Format

P08. Problem-Solving and Learning in Multilevel Governance

COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Eva Thomann
University of Exeter
Main chair
Claire Dunlop
University of Exeter
Second chair
CATEGORISATION
POLICY TOPIC
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
SECTOR
—
KEYWORDS
—
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE

Multilevel governance is the result of a process in which decision makers shifted competencies away from the nation-state in order to deal with pressing policy challenges that exceed the reach of the central government. As such, multilevel governance is a result of globalization and modernization, based on the assumption of an improved problem-solving capacity. Problem-solving can both be seen as a decision-making mode/process, and as a result of these processes. Trein et al. (2019) define problem-solving as a process through which the policymakers in charge make policies so as to deal with problems that are perceived as important for society by organized groups and/or by policymakers themselves, through the cooperative production of a policy output that is expected to be collectively beneficial in making a contribution to solve the policy problem at stake. The goal of this panel is to collect contributions that provide theoretical and empirical insights on problem-solving in multilevel governance.

 

Recent years have witnessed important theoretical, conceptual and empirical innovations in how we think of problem-solving in multilevel governance. Scholars have moved beyond traditional approaches to thinking of multilevel governance mainly in structural terms and through a command-and-control perspective, as these often cannot explain the distinct workings of multilevel governance in the absence of a clear “shadow of hierarchy”. Moreover, there is a move beyond the assumption that policy adoption is the decisive stage of problem-solving. Instead, there is emphasis on the processes of implementation, evaluation, and problem definition, the patterns and underlying mechanisms of differentiation as well convergence. Scholars increasingly emphasize mechanisms of learning (Dunlop et al. 2018) and experimentalist governance (Sabel and Zeiltin 2010) and link such mechanisms with patterns of policy differentiation (e.g., customization), success, and failure (Dunlop 2017; Thomannn 2019).

  

References

Dunlop, C. A. (2017). Policy learning and policy failure: Definitions, dimensions and intersections. Policy & Politics, 45(1), 3-18.

Dunlop, C. A., Radaelli, C. M., & Trein, P. (Eds.). (2018). Learning in Public Policy: Analysis, Modes and Outcomes. Springer.

Sabel, C. F., & Zeitlin, J. (Eds.). (2010). Experimentalist governance in the European Union: towards a new architecture. Oxford University Press on Demand.

Trein, P., Thomann, E. & M. Maggetti (2019). Integration, functional differentiation and problem-solving in multilevel governance: a comparative perspective. Symposium in Public Administration.

Thomann, E. (2019). Customized implementation of European Union food safety policy: United in diversity? Palgrave Macmillan, International Series on Public Policy.

 

CALL FOR PAPERS

This panel gathers theoretical, conceptual, and empirical contributions by both junior and senior scholars that look at the processes and outcomes of problem-solving and learning in multilevel governance systems in terms of both convergence and differentiation. We particularly invite contributions that either comprehensively review or systematize the state of the art, apply theoretical, conceptual or methodological innovations to empirical settings,  connect methods with theories, and/or contribute to innovation themselves.

 

Preference is given to papers that:

  • apply or contribute to the recent theoretical state of the art
  • are theoretically, conceptually or empirically innovative
  • adopt a comparative logic/ identify regularities beyond a single case
  • connect different stages or outcomes of the policy process with each other (beyond policymaking)
  • consider the interplay of political, administrative, and societal actors or of different levels of governance
  • give insight into the functioning of multilevel governance (e.g., European integration) in times of crisis

 

Abstracts should include a clear puzzle, research question, and an outline of the approach, research design and main contribution of the proposed paper. Preference is given to abstracts that demonstrate an understanding of recent theoretical and conceptual developments.

 

 

ACCEPTED
Format
01 - How to use evidence to identify, learn from, and transfer policy success
Paul Cairney (University of Stirling)
CO-AUTHORS
Emily St Denny (Nottingham Trent University)
ABSTRACT

This paper combines theory and practice to describe practical ways to use academic insights to encourage policy learning across multi-level systems. The focus is the EU-funded IMAJINE project to reduce territorial inequalities across Europe. Our overall aim is to identify, analyse, learn from, and help transfer policies that have reduced territorial inequalities. Our first objective is to research and share lessons from the governments who project policy success in reducing inequalities in areas such as education attainment, drug-related punishment, and income. However, policy theories prompt us to manage our expectations about learning. They explain the relationship between (a) politics, (b) complex policymaking systems, and (c) the lack of ‘evidence-based’ policymaking, learning, and transfer. It is not feasible to propose a simple evidence-based model for learning, or seek to transfer policy solutions from one region to another without considering their political and policymaking contexts. Our second objective is to use our knowledge of policy processes to help produce pragmatic and innovative ways to foster the systematic use of evidence in policy transfer. Our third objective is to make sure that we have sufficient knowledge of our audience to make an impact with this study. We will (a) produce evidence on the technical feasibility of policy solutions, and (b) investigate the ways in which potential importing governments determine their political feasibility. We use an iterative process, to identify and generate initial attention for success stories, identify how the case study government defined the policy problem, work with actors in other systems to understand how they would interpret and use the evidence, and use this knowledge to inform our research.

ACCEPTED
Format
02 - Red tape or problem-solving? Customisation and practical compliance with EU policies
Eva Thomann (University of Exeter)
CO-AUTHORS
Asya Zhelyazkova (ETH Zurich)
ABSTRACT

European Union (EU) policies change as they are being customised throughout the implementation chain. How do these changes affect the practical implementation of EU policies? While better regulation approaches point to the danger of red tape when deviating from EU law, theories of policy implementation see a role of discretion in decentralised problem-solving. This study analyses how customisation affects the practical compliance with EU antidiscrimination, environmental, and justice and home affairs directives in 27 member states. Results suggest that general customisation levels neither exert a significant direct nor conditional effect on practical compliance. However, higher levels of customised density negatively affect practical compliance. We also find a partly sector-specific, direct positive effect of customised restrictiveness on practical compliance. Thus, while customised density can indeed reinforce problems of red tape, customised restrictiveness can contribute to problem-solving. The crucial distinction is that between changes in the quantity or the quality of regulation.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
03 - Engines of learning? Policy instruments, cities and climate governance
Ekaterina Domorenok (University of Padua)
CO-AUTHORS
Anthony Zito (University of Newcastle-upon-Tyne)
ABSTRACT

Although a great variety of learning-oriented policy instruments has been promoted across EU public policies increasingly over the last decade, little knowledge still exists about how socialization, emulation and reflexivity matter for policy convergence in the EU (Holzinger and Knill, 2008; Zito and Schout 2009) and the extent of exploitation of specific learning oriented policy tools (Radaelli, 2008; Dunlop and Radaelli 2012). Most of empirical research in this field has focused on the implementation of the so-called Open Method of Coordination (OMC) (Borras and Jacobsson, 2004), while only a few studies have adopted a different perspective, conceiving learning in terms of change and adaptation of policy instruments (Wurzel et al. 2013); policy diffusion and transfer (Jordan et al. 2015; Musialkowska, Dabrowski and Polverari 2014) or political learning (Graziano et al. 2011). Yet, efforts to investigate systematically the impact and limits of both individual instruments and instrument packages, with respect to wider policy and institutional change, have been scarce, regardless of concerns expressed about insufficient impact of such instruments on policy outcomes (Radaelli, 2008).

New challenges for both academic researchers and policy assessors arise as more recent network-type modes of governance based on mutual coordination and learning have targeted not only central governments but also sub-state authorities and non-state actors. EU Commission DGs and Executive Agencies have often been directly involved into these networks, providing coordination or support functions.

Drawing on existing scholarship on policy learning and change in the EU, this paper sets out to explore the overall learning effects of the EU Covenant of Mayors (CoM) programme since its inception until the present.  The EU Commission launched this programme in 2008 with the objective of enhancing and supporting the coordinated action of local authorities for sustainable energy and climate. Building on an original analytical framework, the research aims to understand (i) to what extent local authorities have exploited the learning tools embedded in the programme, (ii) how the methodological and expert knowledge diffused through the programme shaped local policy agendas and settings, and (iii) whether there has been a learning effect for the EU Commission itself.  The theoretical approach provides analytical tools for understanding how instrument design, selection and application bridge and influence the political motivations of actors and the policy processes.

This research stems from the research project ‘Research Project Climate change policies and governance. The experience of EU voluntary instruments’ (BIRD165757) financed by the University of Padova during 2017 – 2018. In addition to the empirical material collected through desk-research, interviews and a survey administered in four EU countries (Italy, Germany, Poland and United Kingdom), this paper utilises wider quantitative data covering the entire CoM membership.

ACCEPTED
Format
04 - Power Dynamics in Multisector and Multilevel Coordination: the case of Antimicrobial Resistance (AMR)
Martin Stangborli Time (University of Agder)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Emphasis on power dynamics in society is frequently held to be a common denominator of the multi-faceted discipline that is political science. Nonetheless, scholars writing from a neo-institutionalist tradition increasingly point to a lack of systematic and explicit treatment of power in contemporary research (Morriss 2002; Clegg et al. 2006; Göhler 2009; Munir 2015; Dowding 2008, 2012; Lawrence and Buchanan 2017).

 

In this paper I address the following research question: what is the added value to studies of political-administrative coordination processes from treating power dynamics explicitly?

 

The main argument is that power dynamics are fundamental conditioners for how processes of political and administrative coordination progress (and possibly stagnate). Furthermore, I argue that the composite and diverse nature of power is yet to be wholly appreciated by students of coordination. The larger share of power conceptualizations has some resemblance with Dahl’s (1957: 82) classical conception “[involving] a successful attempt by A to get a to do something he would not otherwise do”. Such an understanding of power dynamics is usually referred to as power “over” (Lukes 2005: 12; Pansardi 2011). However, scholars have come to emphasise an additional power dynamic; the power “to” or the ability to act autonomously (Pitkin 1972; Morriss 2002; Dowding 1996, 2008; Göhler 2009). This paper suggests that a power “over” vs. power “to” framework can yield new insights on the conditioners of coordination processes. It aspires to contribute to, on the one hand, the literature on coordination in multilevel settings, and, on the other, the literature on translation processes whereby actors, via editing, come to rationalize their behaviours (Sahlin-Andersson 1996; Höllerer et al. 2017; Wedlin and Sahlin 2017).

 

To illustrate the utility of a power dynamics framework, I make use of anecdotal, qualitative, data from a “typical” case (Seawright and Gerring 2008: 299) of global challenges to society; Antimicrobial Resistance (AMR). Challenges such as AMR and climate change respect neither jurisdictional nor sectorial boundaries, as such they are inherently transcendental (Drori et al. 2014; Höllerer et al. 2017). The global response to AMR thus rests on the advocacy of cross-border, “whole of society” coordination (c.f. WHO 2015). AMR governance involves at minimum the animal-/food safety and human medicine sectors, and multiple levels of jurisdiction (due to the ease with which resistant microbes are spreading). Transcendence arguably makes effective coordination more challenging. Firstly, to contain the resistant microbes requires some level of concerted action by a considerable number of, often diverse, organizations. Secondly, power dynamics come into play via the interactions between actors from various organizational fields. AMR governance thus ought to be a promising ground for enquiry into the power dynamics in coordination. The paper focuses particularly on AMR problem-solving within the European Union (EU)/European Economic Area (EEA). This is due to the difference in competence allocation between the EU- and Member State-level on animal-/food safety and human medicine respectively. The data material is constituted by a series of elite-interviews plus policy documents and secondary literature.

ACCEPTED
Format
05 - Contextualizing Institutional Reforms in Developing Countries: A Study on the Introduction of the Management Performance Assessment Tool (MPAT) in Uganda and South Africa
Aisha Jore Ali (University of Oxford)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Institutional reforms are ubiquitously applied in developing countries to improve government capabilities (Andrews, Pritchett, & Woolcock, 2012). However, evidence indicates that efforts to curb anti-corruption in Malawi, strengthen the justice sector in South Sudan, or support decentralization programmes in Uganda, consistently failed to address reform objectives (Doig, Watt, & Williams, 2005). The investment in institutional reforms globally and their dismal performance have elicited numerous explanations by development experts and academics with examples ranging from challenging contexts to lack of political will. However, none of these reasons seems to offer specific answers to why reforms in developing contexts continue to fail  (Evans, Peter; Rauch, 1999; Grindle, 2007). An explanation advanced by Matt Andrews and others seems to go further to provide an alternative model to introducing reforms that is a departure from approaches currently being applied. Andrews (2014) proposes an alternative model called Problem-Driven Iterative Adaptation (PDIA) which is argued to produce best practice reforms in developing countries if they are crafted as a response to locally identified problems, undertaken in an iterative fashion through experimentation and learning, involving multiple agents and producing hybrid solutions that are locally owned, understood and implemented. In developing countries, meeting challenges to development are largely dependent on the effectiveness of the state to undertake its core functions. Strengthening institutional capability and performance of the state to deliver these functions becomes of paramount interest to reform suppliers however if the reforms are not addressing locally relevant problems, and have little political traction then evidence suggests that the recipient countries will adapt these reforms only in the spirit of compliance leading to less than satisfactory changes in the conditions set out to be addressed (Andrews et al., 2012). This paper uses new institutional theory and an interdisciplinary approach derived from the fields of political science, sociology and management to understand the introduction of key institutional reforms (Management Performance Assessment Tool -MPAT) related to improving public sector performance in Uganda and South Africa. These country environments contend with structurally limiting conditions, consequences of a series of state failures for instance apartheid in South Africa and conflict in Uganda (Alam et al., 2016; Andrews and Bategeka., 2013) and more recently, their governments have struggled with underperforming economies and governance challenges. Using an institutional ethnography research design, the paper explores ideas emerging from institutional economics covering concepts of institutional logics, institutional entrepreneurship, isomorphism and decoupling. at the introduction stage of the MPAT in each country. Findings from this paper provides insights on the conditions under which reforms are introduced, how different agents were engaged in the process and what the implications are for future value of the reform.

ACCEPTED
Format
06 - Problem-solving and social learning in transnational spatial planning processes: the ‘V4+2’ collaboration process on spatial development
Stefanie Dühr (University of South Australia)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Spatial planning approaches have evolved historically and reflect political traditions and institutional arrangements. In transboundary planning processes aimed at joint policy and action, social learning can be a useful governance mechanism to develop shared understanding about spatial trends that stretch across administrative boundaries and for supporting collective action. In this article, we apply a social learning perspective to a recent transnational spatial planning process by the ‘Visegrad 4’ (Poland, Hungary, Czech Republic and Slovakia) with Bulgaria and Romania (V4+2). We analyse the problem-solving and social learning effects of the V4+2 initiative between 2008 and 2014 as part of an on-going political process. Using in-depth interviews, document analysis and participant observation, this allows a discussion about how the cooperation agendas evolved and were shaped by the political context and timelines, how problems were framed and addressed, and about the instrumental, communicative and social learning effects that were achieved in the collaboration to date. The research also offers recommendations for other transnational spatial planning processes in relation to the role of political goals for providing the structural context and the importance of process management in collaborative arrangements for fostering problem-solving social learning.

 

ACCEPTED
Format
07 - From innovation policy to policy innovation: a matter of learning?
Giulia Bazzan (Tilburg University)
CO-AUTHORS
Maria Stella Righettini (University of Padova )
ABSTRACT

Academic literature has recently shown much interest in socio-technical systems and policy innovation, and debates about innovation give much attention to renewable energy options, and possible policy measures to stimulate them (Vernong and Geels, 2007). Literature suggests that a socio-technical system implies a transition from RTD to innovation policies, not just as important sectoral arenas of action in themselves, but as instruments towards new wide ranging policy objectives that integrate the user side with the scientific development side (Geels, 2004).

The renewable energy has been treated as a socio-technical issue that is worthy of exploration, and in recent years many scholars have undertaken empirical studies. The conception of socio-technical systems is frequently used to study this issue (Verbong and Geels, 2007), by adopting a bottom up and user approaches and a multi-level perspective. However, empirical contributions that investigate how in governance modes technical innovation is combined with users learning (both industries and domestic users) to increase governmental learning are still lacking. Likewise, investigations on how policy-makers try to draw lessons from technical innovation in renewable energy policies and how they activate mechanism to increase users collective learning need to be further explored (Dunlop and Radaelli, 2017).

We use a multi-level perspective to provide insights on renewable energy policy processes, in the aim to prove the effects of coevolution of the three acknowledged levels of policy learning – i.e. government, network (lesson-drawing), and social learning (Borràs, 2011), on policy effectiveness. Specifically, this paper investigates whether coevolution of the three level of learning characterizes the most successful cases of renewable energy policy. Is the coevolution of the governmental, network, and social levels of learning having effects on policy effectiveness? How do the three levels of learning interact with the elements of the socio-technical system in renewable energy sector? Through means of comparative case study analysis, this paper answers to these research questions, providing insights on both policy learning and policy innovation theories, in the attempt of underlying linkages between the two. To do so, the empirical investigation on governance modes is based on the IEA (International Energy Agency) and the EC DG for Energy data on CO2 emissions pro capita and on renewable energy targets of the selected cases, on the basis of their success in terms of renewable energy shares (EC 2018).

ACCEPTED
Format
08 - Reap what you sow: the use of domestic implementation experiences by the European Commission in the Common Agricultural Policy
Daniel Polman (Wageningen University)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In the multi-level polity of the European Union (EU), policy instruments are often re-interpreted in domestic bureaucracies. In the day-to-day activities of these bureaucratic organizations EU policies are practiced and lead to new experiences about the functioning of the instruments formulated in Brussels. These implementation experiences may be seen as part of a bureaucratic “trial and error” mechanism, where those administrating a policy obtain new information about problems with policy instruments. In order to solve these problems, implementation experiences are a crucial resource. In particular for the European Commission, with its power of initiative and responsibility for drafting reform proposals, effectively setting the agenda for the reform, and providing the alternatives which are decided upon by the Parliament and member states.

 

Most approaches to the (EU) policy process link the implementation of policies to new rounds of policy formulation through stages of evaluation, problem definition and agenda-setting. However, little to no attention is paid to how administrative experiences from the domestic implementation of EU policies affect the formulation of new policy proposals by the European Commission. The aim of this paper is to improve our understanding about how and when these implementation experiences play a role in new policy proposals and to find out to what extent feedback from the domestic implementation of policies affects new rounds of EU policy reform. In this regard the main question of the paper is: when does the European Commission make use of implementation experiences from domestic implementing agencies in its policy proposals?

 

On the one hand studies on policy feedback have addressed the impact of (the implementation of) existing policies on future policy developments. However, these mainly look at the mobilization of experiences by actors affected by the policies, and not at the considerations of the policymakers to use these experiences. Studies on resource dependency and knowledge use, on the other hand, have focused predominantly on the demand for policy relevant input of the side of the policymakers. This paper will make a theoretical contribution by integrating these approaches.

 

Through process tracing, based on both document analysis and interviews, we will take a closer look at the use of implementation experiences by the European Commission in its policy proposals in the time period covering the post-2013 and post-2020 reform proposals for the Common Agricultural Policy. We expect to see changes over this time period in supply, demand, and use on basis of the nature of experiences (positive or negative), the politicization of policy instruments, and the number of veto-players involved. Additionally, the findings of this paper will provide new insights in the trade-offs made by policymakers when dealing with implementation problems in the formulation of policy (reform) proposals.

ACCEPTED
Format
09 - How crisis changes policy cycles: a case study of state aid in the EU
Elena Escalante Block (SciencesPo)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper uses state aid policy and the period of the financial crisis to understand how the European Union (EU) dealt with pressing policy challenges. The financial crisis fundamentally challenged the EU’s model of regulation and as a result, this has raised questions about the role of the state in aiding companies (Lowe 2009). EU competition policies and state aid rulings were crucial to the EU’s recovery plan after the financial crisis (Lowe 2009). This paper seeks to understand how a Multilevel Governance (MLG) structure such as the EU dealt with the financial crisis through problem-solving. This paper will first outline how the policy cycle can be transferred to MLG in times of normalcy using state aid policy. Then, it will see how the policy cycle was adapted during the financial crisis. The research questions this paper seeks to answer are: how can the policy cycle be transferred to studies on MLG? How did the policy cycle model change during the financial crisis?

 

A policy cycle is a way of studying and analysing these policy-making processes. This approach sees policy “as a logical succession of stages” (Colebatch 2009, p. 5). It is also said that the policy cycle is the “most widely applied framework to organise and systematise research on public policy” (Jann and Wegrich 2007). This framework is a “heuristic device” (Bridgman & Davis 2003, p. 102) which is also valuable as it aides the researcher to look at the process behind policy-making. The policy cycle has had a number of criticisms: some scholars suggest that the framework is too uniform, as there can be several policy cycles for different policy types (Bridgman and Davis 2003). It has also been argued that the policy cycle is not flexible enough and can be interpreted differently by the public policy analyst and the policy-maker (Colenbatch 2005). Lastly, and more relevant to this study are the criticisms which suggest that the policy cycle offers a very state-centric approach to the study of policy-making (Barzelay et al., 2010).

 

Due to its heavy focus on the nation-state, it seems that the policy cycle has two main issues when translated to the MLG structure. First, the policy cycle is heavily nation-state driven and the relevant literature has been focused mainly on nation-state issues and policies. The cycle must, therefore, be adapted to the “demoi” aspect of the EU. Second, each issue that becomes part of the policy cycle is “sui-generis” from another issue. However, in MLG, one can imagine that problems that arise in the policy cycle can create other problems in different levels of governance (whether the policy issues start at the nation-state level and transform differently at the EU level or vice versa). Therefore, this study aims to understand how policy processes occur in MLG, how each governance level is affected and how each adapts in times of crisis.

ACCEPTED
Format
10 - Collective learning in collaborativel governance: a network approach
Cécile Riche (Université catholique de Louvain)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Collective learning is crucial for effective problem-solving in  collaborative, multilevel, mode of governance which involves public and private actors holding different views and interests across jurisdictional level. Defined as the development of shared understanding and the alignment of actors’ perspectives and goals, collective learning supports the emergence of solutions that benefit to all the parties involved. Hence, identifying the drivers of collective learning contribute to our understanding of the problem-solving capacity of collaborative and multilevel governance. Recent studies have pinpointed to the role of knowledge acquisition and strong social relations in the development of shared understanding. Yet, little is known about the type of knowledge and the relational configuration that is needed for collective learning to emerge. Based on the data of eight Belgian collaborative and cross-level governance structure, this communication assesses the role of knowledge acquisition and strong ties for collective learning, defined as the extent to which individuals perceive that actors’ perspectives and goals have aligned over time. The eight networks are composed of 10 to 20 individuals who were both surveyed and interviewed about their participation. Using logistic regression and controlling for network autocorrelations, it appears that the number of strong ties held by an individual with other members of the network positively influences her perception of collective learning. The acquisition of knowledge about other participants’ interests also appears significant. In sum, this communication on collective learning highlights the social processes that enhance collective learning and problem-solving capacity of collaborative and multilevel governance.  

ACCEPTED
Format
11 - Policy Failure, Ignorance in Government and the Creation of a Hostile Environment for Health and Safety
Claire Dunlop (University of Exeter)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Much of the social scientific literature examining knowledge use public policy is biased towards the existence of learning. Yet, empirically we observe several institutions and policy domains that do not seem to learn at all, even when this may put in jeopardy human safety. Indeed, we can think of many cases of policy failures and disasters where learning has been entirely absent. In this paper, I explore this darker side of policy learning. Specifically, I draw on the concept of ignorance to explore non-learning in hierarchical settings. Empirically, we develop this model of non-learning by using an analytic narrative of successive residential high rise building fires in England and Scotland that preceded the Grenfell Tower tragedy. Our analysis identifies three types of ignorance that led to a de-coupling of regulation from safety, accountability and human beings themselves: ignorance as denial; ignorance as delegation of learning; and, ignorance as bureaucratic hubris. We conclude with the prospects for change in this area and specifically ask what it takes to create a functional learning environment

ACCEPTED
Format
12 - The diffusion of fire retardation policies across US states
Sonja Walti (American University - School of Public Affairs)
CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

During the 1970s, new chemicals that promised to slow materials from catching fire spread quickly among relevant industries, such as the production of textiles, furniture and home building materials. Policies and practices were adopted at the state-level, from California to Maine, in order to encourage and/or mandate the adoption of new technologies that promised to save lives, including those of potential burn victims and first responders. If not for general use, many states adopted policies that required the addition or application of relevant fire retardant materials and substances in the construction and furnishings of hospitals, schools, and other public buildings.

As research on fire retardants progressed in the scientific community, occasionally entering mainstream news, doubts about the safety of fire retardant chemicals for environmental and human health started emerging among relevant epistemic communities and the public. California has been the first state to roll back fire retardant use in recent years, calling for their regulation and labeling on furnishings containing such substances. Other states have followed or are following suit. These state-level efforts have pitted the chemical industry, environmental groups, and affected stakeholders in an effort to regulate the use of relevant chemicals while also allowing for innovation of new substances and practices to progress. While some efforts to regulate fire retardants at the federal level emerged in light of the 2013 and 2015 to the Toxic Substances Control Act of 1976 (TSCA), their regulatory and de-regulatory trajectory is still largely left to the states, providing for a unique opportunity to study the diffusion of regulatory retrenchment.

This contribution is based on qualitative empirical research that retraces the policy making process in key states, while examining how stakeholders at various levels of government interact to influence the state-to-state regulatory retrenchment process. The results not only point the key role policy communities and entrepreneurs play in shaping state-level innovation processes but also illustrate the difficulties in finding effective regulatory solutions to a complex problem that leave open sufficient room for innovation.

CO-AUTHORS
Emily St Denny (Nottingham Trent University)
ABSTRACT

This paper combines theory and practice to describe practical ways to use academic insights to encourage policy learning across multi-level systems. The focus is the EU-funded IMAJINE project to reduce territorial inequalities across Europe. Our overall aim is to identify, analyse, learn from, and help transfer policies that have reduced territorial inequalities. Our first objective is to research and share lessons from the governments who project policy success in reducing inequalities in areas such as education attainment, drug-related punishment, and income. However, policy theories prompt us to manage our expectations about learning. They explain the relationship between (a) politics, (b) complex policymaking systems, and (c) the lack of ‘evidence-based’ policymaking, learning, and transfer. It is not feasible to propose a simple evidence-based model for learning, or seek to transfer policy solutions from one region to another without considering their political and policymaking contexts. Our second objective is to use our knowledge of policy processes to help produce pragmatic and innovative ways to foster the systematic use of evidence in policy transfer. Our third objective is to make sure that we have sufficient knowledge of our audience to make an impact with this study. We will (a) produce evidence on the technical feasibility of policy solutions, and (b) investigate the ways in which potential importing governments determine their political feasibility. We use an iterative process, to identify and generate initial attention for success stories, identify how the case study government defined the policy problem, work with actors in other systems to understand how they would interpret and use the evidence, and use this knowledge to inform our research.

CO-AUTHORS
Asya Zhelyazkova (ETH Zurich)
ABSTRACT

European Union (EU) policies change as they are being customised throughout the implementation chain. How do these changes affect the practical implementation of EU policies? While better regulation approaches point to the danger of red tape when deviating from EU law, theories of policy implementation see a role of discretion in decentralised problem-solving. This study analyses how customisation affects the practical compliance with EU antidiscrimination, environmental, and justice and home affairs directives in 27 member states. Results suggest that general customisation levels neither exert a significant direct nor conditional effect on practical compliance. However, higher levels of customised density negatively affect practical compliance. We also find a partly sector-specific, direct positive effect of customised restrictiveness on practical compliance. Thus, while customised density can indeed reinforce problems of red tape, customised restrictiveness can contribute to problem-solving. The crucial distinction is that between changes in the quantity or the quality of regulation.

 

CO-AUTHORS
Anthony Zito (University of Newcastle-upon-Tyne)
ABSTRACT

Although a great variety of learning-oriented policy instruments has been promoted across EU public policies increasingly over the last decade, little knowledge still exists about how socialization, emulation and reflexivity matter for policy convergence in the EU (Holzinger and Knill, 2008; Zito and Schout 2009) and the extent of exploitation of specific learning oriented policy tools (Radaelli, 2008; Dunlop and Radaelli 2012). Most of empirical research in this field has focused on the implementation of the so-called Open Method of Coordination (OMC) (Borras and Jacobsson, 2004), while only a few studies have adopted a different perspective, conceiving learning in terms of change and adaptation of policy instruments (Wurzel et al. 2013); policy diffusion and transfer (Jordan et al. 2015; Musialkowska, Dabrowski and Polverari 2014) or political learning (Graziano et al. 2011). Yet, efforts to investigate systematically the impact and limits of both individual instruments and instrument packages, with respect to wider policy and institutional change, have been scarce, regardless of concerns expressed about insufficient impact of such instruments on policy outcomes (Radaelli, 2008).

New challenges for both academic researchers and policy assessors arise as more recent network-type modes of governance based on mutual coordination and learning have targeted not only central governments but also sub-state authorities and non-state actors. EU Commission DGs and Executive Agencies have often been directly involved into these networks, providing coordination or support functions.

Drawing on existing scholarship on policy learning and change in the EU, this paper sets out to explore the overall learning effects of the EU Covenant of Mayors (CoM) programme since its inception until the present.  The EU Commission launched this programme in 2008 with the objective of enhancing and supporting the coordinated action of local authorities for sustainable energy and climate. Building on an original analytical framework, the research aims to understand (i) to what extent local authorities have exploited the learning tools embedded in the programme, (ii) how the methodological and expert knowledge diffused through the programme shaped local policy agendas and settings, and (iii) whether there has been a learning effect for the EU Commission itself.  The theoretical approach provides analytical tools for understanding how instrument design, selection and application bridge and influence the political motivations of actors and the policy processes.

This research stems from the research project ‘Research Project Climate change policies and governance. The experience of EU voluntary instruments’ (BIRD165757) financed by the University of Padova during 2017 – 2018. In addition to the empirical material collected through desk-research, interviews and a survey administered in four EU countries (Italy, Germany, Poland and United Kingdom), this paper utilises wider quantitative data covering the entire CoM membership.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Emphasis on power dynamics in society is frequently held to be a common denominator of the multi-faceted discipline that is political science. Nonetheless, scholars writing from a neo-institutionalist tradition increasingly point to a lack of systematic and explicit treatment of power in contemporary research (Morriss 2002; Clegg et al. 2006; Göhler 2009; Munir 2015; Dowding 2008, 2012; Lawrence and Buchanan 2017).

 

In this paper I address the following research question: what is the added value to studies of political-administrative coordination processes from treating power dynamics explicitly?

 

The main argument is that power dynamics are fundamental conditioners for how processes of political and administrative coordination progress (and possibly stagnate). Furthermore, I argue that the composite and diverse nature of power is yet to be wholly appreciated by students of coordination. The larger share of power conceptualizations has some resemblance with Dahl’s (1957: 82) classical conception “[involving] a successful attempt by A to get a to do something he would not otherwise do”. Such an understanding of power dynamics is usually referred to as power “over” (Lukes 2005: 12; Pansardi 2011). However, scholars have come to emphasise an additional power dynamic; the power “to” or the ability to act autonomously (Pitkin 1972; Morriss 2002; Dowding 1996, 2008; Göhler 2009). This paper suggests that a power “over” vs. power “to” framework can yield new insights on the conditioners of coordination processes. It aspires to contribute to, on the one hand, the literature on coordination in multilevel settings, and, on the other, the literature on translation processes whereby actors, via editing, come to rationalize their behaviours (Sahlin-Andersson 1996; Höllerer et al. 2017; Wedlin and Sahlin 2017).

 

To illustrate the utility of a power dynamics framework, I make use of anecdotal, qualitative, data from a “typical” case (Seawright and Gerring 2008: 299) of global challenges to society; Antimicrobial Resistance (AMR). Challenges such as AMR and climate change respect neither jurisdictional nor sectorial boundaries, as such they are inherently transcendental (Drori et al. 2014; Höllerer et al. 2017). The global response to AMR thus rests on the advocacy of cross-border, “whole of society” coordination (c.f. WHO 2015). AMR governance involves at minimum the animal-/food safety and human medicine sectors, and multiple levels of jurisdiction (due to the ease with which resistant microbes are spreading). Transcendence arguably makes effective coordination more challenging. Firstly, to contain the resistant microbes requires some level of concerted action by a considerable number of, often diverse, organizations. Secondly, power dynamics come into play via the interactions between actors from various organizational fields. AMR governance thus ought to be a promising ground for enquiry into the power dynamics in coordination. The paper focuses particularly on AMR problem-solving within the European Union (EU)/European Economic Area (EEA). This is due to the difference in competence allocation between the EU- and Member State-level on animal-/food safety and human medicine respectively. The data material is constituted by a series of elite-interviews plus policy documents and secondary literature.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Institutional reforms are ubiquitously applied in developing countries to improve government capabilities (Andrews, Pritchett, & Woolcock, 2012). However, evidence indicates that efforts to curb anti-corruption in Malawi, strengthen the justice sector in South Sudan, or support decentralization programmes in Uganda, consistently failed to address reform objectives (Doig, Watt, & Williams, 2005). The investment in institutional reforms globally and their dismal performance have elicited numerous explanations by development experts and academics with examples ranging from challenging contexts to lack of political will. However, none of these reasons seems to offer specific answers to why reforms in developing contexts continue to fail  (Evans, Peter; Rauch, 1999; Grindle, 2007). An explanation advanced by Matt Andrews and others seems to go further to provide an alternative model to introducing reforms that is a departure from approaches currently being applied. Andrews (2014) proposes an alternative model called Problem-Driven Iterative Adaptation (PDIA) which is argued to produce best practice reforms in developing countries if they are crafted as a response to locally identified problems, undertaken in an iterative fashion through experimentation and learning, involving multiple agents and producing hybrid solutions that are locally owned, understood and implemented. In developing countries, meeting challenges to development are largely dependent on the effectiveness of the state to undertake its core functions. Strengthening institutional capability and performance of the state to deliver these functions becomes of paramount interest to reform suppliers however if the reforms are not addressing locally relevant problems, and have little political traction then evidence suggests that the recipient countries will adapt these reforms only in the spirit of compliance leading to less than satisfactory changes in the conditions set out to be addressed (Andrews et al., 2012). This paper uses new institutional theory and an interdisciplinary approach derived from the fields of political science, sociology and management to understand the introduction of key institutional reforms (Management Performance Assessment Tool -MPAT) related to improving public sector performance in Uganda and South Africa. These country environments contend with structurally limiting conditions, consequences of a series of state failures for instance apartheid in South Africa and conflict in Uganda (Alam et al., 2016; Andrews and Bategeka., 2013) and more recently, their governments have struggled with underperforming economies and governance challenges. Using an institutional ethnography research design, the paper explores ideas emerging from institutional economics covering concepts of institutional logics, institutional entrepreneurship, isomorphism and decoupling. at the introduction stage of the MPAT in each country. Findings from this paper provides insights on the conditions under which reforms are introduced, how different agents were engaged in the process and what the implications are for future value of the reform.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Spatial planning approaches have evolved historically and reflect political traditions and institutional arrangements. In transboundary planning processes aimed at joint policy and action, social learning can be a useful governance mechanism to develop shared understanding about spatial trends that stretch across administrative boundaries and for supporting collective action. In this article, we apply a social learning perspective to a recent transnational spatial planning process by the ‘Visegrad 4’ (Poland, Hungary, Czech Republic and Slovakia) with Bulgaria and Romania (V4+2). We analyse the problem-solving and social learning effects of the V4+2 initiative between 2008 and 2014 as part of an on-going political process. Using in-depth interviews, document analysis and participant observation, this allows a discussion about how the cooperation agendas evolved and were shaped by the political context and timelines, how problems were framed and addressed, and about the instrumental, communicative and social learning effects that were achieved in the collaboration to date. The research also offers recommendations for other transnational spatial planning processes in relation to the role of political goals for providing the structural context and the importance of process management in collaborative arrangements for fostering problem-solving social learning.

 

CO-AUTHORS
Maria Stella Righettini (University of Padova )
ABSTRACT

Academic literature has recently shown much interest in socio-technical systems and policy innovation, and debates about innovation give much attention to renewable energy options, and possible policy measures to stimulate them (Vernong and Geels, 2007). Literature suggests that a socio-technical system implies a transition from RTD to innovation policies, not just as important sectoral arenas of action in themselves, but as instruments towards new wide ranging policy objectives that integrate the user side with the scientific development side (Geels, 2004).

The renewable energy has been treated as a socio-technical issue that is worthy of exploration, and in recent years many scholars have undertaken empirical studies. The conception of socio-technical systems is frequently used to study this issue (Verbong and Geels, 2007), by adopting a bottom up and user approaches and a multi-level perspective. However, empirical contributions that investigate how in governance modes technical innovation is combined with users learning (both industries and domestic users) to increase governmental learning are still lacking. Likewise, investigations on how policy-makers try to draw lessons from technical innovation in renewable energy policies and how they activate mechanism to increase users collective learning need to be further explored (Dunlop and Radaelli, 2017).

We use a multi-level perspective to provide insights on renewable energy policy processes, in the aim to prove the effects of coevolution of the three acknowledged levels of policy learning – i.e. government, network (lesson-drawing), and social learning (Borràs, 2011), on policy effectiveness. Specifically, this paper investigates whether coevolution of the three level of learning characterizes the most successful cases of renewable energy policy. Is the coevolution of the governmental, network, and social levels of learning having effects on policy effectiveness? How do the three levels of learning interact with the elements of the socio-technical system in renewable energy sector? Through means of comparative case study analysis, this paper answers to these research questions, providing insights on both policy learning and policy innovation theories, in the attempt of underlying linkages between the two. To do so, the empirical investigation on governance modes is based on the IEA (International Energy Agency) and the EC DG for Energy data on CO2 emissions pro capita and on renewable energy targets of the selected cases, on the basis of their success in terms of renewable energy shares (EC 2018).

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

In the multi-level polity of the European Union (EU), policy instruments are often re-interpreted in domestic bureaucracies. In the day-to-day activities of these bureaucratic organizations EU policies are practiced and lead to new experiences about the functioning of the instruments formulated in Brussels. These implementation experiences may be seen as part of a bureaucratic “trial and error” mechanism, where those administrating a policy obtain new information about problems with policy instruments. In order to solve these problems, implementation experiences are a crucial resource. In particular for the European Commission, with its power of initiative and responsibility for drafting reform proposals, effectively setting the agenda for the reform, and providing the alternatives which are decided upon by the Parliament and member states.

 

Most approaches to the (EU) policy process link the implementation of policies to new rounds of policy formulation through stages of evaluation, problem definition and agenda-setting. However, little to no attention is paid to how administrative experiences from the domestic implementation of EU policies affect the formulation of new policy proposals by the European Commission. The aim of this paper is to improve our understanding about how and when these implementation experiences play a role in new policy proposals and to find out to what extent feedback from the domestic implementation of policies affects new rounds of EU policy reform. In this regard the main question of the paper is: when does the European Commission make use of implementation experiences from domestic implementing agencies in its policy proposals?

 

On the one hand studies on policy feedback have addressed the impact of (the implementation of) existing policies on future policy developments. However, these mainly look at the mobilization of experiences by actors affected by the policies, and not at the considerations of the policymakers to use these experiences. Studies on resource dependency and knowledge use, on the other hand, have focused predominantly on the demand for policy relevant input of the side of the policymakers. This paper will make a theoretical contribution by integrating these approaches.

 

Through process tracing, based on both document analysis and interviews, we will take a closer look at the use of implementation experiences by the European Commission in its policy proposals in the time period covering the post-2013 and post-2020 reform proposals for the Common Agricultural Policy. We expect to see changes over this time period in supply, demand, and use on basis of the nature of experiences (positive or negative), the politicization of policy instruments, and the number of veto-players involved. Additionally, the findings of this paper will provide new insights in the trade-offs made by policymakers when dealing with implementation problems in the formulation of policy (reform) proposals.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

This paper uses state aid policy and the period of the financial crisis to understand how the European Union (EU) dealt with pressing policy challenges. The financial crisis fundamentally challenged the EU’s model of regulation and as a result, this has raised questions about the role of the state in aiding companies (Lowe 2009). EU competition policies and state aid rulings were crucial to the EU’s recovery plan after the financial crisis (Lowe 2009). This paper seeks to understand how a Multilevel Governance (MLG) structure such as the EU dealt with the financial crisis through problem-solving. This paper will first outline how the policy cycle can be transferred to MLG in times of normalcy using state aid policy. Then, it will see how the policy cycle was adapted during the financial crisis. The research questions this paper seeks to answer are: how can the policy cycle be transferred to studies on MLG? How did the policy cycle model change during the financial crisis?

 

A policy cycle is a way of studying and analysing these policy-making processes. This approach sees policy “as a logical succession of stages” (Colebatch 2009, p. 5). It is also said that the policy cycle is the “most widely applied framework to organise and systematise research on public policy” (Jann and Wegrich 2007). This framework is a “heuristic device” (Bridgman & Davis 2003, p. 102) which is also valuable as it aides the researcher to look at the process behind policy-making. The policy cycle has had a number of criticisms: some scholars suggest that the framework is too uniform, as there can be several policy cycles for different policy types (Bridgman and Davis 2003). It has also been argued that the policy cycle is not flexible enough and can be interpreted differently by the public policy analyst and the policy-maker (Colenbatch 2005). Lastly, and more relevant to this study are the criticisms which suggest that the policy cycle offers a very state-centric approach to the study of policy-making (Barzelay et al., 2010).

 

Due to its heavy focus on the nation-state, it seems that the policy cycle has two main issues when translated to the MLG structure. First, the policy cycle is heavily nation-state driven and the relevant literature has been focused mainly on nation-state issues and policies. The cycle must, therefore, be adapted to the “demoi” aspect of the EU. Second, each issue that becomes part of the policy cycle is “sui-generis” from another issue. However, in MLG, one can imagine that problems that arise in the policy cycle can create other problems in different levels of governance (whether the policy issues start at the nation-state level and transform differently at the EU level or vice versa). Therefore, this study aims to understand how policy processes occur in MLG, how each governance level is affected and how each adapts in times of crisis.

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Collective learning is crucial for effective problem-solving in  collaborative, multilevel, mode of governance which involves public and private actors holding different views and interests across jurisdictional level. Defined as the development of shared understanding and the alignment of actors’ perspectives and goals, collective learning supports the emergence of solutions that benefit to all the parties involved. Hence, identifying the drivers of collective learning contribute to our understanding of the problem-solving capacity of collaborative and multilevel governance. Recent studies have pinpointed to the role of knowledge acquisition and strong social relations in the development of shared understanding. Yet, little is known about the type of knowledge and the relational configuration that is needed for collective learning to emerge. Based on the data of eight Belgian collaborative and cross-level governance structure, this communication assesses the role of knowledge acquisition and strong ties for collective learning, defined as the extent to which individuals perceive that actors’ perspectives and goals have aligned over time. The eight networks are composed of 10 to 20 individuals who were both surveyed and interviewed about their participation. Using logistic regression and controlling for network autocorrelations, it appears that the number of strong ties held by an individual with other members of the network positively influences her perception of collective learning. The acquisition of knowledge about other participants’ interests also appears significant. In sum, this communication on collective learning highlights the social processes that enhance collective learning and problem-solving capacity of collaborative and multilevel governance.  

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

Much of the social scientific literature examining knowledge use public policy is biased towards the existence of learning. Yet, empirically we observe several institutions and policy domains that do not seem to learn at all, even when this may put in jeopardy human safety. Indeed, we can think of many cases of policy failures and disasters where learning has been entirely absent. In this paper, I explore this darker side of policy learning. Specifically, I draw on the concept of ignorance to explore non-learning in hierarchical settings. Empirically, we develop this model of non-learning by using an analytic narrative of successive residential high rise building fires in England and Scotland that preceded the Grenfell Tower tragedy. Our analysis identifies three types of ignorance that led to a de-coupling of regulation from safety, accountability and human beings themselves: ignorance as denial; ignorance as delegation of learning; and, ignorance as bureaucratic hubris. We conclude with the prospects for change in this area and specifically ask what it takes to create a functional learning environment

CO-AUTHORS
—
ABSTRACT

During the 1970s, new chemicals that promised to slow materials from catching fire spread quickly among relevant industries, such as the production of textiles, furniture and home building materials. Policies and practices were adopted at the state-level, from California to Maine, in order to encourage and/or mandate the adoption of new technologies that promised to save lives, including those of potential burn victims and first responders. If not for general use, many states adopted policies that required the addition or application of relevant fire retardant materials and substances in the construction and furnishings of hospitals, schools, and other public buildings.

As research on fire retardants progressed in the scientific community, occasionally entering mainstream news, doubts about the safety of fire retardant chemicals for environmental and human health started emerging among relevant epistemic communities and the public. California has been the first state to roll back fire retardant use in recent years, calling for their regulation and labeling on furnishings containing such substances. Other states have followed or are following suit. These state-level efforts have pitted the chemical industry, environmental groups, and affected stakeholders in an effort to regulate the use of relevant chemicals while also allowing for innovation of new substances and practices to progress. While some efforts to regulate fire retardants at the federal level emerged in light of the 2013 and 2015 to the Toxic Substances Control Act of 1976 (TSCA), their regulatory and de-regulatory trajectory is still largely left to the states, providing for a unique opportunity to study the diffusion of regulatory retrenchment.

This contribution is based on qualitative empirical research that retraces the policy making process in key states, while examining how stakeholders at various levels of government interact to influence the state-to-state regulatory retrenchment process. The results not only point the key role policy communities and entrepreneurs play in shaping state-level innovation processes but also illustrate the difficulties in finding effective regulatory solutions to a complex problem that leave open sufficient room for innovation.