Format

P09. Australia and New Zealand Public Policy in Comparative Perspective

COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Joshua Newman
Monash University
Main chair
Brian Coffey
RMIT University
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

As Western industrialized democracies located in the southern hemisphere, Australia and New Zealand are unique entities in the global policy arena. They are the two richest countries in the southern hemisphere as measured by GDP per capita, and they represent two out of only three southern members of the OECD. They have the highest life expectancies, the lowest income inequality, and the highest happiness index of any country in the southern hemisphere. Indeed, in a time when Global South is a term used to represent emerging economies and developing democracies, Australia and New Zealand are uniquely characterised by their status as wealthy and influential southern democracies.

 

Australia and New Zealand face unique policy challenges, but within similar contexts. The economies of both countries depend heavily on primary resource extraction and export, and the fluctuating demands of China and other emerging Asian economies, along with a rethinking of global trade strategies, pose high levels of uncertainty for decision making in a number of policy areas, including industry, military, and research and development. Conservation, biodiversity, and environmental protection remain especially challenging for domestic policy making in these two unique ecosystems, under the looming effects of climate change and the persistent problem of invasive species.

 

On the other hand, both countries are dealing with issues that are also relevant in many other developed democracies. Tension between socially progressive and more conservative voices have revealed a polarised landscape of public opinion on social issues, and policy decisions in a variety of social areas, from immigration to marriage equality, continue to pose significant challenges for decision makers. Shifts in the labour force and in population demographics mean that many social policies, from child care to aged care, are being redesigned. As in other jurisdictions, a decline in many forms of violent crime is concurrent with a dramatic rise in domestic violence, which has created difficulties for policy making in the areas of law enforcement and criminal justice.

 

Australia and New Zealand present a unique opportunity for comparison with the rest of the world. Though small and isolated in relation to other Western democracies, the presence of both unique and common policy issues invites a comparative analysis with other policy making jurisdictions.

CALL FOR PAPERS

This panel invites scholarship that compares policy making in Australia and/or New Zealand with the rest of the world. Papers can be theory-building or empirical, can examine the policy process or substantive analyses of specific policies, and all theoretical perspectives and methodologies are welcome.

 

The objective of this panel is to bring together comparative analysis of policy making in Australia and New Zealand to showcase the lessons that can be learned from comparison with these unique jurisdictions but also to highlight the global nature of many areas of public policy making. What can other jurisdictions learn from comparison with Australia and New Zealand? What can Australia and New Zealand learn from the rest of the world? How can the unique contexts of these two countries be used to advance scholarship of public policy?

 

Paper proposals should be submitted through the IPPA website by 30 January 2019.

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - The template as comparative method: the International Library of Policy Analysis
Hal Colebatch (UNSW Australia)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

A book series, the ‘International Library of Policy Analysis’ has recently been launched to promote ‘international dialogue in the area of policy analysis’ through a succession of country studies.  It was not planned to be a ‘world series’, but was built from a volume on policy analysis in Canada, which then served as a template for the subsequent volumes.  Fourteen volumes have now appeared, mostly from what Jared Diamond would call WEIRD societies (Western, Educated, Industrial, Rich and Democratic). 

This paper addresses the aspirations of this series, and the way in which they have been applied to produce a volume on policy analysis in Australia (Head, B, and Crowley, K. (eds) Policy Analysis in Australia).  It examines the concepts and assumptions that underlie the focus on policy analysis, and the way in which the Canadian template has been applied to give an account of policy analysis in Australia.  It discusses the ways in which this approach draws on, or adds to, what is already know about policy practice in Australia, and explores the contribution which the series makes to ‘promoting international dialogue’ in policy studies and developing comparative method.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Privatizing in the Commonwealth: State-Owned Enterprises in Canada and Australia
Joshua Newman (Monash University)
CO-AUTHORS
Malcolm Bird (University of Winnipeg)
ABSTRACT

Our paper sets out to compare and contrast the use of state-owned enterprise (SOEs) as a policy instrument in Canada and Australia. While privatizations have occurred in both countries, there are considerable differences in levels of enthusiasm for and the number of firms turned over to the private sector. Very generally, Australia and its sub-national units have embraced privatization with considerably more gusto than their Canadian federal and provincial counterparts. Canadian “Crown corporations” continue to play a significant role in the country’s economy in general, including substantial roles in electricity generation, alcohol distribution and gaming, among others. While Canada and Australia share similar colonial historical legacies, a Westminster-style political system, and are both dependent on resource-extractive industries, among other congruencies, they differ considerably in their treatment of SOEs. While studies on state-owned enterprise in Canada are more limited than in the Australian context, it appears that the use of SOEs in Canada is more strategic and interventionist in character, with Canadian governments more eager to use them as a tool for achieving policy objectives and only willing to privatize when they are left with few other choices to resolve an ongoing problem. In contrast, Australian governments are quicker to put privatization on the agenda, representing a wholesale ideological shift to reduce the role and scope of the state’s intervention in the marketplace. Using information from annual reports and documents obtained through Freedom of Information requests, we set out to draw out these differences in treatment of SOEs and to use it to explore decision-making processes within these respective governments.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Standing Out: Australia’s economic performance in comparative perspective
Alan Fenna (Curtin University)
CO-AUTHORS
John Phillimore (Curtin University)
Alan Tapper (Curtin University)
ABSTRACT

Australia seems to have performed very well by a number of economic and social indicators over the past quarter of a century.  This paper examines that performance in comparative perspective and explores the institutional factors and policy decisions that may have contributed. To what extent must the distinctiveness be still seen as an Australasian phenomenon rather than just and Australian one?  Where does Australia sit vis-à-vis the so-called ‘anglosphere’?  How does Australia compare with the OECD in general?  A long scholarly tradition sees Australia as having had a distinctive welfare state, but a number of critics have pointed to its dismantling.  Is the AWS still distinctive, and, to the extent it is, has that played a role in Australia’s performance?

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Governing biodiversity: Australia and Sweden compared
Brian Coffey (RMIT University)
CO-AUTHORS
Nooshin Torabi
Florence Damiens (ICON group, Center for Urban Research, RMIT University)
Erik Hysing (Örebro University)
ABSTRACT

The decline of biodiversity can have profound economic, social and environmental consequences which diminish the total quality of the web of life on planet earth. In response, under the context of the UN Convention on Biological Diversity, governments around the world have developed national biodiversity strategies as a means for demonstrating their commitment, and approach, to the conservation of biodiversity within their specific national contexts. Given the UN’s commitments on biodiversity and that Australia has a draft biodiversity strategy in development, it is timely to investigate the strengths and weaknesses of different approaches to the development and implementation of national strategies for the conservation of biodiversity. In addition, the disruptions association with the emergence of the Anthropocene create further significant challenges for the conservation of biodiversity now and into the future. Informed by a policy studies perspective, we compare existing biodiversity strategies in Australia and Sweden. Sweden and Australia provide a fertile ground for comparison on the basis that both are wealthy countries with sufficient resources to manage the threats to biodiversity within their borders while generally classified within different policy traditions (neo-liberalism and neo-corporatism) and with different governance system (federal and unitary state). We explore how biodiversity is conceptualised in each strategy, and the implications this has for how it is governed. We also reflect on how well the two national strategies respond to the challenges for biodiversity conservation that are associated with the Anthropocene.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - A concierge approach to innovation? Insights from the Australian and Scottish National Systems of Innovation.
David Noble (Southern Cross University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Introduction:

National Systems of Innovation (NSIs) have become ubiquitous throughout the OECD, and increasingly in non-OECD countries. Each NSI is informed by, and subject to, the local policy, political, and commercial environment, to name but a few factors (Borowiecki & Paunov, 2018). Although scholars warn that an innovation policy mechanism that may be successful in one jurisdiction may not work in another (Izsák, et al, 2013), nonetheless there may be lessons to draw for Australia and Scotland – and wider - by a comparative evaluation of elements of their NSI programs.

 

Research questions:

How can Scotland’s ‘Interface’ program, and the Australian CRC-P program, inform the policy mixes for each country? What differences exist that could be beneficial and transferable between countries, and what might be some of the challenges? What can other jurisdictions learn from these models?

 

Methodology:

Two research projects in 2018 interviewed participants in the Scottish ‘Interface’ program, and in the Australian CRC-P program. A qualitative approach was employed using the NSI framework. Transcripts were thematically analysed, with emergent themes from each jurisdiction cross-referenced and compared.

 

Findings:

In each program, similar issues arose to do with IP management, partnership agreements, difficulties universities experience in responding to the dynamism of the commercial world, and the formative nature of the programs for the SME community. However, differences such as how SMEs discover and access an appropriate research partner, governance requirements for each program, the quantum of the available grants, and the application process, are highlighted in the research.

 

Fit with research panel questions:

Australia and Scotland, while different in many respects, also have similarities that go beyond a shared language. These include a modern research environment, a desire for economic growth, and governments that are focussed on achieving this growth through NSIs. The choice of the two NSI programs in this research provides scope for each country to discover potentially beneficial policy changes. There is the opportunity for Australia to learn from the ‘concierge’ nature of the Scottish program, and Scotland to learn from the highly targeted CRC-P program, designed to drive academia and SMEs closer together.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Do regulators use science in policy formulation? Evidence from regulatory impact statements in Australia, New Zealand and the European Union
Oliver Fritsch (Murdoch University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The debate on the use, non-use and abuse of science in regulatory policy is as old as the field of regulation. But there have been few attempts to link the different usages to specific policy instruments. In this paper I focus on a policy instrument called impact assessment (IA). IA is now a common tool for policy appraisal in all OECD countries including Australia as well as at European Union level. Its thrust is to analyse the likely effects of primary and delegated legislation. This analysis revolves around a definition of the problem to be regulated, an appraisal of the status quo and its likely evolution, consultation, an (ideally) monetised analysis of the effects of a range of feasible alternatives that address the identified problem, and an indication of the preferred policy option. The three-fold characterisation of ‘impacts’ typical for many IA systems – economic, social and environmental – suggests that policy makers cast their net widely when it comes to the search for scientific knowledge, covering both the social and the natural sciences as well as a range of other sources to inform IA. But is this the case, and how do we know? I have taken a statistically representative sample of IAs in three jurisdictions, Australia, New Zealand and the European Union, published between 2008 and 2018, stratified by year and department/agency (in the EU the correct term would be ‘Directorate Generale’). This represents roughly 25 per cent of the total number of IAs supporting legislation and regulations, covering policy areas as diverse as health and safety, environment, media and communications. I then code the type of scientific and non-scientific evidence mentioned in the references of the document to explore four competing theoretical approaches: First, IAs as tools to bring scientific envidence into the policy-making process, either to learn from science or in order to appeal to a target community – resulting in a high number of scientific references. Second, IAs operate in a specific legal context and bring together various strands of the bureaucracy – resulting in a high number of references to legal acts, policy documents, and court cases. Third, IAs reflect policy initiatives that respond to or anticipate the concerns of their core audiences, i.e. interest groups – resulting in a high number of references to statements made and documents published by stakeholders. Fourth, one could assume that policy makers prepare IAs for symbolic reasons, with no specific concerns as to the impact of IA on regulation. The observable implication is that we should find no specific citation pattern. IAs then may contain very few or too many references – this should be erratic, because in the end the use of science or legal acts or anything else would be just decorative and perfunctory. The conclusions contribute to the literature on regulatory policy and the usages of science in government.

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - INTEGRATION WITHIN CER: REGULATING FDI, CRISES AND THE CHALLENGE OF CULTURAL NORMS
Greg Mahony (University of Canberra IGPA)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

ABSTRACT

 

Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is integral to regional integration and attracted increasing attention in the wake of significant reductions in trade barriers over the last half century. This has been the case in the development of relations between Australia and New Zealand under Closer Economic Relations (CER) or more formally ANZCERTA, The Australia - New Zealand Closer Economic Relations Trade Agreement, signed in 1983. After protracted negotiations The Protocol on Investment to CER was signed in 2011 and enacted in 2013.  

 

Similar institutions and a range of deeply shared social norms have underpinned a long period of trans-Tasman integration; however, differences in institutions and social norms may also configure and constrain further and more rapid integration. Integration requires changes in the institutional, administrative, legal and political fields. However, unlike other regional groupings such as the European Union explicit aspirations for such non-economic integration have been noticeably absent from this regional relationship. Whilst trade liberalisation has been achieved under ANZCERTA, deep integration goes beyond the concentration upon strictly economic policy related to factors such as border trade barriers, differences in regulatory regimes, technical regulations, and different exchange rates.

 

Adopting a cross-disciplinary approach this paper employs theories from institutionalist approaches to political science, economics, political economy and international business to examine the regulatory frameworks for FDI in Australia and New Zealand. In particular, the methodology used explores a series of natural experiments which have posed challenges to the operation of the agreement. That is, greater integration regularly faces external shocks which test extant regulatory practice.  By examining the effects of three crises - globalisation, the global financial crisis and food security - experienced on both sides of the Tasman, we identify tensions between norms and trans-Tasman governance. From this experience we draw inferences to aid understanding of extant and emerging norms and subsequent impediments to integration applicable to both regional and global contexts. Theories employed in the paper such as historical institutionalism and sociological institutionalism inform the explanation of the role institutions play in both political and economic paths to integration within a regional grouping.

 

 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Refugee employment support: Policy collaboration and competition in Australia, Canada and Belgium
Adele Garnier (Macquarie University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In recent years, as the refugee intake increased in many industrialised countries, refugees’ labour market participation gained political and policy significance.  Yet ‘refugee employment support’ does not exist as a well-defined policy field. Rather, supporting refugees’ labour market participation is at the confluence of labour market policies and immigrant settlement policies, two fields whose structure and objectives can significantly differ. In federal countries, the governance of both labour market and immigrant settlement policies is multileveled. Delivering refugee employment support is complex as it involves a great array of public, not-for-profit and for-profit agencies often competing for resources. A greater understanding of ‘refugee employment support’ can thus contribute to our understanding of dynamics of policy competition and collaboration, and of opportunities and challenges for the development of network and knowledge-sharing, in salient policy areas.

 

To this end, my paper compares the political and organisational setting of refugee employment support in three federal states: Australia, Canada and Belgium, with a focus on the subnational level, namely the Canadian Province of Quebec, the Belgian Region of Brussels and the Australian State of New South Wales. Whereas Australia and Canada are frequently compared as ‘most similar’ federal settler states, Belgium and Canada are both bilingual states with strong subnational policy cultures. At the subnational level, state-led and municipal mobilisation to foster refugees’ labour market participation has been particularly strong in New South Wales. Thus this comparison can reveal unexplored similarities and differences among federal countries and help reflect upon what Canadian and Belgian jurisdictions could learn from the subnational Australian experience.

 

Empirically, my paper relies on documentary analysis as well as more than sixty semi-structured interviews conducted with subnational government authorities, employment service providers and labour-market active refugees in Quebec, Brussels and New South Wales between 2015 and 2018. Interviews aimed to identify how participants work together, and with national government authorities, to locally support refugee employment, and to gauge the impact of budgetary and organisational constraints on policy collaboration.

 

The paper shows that political mobilisation and policy innovation currently distinguish New South Wales, which at first sight may appear as a model for the two other cases and for other subnational jurisdictions in Australia and beyond. However, the sustainability of New South Wales’ innovation and collaboration – and thus the establishment of refugee employment support as a policy field - is jeopardised by the current structure of service delivery as well as the resurging political salience of immigrant and refugee settlement.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - Self-determination and participation of indigenous minorities in theory and practice: Drawing lessons from New Zealand and Australia
Diana Perche (University of New South Wales, Sydney)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The inclusion of minorities in liberal democracies is a perennial challenge, particularly with respect to their effective participation in the policy process. International and local debates around the place of indigenous peoples in democratic systems have focused on self-determination as a means of protecting minority rights and allowing for some degree of autonomy and self-governance, though these remain highly contested in both theory and practice. Following the adoption of the United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) by 144 countries in 2007, many nations are working to implement the principles of self-determination. In doing so, many nations are forced to confront their own histories of racial discrimination and oppression, and consider adaptation of their existing institutions and processes.
 
Australia and New Zealand are both liberal democracies with strong parliamentary systems and well established independent public services. Both nations have historically articulated strong support for indigenous self-determination, yet were notably reluctant signatories to the UNDRIP, initially voting against the Declaration alongside Canada and the United States. The political unease around UNDRIP reflects a social and cultural divisions in both nations around their colonial history and ongoing experiences of racial tension and discrimination. These nations share a very similar history of British colonisation and dispossession of the First Nations but are distinct in the ways in which they have established political and legal relationships with First Nations, in particular because New Zealand has used the historical signing of the Treaty of Waitangi as the basis of continuing negotiations and accountability around Maori sharing of power, along with dedicated Maori seats in parliament. With no such historical basis for power sharing in Australia, current debates continue to call for constitutional change, political recognition of First Nations in the form of a treaty, and the establishing of a body which can provide a First Nations voice to parliament, as articulated in the Uluru Statement from the Heart.
 
The comparison of New Zealand and Australia with respect to present day participation in policy decision making allows us to consider divergent models of self-determination and accommodation of minority interests at the centre of political power, particularly with respect to the development of community-controlled organisations engaging in service delivery, and representative bodies participating in policy formulation. The paper will outline the broad policy trajectory of each government’s acceptance of principles of self-determination and examine the practical application of self-determination principles in the policy area of health care, through the Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisations in Australia and the more recent development of Whanau Ora in New Zealand. The paper will seek to uncover the practical policy implications of a self-determination approach and consider how autonomy is supported or undermined through funding mechanisms, monitoring and reporting requirements, local governance structures, and integration into the “mainstream” population’s systems of service delivery. These questions can provide the basis of constructive comparisons with other countries also working on improving the participation of ethnic minorities in government and policy decision making, particularly in the Asia-Pacific region.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Child support in Australia, New Zealand, the UK and the USA: Rhetorical and policy divergences within liberal regimes
Kay Cook (Swinburne University of Technology)
CO-AUTHORS
Michael Fletcher
Christine Skinner
Daniel Meyer (University of Wisconsin - Madison)
ABSTRACT

Child support (money from one parent to the other to support children following relationship dissolution) is a contentious policy in many countries. Many non-resident parents feel they are being ordered to pay unreasonably high amounts, while many resident parents feel that payments are unreasonably low. These tensions may be because it is unclear whether the purpose of child support is to enforce parental responsibility, prevent poverty, or limit government benefit expenditures. Examining the logic governments use to discuss policy can: reveal the purpose of the scheme; expose inconsistencies between government rhetoric and how the system works for families; and lead to policy change. We examine the child support logics espoused by four seemingly similar countries: USA, UK, Australia and New Zealand to reveal how each country conceptualises child support, the logics that exist within and across countries, and how rhetoric compares to the policy reality. To examine the framing of child support, we retrieved the most recent, publicly available government documents from each country and entered them into the software program, ‘Wmatrix’. Using this program, we compared the rhetorical devices used in each country’s corpus of texts to provide instances where the rhetoric was either largely consistent or dissimilar across the four countries. We then interpreted these discourses given the unique policy settings that exist in each country. The four countries share similar policy origins, and initially all highlighted child support’s role in lessening poverty. However, the four countries diverge considerably with respect to their policy goal, as revealed by the way child support interacts with welfare benefits, and the current focus of their policy rhetoric. For example, in New Zealand, all child support payments are retained by the state if the resident parent is a benefit recipient, limiting the effect on poverty. Conversely, the UK has little role in determining obligation amounts (beyond offering guidance) and plays almost no role in transferring payments or in enforcing payments, unless parents choose to opt-in and pay fees for collection and enforcement services. However, and all money received is retained by the recipient. Australia typically assumes full child support compliance irrespective of payment reality, which reduces government benefit outlays and resident parents’ incomes. Finally, while US states set policy for how much support benefit recipients can keep, states are being encouraged to lower obligations for low-income non-resident parents. The way that each country discussed child support illustrated two important underpinning concepts: how child support debts were treated, and who these debts were owed to. Given the differences in program funding and state claw-back of payments, the four countries place very different emphases on the collection and enforcement of payments, and only vigorously pursued these when it buttressed state interests – despite compelling parents to seek payments in Australia, the US and New Zealand. Our analysis shows that the rhetoric justifying child support policy is relatively similar across these countries; however, the policies have important differences that mean that these four countries cannot be considered as homogenous examples of the liberal welfare state regime-type and illustrates the utility of comparing within-type countries to tease out differences in underlying logics.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

A book series, the ‘International Library of Policy Analysis’ has recently been launched to promote ‘international dialogue in the area of policy analysis’ through a succession of country studies.  It was not planned to be a ‘world series’, but was built from a volume on policy analysis in Canada, which then served as a template for the subsequent volumes.  Fourteen volumes have now appeared, mostly from what Jared Diamond would call WEIRD societies (Western, Educated, Industrial, Rich and Democratic). 

This paper addresses the aspirations of this series, and the way in which they have been applied to produce a volume on policy analysis in Australia (Head, B, and Crowley, K. (eds) Policy Analysis in Australia).  It examines the concepts and assumptions that underlie the focus on policy analysis, and the way in which the Canadian template has been applied to give an account of policy analysis in Australia.  It discusses the ways in which this approach draws on, or adds to, what is already know about policy practice in Australia, and explores the contribution which the series makes to ‘promoting international dialogue’ in policy studies and developing comparative method.

CO-AUTHORS
Malcolm Bird (University of Winnipeg)
ABSTRACT

Our paper sets out to compare and contrast the use of state-owned enterprise (SOEs) as a policy instrument in Canada and Australia. While privatizations have occurred in both countries, there are considerable differences in levels of enthusiasm for and the number of firms turned over to the private sector. Very generally, Australia and its sub-national units have embraced privatization with considerably more gusto than their Canadian federal and provincial counterparts. Canadian “Crown corporations” continue to play a significant role in the country’s economy in general, including substantial roles in electricity generation, alcohol distribution and gaming, among others. While Canada and Australia share similar colonial historical legacies, a Westminster-style political system, and are both dependent on resource-extractive industries, among other congruencies, they differ considerably in their treatment of SOEs. While studies on state-owned enterprise in Canada are more limited than in the Australian context, it appears that the use of SOEs in Canada is more strategic and interventionist in character, with Canadian governments more eager to use them as a tool for achieving policy objectives and only willing to privatize when they are left with few other choices to resolve an ongoing problem. In contrast, Australian governments are quicker to put privatization on the agenda, representing a wholesale ideological shift to reduce the role and scope of the state’s intervention in the marketplace. Using information from annual reports and documents obtained through Freedom of Information requests, we set out to draw out these differences in treatment of SOEs and to use it to explore decision-making processes within these respective governments.

 

CO-AUTHORS
John Phillimore (Curtin University)
Alan Tapper (Curtin University)
ABSTRACT

Australia seems to have performed very well by a number of economic and social indicators over the past quarter of a century.  This paper examines that performance in comparative perspective and explores the institutional factors and policy decisions that may have contributed. To what extent must the distinctiveness be still seen as an Australasian phenomenon rather than just and Australian one?  Where does Australia sit vis-à-vis the so-called ‘anglosphere’?  How does Australia compare with the OECD in general?  A long scholarly tradition sees Australia as having had a distinctive welfare state, but a number of critics have pointed to its dismantling.  Is the AWS still distinctive, and, to the extent it is, has that played a role in Australia’s performance?

CO-AUTHORS
Nooshin Torabi
Florence Damiens (ICON group, Center for Urban Research, RMIT University)
Erik Hysing (Örebro University)
ABSTRACT

The decline of biodiversity can have profound economic, social and environmental consequences which diminish the total quality of the web of life on planet earth. In response, under the context of the UN Convention on Biological Diversity, governments around the world have developed national biodiversity strategies as a means for demonstrating their commitment, and approach, to the conservation of biodiversity within their specific national contexts. Given the UN’s commitments on biodiversity and that Australia has a draft biodiversity strategy in development, it is timely to investigate the strengths and weaknesses of different approaches to the development and implementation of national strategies for the conservation of biodiversity. In addition, the disruptions association with the emergence of the Anthropocene create further significant challenges for the conservation of biodiversity now and into the future. Informed by a policy studies perspective, we compare existing biodiversity strategies in Australia and Sweden. Sweden and Australia provide a fertile ground for comparison on the basis that both are wealthy countries with sufficient resources to manage the threats to biodiversity within their borders while generally classified within different policy traditions (neo-liberalism and neo-corporatism) and with different governance system (federal and unitary state). We explore how biodiversity is conceptualised in each strategy, and the implications this has for how it is governed. We also reflect on how well the two national strategies respond to the challenges for biodiversity conservation that are associated with the Anthropocene.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Introduction:

National Systems of Innovation (NSIs) have become ubiquitous throughout the OECD, and increasingly in non-OECD countries. Each NSI is informed by, and subject to, the local policy, political, and commercial environment, to name but a few factors (Borowiecki & Paunov, 2018). Although scholars warn that an innovation policy mechanism that may be successful in one jurisdiction may not work in another (Izsák, et al, 2013), nonetheless there may be lessons to draw for Australia and Scotland – and wider - by a comparative evaluation of elements of their NSI programs.

 

Research questions:

How can Scotland’s ‘Interface’ program, and the Australian CRC-P program, inform the policy mixes for each country? What differences exist that could be beneficial and transferable between countries, and what might be some of the challenges? What can other jurisdictions learn from these models?

 

Methodology:

Two research projects in 2018 interviewed participants in the Scottish ‘Interface’ program, and in the Australian CRC-P program. A qualitative approach was employed using the NSI framework. Transcripts were thematically analysed, with emergent themes from each jurisdiction cross-referenced and compared.

 

Findings:

In each program, similar issues arose to do with IP management, partnership agreements, difficulties universities experience in responding to the dynamism of the commercial world, and the formative nature of the programs for the SME community. However, differences such as how SMEs discover and access an appropriate research partner, governance requirements for each program, the quantum of the available grants, and the application process, are highlighted in the research.

 

Fit with research panel questions:

Australia and Scotland, while different in many respects, also have similarities that go beyond a shared language. These include a modern research environment, a desire for economic growth, and governments that are focussed on achieving this growth through NSIs. The choice of the two NSI programs in this research provides scope for each country to discover potentially beneficial policy changes. There is the opportunity for Australia to learn from the ‘concierge’ nature of the Scottish program, and Scotland to learn from the highly targeted CRC-P program, designed to drive academia and SMEs closer together.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The debate on the use, non-use and abuse of science in regulatory policy is as old as the field of regulation. But there have been few attempts to link the different usages to specific policy instruments. In this paper I focus on a policy instrument called impact assessment (IA). IA is now a common tool for policy appraisal in all OECD countries including Australia as well as at European Union level. Its thrust is to analyse the likely effects of primary and delegated legislation. This analysis revolves around a definition of the problem to be regulated, an appraisal of the status quo and its likely evolution, consultation, an (ideally) monetised analysis of the effects of a range of feasible alternatives that address the identified problem, and an indication of the preferred policy option. The three-fold characterisation of ‘impacts’ typical for many IA systems – economic, social and environmental – suggests that policy makers cast their net widely when it comes to the search for scientific knowledge, covering both the social and the natural sciences as well as a range of other sources to inform IA. But is this the case, and how do we know? I have taken a statistically representative sample of IAs in three jurisdictions, Australia, New Zealand and the European Union, published between 2008 and 2018, stratified by year and department/agency (in the EU the correct term would be ‘Directorate Generale’). This represents roughly 25 per cent of the total number of IAs supporting legislation and regulations, covering policy areas as diverse as health and safety, environment, media and communications. I then code the type of scientific and non-scientific evidence mentioned in the references of the document to explore four competing theoretical approaches: First, IAs as tools to bring scientific envidence into the policy-making process, either to learn from science or in order to appeal to a target community – resulting in a high number of scientific references. Second, IAs operate in a specific legal context and bring together various strands of the bureaucracy – resulting in a high number of references to legal acts, policy documents, and court cases. Third, IAs reflect policy initiatives that respond to or anticipate the concerns of their core audiences, i.e. interest groups – resulting in a high number of references to statements made and documents published by stakeholders. Fourth, one could assume that policy makers prepare IAs for symbolic reasons, with no specific concerns as to the impact of IA on regulation. The observable implication is that we should find no specific citation pattern. IAs then may contain very few or too many references – this should be erratic, because in the end the use of science or legal acts or anything else would be just decorative and perfunctory. The conclusions contribute to the literature on regulatory policy and the usages of science in government.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

ABSTRACT

 

Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is integral to regional integration and attracted increasing attention in the wake of significant reductions in trade barriers over the last half century. This has been the case in the development of relations between Australia and New Zealand under Closer Economic Relations (CER) or more formally ANZCERTA, The Australia - New Zealand Closer Economic Relations Trade Agreement, signed in 1983. After protracted negotiations The Protocol on Investment to CER was signed in 2011 and enacted in 2013.  

 

Similar institutions and a range of deeply shared social norms have underpinned a long period of trans-Tasman integration; however, differences in institutions and social norms may also configure and constrain further and more rapid integration. Integration requires changes in the institutional, administrative, legal and political fields. However, unlike other regional groupings such as the European Union explicit aspirations for such non-economic integration have been noticeably absent from this regional relationship. Whilst trade liberalisation has been achieved under ANZCERTA, deep integration goes beyond the concentration upon strictly economic policy related to factors such as border trade barriers, differences in regulatory regimes, technical regulations, and different exchange rates.

 

Adopting a cross-disciplinary approach this paper employs theories from institutionalist approaches to political science, economics, political economy and international business to examine the regulatory frameworks for FDI in Australia and New Zealand. In particular, the methodology used explores a series of natural experiments which have posed challenges to the operation of the agreement. That is, greater integration regularly faces external shocks which test extant regulatory practice.  By examining the effects of three crises - globalisation, the global financial crisis and food security - experienced on both sides of the Tasman, we identify tensions between norms and trans-Tasman governance. From this experience we draw inferences to aid understanding of extant and emerging norms and subsequent impediments to integration applicable to both regional and global contexts. Theories employed in the paper such as historical institutionalism and sociological institutionalism inform the explanation of the role institutions play in both political and economic paths to integration within a regional grouping.

 

 

 

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In recent years, as the refugee intake increased in many industrialised countries, refugees’ labour market participation gained political and policy significance.  Yet ‘refugee employment support’ does not exist as a well-defined policy field. Rather, supporting refugees’ labour market participation is at the confluence of labour market policies and immigrant settlement policies, two fields whose structure and objectives can significantly differ. In federal countries, the governance of both labour market and immigrant settlement policies is multileveled. Delivering refugee employment support is complex as it involves a great array of public, not-for-profit and for-profit agencies often competing for resources. A greater understanding of ‘refugee employment support’ can thus contribute to our understanding of dynamics of policy competition and collaboration, and of opportunities and challenges for the development of network and knowledge-sharing, in salient policy areas.

 

To this end, my paper compares the political and organisational setting of refugee employment support in three federal states: Australia, Canada and Belgium, with a focus on the subnational level, namely the Canadian Province of Quebec, the Belgian Region of Brussels and the Australian State of New South Wales. Whereas Australia and Canada are frequently compared as ‘most similar’ federal settler states, Belgium and Canada are both bilingual states with strong subnational policy cultures. At the subnational level, state-led and municipal mobilisation to foster refugees’ labour market participation has been particularly strong in New South Wales. Thus this comparison can reveal unexplored similarities and differences among federal countries and help reflect upon what Canadian and Belgian jurisdictions could learn from the subnational Australian experience.

 

Empirically, my paper relies on documentary analysis as well as more than sixty semi-structured interviews conducted with subnational government authorities, employment service providers and labour-market active refugees in Quebec, Brussels and New South Wales between 2015 and 2018. Interviews aimed to identify how participants work together, and with national government authorities, to locally support refugee employment, and to gauge the impact of budgetary and organisational constraints on policy collaboration.

 

The paper shows that political mobilisation and policy innovation currently distinguish New South Wales, which at first sight may appear as a model for the two other cases and for other subnational jurisdictions in Australia and beyond. However, the sustainability of New South Wales’ innovation and collaboration – and thus the establishment of refugee employment support as a policy field - is jeopardised by the current structure of service delivery as well as the resurging political salience of immigrant and refugee settlement.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

The inclusion of minorities in liberal democracies is a perennial challenge, particularly with respect to their effective participation in the policy process. International and local debates around the place of indigenous peoples in democratic systems have focused on self-determination as a means of protecting minority rights and allowing for some degree of autonomy and self-governance, though these remain highly contested in both theory and practice. Following the adoption of the United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) by 144 countries in 2007, many nations are working to implement the principles of self-determination. In doing so, many nations are forced to confront their own histories of racial discrimination and oppression, and consider adaptation of their existing institutions and processes.
 
Australia and New Zealand are both liberal democracies with strong parliamentary systems and well established independent public services. Both nations have historically articulated strong support for indigenous self-determination, yet were notably reluctant signatories to the UNDRIP, initially voting against the Declaration alongside Canada and the United States. The political unease around UNDRIP reflects a social and cultural divisions in both nations around their colonial history and ongoing experiences of racial tension and discrimination. These nations share a very similar history of British colonisation and dispossession of the First Nations but are distinct in the ways in which they have established political and legal relationships with First Nations, in particular because New Zealand has used the historical signing of the Treaty of Waitangi as the basis of continuing negotiations and accountability around Maori sharing of power, along with dedicated Maori seats in parliament. With no such historical basis for power sharing in Australia, current debates continue to call for constitutional change, political recognition of First Nations in the form of a treaty, and the establishing of a body which can provide a First Nations voice to parliament, as articulated in the Uluru Statement from the Heart.
 
The comparison of New Zealand and Australia with respect to present day participation in policy decision making allows us to consider divergent models of self-determination and accommodation of minority interests at the centre of political power, particularly with respect to the development of community-controlled organisations engaging in service delivery, and representative bodies participating in policy formulation. The paper will outline the broad policy trajectory of each government’s acceptance of principles of self-determination and examine the practical application of self-determination principles in the policy area of health care, through the Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisations in Australia and the more recent development of Whanau Ora in New Zealand. The paper will seek to uncover the practical policy implications of a self-determination approach and consider how autonomy is supported or undermined through funding mechanisms, monitoring and reporting requirements, local governance structures, and integration into the “mainstream” population’s systems of service delivery. These questions can provide the basis of constructive comparisons with other countries also working on improving the participation of ethnic minorities in government and policy decision making, particularly in the Asia-Pacific region.

CO-AUTHORS
Michael Fletcher
Christine Skinner
Daniel Meyer (University of Wisconsin - Madison)
ABSTRACT

Child support (money from one parent to the other to support children following relationship dissolution) is a contentious policy in many countries. Many non-resident parents feel they are being ordered to pay unreasonably high amounts, while many resident parents feel that payments are unreasonably low. These tensions may be because it is unclear whether the purpose of child support is to enforce parental responsibility, prevent poverty, or limit government benefit expenditures. Examining the logic governments use to discuss policy can: reveal the purpose of the scheme; expose inconsistencies between government rhetoric and how the system works for families; and lead to policy change. We examine the child support logics espoused by four seemingly similar countries: USA, UK, Australia and New Zealand to reveal how each country conceptualises child support, the logics that exist within and across countries, and how rhetoric compares to the policy reality. To examine the framing of child support, we retrieved the most recent, publicly available government documents from each country and entered them into the software program, ‘Wmatrix’. Using this program, we compared the rhetorical devices used in each country’s corpus of texts to provide instances where the rhetoric was either largely consistent or dissimilar across the four countries. We then interpreted these discourses given the unique policy settings that exist in each country. The four countries share similar policy origins, and initially all highlighted child support’s role in lessening poverty. However, the four countries diverge considerably with respect to their policy goal, as revealed by the way child support interacts with welfare benefits, and the current focus of their policy rhetoric. For example, in New Zealand, all child support payments are retained by the state if the resident parent is a benefit recipient, limiting the effect on poverty. Conversely, the UK has little role in determining obligation amounts (beyond offering guidance) and plays almost no role in transferring payments or in enforcing payments, unless parents choose to opt-in and pay fees for collection and enforcement services. However, and all money received is retained by the recipient. Australia typically assumes full child support compliance irrespective of payment reality, which reduces government benefit outlays and resident parents’ incomes. Finally, while US states set policy for how much support benefit recipients can keep, states are being encouraged to lower obligations for low-income non-resident parents. The way that each country discussed child support illustrated two important underpinning concepts: how child support debts were treated, and who these debts were owed to. Given the differences in program funding and state claw-back of payments, the four countries place very different emphases on the collection and enforcement of payments, and only vigorously pursued these when it buttressed state interests – despite compelling parents to seek payments in Australia, the US and New Zealand. Our analysis shows that the rhetoric justifying child support policy is relatively similar across these countries; however, the policies have important differences that mean that these four countries cannot be considered as homogenous examples of the liberal welfare state regime-type and illustrates the utility of comparing within-type countries to tease out differences in underlying logics.