Format

W02. Managing Uncertainty in Policy Design: Policy Tools and Capacities

Policy Design, Evaluation, Policy Analysis
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Azad Singh Bali
University of Melbourne
Main chair
Brian Head
University of Queensland, Australia
Second chair
Jenny Lewis
University of Melbourne
Third chair
M Ramesh
LKY School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore
Fourth chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
Policy Design, Evaluation, Policy Analysis
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Dealing with uncertainty is a central challenge for policy designers and design studies. Recent events, including polycrises, public health emergencies, and the rapid proliferation of new technologies such as artificial intelligence, have underscored the critical importance of addressing uncertainty in policy design. The central question this workshop engages with is how to address and manage uncertainty in policy design. Our goal is to categorize these uncertainties and explore strategies for their effective management.

 

A lot of the discussion around uncertainty in the context of policy design  has focussed on what are described as 'ill-structured' problems, marked by a lack of clarity about the issue's nature and limited knowledge about solutions. Extensive literature over six decades categorizes types of uncertainty faced by policymakers, including in 'complex,' 'complicated,' 'wicked,' 'super wicked,' and 'tame' problems (see Peters, 2018 and Head 2022 for a review).  Janicke  and  Jorgens  (1999), Koppenjan and Klijn, (2004) and Nair and Howlett (2017) have described different forms of uncertainties that can undermine policy designs.

 

Policymakers often deal with limited information, asymmetric knowledge, or an inability to grasp a problem's root causes within time constraints (Koppenjan and Klijn, 2004; Howlett, 2024). This differs from debates involving contested problem definitions, as seen in climate change or health reform discussions (Sovacool, Brown and Valentine, 2016; Ramesh and Bali, 2021). Uncertainties in goals, objectives, and policy tools can stem from decision-makers' awareness and the nature of the issue (Howlett, 2024). Uncertainty also surrounds the effectiveness of policy tools and their combinations, particularly over time. That is, are interventions made at time t likely to be effective at time t + 1 (Howlett and Leong, 2021). There are also uncertainties associated with the accuracy of  specific settings of policy tools, such as tax rates or subsidy levels, which tend to resist change despite calls for flexibility. Further, policymakers also grapple with overarching uncertainties in the political environment and resource availability (Howlett, 2024), which are interconnected in unfathomable ways which make policymaking difficult.

 

To understand how policy designers deal with these different types of uncertainty and manage them, this workshop looks at two interconnected issues: a) specific tools used to deal with uncertainty in policy designs, and b) the role of policy capacity.

 

The twin focus on tools, and the capacities of policymakers to effectively deploy are central to the new design orientation in the policy sciences (Howlett and Lejano, 2013; Mukherjee and Bali, 2018). Policy tools or instruments are specific means that are used to realise policy objectives. Recent studies in policy design have focussed on how multiple tools are assembled in ‘policy mixes’ to include substantive and procedural elements, and primary and secondary elements (Bali et al 2021). The choice of tools and their effective deployment is also a function of the capacities of policymakers and implementing agencies (Wu et al 2015). That is, the skills and competencies of public actors to be able to understand these uncertainties, develop processes, and choose tools to manage them.

 

The workshop will bring together scholars that advance conceptual as well as empirical case studies. All papers will include a discussion that develops strategies or offers insights for policy designers in dealing with uncertainty.

 

Questions specific papers will focus on include:

1)    How designers deal with problems or challenges in the context of uncertainty (in the understanding of the issue or lack of an appropriate knowledge base such)? (see for e.g. Head, 2019; 2023; Cairney 2016;

2)    How designers set policy goals and objectives in an environment characterised by uncertainty?

3)    How designers use policy tools and mixes to address uncertainty in policy designs (Howlett and Ramesh, 2023; Fowler, 2021;)?

4)    How designers adjust policy settings in the context of uncertainty in targets (Capano and Woo, 2018)?

5)    The role policy capacity plays in managing uncertainty during the design process? Are certain types of capacities more critical in dealing with uncertainty? (Wu, Ramesh and Howlett, 2015; Mukherjee and Bali, 2018) 

6)    How lessons/best practices in dealing with uncertainty are institutionalised (Stark and van der Erend, 2023;  Nair and Howlett, 2017; Dunlop and Radaelli 2017)? 

 

Engaging with these questions will advance scholarly debate and discussion within the policy sciences around the efficacy of policy designs, as well as contribute to policy practice by developing strategies/best practices for the effective management of uncertainty.

CALL FOR PAPERS

Dealing with uncertainty is a central challenge for policy designers and in design studies. Recent events, including polycrises, public health emergencies, and the rapid proliferation of new technologies such as artificial intelligence, have underscored the critical importance of addressing uncertainty in policy design. The central question this workshop engages with is how to address and manage uncertainty in policy design.


We explore two inter-connected issues: a) specific tools used to deal with uncertainty in policy designs, and b) the role of policy capacity.

We welcome submissions that advance conceptual understanding or case studies on addressing uncertainty in policy designs. We encourage authors to engage with some aspects of the questions outlined below. All papers will include a discussion that develops strategies or offers insights for policy designers in dealing with uncertainty.


1) How designers deal with problems or challenges in the context of uncertainty (in the understanding of the issue or lack of an appropriate knowledge base such)? (see for e.g. Head, 2019; 2023; Cairney 2016;
2) How designers set policy goals and objectives in an environment characterised by uncertainty?
3) How designers use policy tools and mixes to address uncertainty in policy designs (Howlett and Ramesh, 2023; Fowler, 2021;)?
4) How designers adjust policy settings in the context of uncertainty in targets (Capano and Woo, 2018)?
5) The role policy capacity plays in managing uncertainty during the design process? Are certain types of capacities more critical in dealing with uncertainty? (Wu, Ramesh and Howlett, 2015; Mukherjee and Bali, 2018)
6) How lessons/best practices in dealing with uncertainty are institutionalised (Stark and van der Erend, 2023; Nair and Howlett, 2017; Dunlop and Radaelli 2017)?

ABSTRACT

A lot of the discussion around uncertainty in the context of policy design has focussed on what are described as 'ill-structured' problems, marked by a lack of clarity about the issue's nature and limited knowledge about solutions. An extensive literature describes and categorizes types of uncertainty and the challenges they present in policymaking (see Peters, 2018, Head 2022; Janicke and Jorgens 1999; Koppenjan and Klijn 2004; Nair and Howlett, 2017).


Policymakers often deal with limited information, asymmetric knowledge, or an inability to grasp a problem's root causes within time constraints (Koppenjan and Klijn, 2004; Howlett, 2024). This differs from debates involving contested problem definitions, as seen in climate change or health reform discussions (Sovacool, Brown and Valentine, 2016; Ramesh and Bali, 2021). Uncertainties in goals, objectives, and policy tools can stem from decision-makers' awareness and the nature of the issue (Howlett, 2024). Uncertainty also surrounds the effectiveness of policy tools and their combinations, particularly over time. That is, are interventions made at time t likely to be effective at time t + 1 (Howlett and Leong, 2021). There are also uncertainties associated with the accuracy of specific settings of policy tools, such as tax rates or subsidy levels, which tend to resist change despite calls for flexibility. Further, policymakers also grapple with overarching uncertainties in the political environment and resource availability (Howlett, 2024), which are interconnected in unfathomable ways which make policymaking difficult.


To understand how policy designers deal with these different types of uncertainty and manage them, this workshop looks at two interconnected issues: a) specific tools used to deal with uncertainty in policy designs, and b) the role of policy capacity.


Recent design studies reiterate the need for multiple tools (with substantive and procedural components, primary and secondary elements) to manage uncertainties and create ‘agile’ or ‘resilient’ designs to deal with uncertainties (Capano and Woo, 2018; Bali et al 2021). The choice of tools and their effective deployment is equally a function of the capacities of policymakers and implementing agencies (Wu et al 2015). That is, the skills and competencies of public actors to be able to understand the spectrum of uncertainties, develop processes, and choose tools to manage them.


The twin foci on tools, and the capacities of policymakers to effectively deploy are central to the new design orientation in the policy sciences (Howlett and Lejano, 2013; Mukherjee and Bali, 2018).This workshop thus aims to advance scholarly debate and discussion within the policy sciences around the efficacy of policy designs, as well as contribute to policy practice by developing strategies/best practices for the effective management of uncertainty

BIOGRAPHICAL PRESENTATION

Azad Singh Bali is based at the University of Melbourne and Hamad Bin Khalifa University. Bali also holds an honorary Associate Professorship at the Australian National University.   His research interests include policy design and comparative studies in public policy with an emphasis on health policy. Some of this research has been published in Social Policy & Administration, Policy & Society, Policy Sciences, Public Administration among others. His most recent book is Health Policy in Asia: A Design Approach (CUP 2021, Co-authored).

 

M Ramesh is Professor and UNESCO Chair on Social Policy Design in Asia. Previously, he was the Founding Head of the Department of Asian and Policy at the Hong Kong Institute of Education; Professor of Social Policy at the University of Hong Kong; and Chair of the Department of Government and International Relations at the University of Sydney. Specialising in public policy and governance in Asia with a particular focus on social policy, Ramesh has authored and edited several dozen books and journal articles. He is the founder and editor of highly ranked journals Policy and Society and Policy Design and Practice as well as the acclaimed series Cambridge Elements in Public Policy.  He is currently the President of the International Public Policy Association.

 

Professor Brian Head joined the University of Queensland in mid-2007 after holding senior roles in government, universities, and the non-government sector. He is the author or editor of several books and numerous articles on public management, governance, social isues and environmental policy. His major interests are evidence-based policy, complex or 'wicked' problems, program evaluation, early intervention and prevention, collaboration and consultation, public sector integrity, and leadership. His recent books include Wicked Problems in Public Policy (2022, Palgrave, open access), Reconsidering Policy (2020, Policy Press, co-authored), and Learning Policy, Doing Policy (2021, ANU Press, co-edited).

 

Professor Jenny Lewis is Professor of Public Policy in the School of Social and Political Sciences. She is also Academic Director, Scholarly and Social Research Impact for Chancellery Research and Enterprise. She was made a Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences Australia in 2020 and presented with a Routledge lifetime achievement award by the International Research Society for Public Management in 2023. Jenny is a past President of the International Research Society for Public Management, and the Australian Political Studies Association. She is an expert on policy making, policy design and public sector innovation and was the founding Director of The Policy Lab. In 2022, Jenny was a guest professor at the Department of Governance and Public Management, Ghent University, Belgium. She has also been a visiting professor at Copenhagen Business School in Denmark, Utrecht University in the Netherlands, and Fudan University in China.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - How can we design policy better? Frameworks and Approaches for Sustainability Transitions
MARIA TOMAI (United Nations University)
CO-AUTHORS
Shyama Ramani (United Nations University - UNU-MERIT)
ABSTRACT

The literature on socio-technical transitions offers a wide range of approaches and frameworks to conceptualise sustainability transitions and steer them through policies. However, the multitude of concepts scattered throughout the literature makes their practical application challenging. In response, this paper presents a state-of-the-art review of tools and frameworks for sustainability transitions research and synthesises the significant conceptual and methodological developments from a policy practice perspective. Our overview looks into the complexities and uncertainties of socio-technical systems transitions, by drawing on contemporary examples. We then analyse the utility of different approaches and frameworks for: (i) Baseline assessment of the system to identify key drivers of societal challenges; (ii) Target visioning to set direction and strategic priorities for action, and (iii) Transition governance to design, implement and evaluate efforts for change. We conclude by synthesising the findings in a conceptual framework to advance the operationalisation and orientation of policies for sustainability transitions.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Policy design under policy uncertianities : Tools and Capacities for Sustainable Development in Qatar
Muhammad Ehsan (Hammad Bin Khalifa University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

A key obstacle to understanding the policy dynamics of policy design in constitutional monarchy with its governance based on the separation of powers is complex. Especially considering the environmental uncertainties and growing policy crises. Moreover, the added compliance with global standards such as the Sustainable Development Goals.

In this paper, we explore policy setting in Qatar’s context and identify existing path dependency in the institutions that currently explain the policy making. With its unique socio-economic and environmental context, Qatar offers an intriguing case for exploring how policy tools can be adapted to manage uncertainty in economic diversification, environmental sustainability, and social welfare. To signify specific examples, the paper examines Qatar’s current policy landscape. It identifies external influences that have historically caused uncertainties, such as fluctuations in oil prices and geopolitical dynamics, that amplify the significance of economic diversification. The paper highlights specific policy tools employed in Qatar, such as scenario mapping, public-private partnerships and regulatory frameworks. The effectiveness of these tools in managing uncertainty is evaluated through a multi-disciplinary approach, integrating insights from environmental engineering, economics, and political science.

The paper addresses enhancement policy resilience by focusing specifically on the role of technology innovation and sustainable practices. Subsequently, the paper reflects on Qatar’s Vision 2030 in the context of innovation and sustainability and comments on how these policy targets are achievable based on the policy capacities and tools available for the key stakeholders. (First Author Dr. Esmat Zaidan)

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Designing and uncertainty: Can policy labs be the right tool to provide lessons?
Jenny Lewis (University of Melbourne)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The growth of policy labs over the last few decades has been substantial, with numerous examples appearing in many nations. In response, there has been a focus on developing typologies of labs based on relationship to governments, staffing, focus of inquiry, methods used, and other factors. There have also been considerations of which part of the policy process these labs are most engaged with, analyses of the policy sectors that they examine and at what level of jurisdiction, and considerations of how effective they are in addressing policy problems. Critically, there has also been a growing interest in understanding whether labs that use design methods are able to function alongside more traditional approaches to policy design.

 

But how do labs deal with problems or challenges in the context of uncertainty? Many labs have been established to deal with ‘ill-structured problems’, taking mainly cross-sectoral policy problems outside of the bureaucratic structures of government so that they can be ‘labbed’ in hope of a solution. These labs can be considered as a particular type of procedural policy tool, with a focus on changing the shape of governing structures. But given the limits of labs in ‘everyday’ situations, where they have been shown to hold promise but also face significant limits, are they capable of producing solutions in a context of uncertainty?

 

This paper examines policy labs and their potential for functioning under uncertainty, aiming to address two gaps. First, while labs are often created to deal with seemingly intractable problems, that is against a background of understanding that the issue is multifaceted and the knowledge base might be strong but conflicting across different actors who hold a stake in the solution. This is a different situation to one where labs are used to work on problems where there is little understanding of the issue or there is an inadequate knowledge base to support solutions, as is the case in uncertainty. How do policy labs work in this context?

 

Second, because labs are ‘outside’ the bureaucratic system in many nations, even though they are at least loosely coupled with it, there is an important question about how lessons in dealing with uncertainty can be spread via networks and institutionalised by governments and other organisations. While labs are connected to each other around the world, they are often less connected to government departments where policy decisions are made. In some situations, labs are being funded and evaluated by national or international agencies, while in others there is little steering of labs and not much evidence of whether they are achieving what they were established to do. What kinds of structures are needed to ensure that the lessons learned from mostly small and transient labs are captured, shared, and ultimately institutionalised?

 

These questions about how policy labs work under uncertainty and how lessons from their work can be institutionalised, will be addressed conceptually and by using empirical examples from labs.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Designing goals under uncertainty
Kidjie Saguin (University of Melbourne)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Policy goals play an important role in shaping the effectiveness of policy instruments by simplifying complex policy interdependencies and setting policy priorities (Fukuda-Parr 2014). But current understanding of the role of policy goals in effective policy design is often undermined by the tendency to relegate policy goals as fixed constraints that policymakers need to work with  (Howlett 2009,  Thacher  and Rein  2004). In taking goals as givens, policy sciences ignored how goal formulation can motivate action, “which is the foundation of purposiveness” of policy design (Anderson 1986, 64). Since goals are what distinguishes a public policy from a random action, the policy sciences need to pay more attention to policy goals. After all, consciously modifying goals are argued to be instrumental to achieving them (Linder and Peters 1984). 

 

This proposed article seeks to advance Linder and Peters’ (1984) seminal work on policy design by conceptualizing the design of goals under uncertainty. Existing studies rely on Wildavsky’s (1979) notion of ‘strategic retreat on objectives’ to examine goal changes as a fixation on implementing the means rather than achieving the substantive goals of the policy. This process of goal displacement is often a response to an certain type of uncertainty pertaining the complexity of the policy problem. However, there are different kinds of uncertainties that are ignored in policy design. On top of uncertainty over the means-ends relationship, uncertainty over actor interdependence (strategic uncertainty) and institutional divergence or conflict (institutional uncertainty) also exists to undermine policy effectiveness (Koppenjan and Klijn 2004). This article argues that the process of goal changes would depend on the type of uncertainty that policymakers face.

 

The proposed paper presents three empirical cases from the Philippines to develop this argument. It argues that different types of uncertainties are responded to through different forms of goal changes. The Bottom-Up Budgeting (BUB) is an experiment at improving local governance but is faced with uncertainty over what participatory instruments works best to improve local governance. The goal of poverty reduction was displaced over implementing ‘good governance’ measures to instill budget and planning discipline in local governments. The BUB is a quintessential example of goal displacement. The oldest private-public partnership on education in the world (Education Service Contracting) is presented as a case of strategic uncertainty where goals were modified to establish some predictability around how the state can regulate private schools. New goals were replaced as a form of goal diversion where old goals were considered irrelevant given the changes in policy context. I propose a new form of goal change – goal dissociation – to capture responses to institutional uncertainty in the national cash transfer program (Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program). Dissociated goals serve to legitimize means irrelevant to the existing policy but relevant to goals of other policies. In this case, dissociated goals of the program were relevant to increasing the supply-side interventions for education and health.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Tackling uncertain targets’ behavior. Instrument mixes and policy design for highly collaborative policies.
Federico Toth (Università di Bologna)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

From the policy designer's perspective, one of the main sources of uncertainty concerns how policy recipients will respond to the policy initiative. Will they cooperate in the success of the policy or will they remonstrate against it? It is not just a matter of political consensus or social legitimacy of the measures taken, but of active policy cooperation and behavior change.

Recent literature on co-design has highlighted the potential benefits of involving stakeholders, citizens and, more generally, policy recipients in the policy formulation phase, in terms of the quality of interventions, the innovativeness of proposed policy solutions, as well as the increased willingness of 'lay actors' to cooperate with policy-makers in the production of goods and services that benefit the community. However, the full benefits of such an opening up of policy-making to potential policy recipients appear reduced in all those policy areas that go beyond the provision of goods and services, but rather affect the individual conduct of citizens. This is especially true for what we might call behavior-oriented policies (or "highly collaborative policies"), i.e. those where the active participation/compliance of policy recipients is critical to the achievement of policy goals and policy success.

In these policy areas, finding a mix of instruments that can overcome any resistance to compliance on the part of the target group and nudge them towards the desired behavior is one of the key challenges for policymakers in reducing the uncertainty of policy outcomes (and hence the risk of failure). In this regard, some authors suggest the strategy of the least intrusive policy instruments (the 'least restrictive alternative' principle) and that a purely regulatory and intrusive approach risks not only being ineffective but even counterproductive compared to inaction. However, there is no clear evidence on the merits of different policy recipes. Assessing the effectiveness of different policy mix schemes is still an open question for empirical research.

The paper sets out to reflect on these issues, focusing in particular on two cases of 'highly collaborative'/behaviour-oriented policies, both of which can be ascribed to the macro-sphere of public health interventions: 1) tobacco control policies; 2) childhood vaccinations. Through the comparison of policy mix design strategies in these two policy areas in a number of countries characterised by different welfare regimes and varying degrees of democratic consolidation, we intend to answer a threefold research question:

a) is it possible to identify recurring patterns in the policy mixes adopted by individual countries in the two different areas, from a configurational and/or evolutionary perspective?

b) is it possible to identify recurring patterns for 'families' of countries that share certain political-institutional characteristics (e.g. policy legacy in the health field; margins of freedom left to individual initiative)?

c) is it possible to identify a relationship between specific patterns of policy mix and the results obtained in terms of target groups' compliance?

 

Authors: Federico Toth and Stefania Profeti (University of Bologna). Federico Toth is the corresponding author and will attend the panel.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Water Policy Design Under Uncertainty: Policy Capacities Under Weak Institutions in Latin American Cities
Jaime Sainz-Santamaría (Instituto Tecnológico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey (ITESM))
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Latin American cities face deep uncertainty about the volume of water available to meet their competing demands. This uncertainty arises not only from climate change but also due to the intrinsic complexity of groundwater and surface water systems that supply most of the major capitals in the region. In addition to climate-derived and scientific uncertainty, water stress and occasionally water policy itself generate social conflict (political uncertainty), further complicating the design of water policies. Policy regimes characterized by weak institutions, seen as settings of low stability and poor enforcement, add to the complexity faced by policymakers. The policy mix to navigate these uncertainties includes a range not limited to inter-basin water transfers, price reforms, green infrastructure, and desalination, each with distinct trade-offs among various policy criteria such as water delivery, conflict management, and political payoffs. What are the analytical, operational, and political capacities required for effective policy design under these uncertainties? Through content analysis of policy reports, scholarly research, and newspapers, this paper takes inventory of the capacities demonstrated in managing water crises in a sample of Latin American countries and identifies the capacities that need to be developed. The paper discusses implications for building theory on policy design under uncertainty.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - Mitigating Uncertainty in Policy Design during Implementation: Organizational Responses from a Carnegie Perspective
Wai-Hang Yee (The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shenzhen)
CO-AUTHORS
Naikang Feng
ABSTRACT

Inherent uncertainty in local policy environments demands appropriate system-wide adaptations of organizational dynamics and policy design during policy implementation. Extant literature explains policy design patterns mainly through state-level drivers and/or perceptions and logics of individual decision makers. While the two complementary perspectives balance structural and agentic forces, few studies explicitly investigate the influence of organizational structures and processes. Drawing on insights from the behavioral decision school in the organizational literature, the study discusses their influence on policy design and discuss ways how implementing organizations may address local environmental uncertainty during policy implementation.

 

Based on the Carnegie perspective, this study conceptualizes organizations as adaptive systems consisting of a coalition of participants. We formulate propositions linking implementing organization’s responses to uncertainty in policy design to three major pathways of organizational adaptations: adaptation of goals, adaptation of attention rules, and adaptation of search rules. First, organizations can mitigate uncertainty in policy design through goal adaptation, adjusting their goals based on past experience and the experience of comparable organizations. Second, attention rules adaptation allows organizations to focus on a select set of performance criteria as demanded by organizational participants, reducing uncertainty in the performance effects of policy design choices. Third, organizations can engage in search rules adaptation, learning from their performance outcomes and actively seeking more effective policy design in local implementation environments.

 

A case study on the adoption of market-based instruments in China’s food policy reform is discussed as an illustration of how organizations adapt and adjust its policy design in response to uncertainty. Specifically, this research examines the joint conditions that facilitate the recurrent use of market-based instruments among street-level food safety regulatory organizations (SLOs) in China. Data from ten cities in five provinces, spanning diverse socioeconomic stages and policy enforcement scenarios, were collected through surveys of chief executive officers and frontline workers. A fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) is employed to analyze the data and identify causal configurations leading to the adoption of policy design with high usage of market-based instruments.

 

The findings reveal three distinct configurations of causal conditions that explain the frequent use of market-based instruments by SLOs. The first configuration involves goal adaptation to meet target demands, considering policy targets' compliance attitude and upper-level governments' policy style and capacity. The second configuration highlights attention rules adaptation by referencing instrument choices and effectiveness in other SLOs, as well as considering upper-level governments' style and strategy. The third configuration suggests search rules adaptation through internal communication channels, enabling organizations to negotiate conventions and reduce decision-making uncertainty.

 

This study contributes to understanding organizational influences on policy design, emphasizing the Carnegie perspective as a foundation for examining how organizations respond to uncertainty. The findings provide valuable insights for policymakers and practitioners in mitigating uncertainty during policy implementation through adaptive adjustment in organizational and policy design.

 

 

FULL PAPER IS AVAILABLE. (Apology, as I thought the call is a paper call.)

 

I plan to present the paper in person at the workshop, but I shall confirm my summer class schedule first.

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Co-creative Processes in the Face of Wicked Problems: Ownership as a Catalyst for Integration into Public Policies
Fanny Sbaraglia (Université Libre de Bruxelles)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

For about a decade, co-creative processes have received special attention from public policy, urban planning, and environmental researchers to address the acceleration, proliferation, and complexity of wicked problems (Head, 2022). Defined as the organizational capacity to collaboratively work with relevant stakeholders to develop innovative solutions to our most pressing societal challenges (Ansell & Torfing, 2021), co-creative processes are currently being analyzed in terms of public value (Osborne & al., 2021) and the democratic quality of the process (Ansell & Torfing, 2022). Few studies explore how these co-creative processes fundamentally transform public policies in the face of wicked problems.

To tackle this question, I argue that the degree of ownership by different policy designers and stakeholders enables the sustainable integration of co-creative process outcomes into public policies. Drawing from Lachapelle's definition, which sees ownership as "a concept through which to assess whose voice is heard, who has influence over decisions, and who is affected by the process and outcome" (2008: 52), I propose an operationalization of this concept to qualitatively observe two contrasting cases of processes addressing wicked problems in the Brussels-Capital Region: a group co-creation case (Team4 Neder-over-Hembeek) and a co-creation case with a societal dimension (Les Lieux d'avenir). My analyses will be based on participant observations, stakeholder interviews, and documentary research. I will demonstrate the significance of the ownership concept for policy designers, emphasizing its role in integrating co-creation outcomes in both research and policymaking processes related to wicked problems.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Designing policy strategies for complex environmental issues
Brian Head (University of Queensland, Australia)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

 

This paper sketches the challenges of designing effective policies for three environmental policy challenges marked by complexity, uncertainty and policy controversy. The first example, plastic waste management, is often discussed in terms of the ‘circular economy’ framework and optimising recycling.  The second example, biodiversity conservation, is often discussed in terms of habitat protection and requiring ‘offset’ equivalence where habitat is ‘necessarily’ destroyed.  The third example, protecting water quality on the Great Barrier Reef, is often discussed in terms of reducing harmful runoff from agricultural lands. These three policy challenges have shared a common historical pattern, namely, that governmental attempts to influence the behaviour of corporations and citizens have commenced with soft or voluntary measures, such as information, financial incentives, and industry codes of conduct. The paper suggests that these voluntary measures have facilitated avoidance and non-compliance. The alternatives require enforceable standards and targets as part of a multi-layered approach to addressing complexity, uncertainty and the need for public support.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Stewards or architects of the electricity order? Planning for uncertainty in the regulatory state
Jose Maria Valenzuela (University of Oxford)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Liberalised electricity markets had marginalised the role of government long-term planning in the electricity industry. However, the decarbonisation of electricity and the electrification of energy consumptions require inter-sectoral coordination, state policy support, and large investment in new infrastructure systems, all within a context of high technological, geopolitical, and environmental uncertainty. The demand to coordinate action under uncertainty has opened an opportunity for the development and experimentation with new forms of energy planning, or anticipation more broadly, by state agencies or regulated companies. The article documents the tools for planning through contrasting narrative scenarios (i.e, Future Energy Scenarios in the UK) and their integration into existing policy system to deal with uncertainty. Focus on the tools of policy deliberation, the article dissects the tensions that government experience in finding and defining a role for planning in public economic governance and the delegation of planning within existing or new institutions, a tension summarised in the dichotomy: do governments reassume the role of architects or, reluctantly, only of stewards. The article revises the characterisation of the regulatory state as the dominant form of governance organisation in the electricity sector through comparative evidence on the evolution of planning instruments. While the most immediate or explicit cause for these developments are the goals for decarbonisation and the political anxieties over energy security, an industrial orders perspective drives attention to the political imagination over the organisation of the industry. The article introduces the problems through a new database on planning instruments but develops its theoretical insights from the review of a subset of cases in Western Europe, North and South America.

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - Policy design for SDG localization: innovations and challenges in uncertain contexts
Kris Hartley (Arizona State University)
CO-AUTHORS
Glen D. Kuecker (DePauw University)
ABSTRACT

Urban policymaking is under stress from political and environmental uncertainties. Global policy narratives give the impression of a growing consensus about polycrises, but policy guidance at high levels is intentionally general and often ambiguous. With progress measured against the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals tracker, national governments endeavor to varying degrees to meet global policy expectations even in the absence of enforcement and sanctioning power. Where national governments fall short in such efforts, city governments having adequate capacities often embrace aspects of the SDGs that concern their local needs and have undertaken structured tracking and reporting through Voluntary Local Reviews. In this context, some city governments are pursuing policy innovations through the SDG framework as a way to secure legitimacy. Does the dynamic interface between global policy goals and local policy action change the way urban policies are designed? This article addresses this underexplored question through the case of smart cities in London, New York, and Singapore, examining whether new uncertainties that contextualize urban policymaking engender innovative thinking about policy design and capacity. Findings suggest (i) that instrumental-rationalist policy narratives and techno-fundamentalist discourses like ‘smart’ and ‘sustainable’ are common pathways for attempting to manage existential uncertainty, and (ii) that they also perpetuate an anachronistic policy epistemic and safeguard the powerful interests relying on it.

ACCEPTED
Format
12 - Negotiating uncertainty with policy disruption: the case of India’s Social Stock Exchange
Ankur Sarin (Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Social Stock Exchanges (SSE) are conceived to be “trading platforms that allow social businesses and non-profits to raise capital by attracting ethical investors willing to invest in organisations that have a dual corporate and social mission” (Balasubramaniam, 2023). Despite the fact that the idea of a SSE has not experienced much empirical success (Wendt, 2017), the Indian Finance Minister announced the setting up of an Indian SSE in 2019-20. As the Chairman of the SSE admits, “for both investors and stock exchanges, finding the right investment and the right instrument is a complex task” (Balasubramaniam, 2023). India’s SSE seeks to distinguish itself by the fact that it has been set up in the two largest stock exchanges in the country (the National Stock Exchange (NSE) and the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE))  and is regulated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), which regulates mainstream financial capital markets as well. While putting the heft of these institutions behind the SSE signals a strong commitment to the idea, doing so also comes with significant reputational risk to these well-regarded institutions who carry the liability of ensuring that an idea fraught with significant uncertainty succeeds. In addition, a significant intervention such as this carries risks for other actors in the ecosystem as well. The design decisions that needed to be made included eligibility criteria for participating organizations (donors and funders), the nature of financial instruments traded on the exchange, choice of metrics for regulation as well as reporting and auditing standards. Besides laying out the design, the SSE is also tasked with developing and therefore shaping capacity for the envisioned ecosystem. 


I use the design and development of the SSE as a Case Study for inductive theorization (Eisenhardt, 1989)  along with a close engagement with prior literature (Hartley et al., 2019; Howlett & Leong, 2022; Mukherjee & Bali, 2019) on how risk is both mitigated and distributed during the design of a public institution seeking to create transformational change in a complex environment. I compare and contrast risks perceived by different stakeholders – decision makers as well as potential beneficiaries (investors as well as investees)  and critically examine both the process of designing along with the adopted design elements to negotiate not only the risks from policy failure but also institutional risks carried by the participating institutions. A critical dimension of inquiry is the nature of expertise and capacity engaged in the process. I draw on publicly available committee reports, public webinars along with in-depth interviews with key participants in the design process. Although the implementation is only in its nascent stages, I tentatively examine how design decisions have played out in reducing uncertainty and risks, as perceived by different actors.

ACCEPTED
Format
13 - From decision to deliberation support: Modeling for water quality problem-structuring and intervention
Schuyler Houser (TU Delft)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Water managers and planners working within complex social-environmental water systems are challenged with difficult choices when tasked with prioritizing interventions, particularly when water problems and attendant goals are unclear and when problems and interventions can be experienced and applied at multiple scales. This is often the case for river water quality management, which involves coordinating pollution control across sectors and administrative bounds to steer progress towards multiple (and potentially competing) ecological, social, and economic goals expressed at local, regional, and hydrological levels – all in the presence of competing definitions of the notion of ‘water quality’ itself. As such, water planners and other decision-makers must grapple with a bundle of shifting objectives and targets that introduce policy ambiguities and limit the applicability of optimizing approaches.

Through the case of a multi-stakeholder water quality project in the Brantas River basin in East Java, Indonesia, this paper explores the how systems-based water quality modelling, often applied as an optimizing decision support tool, can also be used to support open deliberations regarding the characterization of water pollution problems in terms of both measurable water quality parameters and adjacent policy goals, in turn to support prioritization of interventions according to emergent problem structures. The water quality model combines mapped terrestrial pollution source estimates with rainfall-runoff and pollution transport and fate process models to estimate localized, regional, and basin-wide impacts of various source-reduction scenarios on water quality. By visually identifying pollution source concentrations and illustrating estimated impacts of alternative source reduction strategies, the model offers a visual tool for policymakers to consider root causes of water pollution, relative effects of geographically-targeted versus dispersed interventions, and desirability of alternatives based on different definitions of effectiveness at various scales (e.g., reduction of municipal water supply costs versus basin-level attainment of environmental standards). In this way, the case demonstrates how model-based scenario-building can be an invitation for policy-makers to simultaneously deliberate alternative problem structures alongside interventions at various scales in order to better deal with policy ambiguities inherent to water resources management.

ACCEPTED
Format
14 - Assessing policy capacity for disaster risk reduction policies implementation
Guiselle Romero Lora (Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In the context of the intensification of natural disasters because of climate change and the slow progress of disaster risk reduction policies in Latin America, this paper proposes an analytical framework to assess policy capacity of relevant stakeholders to implement the National Disaster Risk Management Policy in Peru. Building on the conceptual framework developed by Wu, Ramesh and Howlett (2015) who propose a model of analysis of competencies and skills analyzed at the individual, organizational and systemic level and considering operational, analytical and political competencies; this framework focuses on the organizational and systemic level and the competences and resources needed to implement  disaster risk reduction (DRR) policies. 


The framework includes perspectives from the organizational resilience literature. Resilience allows organizations to cope with crises and not interrupt their operational capacity (Barnett and Pratt, 2000; Vogus and Sutcliffe, 2007). Another perspective goes beyond and suggests that resilience allows organizations to be inherently transformed, strengthened, and able to overcome threats (Lengnick-Hall et al., 2011). Thus, resilient organizations are better prepared to perform in contexts of disasters.

 

The framework also includes reflections from the work of Kattel (2022) on dynamic capabilities and Head's (2019, 2022) studies on the wicked problems due to their implication on policy capacity studies; as well as concepts related with DRR policies such as vulnerability, disaster, and risk (Brenes 2007, Lavell 1993).

 

Building on this literature, the framework proposes variables that reconcile with the model developed by Wu, Ramesh and Howlett (2015) to assess policy capacity for DRR policies.

 

References:

Barnett, C. and Pratt, M. (2000), “From threat‐rigidity to flexibility - Toward a learning model of autogenic crisis in organizations”, Journal of Organizational Change Management, Vol. 13 No. 1, pp. 74-88.

Brenes, Alonso. 2007. “Elementos conceptuales y desarrollo histórico de la noción de gestión del riesgo y los desastres”. Rev. Reflexiones 86 (2): 75-91.

Head, Brian. 2019. “Forty years of wicked problems literature: forging closer links to policy studies”, Policy and Society, 38:2, 180-197, DOI: 10.1080/14494035.2018.1488797 

Head, Brian. 2022. Wicked problems in public policy. Understanding and responding to complex challenges. Cham: Palgrave McMillan.

Kattel, Rainer. 2022. “Dynamic capabilities of the public sector: Towards a new synthesis”. Discussion Paper. Institute for Applied Economic Research. Brasilia. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.38116/dp267

Lavell, Allan. 1993. “Ciencias sociales y desastres naturales en América Latina: un encuentro inconcluso”. Revista EURE. 19(58). pp. 73-84.

Lengnick-Hall, C., Beck, T. and Lengnick-Hall, M. (2011), “Developing a capacity for organizational resilience through strategic human resource management”, Human Resource Management Review, Vol. 21 No. 3, pp. 243-255, doi: 10.1016/J.HRMR.2010.07.001.

Vogus, T. and Sutcliffe, K. (2007), “Organizational resilience: Towards a theory and research agenda”, Paper presented at the IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, SMC, Montréal, Canada, October 7-10.

Wu, Xun, M. Ramesh, Michael Howlett. (2015) Policy capacity: A conceptual framework for understanding policy competences and capabilities. Policy and Society 34:3-4, pages 165-171.

ACCEPTED
Format
15 - HOW (NOT) TO DEAL WITH CLIMATE CHANGE CONSEQUENCES: ADAPTING, MITIGATING AND RESILIENCE IN THE SOUTH OF BRAZIL
Júlia Gabriele da Rosa (Universidade Estadual Paulista)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The effects of climate change in Southern Brazil are evidenced by floods, inundations, and power outages, resulting in water rationing and the displacement of communities and ecosystems. There remains uncertainty regarding the impacts of these activities. In response to this issue, international organizations and treaties emphasize the need for public policies that address everything from reducing greenhouse gas emissions (mitigation) to adaptation and resilience strategies. However, the prevention of catastrophes through mitigation policies becomes complementary in the face of the emergency of the most vulnerable populations who seek to maintain life, especially women and girls. An analysis of policies produced by the capitals of Southern Brazil reveals a significant gap in responding to these problems: less than 5% of policies address adaptation and resilience strategies. Overall, policies related to the consequences of climate change lack clear objectives and sustainability in their instruments. These results were obtained through a qualitative doctoral research study that examined the content of public policies published between September 2015 and January 2024 in the capitals of Southern Brazil states: Porto Alegre (Rio Grande do Sul), Florianópolis (Santa Catarina), and Curitiba (Paraná). An analytical model was developed to examine these policies, utilizing concepts, categories, and classifications. The concept of objective was employed to evaluate the social change that the policy aims to consolidate, while the concept of instrument was used to understand the strategies outlined to achieve the objectives. Categories of mitigation, resilience, and adaptation were used as parameters for the sustainability of policy content. Classifications were employed to indicate the consistency of objectives, instruments, and the congruence between them in pursuit of intended outcomes. The primary objective of presenting this work on-site is to refine the analytical model, and the specific objective is to promote the usability of the results obtained from the doctoral research.

CO-AUTHORS
Shyama Ramani (United Nations University - UNU-MERIT)
ABSTRACT

The literature on socio-technical transitions offers a wide range of approaches and frameworks to conceptualise sustainability transitions and steer them through policies. However, the multitude of concepts scattered throughout the literature makes their practical application challenging. In response, this paper presents a state-of-the-art review of tools and frameworks for sustainability transitions research and synthesises the significant conceptual and methodological developments from a policy practice perspective. Our overview looks into the complexities and uncertainties of socio-technical systems transitions, by drawing on contemporary examples. We then analyse the utility of different approaches and frameworks for: (i) Baseline assessment of the system to identify key drivers of societal challenges; (ii) Target visioning to set direction and strategic priorities for action, and (iii) Transition governance to design, implement and evaluate efforts for change. We conclude by synthesising the findings in a conceptual framework to advance the operationalisation and orientation of policies for sustainability transitions.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

A key obstacle to understanding the policy dynamics of policy design in constitutional monarchy with its governance based on the separation of powers is complex. Especially considering the environmental uncertainties and growing policy crises. Moreover, the added compliance with global standards such as the Sustainable Development Goals.

In this paper, we explore policy setting in Qatar’s context and identify existing path dependency in the institutions that currently explain the policy making. With its unique socio-economic and environmental context, Qatar offers an intriguing case for exploring how policy tools can be adapted to manage uncertainty in economic diversification, environmental sustainability, and social welfare. To signify specific examples, the paper examines Qatar’s current policy landscape. It identifies external influences that have historically caused uncertainties, such as fluctuations in oil prices and geopolitical dynamics, that amplify the significance of economic diversification. The paper highlights specific policy tools employed in Qatar, such as scenario mapping, public-private partnerships and regulatory frameworks. The effectiveness of these tools in managing uncertainty is evaluated through a multi-disciplinary approach, integrating insights from environmental engineering, economics, and political science.

The paper addresses enhancement policy resilience by focusing specifically on the role of technology innovation and sustainable practices. Subsequently, the paper reflects on Qatar’s Vision 2030 in the context of innovation and sustainability and comments on how these policy targets are achievable based on the policy capacities and tools available for the key stakeholders. (First Author Dr. Esmat Zaidan)

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The growth of policy labs over the last few decades has been substantial, with numerous examples appearing in many nations. In response, there has been a focus on developing typologies of labs based on relationship to governments, staffing, focus of inquiry, methods used, and other factors. There have also been considerations of which part of the policy process these labs are most engaged with, analyses of the policy sectors that they examine and at what level of jurisdiction, and considerations of how effective they are in addressing policy problems. Critically, there has also been a growing interest in understanding whether labs that use design methods are able to function alongside more traditional approaches to policy design.

 

But how do labs deal with problems or challenges in the context of uncertainty? Many labs have been established to deal with ‘ill-structured problems’, taking mainly cross-sectoral policy problems outside of the bureaucratic structures of government so that they can be ‘labbed’ in hope of a solution. These labs can be considered as a particular type of procedural policy tool, with a focus on changing the shape of governing structures. But given the limits of labs in ‘everyday’ situations, where they have been shown to hold promise but also face significant limits, are they capable of producing solutions in a context of uncertainty?

 

This paper examines policy labs and their potential for functioning under uncertainty, aiming to address two gaps. First, while labs are often created to deal with seemingly intractable problems, that is against a background of understanding that the issue is multifaceted and the knowledge base might be strong but conflicting across different actors who hold a stake in the solution. This is a different situation to one where labs are used to work on problems where there is little understanding of the issue or there is an inadequate knowledge base to support solutions, as is the case in uncertainty. How do policy labs work in this context?

 

Second, because labs are ‘outside’ the bureaucratic system in many nations, even though they are at least loosely coupled with it, there is an important question about how lessons in dealing with uncertainty can be spread via networks and institutionalised by governments and other organisations. While labs are connected to each other around the world, they are often less connected to government departments where policy decisions are made. In some situations, labs are being funded and evaluated by national or international agencies, while in others there is little steering of labs and not much evidence of whether they are achieving what they were established to do. What kinds of structures are needed to ensure that the lessons learned from mostly small and transient labs are captured, shared, and ultimately institutionalised?

 

These questions about how policy labs work under uncertainty and how lessons from their work can be institutionalised, will be addressed conceptually and by using empirical examples from labs.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Policy goals play an important role in shaping the effectiveness of policy instruments by simplifying complex policy interdependencies and setting policy priorities (Fukuda-Parr 2014). But current understanding of the role of policy goals in effective policy design is often undermined by the tendency to relegate policy goals as fixed constraints that policymakers need to work with  (Howlett 2009,  Thacher  and Rein  2004). In taking goals as givens, policy sciences ignored how goal formulation can motivate action, “which is the foundation of purposiveness” of policy design (Anderson 1986, 64). Since goals are what distinguishes a public policy from a random action, the policy sciences need to pay more attention to policy goals. After all, consciously modifying goals are argued to be instrumental to achieving them (Linder and Peters 1984). 

 

This proposed article seeks to advance Linder and Peters’ (1984) seminal work on policy design by conceptualizing the design of goals under uncertainty. Existing studies rely on Wildavsky’s (1979) notion of ‘strategic retreat on objectives’ to examine goal changes as a fixation on implementing the means rather than achieving the substantive goals of the policy. This process of goal displacement is often a response to an certain type of uncertainty pertaining the complexity of the policy problem. However, there are different kinds of uncertainties that are ignored in policy design. On top of uncertainty over the means-ends relationship, uncertainty over actor interdependence (strategic uncertainty) and institutional divergence or conflict (institutional uncertainty) also exists to undermine policy effectiveness (Koppenjan and Klijn 2004). This article argues that the process of goal changes would depend on the type of uncertainty that policymakers face.

 

The proposed paper presents three empirical cases from the Philippines to develop this argument. It argues that different types of uncertainties are responded to through different forms of goal changes. The Bottom-Up Budgeting (BUB) is an experiment at improving local governance but is faced with uncertainty over what participatory instruments works best to improve local governance. The goal of poverty reduction was displaced over implementing ‘good governance’ measures to instill budget and planning discipline in local governments. The BUB is a quintessential example of goal displacement. The oldest private-public partnership on education in the world (Education Service Contracting) is presented as a case of strategic uncertainty where goals were modified to establish some predictability around how the state can regulate private schools. New goals were replaced as a form of goal diversion where old goals were considered irrelevant given the changes in policy context. I propose a new form of goal change – goal dissociation – to capture responses to institutional uncertainty in the national cash transfer program (Pantawid Pamilyang Pilipino Program). Dissociated goals serve to legitimize means irrelevant to the existing policy but relevant to goals of other policies. In this case, dissociated goals of the program were relevant to increasing the supply-side interventions for education and health.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

From the policy designer's perspective, one of the main sources of uncertainty concerns how policy recipients will respond to the policy initiative. Will they cooperate in the success of the policy or will they remonstrate against it? It is not just a matter of political consensus or social legitimacy of the measures taken, but of active policy cooperation and behavior change.

Recent literature on co-design has highlighted the potential benefits of involving stakeholders, citizens and, more generally, policy recipients in the policy formulation phase, in terms of the quality of interventions, the innovativeness of proposed policy solutions, as well as the increased willingness of 'lay actors' to cooperate with policy-makers in the production of goods and services that benefit the community. However, the full benefits of such an opening up of policy-making to potential policy recipients appear reduced in all those policy areas that go beyond the provision of goods and services, but rather affect the individual conduct of citizens. This is especially true for what we might call behavior-oriented policies (or "highly collaborative policies"), i.e. those where the active participation/compliance of policy recipients is critical to the achievement of policy goals and policy success.

In these policy areas, finding a mix of instruments that can overcome any resistance to compliance on the part of the target group and nudge them towards the desired behavior is one of the key challenges for policymakers in reducing the uncertainty of policy outcomes (and hence the risk of failure). In this regard, some authors suggest the strategy of the least intrusive policy instruments (the 'least restrictive alternative' principle) and that a purely regulatory and intrusive approach risks not only being ineffective but even counterproductive compared to inaction. However, there is no clear evidence on the merits of different policy recipes. Assessing the effectiveness of different policy mix schemes is still an open question for empirical research.

The paper sets out to reflect on these issues, focusing in particular on two cases of 'highly collaborative'/behaviour-oriented policies, both of which can be ascribed to the macro-sphere of public health interventions: 1) tobacco control policies; 2) childhood vaccinations. Through the comparison of policy mix design strategies in these two policy areas in a number of countries characterised by different welfare regimes and varying degrees of democratic consolidation, we intend to answer a threefold research question:

a) is it possible to identify recurring patterns in the policy mixes adopted by individual countries in the two different areas, from a configurational and/or evolutionary perspective?

b) is it possible to identify recurring patterns for 'families' of countries that share certain political-institutional characteristics (e.g. policy legacy in the health field; margins of freedom left to individual initiative)?

c) is it possible to identify a relationship between specific patterns of policy mix and the results obtained in terms of target groups' compliance?

 

Authors: Federico Toth and Stefania Profeti (University of Bologna). Federico Toth is the corresponding author and will attend the panel.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Latin American cities face deep uncertainty about the volume of water available to meet their competing demands. This uncertainty arises not only from climate change but also due to the intrinsic complexity of groundwater and surface water systems that supply most of the major capitals in the region. In addition to climate-derived and scientific uncertainty, water stress and occasionally water policy itself generate social conflict (political uncertainty), further complicating the design of water policies. Policy regimes characterized by weak institutions, seen as settings of low stability and poor enforcement, add to the complexity faced by policymakers. The policy mix to navigate these uncertainties includes a range not limited to inter-basin water transfers, price reforms, green infrastructure, and desalination, each with distinct trade-offs among various policy criteria such as water delivery, conflict management, and political payoffs. What are the analytical, operational, and political capacities required for effective policy design under these uncertainties? Through content analysis of policy reports, scholarly research, and newspapers, this paper takes inventory of the capacities demonstrated in managing water crises in a sample of Latin American countries and identifies the capacities that need to be developed. The paper discusses implications for building theory on policy design under uncertainty.

CO-AUTHORS
Naikang Feng
ABSTRACT

Inherent uncertainty in local policy environments demands appropriate system-wide adaptations of organizational dynamics and policy design during policy implementation. Extant literature explains policy design patterns mainly through state-level drivers and/or perceptions and logics of individual decision makers. While the two complementary perspectives balance structural and agentic forces, few studies explicitly investigate the influence of organizational structures and processes. Drawing on insights from the behavioral decision school in the organizational literature, the study discusses their influence on policy design and discuss ways how implementing organizations may address local environmental uncertainty during policy implementation.

 

Based on the Carnegie perspective, this study conceptualizes organizations as adaptive systems consisting of a coalition of participants. We formulate propositions linking implementing organization’s responses to uncertainty in policy design to three major pathways of organizational adaptations: adaptation of goals, adaptation of attention rules, and adaptation of search rules. First, organizations can mitigate uncertainty in policy design through goal adaptation, adjusting their goals based on past experience and the experience of comparable organizations. Second, attention rules adaptation allows organizations to focus on a select set of performance criteria as demanded by organizational participants, reducing uncertainty in the performance effects of policy design choices. Third, organizations can engage in search rules adaptation, learning from their performance outcomes and actively seeking more effective policy design in local implementation environments.

 

A case study on the adoption of market-based instruments in China’s food policy reform is discussed as an illustration of how organizations adapt and adjust its policy design in response to uncertainty. Specifically, this research examines the joint conditions that facilitate the recurrent use of market-based instruments among street-level food safety regulatory organizations (SLOs) in China. Data from ten cities in five provinces, spanning diverse socioeconomic stages and policy enforcement scenarios, were collected through surveys of chief executive officers and frontline workers. A fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) is employed to analyze the data and identify causal configurations leading to the adoption of policy design with high usage of market-based instruments.

 

The findings reveal three distinct configurations of causal conditions that explain the frequent use of market-based instruments by SLOs. The first configuration involves goal adaptation to meet target demands, considering policy targets' compliance attitude and upper-level governments' policy style and capacity. The second configuration highlights attention rules adaptation by referencing instrument choices and effectiveness in other SLOs, as well as considering upper-level governments' style and strategy. The third configuration suggests search rules adaptation through internal communication channels, enabling organizations to negotiate conventions and reduce decision-making uncertainty.

 

This study contributes to understanding organizational influences on policy design, emphasizing the Carnegie perspective as a foundation for examining how organizations respond to uncertainty. The findings provide valuable insights for policymakers and practitioners in mitigating uncertainty during policy implementation through adaptive adjustment in organizational and policy design.

 

 

FULL PAPER IS AVAILABLE. (Apology, as I thought the call is a paper call.)

 

I plan to present the paper in person at the workshop, but I shall confirm my summer class schedule first.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

For about a decade, co-creative processes have received special attention from public policy, urban planning, and environmental researchers to address the acceleration, proliferation, and complexity of wicked problems (Head, 2022). Defined as the organizational capacity to collaboratively work with relevant stakeholders to develop innovative solutions to our most pressing societal challenges (Ansell & Torfing, 2021), co-creative processes are currently being analyzed in terms of public value (Osborne & al., 2021) and the democratic quality of the process (Ansell & Torfing, 2022). Few studies explore how these co-creative processes fundamentally transform public policies in the face of wicked problems.

To tackle this question, I argue that the degree of ownership by different policy designers and stakeholders enables the sustainable integration of co-creative process outcomes into public policies. Drawing from Lachapelle's definition, which sees ownership as "a concept through which to assess whose voice is heard, who has influence over decisions, and who is affected by the process and outcome" (2008: 52), I propose an operationalization of this concept to qualitatively observe two contrasting cases of processes addressing wicked problems in the Brussels-Capital Region: a group co-creation case (Team4 Neder-over-Hembeek) and a co-creation case with a societal dimension (Les Lieux d'avenir). My analyses will be based on participant observations, stakeholder interviews, and documentary research. I will demonstrate the significance of the ownership concept for policy designers, emphasizing its role in integrating co-creation outcomes in both research and policymaking processes related to wicked problems.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

 

This paper sketches the challenges of designing effective policies for three environmental policy challenges marked by complexity, uncertainty and policy controversy. The first example, plastic waste management, is often discussed in terms of the ‘circular economy’ framework and optimising recycling.  The second example, biodiversity conservation, is often discussed in terms of habitat protection and requiring ‘offset’ equivalence where habitat is ‘necessarily’ destroyed.  The third example, protecting water quality on the Great Barrier Reef, is often discussed in terms of reducing harmful runoff from agricultural lands. These three policy challenges have shared a common historical pattern, namely, that governmental attempts to influence the behaviour of corporations and citizens have commenced with soft or voluntary measures, such as information, financial incentives, and industry codes of conduct. The paper suggests that these voluntary measures have facilitated avoidance and non-compliance. The alternatives require enforceable standards and targets as part of a multi-layered approach to addressing complexity, uncertainty and the need for public support.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Liberalised electricity markets had marginalised the role of government long-term planning in the electricity industry. However, the decarbonisation of electricity and the electrification of energy consumptions require inter-sectoral coordination, state policy support, and large investment in new infrastructure systems, all within a context of high technological, geopolitical, and environmental uncertainty. The demand to coordinate action under uncertainty has opened an opportunity for the development and experimentation with new forms of energy planning, or anticipation more broadly, by state agencies or regulated companies. The article documents the tools for planning through contrasting narrative scenarios (i.e, Future Energy Scenarios in the UK) and their integration into existing policy system to deal with uncertainty. Focus on the tools of policy deliberation, the article dissects the tensions that government experience in finding and defining a role for planning in public economic governance and the delegation of planning within existing or new institutions, a tension summarised in the dichotomy: do governments reassume the role of architects or, reluctantly, only of stewards. The article revises the characterisation of the regulatory state as the dominant form of governance organisation in the electricity sector through comparative evidence on the evolution of planning instruments. While the most immediate or explicit cause for these developments are the goals for decarbonisation and the political anxieties over energy security, an industrial orders perspective drives attention to the political imagination over the organisation of the industry. The article introduces the problems through a new database on planning instruments but develops its theoretical insights from the review of a subset of cases in Western Europe, North and South America.

CO-AUTHORS
Glen D. Kuecker (DePauw University)
ABSTRACT

Urban policymaking is under stress from political and environmental uncertainties. Global policy narratives give the impression of a growing consensus about polycrises, but policy guidance at high levels is intentionally general and often ambiguous. With progress measured against the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals tracker, national governments endeavor to varying degrees to meet global policy expectations even in the absence of enforcement and sanctioning power. Where national governments fall short in such efforts, city governments having adequate capacities often embrace aspects of the SDGs that concern their local needs and have undertaken structured tracking and reporting through Voluntary Local Reviews. In this context, some city governments are pursuing policy innovations through the SDG framework as a way to secure legitimacy. Does the dynamic interface between global policy goals and local policy action change the way urban policies are designed? This article addresses this underexplored question through the case of smart cities in London, New York, and Singapore, examining whether new uncertainties that contextualize urban policymaking engender innovative thinking about policy design and capacity. Findings suggest (i) that instrumental-rationalist policy narratives and techno-fundamentalist discourses like ‘smart’ and ‘sustainable’ are common pathways for attempting to manage existential uncertainty, and (ii) that they also perpetuate an anachronistic policy epistemic and safeguard the powerful interests relying on it.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Social Stock Exchanges (SSE) are conceived to be “trading platforms that allow social businesses and non-profits to raise capital by attracting ethical investors willing to invest in organisations that have a dual corporate and social mission” (Balasubramaniam, 2023). Despite the fact that the idea of a SSE has not experienced much empirical success (Wendt, 2017), the Indian Finance Minister announced the setting up of an Indian SSE in 2019-20. As the Chairman of the SSE admits, “for both investors and stock exchanges, finding the right investment and the right instrument is a complex task” (Balasubramaniam, 2023). India’s SSE seeks to distinguish itself by the fact that it has been set up in the two largest stock exchanges in the country (the National Stock Exchange (NSE) and the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE))  and is regulated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), which regulates mainstream financial capital markets as well. While putting the heft of these institutions behind the SSE signals a strong commitment to the idea, doing so also comes with significant reputational risk to these well-regarded institutions who carry the liability of ensuring that an idea fraught with significant uncertainty succeeds. In addition, a significant intervention such as this carries risks for other actors in the ecosystem as well. The design decisions that needed to be made included eligibility criteria for participating organizations (donors and funders), the nature of financial instruments traded on the exchange, choice of metrics for regulation as well as reporting and auditing standards. Besides laying out the design, the SSE is also tasked with developing and therefore shaping capacity for the envisioned ecosystem. 


I use the design and development of the SSE as a Case Study for inductive theorization (Eisenhardt, 1989)  along with a close engagement with prior literature (Hartley et al., 2019; Howlett & Leong, 2022; Mukherjee & Bali, 2019) on how risk is both mitigated and distributed during the design of a public institution seeking to create transformational change in a complex environment. I compare and contrast risks perceived by different stakeholders – decision makers as well as potential beneficiaries (investors as well as investees)  and critically examine both the process of designing along with the adopted design elements to negotiate not only the risks from policy failure but also institutional risks carried by the participating institutions. A critical dimension of inquiry is the nature of expertise and capacity engaged in the process. I draw on publicly available committee reports, public webinars along with in-depth interviews with key participants in the design process. Although the implementation is only in its nascent stages, I tentatively examine how design decisions have played out in reducing uncertainty and risks, as perceived by different actors.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Water managers and planners working within complex social-environmental water systems are challenged with difficult choices when tasked with prioritizing interventions, particularly when water problems and attendant goals are unclear and when problems and interventions can be experienced and applied at multiple scales. This is often the case for river water quality management, which involves coordinating pollution control across sectors and administrative bounds to steer progress towards multiple (and potentially competing) ecological, social, and economic goals expressed at local, regional, and hydrological levels – all in the presence of competing definitions of the notion of ‘water quality’ itself. As such, water planners and other decision-makers must grapple with a bundle of shifting objectives and targets that introduce policy ambiguities and limit the applicability of optimizing approaches.

Through the case of a multi-stakeholder water quality project in the Brantas River basin in East Java, Indonesia, this paper explores the how systems-based water quality modelling, often applied as an optimizing decision support tool, can also be used to support open deliberations regarding the characterization of water pollution problems in terms of both measurable water quality parameters and adjacent policy goals, in turn to support prioritization of interventions according to emergent problem structures. The water quality model combines mapped terrestrial pollution source estimates with rainfall-runoff and pollution transport and fate process models to estimate localized, regional, and basin-wide impacts of various source-reduction scenarios on water quality. By visually identifying pollution source concentrations and illustrating estimated impacts of alternative source reduction strategies, the model offers a visual tool for policymakers to consider root causes of water pollution, relative effects of geographically-targeted versus dispersed interventions, and desirability of alternatives based on different definitions of effectiveness at various scales (e.g., reduction of municipal water supply costs versus basin-level attainment of environmental standards). In this way, the case demonstrates how model-based scenario-building can be an invitation for policy-makers to simultaneously deliberate alternative problem structures alongside interventions at various scales in order to better deal with policy ambiguities inherent to water resources management.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In the context of the intensification of natural disasters because of climate change and the slow progress of disaster risk reduction policies in Latin America, this paper proposes an analytical framework to assess policy capacity of relevant stakeholders to implement the National Disaster Risk Management Policy in Peru. Building on the conceptual framework developed by Wu, Ramesh and Howlett (2015) who propose a model of analysis of competencies and skills analyzed at the individual, organizational and systemic level and considering operational, analytical and political competencies; this framework focuses on the organizational and systemic level and the competences and resources needed to implement  disaster risk reduction (DRR) policies. 


The framework includes perspectives from the organizational resilience literature. Resilience allows organizations to cope with crises and not interrupt their operational capacity (Barnett and Pratt, 2000; Vogus and Sutcliffe, 2007). Another perspective goes beyond and suggests that resilience allows organizations to be inherently transformed, strengthened, and able to overcome threats (Lengnick-Hall et al., 2011). Thus, resilient organizations are better prepared to perform in contexts of disasters.

 

The framework also includes reflections from the work of Kattel (2022) on dynamic capabilities and Head's (2019, 2022) studies on the wicked problems due to their implication on policy capacity studies; as well as concepts related with DRR policies such as vulnerability, disaster, and risk (Brenes 2007, Lavell 1993).

 

Building on this literature, the framework proposes variables that reconcile with the model developed by Wu, Ramesh and Howlett (2015) to assess policy capacity for DRR policies.

 

References:

Barnett, C. and Pratt, M. (2000), “From threat‐rigidity to flexibility - Toward a learning model of autogenic crisis in organizations”, Journal of Organizational Change Management, Vol. 13 No. 1, pp. 74-88.

Brenes, Alonso. 2007. “Elementos conceptuales y desarrollo histórico de la noción de gestión del riesgo y los desastres”. Rev. Reflexiones 86 (2): 75-91.

Head, Brian. 2019. “Forty years of wicked problems literature: forging closer links to policy studies”, Policy and Society, 38:2, 180-197, DOI: 10.1080/14494035.2018.1488797 

Head, Brian. 2022. Wicked problems in public policy. Understanding and responding to complex challenges. Cham: Palgrave McMillan.

Kattel, Rainer. 2022. “Dynamic capabilities of the public sector: Towards a new synthesis”. Discussion Paper. Institute for Applied Economic Research. Brasilia. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.38116/dp267

Lavell, Allan. 1993. “Ciencias sociales y desastres naturales en América Latina: un encuentro inconcluso”. Revista EURE. 19(58). pp. 73-84.

Lengnick-Hall, C., Beck, T. and Lengnick-Hall, M. (2011), “Developing a capacity for organizational resilience through strategic human resource management”, Human Resource Management Review, Vol. 21 No. 3, pp. 243-255, doi: 10.1016/J.HRMR.2010.07.001.

Vogus, T. and Sutcliffe, K. (2007), “Organizational resilience: Towards a theory and research agenda”, Paper presented at the IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, SMC, Montréal, Canada, October 7-10.

Wu, Xun, M. Ramesh, Michael Howlett. (2015) Policy capacity: A conceptual framework for understanding policy competences and capabilities. Policy and Society 34:3-4, pages 165-171.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The effects of climate change in Southern Brazil are evidenced by floods, inundations, and power outages, resulting in water rationing and the displacement of communities and ecosystems. There remains uncertainty regarding the impacts of these activities. In response to this issue, international organizations and treaties emphasize the need for public policies that address everything from reducing greenhouse gas emissions (mitigation) to adaptation and resilience strategies. However, the prevention of catastrophes through mitigation policies becomes complementary in the face of the emergency of the most vulnerable populations who seek to maintain life, especially women and girls. An analysis of policies produced by the capitals of Southern Brazil reveals a significant gap in responding to these problems: less than 5% of policies address adaptation and resilience strategies. Overall, policies related to the consequences of climate change lack clear objectives and sustainability in their instruments. These results were obtained through a qualitative doctoral research study that examined the content of public policies published between September 2015 and January 2024 in the capitals of Southern Brazil states: Porto Alegre (Rio Grande do Sul), Florianópolis (Santa Catarina), and Curitiba (Paraná). An analytical model was developed to examine these policies, utilizing concepts, categories, and classifications. The concept of objective was employed to evaluate the social change that the policy aims to consolidate, while the concept of instrument was used to understand the strategies outlined to achieve the objectives. Categories of mitigation, resilience, and adaptation were used as parameters for the sustainability of policy content. Classifications were employed to indicate the consistency of objectives, instruments, and the congruence between them in pursuit of intended outcomes. The primary objective of presenting this work on-site is to refine the analytical model, and the specific objective is to promote the usability of the results obtained from the doctoral research.