W01. Decentralization, state capacities and public policies: what is new to discover?
Public Administration, Governance, NetworksCATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
In decentralized countries the subnational governments have become the central units for implementing and providing public policies, which has increased their responsibilities and powers. These new responsibilities were followed by greater political, administrative and financial autonomy. In this sense, the requirements to qualify the subnational administration and governance were expanded to respond to its new roles both at the local level and in intergovernmental relations. Considering that, the research question of the workshop is: how does decentralization affect subnational state capacities and the implementation and provision of public policies?
Many countries have implemented the decentralization since the 1980’s, especially the Latin American federations (Argentina, Brazil, Mexico) and unitary countries (Colombia, Ecuador, Costa Rica, Uruguay, among others). This process also has characterized European countries such as Germany, Spain, and Switzerland, and dual federations such as United States and Canada. India in Asia is also a relevant case, as Australia in Oceania and Nigeria, Ethiopia, and South Africa in Africa. There are many different routes to decentralization and each national case does not have the same and political, administrative, and financial designs.
The demands imposed by the new responsibilities to the subnational level as a result of decentralized public policies has induced the creation, building and/or strengthening of their state capacities. In this sense, capabilities have become a key element to build and consolidate the autonomy attributed to subnational governments within the framework of decentralizing models. Therefore, the decentralization process requires more capacities in subnational governments. However, the comparative literature on decentralization lacks a more systematic approach linking this process and its effects on subnational state capacities and public policies. This is theoretical and empirical problem still asks more research.
This analytical gap of the decentralization takes on greater relevance after the COVID-19 pandemic because subnational governments were the main sphere responsible for formulating and implementing many public policies. The workshop is proposed in the context of the rapid changes in public administration and territorial governance provoked by the pandemic as a complex intergovernmental problem (Paquet and Schertzer, 2020). Investigating how subnational governments managed to provide service and public policies in this scenario is also linked to the historical design of decentralization in each country with its political, financial, and administrative dimensions. The context of the pandemic crisis is a hallmark for assessing whether subnational state capacities have contributed to improve the public administration and public policies. In this context, the research question is relevant to allow understanding whether national cases of decentralization have been implemented, considering the need to strengthen subnational state capacities as core inputs to implement public policies.
This goal is even more challenging when the problems require high levels of multilevel governance was the case with the COVID-19 pandemic. The complexity and novelty of this problem, considering its spillover effects, challenged countries to develop new intergovernmental policy capacities, especially the subnational units. It is also important to highlight the importance of subnational governments in the 2030 Agenda (Lee, 2023). In short, analyzing decentralization and its effects on subnational governments and their state capacities and public policies, the context after the pandemic and the implementation of the SDGs updates the research question.
The research question is scientifically relevant because decentralization has become a dynamic process through which many federative and unitary countries, at least in the last four decades, have built instruments to delegate responsibilities for public policies to regions and cities. Although, in many cases, the decentralization was not an organized process it stimulated the development of local and/or regional bureaucracies focused on implementing different public policies for many groups of citizens. Somehow, subnational state capacities were developed, but we know little about this side of the decentralization and the consequences in the implementation of public policies.
The research question is also relevant because the effort to approach the literature on decentralization to and the variance of subnational state capacity is more recent, seeking to address their effects on public policies at the territorial level (Luna and Soifer, 2017; Meza, 2021). In general, decentralization promised better democratic governance, more efficiency for the public administration and public policies more adjusted to needs of citizens. However, over time, many problems and challenges still persist, such as territorial inequality, poor quality of life, corruption, poor performance in providing services to citizens, reduced own-source revenues, and weak democratic governance, at least in less developed countries. These issues have become even more important after the pandemic because changes in the economic and social context have hit affected the people’s lives in the territories harder (Peters, Grin, and Abrucio, 2021).
This state-of-the-art seeks to approach two strands of literature based on the assumption that subnational administrative, technical, institutional, and political state capacities are pivotal for a sustainable decentralization and good public policies at the territorial level (Andrews, Pritchett, and Woolcock, 2017; OECD, 2019). Considering this current debate, the contributions expected from workshop participants are focused on connecting these three topics – decentralization, state capacity, and public policies (Smith, 2023). We hope that participants from federations and unitary countries will contribute to deepening the knowledge around these issues, both theoretically and empirically, to advance the understanding of this research topic.
This workshop builds on existing research considering the need to approach the three theorical strands. There are many works that addresses decentralization and public policies, as well as a literature that analyzes state capacities and public policies. However, to advance scientific knowledge of the decentralization process it would be important to consider state capacity as an additional theoretical. The post-COVID-19 pandemic has made this discussion even more relevant, and we hope that this workshop can contribute in this regard. The main hypotheses that the workshop seek to explore are:
1. The development and variance of subnational state capabilities in decentralization contexts affects the territorial equality and the performance of public policies.
2. The design and quality of democratic governance in territories are affected by the level of development of subnational state capacities.
3. The development of subnational state capabilities in decentralization contexts is related to the quality of public administration in combating corruption, increasing own revenues and the performance of bureaucracies.
4. The development of subnational state capacities affects their role in the multilevel arrangements.
These three hypotheses are original, as they: a) highlight the importance of using the literature on state capabilities to analyze their variance in subnational governments and their effects on public policies and territorial inequality; b) allow analyzing whether the performance of democratic governance in the territories is related to the quality of subnational state capabilities; c) allow us to analyze whether subnational state capabilities helped local governments fulfill key promises of decentralization (less corruption, greater administrative and bureaucratic efficiency and greater potential for generating their own revenue) that would boost better public policies and quality of life in the territories.
This workshop is open to receive papers focused on developing theoretical, methodological and analytical models that address decentralization, state capacities, and public policies, empirical works both discussing national cases or in a comparative way. We welcome both quantitative or qualitative papers that explore different dimensions of the decentralization (administrative, financial, and political), and different dimensions of state capacity (administrative, technical, institutional, and political). The papers could address sectoral policies or even analyze decentralization in a more general way. The workshop is open to a variety of different types of papers in order to contribute to improve the knowledge on this research topic.
The sessions will be organized this way. Each author will present their paper in 15 minutes. The discussant will provide feedback and the author will respond. If necessary, the chair and co-chairs may also contribute with additional comments. Next, the discussion will open to participants who will also be asked to read the works, as a way of qualifying comments, questions and the discussion as whole. We hope that each session can contribute to improve the papers aiming at organizing a Special Issue to be submitted to a well-ranked journal. Thus, the chair and co-chair will follow-up the papers in order to contribute with their theoretical, methodological, and empirical research before submitting to the journal.
References
Andrew, M.; L. Prtichett, and M. Woolcock (2017). Building State Capability: Evidence, Analysis, Action. Oxford University Press.
Lee, H. (2023). Strategic types, implementation, and capabilities: Sustainability policies of local governments. Public Administration, first published online.
Luna, J. P. and D. H. Soifer (2017). Capturing Subnational Variation in State Capacity: A Survey-Based Approach. American Behavioral Scientist, 61 (8): 887-907.
Meza, O. (2021). Punctuated equilibrium in multilevel contexts: How federal and state level forces feedback into shaping the local policy agenda in Mexico. Policy Studies Journal, 2 (50): 575-594.
OECD (2019). Making Decentralisation Work. A Handbook for Policy-Makers. OECD Publishing
Paquet, M., & Schertzer, R. (2020). COVID-19 as a Complex Intergovernmental Problem. Canadian Journal of Political Science, 53(2), 1-5.
Peters, B. G.; Grin, E. J. & Abrucio, F. L. (2021). American federal systems and covid-19. Responses to a Complex Intergovernmental Problem. Emerald Publishing.
Smith, B. C. (2023). Decentralization: The Territorial Dimension of the State. Routledge.
CALL FOR PAPERS
In decentralized countries the subnational governments have become the central units for implementing and providing public policies, which has increased their responsibilities and powers. In this sense, the requirements to qualify the subnational administration and governance were expanded to respond to its new roles both at the local level and in intergovernmental relations. Considering that, the research question of the workshop is: how does decentralization affect subnational state capacities and the implementation and provision of public policies? This workshop invites research scholars to submit papers focused on this question.
The demands imposed by the new responsibilities to the subnational level as a result of decentralized public policies has induced the creation, building and/or strengthening of their state capacities. In this sense, capabilities have become a key element to build and consolidate the autonomy attributed to subnational governments within the framework of decentralizing models. Therefore, the decentralization process requires more capacities in subnational governments. However, the comparative literature on decentralization lacks a more systematic approach linking this process and its effects on subnational state capacities and public policies. This is theoretical and empirical problem still asks more research.
This analytical gap of the decentralization takes on greater relevance after the COVID-19 because subnational governments were the main sphere responsible for implementing many public policies to face the pandemic. This scenario is even more challenging when the problems require high levels of multilevel governance as was the case with the COVID-19 pandemic. The complexity and novelty of this problem, considering its spillover effects, challenged countries to develop new intergovernmental policy capacities, especially the subnational units. It is also important to highlight the importance of subnational governments in the 2030 Agenda. The contributions expected from workshop participants are focused on connecting these three topics – decentralization, state capacity, and public policies. Among others, the workshop seeks to explore the following topics: (1) if he development and variance of subnational state capabilities in decentralization contexts affects the territorial equality and the performance of public policies; (2) if the design and quality of democratic governance in territories are affected by the level of development of subnational state capacities; (3) the development of subnational state capabilities in decentralization contexts is related to the quality of public administration in combating corruption, increasing own revenues and the performance of bureaucracies; (4) the development of subnational state capacities affects their role in the multilevel governance.
This workshop is open to receive papers focused on and developing theoretical, methodological and analytical models that address decentralization, state capacities, and public policies, empirical works both discussing national cases or in a comparative way. We welcome both quantitative or qualitative papers that explore different dimensions of the decentralization (administrative, financial, and political), and different dimensions of state capacity (administrative, technical, institutional, and political). The papers could address sectoral policies or even analyze decentralization in a more general way. The workshop is open to a variety of different types of papers in order to contribute to improve the knowledge on this research topic.
ABSTRACT
In decentralized countries the subnational governments have become the central units for implementing and providing public policies. The requirements to qualify the subnational administration and governance were expanded to respond to its new roles both at the local level and in intergovernmental relations. This workshop discusses how does decentralization affect subnational state capacities and the implementation and provision of public policies. The comparative literature on decentralization lacks a more systematic approach linking this process and its effects on subnational state capacities and public policies. This is theoretical and empirical problem still asks more research.
This analytical gap of the decentralization takes on greater relevance after the COVID-19 pandemic because subnational governments were the main sphere responsible for implementing public policies. Furthermore, the complexity and novelty of this problem challenged countries to develop new intergovernmental policy capacities, especially the subnational units. It is also important to highlight the importance of subnational governments in the 2030 Agenda.
The workshop addresses these three topics – decentralization, state capacity, and public policies. There are many works that analyze decentralization and public policies, as well as a literature that analyzes state capacities and public policies. To advance scientific knowledge of the decentralization and public policies is also relevant to consider state capacity as a theoretical support. The workshop explores four hypotheses: (i) the development and variance of subnational state capacities in decentralization contexts affects the territorial equality and the performance of public policies; (ii) the design of democratic governance in territories are affected by the level of development of subnational state capacities; (iii) the development of subnational state capabilities in decentralization contexts is related to the quality of public administration in combating corruption, increasing own revenues and the performance of bureaucracies; (iv) the development of subnational state capacities affects their role in the multilevel arrangements.
BIOGRAPHICAL PRESENTATION
PhD in Public Administration and Government (Fundação Getulio Vargas-SP), Master’s in Political Science (University of São Paulo), Specialist in Sociology (UFRGS), Bachelor's degree and degree in Social Sciences (UNISINOS). Visiting scholar ar UC Berkeley (2023). Professor at School do Public Policy and Government (FGV-Brasília). He teaches courses on: a) political system and political institutions in Brazil; b) federalism, decentralization and intergovernmental relations, with an emphasis on municipal management and public policies. Professor at Universidad del Valle (Colômbia) in the PhD Program of Public Administrationt Professor at Oficina Municipal. Professor at Ibero-American School of Public Policy. Professor at the National School of Public Administration. Researcher at Center for Studies in Public Administration and Government in the areas of planning and public policies and studies of decentralization and local government having participated in more than 20 projects with Brazilian municipal governments.. He was a member of the Public Management Qualification and Modernization Commission of the Brazilian Association of Municipalities (2009-2011). He has experience in the field of Public Management with participation in institutional development projects, with an emphasis on decentralization process. He produces didactic material for the public administration. Consultant of World Bank, Interamerican Bank of Development, UNESCO consultant, Natura Institute, British Embassy in Brazil, Latin American Center for Development Administration and Global Initiative for Fiscal Transparency. Winner of the award for best work at the National Meeting of Public Administration (2012), and also the best work at the Brazilian Society of Public Administration (2021). Honorable Mention Award in the monograph contest promoted by the Consejo de Adminstración para el Desarrollo (2008). Associate publisher for Latin American of Cadernos Gestão Pública e Cidadania. He is Director of Institutional Relations of Brazillian Society of Public Administration and also is a member of the board of directors of the Local Government Research Committee (IPSA).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Sustainable energy management practices contribute a great deal in the national economy. The Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 7 focuses on affordable clean energy, for which renewable energy such as biogas, and solar energy could be suitable options for countries like Nepal, where majority of the people depend upon agriculture. The study aims at documenting the effectiveness of sustainable energy practices at local level in Nepal.
Adopting qualitative study design, this study analyzes the various factors being hindrances in successful promotion and regulation of sustainable energy practices in selected areas of Nepal. Key informant interviews and focused group discussions were carried out among the relevant policy stakeholders and community members in three local governments: Kankai Municipality, Jhapa Rural Municipality and Shivasatakshi Municipality of Jhapa district, Koshi Province. Likewise, policy review of the annual work plan and budgets of the three local governments was carried out to identify whether and how sustainable energy related interventions were planned and implemented at the local level.
The study findings highlight that there was reluctance from both the local governments and communities to adopt sustainable energy practices.
Lack of information and awareness, and less prioritization of local governments as service providers have hindered promotion of sustainable energy use. Likewise, the lack of policy guidelines and instruments at the local level, improper natural resources management, less technical knowledge has aggravated the difficulties for sustainable energy prioritization. Moreover, the misconception of 'development' of local policy makers from a narrow lens of just having bridges and roads, rather than focusing on natural resources management, has also led to this less prioritization.
This study recommends for policy prioritization at the local level, enhanced capacity of policy stakeholders to understand and prioritize sustainable energy practices through inclusion of specific programs in annual work plan and budget, alongside providing subsidies as community incentives. Likewise, tailored behavior change interventions at the community level will help to build community ownership and sustainability.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The objective of the presentation is to show the results that quantify the municipal institutional capabilities index (ICIM) in the State of Mexico. This index was obtained by applying the methodology developed by Huerta and Vanegas (2021), based on the works of North (2006), Romer (1994) and Sen (2000). The ICIM integrates economic, social and government performance variables to identify strengths and weaknesses in local development processes. Databases were built from the information provided by the Mexican government in the economic censuses (INEGI, 2019), municipal public finances (INEGI, 2019), the population census (INEGI, 2020), the social backwardness index (CONEVAL,2020), the municipal functional capabilities index (2016) and the human development index (UNDP, 2020). The data were normalized to make them comparable and, subsequently, through the principal components method and with the use of the INFOSTAT statistical software, the general index was obtained for the State of Mexico and each of its 125 municipalities. The results show that economic variables explain 79% of local development and social variables 13%. Likewise, 71% of the municipalities have a low or very low level in the ICIM. The content of this document is as follows: after the introduction, the theoretical bases of the ICIM are presented, in section 3 the results and main findings, in section four the discussion and at the end the conclusions.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
A political factor that influences the degrees of corruption (measured from perception and other types of indicators) is the structure of the states: it matters whether they are federal or unitary. The literature has shown that federalism is related to high levels of corruption and that a feature of federalism that influences this phenomenon is decentralization. In this regard, there is an academic debate between those who argue that decentralization can reduce corruption and others who claim that, although decentralization can reduce corruption by bringing government decisions closer to the electorate, in practice this does not seem to be the case since local leaders take advantage of their positions for private benefits.
To contribute to this discussion, this research seeks to answer what factors explain the variation in levels of corruption in the provision of public services in the Mexican states? The hypothesis is that this variation is explained by the degree and dynamics of fiscal decentralization that exist in each type of service. The objective of the research is to explain to what extent the dynamics of the distribution of financial resources and authority from the federal government to subnational governments influence the levels of corruption in the provision of three types of public services in Mexico: education, health, and public security.
The methodological strategy designed to test the hypothesis consists of two stages. In the first, quantitative techniques are used to know the relationship that exists between the degree of fiscal decentralization (independent variable) and the variation in corruption (dependent variable) in the 32 states. The data collected in the quantitative study corresponds to three years: 2015, 2019 and 2021. In the second stage, a case study will be carried out to find the explanatory mechanisms that connect the independent variable with the object of study.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Kenya National Trade Policy and Women Traders Socio-economic Empowerment. A Case of Nairobi County
Abstract
Women Socio-economic Empowerment has become an integral part of the global development agenda for sustainable development. Globally, Trade has emerged as a key contributor to sustainability through opportunities that allow and maintain growth and development; including women empowerment. In this cognisance, governments have designed and implemented public policies to guide and regulate national and international trade engagements. These policies at times are multilevel cutting through the national governments to the subnational governments coordinated through existing intergovernmental relations or each level of government having its policies as per their specific functions. Kenya for example, is decentralised through devolution in to a two-tie level of governments; national and 47 county governments. The Kenya National Trade Policy guide and regulate trade in the country. The policy has provided for-among others- gender equality and women socio-economic empowerment. To achieve this, the policy has sought the domestication of its objectives within the decentralised 47 subnational units known as “County Governments”. This has raised concerns on how the County governments’ capacities to adopt, domesticate and implement national government policies impact on the multilevel policies’ outcomes. This study therefore seeks to undertake a cross-sectional mixed methods research to find out how Kenyan county governments capacities in adoption and implementation of national trade policy has impacted on the policies outcome in relation to women socio-economic empowerment. Specifically, the study seeks to find out the extent to which the county governments’ trade licensing regulations impact women traders’ socio-economic empowerment; a case of Nairobi County. The findings will be instrumental for policy reviews towards improving county capacities in the implementation of public policies for effective multilevel policy outcomes. Further, it will provide literature for scholars and future studies.
Key words: Public Policy, Trade, Women Socio-economic Empowerment, Government Capacity, Trade Licensing.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
States' financial capacities are central to what public policies may be implemented, for the total budget is a critical restraint for the actions and projects that a government can pursue.
The decentralization process in Mexico began during the 1980s. However, it was not until 1997 that the “Fund of Contributions for Municipal Social Infrastructure” (FISM, due to its acronym in Spanish) was created to bolster the financial capacities of the municipalities where there is more poverty, so they could implement more projects and public policies to reduce it. So, a formula was established in the Fiscal Coordination Law that allocates resources towards the poorest jurisdictions. The importance of this Fund cannot be underpinned in the Mexican decentralization framework: this Fund is, on average, the main source of the budget for the municipalities within the poorest (in severity) state Guerrero (36% vs 28% Participations) and is usually the second main budget source among the municipalities from half of the other states.
Hence, it can be stated that the purpose of the Fund is to reduce inequalities in the financial capacity of the municipalities so that the poor jurisdictions can access resources greater than if they were left alone with taxing and Participations, since these governments face a structural disadvantage that creates a vicious circle: poverty impedes taxing, and low budgets impede implementing actions to create conditions for economic activity due to the lack of infrastructure, public services, law enforcement, labor and capital availability, and in general high transactional costs.
The Fund is usually reckoned within the institutional framework as the most progressive Federalist Fund and is, consequently, considered the point of the spear in reducing poverty. Despite its recent 25th anniversary, still near to 40% of the population in Mexico remains in poverty or economically vulnerable.
There have been studies that address the impact of the Fund on well-being and poverty reduction, finding that it has been a useful tool mainly for improving housing and public services and therefore reducing poverty through its multidimensional component. Despite these results, the remainder of poverty among Mexicans strongly suggests inquiring about the potential of this Fund, particularly, whether the actual distribution procedure is optimal.
However, prior analysis among municipalities within states suggests that the Fund often goes towards entities that have not only strong economic activity and population but greater economic activity per capita, factors that imply a greater taxing potential, critical for financial capacity. Since the distribution of resources is highly revised, this is not due to allocation mistakes or discretionality but the results of the formula in the Law.
These findings raise a crucial question: since greater potential for financial capacity (understood as a potential budget) is related to economic activity and population, does the Fund reduce inequality in the financial capacity of municipalities, or enhance it? To find the answer, the distributions of local municipality budgets are examined with and without the FISM through concentration curves and indices, for available information in the period 2000-2020 with a national scope.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Identifying the role of collaborative governance in policy implementation is one of the challenges faced by empirical analysis in local spaces, especially knowing how it enables better performance in the action of subnational governments. The issue presents a lack of analysis, especially when it refers to countries transitioning from a conflict or territorial spaces with institutional fragility, such as Colombia. One of the challenges is associated with overcoming the technical and administrative weaknesses of territorial entities, which are obstacles to developing mechanisms that allow the implementation of local public policies more effectively. The above suggests that territories plagued by conflict and violence not only suffer the rigor of war. Still, it must also double its efforts to overcome the implementation of a distant government apparatus and not at all close to local problems.
Using Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA), collaborative governance is assumed to be a variable dependent on the indicated areas and contexts. In this sense, we answer: What factors determine whether a subnational government adopts a Collaborative governance model in the implementation of a policy area? The results show important implications for institutional design consistency and policy outcomes effectiveness in subnational territories. An important challenge for future work lies in investigating, based on empirical case studies, whether collaborative governance can generate better policy performance when it constitutes the framework of action of a subnational government.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Policy Capacity Framework proposed by Wu et al. (2015) is defined as a set of skills and resources - or competencies and capabilities - necessary for state action. These skills or competencies can be categorized into three types: analytical, operational, and political. Each of these competencies involves resources or capabilities at three different levels: individual, organizational, and systemic. This multidimensional model allows for understanding the obstacles and opportunities of policies. Therefore, the study aims to answer: how do the analytical, operational, and political capacities of the health and environment sector produce public action? For this, two policies that represent the Brazilian federal complexity were selected: the National Immunization Program (PNI) and the National Policy on Climate Change (PNMC). The main objective is to understand the policy capacities present at both the federal and local levels, structuring health and climate policies in Brazil. The specific objectives include mapping and comprehending the policy capacities present at both the federal and local levels. The methodology covers a multifaceted approach that begins with an analysis of Brazilian public policies in the areas of health and climate. The focus specifically lies on the implementation of the National Immunization Program and the National Policy on Climate Change, the independent variable of the research. This analysis involves investigating government documents and reviewing existing literature, aiming to understand the guidelines and objectives outlined in these policies. In this regard, a case study will be developed, where the PNI will represent one case and the PNMC another, to provide a deeper insight into the implementation and impacts of these policies. Additionally, the methodology includes the application of Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA). This technique will be used to analyze the collected information, identify patterns and causal relationships between the cases studied, enabling a systematized understanding of the factors that influence implementation. From the comparative analysis between the policy capacities of health and the environment, there is a lack of capacities in the PNMC. Once the PNI has capillarity and can achieve local action, and the PNMC does not. The results may suggest that the PNMC has analytical capacity and some operational capacity, however, it lacks political capacity. This is partly due to the fact that political capacity has been largely replaced by a management that cannot prioritize issues involving climate change.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Abstract
Since last century, developed and developing countries have been trying to implement reforms wherein fiscal decentralization can play its role in raising revenue and spending the same for the provision of public services and other such functions in the most efficient way. These countries have been trying out local or sub-national governments’ roles instead of the national government, for numerous reasons like better accountability, poverty reduction, development, inequality, and improvement in efficiency. This study looks into whether fiscal decentralization can counter the challenges and catch the opportunities for the people of Pakistan who are suffering from hunger and poverty that are mainly emanating from low-income and financial hardships. This study is conducted to examine the effect of decentralization on poverty reduction in Pakistan. The key objective of the research is to study the correlation between fiscal decentralization and multidimensional poverty. A measure of decentralization is developed to examine its impact on poverty reduction. The methodology of the study is a blend of qualitative and quantitative analysis of the topic. The study incorporates a conceptual framework and tries to explain the phenomenon with the help of growth theories. The study also uses the empirical model as a methodology. This study explains the dynamics of the political economy of fiscal decentralization in Pakistan. It also touches briefly on the evolution of federalism in Pakistan. This study also engages economic models to explain the phenomenon. It begins with working on the theoretical framework to understand and explain the relationship between fiscal decentralization and poverty reduction outcomes. It examines especially the key areas of public policy like public education, public healthcare, and political economy. This article has demonstrated that the marginal effect of fiscal decentralization on pro-poor sectors hinges mainly as a result of the trade-off among prospective welfare originating from the better matching of local preferences due to location proximity, and the lack of technical capacity at the local level. Finally, statistical software is used to find empirical evidence of the relationship between Decentralization and Poverty. The study uses time series data spanning the last 30 years. The study uses revenue decentralization data and expenditure decentralization data along with indicators of multidimensional poverty. The data is then run into the ARDL model to find out the correlation between independent and dependent variables. The study concludes that fiscal decentralization has a statistically significant relationship with poverty reduction. Fiscal decentralization improves poverty reduction outcomes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The COVID-19 pandemic presented a substantial multilevel governance challenge globally, leading to confusion among numerous countries regarding the allocation of responsibilities among different levels of government. Analyzing how various nations employed coordination mechanisms both vertically and horizontally in response to the crisis, recent research has embraced the multilevel governance theory, with a focus on China, the U.S., and EU countries (Bergstrom et al., 2022; Liu et al., 2021). However, there is a dearth of research on the situation in Japan from a multilevel governance perspective.
This study aims to analyze Japanese inter-governmental relations in the public health response during the COVID-19 crisis from a comparative standpoint. Owing to stringent constitutional constraints, Japan's states of emergency declared in April 2020 differed from those in many other countries. Notably, the law in Japan does not empower the government to impose curfews or lockdowns. In a state of emergency, prefectural governors, rather than central government authorities, can appeal to the public to stay at home and request temporary closures of stores and other commercial activities to prevent disease spread. However, this remains a request and not a mandate. Despite the challenges posed by an aging society and its "soft" approach, Japan has witnessed lower per capita infection rates and deaths compared to other nations, with no significant excess deaths observed in 2020.
In the early stages of the COVID-19 crisis, particularly in early 2020, the relationship between the central government and local governments in public health response was characterized by confusion, akin to many other countries experiencing a state of emergency declaration. Prefectural governors and governments were granted authority to issue requests to citizens without clear guidelines from the central government. For instance, in Tokyo, the largest city in Japan, the governor attempted to issue a shutdown request, but the central government insisted on prior consultation. Following such incidents, local governments urged the central government to establish a clear division of roles and responsibilities. Criticisms focused on information sharing between the central government and local governments, as well as among local governments. This inadequacy led to the creation of the Digital Agency in 2021, aiming to standardize core information systems developed and maintained by each local government by 2026. While this standardization facilitates information sharing, it also implies coercive standardization led by the central government. More recently, the central government seeks to revise the Local Autonomy Law, the fundamental legislation defining central-local relations, to enhance the comprehensive directive authority of the central government over local governments during crises.
This study contributes nuanced case studies to better understand intergovernmental relations in times of crisis from a comparative perspective, shedding light on the evolution of Japan's approach to COVID-19.
Tomas Bergström, Sabine Kuhlmann, Martin Laffin & Ellen Wayenberg (2022) Special issue on comparative intergovernmental relations and the pandemic: how European devolved governments responded to a public health crisis, Local Government Studies, 48:2, 179-190
Zhilin Liu, Jing Guo, Wei Zhong & Tianhan Gui (2021) Multi-Level Governance, Policy Coordination and Subnational Responses to COVID-19: Comparing China and the US, Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, 23:2, 204-218
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Brazilian public education is historically marked by inequality in access and quality of provision (UNICEF, 2021). After the 1988 constitution, the country underwent profound transformations, one of which was universalizing the right to education. This resulted in enormous and rapid progress in access, professionalization, educational assessment, and, most importantly, an unprecedented combination of decentralization with national policies, with a cooperative model that sought to balance autonomy and interdependence (GRIN, 2016). The 1988 Constitution sought to guarantee the political, administrative, and financial autonomy of municipalities, based on the assumption that this model would generate more democracy and fiscal efficiency (GRIN et. al, 2018) and, to this end, distributed the powers for implementing the policy among union, states, federal district and municipalities (OLIVEIRA & SOUZA, 2010). However, the asymmetry of economic, institutional, and technical conditions in the territories (ABRUCIO, 2005; SOUZA, 2005; GRIN and ABRUCIO, 2018) generated a scenario that required coordination efforts to ensure that territorial inequalities were not worsening. In recent years, Brazilian public policies have sought in different ways and with varying degrees of success to create strategies to reduce local asymmetries. In the case of education, the creation of a federative financing model was essential, based on FUNDEB (Fund for the Maintenance and Development of Basic Education and Valorization of Teaching). However, these ingenious mechanisms for transferring resources in a territorially very heterogeneous country were not able to address all types of inequalities, especially those of local state capabilities. Dealing with demands for a more decentralized and shared provision model requires greater management capacity from territories (GRIN, DEMARCO & ABRUCIO, 2021), making it necessary to understand which mechanisms can stimulate the creation of local state capabilities, strengthening cooperative relations and the functioning effectiveness of public policies. Although in its creation FUNDEB was restricted to the issue of budget transfers, not interfering in the operational parameters of education networks, in 2020 the Fund was changed by constitutional amendment 108 to promote greater equity between networks. The measures adopted by the new legislation sought to create indicators that would allow calculating the transfer of resources based not only on the number of enrollments but also looking at some conditionalities: 1. Filling the position or role of school manager by technical merit criteria and performance; 2. Participation of at least eighty percent of students from each school year in the national exams of the basic education assessment system; 3. Reduction of socioeconomic and racial inequalities measured in national education assessment exams; 4. Formalization of the collaboration regime between states and municipalities in state legislation; 5. Curricular references aligned with the common national curricular base. This article aims to analyze how the most recent constitutional change, called the new FUNDEB, creates new ways of combating inequality and establishes incentives to strengthen local state capacities in Education.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Decentralization is often regarded as a potent vehicle for improving effective implementation of increasingly contested or complex policies. Prior studies have argued that decentralization can make bureaucracies more efficient, promote government accountability, empower communities, and facilitate responsiveness (Hood, 1991; Pollitt, 2007). This points to the many fronts that policy problems, in particular wicked and super-wicked face today(Cashore 2021). First and second waves of decentralization with formal allocation of competences have increasingly been complemented by more instrument-specific based ones at the city level, intended at specifically address sectoral problems like the environment or security (Artigas 2019) .
The adoption of local climate action plans (LCAPs) is the expression of these dynamics at work, and constitutes an innovation in policy-making processes in both developing and industrialized nations across the board. By setting up timelines and potentially actionable commitments in a much narrower perimeter (metro instead of national or sectoral), they point to tangible goals and policy outputs. In this sense, they bear an incredible potential for environmental problems streamlining, as they are a tool for narrowing down the complexity of environmental issues. By bringing a new “operational” framing of issues stemming from the local level, they have, by the increasing operational take on these issues, often revived dormant environmental policies that would have otherwise lingered and remained stagnant (air quality, mobility transitions, to metion a few). The specific commitment of national GHG -greenhouse gases- reduction targets, central to any LCAP is even the more significant to local policy capacity, since major cities and urban centers bear the greatest concentration of emissions per territory and suffer the direct consequences of particulate matter on human health and worsening living standards (like the Urban Heat Island effect).
Resorting to a small-n comparison, this paper will focus on the case of three Latin American metropolis, Sao Paulo, Santiago and Montevideo, building on empirical research carried in recent years over different research projects (CAPinGHG etc). It particularly addresses how the creation of climate action plans led to an implicit de facto creation of a metropolitan perimeter when there was none, or sought to further coordinate disjointed metropolitan city areas. Building on these preliminary results, the potential for deepening of centralization born out of climate policy action plans is interrogated by looking into policy capacity and two specific connected variables: financial transfers for monitoring of emissions, and then the co-production of evaluation vehicles partaking of the integration of feedback loops into the national environmental goals.
At a more fundamental level, this paper will explore how devolution (to subnational governments) affects policy agendas in this critically important issue in time and in a paradoxical way. The results intend to show that the devolution has a potentially contradictory consequence of reinforcing local capacities and refining policy instrumentation while at the same time potentially exacerbating coordination shortcomings of national environmental policies at the local level.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
For some years now, public policy innovations have emerged in Chile at local level looking to deal with wicked problems. Despite the recognised centralism of the Chilean political system, municipalities have become a decision-making scenario to tackle public problems, in some cases 'wicked issues' (Rittel and Webber, 1973). These local initiatives have also circulated horizontally - to other municipalities - or influenced policy guidelines at the national level. Therefore we are observing, a substantive change in the multi-level dynamics of policy-making in this country.
Our team has documented this process in two papers (under review) dealing with specific cases: popular pharmacies and water offices. For the workshop “Decentralization, state capacities and public policies: what is new to discover?”, we intend to present a paper that will build on these case studies and add a third one (inclusion offices), in order to elaborate a more general reflection about the dynamics and determinants of the Chilean policy process seen from the municipal perspective.
In all three cases, these innovations face issues that go beyond the local level and strain the capacities and resources of municipalities. Moreover, the innovations have been replicated in other municipalities and have mobilized multi-level governance dynamics and instances involving various actors and levels (local, regional and national). Given the above, our research question is: what dynamics and actors make municipal innovations possible in a context as unfavourable for the local level as the Chilean one?
Our answer to this question is in direct connection with the issues raised in the call, especially “(4) the development of subnational state capacities affects their role in the multilevel governance”, as our main goal is to understand how municipalities in Chile have gone from being an irrelevant player in policy process to a key actor in the multilevel governance of issues that seem at first sight out of their jurisdiction. We also deal with state (and policy) capacities (mostly administrative and political), as we pay particular attention to the rising importance of middle management to foster these innovations and make them sustainable, in a varying relation with the political leadership of the mayors.
Our research is based on qualitative data, such as policy documents and in-depth interviews with key actors, carried out between 2021 and 2022. Our particular focus on understanding public policy innovations at the local level in adverse contexts has the potential to contribute to the advancement of the agenda on “decentralization, state capacities and public policies”, and we also hope to refine our analysis thanks to the insights of the workshop chairs and participants and the knowledge we will acquire on more theoretical approaches and cases.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The rise of global semiconductor competition has brought national industrial funding initiatives to prominence, yet the governance challenges entangled with such initiatives remain underexplored. This study offers an in-depth case study of China's National Integrated Circuit Industry Investment Fund (NICIIF), initiated in 2014 to advance the domestic semiconductor sector. Applying principal-agent theory, we examine NICIIF’s decentralized four-layered governance structure which involves multi-level government and market principals alongside industry agents. Our findings reveal that national industrial funding initiatives with a decentralized governance structure such as the NICIIF face trade-offs between the expertise of rapid-changing industrial knowledge enabled by the wide participation of subnational governments and industry entities that aid large fund allocation, and the associated challenges such as misaligned incentives and unintended consequences. We examined NICIIF's historical investment incidents and showed how heterogeneous constraints associated with different tasks imposed by different principals led to moral hazard issues, with agents prioritizing financial returns over strategic technology goals that involve less oversight. Our study highlights the nuanced trade-offs between national technology objectives and financial return imperatives, advocating for an enhanced policy evaluation capacity such as the recalibration of performance metrics to better reflect national-level strategic technology goals in the design and operation of national industrial funding initiatives. This paper broadens both theoretical and practical understanding of governance innovations in national industrial funding initiatives with decentralized governance structures that capitalize on industry expertise while safeguarding strategic ambitions amid global technology rivalry.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In this research, my main goal is to understand the relationship between (de-)centralization and state capacity in the field of public land policy-making in two cases: Mexico and Turkey. The main research question I seek to answer is how have the public land policy-making in these two middle-income countries evolved over the past 30 years, and how was this process affected by their respective (de-)centralized administrative systems and state capacities. In Mexico, the state has been trying to de-centralize since the 1990s (Harbers 2014; Jones and Ward 1998) whereas in Turkey, the subnational administrative system has been quite centralized. Even though there have been attempts to de-centralize in the first years of the 2000s (Kayasü and Yetişkul 2014; Kuyucu 2018), the municipal system has come to be increasingly centralized since the 2010s (Eraydin and Taşan‐Kok 2014). The main goal of this research is to shed light on the conundrum between centralization and de-centralization with a focus on public land policy-making in its use for the provision of housing. In other words, I aim to understand how public lands are used in providing housing to citizens in these two countries, and what kinds of roles and capacities local and central governments hold in this process. Public lands and housing, by the nature of land value, asset and speculation, is a significant public policy area. Therefore, it is possible to observe the conflicts and power struggles as well as capacity differences between and across the central and local governments in terms of autonomous policy implementation, possession of administrative power, collection and analysis of data and financial resources. In Mexico, while the federal government retains power to make and implement public land policies, the local governments and states have a lot of power and authority to decide on land use in their specific territories. In Turkey, the public land policy-making has been very centralized and the local governments have been stripped of their power to make policies regarding the land use. This research relies on a comparative case study of Mexico and Turkey. The principal source of data is spatial data and semi-structured interview data collected during respective fieldworks in Mexico City Metropolitan Area (MCMA), Istanbul and Ankara, and it will be supported by the secondary litarture on the subject. The spatial data will be analyzed via GIS (Geographical Information Systems) to present an overview of the location and use of public lands for housing in MCMA and Istanbul. Qualitative data includes meetings with academics, policy-makers and implementers at various government bodies in these cities to understand the politics of public land policy-making and the respective powers of the central and local governments and the implications on citizens The present study is very much in line with the workshop’s theme because it aims to understand the patterns of (de-)centralization in a comparative perspective, and tries to establish a relationship with state capacity. It increases the variation of (de-)centralization patterns by conducting a comparative analysis, and looks at one of the most important arenas of public policy-making, i.e. public land, where it is possible to understand the variation in local and central state capacity in terms of administrative, political and fiscal powers.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Historically, Brazilian education has faced various challenges due to the country's political, economic, and social contradictions. Faced with the context in which education is embedded, there arose the need to investigate the implementation of resources from PDDE (Direct Money to Schools Program) and PROFIN (Program for the Transfer of Financial Resources to State Public Schools) and its relationship with academic performance. This consideration involves the decentralization of resources as a tool oriented towards realizing the principle of democratic management, through the involvement of School Councils. These councils are entities with responsibilities for the financial, administrative, and pedagogical management of state school units, composed of representatives from the various segments within the school community. In this context, action research was adopted as the applied methodology within the field of education (ENGEL, 2000). The theoretical framework is based on the premises put forth by the economist and philosopher Amartya Sen in his theory of development, which goes beyond socioeconomic indices to include development as freedom. Furthermore, the research has a quantitative and qualitative approach and encompassed 10 schools represented by each Regional Directorate (DR), selected based on their performance in the IDEB (Basic Education Development Index) and the funds received from PDDE and PROFIN. The study was conducted from February 2021 to December 2022. The final conclusions are outlined in the following five points: I) The lack of in-person contact, due to the pandemic, hindered the project's development; II) There was significant resistance, resulting in delays in providing school data, suggesting both a lack of systematic record-keeping of school life and a lack of positive perception regarding the benefits that the analysis of collected data could bring as support for enhancing the conditions under which the School Council operates; III) The collected data, along with on-site visits, indicate the need for the development of monitoring and evaluation indicators specific to the State Department of Education (SEDUC) for analyzing the implementation of public policy; IV) The collected data on training suggest non-compliance with the provisions of the National Plan for Education in Human Rights, as if education were not a human right collectivized through public policy, with the responsibility for implementation lying with the state education department; V) The investigation's development, in its various stages, suggests a significant lack of understanding about the various phases of the current education public policy in the country and specifically in the state of Sergipe. This includes a precise understanding of the social actors influencing agenda formation, problem selection whose solution requires policy actions, policy implementation, monitoring, and evaluation, where the IDEB serves as one of the tools. Additionally, there is a direct connection with the process of governance through budgetary choices. It is worth noting that the education public policy, constitutionally established, is perceived ideally and not as a governmental action that must achieve the concrete results outlined by the governing legislation in place. Consider presentation on-site.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this research is to analyze the role of cooperative federalism in promoting the right to health, focused on intermunicipal action. The structure of the Brazilian Unified Health System (SUS) requires an effective cooperative federative structure, allowing municipalities to take the lead in the provision of health services, ensuring that services are provided in a regionalized and decentralized way. The problem associated with this subject is the limitation of the financial, political, and administrative autonomy of municipal entities to centralize the implementation of health policies and services, brought by the discrepancy between the demand involved and municipal capacities. Thus, the performance of intermunicipal consortiums will be evaluated to optimize municipal autonomy in the execution of healthcare policies and services, using the case study of the State of Minas Gerais and the Consórcio Intermunicipal de Saúde Entre os Vales Mucuri e Jequitinhonha. The research methodology adopted was a qualitative analysis of a literature review and a quantitative analysis of data published by the government and research organizations. Therefore, at the conclusion of the research, it was possible to confirm the argument that intermunicipal consortia can improve the execution of healthcare policies and services by municipalities.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This research aims to analyze the quality of governance (QoG) in Chile at the subnational level, specifically across its 16 regions and 345 municipalities. Following the methodology of Charron et al. (2013, 2017, 2021), the study measures the QoG levels of each Chilean region and compares them with European countries to understand subnational QoG variation. A crucial aspect will be comparing QoG levels between regions and municipalities managing public education and health services against those with lesser responsibilities in these areas.
The purpose of this analysis is to identify the advantages or disadvantages of decentralization in subnational governmental performance and governance quality in Chile. The research will examine how the autonomy in administering public services in education, health, and in some cases, public security, has influenced the perception of governance quality at the subnational level. The focus will be on the government's ability to provide high-quality public services, impartiality, and absence of corruption.
Furthermore, the study will explore how socioeconomic and well-being indicators, such as GDP per capita, infant mortality, education levels, and crime rates, relate to subnational governance quality. This perspective is crucial to determine if decentralization, as a method to enhance administrative efficiency, is effective and improves the quality of life in the regions.
To study governance quality in Chile's regions, the research included the first national survey on the perception of governance quality at the regional level in the country. Conducted between December 2023 and January 2024, the survey sampled 4,000 respondents across the country (250 individuals surveyed online in each of the 16 Chilean regions). The results are expected to significantly expand the debate on decentralization and its effects on the capacities and governance of subnational states, particularly in the Latin American context.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Objective: This theoretical essay aims to analyze the concept of State Capacity as applied to Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM), addressing a gap in the literature that lacks a robust theoretical definition for this perspective.
The integrated management of water, based on collaborative and multi-level governance among actors, institutions, and entities, aligns with the UN's directives in the 2030 Agenda. The agenda advocates for nations to adopt the IWRM model, considering river basins as units for water management planning.
In decentralized contexts, where competencies and responsibilities are distributed among states and municipalities, water policy often faces challenges related to the distribution and overlapping of roles among federative entities within the same river basin.
Given the well-known impact of State Capacities of states and municipalities on public policy outcomes, it becomes essential to understand how the distribution of competencies at the river basin level affects both the development of State Capacities focused on IWRM and the outcomes of water policies in nations adopting this model. This is crucial as it involves not only states and municipalities but also other authorities at the river basin level, as observed in the context of Brazil.
Methodology: The implementation of IWRM is monitored through indicators of Sustainable Development Goal 6, evaluating (i) conducive normative and legal environment, (ii) institutions and social participation, (iii) management instruments, and (iv) financing.
Building upon the UN's evaluation categories for IWRM and the monitoring of indicator SDG 6.5.1, the essay seeks to understand how these practical dimensions translate into essential theoretical conditions for the integrated management of river basins by the State. This involves analyzing the competencies and skills required at different government levels (municipal, state, river basin, and national) in pursuit of sustainable development aligned with the objectives outlined in the Agenda 2030.
After theoretically understanding the necessary conditions for successful IWRM implementation, the proposal suggests utilizing dimensions of the State Capacity concept to provide a robust theoretical definition guiding researchers and policymakers on State Capacities for integrated water resources management (IWRM).
Alignment with the Theme: This essay addresses relevant issues for the workshop, providing a solid conceptual foundation for understanding the State Capacities required for IWRM in decentralized contexts. It discusses whether the development and variation of subnational capacities within the same river basin affect the performance of IWRM, equality, territorial development, social participation, and the effectiveness of water policy across different river basins (state and federal). Likewise, it reflects on how collaborative and multi-level governance may influence meeting the demands of the population and the demands of subnational entities.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
There are several government records to document public policies in Mexico: laws, programs, Operating Rules, Reports and even the so-called Public Account. However, there are other records from which it is possible to identify how the implementation of policies in the subnational space faces difficulties: these are the records of the intervention of the Supreme Court in the resolution of controversies regarding the action of the subnationals. governments.
The intervention of the judiciary in political activity gained academic interest at the end of the last century (Vallinder, 1994; Hirschl, 2008). Interest in electoral issues, in the invasion of powers between powers, or in conflicts between levels of government also spread among academics in Mexico (Berruecos, 2003; Magaloni and Zepeda, 2004; Ugalde, 2011). The record of the activity of the Supreme Court to resolve conflicts about the federal system is a source, not only to know how that power intervenes in the arbitration of conflicts, it is also a source of the concrete applications that subnational governments make of constitutional provisions and laws by which decentralization is carried out.
This work presents results of a review of resolutions of the Mexican Supreme Court in which subnational governments are involved. This work sees in these resolutions a valuable record of the governmental action of local governments and allows us to take stock of the role of the Supreme Court in the full realization of decentralization towards subnational governments.
Berruecos, Susana (2003), Electoral Justice in Mexico: The Role of the Electoral Tribunal under New Federalism, Journal of Latin American Studies, 35, pp. 801–825.
Hirschl, Ran (2008), “The judicialization of Politics” in Keith E. Whittington, Daniel Kelemen y Gregory A. Caldera (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Law and Politics, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 119-141.
Magaloni, Beatriz y Zepeda, Guillermo (2004), Democratization, Judicial and Law Enforcement Institutions, and the Rule of Law in Mexico, in Kevin J. Middlebrook (ed.), Dilemmas of political change in Mexico, Londres, Insitute of Latin American Studies, University of London, pp. 168-197.
Ugalde, Vicente (2011) La judiciarisation des relations intergouvernementales au Mexique depuis 1994, Politique et sociétés, vol. 30, pp. 9-41 .
Vallinder, Torbjörn (1994), The Judicialization of Politics - A World-wide Phenomenon: Introduction, International Political Science Review, Vol. 15, No. 2, pp. 91-99.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Decentralization's impact on marine protected area (MPA) governance in Mexico offers unique insights into the complex interplay between subnational state capacity and public policy effectiveness. Coastal zone governance is characterized by multiple actors, institutions, and collective action problems. A complex adaptive systems approach is useful to understand the multiple levels and scales nested in these decision-making arenas on environmental public forums, management projects and financing. In these polycentric governance systems, simultaneous processes of conflict, cooperation and negotiation occur. Resources and regulations are the main issues at stake. Governance also encompasses formal and informal rules and norms that shape individual and collective action. Including laws, regulations, and discursive debates. ¿How does decentralization affect subnational state capacities and the implementation of public policies in the management of marine protected areas in Mexico? We compared the processes of collaboration, conflict, and negotiation in three marine protected areas: Cabo Pulmo National Park (PNCP), Islas Marietas National Park (PNIM), Los Arcos Flora and Fauna Protection Zone (ZPFFLA). Between October 2013 and August 2023, multiplex social networks were mapped, semi-structured interviews were applied, and relational data were extracted from documents from historical archives. R was used to compare the global and nodal properties of the networks. Simultaneous processes of collaboration and conflict were detected in both Islas Marietas and Cabo Pulmo National Park. However, in Cabo Pulmo we found a disconnection between the public sector and the rest of the multiplex network, mainly due differences on land planning adjacent to the marine park. In contrast the National Park officials in Islas Marietas occupied a central positions in the network that allowed brokerage opportunities such as negotiator between environmental ministry officials and local tourism operators. In this case we found evidence of the negotiation process of both the rules of authority and the management of autogenerated financial resources. Islas Marietas descentralization shows how formalized public private colaboration can increased revenue generation through tourism fees led to enhanced capacity for MPA management and law enforcement. In the case of Los Arcos, the use of informal rules was detected as a mechanism to avoid conflict between tourism operators who use the area. In Los Arcos the law enforcement was partial and funded by NGOs. The lessons learned about these decentralization processes are fundamental to facilitate the intersectoral collaboration on which compliance with formal and informal agreements for the protection and good governance of these common marine resources depends.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The federal system of governments in the United States is such that the federal and the fifty state governments are co-sovereigns while municipal governments are sub-sovereigns of the state governments. Each local government is subject to the rules of their respective state leading to fifty different legal and political situations. There exists great diversity in state-local relations both within and between states. This diversity also extends to state- local financial relations as each state along with its municipalities can decide on a local basis (without federal intervention), the provision and financing of government services that best reflect their citizen’s desires and are optimal for the jurisdiction’s economic and social circumstances. States have also developed a variety of tools to oversee local government finances which ranges from numerical limits such as tax and expenditure limits to intervention programs in case of fiscal distress. By supervising local government fiscal health, states ensure that local governments are in a fiscally healthy situation thus maintaining their ability to provide services and to access the financial markets to finance the necessary improvements.
One such tool established by states is debt oversight rules that allow states to proactively oversee local government debt issuance. These rules were developed due to the failure of debt limitations to control the borrowing by local governments from the domestic capital markets. Existing literature on this topic is limited. This paper takes the first step towards conducting a national study of these rules by reviewing the state laws and creating a framework to examine its impact on local government financial outcomes, specifically their interest costs. The paper finds that 28 states have developed debt oversight rules that require their local governments to report debt and other financial information to their respective state agencies. This allows states to proactively supervise and scrutinize local government borrowing to avoid unsustainable debt. Each state has developed their own design creating substantial variation in the procedure and the type of authorities responsible for debt oversight. The features of these rules influence the rigor of the oversight process. More rigorous oversight by the state is expected to be associated with low interest costs for the local governments. To test this effect, this paper examines the effect of these rules on the interest costs of local governments using municipal bond data issued competitively from the years 2008-2016. Results vary with the procedure, type of oversight agency, as well as timing of the submission of information. Interest costs are lower for those local governments that are granted state approval based on their ability to pay, that report to a state appointed commission, or that are subject to an annual monitoring process. This paper contributes directly to the research questions explored in this workshop by examining the implications of financial rules established in a decentralized structure. Depending on the design, such rules could either help positively influence the financial health of local governments or lead to potentially distorting or destabilizing effects.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Conclusions and prospective projects
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Sustainable energy management practices contribute a great deal in the national economy. The Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 7 focuses on affordable clean energy, for which renewable energy such as biogas, and solar energy could be suitable options for countries like Nepal, where majority of the people depend upon agriculture. The study aims at documenting the effectiveness of sustainable energy practices at local level in Nepal.
Adopting qualitative study design, this study analyzes the various factors being hindrances in successful promotion and regulation of sustainable energy practices in selected areas of Nepal. Key informant interviews and focused group discussions were carried out among the relevant policy stakeholders and community members in three local governments: Kankai Municipality, Jhapa Rural Municipality and Shivasatakshi Municipality of Jhapa district, Koshi Province. Likewise, policy review of the annual work plan and budgets of the three local governments was carried out to identify whether and how sustainable energy related interventions were planned and implemented at the local level.
The study findings highlight that there was reluctance from both the local governments and communities to adopt sustainable energy practices.
Lack of information and awareness, and less prioritization of local governments as service providers have hindered promotion of sustainable energy use. Likewise, the lack of policy guidelines and instruments at the local level, improper natural resources management, less technical knowledge has aggravated the difficulties for sustainable energy prioritization. Moreover, the misconception of 'development' of local policy makers from a narrow lens of just having bridges and roads, rather than focusing on natural resources management, has also led to this less prioritization.
This study recommends for policy prioritization at the local level, enhanced capacity of policy stakeholders to understand and prioritize sustainable energy practices through inclusion of specific programs in annual work plan and budget, alongside providing subsidies as community incentives. Likewise, tailored behavior change interventions at the community level will help to build community ownership and sustainability.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The objective of the presentation is to show the results that quantify the municipal institutional capabilities index (ICIM) in the State of Mexico. This index was obtained by applying the methodology developed by Huerta and Vanegas (2021), based on the works of North (2006), Romer (1994) and Sen (2000). The ICIM integrates economic, social and government performance variables to identify strengths and weaknesses in local development processes. Databases were built from the information provided by the Mexican government in the economic censuses (INEGI, 2019), municipal public finances (INEGI, 2019), the population census (INEGI, 2020), the social backwardness index (CONEVAL,2020), the municipal functional capabilities index (2016) and the human development index (UNDP, 2020). The data were normalized to make them comparable and, subsequently, through the principal components method and with the use of the INFOSTAT statistical software, the general index was obtained for the State of Mexico and each of its 125 municipalities. The results show that economic variables explain 79% of local development and social variables 13%. Likewise, 71% of the municipalities have a low or very low level in the ICIM. The content of this document is as follows: after the introduction, the theoretical bases of the ICIM are presented, in section 3 the results and main findings, in section four the discussion and at the end the conclusions.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
A political factor that influences the degrees of corruption (measured from perception and other types of indicators) is the structure of the states: it matters whether they are federal or unitary. The literature has shown that federalism is related to high levels of corruption and that a feature of federalism that influences this phenomenon is decentralization. In this regard, there is an academic debate between those who argue that decentralization can reduce corruption and others who claim that, although decentralization can reduce corruption by bringing government decisions closer to the electorate, in practice this does not seem to be the case since local leaders take advantage of their positions for private benefits.
To contribute to this discussion, this research seeks to answer what factors explain the variation in levels of corruption in the provision of public services in the Mexican states? The hypothesis is that this variation is explained by the degree and dynamics of fiscal decentralization that exist in each type of service. The objective of the research is to explain to what extent the dynamics of the distribution of financial resources and authority from the federal government to subnational governments influence the levels of corruption in the provision of three types of public services in Mexico: education, health, and public security.
The methodological strategy designed to test the hypothesis consists of two stages. In the first, quantitative techniques are used to know the relationship that exists between the degree of fiscal decentralization (independent variable) and the variation in corruption (dependent variable) in the 32 states. The data collected in the quantitative study corresponds to three years: 2015, 2019 and 2021. In the second stage, a case study will be carried out to find the explanatory mechanisms that connect the independent variable with the object of study.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Kenya National Trade Policy and Women Traders Socio-economic Empowerment. A Case of Nairobi County
Abstract
Women Socio-economic Empowerment has become an integral part of the global development agenda for sustainable development. Globally, Trade has emerged as a key contributor to sustainability through opportunities that allow and maintain growth and development; including women empowerment. In this cognisance, governments have designed and implemented public policies to guide and regulate national and international trade engagements. These policies at times are multilevel cutting through the national governments to the subnational governments coordinated through existing intergovernmental relations or each level of government having its policies as per their specific functions. Kenya for example, is decentralised through devolution in to a two-tie level of governments; national and 47 county governments. The Kenya National Trade Policy guide and regulate trade in the country. The policy has provided for-among others- gender equality and women socio-economic empowerment. To achieve this, the policy has sought the domestication of its objectives within the decentralised 47 subnational units known as “County Governments”. This has raised concerns on how the County governments’ capacities to adopt, domesticate and implement national government policies impact on the multilevel policies’ outcomes. This study therefore seeks to undertake a cross-sectional mixed methods research to find out how Kenyan county governments capacities in adoption and implementation of national trade policy has impacted on the policies outcome in relation to women socio-economic empowerment. Specifically, the study seeks to find out the extent to which the county governments’ trade licensing regulations impact women traders’ socio-economic empowerment; a case of Nairobi County. The findings will be instrumental for policy reviews towards improving county capacities in the implementation of public policies for effective multilevel policy outcomes. Further, it will provide literature for scholars and future studies.
Key words: Public Policy, Trade, Women Socio-economic Empowerment, Government Capacity, Trade Licensing.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
States' financial capacities are central to what public policies may be implemented, for the total budget is a critical restraint for the actions and projects that a government can pursue.
The decentralization process in Mexico began during the 1980s. However, it was not until 1997 that the “Fund of Contributions for Municipal Social Infrastructure” (FISM, due to its acronym in Spanish) was created to bolster the financial capacities of the municipalities where there is more poverty, so they could implement more projects and public policies to reduce it. So, a formula was established in the Fiscal Coordination Law that allocates resources towards the poorest jurisdictions. The importance of this Fund cannot be underpinned in the Mexican decentralization framework: this Fund is, on average, the main source of the budget for the municipalities within the poorest (in severity) state Guerrero (36% vs 28% Participations) and is usually the second main budget source among the municipalities from half of the other states.
Hence, it can be stated that the purpose of the Fund is to reduce inequalities in the financial capacity of the municipalities so that the poor jurisdictions can access resources greater than if they were left alone with taxing and Participations, since these governments face a structural disadvantage that creates a vicious circle: poverty impedes taxing, and low budgets impede implementing actions to create conditions for economic activity due to the lack of infrastructure, public services, law enforcement, labor and capital availability, and in general high transactional costs.
The Fund is usually reckoned within the institutional framework as the most progressive Federalist Fund and is, consequently, considered the point of the spear in reducing poverty. Despite its recent 25th anniversary, still near to 40% of the population in Mexico remains in poverty or economically vulnerable.
There have been studies that address the impact of the Fund on well-being and poverty reduction, finding that it has been a useful tool mainly for improving housing and public services and therefore reducing poverty through its multidimensional component. Despite these results, the remainder of poverty among Mexicans strongly suggests inquiring about the potential of this Fund, particularly, whether the actual distribution procedure is optimal.
However, prior analysis among municipalities within states suggests that the Fund often goes towards entities that have not only strong economic activity and population but greater economic activity per capita, factors that imply a greater taxing potential, critical for financial capacity. Since the distribution of resources is highly revised, this is not due to allocation mistakes or discretionality but the results of the formula in the Law.
These findings raise a crucial question: since greater potential for financial capacity (understood as a potential budget) is related to economic activity and population, does the Fund reduce inequality in the financial capacity of municipalities, or enhance it? To find the answer, the distributions of local municipality budgets are examined with and without the FISM through concentration curves and indices, for available information in the period 2000-2020 with a national scope.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Identifying the role of collaborative governance in policy implementation is one of the challenges faced by empirical analysis in local spaces, especially knowing how it enables better performance in the action of subnational governments. The issue presents a lack of analysis, especially when it refers to countries transitioning from a conflict or territorial spaces with institutional fragility, such as Colombia. One of the challenges is associated with overcoming the technical and administrative weaknesses of territorial entities, which are obstacles to developing mechanisms that allow the implementation of local public policies more effectively. The above suggests that territories plagued by conflict and violence not only suffer the rigor of war. Still, it must also double its efforts to overcome the implementation of a distant government apparatus and not at all close to local problems.
Using Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA), collaborative governance is assumed to be a variable dependent on the indicated areas and contexts. In this sense, we answer: What factors determine whether a subnational government adopts a Collaborative governance model in the implementation of a policy area? The results show important implications for institutional design consistency and policy outcomes effectiveness in subnational territories. An important challenge for future work lies in investigating, based on empirical case studies, whether collaborative governance can generate better policy performance when it constitutes the framework of action of a subnational government.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The Policy Capacity Framework proposed by Wu et al. (2015) is defined as a set of skills and resources - or competencies and capabilities - necessary for state action. These skills or competencies can be categorized into three types: analytical, operational, and political. Each of these competencies involves resources or capabilities at three different levels: individual, organizational, and systemic. This multidimensional model allows for understanding the obstacles and opportunities of policies. Therefore, the study aims to answer: how do the analytical, operational, and political capacities of the health and environment sector produce public action? For this, two policies that represent the Brazilian federal complexity were selected: the National Immunization Program (PNI) and the National Policy on Climate Change (PNMC). The main objective is to understand the policy capacities present at both the federal and local levels, structuring health and climate policies in Brazil. The specific objectives include mapping and comprehending the policy capacities present at both the federal and local levels. The methodology covers a multifaceted approach that begins with an analysis of Brazilian public policies in the areas of health and climate. The focus specifically lies on the implementation of the National Immunization Program and the National Policy on Climate Change, the independent variable of the research. This analysis involves investigating government documents and reviewing existing literature, aiming to understand the guidelines and objectives outlined in these policies. In this regard, a case study will be developed, where the PNI will represent one case and the PNMC another, to provide a deeper insight into the implementation and impacts of these policies. Additionally, the methodology includes the application of Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA). This technique will be used to analyze the collected information, identify patterns and causal relationships between the cases studied, enabling a systematized understanding of the factors that influence implementation. From the comparative analysis between the policy capacities of health and the environment, there is a lack of capacities in the PNMC. Once the PNI has capillarity and can achieve local action, and the PNMC does not. The results may suggest that the PNMC has analytical capacity and some operational capacity, however, it lacks political capacity. This is partly due to the fact that political capacity has been largely replaced by a management that cannot prioritize issues involving climate change.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Abstract
Since last century, developed and developing countries have been trying to implement reforms wherein fiscal decentralization can play its role in raising revenue and spending the same for the provision of public services and other such functions in the most efficient way. These countries have been trying out local or sub-national governments’ roles instead of the national government, for numerous reasons like better accountability, poverty reduction, development, inequality, and improvement in efficiency. This study looks into whether fiscal decentralization can counter the challenges and catch the opportunities for the people of Pakistan who are suffering from hunger and poverty that are mainly emanating from low-income and financial hardships. This study is conducted to examine the effect of decentralization on poverty reduction in Pakistan. The key objective of the research is to study the correlation between fiscal decentralization and multidimensional poverty. A measure of decentralization is developed to examine its impact on poverty reduction. The methodology of the study is a blend of qualitative and quantitative analysis of the topic. The study incorporates a conceptual framework and tries to explain the phenomenon with the help of growth theories. The study also uses the empirical model as a methodology. This study explains the dynamics of the political economy of fiscal decentralization in Pakistan. It also touches briefly on the evolution of federalism in Pakistan. This study also engages economic models to explain the phenomenon. It begins with working on the theoretical framework to understand and explain the relationship between fiscal decentralization and poverty reduction outcomes. It examines especially the key areas of public policy like public education, public healthcare, and political economy. This article has demonstrated that the marginal effect of fiscal decentralization on pro-poor sectors hinges mainly as a result of the trade-off among prospective welfare originating from the better matching of local preferences due to location proximity, and the lack of technical capacity at the local level. Finally, statistical software is used to find empirical evidence of the relationship between Decentralization and Poverty. The study uses time series data spanning the last 30 years. The study uses revenue decentralization data and expenditure decentralization data along with indicators of multidimensional poverty. The data is then run into the ARDL model to find out the correlation between independent and dependent variables. The study concludes that fiscal decentralization has a statistically significant relationship with poverty reduction. Fiscal decentralization improves poverty reduction outcomes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The COVID-19 pandemic presented a substantial multilevel governance challenge globally, leading to confusion among numerous countries regarding the allocation of responsibilities among different levels of government. Analyzing how various nations employed coordination mechanisms both vertically and horizontally in response to the crisis, recent research has embraced the multilevel governance theory, with a focus on China, the U.S., and EU countries (Bergstrom et al., 2022; Liu et al., 2021). However, there is a dearth of research on the situation in Japan from a multilevel governance perspective.
This study aims to analyze Japanese inter-governmental relations in the public health response during the COVID-19 crisis from a comparative standpoint. Owing to stringent constitutional constraints, Japan's states of emergency declared in April 2020 differed from those in many other countries. Notably, the law in Japan does not empower the government to impose curfews or lockdowns. In a state of emergency, prefectural governors, rather than central government authorities, can appeal to the public to stay at home and request temporary closures of stores and other commercial activities to prevent disease spread. However, this remains a request and not a mandate. Despite the challenges posed by an aging society and its "soft" approach, Japan has witnessed lower per capita infection rates and deaths compared to other nations, with no significant excess deaths observed in 2020.
In the early stages of the COVID-19 crisis, particularly in early 2020, the relationship between the central government and local governments in public health response was characterized by confusion, akin to many other countries experiencing a state of emergency declaration. Prefectural governors and governments were granted authority to issue requests to citizens without clear guidelines from the central government. For instance, in Tokyo, the largest city in Japan, the governor attempted to issue a shutdown request, but the central government insisted on prior consultation. Following such incidents, local governments urged the central government to establish a clear division of roles and responsibilities. Criticisms focused on information sharing between the central government and local governments, as well as among local governments. This inadequacy led to the creation of the Digital Agency in 2021, aiming to standardize core information systems developed and maintained by each local government by 2026. While this standardization facilitates information sharing, it also implies coercive standardization led by the central government. More recently, the central government seeks to revise the Local Autonomy Law, the fundamental legislation defining central-local relations, to enhance the comprehensive directive authority of the central government over local governments during crises.
This study contributes nuanced case studies to better understand intergovernmental relations in times of crisis from a comparative perspective, shedding light on the evolution of Japan's approach to COVID-19.
Tomas Bergström, Sabine Kuhlmann, Martin Laffin & Ellen Wayenberg (2022) Special issue on comparative intergovernmental relations and the pandemic: how European devolved governments responded to a public health crisis, Local Government Studies, 48:2, 179-190
Zhilin Liu, Jing Guo, Wei Zhong & Tianhan Gui (2021) Multi-Level Governance, Policy Coordination and Subnational Responses to COVID-19: Comparing China and the US, Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, 23:2, 204-218
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Brazilian public education is historically marked by inequality in access and quality of provision (UNICEF, 2021). After the 1988 constitution, the country underwent profound transformations, one of which was universalizing the right to education. This resulted in enormous and rapid progress in access, professionalization, educational assessment, and, most importantly, an unprecedented combination of decentralization with national policies, with a cooperative model that sought to balance autonomy and interdependence (GRIN, 2016). The 1988 Constitution sought to guarantee the political, administrative, and financial autonomy of municipalities, based on the assumption that this model would generate more democracy and fiscal efficiency (GRIN et. al, 2018) and, to this end, distributed the powers for implementing the policy among union, states, federal district and municipalities (OLIVEIRA & SOUZA, 2010). However, the asymmetry of economic, institutional, and technical conditions in the territories (ABRUCIO, 2005; SOUZA, 2005; GRIN and ABRUCIO, 2018) generated a scenario that required coordination efforts to ensure that territorial inequalities were not worsening. In recent years, Brazilian public policies have sought in different ways and with varying degrees of success to create strategies to reduce local asymmetries. In the case of education, the creation of a federative financing model was essential, based on FUNDEB (Fund for the Maintenance and Development of Basic Education and Valorization of Teaching). However, these ingenious mechanisms for transferring resources in a territorially very heterogeneous country were not able to address all types of inequalities, especially those of local state capabilities. Dealing with demands for a more decentralized and shared provision model requires greater management capacity from territories (GRIN, DEMARCO & ABRUCIO, 2021), making it necessary to understand which mechanisms can stimulate the creation of local state capabilities, strengthening cooperative relations and the functioning effectiveness of public policies. Although in its creation FUNDEB was restricted to the issue of budget transfers, not interfering in the operational parameters of education networks, in 2020 the Fund was changed by constitutional amendment 108 to promote greater equity between networks. The measures adopted by the new legislation sought to create indicators that would allow calculating the transfer of resources based not only on the number of enrollments but also looking at some conditionalities: 1. Filling the position or role of school manager by technical merit criteria and performance; 2. Participation of at least eighty percent of students from each school year in the national exams of the basic education assessment system; 3. Reduction of socioeconomic and racial inequalities measured in national education assessment exams; 4. Formalization of the collaboration regime between states and municipalities in state legislation; 5. Curricular references aligned with the common national curricular base. This article aims to analyze how the most recent constitutional change, called the new FUNDEB, creates new ways of combating inequality and establishes incentives to strengthen local state capacities in Education.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Decentralization is often regarded as a potent vehicle for improving effective implementation of increasingly contested or complex policies. Prior studies have argued that decentralization can make bureaucracies more efficient, promote government accountability, empower communities, and facilitate responsiveness (Hood, 1991; Pollitt, 2007). This points to the many fronts that policy problems, in particular wicked and super-wicked face today(Cashore 2021). First and second waves of decentralization with formal allocation of competences have increasingly been complemented by more instrument-specific based ones at the city level, intended at specifically address sectoral problems like the environment or security (Artigas 2019) .
The adoption of local climate action plans (LCAPs) is the expression of these dynamics at work, and constitutes an innovation in policy-making processes in both developing and industrialized nations across the board. By setting up timelines and potentially actionable commitments in a much narrower perimeter (metro instead of national or sectoral), they point to tangible goals and policy outputs. In this sense, they bear an incredible potential for environmental problems streamlining, as they are a tool for narrowing down the complexity of environmental issues. By bringing a new “operational” framing of issues stemming from the local level, they have, by the increasing operational take on these issues, often revived dormant environmental policies that would have otherwise lingered and remained stagnant (air quality, mobility transitions, to metion a few). The specific commitment of national GHG -greenhouse gases- reduction targets, central to any LCAP is even the more significant to local policy capacity, since major cities and urban centers bear the greatest concentration of emissions per territory and suffer the direct consequences of particulate matter on human health and worsening living standards (like the Urban Heat Island effect).
Resorting to a small-n comparison, this paper will focus on the case of three Latin American metropolis, Sao Paulo, Santiago and Montevideo, building on empirical research carried in recent years over different research projects (CAPinGHG etc). It particularly addresses how the creation of climate action plans led to an implicit de facto creation of a metropolitan perimeter when there was none, or sought to further coordinate disjointed metropolitan city areas. Building on these preliminary results, the potential for deepening of centralization born out of climate policy action plans is interrogated by looking into policy capacity and two specific connected variables: financial transfers for monitoring of emissions, and then the co-production of evaluation vehicles partaking of the integration of feedback loops into the national environmental goals.
At a more fundamental level, this paper will explore how devolution (to subnational governments) affects policy agendas in this critically important issue in time and in a paradoxical way. The results intend to show that the devolution has a potentially contradictory consequence of reinforcing local capacities and refining policy instrumentation while at the same time potentially exacerbating coordination shortcomings of national environmental policies at the local level.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
For some years now, public policy innovations have emerged in Chile at local level looking to deal with wicked problems. Despite the recognised centralism of the Chilean political system, municipalities have become a decision-making scenario to tackle public problems, in some cases 'wicked issues' (Rittel and Webber, 1973). These local initiatives have also circulated horizontally - to other municipalities - or influenced policy guidelines at the national level. Therefore we are observing, a substantive change in the multi-level dynamics of policy-making in this country.
Our team has documented this process in two papers (under review) dealing with specific cases: popular pharmacies and water offices. For the workshop “Decentralization, state capacities and public policies: what is new to discover?”, we intend to present a paper that will build on these case studies and add a third one (inclusion offices), in order to elaborate a more general reflection about the dynamics and determinants of the Chilean policy process seen from the municipal perspective.
In all three cases, these innovations face issues that go beyond the local level and strain the capacities and resources of municipalities. Moreover, the innovations have been replicated in other municipalities and have mobilized multi-level governance dynamics and instances involving various actors and levels (local, regional and national). Given the above, our research question is: what dynamics and actors make municipal innovations possible in a context as unfavourable for the local level as the Chilean one?
Our answer to this question is in direct connection with the issues raised in the call, especially “(4) the development of subnational state capacities affects their role in the multilevel governance”, as our main goal is to understand how municipalities in Chile have gone from being an irrelevant player in policy process to a key actor in the multilevel governance of issues that seem at first sight out of their jurisdiction. We also deal with state (and policy) capacities (mostly administrative and political), as we pay particular attention to the rising importance of middle management to foster these innovations and make them sustainable, in a varying relation with the political leadership of the mayors.
Our research is based on qualitative data, such as policy documents and in-depth interviews with key actors, carried out between 2021 and 2022. Our particular focus on understanding public policy innovations at the local level in adverse contexts has the potential to contribute to the advancement of the agenda on “decentralization, state capacities and public policies”, and we also hope to refine our analysis thanks to the insights of the workshop chairs and participants and the knowledge we will acquire on more theoretical approaches and cases.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The rise of global semiconductor competition has brought national industrial funding initiatives to prominence, yet the governance challenges entangled with such initiatives remain underexplored. This study offers an in-depth case study of China's National Integrated Circuit Industry Investment Fund (NICIIF), initiated in 2014 to advance the domestic semiconductor sector. Applying principal-agent theory, we examine NICIIF’s decentralized four-layered governance structure which involves multi-level government and market principals alongside industry agents. Our findings reveal that national industrial funding initiatives with a decentralized governance structure such as the NICIIF face trade-offs between the expertise of rapid-changing industrial knowledge enabled by the wide participation of subnational governments and industry entities that aid large fund allocation, and the associated challenges such as misaligned incentives and unintended consequences. We examined NICIIF's historical investment incidents and showed how heterogeneous constraints associated with different tasks imposed by different principals led to moral hazard issues, with agents prioritizing financial returns over strategic technology goals that involve less oversight. Our study highlights the nuanced trade-offs between national technology objectives and financial return imperatives, advocating for an enhanced policy evaluation capacity such as the recalibration of performance metrics to better reflect national-level strategic technology goals in the design and operation of national industrial funding initiatives. This paper broadens both theoretical and practical understanding of governance innovations in national industrial funding initiatives with decentralized governance structures that capitalize on industry expertise while safeguarding strategic ambitions amid global technology rivalry.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In this research, my main goal is to understand the relationship between (de-)centralization and state capacity in the field of public land policy-making in two cases: Mexico and Turkey. The main research question I seek to answer is how have the public land policy-making in these two middle-income countries evolved over the past 30 years, and how was this process affected by their respective (de-)centralized administrative systems and state capacities. In Mexico, the state has been trying to de-centralize since the 1990s (Harbers 2014; Jones and Ward 1998) whereas in Turkey, the subnational administrative system has been quite centralized. Even though there have been attempts to de-centralize in the first years of the 2000s (Kayasü and Yetişkul 2014; Kuyucu 2018), the municipal system has come to be increasingly centralized since the 2010s (Eraydin and Taşan‐Kok 2014). The main goal of this research is to shed light on the conundrum between centralization and de-centralization with a focus on public land policy-making in its use for the provision of housing. In other words, I aim to understand how public lands are used in providing housing to citizens in these two countries, and what kinds of roles and capacities local and central governments hold in this process. Public lands and housing, by the nature of land value, asset and speculation, is a significant public policy area. Therefore, it is possible to observe the conflicts and power struggles as well as capacity differences between and across the central and local governments in terms of autonomous policy implementation, possession of administrative power, collection and analysis of data and financial resources. In Mexico, while the federal government retains power to make and implement public land policies, the local governments and states have a lot of power and authority to decide on land use in their specific territories. In Turkey, the public land policy-making has been very centralized and the local governments have been stripped of their power to make policies regarding the land use. This research relies on a comparative case study of Mexico and Turkey. The principal source of data is spatial data and semi-structured interview data collected during respective fieldworks in Mexico City Metropolitan Area (MCMA), Istanbul and Ankara, and it will be supported by the secondary litarture on the subject. The spatial data will be analyzed via GIS (Geographical Information Systems) to present an overview of the location and use of public lands for housing in MCMA and Istanbul. Qualitative data includes meetings with academics, policy-makers and implementers at various government bodies in these cities to understand the politics of public land policy-making and the respective powers of the central and local governments and the implications on citizens The present study is very much in line with the workshop’s theme because it aims to understand the patterns of (de-)centralization in a comparative perspective, and tries to establish a relationship with state capacity. It increases the variation of (de-)centralization patterns by conducting a comparative analysis, and looks at one of the most important arenas of public policy-making, i.e. public land, where it is possible to understand the variation in local and central state capacity in terms of administrative, political and fiscal powers.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Historically, Brazilian education has faced various challenges due to the country's political, economic, and social contradictions. Faced with the context in which education is embedded, there arose the need to investigate the implementation of resources from PDDE (Direct Money to Schools Program) and PROFIN (Program for the Transfer of Financial Resources to State Public Schools) and its relationship with academic performance. This consideration involves the decentralization of resources as a tool oriented towards realizing the principle of democratic management, through the involvement of School Councils. These councils are entities with responsibilities for the financial, administrative, and pedagogical management of state school units, composed of representatives from the various segments within the school community. In this context, action research was adopted as the applied methodology within the field of education (ENGEL, 2000). The theoretical framework is based on the premises put forth by the economist and philosopher Amartya Sen in his theory of development, which goes beyond socioeconomic indices to include development as freedom. Furthermore, the research has a quantitative and qualitative approach and encompassed 10 schools represented by each Regional Directorate (DR), selected based on their performance in the IDEB (Basic Education Development Index) and the funds received from PDDE and PROFIN. The study was conducted from February 2021 to December 2022. The final conclusions are outlined in the following five points: I) The lack of in-person contact, due to the pandemic, hindered the project's development; II) There was significant resistance, resulting in delays in providing school data, suggesting both a lack of systematic record-keeping of school life and a lack of positive perception regarding the benefits that the analysis of collected data could bring as support for enhancing the conditions under which the School Council operates; III) The collected data, along with on-site visits, indicate the need for the development of monitoring and evaluation indicators specific to the State Department of Education (SEDUC) for analyzing the implementation of public policy; IV) The collected data on training suggest non-compliance with the provisions of the National Plan for Education in Human Rights, as if education were not a human right collectivized through public policy, with the responsibility for implementation lying with the state education department; V) The investigation's development, in its various stages, suggests a significant lack of understanding about the various phases of the current education public policy in the country and specifically in the state of Sergipe. This includes a precise understanding of the social actors influencing agenda formation, problem selection whose solution requires policy actions, policy implementation, monitoring, and evaluation, where the IDEB serves as one of the tools. Additionally, there is a direct connection with the process of governance through budgetary choices. It is worth noting that the education public policy, constitutionally established, is perceived ideally and not as a governmental action that must achieve the concrete results outlined by the governing legislation in place. Consider presentation on-site.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this research is to analyze the role of cooperative federalism in promoting the right to health, focused on intermunicipal action. The structure of the Brazilian Unified Health System (SUS) requires an effective cooperative federative structure, allowing municipalities to take the lead in the provision of health services, ensuring that services are provided in a regionalized and decentralized way. The problem associated with this subject is the limitation of the financial, political, and administrative autonomy of municipal entities to centralize the implementation of health policies and services, brought by the discrepancy between the demand involved and municipal capacities. Thus, the performance of intermunicipal consortiums will be evaluated to optimize municipal autonomy in the execution of healthcare policies and services, using the case study of the State of Minas Gerais and the Consórcio Intermunicipal de Saúde Entre os Vales Mucuri e Jequitinhonha. The research methodology adopted was a qualitative analysis of a literature review and a quantitative analysis of data published by the government and research organizations. Therefore, at the conclusion of the research, it was possible to confirm the argument that intermunicipal consortia can improve the execution of healthcare policies and services by municipalities.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This research aims to analyze the quality of governance (QoG) in Chile at the subnational level, specifically across its 16 regions and 345 municipalities. Following the methodology of Charron et al. (2013, 2017, 2021), the study measures the QoG levels of each Chilean region and compares them with European countries to understand subnational QoG variation. A crucial aspect will be comparing QoG levels between regions and municipalities managing public education and health services against those with lesser responsibilities in these areas.
The purpose of this analysis is to identify the advantages or disadvantages of decentralization in subnational governmental performance and governance quality in Chile. The research will examine how the autonomy in administering public services in education, health, and in some cases, public security, has influenced the perception of governance quality at the subnational level. The focus will be on the government's ability to provide high-quality public services, impartiality, and absence of corruption.
Furthermore, the study will explore how socioeconomic and well-being indicators, such as GDP per capita, infant mortality, education levels, and crime rates, relate to subnational governance quality. This perspective is crucial to determine if decentralization, as a method to enhance administrative efficiency, is effective and improves the quality of life in the regions.
To study governance quality in Chile's regions, the research included the first national survey on the perception of governance quality at the regional level in the country. Conducted between December 2023 and January 2024, the survey sampled 4,000 respondents across the country (250 individuals surveyed online in each of the 16 Chilean regions). The results are expected to significantly expand the debate on decentralization and its effects on the capacities and governance of subnational states, particularly in the Latin American context.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Objective: This theoretical essay aims to analyze the concept of State Capacity as applied to Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM), addressing a gap in the literature that lacks a robust theoretical definition for this perspective.
The integrated management of water, based on collaborative and multi-level governance among actors, institutions, and entities, aligns with the UN's directives in the 2030 Agenda. The agenda advocates for nations to adopt the IWRM model, considering river basins as units for water management planning.
In decentralized contexts, where competencies and responsibilities are distributed among states and municipalities, water policy often faces challenges related to the distribution and overlapping of roles among federative entities within the same river basin.
Given the well-known impact of State Capacities of states and municipalities on public policy outcomes, it becomes essential to understand how the distribution of competencies at the river basin level affects both the development of State Capacities focused on IWRM and the outcomes of water policies in nations adopting this model. This is crucial as it involves not only states and municipalities but also other authorities at the river basin level, as observed in the context of Brazil.
Methodology: The implementation of IWRM is monitored through indicators of Sustainable Development Goal 6, evaluating (i) conducive normative and legal environment, (ii) institutions and social participation, (iii) management instruments, and (iv) financing.
Building upon the UN's evaluation categories for IWRM and the monitoring of indicator SDG 6.5.1, the essay seeks to understand how these practical dimensions translate into essential theoretical conditions for the integrated management of river basins by the State. This involves analyzing the competencies and skills required at different government levels (municipal, state, river basin, and national) in pursuit of sustainable development aligned with the objectives outlined in the Agenda 2030.
After theoretically understanding the necessary conditions for successful IWRM implementation, the proposal suggests utilizing dimensions of the State Capacity concept to provide a robust theoretical definition guiding researchers and policymakers on State Capacities for integrated water resources management (IWRM).
Alignment with the Theme: This essay addresses relevant issues for the workshop, providing a solid conceptual foundation for understanding the State Capacities required for IWRM in decentralized contexts. It discusses whether the development and variation of subnational capacities within the same river basin affect the performance of IWRM, equality, territorial development, social participation, and the effectiveness of water policy across different river basins (state and federal). Likewise, it reflects on how collaborative and multi-level governance may influence meeting the demands of the population and the demands of subnational entities.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
There are several government records to document public policies in Mexico: laws, programs, Operating Rules, Reports and even the so-called Public Account. However, there are other records from which it is possible to identify how the implementation of policies in the subnational space faces difficulties: these are the records of the intervention of the Supreme Court in the resolution of controversies regarding the action of the subnationals. governments.
The intervention of the judiciary in political activity gained academic interest at the end of the last century (Vallinder, 1994; Hirschl, 2008). Interest in electoral issues, in the invasion of powers between powers, or in conflicts between levels of government also spread among academics in Mexico (Berruecos, 2003; Magaloni and Zepeda, 2004; Ugalde, 2011). The record of the activity of the Supreme Court to resolve conflicts about the federal system is a source, not only to know how that power intervenes in the arbitration of conflicts, it is also a source of the concrete applications that subnational governments make of constitutional provisions and laws by which decentralization is carried out.
This work presents results of a review of resolutions of the Mexican Supreme Court in which subnational governments are involved. This work sees in these resolutions a valuable record of the governmental action of local governments and allows us to take stock of the role of the Supreme Court in the full realization of decentralization towards subnational governments.
Berruecos, Susana (2003), Electoral Justice in Mexico: The Role of the Electoral Tribunal under New Federalism, Journal of Latin American Studies, 35, pp. 801–825.
Hirschl, Ran (2008), “The judicialization of Politics” in Keith E. Whittington, Daniel Kelemen y Gregory A. Caldera (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Law and Politics, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 119-141.
Magaloni, Beatriz y Zepeda, Guillermo (2004), Democratization, Judicial and Law Enforcement Institutions, and the Rule of Law in Mexico, in Kevin J. Middlebrook (ed.), Dilemmas of political change in Mexico, Londres, Insitute of Latin American Studies, University of London, pp. 168-197.
Ugalde, Vicente (2011) La judiciarisation des relations intergouvernementales au Mexique depuis 1994, Politique et sociétés, vol. 30, pp. 9-41 .
Vallinder, Torbjörn (1994), The Judicialization of Politics - A World-wide Phenomenon: Introduction, International Political Science Review, Vol. 15, No. 2, pp. 91-99.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Decentralization's impact on marine protected area (MPA) governance in Mexico offers unique insights into the complex interplay between subnational state capacity and public policy effectiveness. Coastal zone governance is characterized by multiple actors, institutions, and collective action problems. A complex adaptive systems approach is useful to understand the multiple levels and scales nested in these decision-making arenas on environmental public forums, management projects and financing. In these polycentric governance systems, simultaneous processes of conflict, cooperation and negotiation occur. Resources and regulations are the main issues at stake. Governance also encompasses formal and informal rules and norms that shape individual and collective action. Including laws, regulations, and discursive debates. ¿How does decentralization affect subnational state capacities and the implementation of public policies in the management of marine protected areas in Mexico? We compared the processes of collaboration, conflict, and negotiation in three marine protected areas: Cabo Pulmo National Park (PNCP), Islas Marietas National Park (PNIM), Los Arcos Flora and Fauna Protection Zone (ZPFFLA). Between October 2013 and August 2023, multiplex social networks were mapped, semi-structured interviews were applied, and relational data were extracted from documents from historical archives. R was used to compare the global and nodal properties of the networks. Simultaneous processes of collaboration and conflict were detected in both Islas Marietas and Cabo Pulmo National Park. However, in Cabo Pulmo we found a disconnection between the public sector and the rest of the multiplex network, mainly due differences on land planning adjacent to the marine park. In contrast the National Park officials in Islas Marietas occupied a central positions in the network that allowed brokerage opportunities such as negotiator between environmental ministry officials and local tourism operators. In this case we found evidence of the negotiation process of both the rules of authority and the management of autogenerated financial resources. Islas Marietas descentralization shows how formalized public private colaboration can increased revenue generation through tourism fees led to enhanced capacity for MPA management and law enforcement. In the case of Los Arcos, the use of informal rules was detected as a mechanism to avoid conflict between tourism operators who use the area. In Los Arcos the law enforcement was partial and funded by NGOs. The lessons learned about these decentralization processes are fundamental to facilitate the intersectoral collaboration on which compliance with formal and informal agreements for the protection and good governance of these common marine resources depends.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The federal system of governments in the United States is such that the federal and the fifty state governments are co-sovereigns while municipal governments are sub-sovereigns of the state governments. Each local government is subject to the rules of their respective state leading to fifty different legal and political situations. There exists great diversity in state-local relations both within and between states. This diversity also extends to state- local financial relations as each state along with its municipalities can decide on a local basis (without federal intervention), the provision and financing of government services that best reflect their citizen’s desires and are optimal for the jurisdiction’s economic and social circumstances. States have also developed a variety of tools to oversee local government finances which ranges from numerical limits such as tax and expenditure limits to intervention programs in case of fiscal distress. By supervising local government fiscal health, states ensure that local governments are in a fiscally healthy situation thus maintaining their ability to provide services and to access the financial markets to finance the necessary improvements.
One such tool established by states is debt oversight rules that allow states to proactively oversee local government debt issuance. These rules were developed due to the failure of debt limitations to control the borrowing by local governments from the domestic capital markets. Existing literature on this topic is limited. This paper takes the first step towards conducting a national study of these rules by reviewing the state laws and creating a framework to examine its impact on local government financial outcomes, specifically their interest costs. The paper finds that 28 states have developed debt oversight rules that require their local governments to report debt and other financial information to their respective state agencies. This allows states to proactively supervise and scrutinize local government borrowing to avoid unsustainable debt. Each state has developed their own design creating substantial variation in the procedure and the type of authorities responsible for debt oversight. The features of these rules influence the rigor of the oversight process. More rigorous oversight by the state is expected to be associated with low interest costs for the local governments. To test this effect, this paper examines the effect of these rules on the interest costs of local governments using municipal bond data issued competitively from the years 2008-2016. Results vary with the procedure, type of oversight agency, as well as timing of the submission of information. Interest costs are lower for those local governments that are granted state approval based on their ability to pay, that report to a state appointed commission, or that are subject to an annual monitoring process. This paper contributes directly to the research questions explored in this workshop by examining the implications of financial rules established in a decentralized structure. Depending on the design, such rules could either help positively influence the financial health of local governments or lead to potentially distorting or destabilizing effects.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Conclusions and prospective projects
EXPORT PDF (FULL)