W02. Wicked Problems in Public Policy: Definitions, Methods, Ethics and Uncertainty in Decision-Making
Wicked & Wild Problem Agenda SettingCATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
Co-chairs:
Raul Pacheco-Vega, FLACSO Mexico
Fausto Amador-Cid, FLACSO Mexico
Camila Sanchez-Sandoval, FLACSO Mexico
1. Research Question
This workshop seeks to examine the underlying challenges of using wicked problems in public policy scholarship. What do we know about wickedness, wicked problems and the use of wicked problems scholarship in policy studies? What is left to study? Which potential avenues for further research do we have?
We propose examining this research question through four different avenues of inquiry:
a) How do we define wicked problems? Which parameters, characteristics, and elements define wicked, wickedness and a wicked problem?
b) What types of methods can be used to understand wicked problems from a public policy perspective? How can we merge qualitative, quantitative, spatial, relational and other types of research methods to better understand wicked problems?
c) Which ethical challenges exist when examining public policy issues through the wicked problems framework?
d) How does uncertainty affect wicked-problem-solving across different policy contexts?
2. Context
Public policy issues can always be framed through a wicked problems framework. However, despite recent efforts to make this scholarship more visible and relevant (Head, 2019, 2023; Peters, 2017; Peters & Tarpey, 2019), global challenges such as the COVID19 pandemic, the increase in violence against women, the growth in applications of large scale language models (LLMs, also known as artificial intelligence) have made it clear that policy issues can definitely be wicked problems. It is in this context that we seek to advance literature and make substantive contributions to the wicked problems literature.
3. State of the Art
Wicked problems are complex, multifaceted, intractable and often ill-formulated (Crowley & Head, 2017; Head, 2022). Scholarship around the world has evolved over the past 60 years to use the conceptual lens of wicked problems to examine challenging issues of urban planning, sustainable development, water governance, human development and social justice. Though the term “wicked problems” emerged from the urban and regional planning literature (Peters, 2017), it has become widely used across multiple disciplines, sub-fields and areas of study (Clark et al., 2022; Hannigan & Coffey, 2011; Herrington & Horndeski, 2023; Smith et al., 2000). Though there are fair and substantive critiques of the concept (Termeer et al., 2019), there are also important and relevant avenues to expand the current body of academic works on wicked problems in public policy, building on these critiques (Peters, 2017; Peters & Tarpey, 2019). Both from an area issues perspective as well as a disciplinary viewpoint, there are clearly multiple spaces where one could contribute to our understanding of the definitional challenges of wicked problems in public policy.
One of the biggest challenges facing scholarly literature on wicked problems is definitional. Peters makes three core assertions about this body of scholarly works: firstly, that relatively few problems facing governments are actually wicked in the way we define wicked problems. Secondly, that many ordinary policy problems could also be characterized as wicked, And thirdly, that wicked problems as a theoretical construct has been converted from an explanatory framework to a normative approach to policy design (Peters, 2017).
While there are multiple angles of analysis for wicked problems, four main avenues emerge from a cursory literature review. Firstly, the definitional problems that emerge from trying to discern which public affairs can or cannot be framed as wicked problems (Alford & Head, 2017; Head, 2022; Peters & Tarpey, 2019; Termeer et al., 2019). There is a very strong variation in the types of issues that can be examined through wicked problems scholarship, from homelessness (Clark et al., 2022) to wellbeing (Bache et al., 2016) to urban stream restoration (Herrington & Horndeski, 2023) to air pollution sustainable development and land title regularization (Pipkin, 2023). There is still substantive space for additional efforts to define wicked problems and advance scholarship on wickedness in public policy.
Secondly, there are substantial methodological challenges that come with attempting to understand and solve wicked problems. A clear gap in the literature is a systematic examination of different methodologies that can be used to better understand public policy issues through the wicked problems framing. Though there is substantial work on the definitional elements that make a public policy issue a wicked problem (Alford & Head, 2017; Crowley & Head, 2017; Head, 2019; Lönngren & van Poeck, 2021; Turnbull & Hoppe, 2019), there is less work on applications of qualitative, quantitative, social network analysis, spatial analysis to the study of wicked problems. Certainly, understanding policy issues requires specific skill sets and methodological tools. For example, to understand mental health as a wicked problem (Pipkin, 2023) we would need ethnographic approaches. The same could be said of homelessness (Clark et al., 2022). Studying land titles’ regularization (Pipkin, 2023) most certainly would necessitate spatial analysis and geographical information systems.
Thirdly, there is a need for additional work on the ethical implications of examining public policy issues through a wicked problems framework (Wexler, 2009). Given the normative nature of the wicked problems literature, we need to exercise caution when examining policy challenges through this theoretical lens, as it is likely that we may fall into a blind spot and make the problem even more wicked than it was before our analysis. The entire notion of wicked problems implies that there is a certain “wickedness” that needs to be tamed. One important challenge is the ethical decision to choose certain policy options over others when addressing a wicked problem (Wexler, 2009). The scholarly literature on ethics in wicked problems has therefore several potential avenues for additional research.
Fourthly, there is substantial uncertainty within the specific wicked problem we might be attempting to address. We may frequently find scholarly research papers that address a policy issue attempting to tackle one of its causes without actually addressing all of them. These uncertainties can be associated with the specific policy issue (Kirschke & Kosow, 2022), or with the types of stakeholders that are involved in decision-making (Esposito & Terlizzi, 2023; Hudon & Floricel, 2023) or the specific processes used to make decisions around a specific wicked problem (Bache et al., 2016; Kirschke & Kosow, 2022). Given that wicked problems are also political (McConnell, 2018), there is ample opportunity for further investigation of the politics of uncertainty in wicked problems scholarship.
Wicked problems are substantially different in root causes, policy instruments that can be designed and implemented, temporal horizons and target populations. While this workshop proposes an examination of wicked problems in public policy scholarly literature and case studies in four specific areas, it is clear that there are other potential avenues worthy of research that can be examined. We welcome papers that examine specific case studies, a broader range of public policy areas, or take a comparative perspective.
4. Hypotheses
This workshop does not follow a hypothesis-testing strategy. We examine research questions as posited above.
5. Papers
We have abstracts for at least 5 papers already prepared, and we will be seeking additional submissions. We welcome theoretical, empirical and methodological papers and will organize them accordingly.
6. Agenda
The workshop will take place over 3 days. Depending on the number of participants and papers, we will devote 1-1.5 up to 2 days to presenting and discussing the papers in a traditional roundtable (chair, presenters, discussant) format. We then will devote the remainder of the workshop (1-1.5 days) to discuss a publication strategy and offer some time for participants to edit their papers for publication. We will explore research questions along the four avenues indicated and produce four sets of papers that can be then published in a series of special issues.
7. Paper titles and authors (to be updated with additional participants emerging from the call for participants)
Raul Pacheco-Vega (FLACSO Mexico) “Elder Care Policy as a Wicked Problem: An Intersectional Approach to Understanding Policies for Older Persons”.
Fausto Amador-Cid (FLACSO Mexico) “Methods for Studying Wicked Public Policy Problems in the Context of Homelessness: A Case Study in Mexico”
Camila Sanchez-Sandoval (FLACSO Mexico) “Religious Freedom Expansion as a Wicked Problem: A Comparative Public Policy Approach”
Jeraldine del Cid and Gloria del Castillo (FLACSO Mexico) Problem Definition in the Agenda-Setting Process for the Decriminalization of Abortion in Central America: A Very Wicked Problem
Two additional authors have been identified:
Ulises Flores Llanos
Guillaume Fontaine
8. Bibliography
Alford, J., & Head, B. W. (2017). Wicked and less wicked problems: A typology and a contingency framework. Policy and Society, 36(3), 397–413. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2017.1361634
Bache, I., Reardon, L., & Anand, P. (2016). Wellbeing as a Wicked Problem: Navigating the Arguments for the Role of Government. Journal of Happiness Studies, 17(3), 893–912. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10902-015-9623-y
Clark, M., Cornes, M., Whiteford, M., Aldridge, R., Biswell, E., Byng, R., Foster, G., Fuller, J. S., Hayward, A., Hewett, N., Kilminster, A., Manthorpe, J., Neale, J., & Tinelli, M. (2022). Homelessness and integrated care: an application of integrated care knowledge to understanding services for wicked issues. Journal of Integrated Care, 30(1), 3–19. https://doi.org/10.1108/JICA-03-2021-0012
Crowley, K., & Head, B. W. (2017). The enduring challenge of ‘wicked problems’: revisiting Rittel and Webber. Policy Sciences, 50(4), 539–547. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-017-9302-4
Esposito, G., & Terlizzi, A. (2023). Governing wickedness in megaprojects: discursive and institutional perspectives. Policy and Society, 42(2), 131–147. https://doi.org/10.1093/polsoc/puad002
Hannigan, B., & Coffey, M. (2011). Where the wicked problems are: The case of mental health. Health Policy, 101(3), 220–227. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.healthpol.2010.11.002
Head, B. W. (2019). Forty years of wicked problems literature: forging closer links to policy studies. Policy and Society, 38(2), 180–197. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2018.1488797
Head, B. W. (2022). Wicked Problems in Public Policy: Understanding and Responding to Complex Challenges. Palgrave Macmillan.
Head, B. W. (2023). Wicked Problems in Public Policy. Encyclopedia of Public Policy, 3(2), 101–108. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-90434-0_43-1
Herrington, C. S., & Horndeski, K. (2023). Is urban stream restoration really a wicked problem? Urban Ecosystems, 26(2), 479–491. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11252-022-01307-7
Hudon, P.-A., & Floricel, S. (2023). The development of large public infrastructure projects: integrating policy and project studies models. Policy and Society, 42(2), 148–163. https://doi.org/10.1093/polsoc/puad004
Kirschke, S., & Kosow, H. (2022). Designing policy mixes for emerging wicked problems. The case of pharmaceutical residues in freshwaters. Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 24(5), 486–497. https://doi.org/10.1080/1523908X.2021.1960808
Lönngren, J., & van Poeck, K. (2021). Wicked problems: a mapping review of the literature. International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology, 28(6), 481–502. https://doi.org/10.1080/13504509.2020.1859415
McConnell, A. (2018). Rethinking wicked problems as political problems and policy problems. Policy and Politics, 46(1), 165–180. https://doi.org/10.1332/030557317X15072085902640
Peters, B. G. (2017). What is so wicked about wicked problems? A conceptual analysis and a research program. Policy and Society, 36(3), 385–396. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2017.1361633
Peters, B. G., & Tarpey, M. (2019). Are wicked problems really so wicked? Perceptions of policy problems. Policy and Society, 38(2), 218–236. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2019.1626595
Pipkin, S. (2023). Dissolving “Wicked” Problems: Beyond Institutionalist and Participatory Approaches to Land Title Regularization. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 43(1), 94–105. https://doi.org/10.1177/0739456X19856066
Smith, P. C., Nutley, S. M., & Davies, H. T. O. (2000). Urban policy: addressing wicked problems. What Works?: Evidence-Based Policy and Practice in Public Services, 383.
Termeer, C. J. A. M., Dewulf, A., & Biesbroek, R. (2019). A critical assessment of the wicked problem concept: relevance and usefulness for policy science and practice. Policy and Society, 38(2), 167–179. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2019.1617971
Turnbull, N., & Hoppe, R. (2019). Problematizing ‘wickedness’: a critique of the wicked problems concept, from philosophy to practice. Policy and Society, 38(2), 315–337. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2018.1488796
Wexler, M. N. (2009). Exploring the moral dimension of wicked problems. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 29, 531–542. https://doi.org/10.1108/01443330910986306
CALL FOR PAPERS
Call for Papers: Exploring Public Policy Issues as Wicked Problems: Methods, Ethics, Definitions, and Uncertainties
Over the past 50 years, the concept of "wicked problems" has gained prominence in various fields, encompassing complex, multifaceted issues that resist easy resolution. In this workshop we invite scholars, practitioners, and researchers in the areas of public policy and public administration to engage in a comprehensive exploration of wicked problems from multiple perspectives. We seek contributions that delve into four key dimensions of wicked problems: methods for their study, the ethical implications they pose, the challenges inherent in defining them, and the uncertainties that surround their understanding.
Our proposed workshop has four main tracks or avenues of research inquiry, as outlined below.
1. The Challenges of Defining Wicked Problems:
Defining wicked problems is an inherently complex task. This track seeks contributions that scrutinize the process of identifying and framing wicked problems, as well as the nuances that arise when attempting to establish clear boundaries and parameters. We encourage submissions that analyze the contextual, cultural, and epistemological factors that shape the definitions of wicked problems and influence the strategies employed to address them.
2. Methods to Study Wicked Problems:
This track invites submissions that elucidate innovative approaches, tools, and methodologies for effectively analyzing and tackling wicked problems. We welcome empirical studies, case analyses, and theoretical frameworks that demonstrate novel ways to dissect and address the intricate nature of these challenges. Submissions may encompass quantitative, qualitative, mixed-methods approaches that shed light on the underlying structures, dynamics, and potential solutions of wicked problems.
3. The Ethics of Wicked Problems:
This track aims to foster discussions on the moral and ethical considerations associated with wicked problems. We invite papers that critically examine the ethical dimensions of decision-making, policy formulation, and implementation strategies in the context of wicked problems. Submissions may explore issues such as distributive justice, stakeholder engagement, and the ethical responsibilities of individuals, organizations, and societies in confronting these complex challenges.
4. The Uncertainties Associated with Wicked Problems:
Uncertainty is an inherent feature of wicked problems, encompassing a range of ambiguities, unpredictabilities, and unforeseeable consequences. This track welcomes papers that delve into the various dimensions of uncertainty in the context of wicked problems, including but not limited to modeling approaches, scenario planning, and decision-making under conditions of limited information.
Submission Guidelines:
Abstract submissions should be no more than 300 words and must clearly state the research questions, methodology, and key findings. If the paper is theoretical, then please state how your paper will advance the wicked problems scholarly literature. If your paper is methodological, please make clear which methods will be examined or tested. If the proposed paper is empirical, please state clearly the type of case study or policy area under analysis. Full papers should be no more than 8,000 words, including references and appendices. We will consider all formats for bibliography but prefer them formatted in APA style.
All submissions will be considered for one or more special issues on wicked problems in public policy and as such, will undergo a double-blinded peer-review process.
Important Dates:
Abstract Submission Deadline: January 31st, 2024
Notification of Acceptance: February 16th, 2024
Full Paper Submission Deadline: May 30th, 2024
Conference Dates: June 26th-28th, 2024
We look forward to receiving your contributions and fostering a dynamic dialogue on wicked problems and their multifaceted dimensions.
For inquiries, please contact Dr. Raul Pacheco-Vega (raul.pacheco-vega@flacso.edu.mx)
ABSTRACT
Exploring Public Policy Issues as Wicked Problems: Definitions, Methods, Ethics, and Uncertainties in Decision-Making
Abstract
Public policy problems can be considered wicked problems if they are very complex, multifaceted, lacking a clear way of understanding of the phenomena and straightforward solutions (Head, 2022; Peters, 2017). Scholarship on wicked problems in public policy became quite popular in the early 2000s and has recently regained interest. In this workshop, we propose a fresh look on the value of wicked problems’ theoretical underpinnings and their value in understanding complex public policy problems.
Wicked problems are multifaceted, intractable and complex issues. Many public policy issues require intersectional, multidisciplinary and collaborative approaches to problem-solving. Framing these challenging issues as wicked problems enables scholars to seek a holistic approach to understanding root causes and potential solutions’ spaces. This workshop explores research questions around 4 themes: approaches to defining wicked problems, the ethics of wicked problems research, quantitative and qualitative methods to study wicked problems, and the role of uncertainty in managing wicked problems.
We seek papers that answer research questions seeking to explain the emergence of wicked problems in public policy, the challenges of defining a wicked problem, the different methodological approaches that can be used to better understand wicked problems, and the ethics of tackling wicked problems using public policy theoretical and empirical tools. We welcome theoretical papers addressing any of the four avenues of research we indicate. We also welcome empirical case studies that can offer lessons learned from applying the analytical lenses of wicked problems.
Bibliography:
Head, B. W. (2022). Wicked Problems in Public Policy: Understanding and Responding to Complex Challenges. Palgrave Macmillan.
Peters, B. G. (2017). What is so wicked about wicked problems? A conceptual analysis and a research program. Policy and Society, 36(3), 385–396. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2017.1361633
BIOGRAPHICAL PRESENTATION
Dr. Raul Pacheco-Vega is a Professor in the Methods Lab of the Latin American Faculty for Social Sciences (Facultad Latinoamericana de Ciencias Sociales, FLACSO) Sede México. He is a specialist in comparative public policy and focuses on North American environmental politics, primarily sanitation and water governance, solid waste management, neoinstitutional theory, transnational environmental social movements and experimental methods in public policy. He is a member of the Mexican National Researchers’ System (SNI), and holds the distinction of National Researcher Level 1.
Fausto Amador-Cid is a Doctoral Student at the Latin American Faculty for Social Sciences (FLACSO) Mexico. His primary research interests lie in the realm of public policy and vulnerable populations. His main research focus is Policy Design and Implementation, Behavioural Public Policy, Experimental Methods, Mixed Methods, Street-level Bureaucracy, and Homelessness. Fausto is interested in the complex dynamics of vulnerable communities and their experiences within policy frameworks. He is keenly interested in nuanced understandings of the intricate relationships between governance structures, social identities, and marginalized populations.
Camila Andrea Sánchez Sandoval has an M.A in sociology from the Universidad Iberoamericana and is a doctoral candidate in social sciences with a mention in political science at FLACSO Mexico. Her research interests have been religious political parties, expansion of religious freedom and public policies. Camila has taught undergraduate and graduate courses in religious freedom, and is a specialist in qualitative methods. She’s also conducted several collaborative applied projects.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The discussion on Universal Health Coverage (UHC) and health financing to achieve UHC took pace with the 64th World Health Assembly (WHA) held in 2011, which had health financing as an effective plan. Anchoring the resolution of access to healthcare services without financial hardships of previous WHA resolutions and Article 25.1 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights,24 the 64th Assembly appealed to all the signatories to provide universal coverage and access to health on the principles of equity and solidarity. Invoking these principles of equity and solidarity helps recognize the wicked nature of the problem to be addressed by UHC. Equitable access to healthcare services without getting pushed into poverty is not simply dependent on the availability of services. Thereby unleashing the various levels of factors influencing health inequities like socio-economic differences, gender biases, and complex epidemiological and demographic patterns, making it impossible for the health systems to come up with a 'one size fits all' solution in eradicating inequities and achieving UHC.
The concept of Universal Health Coverage, as defined by the High-Level Expert Group in India, entails both protection from financial hardship and addressing social inequities in access to health. Given the vast diversity in the demographics of India and various healthcare needs, we attempt to view Universal Health Coverage as a wicked problem. A wicked problem occurs due to the existence of an underlying problem and discrepancies in its representation. The path of Universal Health Coverage in India entails ten central pillars under which policymakers must address the web of problems. We argue that the characteristics defining a wicked problem make Universal Health Coverage arduous for policymakers. And that the path to achieving Universal Health Coverage cannot be a straight one with a government-funded health insurance scheme. In this article, we argue that attaining Universal Health Coverage due to its multifaceted aspects is a wicked problem for the government. We specifically discuss whether the health financing and infrastructure attempts by the Indian government are the solution to the wicked problem of attaining Universal Health Coverage. We begin by briefly describing the path followed by India after independence towards Universal Health Coverage. We then discuss the distinctive features that make any problem wicked vis-à-vis the pillars of Universal Health Coverage as described by the High-Level Expert Group in India and discuss their wickedness aspects. This perspective article intends to draw the attention of the policymakers and relevant stakeholders to view achieving Universal Health Coverage beyond the scope of offering means-tested financial protection.
This article fits in with the first research question of the workshop, focusing on the challenges to define a wicked problem. Universal Health Coverage is viewed significantly differently across health systems, from being a guiding principle to being treated like a goal to achieve. However, in a health system like India, with vast geographic and demographic variations, achieving Universal Health Coverage uncovers a web of underlying problems. The lack of literature that views UHC as a wicked problem has encouraged us to explore the possibility of it being wicked to solve.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Wicked problems in the sustainable management of marine and coastal zone resources are intricately related to societal processes. They are produced largely by a combination of three major factors - 1. lack of data, poor or misrepresented data on the statuses of marine natural resources management, 2. the complexity of public responses to governance, and 3. absence of practically useful frameworks for local versus national governance of the sensitive zones. Wicked problems are largely associated with mismanagement of fisheries, unsustainable practices associated with eco-sensitive areas like mangroves, seagrass systems reefs or atolls, etc., and local misgovernance without identifying with the community-level socio-technical constraints. In a sea of wicked problems, the challenging endeavors of policymaking rely on avoiding the impacts on both the shores and the deep seas.
With dense population concentrated in coastal areas, growing human dependency on coastal ecosystem services, issues related to climate change, habitat alteration, urbanization and disasters in coastal zones around the world have put the spotlight on identifying and resolving wicked problems. These are critical assessments at the frontier of debates involving human development versus sustainable development. The first pre-requisite to positive capacity building towards resilience and adaptation is the resolution of the wicked problems to some extent, that may otherwise complicate key functionalities of governance - strategy making, organizational design, people management, and performance measurement (e.g. Head and Alford, 2015; Administration and Society) in non-traditional and nature-based sectors. The major objective of the present investigation is to understand the existence, type, and nature of wicked problems in the marine and coastal environmental sector from the perspective of the Global North and the Global South countries. The general objectives with special relevance to the marine and coastal zones are:
1. To explore the existence of unique wicked problems in the sector
2. To describe the nature, intensity, and magnitudes of those wicked problems
3. To determine framework setting goals that will alleviate the impacts of wicked problems exclusive to the sector.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The current and projected increase in water rates in a framework promoting water sobriety necessitates the establishment of compensatory measures by suppliers to ensure the availability of service for low-income households connected to water networks. In this perspective, a social water policy is implemented in France through direct aid systems - such as the water check, aid to manage debts, etc. - or preferential, even free, pricing systems for volumes of water considered essential. In this communication, we will revisit the genesis of this social water policy to examine the effectiveness of these systems in light of the real problems of access to drinking water and sanitation services for low-income households. The thesis defended in this work is that the social water policy in France was designed as a policy serving water operators - to avoid unpaid bills - rather than as a policy based on the real problems of precarious households in their access to water. This eco-solidarity policy needs to be reviewed in order to be a real lever of socio-environmental justice.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Participation of people in decision making and tackling complex problems where there is lack of consensus on the science and relevant values continues to be an important research topic. The Split Ladder of Participation was developed as a way of conceptualizing uncertainty in science as well as in values that inform policy decisions, thus adding a novel twist to the analysis of complex problems of Rittel and Webber (Rittel & Weber, 1973) that originally envisioned these problems as only involving facts (Potting et al., 2022). The Split Ladder offers a diagnostic framework for assessing which type of problems merit participation and what the possible policy outcomes of such participation would be. It enables strategizing participation in relation to policy problems based on considerations such as trust, complexity, desired outcome, and time. It was developed as a diagnostic tool to enable understanding on when participation is needed, and when participation could lead to problem solving. Moreover, when participation is done poorly, it can have negative consequences resulting in loss of trust. Building on Arnstein’s ladder of participation, the Split Ladder of Participation (Hurlbert & Gupta, 2015) addresses the conditions when participation is needed, is likely to work, and what it might achieve in difference circumstances. Four ideal typical circumstances (quadrants) were created to explain what the nature and goal of stakeholder participation is in each quadrant.
Against that background, this paper addresses the question: What does a literature review of the papers that applied the Split Ladder of Participation reveal about how this diagnostic and strategic tool can be improved? A systematic literature review revealed the ladder is applied to diverse, unstructured policy problems. Multiple actors define whether a problem is structured – including the researcher or policy entrepreneurs. Consensus on scientific and social science issues need differentiation. Participation in solving structured problems where there is agreement on science and values could promote learning and motivate participation. The inappropriate use of participation for complex problems might also (f) lead to policy lock-in and stalemates. Room for plural solutions and movement between structured and unstructured problems is also at times idea. Lastly, participation and politicization are important for democracy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The concept of wicked problem has an important deployment in public policy studies (Norton, 2012; Duckett et al., 2016) and public management (Christensen & Lægreid, 2011). Moreover, Xiang (2013) argues that several investigations analyze phenomena that meet their characteristics even without naming them as a wicked problem. Nevertheless, few investigations have approached the human rights study and policies aimed at guaranteeing them. However, human rights can be typified as a wicked problem (Herrera-Kit, 2019). This, because "If there is a consensus among those engaged in the systematic study of rights, it is precisely around the ambiguous and imprecise character of this notion" (Papacchini, 2003, p. 42).
However, the wickedness of human rights suggests going beyond the delimitation of the public problem to be intervened. The proliferation and dispersion of actions in the same field or system of policies addressed to managing a wicked problem can also have an impact on the overall coherence of the state response (Cejudo & Michel, 2016).
In Colombia, since the 1990s, several human rights education programs have been formulated as a chapter of human rights policies. The most recent policy, 2022, reports on the simultaneous coexistence of numerous strategies in human rights education carried out by different institutions (Herrera-Kit & Mejía, 2022). The purpose of this article is to analyze, based on a documentary review of current public actions with closed coding in MaxQDA, the effect that the wickedness of human rights education has on the coherence of the Colombian State's response in this issue. For this purpose, the wicked problem of human rights education in Colombia is documented. Then, the effect this has on the external coherence of the State's response to the international obligation of human rights education is characterized.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The human rights-based approach in public policy: A supporting tool for addressing wicked problems
Research question: Can the human rights approach be used as a public policy tool to understand better and address wicked problems?
The research is based on the premise that one factor that influences the correspondence of public policies with the requirements of contemporary society is their development in a polycontextual and polycentric environment. That is to say, in scenarios that favour their openness to different social contexts and the intervention of diverse actors.
Given the above, an analytical-synthetic study was carried out involving the human rights approach variable—related to the polycontextualism and polycentrism of public action— and the public policy variable—related to the technique according to which public action is systematically developed—. The analytical part of the research was carried out by examining the leading academic, legal and political documents linked to the origin, concept, development and practice of the human rights and public policy approach variables. Subsequently, the synthetic part of the research was carried out by articulating both variables in a structure related to the incidence of the human rights approach in the public policy cycle.
Based on the above, a methodology was designed to calculate the human rights approach of the entire public policy cycle or some of its phase(s) by selecting a set of elements of the indicator system and applying a mathematical algorithm created for this purpose.
*If my proposal is accepted, my participation will be in person.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Dark networks, covert and illegal, such as drugs and human trafficking, arms smuggling, terrorism, and unlawful immigration, among others, are considered a problem that brings disturbances in economic, social, and political terms at all government levels (Raab & Milward, 2003). To date, the literature on dark networks has focused on understanding the structure (Raab & Milward, 2003; 2006), topology (Xu & Chen, 2008), and governance (Bakker, Raab & Milward; 2011) of these networks, which would inform efforts to disrupt their activities (McBride & Hewitt, 2013). However, no theoretical or empirical contributions demonstrate how bright networks--overt and legal--might unintentionally create a "reflective bridge" that holds the dark networks' activities, effectiveness, and resilience.
Unlawful immigration across borders is a global and national public management concern and one that is linked to divisive politics and policy in the U.S. and other countries around the world. The U.S. government's efforts to prevent unauthorized immigration have been extensive, particularly in enforcement policy and in prosecuting dark network members and deporting undocumented immigrants. However, what may be underestimated is the "bridge" that bright networks furnish to unauthorized immigrants.
Building from the bright and dark networks scholarship and using secondary sources, we explore the relationship between bright and dark networks in the case of unauthorized immigration from Latin America (L.A.) to the U.S. The sources relied on immigration policies at the national and state levels, agency and organizational records, case studies reporting immigrants' experiences and correspondence between critical actors (e.g., coyotes, immigrants, NGOs), and other first-person accounts, news reports, and memoirs, yielding a rich account of networks' operations.
The main contribution is developing a conceptual framework called the "reflective bridge." We theorize that bright networks (e.g., religious organizations, NGOs, hybrid partnerships, and policy-making processes at the state level) may unintentionally create a "reflective bridge" that entices unauthorized immigration to the U.S. In doing so, bright networks refract brightness to dark networks, hiding and furthering their activities. We also argue that although opposite values and logic drive bright and dark networks, their work overlaps, creating a vicious cycle.
Given that the activity from dark networks is considered a transnational problem that brings disturbances in economic, social, and political terms, the arguments given in this paper will contribute to understanding their resilience. The concept of the reflective bridge could provide clues and insights into the regulations that local, national, and international governments should establish if the matter is to disrupt dark networks. Although this paper will only consider the case study of the dark network of informal immigration from Latin American countries to the United States, the theoretical development of reflective bridge could be examined in future study cases and research about dark networks in other policy areas.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The goal of the article is to propose a definition of the problem of technological unemployment based on the concepts of wicked problems literature. It is argued that this phenomenon is actually a system of at least two negatively correlated problems, since as one is resolved the other tends to worsen (Alford and Head, 2017; Head, 2019, 2022, 2023). The first is the lag in productivity, explained by an environment that is not conducive to technological automation; The second is the replacement of employees with automation technologies that incorporate artificial intelligence, which we will refer to as intelligent automation technologies (Dondi et al., 2021).
The dilemma of this system of problems occurs when attention is focused on only one, for example, when aggressive public policies are formulated for the incorporation of intelligent automation technologies, the total productivity of the factors of production is likely to increase. However, there will also be more workers displaced from their occupations who will find it difficult to relocate to contexts of economies with low growth, as is the case of those in Latin America. On the other hand, if legal measures are created to protect workers against automation, it is possible that jobs will be maintained for a time, but eventually these economies will become less productive than others and will inevitably produce fewer jobs.
According to the specialized literature, the system of problems described has at least three general causes: (1) the existence of environments that are not conducive to the adoption of automation technologies; (2) the inability of the educational system to generate human capital capable of coexisting with this type of technologies; and, (3) the rigidity of labor markets that make it difficult for workers to move between productive sectors, as well as the emergence of new forms of employment (Blit et al., 2018; EIU, 2018; Dondi et al., 2021).
Regarding the first cause, it is argued that actions that foster an environment conducive to the adoption of intelligent automation technologies can increase the productivity of production factors, although they also accelerate worker substitution processes. On the other hand, the other two causes have a direct relationship with both problems; That is, improvements in educational systems, as well as increases in the flexibility of labor markets, will tend to reduce both the lags in productivity and the probabilities that, in the short term, technological unemployment will occur (Blit et al., 2018).
In addition to the detailed definition of the problem, the article aims to outline the general elements that a mix of public policies should have to address them simultaneously (Howlett and del Río, 2015). It is considered an original contribution given that until now no efforts have been made to study this public problem from the perspective of wicked problems.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Depression in Mexico represents a complex public health challenge, characterized by its elusive nature and far-reaching consequences. This paper explores the prevalence, risk factors, and implications of adolescent depression, emphasizing its classification as a wicked problem in public health, for which there is no consensus on their nature, their possible solutions, or the values and principles that should guide their improvement (Head, 2022). Despite being a leading cause of disability globally (Moreno-Gordillo et al., 2019), the intangibility of its root causes and the societal stigma surrounding mental health have contributed to its invisibility within public policy and healthcare systems.
The study highlights the interaction between sociostructural factors and adolescent depression, revealing how limited resources and educational opportunities render individuals more susceptible to experiencing episodes of sadness or depression. In this sense, the paper aims to answer the question of how the interrelation of various societal factors impacts Mexican adolescents' mental health. For this purpose, some data from the National Health and Nutrition Survey and a Correspondence Analysis are used, emphasizing the need for a deep understanding of the underlying causes of depression to develop effective interventions and policies.
The paper points out the urgency of addressing adolescent depression as a wicked problem, transcending traditional linear theoretical approaches to public health challenges. It becomes apparent that simply addressing the symptoms or consequences of depression is insufficient. Instead, a holistic and multidimensional approach is essential for developing comprehensive and sustainable interventions that prioritize the well-being of the younger generation.
By analyzing data on mortality from the National Institute of Statistics and Geography, the study also draws attention to the alarming increase in suicide rates among adolescents in Mexico over the past decade, as a response to hopelessness and meaninglessness in life (Case & Deaton, 2020). It also highlights the critical need for a paradigm shift in addressing mental health issues. By reframing the discourse around mental health as a public problem and acknowledging the dense web of factors contributing to adolescent depression, policymakers and healthcare professionals can work towards developing innovative and collaborative solutions that emphasize the importance of primary care policies.
References
Case, A., & Deaton, A. (2020). Deaths of despair and the future of capitalism. Princeton University Press.
Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geografía (INEGI). (s.f.). Mortalidad. Recuperado de https://www.inegi.org.mx/temas/mortalidad/#tabulados
Head, B. W. (2022). Wicked Problems in Public Policy Understanding and Responding to Complex Challenges. Palgrave Macmillan.
Moreno-Gordillo, G. de J., Trujillo-Olivera, L. E., García-Chong, N. R., & Tapia-Garduño, F. (2019). Suicidio y depresión en adolescentes: una revisión de la literatura. Revista Chilena de Salud Pública, 23(1).
ENSANUT. (2021). Encuesta Nacional de Salud y Nutrición. Instituto Nacional de Salud Pública.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Although policy coherence is pivotal in contemporary public administration, its boundary-spanning nature in complex policies (Jochim & May, 2010), like social protection, makes it a wicked problem. Social protection uses a mix of sub-policy instruments e.g., social insurance, social assistance, and labour-market policies, to reduce poverty (ILO, 2017). Simultaneously, policy coherence combines policy domains through programmes which address every dimension of the problem, and requires cross-ministerial coordination to avoid duplication (Cejudo & Michel, 2017). For social protection systems, this is potentially a wicked problem - lacking a definitive formulation, a finite set of binary potential solutions, and an ultimate test of effectiveness (Rittel & Webber, 1973).
Despite the generalisation that most African social protection systems lack coherence (ILO, 2017), there is limited research on the problem’s wickedness. Therefore, this article examines the question, “How and why is social protection systems-coherence a persistent wicked problem in Africa despite various coherence mechanisms?” It employs the ‘wicked problems’ heuristic by Alford & Head (2017) and its intersection with ‘policy coherence’ and ‘social protection systems.’ The heuristic suggests that wickedness varies by clarity of the problem and solution on the one hand and complexity of stakeholders on the other – offering nine possible levels of wickedness. This study plots five dimensions of social protection-systems-coherence i.e., system-definition, policy-coherence, administrative-coherence, internal-coherence, and external-coherence - on the wickedness continuum. A qualitative case study design of Uganda’s and South Africa’s social protection systems was used. Elite interviews were conducted with bureaucrats, academics and NGOs in Uganda (N=40) and South Africa (N=22) in April – December 2023, complemented by secondary data. MAXQDA analysis software was used.
Preliminary results reveal diverse wickedness levels. Uganda faces 'politically turbulent' challenges in administrative and internal coherence, while South Africa confronts a 'very wicked' problem in administrative, internal, and external coherence. Both countries grapple with a 'very wicked’ problem of external-coherence, dealing with multiple possible policy configurations. South Africa's internal-coherence is a 'very wicked’ problem due to a diverse range of social protection programmes, contrasting with Uganda's fewer programmes and 'politically turbulent' nature in this regard. ‘Conceptual contentions’ in defining social protection systems exist in both settings. Additionally, variations in the level of wickedness emerge in the policy-coherence dimension. Uganda presents an 'analytically complex' scenario with a cognitive lead ministry and a unifying policy, while South Africa faces a 'conceptually contentious' policy-coherence challenge with neither a lead ministry nor a unified policy. Therefore, mature systems and nascent systems exhibit varying degrees of wickedness.
Alford, J., & Head, B. W. (2017). Wicked and less wicked problems: A typology and a contingency framework. Policy and Society, 36(3), 397–413. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2017.1361634
Cejudo, G. M., & Michel, C. L. (2017). Addressing fragmented government action: coordination, coherence, and integration. Policy Sciences, 50(4). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-017-9281-5
ILO. (2017). World Social Protection Report 2017–19: Universal social protection to achieve the Sustainable Development Goals. In World Social Protection Report 2017-19.
Jochim, A. E., & May, P. J. (2010). Beyond subsystems: Policy regimes and governance. Policy Studies Journal, 38(2), 303–327. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1541-0072.2010.00363.x
Rittel, H. W. J., & Webber, M. M. (1973). Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning. In Policy Sciences (Vol. 4).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Wicked problems have been studied from different public policy perspectives (Rittel and Webber, 1973) during the last 50 years. Their study has been fundamental to the understanding of how policy regimes have overlapping topics. Two policy regimes have been promoted in the past 8 years in a parallel way, without enough interaction of their practices and study. Disaster Risk Reduction policies and Climate Change policies, which in practice involve similar actions, have their framework, language, and treaties in the international and academic community. This research asks: how can local governments adapt their policies to the international framework of risk reduction and climate change? The research argues that the lack of dialogue between the international guidelines increases the wickedness behind climate change and disaster policies at the local level. Through legal and policy analysis of the international, national, and local policies in Mexico, it is shown that the deep disconnection between them makes it difficult to address concrete solutions and responses to hydrometeorological hazards. As theoretical research, the droughts in Zacatecas, México, are used as an example of how the miscommunication between frameworks contributes to increasing the wickedness of isolated policies. It was found how droughts, which have been a constant hazard with 1967 municipal declarations during 2000 and 2023, from which 108 were from Zacatecas, are addressed as isolated and random phenomena instead of being understood as a result of socio-environmental processes. Framed in the literature as both disasters and a consequence of climate change, droughts are partially treated from both types of policies in Zacatecas, without a holistic approach considering the local capabilities and vulnerabilities of the community. This case provides evidence of how the wickedness of public problems could lead to disarticulated frameworks that just perpetuate their causes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
An exhaustive analysis of the public policy network in the Pánuco River Basin area of Mexico has been conducted. The objective is to identify the structural conditions within the policy subsystem that foster an agenda of integrated, adaptive, and participatory water management, particularly one that advances environmental water policies. The approach to this policy network analysis centers on the characteristics of the community of actors, encompassing both public and private entities, associated with the key public issues related to water management in the Pánuco River Basin from 2012 to 2022. Additionally, it examines the nature of interactions, whether cooperative or conflictual, among these actors. Methodologically, the analysis employs policy network analysis using secondary sources of information, primarily official documents and newspaper sources. The information obtained was processed using Gephi software. The results reveal a highly centralized policy network, dominated by federal authorities and state governments, with identified conflicts on various issues. This configuration shapes the network as a system of asymmetrical dominance and negotiation, presenting a significant impediment to a shift in orientation in the basin's water policy. The presence of conflicts and the centralization of decision-making that hinder greater actor participation in policy design and operational instruments are discussed. The discussion emphasizes the necessity to promote an inclusive and participatory structure that fosters collaboration to advance towards sustainable and equitable water management in the Pánuco River Basin.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The main objective of this article is to explore the expansion of religious freedom as a "wicked problem" through a public policy approach. To achieve this, I employ a qualitative methodology that integrates elements of grounded theory by conducting an analysis of public policy documents on religious freedom in Mexico and Colombia from 1990 to 2023. A key insight I have discovered is the intricate nature of the expansion of religious freedom, that, since its inception as a public issue, there is no well-defined public problem. In addition, I have observed that programs and interventions aimed at addressing this issue are inherently diffuse in both countries. Moreover, I have identified moments of policy change and counter-transfer within the process of expanding religious freedom, highlighting the interplay between social demands originating in the religious sector and the politicization of this right in the context of electoral processes. In sum, my research sheds light on the complexity of the expansion of religious freedom, while underscoring the importance of considering its political and social dimensions in the public policy arena in Mexico and Colombia.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Recognizing the growing significance of wicked problems in public policy, I delve into the intricate ways homelessness is socially constructed and framed within Mexico's specific public policy context. Homelessness is widely acknowledged as a wicked problem due to its multifaceted nature and the absence of straightforward solutions. This study focuses on Mexico, where homelessness presents a complex societal challenge. One significant knowledge gap lies in understanding the social construction of target populations, especially individuals experiencing homelessness, within the broader context of wicked public policy problems. To address this gap, this paper presents innovative methodological approaches and interdisciplinary strategies. I explore the inherent challenges of defining wicked problems, emphasizing the characteristics that distinguish them within public policy. This discussion clarifies what makes a problem "wicked" in this context. Furthermore, I discuss the methodological approaches, both quantitative and qualitative, as well as the use of mixed-method designs, applied to analyze the complexity and dynamics of wicked problems. Through this research, I highlight the pivotal role of social narratives in shaping the identities and experiences of homeless populations within public policy. By studying homelessness as a wicked problem through the lens of social construction, I contribute valuable insights to inform more effective and empathetic policy responses in Mexico.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
As populations age, the design and implementation of public policies aimed at tackling challenges faced by older persons become even more relevant and acutely necessary. However, there is still a gap in our understanding of the multiple intersecting difficulties that people face as they age. In this paper I use an intersectional lens to examine contemporary eldercare policies. I undertake a comparative analysis of policy instruments for older persons’ care in two Mexican cities. Using a combination of ethnographic fieldwork and interviews, I examine how different subnational governments frame the care of older persons and whether the policy instruments they have implemented can be considered truly intersectional. I argue that a wicked problems lens combined with an intersectional approach can shed light on the potential solutions to this policy issue.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This article is set in the perspective of public policy studies and is based on the importance of defining the public problem, considering it a crucial process for finding effective solutions. The proper definition of a public problem is fundamental for the formulation of policies that address issues competing for the attention of decision-makers in the public sphere.
Some problems are so complex (wicked problems) that there is no consensus on their definition among the actors involved in the process. One prominent issue is the issue of abortion, which has been addressed in different ways in different States. Legislation varies, ranging from legalization, to decriminalization in certain circumstances, to total prohibition in some contexts.
This article focuses on a few Central American countries where there is a significant lag in decriminalization. It examines how the definition of the public problem of abortion by those who promote policies or reforms can determine whether the demand for decriminalization is successful or not. It analyzes the various definitions of abortion in these countries, both in the policy structure (polity) and in the actors involved in the construction of the agenda (politics).
A content analysis is applied to identify key discursive codes in the definition of the public problem of abortion. This technical and political approach to the definition of the problem offers a comprehensive view of how the abortion issue is addressed in the Central American context and how it influences public policy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
New technologies and artificial intelligence have been presented as an innovative way of approaching the problem of evidence for policymaking purposes, looking at the opportunities offered by big data and machine learning to transform the use of data (Calo, 2017). Artificial intelligence is already used in several policy areas such as public health and tax collection as an important tool for producing new evidence and processing the information needed for policymaking purposes when dealing with wicked problems. However, its use has also opened a vast new area of inquiry into the use of information in public policymaking, and much of it is related to ethics (Newman and Mintrom, 2023, p. 1840). Analysing the literature on the ethics of artificial intelligence in policymaking, Newman (2022) has concluded that scholars and analysts sit on two extremes. They are either highly supportive, looking at how machine learning can help to overcome biases and boost fairness, therefore enabling the use of evidence, or, at the very least, supporting policy-based evidence to better communicate and unpack the values of both the society and of policymakers, allowing a dialogue both ways (from the policymakers to citizens and the other way around). Or, on the other extreme, observers have criticised the use of artificial intelligence and how it can increase biases, leading to more injustice for the already vulnerable groups, being a black box, which does not allow adapting policies on time, and decreasing policy capacity by not using institutional memory (Newman and Mintrom, 2023).
We argue that this debate needs to be complemented by an understanding of how artificial intelligence helps or, therefore, prevents policymakers from navigating the complexity of policy creation and implementation when dealing with wicked problems. When discussing complexity, we refer to the feedback loops that the use of artificial intelligence can initiate or reinforce, and the unintended consequences that emerge as a consequence of using policy evidence created through machine learning.
We aim to clarify how and if the distinction between the creation and use of evidence needs to be re-conceptualised in an era of artificial intelligence in which information is created to be deployed for policy design, but its use can be corrected through the continuous flow of information which can then be transformed into new evidence that can nourish the process of deploying new policies, therefore addressing the ethical concerns that have been raised previously. Moreover, we look at how and if recent efforts of regulating the use of artificial intelligence can address these ethical concerns, and if the use of evidence generated by artificial intelligence has more potential in one of the policy stages (either agenda-setting, or policy creation, implementation and evaluation).
Our proposal fits within T03-W02, accounting for the connection between ethics and uncertainty in policymaking when dealing with wicked problems. We aim to present our research on-site during the IWPP4.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Some authors in the literature argue that wicked problems are proliferating. However, in analyzing why some contemporary problems are "wicked," we tend to find that most explanations are vague and very generalist. Originally, wicked problems emerged as a critique of systems analysis and rational planning, not as a proposal to "improve policy analysis and social planning practices" (Head 2019, p. 181). And, for the founders of the concept, wicked problems were not some special policy problems, but "almost all public policy issues" (Rittel &Webber 1973, p. 160). However, in the literature there has been an "essentialist" (or ontological) approach that understands that there are different types of "policy problems", some of them being wicked. This "essentialist" approach has been criticized by various authors (Turnbull & Hoppe, 2017; Noordegraaf, et al., 2019; Peters, 2017).
In this paper we argue that this "essentialist" approach could be related to the inability to generate a solid analytical framework on what factors make it difficult to manage certain issues from a policy perspective. In this sense, we argue that we should not focus on the "policy problem", but rather on the factors that interact in the policy process intensifying wickedness. In this sense, the research question guiding the article is the following: what are the factors that intensify wickedness in the policy process? This article explores a process-oriented approach to wicked problems and proposes a new framework that identifies some key factors that intensify wickedness in the policy process.
I would like to present the document on site.
References:
- Head, B. W. (2019). Forty years of wicked problems literature: Forging closer links to policy studies. Policy and Society, 38(2), 180-197. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2018.1488797.
- Noordegraaf, M., Douglas, S., Geuijen, K., & Van Der Steen, M. (2019). Weaknesses of wickedness: A critical perspective on wickedness theory. Policy and Society, 38(2), 278-297. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2019.1617970.
- Peters, B. G. (2017). What is so wicked about wicked problems? A conceptual analysis and a research program. Policy and Society, 36(3), 385-396. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2017.1361633.
- Rittel, H. W., & Webber, M. M. (1973). Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Policy sciences, 4(2), 155-169. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01405730.
- Turnbull, N., & Hoppe, R. (2019). Problematizing ‘wickedness’: a critique of the wicked problems concept, from philosophy to practice. Policy and Society, 38(2), 315-337. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2018.1488796.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Climate change presents a quintessential example of a wicked problem, necessitating ambitious and accelerated climate policy. However, the implementation of such policies, particularly 'hard' policies imposing costs and sanctions, pose the risk of triggering policy backlash. From the perspective of wicked problems, these policies are “subject to real-world constraints” (Rittel and Weber, 1973) which in turn, might condition policy backlash. But despite growing concern about backlash, there remains limited understanding of when it does or does not occur. Therefore, this paper seeks to unravel the conditions under which policy backlash occurs.
We adopt an innovative methodological design bringing together the richness of qualitative data with medium-N comparative analysis by conducting a fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) of a systematic sample of 30 national-scale hard climate policies in OECD countries from 2009-2022. Building on recent calls to re-embrace the qualitative essence of fsQCA, we interpretively draw on multiple in-depth data sources including over 50 structured interviews with national policymakers in the cases, policy documents, media analysis, and existing quantitative data. We systematically analyze a comprehensive deductively-derived set of possible explanatory conditions spanning both policy design and policy context. Findings suggest that policy stringency, implementation approach, and equity within policy design, along with political polarization, economic vulnerability, and societal inequality in the broader policy context, seem to be associated with backlash.
Overall, this paper makes three significant contributions to understanding the politics of climate policy action. First, it provides insights into the drivers of volatile reactions in wicked climate policymaking extending beyond design-focused considerations to encompass the broader policy context, which is lacking to date. Second, an original data-rich fsQCA provides a novel comparative perspective on policy backlash beyond existing small-N case studies. Third, it helps improve policymaking practices by accounting for critical drivers of contestation in climate policy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In Mexico, families of missing persons, their companions, and advocates have taken on search tasks in various contexts. This has been a response to the absolute or partial gaps left by the institutionalization of search efforts and the implementation of policies regarding disappearances. In light of this scenario, questions arise about the factors that influence the construction of the search as a complex problem, so that citizen strategies have been key in this process.
Assuming the analytical perspective of actor-centered institutionalism, the discussion delves into the case study of the National Brigades for the Search of Missing Persons (Brigadas Nacionales de Búsqueda de Personas Desaparecidas). This initiative, propelled by the National Links Network (Red de Enlaces Nacionales), has been promoted in four entities of the country between 2016 and 2022. This articulation space serves as a platform for coordination among collectives of victims' families, that through exchanges with various social and political actors, has developed a comprehensive search methodology as an alternative solution to an extremely complex problem.
In light of these search experiences, the results highlight the slow progress in ensuring the right of every person to be searched for, the failure of the Mexican state's obligation to locate and identify all victims of the crime, and the absence of a structural solution to the public problem of disappearances. There is a call to continue fostering deep and interdisciplinary discussions that allow for addressing search strategies as alternative solutions to a complex problem that varies according with different contexts and local dynamics.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Throughout most of Mexico’s participation in the OECD’s PISA test (every three years between 2000 and 2018), mean performance remained stable in reading, mathematics and science. Nevertheless, the OECD acknowledged that there were hidden positive trends: at the same time the matriculation improved significantly, the lowest-achieving students shrank their gap in mathematics and science with the highest- achieving students.
Even though the learning outcomes of basic education students is a strong indicator of the quality of an educational system, assessing them through national and international surveys is no guarantee that educational authorities will use its results to enhance public policies or that, if they do, they can claim a clear link between the evidence of an improvement and previous policy decisions. Why is this so?
In this paper I argue that addressing the quality of education is a typical wicked problem that additionally poses specific dimensions of uncertainty for decision-makers. My case will be based on the examination of the Mexican policy process on the use of foreign and domestic assessments to inform policy decisions to improve the quality of basic education. I will make use of secondary sources and of semi-structured interviews to former authorities and high level bureaucrats to document these difficulties.
My research will comprise three presidential terms (2000-2006, 2006-2012 and 2012-2018) from two different political parties (PAN, 2000-2012 and PRI, 2012-2008). These three governments implemented policies to improve the quality of basic education, but they did so through different approaches, varying from an inherited Program, a political agreement with the teacher’s union, new laws and programs, and a Constitutional reform.
The main contribution of this paper is to demonstrate that there is no clear causal link between today’s policy-decisions, its implementation tomorrow and the evidence of an improvement (or not) on learning outcomes to be measured later by learning assessments. The political context as well as the students implied by previous decisions on policy will have changed by then.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Practices of sex-selective abortions, female infanticide and abandonment of girl infants manifest the “unwantedness” of girl children in India. In 2016, the Rajasthan state government emulated a 27-year-old programme in Tamil Nadu. It introduced the “Cradle Scheme” which entailed public hospitals installing cradles in which parents could ‘safely’ abandon their girl child (Ali, 2016). Exposing uncertainties, ambiguities and unforeseeable consequences, schemes like these epitomise wicked problems and lay bare the tension between immediate state responses and the inadvertent endorsement of condemned behaviours. In this paper, we explore cases of different numbers and policy targets (e.g., sex ratio and population), and analyse their intersections and contradictions. Using a multiple exploratory case-study method, we review debates and discourses in existing literature using secondary data sources like newspaper reports, journal articles, government policy documents, etc.
We argue that interventions guided by narrowly defined aims and quantifiable targets lend themselves to a technocratic approach fixated on numbers and outputs, often ignoring the impact of the programme on multiple stakeholders. Through the findings, this paper calls for comprehensive framing of policies and evaluation measures which facilitate more effective responses, accounting for qualitative social and ethical concerns and externalities. Contributing to the extant scholarly literature on wicked problems, this paper theoretically locates wicked problems in the context of social policies. Unveiling the multiplexity and uncertainties that enmesh such issues, the paper yields key insights for policymakers to rethink the definition of initiatives and the assessment of outcome measures beyond myopic technocratic frameworks. It provides direction for further research to test these findings with similar government initiatives across different empirical settings.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Policy issues are characterized by a composite character of the problem. The concept of “Wicked Problems” has gained significance across various fields (Head, 2022; Peters, 2017; Peters and Hoornbeek , 2005). Public decision-makers cope with "wicked or intractable" problems, often tied to historical periods, contexts and available knowledge. These reflections are articulated in the works of Rittel and Weber [1973] who emphasize the need to address "wicked problems", those that are difficult or impossible to solve due to being indefinable or insoluble or lacking a single solution.
One of the sectors that can present emerging problems is the environmental policy, marked by complexity, uncertainty, and novelty.
The paper aims to address the following questions: How can we define a “wicked problem” in a multilevel context? Does the multilevel context and the competing competences of authorities- influence the definition and resolution of wicked problems?
The paper will investigate an empirical case study providing lessons learned from applying the analytical lenses of wicked problems. Considering the European Green, designed to tackle the green transition through strategic leverage at the EU level, the paper will examine the Italian case by analysing the National Plan for the Green Transition in order to explain the contextual factors and the different implementation patterns. Particularly, the paper will focus on improving air quality as the “wicked problem” to be inquired, detecting the strategies employed to address them. The paper will trace the case by means of semi-structured interviews, media and document analysis.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
"Unveiling Inequality: An Environmental Justice Approach to Air Pollution Wicked Problem on Environmental Policy"
There is a global consensus regarding the importance of mitigating air pollution. Policies that address environmental contamination help address both climate change and human health issues. Despite substantive efforts to design robust environmental policies in Mexico, air pollution remains a public issue far from being resolved. This paper introduces an environmental justice approach to analyze and assess, within the policy decision process of environmental policy design, to what extent inequality impacts the selection of environmental public policy instruments aimed at addressing air pollution wicked problem. An environmental justice approach, focused on equity and collective well-being, is considered essential for understanding the outcomes of environmental policies in Mexico, given that it involves a wicked problem. In the present research, a sequential exploratory mixed-methods methodology was employed, consisting of two sections: Qualitative (recessive and dominant) and Quantitative. For the qualitative section, semi-structured interviews were analyzed with decision-makers in subnational environmental policy to explore social relationships and systems of meaning, as well as to understand the motivations of the involved actors. In the sequential quantitative section, an ordinary least squares (OLS) model was developed to explain the effect of political, economic, and racial inequality on the approximated outcomes of environmental policies. The qualitative component generated independent findings and informed the quantitative component, while also supporting the primary quantitative objective. The research empirically confirmed two hypotheses: 1) Economic inequality affects the ability to advocate for stricter environmental controls, and 2) Economic-political elites influence the selection of policy actions in environmental policies. This paper aims to identify air pollution as a wicked problem within the framework of environmental justice, allowing for an exploration of how wicked problems in air pollution policy have been addressed and can be addressed in the future.
Keywords: Wicked problems, Environmental Justice, Mixed-Methods, Air Pollution, Policy Decisions
I am considering presenting on-site
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Breede Valley within the Cape Winelands district municipality (Western Cape province, South Africa) is renowned for its fast specialization in export-oriented fruit production since South the country’s transition to democracy in 1994. Over a couple of decades, the region has transformed into a booming agricultural place (for table grape production and deciduous fruits), tightly integrated to global value chains, with a high water footprint, while attracting a massive influx of workers seeking jobs in the industry.
South Africa however is a water-scarce country, periodically dealing with prolonged episodes of drought. Climate change is predicted to worsen these semi-arid conditions. At the same time, the Breede Valley exhibits alarming levels of poverty which prompted the municipality to roll out programs of food security and climate change adaptation. Against such backdrop, this paper questions how local government might be able to deal with such challenges in order to promote sustainable local food systems. Indeed, there has been a dense literature advocating food re-localization going all the way back to the 1990-2000s, amidst criticisms against agricultural industrialization (Kloppenburg et al., 2000), up until today where a territorial approach in food planning and policy is supported in the academic literature as a way to foster food systems‘ resilience and adaptation to changes and effective risk management (Losch & May, 2023). In addition, literature on climate change governance tends to designate the local level as the most suitable one for the sake of adaptation (Henstra, 2019).
We would like to discuss local level’s capabilities in governing food systems, particularly in a context of increasing climate variability. In particular, we raise the question of the local governments’ capabilities in terms of means of action (either human, financial, legal mandate, expertise etc) as well as in terms of political influence more generally. Indeed, despite a general call for local governments to step in and contribute to managing upcoming crises through various policy initiatives (community gardens amongst others), we will emphasize both the local agency but also the many limitations faced by local public actors in promoting just and sustainable food transitions owing to adverse global dynamics and national level policy side-effects. Using neo-institutionalism as well as a multi-scale politics’ theoretical framework, we will mention in particular path dependence explanations in the case of water management policy, the influence of global market price and standards dictating crop selection and production (instead of natural resources availability) as well as the paradoxical effects of a series of regulatory changes intended to protect labor rights, that actually prompted a movement of resorting to seasonal workers with more precarious living conditions. Overall, indeed, there seems to be a growing mismatch between local food regimes and broader scales’ directives. From a methodological viewpoint, we will rely on data collected during a field work conducted in the Breede Valley Municipality in April 2023 where we interviewed over 30 key informants.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper presents findings from my two-year placement in the UK Government's Department for Digital, Culture, Media & Sport (DCMS 2022-24) as digital responsibility unexpectedly leaves DCMS (2023). UK cultural policy is managed as social policy (Gray 2009; Oman 2021). Digital policy-making has been conceptually linked to cultural policy since 1998 (DCMS 1998). However, policy documents and administrative changes (e.g. DCMS & BIS 2009; DCMS 2018) see digital being coupled and decoupled from cultural policy.
The placement investigated ‘digital’ across a portfolio of social and technical responsibilities for a department, with the (ostensibly competing) aims of “driving growth, enriching lives, promoting Britain to the world”. Digital innovations through COVID-19 adaptations formed the basis for commissioning my placement (DCMS 2021; DCMS 2023, p46). Digital was posed as a default solution to other crises, including the cost of living, fuel and sustainability crises, the slower impacts of Brexit (ibid) and central disinvestment, without accommodating the social and technical crises of digital exclusion (House of Lords 2023).
These contradictions and crises were ideal to observe ‘the terms of policy debate’ in the context of wicked problems (Head 2022, pp. 61-62). Embedded research (ER) strengthens the relations between evidence and policy (Cheetham 2018). I undertook an ‘embedded evidence review’ (ERR) of digital policy whilst embedded in (DCMS) and its sectors (arts and culture), with access to evidence in the following categories: in the public domain; government sensitive; evidence in production; unpublished stakeholder evidence; perceptions of evidence and what had worked.
This paper presents findings from a UK ERR case, as an ‘in-the-round’ approach to evidence, improving knowledge of the wicked problems of digital policy, and of policy evidence in and of itself. It argues that were wicked problems better recognised in UK policy practice, digital policy-making and the role of evidence could be more impactful.
References
Cheetham, M. et. al. (2018). Embedded research: a promising way to create evidence-informed impact in public health? Journal of Public Health, 40(1). pp.64-70.
DCMS (1998) Creative Industries Mapping Document.
DCMS (2018) Culture is Digital https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/culture-is-digital
DCMS (2021) Boundless Creativity: Culture in a time of Covid
DCMS (2023) Creative Industries Sector Vision https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/creative-industries-sector-vision
DCMS & BIS (2009) Digital Britain https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a7c70d9e5274a5590059e1c/7650.pdf
Gray, C. (2009) Managing cultural policy: pitfalls and prospects. Public Administration, 87(3). pp. 574-585.
Head, B. (2022) Wicked Problems in Public Policy: Understanding and Responding to Complex Challenges. Palgrave Macmillan.
House of Lords Communications and Digital Committee (2023) Digital exclusion. House of Lords paper 219. https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld5803/ldselect/ldcomm/219/219.pdf
Oman, S. (2021). Understanding Well-being Data: Improving Social and Cultural Policy, Practice and Research. Palgrave Macmillan. https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-030-72937-0
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The discussion on Universal Health Coverage (UHC) and health financing to achieve UHC took pace with the 64th World Health Assembly (WHA) held in 2011, which had health financing as an effective plan. Anchoring the resolution of access to healthcare services without financial hardships of previous WHA resolutions and Article 25.1 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights,24 the 64th Assembly appealed to all the signatories to provide universal coverage and access to health on the principles of equity and solidarity. Invoking these principles of equity and solidarity helps recognize the wicked nature of the problem to be addressed by UHC. Equitable access to healthcare services without getting pushed into poverty is not simply dependent on the availability of services. Thereby unleashing the various levels of factors influencing health inequities like socio-economic differences, gender biases, and complex epidemiological and demographic patterns, making it impossible for the health systems to come up with a 'one size fits all' solution in eradicating inequities and achieving UHC.
The concept of Universal Health Coverage, as defined by the High-Level Expert Group in India, entails both protection from financial hardship and addressing social inequities in access to health. Given the vast diversity in the demographics of India and various healthcare needs, we attempt to view Universal Health Coverage as a wicked problem. A wicked problem occurs due to the existence of an underlying problem and discrepancies in its representation. The path of Universal Health Coverage in India entails ten central pillars under which policymakers must address the web of problems. We argue that the characteristics defining a wicked problem make Universal Health Coverage arduous for policymakers. And that the path to achieving Universal Health Coverage cannot be a straight one with a government-funded health insurance scheme. In this article, we argue that attaining Universal Health Coverage due to its multifaceted aspects is a wicked problem for the government. We specifically discuss whether the health financing and infrastructure attempts by the Indian government are the solution to the wicked problem of attaining Universal Health Coverage. We begin by briefly describing the path followed by India after independence towards Universal Health Coverage. We then discuss the distinctive features that make any problem wicked vis-à-vis the pillars of Universal Health Coverage as described by the High-Level Expert Group in India and discuss their wickedness aspects. This perspective article intends to draw the attention of the policymakers and relevant stakeholders to view achieving Universal Health Coverage beyond the scope of offering means-tested financial protection.
This article fits in with the first research question of the workshop, focusing on the challenges to define a wicked problem. Universal Health Coverage is viewed significantly differently across health systems, from being a guiding principle to being treated like a goal to achieve. However, in a health system like India, with vast geographic and demographic variations, achieving Universal Health Coverage uncovers a web of underlying problems. The lack of literature that views UHC as a wicked problem has encouraged us to explore the possibility of it being wicked to solve.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Wicked problems in the sustainable management of marine and coastal zone resources are intricately related to societal processes. They are produced largely by a combination of three major factors - 1. lack of data, poor or misrepresented data on the statuses of marine natural resources management, 2. the complexity of public responses to governance, and 3. absence of practically useful frameworks for local versus national governance of the sensitive zones. Wicked problems are largely associated with mismanagement of fisheries, unsustainable practices associated with eco-sensitive areas like mangroves, seagrass systems reefs or atolls, etc., and local misgovernance without identifying with the community-level socio-technical constraints. In a sea of wicked problems, the challenging endeavors of policymaking rely on avoiding the impacts on both the shores and the deep seas.
With dense population concentrated in coastal areas, growing human dependency on coastal ecosystem services, issues related to climate change, habitat alteration, urbanization and disasters in coastal zones around the world have put the spotlight on identifying and resolving wicked problems. These are critical assessments at the frontier of debates involving human development versus sustainable development. The first pre-requisite to positive capacity building towards resilience and adaptation is the resolution of the wicked problems to some extent, that may otherwise complicate key functionalities of governance - strategy making, organizational design, people management, and performance measurement (e.g. Head and Alford, 2015; Administration and Society) in non-traditional and nature-based sectors. The major objective of the present investigation is to understand the existence, type, and nature of wicked problems in the marine and coastal environmental sector from the perspective of the Global North and the Global South countries. The general objectives with special relevance to the marine and coastal zones are:
1. To explore the existence of unique wicked problems in the sector
2. To describe the nature, intensity, and magnitudes of those wicked problems
3. To determine framework setting goals that will alleviate the impacts of wicked problems exclusive to the sector.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The current and projected increase in water rates in a framework promoting water sobriety necessitates the establishment of compensatory measures by suppliers to ensure the availability of service for low-income households connected to water networks. In this perspective, a social water policy is implemented in France through direct aid systems - such as the water check, aid to manage debts, etc. - or preferential, even free, pricing systems for volumes of water considered essential. In this communication, we will revisit the genesis of this social water policy to examine the effectiveness of these systems in light of the real problems of access to drinking water and sanitation services for low-income households. The thesis defended in this work is that the social water policy in France was designed as a policy serving water operators - to avoid unpaid bills - rather than as a policy based on the real problems of precarious households in their access to water. This eco-solidarity policy needs to be reviewed in order to be a real lever of socio-environmental justice.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Participation of people in decision making and tackling complex problems where there is lack of consensus on the science and relevant values continues to be an important research topic. The Split Ladder of Participation was developed as a way of conceptualizing uncertainty in science as well as in values that inform policy decisions, thus adding a novel twist to the analysis of complex problems of Rittel and Webber (Rittel & Weber, 1973) that originally envisioned these problems as only involving facts (Potting et al., 2022). The Split Ladder offers a diagnostic framework for assessing which type of problems merit participation and what the possible policy outcomes of such participation would be. It enables strategizing participation in relation to policy problems based on considerations such as trust, complexity, desired outcome, and time. It was developed as a diagnostic tool to enable understanding on when participation is needed, and when participation could lead to problem solving. Moreover, when participation is done poorly, it can have negative consequences resulting in loss of trust. Building on Arnstein’s ladder of participation, the Split Ladder of Participation (Hurlbert & Gupta, 2015) addresses the conditions when participation is needed, is likely to work, and what it might achieve in difference circumstances. Four ideal typical circumstances (quadrants) were created to explain what the nature and goal of stakeholder participation is in each quadrant.
Against that background, this paper addresses the question: What does a literature review of the papers that applied the Split Ladder of Participation reveal about how this diagnostic and strategic tool can be improved? A systematic literature review revealed the ladder is applied to diverse, unstructured policy problems. Multiple actors define whether a problem is structured – including the researcher or policy entrepreneurs. Consensus on scientific and social science issues need differentiation. Participation in solving structured problems where there is agreement on science and values could promote learning and motivate participation. The inappropriate use of participation for complex problems might also (f) lead to policy lock-in and stalemates. Room for plural solutions and movement between structured and unstructured problems is also at times idea. Lastly, participation and politicization are important for democracy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The concept of wicked problem has an important deployment in public policy studies (Norton, 2012; Duckett et al., 2016) and public management (Christensen & Lægreid, 2011). Moreover, Xiang (2013) argues that several investigations analyze phenomena that meet their characteristics even without naming them as a wicked problem. Nevertheless, few investigations have approached the human rights study and policies aimed at guaranteeing them. However, human rights can be typified as a wicked problem (Herrera-Kit, 2019). This, because "If there is a consensus among those engaged in the systematic study of rights, it is precisely around the ambiguous and imprecise character of this notion" (Papacchini, 2003, p. 42).
However, the wickedness of human rights suggests going beyond the delimitation of the public problem to be intervened. The proliferation and dispersion of actions in the same field or system of policies addressed to managing a wicked problem can also have an impact on the overall coherence of the state response (Cejudo & Michel, 2016).
In Colombia, since the 1990s, several human rights education programs have been formulated as a chapter of human rights policies. The most recent policy, 2022, reports on the simultaneous coexistence of numerous strategies in human rights education carried out by different institutions (Herrera-Kit & Mejía, 2022). The purpose of this article is to analyze, based on a documentary review of current public actions with closed coding in MaxQDA, the effect that the wickedness of human rights education has on the coherence of the Colombian State's response in this issue. For this purpose, the wicked problem of human rights education in Colombia is documented. Then, the effect this has on the external coherence of the State's response to the international obligation of human rights education is characterized.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The human rights-based approach in public policy: A supporting tool for addressing wicked problems
Research question: Can the human rights approach be used as a public policy tool to understand better and address wicked problems?
The research is based on the premise that one factor that influences the correspondence of public policies with the requirements of contemporary society is their development in a polycontextual and polycentric environment. That is to say, in scenarios that favour their openness to different social contexts and the intervention of diverse actors.
Given the above, an analytical-synthetic study was carried out involving the human rights approach variable—related to the polycontextualism and polycentrism of public action— and the public policy variable—related to the technique according to which public action is systematically developed—. The analytical part of the research was carried out by examining the leading academic, legal and political documents linked to the origin, concept, development and practice of the human rights and public policy approach variables. Subsequently, the synthetic part of the research was carried out by articulating both variables in a structure related to the incidence of the human rights approach in the public policy cycle.
Based on the above, a methodology was designed to calculate the human rights approach of the entire public policy cycle or some of its phase(s) by selecting a set of elements of the indicator system and applying a mathematical algorithm created for this purpose.
*If my proposal is accepted, my participation will be in person.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Dark networks, covert and illegal, such as drugs and human trafficking, arms smuggling, terrorism, and unlawful immigration, among others, are considered a problem that brings disturbances in economic, social, and political terms at all government levels (Raab & Milward, 2003). To date, the literature on dark networks has focused on understanding the structure (Raab & Milward, 2003; 2006), topology (Xu & Chen, 2008), and governance (Bakker, Raab & Milward; 2011) of these networks, which would inform efforts to disrupt their activities (McBride & Hewitt, 2013). However, no theoretical or empirical contributions demonstrate how bright networks--overt and legal--might unintentionally create a "reflective bridge" that holds the dark networks' activities, effectiveness, and resilience.
Unlawful immigration across borders is a global and national public management concern and one that is linked to divisive politics and policy in the U.S. and other countries around the world. The U.S. government's efforts to prevent unauthorized immigration have been extensive, particularly in enforcement policy and in prosecuting dark network members and deporting undocumented immigrants. However, what may be underestimated is the "bridge" that bright networks furnish to unauthorized immigrants.
Building from the bright and dark networks scholarship and using secondary sources, we explore the relationship between bright and dark networks in the case of unauthorized immigration from Latin America (L.A.) to the U.S. The sources relied on immigration policies at the national and state levels, agency and organizational records, case studies reporting immigrants' experiences and correspondence between critical actors (e.g., coyotes, immigrants, NGOs), and other first-person accounts, news reports, and memoirs, yielding a rich account of networks' operations.
The main contribution is developing a conceptual framework called the "reflective bridge." We theorize that bright networks (e.g., religious organizations, NGOs, hybrid partnerships, and policy-making processes at the state level) may unintentionally create a "reflective bridge" that entices unauthorized immigration to the U.S. In doing so, bright networks refract brightness to dark networks, hiding and furthering their activities. We also argue that although opposite values and logic drive bright and dark networks, their work overlaps, creating a vicious cycle.
Given that the activity from dark networks is considered a transnational problem that brings disturbances in economic, social, and political terms, the arguments given in this paper will contribute to understanding their resilience. The concept of the reflective bridge could provide clues and insights into the regulations that local, national, and international governments should establish if the matter is to disrupt dark networks. Although this paper will only consider the case study of the dark network of informal immigration from Latin American countries to the United States, the theoretical development of reflective bridge could be examined in future study cases and research about dark networks in other policy areas.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The goal of the article is to propose a definition of the problem of technological unemployment based on the concepts of wicked problems literature. It is argued that this phenomenon is actually a system of at least two negatively correlated problems, since as one is resolved the other tends to worsen (Alford and Head, 2017; Head, 2019, 2022, 2023). The first is the lag in productivity, explained by an environment that is not conducive to technological automation; The second is the replacement of employees with automation technologies that incorporate artificial intelligence, which we will refer to as intelligent automation technologies (Dondi et al., 2021).
The dilemma of this system of problems occurs when attention is focused on only one, for example, when aggressive public policies are formulated for the incorporation of intelligent automation technologies, the total productivity of the factors of production is likely to increase. However, there will also be more workers displaced from their occupations who will find it difficult to relocate to contexts of economies with low growth, as is the case of those in Latin America. On the other hand, if legal measures are created to protect workers against automation, it is possible that jobs will be maintained for a time, but eventually these economies will become less productive than others and will inevitably produce fewer jobs.
According to the specialized literature, the system of problems described has at least three general causes: (1) the existence of environments that are not conducive to the adoption of automation technologies; (2) the inability of the educational system to generate human capital capable of coexisting with this type of technologies; and, (3) the rigidity of labor markets that make it difficult for workers to move between productive sectors, as well as the emergence of new forms of employment (Blit et al., 2018; EIU, 2018; Dondi et al., 2021).
Regarding the first cause, it is argued that actions that foster an environment conducive to the adoption of intelligent automation technologies can increase the productivity of production factors, although they also accelerate worker substitution processes. On the other hand, the other two causes have a direct relationship with both problems; That is, improvements in educational systems, as well as increases in the flexibility of labor markets, will tend to reduce both the lags in productivity and the probabilities that, in the short term, technological unemployment will occur (Blit et al., 2018).
In addition to the detailed definition of the problem, the article aims to outline the general elements that a mix of public policies should have to address them simultaneously (Howlett and del Río, 2015). It is considered an original contribution given that until now no efforts have been made to study this public problem from the perspective of wicked problems.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Depression in Mexico represents a complex public health challenge, characterized by its elusive nature and far-reaching consequences. This paper explores the prevalence, risk factors, and implications of adolescent depression, emphasizing its classification as a wicked problem in public health, for which there is no consensus on their nature, their possible solutions, or the values and principles that should guide their improvement (Head, 2022). Despite being a leading cause of disability globally (Moreno-Gordillo et al., 2019), the intangibility of its root causes and the societal stigma surrounding mental health have contributed to its invisibility within public policy and healthcare systems.
The study highlights the interaction between sociostructural factors and adolescent depression, revealing how limited resources and educational opportunities render individuals more susceptible to experiencing episodes of sadness or depression. In this sense, the paper aims to answer the question of how the interrelation of various societal factors impacts Mexican adolescents' mental health. For this purpose, some data from the National Health and Nutrition Survey and a Correspondence Analysis are used, emphasizing the need for a deep understanding of the underlying causes of depression to develop effective interventions and policies.
The paper points out the urgency of addressing adolescent depression as a wicked problem, transcending traditional linear theoretical approaches to public health challenges. It becomes apparent that simply addressing the symptoms or consequences of depression is insufficient. Instead, a holistic and multidimensional approach is essential for developing comprehensive and sustainable interventions that prioritize the well-being of the younger generation.
By analyzing data on mortality from the National Institute of Statistics and Geography, the study also draws attention to the alarming increase in suicide rates among adolescents in Mexico over the past decade, as a response to hopelessness and meaninglessness in life (Case & Deaton, 2020). It also highlights the critical need for a paradigm shift in addressing mental health issues. By reframing the discourse around mental health as a public problem and acknowledging the dense web of factors contributing to adolescent depression, policymakers and healthcare professionals can work towards developing innovative and collaborative solutions that emphasize the importance of primary care policies.
References
Case, A., & Deaton, A. (2020). Deaths of despair and the future of capitalism. Princeton University Press.
Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geografía (INEGI). (s.f.). Mortalidad. Recuperado de https://www.inegi.org.mx/temas/mortalidad/#tabulados
Head, B. W. (2022). Wicked Problems in Public Policy Understanding and Responding to Complex Challenges. Palgrave Macmillan.
Moreno-Gordillo, G. de J., Trujillo-Olivera, L. E., García-Chong, N. R., & Tapia-Garduño, F. (2019). Suicidio y depresión en adolescentes: una revisión de la literatura. Revista Chilena de Salud Pública, 23(1).
ENSANUT. (2021). Encuesta Nacional de Salud y Nutrición. Instituto Nacional de Salud Pública.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Although policy coherence is pivotal in contemporary public administration, its boundary-spanning nature in complex policies (Jochim & May, 2010), like social protection, makes it a wicked problem. Social protection uses a mix of sub-policy instruments e.g., social insurance, social assistance, and labour-market policies, to reduce poverty (ILO, 2017). Simultaneously, policy coherence combines policy domains through programmes which address every dimension of the problem, and requires cross-ministerial coordination to avoid duplication (Cejudo & Michel, 2017). For social protection systems, this is potentially a wicked problem - lacking a definitive formulation, a finite set of binary potential solutions, and an ultimate test of effectiveness (Rittel & Webber, 1973).
Despite the generalisation that most African social protection systems lack coherence (ILO, 2017), there is limited research on the problem’s wickedness. Therefore, this article examines the question, “How and why is social protection systems-coherence a persistent wicked problem in Africa despite various coherence mechanisms?” It employs the ‘wicked problems’ heuristic by Alford & Head (2017) and its intersection with ‘policy coherence’ and ‘social protection systems.’ The heuristic suggests that wickedness varies by clarity of the problem and solution on the one hand and complexity of stakeholders on the other – offering nine possible levels of wickedness. This study plots five dimensions of social protection-systems-coherence i.e., system-definition, policy-coherence, administrative-coherence, internal-coherence, and external-coherence - on the wickedness continuum. A qualitative case study design of Uganda’s and South Africa’s social protection systems was used. Elite interviews were conducted with bureaucrats, academics and NGOs in Uganda (N=40) and South Africa (N=22) in April – December 2023, complemented by secondary data. MAXQDA analysis software was used.
Preliminary results reveal diverse wickedness levels. Uganda faces 'politically turbulent' challenges in administrative and internal coherence, while South Africa confronts a 'very wicked' problem in administrative, internal, and external coherence. Both countries grapple with a 'very wicked’ problem of external-coherence, dealing with multiple possible policy configurations. South Africa's internal-coherence is a 'very wicked’ problem due to a diverse range of social protection programmes, contrasting with Uganda's fewer programmes and 'politically turbulent' nature in this regard. ‘Conceptual contentions’ in defining social protection systems exist in both settings. Additionally, variations in the level of wickedness emerge in the policy-coherence dimension. Uganda presents an 'analytically complex' scenario with a cognitive lead ministry and a unifying policy, while South Africa faces a 'conceptually contentious' policy-coherence challenge with neither a lead ministry nor a unified policy. Therefore, mature systems and nascent systems exhibit varying degrees of wickedness.
Alford, J., & Head, B. W. (2017). Wicked and less wicked problems: A typology and a contingency framework. Policy and Society, 36(3), 397–413. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2017.1361634
Cejudo, G. M., & Michel, C. L. (2017). Addressing fragmented government action: coordination, coherence, and integration. Policy Sciences, 50(4). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-017-9281-5
ILO. (2017). World Social Protection Report 2017–19: Universal social protection to achieve the Sustainable Development Goals. In World Social Protection Report 2017-19.
Jochim, A. E., & May, P. J. (2010). Beyond subsystems: Policy regimes and governance. Policy Studies Journal, 38(2), 303–327. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1541-0072.2010.00363.x
Rittel, H. W. J., & Webber, M. M. (1973). Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning. In Policy Sciences (Vol. 4).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Wicked problems have been studied from different public policy perspectives (Rittel and Webber, 1973) during the last 50 years. Their study has been fundamental to the understanding of how policy regimes have overlapping topics. Two policy regimes have been promoted in the past 8 years in a parallel way, without enough interaction of their practices and study. Disaster Risk Reduction policies and Climate Change policies, which in practice involve similar actions, have their framework, language, and treaties in the international and academic community. This research asks: how can local governments adapt their policies to the international framework of risk reduction and climate change? The research argues that the lack of dialogue between the international guidelines increases the wickedness behind climate change and disaster policies at the local level. Through legal and policy analysis of the international, national, and local policies in Mexico, it is shown that the deep disconnection between them makes it difficult to address concrete solutions and responses to hydrometeorological hazards. As theoretical research, the droughts in Zacatecas, México, are used as an example of how the miscommunication between frameworks contributes to increasing the wickedness of isolated policies. It was found how droughts, which have been a constant hazard with 1967 municipal declarations during 2000 and 2023, from which 108 were from Zacatecas, are addressed as isolated and random phenomena instead of being understood as a result of socio-environmental processes. Framed in the literature as both disasters and a consequence of climate change, droughts are partially treated from both types of policies in Zacatecas, without a holistic approach considering the local capabilities and vulnerabilities of the community. This case provides evidence of how the wickedness of public problems could lead to disarticulated frameworks that just perpetuate their causes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
An exhaustive analysis of the public policy network in the Pánuco River Basin area of Mexico has been conducted. The objective is to identify the structural conditions within the policy subsystem that foster an agenda of integrated, adaptive, and participatory water management, particularly one that advances environmental water policies. The approach to this policy network analysis centers on the characteristics of the community of actors, encompassing both public and private entities, associated with the key public issues related to water management in the Pánuco River Basin from 2012 to 2022. Additionally, it examines the nature of interactions, whether cooperative or conflictual, among these actors. Methodologically, the analysis employs policy network analysis using secondary sources of information, primarily official documents and newspaper sources. The information obtained was processed using Gephi software. The results reveal a highly centralized policy network, dominated by federal authorities and state governments, with identified conflicts on various issues. This configuration shapes the network as a system of asymmetrical dominance and negotiation, presenting a significant impediment to a shift in orientation in the basin's water policy. The presence of conflicts and the centralization of decision-making that hinder greater actor participation in policy design and operational instruments are discussed. The discussion emphasizes the necessity to promote an inclusive and participatory structure that fosters collaboration to advance towards sustainable and equitable water management in the Pánuco River Basin.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The main objective of this article is to explore the expansion of religious freedom as a "wicked problem" through a public policy approach. To achieve this, I employ a qualitative methodology that integrates elements of grounded theory by conducting an analysis of public policy documents on religious freedom in Mexico and Colombia from 1990 to 2023. A key insight I have discovered is the intricate nature of the expansion of religious freedom, that, since its inception as a public issue, there is no well-defined public problem. In addition, I have observed that programs and interventions aimed at addressing this issue are inherently diffuse in both countries. Moreover, I have identified moments of policy change and counter-transfer within the process of expanding religious freedom, highlighting the interplay between social demands originating in the religious sector and the politicization of this right in the context of electoral processes. In sum, my research sheds light on the complexity of the expansion of religious freedom, while underscoring the importance of considering its political and social dimensions in the public policy arena in Mexico and Colombia.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Recognizing the growing significance of wicked problems in public policy, I delve into the intricate ways homelessness is socially constructed and framed within Mexico's specific public policy context. Homelessness is widely acknowledged as a wicked problem due to its multifaceted nature and the absence of straightforward solutions. This study focuses on Mexico, where homelessness presents a complex societal challenge. One significant knowledge gap lies in understanding the social construction of target populations, especially individuals experiencing homelessness, within the broader context of wicked public policy problems. To address this gap, this paper presents innovative methodological approaches and interdisciplinary strategies. I explore the inherent challenges of defining wicked problems, emphasizing the characteristics that distinguish them within public policy. This discussion clarifies what makes a problem "wicked" in this context. Furthermore, I discuss the methodological approaches, both quantitative and qualitative, as well as the use of mixed-method designs, applied to analyze the complexity and dynamics of wicked problems. Through this research, I highlight the pivotal role of social narratives in shaping the identities and experiences of homeless populations within public policy. By studying homelessness as a wicked problem through the lens of social construction, I contribute valuable insights to inform more effective and empathetic policy responses in Mexico.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
As populations age, the design and implementation of public policies aimed at tackling challenges faced by older persons become even more relevant and acutely necessary. However, there is still a gap in our understanding of the multiple intersecting difficulties that people face as they age. In this paper I use an intersectional lens to examine contemporary eldercare policies. I undertake a comparative analysis of policy instruments for older persons’ care in two Mexican cities. Using a combination of ethnographic fieldwork and interviews, I examine how different subnational governments frame the care of older persons and whether the policy instruments they have implemented can be considered truly intersectional. I argue that a wicked problems lens combined with an intersectional approach can shed light on the potential solutions to this policy issue.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This article is set in the perspective of public policy studies and is based on the importance of defining the public problem, considering it a crucial process for finding effective solutions. The proper definition of a public problem is fundamental for the formulation of policies that address issues competing for the attention of decision-makers in the public sphere.
Some problems are so complex (wicked problems) that there is no consensus on their definition among the actors involved in the process. One prominent issue is the issue of abortion, which has been addressed in different ways in different States. Legislation varies, ranging from legalization, to decriminalization in certain circumstances, to total prohibition in some contexts.
This article focuses on a few Central American countries where there is a significant lag in decriminalization. It examines how the definition of the public problem of abortion by those who promote policies or reforms can determine whether the demand for decriminalization is successful or not. It analyzes the various definitions of abortion in these countries, both in the policy structure (polity) and in the actors involved in the construction of the agenda (politics).
A content analysis is applied to identify key discursive codes in the definition of the public problem of abortion. This technical and political approach to the definition of the problem offers a comprehensive view of how the abortion issue is addressed in the Central American context and how it influences public policy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
New technologies and artificial intelligence have been presented as an innovative way of approaching the problem of evidence for policymaking purposes, looking at the opportunities offered by big data and machine learning to transform the use of data (Calo, 2017). Artificial intelligence is already used in several policy areas such as public health and tax collection as an important tool for producing new evidence and processing the information needed for policymaking purposes when dealing with wicked problems. However, its use has also opened a vast new area of inquiry into the use of information in public policymaking, and much of it is related to ethics (Newman and Mintrom, 2023, p. 1840). Analysing the literature on the ethics of artificial intelligence in policymaking, Newman (2022) has concluded that scholars and analysts sit on two extremes. They are either highly supportive, looking at how machine learning can help to overcome biases and boost fairness, therefore enabling the use of evidence, or, at the very least, supporting policy-based evidence to better communicate and unpack the values of both the society and of policymakers, allowing a dialogue both ways (from the policymakers to citizens and the other way around). Or, on the other extreme, observers have criticised the use of artificial intelligence and how it can increase biases, leading to more injustice for the already vulnerable groups, being a black box, which does not allow adapting policies on time, and decreasing policy capacity by not using institutional memory (Newman and Mintrom, 2023).
We argue that this debate needs to be complemented by an understanding of how artificial intelligence helps or, therefore, prevents policymakers from navigating the complexity of policy creation and implementation when dealing with wicked problems. When discussing complexity, we refer to the feedback loops that the use of artificial intelligence can initiate or reinforce, and the unintended consequences that emerge as a consequence of using policy evidence created through machine learning.
We aim to clarify how and if the distinction between the creation and use of evidence needs to be re-conceptualised in an era of artificial intelligence in which information is created to be deployed for policy design, but its use can be corrected through the continuous flow of information which can then be transformed into new evidence that can nourish the process of deploying new policies, therefore addressing the ethical concerns that have been raised previously. Moreover, we look at how and if recent efforts of regulating the use of artificial intelligence can address these ethical concerns, and if the use of evidence generated by artificial intelligence has more potential in one of the policy stages (either agenda-setting, or policy creation, implementation and evaluation).
Our proposal fits within T03-W02, accounting for the connection between ethics and uncertainty in policymaking when dealing with wicked problems. We aim to present our research on-site during the IWPP4.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Some authors in the literature argue that wicked problems are proliferating. However, in analyzing why some contemporary problems are "wicked," we tend to find that most explanations are vague and very generalist. Originally, wicked problems emerged as a critique of systems analysis and rational planning, not as a proposal to "improve policy analysis and social planning practices" (Head 2019, p. 181). And, for the founders of the concept, wicked problems were not some special policy problems, but "almost all public policy issues" (Rittel &Webber 1973, p. 160). However, in the literature there has been an "essentialist" (or ontological) approach that understands that there are different types of "policy problems", some of them being wicked. This "essentialist" approach has been criticized by various authors (Turnbull & Hoppe, 2017; Noordegraaf, et al., 2019; Peters, 2017).
In this paper we argue that this "essentialist" approach could be related to the inability to generate a solid analytical framework on what factors make it difficult to manage certain issues from a policy perspective. In this sense, we argue that we should not focus on the "policy problem", but rather on the factors that interact in the policy process intensifying wickedness. In this sense, the research question guiding the article is the following: what are the factors that intensify wickedness in the policy process? This article explores a process-oriented approach to wicked problems and proposes a new framework that identifies some key factors that intensify wickedness in the policy process.
I would like to present the document on site.
References:
- Head, B. W. (2019). Forty years of wicked problems literature: Forging closer links to policy studies. Policy and Society, 38(2), 180-197. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2018.1488797.
- Noordegraaf, M., Douglas, S., Geuijen, K., & Van Der Steen, M. (2019). Weaknesses of wickedness: A critical perspective on wickedness theory. Policy and Society, 38(2), 278-297. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2019.1617970.
- Peters, B. G. (2017). What is so wicked about wicked problems? A conceptual analysis and a research program. Policy and Society, 36(3), 385-396. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2017.1361633.
- Rittel, H. W., & Webber, M. M. (1973). Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Policy sciences, 4(2), 155-169. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01405730.
- Turnbull, N., & Hoppe, R. (2019). Problematizing ‘wickedness’: a critique of the wicked problems concept, from philosophy to practice. Policy and Society, 38(2), 315-337. https://doi.org/10.1080/14494035.2018.1488796.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Climate change presents a quintessential example of a wicked problem, necessitating ambitious and accelerated climate policy. However, the implementation of such policies, particularly 'hard' policies imposing costs and sanctions, pose the risk of triggering policy backlash. From the perspective of wicked problems, these policies are “subject to real-world constraints” (Rittel and Weber, 1973) which in turn, might condition policy backlash. But despite growing concern about backlash, there remains limited understanding of when it does or does not occur. Therefore, this paper seeks to unravel the conditions under which policy backlash occurs.
We adopt an innovative methodological design bringing together the richness of qualitative data with medium-N comparative analysis by conducting a fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) of a systematic sample of 30 national-scale hard climate policies in OECD countries from 2009-2022. Building on recent calls to re-embrace the qualitative essence of fsQCA, we interpretively draw on multiple in-depth data sources including over 50 structured interviews with national policymakers in the cases, policy documents, media analysis, and existing quantitative data. We systematically analyze a comprehensive deductively-derived set of possible explanatory conditions spanning both policy design and policy context. Findings suggest that policy stringency, implementation approach, and equity within policy design, along with political polarization, economic vulnerability, and societal inequality in the broader policy context, seem to be associated with backlash.
Overall, this paper makes three significant contributions to understanding the politics of climate policy action. First, it provides insights into the drivers of volatile reactions in wicked climate policymaking extending beyond design-focused considerations to encompass the broader policy context, which is lacking to date. Second, an original data-rich fsQCA provides a novel comparative perspective on policy backlash beyond existing small-N case studies. Third, it helps improve policymaking practices by accounting for critical drivers of contestation in climate policy.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In Mexico, families of missing persons, their companions, and advocates have taken on search tasks in various contexts. This has been a response to the absolute or partial gaps left by the institutionalization of search efforts and the implementation of policies regarding disappearances. In light of this scenario, questions arise about the factors that influence the construction of the search as a complex problem, so that citizen strategies have been key in this process.
Assuming the analytical perspective of actor-centered institutionalism, the discussion delves into the case study of the National Brigades for the Search of Missing Persons (Brigadas Nacionales de Búsqueda de Personas Desaparecidas). This initiative, propelled by the National Links Network (Red de Enlaces Nacionales), has been promoted in four entities of the country between 2016 and 2022. This articulation space serves as a platform for coordination among collectives of victims' families, that through exchanges with various social and political actors, has developed a comprehensive search methodology as an alternative solution to an extremely complex problem.
In light of these search experiences, the results highlight the slow progress in ensuring the right of every person to be searched for, the failure of the Mexican state's obligation to locate and identify all victims of the crime, and the absence of a structural solution to the public problem of disappearances. There is a call to continue fostering deep and interdisciplinary discussions that allow for addressing search strategies as alternative solutions to a complex problem that varies according with different contexts and local dynamics.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Throughout most of Mexico’s participation in the OECD’s PISA test (every three years between 2000 and 2018), mean performance remained stable in reading, mathematics and science. Nevertheless, the OECD acknowledged that there were hidden positive trends: at the same time the matriculation improved significantly, the lowest-achieving students shrank their gap in mathematics and science with the highest- achieving students.
Even though the learning outcomes of basic education students is a strong indicator of the quality of an educational system, assessing them through national and international surveys is no guarantee that educational authorities will use its results to enhance public policies or that, if they do, they can claim a clear link between the evidence of an improvement and previous policy decisions. Why is this so?
In this paper I argue that addressing the quality of education is a typical wicked problem that additionally poses specific dimensions of uncertainty for decision-makers. My case will be based on the examination of the Mexican policy process on the use of foreign and domestic assessments to inform policy decisions to improve the quality of basic education. I will make use of secondary sources and of semi-structured interviews to former authorities and high level bureaucrats to document these difficulties.
My research will comprise three presidential terms (2000-2006, 2006-2012 and 2012-2018) from two different political parties (PAN, 2000-2012 and PRI, 2012-2008). These three governments implemented policies to improve the quality of basic education, but they did so through different approaches, varying from an inherited Program, a political agreement with the teacher’s union, new laws and programs, and a Constitutional reform.
The main contribution of this paper is to demonstrate that there is no clear causal link between today’s policy-decisions, its implementation tomorrow and the evidence of an improvement (or not) on learning outcomes to be measured later by learning assessments. The political context as well as the students implied by previous decisions on policy will have changed by then.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Practices of sex-selective abortions, female infanticide and abandonment of girl infants manifest the “unwantedness” of girl children in India. In 2016, the Rajasthan state government emulated a 27-year-old programme in Tamil Nadu. It introduced the “Cradle Scheme” which entailed public hospitals installing cradles in which parents could ‘safely’ abandon their girl child (Ali, 2016). Exposing uncertainties, ambiguities and unforeseeable consequences, schemes like these epitomise wicked problems and lay bare the tension between immediate state responses and the inadvertent endorsement of condemned behaviours. In this paper, we explore cases of different numbers and policy targets (e.g., sex ratio and population), and analyse their intersections and contradictions. Using a multiple exploratory case-study method, we review debates and discourses in existing literature using secondary data sources like newspaper reports, journal articles, government policy documents, etc.
We argue that interventions guided by narrowly defined aims and quantifiable targets lend themselves to a technocratic approach fixated on numbers and outputs, often ignoring the impact of the programme on multiple stakeholders. Through the findings, this paper calls for comprehensive framing of policies and evaluation measures which facilitate more effective responses, accounting for qualitative social and ethical concerns and externalities. Contributing to the extant scholarly literature on wicked problems, this paper theoretically locates wicked problems in the context of social policies. Unveiling the multiplexity and uncertainties that enmesh such issues, the paper yields key insights for policymakers to rethink the definition of initiatives and the assessment of outcome measures beyond myopic technocratic frameworks. It provides direction for further research to test these findings with similar government initiatives across different empirical settings.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Policy issues are characterized by a composite character of the problem. The concept of “Wicked Problems” has gained significance across various fields (Head, 2022; Peters, 2017; Peters and Hoornbeek , 2005). Public decision-makers cope with "wicked or intractable" problems, often tied to historical periods, contexts and available knowledge. These reflections are articulated in the works of Rittel and Weber [1973] who emphasize the need to address "wicked problems", those that are difficult or impossible to solve due to being indefinable or insoluble or lacking a single solution.
One of the sectors that can present emerging problems is the environmental policy, marked by complexity, uncertainty, and novelty.
The paper aims to address the following questions: How can we define a “wicked problem” in a multilevel context? Does the multilevel context and the competing competences of authorities- influence the definition and resolution of wicked problems?
The paper will investigate an empirical case study providing lessons learned from applying the analytical lenses of wicked problems. Considering the European Green, designed to tackle the green transition through strategic leverage at the EU level, the paper will examine the Italian case by analysing the National Plan for the Green Transition in order to explain the contextual factors and the different implementation patterns. Particularly, the paper will focus on improving air quality as the “wicked problem” to be inquired, detecting the strategies employed to address them. The paper will trace the case by means of semi-structured interviews, media and document analysis.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
"Unveiling Inequality: An Environmental Justice Approach to Air Pollution Wicked Problem on Environmental Policy"
There is a global consensus regarding the importance of mitigating air pollution. Policies that address environmental contamination help address both climate change and human health issues. Despite substantive efforts to design robust environmental policies in Mexico, air pollution remains a public issue far from being resolved. This paper introduces an environmental justice approach to analyze and assess, within the policy decision process of environmental policy design, to what extent inequality impacts the selection of environmental public policy instruments aimed at addressing air pollution wicked problem. An environmental justice approach, focused on equity and collective well-being, is considered essential for understanding the outcomes of environmental policies in Mexico, given that it involves a wicked problem. In the present research, a sequential exploratory mixed-methods methodology was employed, consisting of two sections: Qualitative (recessive and dominant) and Quantitative. For the qualitative section, semi-structured interviews were analyzed with decision-makers in subnational environmental policy to explore social relationships and systems of meaning, as well as to understand the motivations of the involved actors. In the sequential quantitative section, an ordinary least squares (OLS) model was developed to explain the effect of political, economic, and racial inequality on the approximated outcomes of environmental policies. The qualitative component generated independent findings and informed the quantitative component, while also supporting the primary quantitative objective. The research empirically confirmed two hypotheses: 1) Economic inequality affects the ability to advocate for stricter environmental controls, and 2) Economic-political elites influence the selection of policy actions in environmental policies. This paper aims to identify air pollution as a wicked problem within the framework of environmental justice, allowing for an exploration of how wicked problems in air pollution policy have been addressed and can be addressed in the future.
Keywords: Wicked problems, Environmental Justice, Mixed-Methods, Air Pollution, Policy Decisions
I am considering presenting on-site
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Breede Valley within the Cape Winelands district municipality (Western Cape province, South Africa) is renowned for its fast specialization in export-oriented fruit production since South the country’s transition to democracy in 1994. Over a couple of decades, the region has transformed into a booming agricultural place (for table grape production and deciduous fruits), tightly integrated to global value chains, with a high water footprint, while attracting a massive influx of workers seeking jobs in the industry.
South Africa however is a water-scarce country, periodically dealing with prolonged episodes of drought. Climate change is predicted to worsen these semi-arid conditions. At the same time, the Breede Valley exhibits alarming levels of poverty which prompted the municipality to roll out programs of food security and climate change adaptation. Against such backdrop, this paper questions how local government might be able to deal with such challenges in order to promote sustainable local food systems. Indeed, there has been a dense literature advocating food re-localization going all the way back to the 1990-2000s, amidst criticisms against agricultural industrialization (Kloppenburg et al., 2000), up until today where a territorial approach in food planning and policy is supported in the academic literature as a way to foster food systems‘ resilience and adaptation to changes and effective risk management (Losch & May, 2023). In addition, literature on climate change governance tends to designate the local level as the most suitable one for the sake of adaptation (Henstra, 2019).
We would like to discuss local level’s capabilities in governing food systems, particularly in a context of increasing climate variability. In particular, we raise the question of the local governments’ capabilities in terms of means of action (either human, financial, legal mandate, expertise etc) as well as in terms of political influence more generally. Indeed, despite a general call for local governments to step in and contribute to managing upcoming crises through various policy initiatives (community gardens amongst others), we will emphasize both the local agency but also the many limitations faced by local public actors in promoting just and sustainable food transitions owing to adverse global dynamics and national level policy side-effects. Using neo-institutionalism as well as a multi-scale politics’ theoretical framework, we will mention in particular path dependence explanations in the case of water management policy, the influence of global market price and standards dictating crop selection and production (instead of natural resources availability) as well as the paradoxical effects of a series of regulatory changes intended to protect labor rights, that actually prompted a movement of resorting to seasonal workers with more precarious living conditions. Overall, indeed, there seems to be a growing mismatch between local food regimes and broader scales’ directives. From a methodological viewpoint, we will rely on data collected during a field work conducted in the Breede Valley Municipality in April 2023 where we interviewed over 30 key informants.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper presents findings from my two-year placement in the UK Government's Department for Digital, Culture, Media & Sport (DCMS 2022-24) as digital responsibility unexpectedly leaves DCMS (2023). UK cultural policy is managed as social policy (Gray 2009; Oman 2021). Digital policy-making has been conceptually linked to cultural policy since 1998 (DCMS 1998). However, policy documents and administrative changes (e.g. DCMS & BIS 2009; DCMS 2018) see digital being coupled and decoupled from cultural policy.
The placement investigated ‘digital’ across a portfolio of social and technical responsibilities for a department, with the (ostensibly competing) aims of “driving growth, enriching lives, promoting Britain to the world”. Digital innovations through COVID-19 adaptations formed the basis for commissioning my placement (DCMS 2021; DCMS 2023, p46). Digital was posed as a default solution to other crises, including the cost of living, fuel and sustainability crises, the slower impacts of Brexit (ibid) and central disinvestment, without accommodating the social and technical crises of digital exclusion (House of Lords 2023).
These contradictions and crises were ideal to observe ‘the terms of policy debate’ in the context of wicked problems (Head 2022, pp. 61-62). Embedded research (ER) strengthens the relations between evidence and policy (Cheetham 2018). I undertook an ‘embedded evidence review’ (ERR) of digital policy whilst embedded in (DCMS) and its sectors (arts and culture), with access to evidence in the following categories: in the public domain; government sensitive; evidence in production; unpublished stakeholder evidence; perceptions of evidence and what had worked.
This paper presents findings from a UK ERR case, as an ‘in-the-round’ approach to evidence, improving knowledge of the wicked problems of digital policy, and of policy evidence in and of itself. It argues that were wicked problems better recognised in UK policy practice, digital policy-making and the role of evidence could be more impactful.
References
Cheetham, M. et. al. (2018). Embedded research: a promising way to create evidence-informed impact in public health? Journal of Public Health, 40(1). pp.64-70.
DCMS (1998) Creative Industries Mapping Document.
DCMS (2018) Culture is Digital https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/culture-is-digital
DCMS (2021) Boundless Creativity: Culture in a time of Covid
DCMS (2023) Creative Industries Sector Vision https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/creative-industries-sector-vision
DCMS & BIS (2009) Digital Britain https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a7c70d9e5274a5590059e1c/7650.pdf
Gray, C. (2009) Managing cultural policy: pitfalls and prospects. Public Administration, 87(3). pp. 574-585.
Head, B. (2022) Wicked Problems in Public Policy: Understanding and Responding to Complex Challenges. Palgrave Macmillan.
House of Lords Communications and Digital Committee (2023) Digital exclusion. House of Lords paper 219. https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld5803/ldselect/ldcomm/219/219.pdf
Oman, S. (2021). Understanding Well-being Data: Improving Social and Cultural Policy, Practice and Research. Palgrave Macmillan. https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-030-72937-0
EXPORT PDF (FULL)