practices and institutions. Oxford University Press.

 

Polanyi, K. (1977). The livelihood of man. Academia Press.

 

Ruiz-Rivera, M.-J., & Lemaître, A. (2019). Popular and Solidarity Economy in Ecuador: Historical overview, institutional trajectories and types of organisations. In M. Nyssens, L. I. Gaiger, & F. Wanderley (Eds.), Social enterprise in Latin America: Theory, models and practice (pp. 139–168). Routledge.

ACCEPTED
Format
14 - Using the Policy Capacity Framework to Study Latin American MPP and MPA Higher Education: unveiling the region’s contribution to the policy change debate.
Norma Munoz del Campo (Chile)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The policy capacity framework (PCF) outlined by Wu, Ramesh, and Howlett states that the development of knowledge and skills through education programs affects the functioning of public policies and is a determinant of governments' political capacity. Even though this relationship between education and political capability has been established in the academic literature, training programs have been understudied. This study aims to examine the competencies and skills that Master of Public Policy (MPP) and Master of Public Administration (MPA) programs in Latin America intend to instill in their students, as well as the efficacy of the Policy Capacity Framework in achieving this goal. To do so, I analyze nineteen public policy master's programs that meet NASPAA's MPP and MPA degree classifications, focusing on their descriptions, objectives, graduation profiles, and curriculum structure. This study adds deontological and human capacity to the original framework's analytical, operational, and political capacities. The findings show and discuss the regional contribution to the training of future policymakers and public managers rethinking the PCF and open new avenues for studying how competencies and capabilities affect policy change using the five-component framework.

 

 

Key words: Policy Capacity Framework, Policy change, MPA and MPP Education, Teaching Public Policy,  Latin America.

CO-AUTHORS
Leonardo Secchi (Universidade do Estado de Santa Catarina)
ABSTRACT

The objective of this article was to analyze how collective action strategies within tourism advocacy coalitions contribute to policymaking in Florianopolis, capital of Santa Catarina, in Brazil. This research used the advocacy coalition framework (ACF), as put forward by Sabatier and Jenkins (1993) and as developed, more critically, by Schlager (1995), observed through the theoretical lenses of Olson’s (1999) logic of collective action. The research's epistemological framework was designed supported by the sociology of action (BOUDON, 1995), encompassing bibliographic and documentary research and semi-structured interviews with 31 local policy actors specialized in tourism policy. The study adopted a qualitative approach (PATTON, 2002); (DENZIN; LINCOLN, 2000), analyzing the municipality of Florianopolis through a single case study (YIN, 2010). Data collected was treated using Bardin’s (2010) protocol and data triangulation as described by Triviños (1987) and Denzin (2005). The results indicated that the "glue" binding actors and their convictions (deep core and political core beliefs) is insufficient to ensure coalition stability. It suggests that they need converging interests to encourage network coordination, especially in the short term. Finally, the findings pointed out the need to structure collective activities through a regional integrated tourism plan, as gathering different segments around actions with shared benefits.

 

Keywords: Public Policy; Advocacy Coalition Framework; Tourism; Collective Action, Brazil.

CO-AUTHORS
Maria Monica Salazar Tamayo (Universitat Autónoma de Barcelona)
ABSTRACT

Even in the presence of the best scenarios for policy implementation, governments can grapple with complex problems environments in which they must deal with different actors, ideas and interests, where well design policies have a better chance to accomplish goals than non-design ones (Howlett; Muckherjee, 2014, Howlett et al, 2015; Howlett; Muckherjee, 2018; Siddiki, 2018).  In these scenario, national policies with vertical design contexts requires great levels of administrative coordination, calibrated policy subsystems and legit governance modes to achieve policy goals through policy means (Howlett, 2009; McConnel, 2010; Howlett; Ramesh, 2014).  
 
An integrated model that can serves to analyze the consistency of policy design through policy implementation styles and execution feedback was proposed by Tosun and Treib (2018). In this model the link between policy design and implementation can help explain the occurrence of policy failure through aspects related to governance's modes. In this context, this paper seeks to assess the model applicability to government national policies in the global south. A case of special interest emerges in Colombia, where policy design has been around since 1990s, closely tied to development planning and adopted as a flagship in the public sector by the National Planning Department (DNP). However, and until this day, some policy design elements seem to be underattended in most national policies, which leads to the research question this paper intents to answer: If policy design is based in a grounded theory, provided by a national planning agency, why implementation gaps happened and more over can derive in a massive policy failure? 
 
To answer this question, we will focus in understanding the development of the spatial planning policy in Colombia. This policy emerged to address local governments capacities on territorial planning. Since 1998 Colombia, through the expeditions of Law 388 of 1997 and Law 1454 of 2011, has developed comprehensive legislation and regulatory policy guidelines that govern urban planning and spatial development in the country. The main results of this approach were the implementation of a spatial planning instrument developed by local governments in every city in the country, regulating the main issues around land management and use.  However, this planning instrument efficiency has been questioned because 88% of them need to be updated. In this context, and intending to update them, the Colombian national government developed the Modern Territorial Plans Program. 
 
This article aims to apply Tosun and Treib model to Colombia´s policy design in order to analyze the relationship between policy design, implementation structure and governance modes in the main stages of the policy process, also it seeks to understand how effective a top-down policy can be in improving local planning capacities in the context of the subnational government's autonomy, complex competencies distribution, and the pressure to achieve more sustainable and resilient urban settlements. The paper will contribute to the debate around the contradictions that a country faces when top-down policies are implemented without considering the stakeholders' demands, capacities, and powers, and more over how the institutional design and the political interplay impact the policy design. 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

After three decades of regulatory reforms in Latin America, the extent of the diffusion of regulatory agencies across the region is well documented. The ongoing challenges concerning stability, credibility and modernization are also largely mapped. Ideas on how to address these foundational challenges have equally been articulated. However, as previous studies featuring Global North countries have described, the post-delegation (or post-agencification) phase unveils new developments from the perspective of regulatory agencies and the regulatory state. It includes coordination within government and across policy fields, the mobilization, production and provision of regulatory and sectoral evidence and knowledge, new trust and legitimacy challenges and so on. The paper seeks to look into regulatory agencies’ trajectory in Latin America by linking theoretical and empirical inputs to make sense of current regionwide issues as well as relevant particularities that speak to the main post-delegation themes, opportunities and concerns. We rely on already completed in-depth semi-structured interviews with a set of regulatory agencies from Latin American countries that belong to the OECD Network of Economic Regulators to offer novel conclusions on the present state of the regulatory agency model in nations that share important administrative, political and cultural similarities. The paper contributes to the literature on regulatory policy and diffusion, as well as on comparative public administration and policy, by providing new empirical evidence from Latin America, a region in the Global South that has firmly embraced the regulatory state model over the last decades.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Public Policy studies have acquired a central space in contemporary Political Science. Advantages like the focus on the orientation of government action towards the solution of public problems, a process perspective with discernible phases that can serve to analyse complex political phenomena, multidisciplinary and multimethodic approaches that incorporate tools from different social sciences, and an emphasis on the need of  considering the role of non-government actors in public debates and decision-making, are all factors that explain the growing popularity of policy studies around the world. Yet, most theories, models and analytical tools that can be found in the academic literature originated from case studies in North America and Northern Europe, namely countries from the capitalist core, with little contributions from other regions. The present paper shows the importance and relevance of applying Public Policy tools to Latin America. The case study that is analysed is the development of anti-poverty policy in Mexico between the 1990s and 2020s. During this period, the policy to fight poverty passed from one based on communitarian actions in the early 1990s, to programmes of conditional cash transfers from 1997 until 2018, to programmes of unconditional cash transfers after that year. The analysis that is presented in the paper applies different policy theories to explain this evolution and to identify its failures and achievements. In particular, the case study reveals, on the one hand, the usefulness of applying ideational perspectives to understand the outcomes of agenda-setting and policy formulation processes, with reinterpretations of the causes of social problems by policy entrepreneurs triggering proposals for changes, and on the other, the strong influence that street-level bureaucrats, institutional weaknesses and political clientelism can have on policy implementation, the last two issues being practically ignored in the existing theoretical framework of Policy Analysis, but that may actually shape policy development in many contexts. The paper demonstrates how policy research on a case from Latin America can represent a significant contribution to the Public Policy field, offering valuable insights to refine existing theoretical concepts and to incorporate new concepts that are currently neglected.

CO-AUTHORS
Alexandre Faria (FGV EBAPE – Brazilian School of Public and Business Administration)
ABSTRACT

The aim of this working paper is to analyze the configuration of state capacities as a process of disputes over the material and symbolic resources of the State. An important part of the literature on public policies involves understanding a public policy by identifying the actors involved in its definition and reconstructing the structure of relationships that unite them (Dubois, 2023). Among diverse notions for such analysis, the field approach of Bourdieu (1989) emerges as a powerful analytical tool. Based on that, it would be possible to avoid the dichotomy present in regarding the State as a holder or not of autonomy, framing it as a complex web of relationships without pre-defined immutable boundaries.

 Associated with this idea of autonomy, the multidimensional concept of State Capacity emerged in the literature. Initially, "classic" studies highlighted the importance of Weberian bureaucracies as a key element in the state's ability to pursue "official objectives" (Rueschemeyer & Evans, 1985) but more recently, state capacity has also been related to the idea of governance, opening a path for deploying categories such as technical-administrative and political-relational capacities (Pires & Gomide, 2016). These elements are placed as conditions for governments to produce public policies and deliverables. Nonetheless, considering that the discussion on state capacities tends to undervalue the issue of power (Lindvall & Teorell, 2016), we assume that state capacities should be read as the accumulation of material and symbolic powers to socially authorize the solution of public problems (Moretti & Mello, 2017). The aim is to advance the framework on the configuration of state capacities as a result of disputes that happen in the exchanges between the political-bureaucratic space in a certain public domain and its corresponding field. So, we ask: “how take place the disputes over the configuration of state capacities aimed at promoting Food and Nutrition Security (FNS) in Brazil?”

Methodologically, as a starting point, the analysis was limited to the Federal Executive, taking the National Secretariat for Food Security as a hard core in which the FNS policy occurs. Without neglecting other elements of the field's historical reconstruction, the focus will be between 2011-2022, understood as a period capable of encompassing the moment when the state's FNS capacities went through a series of reconfiguration processes. Primary and secondary data from multiple sources were analyzed using techniques such as Content Analysis and Multiple Correspondence Analysis. 

The preliminary results allow to indicate how the different stages of the power relations that involve the political-bureaucratic space of a public domain and its corresponding field are related to different arrangements of material and symbolic resources directed towards tackling a public problem. We consider this proposal suitable for the Workshop T01/W05 because even though it mobilizes two theoretical approaches from the Global North, it provides an approximation between them that are conceived in Latin America, opening reflections about parallels and contrasts. Also, it is done to shed light on an empirical problem typical of our continent, from which Latin America provided significant international contributions. (We consider on-site presentation).

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Urban development poses significant challenges for municipal governments worldwide, with a particular emphasis on Latin America. The rapid urbanization fueled by migration from rural areas exacerbates issues such as housing and public service provision.

 

This paper seeks to delineate the challenges inherent in urban development, focusing primarily on the transition from urban planning theory to practical implementation. The central research inquiry guiding this study is: To what extent do the complexities of Latin American cities hinder the establishment of urban development zones and regulations?

 

Various variables will undergo analysis to elucidate municipal urban challenges, including demographic factors such as population growth rates and land requirements, as well as phenomena like land speculation, disparities in housing prices relative to worker incomes, irregular human settlements, agrarian regulations, impediments in public service delivery, environmental concerns, irregular constructions, and deficiencies in urban regulatory enforcement.

 

This study will employ a case study methodology to scrutinize urban challenges, aiming to underscore the primary obstacles confronting urban policy formulation, which must be designed with medium to long-term considerations in mind.

 

The Municipal Urban Development Program of Morelia, Mexico, will serve as the primary case study, highlighting policy challenges. This selection is motivated by the necessity to navigate demographic and land analyses, processes often circumvented in Latin American cities due to the prevalence of irregular settlements. A Municipal Urban Development Program delineates, through zoning maps, future urban areas within the municipality, the regulatory frameworks governing their development, and, importantly, identifies environmentally sensitive zones unsuitable for urbanization.


This paper will enrich workshop analyses by fostering discussions on urban policy, recognizing the challenges inherent in the policymaking process and the realities of implementation, especially considering the distinctive characteristics of Latin American cities.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Since the late 1990s, Latin American countries have taken an increasing interest in social policy, but the post-retrenchment expansion is difficult. Chile is a country where neoliberal resilience has made social policy expansion hard to occur. While pro-welfare reforms staged in traditional arenas like pension or healthcare insurance, work-family policies as the provision of childcare and early education and parental leave policies have been adopted or expanded in Chile since the early 2000s thanks to a gradual process of policy change with transversal political support. How was this possible? This article intends to explain the puzzling case of Chilean work-family policy change by discussing the policy framing strategy adopted by policy entrepreneurs which successfully disentangled the problem definition from welfare burden to social investment. This article contributes to discussions about policy change driven by ideas by focusing on the childcare service program implemented under the socialist president Michelle Bachelet’s government (2006-2010) and the extension/adoption of parental leave during right-wing government under Sebastian Piñera(2010-2014). The analysis is based on an array of data sources including semi-structural interviews with key actors, newspaper reports, and legislative proceedings.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This research focuses on investigating the generation and sustainability of curricular educational reforms during periods of populist leadership. To address this issue, the case of Ecuador between 2007 and 2017 is examined, during the tenure of the political movement "Revolución Ciudadana" led by Rafael Correa, characterized in the literature as a technopopulist leader (De la Torre 2013b; Bickerton and Inverizzi 2021). This characterization is grounded in both his rhetoric, which pitted the people against the elites, and his public policy ideas advocating for the presence of the most qualified individuals in the State to make optimal decisions for the country.

During this period, a constitutional transformation took place, strengthening the executive power and establishing a technocratic apparatus for the reform and management of social areas, including health and education. In the educational realm, the veto power of teachers' unions and indigenous movements was eliminated by creating a state teachers' guild that supported the political decisions formulated by the Ministry of Education (Granda Merchán 2018; Ortiz Crespo 2021). As part of this process, the educational curriculum was completely redefined, proposing an expansion of civic education through three subjects: History, Citizenship Education, and Philosophy.

The objective of this research is to analyze the articulation of networks of experts involved in the curricular reform to understand the nature of civic education promoted during this government, evaluating it based on categories such as maximalist, minimalist, liberal or republican citizenship, support for elite democracy, or reinforcement of participatory democracy (Walzer 2001; Cox et al. 2018). Furthermore, the research seeks to understand why this reform has endured after the departure of the populist leader in 2017, even with the arrival of presidents with opposing ideologies. Two hypotheses are proposed: a) The durability of the reform is attributed to the specific design, execution, and promotion, facilitated by a highly skilled technical bureaucratic body (technocrats) that has persisted over time due to the new state configuration of centralization and planning of social services; b) The curriculum is likely supported by various actors due to its technical-pedagogical content but may be contested in terms of its political-ideological content.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In a previous paper (Vieira, 2017), I wondered whether Carlos Matus' social game theory, elaborated to support his proposals for the sciences and techniques of government and situational strategic planning, could be considered a public policy process theory, perhaps the first in Latin America. I first analysed whether it fitted the definition of theory, and then the definition of public policy process theories in the tradition of Sabatier and Weible (2017, 2023), both of which I found no buts. Finally, I exploratively reviewed whether traditional explanatory factors of public policy theories, such as actors, institutions, ideas, networks, socio-economic factors and focal events, had a place in their conceptual framework. I found that in principle all these elements could be part of social game theory as policy process theory. The 2017 exploration is an important advance, it shows the potential of a theory, starting from its conceptual framework, but it does not advance in specifying social game theory as policy process theory, what dimensions of the process it explains, with what hypotheses and through what methods it operationalises its concepts. In this paper, I explore these aspects and advance their specification with a view to outlining the formulation of a proposal for analysis, the first empirical test of a policy in the light of social game theory as an explanatory framework for the dynamics of public policy in Latin America.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In Latin American cities, episodes of gender-based violence against women in public transportation are routine, with countless cases of men touching their bodies without consent, taking advantage of the overcrowding of buses and trains during peak hours. Moving freely in stops, terminals, buses, train cars, and stations, fully enjoying the right to the city, is still not a reality for many women. The purpose of this research in the field of Sociology of Law and Public Policy was to empirically discuss the existence and effectiveness of policies combating gender-based violence against women using urban public transportation to actualize  the right to the city. The research aimed to answer the question: Which measures have been taken in place to fight gender violence in public transportation in the context of the metropolitan area of Porto Alegre? The first stage of the investigation was a literature review that aimed at discussing research in social sciences involving the three axes that guided this research: right to the city, gender-based violence and urban mobility. The subsequent research phase included an empirical study on the measures effectively used in the metropolitan region of the capital of Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil, to combat this type of violence. Two case studies were conducted: a) the case of urban bus lines in Porto Alegre, covering vehicles, stops, and terminals regulated by EPTC; b) the case of Trensurb lines, involving train cars and stations that are part of the metropolitan urban train line in the metropolitan region of Porto Alegre. The case studies involved documentary research, direct observations, and semi-structured interviews with company employees. As a complement, a review on news published by local media was made. Finally, the research identified the existence of educational measures, segregative measures, criminalization measures, and situational prevention measures. Besides, it was verified that gender issues are not put as a motivational element on the formulation of public policy and that the major part of the measures that eventually come up in favor of women weren't put in order in public transportation for their safety, but aiming the confrontation of other issues.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The challenges in Latin American societies are intricate, necessitating continuous adjustments to public policies by national and local governments to alleviate them. In this regard, designing public policies based on technical guidelines rather than ambiguous or overly political criteria is crucial for enhancing the quality of life in the region. Although there has been a surge in policy formulation, the management of local and national government policy portfolios has made less progress. The concept of 'policy portfolio' extends the analysis beyond individual policies to encompass multiple policies, as proposed by Howlett and Rayner (2013) and Howlett and del Río (2015). We extend the concept to the entirety of policies of a single entity or government level. This perspective allows us to analyze fundamental issues, such as the number of public problems a governmental entity can address to build manageable public policy portfolios, as well as the quality of the formulation of each policy in the portfolio. This analysis identifies design and non-design issues in policies.

 

Although the policy portfolio concept in Howlett and colleagues' work has been valuable, it lacks an empirical methodology for systematically evaluating the entire policy portfolio of a single government unit, such as a state government or department. To address this gap, we created the Model for Analysis and Diagnosis of Public Policies (MADPP), a rubric that measures the quality of policy design. This methodology is the result of fifteen years of continuous applied research and consulting by EAFIT University across different administrations and levels of government. The rubric evaluates 7 dimensions of policy design using 45 criteria and four performance levels - optimal, considerable, basic, and insufficient - providing a comprehensive view of the status of any public policy. This tool enables the improvement of the policy portfolio by addressing policies that are poorly designed, lack technical merit, or are developed in response to short-term political pressures. By identifying and rectifying these issues, we can create a more effective portfolio of policies that align with long-term goals and objectives.

 

To demonstrate the usefulness of this tool, we applied it to the policy portfolio of the government of Antioquia, Colombia, composed of 43 policies developed during the last 23 years, about a wide range of topics, including environmental protection, early childhood, indigenous issues, mental health, and risk management. However, the rapid growth of policies in Colombia has resulted in them being developed in a fragmented manner, with varying levels of quality.

The implementation of our methodology enabled the Antioquia Government to overcome its policy-by-policy approach, which was fragmented. Our MADPP methodology not only allowed the Government to assess the current state of public policies' design quality and identify non-design problems but also provided a unified perspective on managing the policy portfolio and improving design processes and protocols.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Early COVID-19 responses in many parts of the world were quite similar: just to name a few, people were ordered to remain at home to avoid contagion, and only essential businesses stayed open. It seemed like a coordinated global response, irrespective of the particularities of the countries. In Latin America, for example, most countries shut down their economies in an attempt to protect their health systems, just like their European counterparts did. Notwithstanding the noble purpose, key characteristics of the region were not considered, which might have prevented an important part of its population to comply with policies such as staying home. These include, but are not limited to, the mostly informal nature of their economies (with workers living day-to-day) or the unsuitable housing infrastructure where people were supposed to remain to protect themselves from the virus. In comparison, the safety nets already in place in most European countries potentially allowed its population to comply with a certain ease.

 

This article aims at establishing a comparison between the policy responses to the COVID-19 pandemic and the results yielded by those (in terms of economic impact and health indicators) in the first semester of 2020 in a sample of Latin American and European countries. Most of the data analysed will be extracted from the CoronaNet dataset, a Technical University of Munich-based project that collected policy response data from around the world. The results of the comparison are set to provide an explanation on why not considering the particularities of Latin American countries might have been counterproductive in the goal of preventing contagions. The population might have wanted to comply, but the cruel dilemma—protecting themselves from the virus and not earning money, or vice versa— they were put into, called for a different policy response that considers those realities.

 

By highlighting the importance of considering the particularities of Latin America when designing public policy responses, it is expected to provide suggestions for policymakers to consider in the design of policies in future emergency scenarios. One particularity the article focuses on are solidarity networks. These are a way of organisation of civil society by coming together to try to tackle some of the shortcomings of their countries’ policymakers. These include the provision and distribution of food, medicine, or even personal services. Their experience with extreme situations even before the pandemic might have helped to avoid a worse scenario in some Latin American countries and its understanding could be useful to comprehend the need for considering the local particularities for policy making.
 
The article will initially focus on Peru and Spain, two countries that had a similar response at the same time. Given that this is a work in progress, other countries are intended to be included in the final version, such as Italy and Argentina, and Germany and Chile. Presentation would be suitable for either format.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Ecuador has constitutionally acknowledged a plural economy comprising private capitalistic and public statist forms of economic organization as well as a solidarity economy (SE) sector. SE organizations are collective initiatives undertaking the production of goods and services whose aim is not to maximize profit but to sustain the livelihoods of their members or the community and enhance democratization (Hillenkamp et al., 2013). They have emerged through historically particular institutional paths: the cooperative tradition, associations supported by the Catholic Church and development-oriented NGOs, and more recent expressions embedded in social movements (Ruiz-Rivera & Lemaître, 2019).

 

The incorporation of the Buen Vivir paradigm in the constitution has led to debates on its operationalization, especially in public procurement programs—a flagship policy for Buen Vivir. The Buen Vivir discourse stands as a beacon of holistic development, emphasizing the well-being of individuals and communities over mere economic output (Caria & Domínguez, 2016). Despite the constitutional commitment to a substantive economy (Polanyi, 1977), policy implementation relies on formal indicators, revealing a tension between innovative constitutional principles and pragmatic governance.

 

This paper aims to analyze public procurement programs in Ecuador as a prominent policy for SE promotion in Latin America. In particular, we elucidate the underlying economic rationales and normative references behind the evaluation criteria (i.e., technification, localization, formalization, and positive discrimination) underpinning public procurement and whether these criteria are rooted in a substantive understanding of the economy or a more conventional interpretation, according to Polanyi (1977). Through an inductive approach (8 months of ethnographic fieldwork, e.g., 36 semi-structured interviews and 6 focus groups conducted with government officials and SE organization members), our study explores discursive repertoires used by state authorities and practitioners' perceptions.

 

Our findings reveal contradictions between SE organizations' ideals and policy foundations, leading to tensions within organizations and their institutional environment. A formal vision of the economy tends to overlook particular features within SE organizations. For instance, capacity assessments in public procurement programs focus on technification and professionalization, favouring modern technology over traditional knowledge and practices. Likewise, the emphasis on economic consolidation through specialization implies a minimalist view of organizations centred on production function efficiency over social aims.

 

By combining macro-institutional (based on context analysis) and meso-level analyses, this research contributes to the debate on policy implementation in Latin America by advancing empirical research in the Ecuador of Buen Vivir paradigm. Our study highlights the tensions between a substantive approach to the economy and formal indicators in policy implementation and provides insights into the challenges in translating constitutional ideals into practical governance.

 

References:

 

Caria, S., & Domínguez, R. (2016). Ecuador’s Buen vivir: A New Ideology for Development. Latin American Perspectives, 43(206), 18–33. https://doi.org/10.1177/0094582X15611126

 

Hillenkamp, I., Lapeyre, F., & Lemaître, A. (Eds.). (2013). Securing livelihoods: Informal economy practices and institutions. Oxford University Press.

 

Polanyi, K. (1977). The livelihood of man. Academia Press.

 

Ruiz-Rivera, M.-J., & Lemaître, A. (2019). Popular and Solidarity Economy in Ecuador: Historical overview, institutional trajectories and types of organisations. In M. Nyssens, L. I. Gaiger, & F. Wanderley (Eds.), Social enterprise in Latin America: Theory, models and practice (pp. 139–168). Routledge.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The policy capacity framework (PCF) outlined by Wu, Ramesh, and Howlett states that the development of knowledge and skills through education programs affects the functioning of public policies and is a determinant of governments' political capacity. Even though this relationship between education and political capability has been established in the academic literature, training programs have been understudied. This study aims to examine the competencies and skills that Master of Public Policy (MPP) and Master of Public Administration (MPA) programs in Latin America intend to instill in their students, as well as the efficacy of the Policy Capacity Framework in achieving this goal. To do so, I analyze nineteen public policy master's programs that meet NASPAA's MPP and MPA degree classifications, focusing on their descriptions, objectives, graduation profiles, and curriculum structure. This study adds deontological and human capacity to the original framework's analytical, operational, and political capacities. The findings show and discuss the regional contribution to the training of future policymakers and public managers rethinking the PCF and open new avenues for studying how competencies and capabilities affect policy change using the five-component framework.

 

 

Key words: Policy Capacity Framework, Policy change, MPA and MPP Education, Teaching Public Policy,  Latin America.