W03. Analyzing and conceptualizing international public policies: towards a sociology of the policy process approach
Policy Process, Policy MakingCATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
Since the 1990s the attention of public policy scholars has increasingly shifted from the national (and European) level to the international and global levels of public policy (Knill and Tosun, 2013: 223). With the second globalization, associated to growing economic and technological interdependency between states, so as to the acceleration of international transport and communication possibilities, public policies are more and more analyzed beyond the Nation State.
This shift of the attention from national (and local) levels to supranational levels has triggered two evolutions in the literature. The first one is the development of “global policies” studies, as the creation of journals dedicated to these new policy levels illustrates (Global Policy, Global Social Policy…). Global public policies can be defined as: “the processes of transnational cooperation and conflict, involving both state and non-state (domestic and international) agents, by which policies are produced to problems related to the global scale” (Porto de Oliveira, 2022: 63). The focus is on the role of transnational actors and interactions in the global circulation of policy ideas and policy instruments. It encompasses different supranational dimensions of a public policy.
The making of public policy in a context of globalization is subject to circulations, transfers and adaptations according to dominant accounts of 'best practices'. While the intensification of these flows is widely acknowledged and public policy and administration studies have developed sound comparative approaches, relatively less attention is being paid to the analysis and conceptualization of international public policy-making by states but also international public administrations and their bureaucracies, transnational corporations and their forms of transnational mobilization, as well as transnational NGOs and citizen grassroots organizations and their transnational reach.
This is why this workshop is more focused on the second perspective: the analysis of international public policies, combining public policy and international relations perspectives. Even if the difference and boundaries with global public policies is not always clear and the overlaps are important, the notion of international public policy is more specifically focused on the role of international (intergovernmental) organizations in the tackling of policy issues historically developed at local and national levels. Our specific objective is to foreground sociological analyses of international policy-making and policy processes (notably issue framing, agenda setting, policy formulation, decision-making and implementation).
The development of international public policies has started with the shaping of the first international organizations in the second half of the 19th century for transport, trade, communication and public health issues. This trend has been strengthened with the creation of new international organizations after WWII, in relation with the United Nations, especially for refugees (HCR), health (WHO), food and agriculture issues (FAO), and for global economic governance with the Bretton Woods institutions. The scope of public policies tackled by international organizations has widened at the end of the 20th century with the creation of the UNEP (1972) and the WTO (1994). International organizations have become a classical dimension of international relations, yet they are still marginal in the public policy field which has more developed the analysis of transnational actors, especially transnational expertise, based on the notion of “epistemic communities” (Haas, 1992).
In international relations perspectives the role of international organizations has been notably analyzed with the notion of “international regimes” (Krasner, 1983), which has been adapted to public policies issues (especially international trade) and not only to issues linked to war and peace. The starting point of this workshop is the analysis of the shaping and development of international public policy regimes combining the four dimensions of a public policy (Hassenteufel, 2021):
-a dominant orientation, based on the framing of the key policy issues, in relation with the use of knowledge and values;
-international and transnational actors structured around these issues: international organizations, NGOs, think tanks, multinational companies, foundations, epistemic communities…;
-institutionalized rules of interactions between international, national and transnational policy actors;
-policy instruments: not only regulatory also financial, fiscal, economic…
The aim of the workshop is to discuss methodological and conceptual issues related to international public policy regimes in various policy fields: health, migrations, environment, food and agriculture, trade, energy, economic development, education, social policies, financial and monetary regulation…
From a methodological point of view, the focus of the workshop is on the sociological analysis of these international and transnational policy actors at the different stages of international public policy processes:
-Problem framing by various actors and agenda setting in international organizations and arenas;
-Policy formulation, focusing on the role of international and transnational expertise in the shaping of international policy instruments;
-Policy decision, based on international negotiations on policy issues, including geopolitical and political dimensions for the understanding of the position and strategies of the participating states;
-Policy implementation in a multi-level perspective, considering that most of the international public policy instruments are not compulsory (soft law, incentives…), what gives more room to national and local actors involved in the implementation than at other policy levels.
Therefore, the main methodological issues raised by this workshop are:
-the internal analysis of international organizations and of transnational actors with qualitative methods (ethnography, observation…), used in public administration and international relations (Ege, Bauer, 2013), also in sociology of mobilization and sociology of interest groups perspectives;
-the interactions between the different policy actors acting in international arenas (also between international organizations which often compete on the same policy issues, between states with different political and geopolitical orientations, between transnational actors who are often structured in coalitions…) by using qualitative (interviews, observation…) and quantitative methods (especially network analysis);
-the empirical analysis of the implementation of international policy instruments at national and local levels.
Our workshop thus seeks to bring together contributions from a wide range of sectors, across different levels of analysis, and in relation to different categories of actors in order to nourish collective discussions around the making and implementation of international public policies. To illustrate these points through a few emblematic examples, we can mention key international actors in the fields of health, migration and the environment, such as the WHO, the IOM and the UNFCC. While these three thematic issues arguably undergo an intensification of internationalization by being increasingly constructed as a ‘global issue’, the corresponding international regimes raise different, yet complementary, conceptual questions.
While international health regulations of the World Health Organization (WHO) date back to 1969, the organization has since then developed a series of global policy tools. It has for instance encouraged the creation of ‘public health emergency operations centers’ at national levels for the dissemination of best practices and it has built a global network around them. This IO has also established in 2011 the ‘Pandemic Influenza Preparedness Framework’ to facilitate creation and access of influenza vaccines, supporting hence international convergence in health-related public policies. More recently, the elaboration of the ‘Covid-19 Strategic Preparedness and Response Plan’ has foregrounded the organization’s global policy reach. While the WHO represents a key actor for health-related international public policies, notably through the establishment of global health standards, the deployment of capacity-building programs and the implementation of global public awareness campaigns, it is facing criticism regarding transparency in policy formulation and decision which foregrounds the broader question of legitimacy and constituency for the policy cycle of international public policies.
In the field of migration governance, a stronghold of sovereign power, the past decades have also seen the development of supranational instruments, notably following the 2016 New York declaration for migrants and refugees, adopted by the UN General Assembly, that acknowledged the need for more international cooperation and paved the way for the 2018 Global Compact for Safe, Orderly and Regular Migration. While the Compact is not legally binding and has thus been critiqued as to its limited policy implementation potential, the inclusive process that led to its adoption, with an active role played by NGOs and civil society organizations at different preparatory stages, sustains the instrument’s relevance to migration-related public policies and the international arenas thus created carve out space for enhanced policy transfers.
Our third example, policies and instruments under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change amount by now to a UN climate change regime with a complex and continuously developing governance. The 2015 Paris Agreement represent for instance a global and legally binding treaty articulated with national public policies through climate action plans that determine countries’ state-level contributions. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) constitutes furthermore a primary example of a transnational epistemic community holding an institutionalized role in setting an agenda for the making of international climate policies (De Pryck, 2022).
Overall, the aim of this workshop is to go a step further in the conceptualization of the development of international public policies by combining different analytical perspectives analyzing sociologically international relations and policy processes : sociology of internal organizations, the role of international and transnational policy communities in the framing of policy issues, analysis of multilevel negotiations, the structuration of instrument constituencies, the mobilization and structuration of transnational policy actors…
CALL FOR PAPERS
The making of public policy in a context of globalization is subject to circulations, transfers and adaptations according to dominant accounts of 'best practices'. While the intensification of these flows is widely acknowledged and studies of global public policies have been developed, relatively less attention is being paid to the analysis and conceptualization of international public policy-making. This is why this workshop is focused on the analysis of international public policies, combining public policy and international relations perspectives. Even if the difference and boundaries with global public policies is not always clear and the overlaps are important, the notion of international public policy is more specifically focused on the role of international (intergovernmental) organizations in the tackling of policy issues, historically developed at local and national levels. Our specific objective is to foreground sociological analyses of international policy-making and policy processes (notably issue framing, agenda setting, policy formulation, decision-making and implementation).
In international relations perspectives the role of international organizations has been notably analyzed with the notion of “international regimes” (Krasner, 1983), which has been adapted to public policies issues (especially international trade) and not only to issues linked to war and peace. The starting point of this workshop is the analysis of the shaping and development of international public policy regimes combining the four dimensions of a public policy (Hassenteufel, 2021):
-a dominant orientation, based on the framing of the key policy issues, in relation with the use of knowledge and values;
-international and transnational actors structured around these issues: international organizations, NGOs, think tanks, multinational companies, foundations, epistemic communities…;
-institutionalized rules of interactions between international, national and transnational policy actors;
-policy instruments: not only regulatory also financial, fiscal, economic…
In this workshop we want to discuss methodological and conceptual issues related to international public policy regimes with papers analyzing various policy fields such as health, migrations, environment, food and agriculture, trade, energy, economic development, education, social policies, financial and monetary regulation…
From a methodological point of view, the focus is on the sociological analysis of these international and transnational policy actors at the different stages of international public policy processes. We welcome papers raising methodological issues such as:
-the internal analysis of international organizations and of transnational actors with qualitative methods (ethnography, observation…), used in public administration and international relations (Ege, Bauer, 2013), also in sociology of mobilization and sociology of interest groups perspectives;
-the interactions between the different policy actors acting in international arenas (also between international organizations which often compete on the same policy issues, between states with different political and geopolitical orientations, between transnational actors who are often structured in coalitions…) by using qualitative (interviews, observation…) and quantitative methods (especially network analysis);
-the empirical analysis of the implementation of international policy instruments at national and local levels.
Overall, the aim of this workshop is to go a step further in the conceptualization of the development of international public policies by combining different analytical perspectives analyzing sociologically international relations and policy processes in different policy fields.
ABSTRACT
This workshop is focused on the analysis of international public policies, combining public policy and international relations perspectives. Even if the difference and boundaries with global public policies is not always clear and the overlaps are important, the notion of international public policy is more specifically focused on the role of international (intergovernmental) organizations in the tackling of policy issues, historically developed at local and national levels. Our specific objective is to foreground sociological analyses of international policy-making and policy processes (notably issue framing, agenda setting, policy formulation, decision-making and implementation).
In international relations perspectives the role of international organizations has been notably analyzed with the notion of “international regimes” (Krasner, 1983), which has been adapted to public policies issues. The starting point of this workshop is the analysis of the shaping and development of international public policy regimes combining the four dimensions of a public policy (Hassenteufel, 2021):
-a dominant orientation, based on the framing of the key policy issues, in relation with the use of knowledge and values;
-international and transnational actors structured around these issues;
-institutionalized rules of interactions between international, national and transnational policy actors;
-policy instruments.
In this workshop we want to discuss methodological and conceptual issues related to international public policy regimes with papers analyzing various policy fields such as health, migrations, environment, food and agriculture, trade, energy, economic development, education, social policies, financial and monetary regulation…
From a methodological point of view, the focus is on the sociological analysis of these international and transnational policy actors at the different stages of international public policy processes.
Overall, the aim of this workshop is to go a step further in the conceptualization of the development of international public policies by combining different analytical perspectives analyzing sociologically international relations and policy processes in different policy fields.
BIOGRAPHICAL PRESENTATION
Patrick Hassenteufel is professor of political science at the University of Paris-Saclay (Graduate School Sociology and Political Science). His main research field is healthcare. His current research is on the territorialization of healthcare systems in Europe, in a multilevel perspective.
Nina Sahraoui is CNRS assistant professor at the University of Paris-Saclay (Graduate School Sociology and Political Science). Her main research field is migration. Her current research is on climate migrations in a multilevel and multi-situated comparative perspective.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
There is growing evidence that severe polarization creates harmful consequences for democracy, such as an increase in support for extremist leaders (Iyengar et al., 2012), a reduction of electoral accountability (Pierson & Schickler, 2020), a deterioration in democratic quality (McCoy & Somer, 2019) and making governance more difficult (Levendusky, 2018). Consequently, we need to learn more about the effects of polarization on public policymaking, mainly when there is more than one country involved. In the case of Mexico and the United States, their relationship has been dominated by trade, immigration, and security issues. However, many other policy fields involve the two countries, such as environmental protection, water management, healthcare, and others. Our paper investigates the core beliefs and perceptions among future policy elites in Mexico and the United States since these might have wide-ranging, long-term policy implications regarding bilateral cooperation. It aims to fill a gap in the existing literature on political polarization by investigating to what extent the rising polarization levels in Mexico and the United States affect the perception of future policy elites of the neighboring country and become an obstacle for binational policy collaboration.
The paper is based on a survey conducted between September 2023 and January 2024 (n=515). Its target population is graduate students enrolled in academic programs that prepare them to influence the public sphere, such as public policy, global affairs, and public management in the United States' border states and Mexico. Data were collected through an online questionnaire with around 65 questions, including civic participation, discrimination and inequality, interpersonal and institutional trust, rule of law, government intervention and individual freedom, accountability and corruption, and views on the neighboring country's public affairs. We find that higher levels of polarization among respondents correlate with their willingness to increase collaboration between the US and Mexico, while simultaneously limiting the topics that collaboration is meant to cover. We find higher levels of partisan polarization in the US, while similar levels of partisan discontent are found in both countries.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Despite scholar and media portraits stating the UN secretary-general as one of the most vocal voices in global climate governance, his role remains understudied and understood as having little formal authority and no material power in global policymaking. What is the real capacity of the SG to influence global policymaking and keep a policy agenda active? Through the study of the climate agendas of the last two UN Secretary-generals, Ban Ki-moon and António Guterres, this paper shows that the SG is a global policy entrepreneur capable of creating and seize the opportunities for climate action.
By tracing the secretary-general’s practices on a particular policy sector, and through observations and interviews, we show that the SG uses both, political and bureaucratic strategies at every moment of the global policymaking process, from problem framing to policy evaluation. As a traditional policy entrepreneur, the SG uses its moral authority and symbolic traditional position as a ‘norm entrepreneur’ to frame the problems and his preferred solutions and encourage agenda setting and decision-making in multilateral arenas. As an innovative policy entrepreneur, however, the SG concretizes a material power when he plays with time and space by multiplying venues for action and precipitating political engagement for policy implementation and conducting evaluations when other UN organs are unable or unwilling to act. Our study concludes that more than a ‘guardian’ of the UN commitments the SG has the ability to influence global policymaking by keeping the window of opportunity open and hence inducing policy change and innovation.
Our research combines the “multiple streams” framework with the study of leadership and power in international arenas. It fits the workshop’s main focus by analysing the shaping and development of one international policy (climate change) through the study of one of the influential but not powerful actors in the global governance (the UN secretary-general).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Despite nearly 50 years since urban planning was institutionalized in Mexico, it has had limited effectiveness in guiding cities to evolve according to their urban development plans, leading to deficiencies and contradictions in the processes of growth and change in Mexican cities (Castro, 2018; Rébora, 2017). These changes can be observed, particularly during moments such as the creation of the first General Law of Human Settlements, its reform in 2016, and more recently, the reform to replace the term "adequate and decent housing" with "adequate housing."
These shifts in urban policy share a common factor: the United Nations Conference on Human Settlements (Habitat I, II, and III) and the creation of international instruments and agendas that transfer ideas and knowledge to national and subnational levels in various countries (Paulsen-Espinoza, 2023; Stren, 2021). This has generated a reliance on 'urban solutionism' (Montero, 2018), driven by international organizations which influences spatial governance and planning in countries and cities of the Global South (Blanc, Cotella, & Dąbrowski, 2023).
In the case of Mexico, the country stands out for promoting significant changes in urban policy in light of the activities of UN-Habitat, aligning with processes of policy transfer. This transfer is understood as a "process by which knowledge of certain policies, administrative arrangements, institutions, and ideas in a political environment (past or present) is used for the development, administrative arrangements, institutions, and ideas in another political environment" (Dolowitz & Marsh, 2000, p. 5). This transfer can occur between international organizations, countries, regions, cities, states, etc.
In this regard, this presentation aims to analyze the role of UN-Habitat in the changes to Mexican urban policy, questioning the nature of the policy transfer UN-Habitat makes to Mexico. The hypothesis is that this transfer process is voluntary, following the characterization of Dolowitz & Marsh (2000:13), where the transfer is driven by the need or desire for international acceptance. To this end, a minimalist process tracing (Beach & Pedersen, 2019) will be conducted to analyze diachronically the creation of the first General Law of Human Settlements in Mexico (1976) with its last reform (2016), to understand the mechanism that drove such change and the type of devolution to which the coalitions of each moment aligned themselves.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The objective of this paper is to further conceptualise transnational policy communities, using the empirical case of the anti-corruption community. Diane Stone coined the term ‘transnational policy community’ (TPC), understood as “a cohesive and bounded groups of professionals from different countries who diffuse shared ideas and practices globally”.[1] Recent research on the transnationalisation of policy suggest that actors situated between sectors and levels of governance, operating at the interaction of states, IOs, public and private sectors, and circulating between them are becoming increasingly common and thus relevant for the study of public policymaking.[2] This makes it all the more important to further develop the concept of transnational policy community, to understand their role in the development of international public policy. Using documentary analysis, interviews with stakeholders and network analysis, this paper applies the concept to the field of international anti-corruption policy, studying the main actors and organisations involved in shaping anti-corruption policy at the international level as well as their interactions, to understand how they facilitate the spread of anti-corruption “best practices”. More than the emergence of isolated international policy brokers, the paper argue that it is their collaboration and exchanges that allowed the spread of anti-corruption instruments, for it created a form of anti-corruption paradigm and shaped the cognitive environment for international and national policy-making. It shows that international organisations and (transnational) actors involved in anti-corruption work perceive themselves as sharing a common understanding of corruption and as working together towards the same goal. Through their collaboration, practices and discourse, they built a policy community that divides labour among members and goes beyond the traditional boundaries of policy-making to include non-state actors operating at the transnational level. The existence of a transnational policy community composed of influential organisations with different mandates and memberships sharing core beliefs narrows down the conflictual space and makes international anti-corruption work largely paradigmatic. This community has progressively grown, through the circulation of actors, members’ efforts to reach out to new audiences and socialising them to a shared conception of corruption and anti-corruption work. In doing so, it even managed to integrate – and mollify – critical views. This has contributed to defuse outside criticism (from academia principally) by giving it a voice inside policy forums. The seeming unity of the policy community and the knowledge it produces contributes to legitimise the policy solutions it prescribed as consensually-agreed ‘good practices’. The selection of policy solutions to promote are however partly the result of unequal power distribution within the community and advocacy of policy pioneers who sought to convince others to emulate their model.
[1] STONE, Diane. Global Public Policy, Transnational Policy Communities, and Their Networks. Policy Studies Journal, Vol. 36, no 1, 2008, pp. 30-31.
[2] Hassenteufel, Patrick. Sociologie politique de l’action publique. 3e éd. [s.l.] : Armand Colin. 2021; STONE, Diane et Kim MOLONEY. The Oxford Handbook of Global Policy and Transnational Administration. Oxford University Press, 2019.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Health policy is increasingly informed by the ideas, strategic plans, advice and data emanating from global health institutions and organisations. In this paper, we focus on a recently influential concept in global health that has yet to garner close attention from public policy scholars, that of ‘vaccine hesitancy’. The ‘hesitancy’ concept has been used in technical and policy circles over the last decade to explain declines in vaccine uptake, with the World Health Organization declaring vaccine hesitancy one of its top ten threats to human health in 2019. We contribute to aims of the workshop by tracing the knowledge contests and institutional factors that shaped its emergence under the auspices of the WHO and subsequent dissemination to domestic policymakers. We draw on in-depth interviews with global vaccination experts and analysis of documents and publications from a WHO working group that developed the concept between 2011 and 2014.
In one sense, we describe a case of an expert group meeting the moment by delineating a concept that has found widespread usage not only among vaccine social scientists, but also political leaders, media and citizens, especially since COVID-19. At the same time, hesitancy has been controversial. Critics have accused governments of using the concept to unfairly blame vulnerable citizens for slower than expected vaccine uptake, and have raised concerns about the inappropriate use of coercive instruments such as mandates in response to uptake issues.
We argue that these tensions can be traced in part to the initial elaboration of the concept. The working group defined hesitancy as something of a ‘polysemic’ catch-all for a range of drivers of non-vaccination, including uncertainty about safety and access barriers. This was done at the behest of key members of the working group, who – seeing a broader shift in the focus of global vaccination policy towards attitudes and behaviours – wanted to ensure that attention on structural barriers to vaccination remained. The broad framing helped to enable agreement and likely contributed to the successful dissemination of the concept – working group members were able to generate evidence that hesitancy was a globally significant health challenge. However, by being tethered to a concept that is most easily understood as being focused on individuals and their choices, structural barriers to vaccination are in some ways left ‘hiding in plain sight’. The case therefore highlights the challenges expert groups face in framing authoritative advice for domestic policymakers, especially where evidence is piecemeal and problems highly complex.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The main goal of this work is to analyze the effect of judicial resolutions from international courts on local public policies. The judicial system, through its exclusive powers as an agent that guarantees (in Western democracies) constitutional supremacy, has the power to veto, confirm or modify public policies submitted for consideration; At the international level, international courts, such as the Inter-American Court, the European Court of Human Rights, among others, have the power to impose resolutions on States, which can represent paradigm shifts in terms of the definition and construction of the public policies in the countries involved. The question that guides this work is: How does the judicial power from the international level affect public policies? To answer this question, a methodology has been developed based on an analysis matrix, that allows quantifying the effects of judicial resolutions and thus determining the degree of influence in each of the stages of the policy cycle. This research is directly related to the study of global public policies, based on research focused on international courts as determining actors in the field of global public policies.
The presentation of the research would be in person.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Cash transfer programs (CTPs) emerged in the mid-nineties and spread across Latin America and the Caribbean, subsequently expanding globally. This paper explores the influence of international organizations (IOs) programmatic ideas on the proliferation of CTPs, focusing on the case of the "Human Development Bonus" (BDH) in Ecuador, during 1998-2003. The hypothesis posited is that IOs' programmatic ideas regarding CTPs, framed as instruments to combat poverty, permeate the national landscape, as instruments for supporting the most poor and vulnerable families, through mechanisms of coercion, emulation, and learning. From a deductive approach and the perspective of critical realism, this research employs sociological neoinstitutionalism to analyze public policy networks, aiming to elucidate the diffusion mechanisms involved by identifying actors and their interrelations, and measuring the behaviors of policy networks and their members. Document analysis and semi-structured interviews were applied.
Three diffusion mechanisms are delineated. Firstly, indirect coercion for the adoption of cash transfers stemming from the dominant influence of the International Monetary Fund and World Bank (WB), as structural adjustment reforms advocated in the Washington Consensus led to the inception of the Solidarity Bonus (BS). Secondly, learning, whereby the BDH draws from instruments of other governments such as "Identification and Selection System of Potential Beneficiaries of Social Programs" in Chile and "Bolsa Escola" (BE) in Brazil, adapted locally to enhance targeting via the "Identification and Selection System of Beneficiaries of Social Programs", and to promote school attendance through conditional cash transfers known as the "School Scholarship", respectly. Thirdly, direct coercion, supported by the authoritative influence of the WB and the Inter-American Development Bank, which facilitated the transformation of the BS into the BDH by imposing educational and healthcare conditionalities as prerequisites for loan disbursement, following the examples set by programs such as "Oportunidades" in Mexico and BE in Brazil. Emulation was not identified due to the influence of national contexts and technical capabilities in program design.
Although, the origin of the BDH is endogenous, since it began as a fiscal policy instrument in response to the political and economic situation of that time, subsequently, it transformed into a social policy instrument. This research shows how programmatic ideas can coexist and evolve over time. While initially BDH was conceived under the programmatic idea of "compensation for the poorest families," ideas such as "targeting" and "school attendance" were later integrated to enhance transfer delivery and ensure the educational engagement of minors, ultimately converging into the broader programmatic idea of "protection and enhancement of human, physical, and social capital".
This paper fits with the workshop research questions by providing insights into the spread of CTPs and the influence of international organizations' programmatic ideas. By examining the diffusion of CTPs towards the BDH through the lens of sociological neoinstitutionalism, which views policy networks as institutions shaping the actions of participating actors, we were able to identify the involved diffusion mechanisms, evolving relationships among actors, and their programmatic ideas. Analyzing public policy networks enabled us to characterize the connections between actors and assess the behavior of the network and its members, thus identifying key actors and intermediaries.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Against the backdrop of unprecedented levels of displacement due to ongoing conflicts, climate change, and persecution, the need for a comprehensive approach to migration became clear. The 2018 United Nations Global Compact for Safe, Orderly, and Regular Migration (hereafter ‘The Compact’) is a ground breaking intergovernmental agreement aimed at addressing the multifaceted and interconnected challenges posed by global migration. This paper will delve into the complex negotiation process of The Compact, while also highlighting its unique challenges and lessons learned for future policies. In terms of methodology, I will be looking at political discourse (e.g. social media, interviews, press releases), national migration policies, academic articles, and interviewing several migration experts (i.e. academics/researchers at universities, NGOs, and United Nations specialized agencies) to shed light on both the conceptualization of this international agreement and the implementation challenges given its non-compulsory nature. The paper will pay particular attention to the role of international and transnational actors, relating it directly to the workshop’s stated objectives. The Compact came as a result of extensive negotiations and consultations of a diverse range of stakeholders including states, civil society, international organizations, and NGOs. A key consideration for The Compact was an understanding that international collaboration was needed to properly address the complexities around contemporary migration/mobility. The Compact, despite its shortcomings, reflects a new approach to migration that is more cooperative, transcending state borders. This paper will aim to explore the following research question: What were the key challenges and compromises faced by the different stakeholders (states, international organizations/NGOs, civil society, etc.) in formulating – and now implementing – the UN Global Compact for Safe, Orderly, and Regular Migration? In analyzing this negotiation process, we will be able to see how states navigated unbalanced power relations, conflicting national interests, and difficult compromises to achieve this agreement. Furthermore, balancing safe, orderly, and regular migration while ensuring that the rights of migrants are safeguarded proved to be challenging in light of conflicting interests. Despite this tension, the participation of advocacy groups and NGOs in the negotiation process meant that a human-rights based approach was at the forefront. Therefore, this paper will dive into the ways in which human rights principles have been upheld and where they fall short. In conclusion, this paper will offer an analysis of the making of the 2018 UN Global Compact for Safe, Orderly, and Regular. By examining the intricate dynamics of shaping The Compact, this paper contributes to a deeper understanding of the complexities around crafting international policies, particularly in the context of addressing global issues like migration. At this time, I prefer to present onsite. However, I am open to presenting online too.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This research critically engages with the international legal and political mechanisms shaping contemporary social and environmental governance, centering its inquiry on the normative, institutional, and epistemological underpinnings of poverty eradication strategies within the framework of Agenda 2030, particularly SDG1's ambitious goal of eradicating poverty by 2030. The study is predicated on the hypothesis that the mainstream international approach to poverty eradication, as encapsulated by the SDGs, is fundamentally limited in its capacity to realize its transformative agenda due to its inherent a-historical, depoliticised, and segregationist nature. The research interrogates the historical, ideological, operational, and implementation dimensions of SDG1 and its related targets, aiming to reveal the contours and constraints of international legal forms in combating poverty and advancing social progress.
Methodologically, the research adopts an interdisciplinary approach, drawing on insights from post-colonial, Third World, and Marxist theories of international law. It critically examines the conceptualization, definition, and measurement of poverty by international legal institutions, the development and application of poverty eradication strategies, and the ideological assumptions that underlie current efforts. The research navigates through the historical development of global governance mechanisms, the post-colonial and capitalist dimensions of international legal structures, and the role of global governance mechanisms, especially Agenda 2030 and the SDGs, in shaping poverty eradication strategies.
Central to this inquiry is the exploration of how international law has historically addressed poverty, shedding light on the continuity of colonial patterns of power and exploitation and their implications for contemporary global poverty. The research critiques the dominant technocratic and managerialist spirit that characterizes global governance, highlighting its detachment from anti-colonial traditions and its failure to address the systemic, structural, and relational character of poverty. It contends that the SDGs' approach is marked by a failure to engage with the historical processes and power dynamics that perpetuate poverty, particularly in the Global South.
By delving into the theoretical underpinnings of poverty measurement and the evolving concept of poverty within the global context, the research aims to contribute to a more nuanced understanding of poverty as a systemic, structural, and relational challenge. It seeks to unveil the limitations and blind spots in the SDGs' approach to poverty eradication, arguing that the contemporary international legal and political forms are insufficient for promoting genuine transformation and cooperation necessary for sustainable development and poverty eradication.
In conclusion, this research aspires to enrich the scholarly discourse on poverty eradication within the context of Agenda 2030, illuminating the complexities inherent in global poverty eradication efforts and suggesting more effective and sustainable strategies. It aligns with the workshop's research questions by offering a critical analysis of the legal and political structures that govern global poverty eradication efforts, thereby contributing to the broader understanding of global poverty dynamics and the potential for systemic change.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Abstract:
This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of strategies to combat extremism among youth and enhance women's rights in the Middle East, with a focus on how educational and policy reforms, as well as international cooperation, can lead to a more stable and equitable region. In the context of recent progressive reforms in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas, this study explores pathways towards peace and mutual acceptance.
The primary research question investigates effective strategies for reducing extremism among youth and strengthening the status of women in Middle Eastern societies. The paper utilizes a multi-methodological approach, encompassing both qualitative and quantitative research methods. This includes an extensive review of existing literature, expert interviews, case studies, and surveys conducted among young individuals across various Middle Eastern countries.
A key aspect of this research is the analysis of recent reforms in Saudi Arabia, which have shown significant progress in women's empowerment and a move towards moderating extremist ideologies. These reforms include allowing women to drive, increasing their participation in the workforce, and a general liberalization of some social norms. The paper evaluates the impact of these reforms on societal attitudes and their potential as a model for other Middle Eastern countries.
Moreover, the paper addresses the conflict between Israel and Hamas in Gaza as a representation of extremist ideologies among Middle Eastern youth. This conflict highlights the challenges posed by entrenched hostilities and the importance of developing strategies that not only counter extremism but also promote dialogue and understanding between conflicting parties.
The study suggests several strategies to prevent the youth in the Middle East from succumbing to extremist ideologies. These include:
Educational Initiatives: Developing curricula that emphasize critical thinking, human rights, and gender equality, to foster a more tolerant and open-minded youth populace.
Media Engagement: Utilizing media to challenge stereotypes and promote narratives of coexistence and mutual respect, particularly between genders and across cultural divides.
Economic Empowerment and Job Creation: Providing economic opportunities to both men and women, particularly in regions afflicted by conflict, to reduce the allure of extremist groups.
Legal and Policy Reforms: Advocating for laws and policies that uphold women's rights and promote gender equality, thereby creating a more inclusive and fair society.
International Diplomacy and Peace Efforts: Encouraging international cooperation to resolve regional conflicts, including the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, thereby reducing one of the key drivers of extremism in the region.
By implementing these strategies, this paper argues that it is possible to create a future where young people in the Middle East respect women's positions, human rights, and embrace gender equality. Such a future would contribute to a stable and peaceful Middle East, where nations and peoples, including Israelis and Palestinians, live in harmony and mutual acceptance.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Title: Epistemic communities or communities of instruments? International food policies through the lens of expertise
International food policies are structured around the global food security paradigm based on agricultural productivism and the defense of free trade (Fouilleux et al., 2017). This paradigm is the product of a "complex of regimes" dominated by international organizations in charge of trade, the latter having appropriated the food issue in the 1990s alongside the human rights regime, to the detriment of organizations in charge of undernourishment and malnutrition in place since the Second World War (Margulis, 2013). To what extent was this paradigm challenged by the price spike of 2007/2008, which coincided with the IPCC experts' questioning of the agricultural sector's responsibility for climate change? The article examines how this food and climate emergency was used by various stakeholders to form an alternative "epistemic community" challenging the established one. Following the methods classically associated with this concept (Haas, 1992; Hopkins, 1992), the research first focused on the transformation of knowledge production through an ethnographic and scientometric study. This study was complemented by a sociology of the main instruments of global food governance (statistics, models, expert reports, standards) aimed at relating the instruments defended by the alternative community to those of the established community. The instrumental approach - rather than the sole tracking of experts - is defended here because it overcomes several of the limitations of the epistemic community concept. Instruments, as tools of proof as much as of government, make it possible to evacuate the mechanical vision of influence on decision-making at work in the concept of epistemic community (Cross, 2013). This focus also makes it possible to go beyond P. Haas's reified vision of knowledge at work, to defend instead an STS perspective that considers the latter to be co-produced by political and scientific actors (Demortain, 2017; Haas, 2017): in so doing, it offers a more dynamic vision of change over the course of instruments. The analysis shows that an alternative community is being structured in the context of the food and climate crisis, but that it is weakly instrumented, which ultimately explains its low impact on decision-making.
Bibliography
Cross, Mai’a K. Davis. 2013. “Rethinking Epistemic Communities Twenty Years Later”. Review of International Studies 39(1):137‑60.
Demortain, David. 2017. “Experts and the Production of International Policy Knowledge: Do Epistemic Communities Do the Job?” p. 76 in The Politics of Expertise in International
Organizations. Routledge.
Fouilleux, Ève, Nicolas Bricas, et Arlène Alpha. 2017. « Feeding 9 billion people… Global food security debates and the productionist trap ». Journal of European Public Policy 24 (11): 1658-1677.
Haas, Peter M. 1992, “Introduction: Epistemic Communities and International Policy
Coordination ». International Organization 46(1):1‑35.
Haas, Peter M. 2017. « Coupling Science to Governance: Straddling the Science-Policy Interface ». In The Politics of Expertise in International Organizations, Littoz-Monnet Annabelle. Oxon and New York: Routledge.
Hopkins, Raymond F. 1992. « Reform in the International Food Aid Regime: The Role of Consensual Knowledge ». International Organization 46 (1): 225‑64.
Margulis, Matias E. 2013. “The Regime Complex for Food Security. Implications for the Global Hunger Challenge”. Global Governance 19(1): 53-67.
I consider presenting online.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since the 1990s the attention of public policy scholars has increasingly shifted from the national (and European) level to the international and global levels of public policy (Knill and Tosun, 2013: 223). With the second globalization, associated to growing economic and technological interdependency between states, so as to the acceleration of international transport and communication possibilities, public policies are more and more analyzed beyond the Nation State.
This shift of the attention from national (and local) levels to supranational levels has triggered two evolutions in the literature. The first one is the development of “global policies” studies, as the creation of journals dedicated to these new policy levels illustrates (Global Policy, Global Social Policy…). Global public policies can be defined as: “the processes of transnational cooperation and conflict, involving both state and non-state (domestic and international) agents, by which policies are produced to problems related to the global scale” (Porto de Oliveira, 2022: 63). The focus is on the role of transnational actors and interactions in the global circulation of policy ideas and policy instruments. It encompasses different supranational dimensions of a public policy.
The making of public policy in a context of globalization is subject to circulations, transfers and adaptations according to dominant accounts of 'best practices'. While the intensification of these flows is widely acknowledged and public policy and administration studies have developed sound comparative approaches, relatively less attention is being paid to the analysis and conceptualization of international public policy-making by states but also international public administrations and their bureaucracies, transnational corporations and their forms of transnational mobilization, as well as transnational NGOs and citizen grassroots organizations and their transnational reach.
This is why this paper is focused on the second perspective: the analysis of international public policies, combining public policy and international relations perspectives. Even if the difference and boundaries with global public policies is not always clear and the overlaps are important, the notion of international public policy is more specifically focused on the role of international (intergovernmental) organizations in the tackling of policy issues historically developed at local and national levels. Our specific objective is to foreground sociological analyses of international policy-making and policy processes (notably issue framing, agenda setting, policy formulation, decision-making and implementation).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The WHO’s Mental Health Action Plan (MHAP) provides a strategic framework to advance mental health at global and regional levels. Failing to meet the original 2020 goals, the MHAP was extended to 2030, with revised objectives and targets. Whilst the global mental health movement has significantly gained traction, multiple challenges continue to hinder progress including weak political will, fragmented policy processes and health systems, and insufficient data and financing.
This study examines how four WHO member-countries (Canada, Guyana, Cuba and USA) have adopted the MHAP and explores their contributions to the global mental health targets. This research employs a mixed-method, multi-case study approach. Given the global scope of the WHO’s state membership, the regional focus for this study is narrowed down to the Americas, where the global burden of NCDs is the highest. Quantitative data is acquired via the WHO’s Mental Health Atlas 2020 country data reports and relevant national policy documents. Qualitative interviews are conducted with subject matter experts, scholars, WHO/PAHO and national health ministry officials. The Shiffman and Smith framework on generation of political priority for global health issues is utilized to organize and assess qualitative data.
Findings show that whilst Guyana and Canada have achieved targets ahead of the MHAP’s 2030 goal, Cuba and USA have thus far made minimal contributions. Lessons include the power of political cohesion in implementing mental health policies and initiatives, as demonstrated by Guyana’s whole-of-government and whole-of-society approach, presenting a learning opportunity in multi-polar policy innovation and adaptation for varying contexts and nations.
Key reflections include; the need for the emerging field of mental health diplomacy as an innovative cross-sectoral tool to advance global mental health; the role of neuroaesthetics in building economies, societies and cities centered for well-being, and for improved circulation of knowledge between Global South-South and Global South-North.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
There is growing evidence that severe polarization creates harmful consequences for democracy, such as an increase in support for extremist leaders (Iyengar et al., 2012), a reduction of electoral accountability (Pierson & Schickler, 2020), a deterioration in democratic quality (McCoy & Somer, 2019) and making governance more difficult (Levendusky, 2018). Consequently, we need to learn more about the effects of polarization on public policymaking, mainly when there is more than one country involved. In the case of Mexico and the United States, their relationship has been dominated by trade, immigration, and security issues. However, many other policy fields involve the two countries, such as environmental protection, water management, healthcare, and others. Our paper investigates the core beliefs and perceptions among future policy elites in Mexico and the United States since these might have wide-ranging, long-term policy implications regarding bilateral cooperation. It aims to fill a gap in the existing literature on political polarization by investigating to what extent the rising polarization levels in Mexico and the United States affect the perception of future policy elites of the neighboring country and become an obstacle for binational policy collaboration.
The paper is based on a survey conducted between September 2023 and January 2024 (n=515). Its target population is graduate students enrolled in academic programs that prepare them to influence the public sphere, such as public policy, global affairs, and public management in the United States' border states and Mexico. Data were collected through an online questionnaire with around 65 questions, including civic participation, discrimination and inequality, interpersonal and institutional trust, rule of law, government intervention and individual freedom, accountability and corruption, and views on the neighboring country's public affairs. We find that higher levels of polarization among respondents correlate with their willingness to increase collaboration between the US and Mexico, while simultaneously limiting the topics that collaboration is meant to cover. We find higher levels of partisan polarization in the US, while similar levels of partisan discontent are found in both countries.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Despite scholar and media portraits stating the UN secretary-general as one of the most vocal voices in global climate governance, his role remains understudied and understood as having little formal authority and no material power in global policymaking. What is the real capacity of the SG to influence global policymaking and keep a policy agenda active? Through the study of the climate agendas of the last two UN Secretary-generals, Ban Ki-moon and António Guterres, this paper shows that the SG is a global policy entrepreneur capable of creating and seize the opportunities for climate action.
By tracing the secretary-general’s practices on a particular policy sector, and through observations and interviews, we show that the SG uses both, political and bureaucratic strategies at every moment of the global policymaking process, from problem framing to policy evaluation. As a traditional policy entrepreneur, the SG uses its moral authority and symbolic traditional position as a ‘norm entrepreneur’ to frame the problems and his preferred solutions and encourage agenda setting and decision-making in multilateral arenas. As an innovative policy entrepreneur, however, the SG concretizes a material power when he plays with time and space by multiplying venues for action and precipitating political engagement for policy implementation and conducting evaluations when other UN organs are unable or unwilling to act. Our study concludes that more than a ‘guardian’ of the UN commitments the SG has the ability to influence global policymaking by keeping the window of opportunity open and hence inducing policy change and innovation.
Our research combines the “multiple streams” framework with the study of leadership and power in international arenas. It fits the workshop’s main focus by analysing the shaping and development of one international policy (climate change) through the study of one of the influential but not powerful actors in the global governance (the UN secretary-general).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Despite nearly 50 years since urban planning was institutionalized in Mexico, it has had limited effectiveness in guiding cities to evolve according to their urban development plans, leading to deficiencies and contradictions in the processes of growth and change in Mexican cities (Castro, 2018; Rébora, 2017). These changes can be observed, particularly during moments such as the creation of the first General Law of Human Settlements, its reform in 2016, and more recently, the reform to replace the term "adequate and decent housing" with "adequate housing."
These shifts in urban policy share a common factor: the United Nations Conference on Human Settlements (Habitat I, II, and III) and the creation of international instruments and agendas that transfer ideas and knowledge to national and subnational levels in various countries (Paulsen-Espinoza, 2023; Stren, 2021). This has generated a reliance on 'urban solutionism' (Montero, 2018), driven by international organizations which influences spatial governance and planning in countries and cities of the Global South (Blanc, Cotella, & Dąbrowski, 2023).
In the case of Mexico, the country stands out for promoting significant changes in urban policy in light of the activities of UN-Habitat, aligning with processes of policy transfer. This transfer is understood as a "process by which knowledge of certain policies, administrative arrangements, institutions, and ideas in a political environment (past or present) is used for the development, administrative arrangements, institutions, and ideas in another political environment" (Dolowitz & Marsh, 2000, p. 5). This transfer can occur between international organizations, countries, regions, cities, states, etc.
In this regard, this presentation aims to analyze the role of UN-Habitat in the changes to Mexican urban policy, questioning the nature of the policy transfer UN-Habitat makes to Mexico. The hypothesis is that this transfer process is voluntary, following the characterization of Dolowitz & Marsh (2000:13), where the transfer is driven by the need or desire for international acceptance. To this end, a minimalist process tracing (Beach & Pedersen, 2019) will be conducted to analyze diachronically the creation of the first General Law of Human Settlements in Mexico (1976) with its last reform (2016), to understand the mechanism that drove such change and the type of devolution to which the coalitions of each moment aligned themselves.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The objective of this paper is to further conceptualise transnational policy communities, using the empirical case of the anti-corruption community. Diane Stone coined the term ‘transnational policy community’ (TPC), understood as “a cohesive and bounded groups of professionals from different countries who diffuse shared ideas and practices globally”.[1] Recent research on the transnationalisation of policy suggest that actors situated between sectors and levels of governance, operating at the interaction of states, IOs, public and private sectors, and circulating between them are becoming increasingly common and thus relevant for the study of public policymaking.[2] This makes it all the more important to further develop the concept of transnational policy community, to understand their role in the development of international public policy. Using documentary analysis, interviews with stakeholders and network analysis, this paper applies the concept to the field of international anti-corruption policy, studying the main actors and organisations involved in shaping anti-corruption policy at the international level as well as their interactions, to understand how they facilitate the spread of anti-corruption “best practices”. More than the emergence of isolated international policy brokers, the paper argue that it is their collaboration and exchanges that allowed the spread of anti-corruption instruments, for it created a form of anti-corruption paradigm and shaped the cognitive environment for international and national policy-making. It shows that international organisations and (transnational) actors involved in anti-corruption work perceive themselves as sharing a common understanding of corruption and as working together towards the same goal. Through their collaboration, practices and discourse, they built a policy community that divides labour among members and goes beyond the traditional boundaries of policy-making to include non-state actors operating at the transnational level. The existence of a transnational policy community composed of influential organisations with different mandates and memberships sharing core beliefs narrows down the conflictual space and makes international anti-corruption work largely paradigmatic. This community has progressively grown, through the circulation of actors, members’ efforts to reach out to new audiences and socialising them to a shared conception of corruption and anti-corruption work. In doing so, it even managed to integrate – and mollify – critical views. This has contributed to defuse outside criticism (from academia principally) by giving it a voice inside policy forums. The seeming unity of the policy community and the knowledge it produces contributes to legitimise the policy solutions it prescribed as consensually-agreed ‘good practices’. The selection of policy solutions to promote are however partly the result of unequal power distribution within the community and advocacy of policy pioneers who sought to convince others to emulate their model.
[1] STONE, Diane. Global Public Policy, Transnational Policy Communities, and Their Networks. Policy Studies Journal, Vol. 36, no 1, 2008, pp. 30-31.
[2] Hassenteufel, Patrick. Sociologie politique de l’action publique. 3e éd. [s.l.] : Armand Colin. 2021; STONE, Diane et Kim MOLONEY. The Oxford Handbook of Global Policy and Transnational Administration. Oxford University Press, 2019.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Health policy is increasingly informed by the ideas, strategic plans, advice and data emanating from global health institutions and organisations. In this paper, we focus on a recently influential concept in global health that has yet to garner close attention from public policy scholars, that of ‘vaccine hesitancy’. The ‘hesitancy’ concept has been used in technical and policy circles over the last decade to explain declines in vaccine uptake, with the World Health Organization declaring vaccine hesitancy one of its top ten threats to human health in 2019. We contribute to aims of the workshop by tracing the knowledge contests and institutional factors that shaped its emergence under the auspices of the WHO and subsequent dissemination to domestic policymakers. We draw on in-depth interviews with global vaccination experts and analysis of documents and publications from a WHO working group that developed the concept between 2011 and 2014.
In one sense, we describe a case of an expert group meeting the moment by delineating a concept that has found widespread usage not only among vaccine social scientists, but also political leaders, media and citizens, especially since COVID-19. At the same time, hesitancy has been controversial. Critics have accused governments of using the concept to unfairly blame vulnerable citizens for slower than expected vaccine uptake, and have raised concerns about the inappropriate use of coercive instruments such as mandates in response to uptake issues.
We argue that these tensions can be traced in part to the initial elaboration of the concept. The working group defined hesitancy as something of a ‘polysemic’ catch-all for a range of drivers of non-vaccination, including uncertainty about safety and access barriers. This was done at the behest of key members of the working group, who – seeing a broader shift in the focus of global vaccination policy towards attitudes and behaviours – wanted to ensure that attention on structural barriers to vaccination remained. The broad framing helped to enable agreement and likely contributed to the successful dissemination of the concept – working group members were able to generate evidence that hesitancy was a globally significant health challenge. However, by being tethered to a concept that is most easily understood as being focused on individuals and their choices, structural barriers to vaccination are in some ways left ‘hiding in plain sight’. The case therefore highlights the challenges expert groups face in framing authoritative advice for domestic policymakers, especially where evidence is piecemeal and problems highly complex.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The main goal of this work is to analyze the effect of judicial resolutions from international courts on local public policies. The judicial system, through its exclusive powers as an agent that guarantees (in Western democracies) constitutional supremacy, has the power to veto, confirm or modify public policies submitted for consideration; At the international level, international courts, such as the Inter-American Court, the European Court of Human Rights, among others, have the power to impose resolutions on States, which can represent paradigm shifts in terms of the definition and construction of the public policies in the countries involved. The question that guides this work is: How does the judicial power from the international level affect public policies? To answer this question, a methodology has been developed based on an analysis matrix, that allows quantifying the effects of judicial resolutions and thus determining the degree of influence in each of the stages of the policy cycle. This research is directly related to the study of global public policies, based on research focused on international courts as determining actors in the field of global public policies.
The presentation of the research would be in person.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Cash transfer programs (CTPs) emerged in the mid-nineties and spread across Latin America and the Caribbean, subsequently expanding globally. This paper explores the influence of international organizations (IOs) programmatic ideas on the proliferation of CTPs, focusing on the case of the "Human Development Bonus" (BDH) in Ecuador, during 1998-2003. The hypothesis posited is that IOs' programmatic ideas regarding CTPs, framed as instruments to combat poverty, permeate the national landscape, as instruments for supporting the most poor and vulnerable families, through mechanisms of coercion, emulation, and learning. From a deductive approach and the perspective of critical realism, this research employs sociological neoinstitutionalism to analyze public policy networks, aiming to elucidate the diffusion mechanisms involved by identifying actors and their interrelations, and measuring the behaviors of policy networks and their members. Document analysis and semi-structured interviews were applied.
Three diffusion mechanisms are delineated. Firstly, indirect coercion for the adoption of cash transfers stemming from the dominant influence of the International Monetary Fund and World Bank (WB), as structural adjustment reforms advocated in the Washington Consensus led to the inception of the Solidarity Bonus (BS). Secondly, learning, whereby the BDH draws from instruments of other governments such as "Identification and Selection System of Potential Beneficiaries of Social Programs" in Chile and "Bolsa Escola" (BE) in Brazil, adapted locally to enhance targeting via the "Identification and Selection System of Beneficiaries of Social Programs", and to promote school attendance through conditional cash transfers known as the "School Scholarship", respectly. Thirdly, direct coercion, supported by the authoritative influence of the WB and the Inter-American Development Bank, which facilitated the transformation of the BS into the BDH by imposing educational and healthcare conditionalities as prerequisites for loan disbursement, following the examples set by programs such as "Oportunidades" in Mexico and BE in Brazil. Emulation was not identified due to the influence of national contexts and technical capabilities in program design.
Although, the origin of the BDH is endogenous, since it began as a fiscal policy instrument in response to the political and economic situation of that time, subsequently, it transformed into a social policy instrument. This research shows how programmatic ideas can coexist and evolve over time. While initially BDH was conceived under the programmatic idea of "compensation for the poorest families," ideas such as "targeting" and "school attendance" were later integrated to enhance transfer delivery and ensure the educational engagement of minors, ultimately converging into the broader programmatic idea of "protection and enhancement of human, physical, and social capital".
This paper fits with the workshop research questions by providing insights into the spread of CTPs and the influence of international organizations' programmatic ideas. By examining the diffusion of CTPs towards the BDH through the lens of sociological neoinstitutionalism, which views policy networks as institutions shaping the actions of participating actors, we were able to identify the involved diffusion mechanisms, evolving relationships among actors, and their programmatic ideas. Analyzing public policy networks enabled us to characterize the connections between actors and assess the behavior of the network and its members, thus identifying key actors and intermediaries.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Against the backdrop of unprecedented levels of displacement due to ongoing conflicts, climate change, and persecution, the need for a comprehensive approach to migration became clear. The 2018 United Nations Global Compact for Safe, Orderly, and Regular Migration (hereafter ‘The Compact’) is a ground breaking intergovernmental agreement aimed at addressing the multifaceted and interconnected challenges posed by global migration. This paper will delve into the complex negotiation process of The Compact, while also highlighting its unique challenges and lessons learned for future policies. In terms of methodology, I will be looking at political discourse (e.g. social media, interviews, press releases), national migration policies, academic articles, and interviewing several migration experts (i.e. academics/researchers at universities, NGOs, and United Nations specialized agencies) to shed light on both the conceptualization of this international agreement and the implementation challenges given its non-compulsory nature. The paper will pay particular attention to the role of international and transnational actors, relating it directly to the workshop’s stated objectives. The Compact came as a result of extensive negotiations and consultations of a diverse range of stakeholders including states, civil society, international organizations, and NGOs. A key consideration for The Compact was an understanding that international collaboration was needed to properly address the complexities around contemporary migration/mobility. The Compact, despite its shortcomings, reflects a new approach to migration that is more cooperative, transcending state borders. This paper will aim to explore the following research question: What were the key challenges and compromises faced by the different stakeholders (states, international organizations/NGOs, civil society, etc.) in formulating – and now implementing – the UN Global Compact for Safe, Orderly, and Regular Migration? In analyzing this negotiation process, we will be able to see how states navigated unbalanced power relations, conflicting national interests, and difficult compromises to achieve this agreement. Furthermore, balancing safe, orderly, and regular migration while ensuring that the rights of migrants are safeguarded proved to be challenging in light of conflicting interests. Despite this tension, the participation of advocacy groups and NGOs in the negotiation process meant that a human-rights based approach was at the forefront. Therefore, this paper will dive into the ways in which human rights principles have been upheld and where they fall short. In conclusion, this paper will offer an analysis of the making of the 2018 UN Global Compact for Safe, Orderly, and Regular. By examining the intricate dynamics of shaping The Compact, this paper contributes to a deeper understanding of the complexities around crafting international policies, particularly in the context of addressing global issues like migration. At this time, I prefer to present onsite. However, I am open to presenting online too.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This research critically engages with the international legal and political mechanisms shaping contemporary social and environmental governance, centering its inquiry on the normative, institutional, and epistemological underpinnings of poverty eradication strategies within the framework of Agenda 2030, particularly SDG1's ambitious goal of eradicating poverty by 2030. The study is predicated on the hypothesis that the mainstream international approach to poverty eradication, as encapsulated by the SDGs, is fundamentally limited in its capacity to realize its transformative agenda due to its inherent a-historical, depoliticised, and segregationist nature. The research interrogates the historical, ideological, operational, and implementation dimensions of SDG1 and its related targets, aiming to reveal the contours and constraints of international legal forms in combating poverty and advancing social progress.
Methodologically, the research adopts an interdisciplinary approach, drawing on insights from post-colonial, Third World, and Marxist theories of international law. It critically examines the conceptualization, definition, and measurement of poverty by international legal institutions, the development and application of poverty eradication strategies, and the ideological assumptions that underlie current efforts. The research navigates through the historical development of global governance mechanisms, the post-colonial and capitalist dimensions of international legal structures, and the role of global governance mechanisms, especially Agenda 2030 and the SDGs, in shaping poverty eradication strategies.
Central to this inquiry is the exploration of how international law has historically addressed poverty, shedding light on the continuity of colonial patterns of power and exploitation and their implications for contemporary global poverty. The research critiques the dominant technocratic and managerialist spirit that characterizes global governance, highlighting its detachment from anti-colonial traditions and its failure to address the systemic, structural, and relational character of poverty. It contends that the SDGs' approach is marked by a failure to engage with the historical processes and power dynamics that perpetuate poverty, particularly in the Global South.
By delving into the theoretical underpinnings of poverty measurement and the evolving concept of poverty within the global context, the research aims to contribute to a more nuanced understanding of poverty as a systemic, structural, and relational challenge. It seeks to unveil the limitations and blind spots in the SDGs' approach to poverty eradication, arguing that the contemporary international legal and political forms are insufficient for promoting genuine transformation and cooperation necessary for sustainable development and poverty eradication.
In conclusion, this research aspires to enrich the scholarly discourse on poverty eradication within the context of Agenda 2030, illuminating the complexities inherent in global poverty eradication efforts and suggesting more effective and sustainable strategies. It aligns with the workshop's research questions by offering a critical analysis of the legal and political structures that govern global poverty eradication efforts, thereby contributing to the broader understanding of global poverty dynamics and the potential for systemic change.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Abstract:
This paper presents a comprehensive analysis of strategies to combat extremism among youth and enhance women's rights in the Middle East, with a focus on how educational and policy reforms, as well as international cooperation, can lead to a more stable and equitable region. In the context of recent progressive reforms in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and the ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas, this study explores pathways towards peace and mutual acceptance.
The primary research question investigates effective strategies for reducing extremism among youth and strengthening the status of women in Middle Eastern societies. The paper utilizes a multi-methodological approach, encompassing both qualitative and quantitative research methods. This includes an extensive review of existing literature, expert interviews, case studies, and surveys conducted among young individuals across various Middle Eastern countries.
A key aspect of this research is the analysis of recent reforms in Saudi Arabia, which have shown significant progress in women's empowerment and a move towards moderating extremist ideologies. These reforms include allowing women to drive, increasing their participation in the workforce, and a general liberalization of some social norms. The paper evaluates the impact of these reforms on societal attitudes and their potential as a model for other Middle Eastern countries.
Moreover, the paper addresses the conflict between Israel and Hamas in Gaza as a representation of extremist ideologies among Middle Eastern youth. This conflict highlights the challenges posed by entrenched hostilities and the importance of developing strategies that not only counter extremism but also promote dialogue and understanding between conflicting parties.
The study suggests several strategies to prevent the youth in the Middle East from succumbing to extremist ideologies. These include:
Educational Initiatives: Developing curricula that emphasize critical thinking, human rights, and gender equality, to foster a more tolerant and open-minded youth populace.
Media Engagement: Utilizing media to challenge stereotypes and promote narratives of coexistence and mutual respect, particularly between genders and across cultural divides.
Economic Empowerment and Job Creation: Providing economic opportunities to both men and women, particularly in regions afflicted by conflict, to reduce the allure of extremist groups.
Legal and Policy Reforms: Advocating for laws and policies that uphold women's rights and promote gender equality, thereby creating a more inclusive and fair society.
International Diplomacy and Peace Efforts: Encouraging international cooperation to resolve regional conflicts, including the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, thereby reducing one of the key drivers of extremism in the region.
By implementing these strategies, this paper argues that it is possible to create a future where young people in the Middle East respect women's positions, human rights, and embrace gender equality. Such a future would contribute to a stable and peaceful Middle East, where nations and peoples, including Israelis and Palestinians, live in harmony and mutual acceptance.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Title: Epistemic communities or communities of instruments? International food policies through the lens of expertise
International food policies are structured around the global food security paradigm based on agricultural productivism and the defense of free trade (Fouilleux et al., 2017). This paradigm is the product of a "complex of regimes" dominated by international organizations in charge of trade, the latter having appropriated the food issue in the 1990s alongside the human rights regime, to the detriment of organizations in charge of undernourishment and malnutrition in place since the Second World War (Margulis, 2013). To what extent was this paradigm challenged by the price spike of 2007/2008, which coincided with the IPCC experts' questioning of the agricultural sector's responsibility for climate change? The article examines how this food and climate emergency was used by various stakeholders to form an alternative "epistemic community" challenging the established one. Following the methods classically associated with this concept (Haas, 1992; Hopkins, 1992), the research first focused on the transformation of knowledge production through an ethnographic and scientometric study. This study was complemented by a sociology of the main instruments of global food governance (statistics, models, expert reports, standards) aimed at relating the instruments defended by the alternative community to those of the established community. The instrumental approach - rather than the sole tracking of experts - is defended here because it overcomes several of the limitations of the epistemic community concept. Instruments, as tools of proof as much as of government, make it possible to evacuate the mechanical vision of influence on decision-making at work in the concept of epistemic community (Cross, 2013). This focus also makes it possible to go beyond P. Haas's reified vision of knowledge at work, to defend instead an STS perspective that considers the latter to be co-produced by political and scientific actors (Demortain, 2017; Haas, 2017): in so doing, it offers a more dynamic vision of change over the course of instruments. The analysis shows that an alternative community is being structured in the context of the food and climate crisis, but that it is weakly instrumented, which ultimately explains its low impact on decision-making.
Bibliography
Cross, Mai’a K. Davis. 2013. “Rethinking Epistemic Communities Twenty Years Later”. Review of International Studies 39(1):137‑60.
Demortain, David. 2017. “Experts and the Production of International Policy Knowledge: Do Epistemic Communities Do the Job?” p. 76 in The Politics of Expertise in International
Organizations. Routledge.
Fouilleux, Ève, Nicolas Bricas, et Arlène Alpha. 2017. « Feeding 9 billion people… Global food security debates and the productionist trap ». Journal of European Public Policy 24 (11): 1658-1677.
Haas, Peter M. 1992, “Introduction: Epistemic Communities and International Policy
Coordination ». International Organization 46(1):1‑35.
Haas, Peter M. 2017. « Coupling Science to Governance: Straddling the Science-Policy Interface ». In The Politics of Expertise in International Organizations, Littoz-Monnet Annabelle. Oxon and New York: Routledge.
Hopkins, Raymond F. 1992. « Reform in the International Food Aid Regime: The Role of Consensual Knowledge ». International Organization 46 (1): 225‑64.
Margulis, Matias E. 2013. “The Regime Complex for Food Security. Implications for the Global Hunger Challenge”. Global Governance 19(1): 53-67.
I consider presenting online.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since the 1990s the attention of public policy scholars has increasingly shifted from the national (and European) level to the international and global levels of public policy (Knill and Tosun, 2013: 223). With the second globalization, associated to growing economic and technological interdependency between states, so as to the acceleration of international transport and communication possibilities, public policies are more and more analyzed beyond the Nation State.
This shift of the attention from national (and local) levels to supranational levels has triggered two evolutions in the literature. The first one is the development of “global policies” studies, as the creation of journals dedicated to these new policy levels illustrates (Global Policy, Global Social Policy…). Global public policies can be defined as: “the processes of transnational cooperation and conflict, involving both state and non-state (domestic and international) agents, by which policies are produced to problems related to the global scale” (Porto de Oliveira, 2022: 63). The focus is on the role of transnational actors and interactions in the global circulation of policy ideas and policy instruments. It encompasses different supranational dimensions of a public policy.
The making of public policy in a context of globalization is subject to circulations, transfers and adaptations according to dominant accounts of 'best practices'. While the intensification of these flows is widely acknowledged and public policy and administration studies have developed sound comparative approaches, relatively less attention is being paid to the analysis and conceptualization of international public policy-making by states but also international public administrations and their bureaucracies, transnational corporations and their forms of transnational mobilization, as well as transnational NGOs and citizen grassroots organizations and their transnational reach.
This is why this paper is focused on the second perspective: the analysis of international public policies, combining public policy and international relations perspectives. Even if the difference and boundaries with global public policies is not always clear and the overlaps are important, the notion of international public policy is more specifically focused on the role of international (intergovernmental) organizations in the tackling of policy issues historically developed at local and national levels. Our specific objective is to foreground sociological analyses of international policy-making and policy processes (notably issue framing, agenda setting, policy formulation, decision-making and implementation).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The WHO’s Mental Health Action Plan (MHAP) provides a strategic framework to advance mental health at global and regional levels. Failing to meet the original 2020 goals, the MHAP was extended to 2030, with revised objectives and targets. Whilst the global mental health movement has significantly gained traction, multiple challenges continue to hinder progress including weak political will, fragmented policy processes and health systems, and insufficient data and financing.
This study examines how four WHO member-countries (Canada, Guyana, Cuba and USA) have adopted the MHAP and explores their contributions to the global mental health targets. This research employs a mixed-method, multi-case study approach. Given the global scope of the WHO’s state membership, the regional focus for this study is narrowed down to the Americas, where the global burden of NCDs is the highest. Quantitative data is acquired via the WHO’s Mental Health Atlas 2020 country data reports and relevant national policy documents. Qualitative interviews are conducted with subject matter experts, scholars, WHO/PAHO and national health ministry officials. The Shiffman and Smith framework on generation of political priority for global health issues is utilized to organize and assess qualitative data.
Findings show that whilst Guyana and Canada have achieved targets ahead of the MHAP’s 2030 goal, Cuba and USA have thus far made minimal contributions. Lessons include the power of political cohesion in implementing mental health policies and initiatives, as demonstrated by Guyana’s whole-of-government and whole-of-society approach, presenting a learning opportunity in multi-polar policy innovation and adaptation for varying contexts and nations.
Key reflections include; the need for the emerging field of mental health diplomacy as an innovative cross-sectoral tool to advance global mental health; the role of neuroaesthetics in building economies, societies and cities centered for well-being, and for improved circulation of knowledge between Global South-South and Global South-North.
EXPORT PDF (FULL)