P04. Migration and Citizenship: Policies and Research in Global Comparative Perspective
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICYCATEGORISATION
KEYWORDS
GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE
According to figures collected by the United Nations, globally the number of international migrants has grown over the course of the twenty-first century, standing at 244 million in 2015, an increase of 41% from 2000. Likewise, the numbers of forcibly displaced peoples and refugees has also grown over the course of the 2000s, and is higher now than at any time since the end of World War II. Because migration is such an increasingly important feature of all world regions and societies, there is a need for a global comparative perspective to assess the nature of national and regional policy responses and their consequences for migrants and refugees, for civil society organizations representing migrants’ and refugees’ interests, for sending and receiving societies, and for international norms pertaining to human rights and protection. The primary objective of the panel(s) associated with “Migration and Citizenship: Policies and Research in Global Comparative Perspective” is to challenge extant global inequalities in immigration research by enabling, showcasing and sustaining a unique dialogue involving the experiences of countries and regions of both the global North and the global South.
Since the end of the 1990s, immigration studies have developed into a considerable field of research in the social sciences. In North America, Australia and Western Europe, the result of this development has been research that often focuses “South-North” migrations and that is concerned with the impact of immigration on host societies in the Global North. Nowhere is this more the case than in political science and in the study of public policy. With notable exceptions, these disciplines rarely engage with work produced by scholars from immigrant-sending countries, or with work that explores the dynamics associated with immigration outside of the global North. Some scholars, in fact, have flagged how existing frameworks, methods, and theories do not account for the specificities of migration trends in the global South. That migration policy studies erroneously assume that most migration follows “a developing-to-developed migration path” or that the same “formalized rights regimes” that exist in the Global North are present in the global South highlights but a few examples of how ideas around migration policy studies are still based on frameworks taken in the global North (seee.g.: Nawyn 2016). As a result, important issues remain unaddressed by political science and policy studies when it comes to immigration. Far from exhaustively, these include: migration regimes of the global south, internal and regional migrations, the social impact of remittance and more, importantly, the consequences of the global North migration regimes on the political context in sending countries. This workshop aims to challenge this silence by asking: i) What are the similar and divergent migration trends, patterns and challenges from a global cross-national perspective? ii) What are the dynamics and structural forces that support the organization and production of current immigration research in political science and policy studies? and iii) What could be the basis for a research agenda for immigration research in political science and policy studies that would consider the global South equally to the global North?
CALL FOR PAPERS
Authors are invited to submit empirical, methodological or theoretical papers on themes such as: the divergent responses to migration and refugee issues at the national, regional, and global levels; the relative impact of national, regional and international factors in shaping immigration-related policies and the politics of global migration management. Case studies and comparative analyses are equality welcome, but proposals should strive to engage with a discussion of causes and consequences of the current structuration of migration studies as a field of research or to identify novel methodologies and practices that can foster a more equal academic dialogue between the global South and the global North.
This panel is co-sponsored by RC 46 on “Migration and Citizenship” in the International Political Science Association, which seeks to better bridge experiences and insights and scholars from both the global North and South.
In order to advance the goals of the panel and the goals of IPSA RC46, the panel organizers have secured funding to support the presentation of papers by scholars from countries of the global South. Please therefore also indicate to the panel organizers whether you would like to be considered for this financial support at the time of submitting your abstract.
Works Cited: Nawyn, Stephanie. (2016) ‘New Directions for Research on Migration in the Global South,’ International Journal of Sociology 46 (3): 163-168.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper explains the current position of humanitarianism with regard to refugees in the Member States (MS) of the European Union (EU). It argues that the Member States´ adopted interpretations of the principles of solidarity and responsibility to protect (R2P) exclude refugees. The principle of solidarity is interpreted as sharing the refugees´ burden, among the Member States, associated with the arrival of refugees.[1] The paper assumes sharing the burden as the internal dimension of solidarity. Moreover, the external dimension of solidarity assumed as solidarity with the refugees is overlooked by the Member States. The paper argues that solidarity with refugees would be a human-centred approach of the external dimension of solidarity. Similarly, the Member States interpret the principle of R2P as the external dimension. This may allow intervention in a sovereign state on humanitarian grounds, while people fleeing war zones and seeking asylum in the Member States are presumed outside of the principle of R2P.[2] The paper further argues that the Member States have also an obligation to protect war-displaced refugees at home. It implies that the protection of refugees at home is the home-based approach of internal dimension of R2P. The Member States´ non-compliance of refugee protection under solidarity and R2P is due to limited interpretation of both humanitarian norms. This results in disregard of home-based and human-centred application of the humanitarian norms. Therefore, the paper argues for refugees´ inclusion in the humanitarian regimes through a broader interpretation of the principles of solidarity and R2P. It reasons that, following a human centre approach, solidarity should be read as a humanitarian responsibility to protect refugees (HRPR). Similarly, following a home-based approach, R2P should also be read as a humanitarian responsibility to protect refugees. This provides a common ground for refugees´ protection between R2P and asylum (Panebianco & Fontana 2005). The paper is divided into three parts: part one provides a theoretical review of the principle of solidarity; part two elaborates R2P; whereas, part three clarifies elusiveness around allocation of humanitarian responsibility between the EU and its Member States and highlights why the Member States have a greater humanitarian responsibility to protect refugees.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
For decades, in Canada we have been talking about models of integration of minorities and especially migration. It is argued that there is a British "communitarian" model of "multiculturalism" in which Canada is identified; a civic French model focused on national identity and an American model of "melting pot".
Using comparative policies in West Europe and North America, it is shown that these so-called "models" are far from reflecting reality and have become simplistic and grotesque concepts. Societies have changed and studies on each country have challenged these assumptions, for example Glazer & Moynihan (1970) have shown that the idea of the "melting pot" is misleading.
Beyond these fixed and deterministic models, countries set up policies with similar challenges of globalization, economic and discursive. Meanwhile, we immigrants face similar issues of integration as well as exclusion.
In addition, conservative political discourses at the international level have had a major impact on national policies and the negative perception of migration. Simplistic solutions like walls claim to substitute immigration policies. Even international cooperation on the subject is poorly perceived as evidence of the Marrakesh Declaration (UN, 2018).
Societies around the world have a great deal of religious, cultural and racial diversity in which a new form of citizenship is defined (Kymlicka, 1996). The challenge for societies is to deal with laws and institutions for all citizens, not to seek an ideal model or to demonize it. In this sense, there is a need to design public policies that focus on social justice, the equity of rights and the inclusion of all citizens. We propose a Southern perspective, particularly of Latin America, in order to establish a dialogue (indispensable but absent) between North and South. Sometimes migration policies fail by factors related to the North-South divide (Castles, 2004). On the one hand, this dialogue must focus on equitable development and North-South cooperation. On the other hand, policies must be part of the Western tradition of thought and values, such as hospitality and universal peace (Kant), mutual recognition (Taylor, 1991) and right of asylum (Derrida).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The “refugee crisis” has been one of the European Union’s most decisive challenges. It has caused major internal disputes and led to a de-facto suspension of Dublin and partly also of Schengen. A truly European approach most certainly would have prevented the influx of refugees from becoming such a severe challenge. However, several member states have opposed distributing asylum seekers across the Union and by doing so obstructed a joint European solution. We argue that some kind of European refugee distribution mechanism (RDM) will be needed in order to sustainably solve the crisis – at least to complement any other possible approach.
Against this backdrop, our paper asks why certain member states reject the establishment of a permanent European refugee distribution mechanism.
To answer our research question, we start by summarizing the attempts the EU has made to manage the refugee crisis. We point out why these steps, while eventually mitigating the crisis in the short-term, do not represent sustainable solutions. In order to detect the factors which have prevented the introduction of an RDM, we derive five hypotheses, which are subsequently tested by applying a fuzzy set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA). We find that any combination of a low share of Muslims, a low degree of EU integration, i.e. the presence of opt-outs or a recent membership, a weak economic performance or/and a high impact of the migration crisis in 2015 sufficiently explains a member state’s rejection of a permanent distribution mechanism. Further, having a small Muslim population is almost a necessary condition for a members state’s opposition. In contrast to past research, our findings show that the strength of EU sceptic forces in the national context cannot be considered as a systematic cause of member states rejecting the distribution of refugees among the Union’s members.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Lately, the focus of international migration has turned both to the Central American issue as to Venezuelan migration in Latin-America. This intraregional migration leads us to rethink the frames from which we analyze south-south migration and the policies implemented by receiving countries. Many questions rise from this issue: should we adopt a migration management approach? Should we consider the migration development duo in our public policies? Should we think it from a local governance perspective? And so on.
While trying to solve some of these questions, and as a result of a doctoral research held from 2014 to 2018 in Colombia, this paper focuses on the migration development debate that has been covering a lot of literature in the migration academic issues but also as a matter of political and public debates from the North. Taking the model of the IOM for return migration management we seek to analyze what is its impact on national policies, we take Ecuador and Colombia as cases to compare from a convergence perspective (Knill, 2005) the issue, approaching it from the South (Delgado Wise, 2018). We conclude that this model is based on an economic approach to migrants rather than a human one which has to consider embeddedness (Van Houte & Davids, 2014) in a reintegration line when it comes to referring to migrants but also to formulate projects and programs that aim not only the migrant as an economic agent but also as a human of rights. Reintegration must take place in the family, in the psychosocial aspect and in the political one, not just in income generation. We invite academics and politicians to rethink the frames from which we formulate policies, taking into account the bias of national methodology approaches and starting to think more globally in a transnational context where local governance is key to this reintegration process.
References
Delgado Wise, R. (2018). On the Theory and Practice of Migration and Development: A Southern Perspective. Journal of Intercultural Studies, 39(2), 163–181. https://doi.org/10.1080/07256868.2018.1446669
Knill, C. (2005). Introduction : Cross-national policy convergence : concepts , approaches and explanatory factors, 12(March), 764–774. https://doi.org/10.1080/13501760500161332
Van Houte, M., & Davids, T. (2014). Moving Back or Moving Forward? Return Migration, Development and Peace-Building. New Diversities, 16(2), 71–87.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The phenomenon of migration has been recorded to be a part of human history. Over the years, scholars have averred that people migrate for different reasons. While some do so for economic reasons and in search of greener pastures, others do so to escape either the wrath of the society or the government owing from their actions and way of life. This phenomenon is not restricted to gender and age, as both males and females, old and young, engage in this act. Of late, it has been discovered that there is a huge desire of youths, including those who have jobs, to exit the country, thereby leading to a massive emigration of youths out of Nigeria. Although it is an undeniable fact that the economy of the country is in shambles, which leads to a desire to search for greener pastures elsewhere, the trend in the youths’ desire and rush to leave Nigeria transcends this sole reason. The belief among the youths that a good life exists only outside of Nigeria and they must leave the country’s shores has emerged as a youth culture. This study therefore critically delved into the reasons for this emerging culture, using failed migrants who have attempted to emigrate via the Sahara and the Mediterranean into Europe. Conclusively, it suggested pragmatic ways to dissuade youths from this act and harnessing the technological innovation brought to fore by Social Media which has been a veritable avenue in job creation in this epoch. A field ethnography method and archival technique was adopted. The data collected was thematically analyzed in relation to the crux of the study. The findings from the study are expected to raise issues that will foster a debate among scholars on youth migration and postulate ways of discouraging this phenomenon in Nigeria.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Migration in the Southern African region has a long and complex history (Crush et al., 2005). However, South Africa continues to attract a significant number of migrants from the Southern African region and beyond (Crush et al., 2005). Similarly, countries like Botswana and Namibia are destinations of choice. Concerning South Africa, migration and immigration increases to the country have attracted a dynamic response from the state, just as it has raised debate in the public and political spheres. A clear indication of this, are the changes in immigration policy, which demonstrates a departure from what can be considered as an apartheid inspired immigration policy up to the about 2002 to the current state, which is based on the benefit that migrants or immigrants should bring to the country (Peberdy, 2009). Indeed, there is wealth of literature which has interrogated the South African immigration policies and dynamics, but the focus has tended to be more on the implications on xenophobia. As a result, there is limited research which has examined the selectivity of the South African immigration policy (which amounts to the creation of South Africa as a `gated community`), and the implications of this on the unwanted classes of migrants. This paper, therefore examines the implications and ramifications of South Africa`s immigration policy on the unwanted classes of migrants, by responding to the following questions; are the trends similar to the fortification of European Union (EU) borders against migrants from Africa? What are the differences if any? What are the contradictions and challenges given the drive for regionalism in Africa?
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In 2015 and 2016, Germany received 1.2 Mio refugees. Accordingly, the schemes for registering, housing, feeding, providing health care to refugees, administrating their asylum procedures and so on, reached their limits. This so-called “refugee crisis” (see Bogumil et al. 2018) drew the scholarly attention to a number of particularities of German refugee policy, especially the division of labor in German federalism (Lautenbach 2015). In Germany, most aspects of migration policy are regulated at the federal level. Yet, since in German federalism the 16 German states have the duty to implement most federal laws, they exert considerable discretion by doing so. This again results in a remarkable diversity in policy implementation. Yet, publications so far have highlighted only very specific aspects of Länder refugee policies (e.g. Schammann 2015; Hörisch 2018), or they have given some overview (Münch 2016; 2017) but did not provide systematic empirical data for all Länder (but see Reiter & Töller 2019). This paper first discloses the remarkable diversity of refugee policies in German Länder by giving fresh empirical data with regard to three core areas: the provision of financial support, housing and health provision to refugees; the procedures for obtaining a protection status; and the implementation of the residence act with regard to the voluntary return or deportation of persons for whom neither protection nor toleration can be provided. Second the paper asks if in this context diversity is a good thing. Since other relevant debates, such as migration studies or the debate on German federalism (e.g. Sack & Töller 2018) fail at offering criteria for evaluating this normative question, we draw on the debate on “Immigration Federalism”. This debate has evolved in order to understand developments in the US American, Canadian and Australian migration policy since the 2000nds (Spiro 2001; Gulasekaram & Ramakrishnan 2015). We argue that albeit there are relevant differences between these federal systems and Germany, the debate has a high potential to help us evaluate federal diversity as we find it in German refugee policy. Drawing on Spiro (2001) we distinguish three issue areas which match well with the three areas which we have addressed before: immigration rights (access to social rights), immigration benefits (acquisition of a status e.g. political asylum); and immigration enforcement (e.g. border control and deportation). We apply two criteria, first, the criterion of equal treatment and second, the criterion of adequate accomplishment of tasks to these three issue areas and come up with a rather critical evaluation of federal diversity in German refugee policy, yet with differences between the issue areas.
More generally we think that such an institutionalist perspective paying attention to state structure as a factor in shaping relevant policies in immigrant-receiving countries can be a useful way to contribute to a global research agenda for immigration research.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In 2016, the Turkish academic field is at the forefront of the sociopolitical upheavals in Turkey. Symbolized by the petitionAcademics for Peace, the social movement led mainly by academics militates for the cessation of interventions by the Turkish army targeting the areas of eastern Anatolia populated mainly by the Kurdish people. The petition also aims to publicize the many human rights violations and international treaties signed by Turkey relating to torture and other forms of "unconventional" violence. Following legal proceedings by the Turkish authorities against the university, one of the preferred solutions for them will be the choice of exile. Especially since the movement of Turkish academicians had been supported through a petition emanating this time from academics from Western Europe on January 18th, 2016. This petition is going to condition the two great trajectories chosen by the Turkish academics, choosing France or Germany as the main land of asylum. Thus, the research project will have the ambition to focus primarily on the multiplicity of social determinants to restore complexity around the conditions of exile of Turkish academics. Continuing by linking these paths of exile and the establishment of a comparative typology of different reception measures specifically set up for "intellectuals". Thus, the research project has the ambition to be interested in the multiplicity of social determinants to restore the complexity surrounding the conditions of exile Turkish academics. The objectification of these exile journeys will involve the establishment of a comparative typology of the various reception measures specifically set up for "intellectuals" in France and Germany.
The methods used may vary: especially interviews with Turkish nationals but also with those who manage these programs and initiatives. A prosopography of successful candidates may be relevant. The characteristics of those who have not been so, focusing on the criteria of acceptance. And in the case of a research project, the evolution over 2 years, it is essential to focus on the evolution within French and German universities and centers and the degree of integration and adaptation of the selected sample. Observation too can be a relevant tool. The subject is current and there is no shortage of conferences and seminars specifically devoted to this. In addition, archives can be very useful including archives dealing with scientists struggling with political power, totalitarian governments. They present important data and can be objects of possible comparisons.
The expected results obviously relate to the very relevance of the comparison. Do the German and French initiatives go in the same direction or do they differ? In one case or the other, it is necessary to note the causes of such similarity or divergence, that they are explained by sociology, sociohistory, geopolitics, among others. It is then a question of comparing the different trajectories over a minimum period of 2 years.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Migration of youth in Africa is an emerging and growing phenomenon which, until recently, has received little attention in the extant literature. The bulging youth population in the region, accompanied by limited economic opportunities for the youth cohort, has spurred massive migration among this demographic group. Zimbabwe is one such country currently in the grip of a youth bulge and a serious migration of the youth to neighbouring countries and beyond. The country has an estimated population of 3 million people living in South Africa alone and the majority of them are young people. Though mobility is a fundamental human activity and a very vital component of developing human capital, reports suggest that host nations are reaching a breaking point; therefore a solution to abate this drift of young people should be sought. The harnessing of the demographic dividend through investing in the youth is one such solution high on the policy agenda of many African governments to deal with this trend. While welcoming the importance of such policy interventions, the paper argues that lack of political will, under-funding of youth programmes, and marginalisation of the youth in decision making, among a host of other issues, vitiate against any prospect of improving the conditions of the youth in Zimbabwe. This study, in contributing to the growing debate on youth vulnerability and migration in Africa, examines the link between youth empowerment and migration, and explores the youth migration trends in Southern Africa taking experiences from Zimbabwe. The study, based on an empirical study on youth empowerment programmes in Zimbabwe and secondary data collated on youth migration in Southern Africa, presents comprehensive perspectives on the complexities related to youth migration in connection to their vulnerability, and also appraises youth investment discourse of the African Union as a solution to youth migration.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Migration is a global phenomenon and globalization has created widespread opportunities for migrants to migrate to all corners of the world. Research on migration has focused on migrants from the Global South moving to the advanced economies in the Global North and South-South migration has been neglected. This paper aims to address this gap by presenting the case of South-South migration in the South Asian region.
United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime claims people from South Asia are the most mobile people when it comes to migration (UNODC, 2007), contribute about 15 percent to the global migrant stock (including refugees and asylum seekers) and receive about 20 percent of total global migrant remittances (World Bank, 2015). This region encompasses the four top-ten migrant source countries (India, Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan) and two of the top-ten largest migration corridors (India-Bangladesh and Afghanistan-Pakistan). Moreover, the grey literature assumes that there are a significant number of illegal migrants living and working in this region because of poor regulation policies and lax enforcement. No travel documents are required for movements between India and Nepal or India and Bhutan, distorting the real picture of trans-border migration.
Given the regions’ importance and contribution in the global migrant labour market and economy, it is important to better understand the policies and programs directly or indirectly impacting migration in this region. It is also important to clarify how regional policies interact with policy developments in Northern recipient countries. For example, reform to immigration policies in the USA and Europe (de Hass et. al., 2018) has restricted prospective migrants and discouraged chain migration (Krikorian, 2017). Moreover, the ‘Nation without violators’ campaign in Saudi Arabia, enforcement of the Sponsorship Scheme in the United Arab Emirates and Qatar, and forcible return from several countries have pressured labour migrants to return to their home countries.
Similarly, the Colombo Process and the Abu Dhabi Dialogue (ADD) are regional networks advocating on behalf of migration management issues in this region and a few of other neighbour Global South countries. Therefore, heeding the call of the Colombo Process and Abu Dhabi Dialogue, there is an urgent need in South Asia to reduce the cost of migration, ensure fair and regular migration, and secure effective utilization of remittances.
This paper will conduct an analysis of the major policies and programs impacting migration in the South Asian region to identify pragmatic solutions to the following issues:
a) Ensuring safe, decent and reliable migration opportunities in the South Asian region; and
b) Ensuring better management of migrant remittances
The outcome of this research paper will be a set of recommendations to encourage safe, orderly and regular migration in this region.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) is a relief and human development agency, providing education, healthcare, social services and emergency aid to over five million Palestinian refugees living in Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, the West Bank & the Gaza Strip. The agency was established by the UN in 1949 as a temporary response to the plight of approximately three quarters of a million Palestinians who became refugees following the 1948 Arab Israel war.
In the succeeding decades, the UNRWA played a significant role in the drama of the Middle East conflict. As this drama has unfolded, the future of the Agency has been the subject of debate in the international community as well as among political scientists and negotiators. This discussion was renewed in 1993 after the Oslo Accords, which were signed by Israel and the Palestinian Liberation Organization. It was further intensified with the concomitant collapse of the Oslo negotiations process and the onset of the second Intifada in September 2000. Following the Trump’s administration recent announcement to cut its fund to UNRWA (nearly $300 million a year), and the state of Israel National Security Council decision of Jan 2019 that revoked the permits allowing UNRWA schools to operate in Jerusalem, the spotlight is once again focused on the agency which becomes, as a result of the conflict and Gaza blockade, an instrumental lifeline for refugees and non refugees alike.
In the context of this renewed interest in UNRWA as well as recent attacks by the Israeli government and funding cuts by the US, the objective of this paper is to assess such policy responses and examine its ramifications for the 5 million refugees living in UNRWA fields of operations. The paper will also assess the impact of these moves on reaching a future settlement to the Palestinian refugee question within the context of UN Resolution 194 (III) of December 1948 and in line with the international norms pertaining to human rights and refugee protection.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
While the experiences and identities of refugees are multiple and complex, dominant representations at the media, in politics and policies tend to reinforce stereotypes of identity, gender, etc. These common perceptions of social reality tend to create stereotypes and to then stigmatise : refugee men are often perceived as a "threat" and women as "vulnerable".
"Otherisation", criminalisation and victimisation are thus often the three modes under which the collective imaginary, dominant in politics and in the media, represents refugees in general. The result is a series of more controlling and administrative policies, rather than humanitarian - a boundary that is becoming increasingly blurred, as "any policy of assistance is simultaneously an instrument of control" (AGIER, 2008, p.24).
In the face of their victimisation, de-humanisation or criminalisation, over which refugees themselves have no say, it is expected of them an incapacity to act, the loss of their agency, the impossibility to see among refugees any form of political organisation, any development of individual and / or collective strategies to confront the constraints imposed by exile. On the contrary, it is possible to observe many initiatives of political, humanitarian, associative or commercial nature, or simply individual or collective strategies to cope with refugeness. Since 2011, despite the difficulties and increasing pressure on refugees, Syrians living in Turkey and Jordan have developed new social structures based on family, friendship, professional or religious ties. These are often informal networks that already existed in Syria or were created in exile.
But if refugees are just nameless victims, with no history, no voice and who are only entitled only to a humanitarian protection, how these initiatives can persist? Or, if they are simply threatening men or passive women who lack the power to act, how are they able to develop different forms of action in exile, even in the face of coercitive policies ?
This study aims to question how refugees develop individual or collective strategies under contraint. What are the forms of these strategies? What are the social practices and institutional frameworks leading refugees to develop these actions? It is a matter of studying the agency of refugees but without neglecting the structures and mechanisms shaping their actions. It is an opportunity to study the process unfolding these "actions" by which refugees, here agents, construct and transform themselves in exile, without neglecting the violence that they may suffer in this process.
The question of the agency of refugees, their strategies, is crucial to understand the State and the implementation of public policies, based on categories artificially created. It questions not only the categories assigned to people fleeing their countries, but it also challenges the same borders that constitute the State - here physical boundaries that refugees must overcome but also symbolic ones. The use of the word agency in this study intends to break with the postulate of a passive refugee, who is only a subject of humanitarian aid and who submits him/herself to a host State as a guest, undesired, without resisting or transforming her/his reality in exile. It is also an opportunity to question the term refugee itself in order to find a subject in exile, while simultaneously debating the presuppositions of the State, such as borders and citizenship. In order to analyse this process, this study is based on a series of semi-structured interviews with Syrians in Turkey and Jordan. The interviews were conducted in several cities, with different profiles in 2016 and 2017. This methodology is complemented with a more anthropological / ethnological approach.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The estimated one million Rohingyas, a Muslim minority group from the Rakhine state of Myanmar, are not recognized by the Government of Myanmar, which considers them illegal immigrants from Bangladesh instead. The large scale violence against them in 2012 and 2015 has forced them flee to neighbouring states of Southeast Asia and Bangladesh as refugees. Most of them are now living in refugee camps in Bangladesh.
International response to the violence against Rohingyas was initially mixed as governments were trying to support the peaceful transition to democracy from military rule in Myanmar but in recent years, criticisms have been scaled up from all directions, including the United Nations while several states have imposed sanctions. Recently, ASEAN member states have publicly called on Myanmar to hold those responsible for the Rohingya crisis accountable and to start the repatriation process from Bangladesh.
An analysis of this humanitarian crisis highlights how mass displacement caused by conflicts and violence is a defining feature of the contemporary world and a major cause of human insecurity. This paper analyses the response of the international community to the Rohingya humanitarian crisis. Based on the framework of migration governance, it stresses the importance of cooperation between different stakeholders to address this humanitarian emergency given its profound impact in local stability and regional security, besides human security. A qualitative approach is adopted for this research which analyses studies centred around internal aspects of the crisis and its humanitarian dimension, in order to reconceptualise migration regional governance studies.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since 2015, Germany has implemented quite a number of legal changes concerning the countries’ asylum and integration policy. In this context, particularly one significant policy change can be identified: The division of asylum seekers in those with a “good perspective to remain in Germany” and those with a “bad perspective to remain in Germany”, both of which are linked to specific opportunities for integration or the lack thereof. While asylum seekers with a “good perspective to remain” are granted access to particular integration tools, like language courses and training assistance, those with a “bad perspective to remain” are prohibited from working, and denied access to formal education. Whether someone has a good or a bad “perspective to remain” (German: “Bleibeperspektive”) depends on his/her country of origin. Implemented with the asylum package 1 (“Asylpaket 1”) in October 2015, the concept “Bleibeperspektive” is quite new and has not made it to the academic agenda yet. Before its implementation, the access to the integration tools mentioned above depended on the outcome of a persons’ individual asylum procedure. Therefore, refugees in the status “asylum seeker”, meaning people whose asylum procedure has not been completed yet, did not have access to the integration tools in general. Furthermore, there were no work and training bans for asylum seekers from specific countries of origin. Bringing forward the decision over a refugees’ integration chances to the time of his/her asylum procedure, and linking it to his/her country of origin, is a major policy change that might fit into Peter Halls category of third order change (Hall 1993). While a principle of equal treatment was in force before the implementation of “Bleibeperspektive”, asylum seekers’ access to integration and social participatory chances became selective and unequal afterwards. This policy change happened mostly outside of the public and academic perception. By first describing “Bleibeperspektive”, placing it into Halls’ categorization, and putting it into an historical and discursive context, the paper contributes to research on integration and asylum policy in Germany and fills a significant research gap. As the topic has not been scientifically explored yet, attempts to explain the emergence of “Bleibeperspektive” need to draw on previous research from the broader field of policy analysis and test its applicability. That is why the paper discusses how existing theoretical approaches from the field of policy analysis can contribute to an analysis of "Bleibeperspektive" and explain the emergence of this specific policy change in a second step.
In conclusion, the paper does not only offer brand-new information on a far-reaching policy change in Germanys’ asylum- and integration policy, but also adds to existing research by giving perspectives for the analysis of up-to-date policy change in a complex policy field which has not been sufficiently researched so far.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Recent events and the rise of Islamophobia across much of the West and Europe in particular have led to evolving patterns in exclusion. For a long time now, immigration from the global South has been used by the far right and nationalist movements as a threat to a fantasised autochthonous and indigenous population, whose very survival is at stake. This has even been argued more recently to be a case of reverse colonialism, where those once colonised now acted as coloniser. In post-racial societies, this reactionary development has necessitated contortions from the far right, which has had to adapt its discourse to its new context.
In this paper, we aim to explore the way the far right has attempted to use successfully some liberal tropes to defend its illiberal project, and how this played out in different national context. Focusing particularly on what has been termed homonationalism by Jasbir Puar, this paper seeks to understand how the far right has attempted use gay rights and equality, once reviled enemies, against what it posed as ‘Muslim immigration’. This is puzzling, particularly considering the pronatalist position of the far right, and how they have excluded and attacked homosexuals based on their allegedly anti-family and anti-children stance.
By examining this strategy based on the enemy of my enemy is my friend, we aim to demonstrate that the liberal approach to gay rights by anti-immigration groups could evolve and become anchored in an illiberal project, where gay rights are only defended for racist reasons and are thus subject to only tenuous and superficial support. To do so, we will build on the framework developed by Aurelien Mondon and Aaron Winter on liberal and illiberal articulations of Islamophobia, which argues that the use of once progressive tropes, such as gay rights, but also women’s rights, secularism and free speech, has become a key strategy to push Islamophobic agendas, as it has allowed actors to dissociate themselves from the traditional extreme right.
The empirical material will be the intersecting representations of anti-immigration and Islamophobic discourse and gay equality issues in the public sphere. Particularly, reports, statements by gender lobbies and Churches, party and interest group campaign material, and general documentation of any related issues by both gender rights and immigrant rights groups will be under study. The context of study is particularly the immigration from the Middle East following the Arab Spring to Central and Western Europe. Hence, its context is mainly states such as Hungary, France, and the UK. Yet, it also presents and relates to empirical evidence from a variety of other European contexts within its general conceptual scope.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this paper is to identify the major issues and gaps in the literature pertaining to international migration, with special attention to the contributions of political scientists to the field of policy studies. Since the end of the 1990s, migration studies has grown as a field, and has been populated by both more comparative, and relatedly policy-relevant, research. However, as we will demonstrate through a recent review of the literature, this work has for the most part focused on countries of the global north, particularly in Europe, North America and Australasia. In particular, we address a tendency to focus on issues from within a framework that veers from an emphasis on integration (of welcomed migrants) and control (of unwanted migrants) in these locales, with only sporadic attention to ethics and colonial legacies. By attending to an empirical analysis of recent research trends with respect to both global and regional migration dynamics and refugee settlement, our paper probes the consequences of this gap in the literature when it comes to the global South. We assess the ethical implications of having such a limited research focus and reflect on issues of knowledge construction and power.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The recent ‘refugee crisis’ emerging from the Middle East, has given rise to questions concerning gender relations by global south scholars about these communities. The emerging inequalities have often been analyzed through a gendered lens with a specific concentration on women’s sexuality. Through a postcolonial perspective, this paper will focus on the Yazidi community in Iraq as a means of expanding our understanding of gendered based violence by focusing on land dispossession, social reproduction, and displacement. In order to further examine issues of sexual slavery and child marriage, this paper will contextualize these issues in the broader political and social context within the global south and in relation to the global north. By specifically focusing on the Yazidi community in Iraq, this paper will unpack women’s positionality beyond their framing as merely victims of sexual violence that dominates the discourses of the ‘refugee crisis’. This paper will do so by situating the changing gender relations within the brutality utilized by state making/unmaking as strategies of terror and land disposition that are both new and continuous - through capitalism, imperialism, and gendered violence. This paper seeks to advance a methodological contribution to migration studies by focusing specifically on the Yazidi community’s experiences of gendered based violence that are intimately connected to land dispossession and displacement in the global south.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Southeast Asia’s response to forced migration is reflective in the enforcement gaps noted in its prevention measures and protection mechanisms for stateless, refugee and non-refugee, children against human trafficking. The Hague Process on Refugees and Migration Foundation Handbook describes the term ‘forced migration’ as the movement of people ‘in which an element of coercion predominates’. The aim of this research is to examine the ASEAN Intergovernmental Commission on Human Rights, and proffer recommendations for change in its ten Member States approach to forced migration and the protection of stateless children against human trafficking. Within the ASEAN Charter States, only Cambodia, East Timor, and the Philippines have ratified the 1951 Refugee Convention. None of the ASEAN States have ratified the 1954 UN Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons Convention or the 1961 UN Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness. Yet, research shows that in Southeast Asia, forced migrating stateless children are trafficked through either a source, transit, or destination State and the incredulous crime encroaches upon cultural, economic, social, political, civil, and human rights.
Keywords: ASEAN Charter States: Bangladesh, Brunei, Burma, Cambodia, East Timor, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Mongolia, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, and Viet Nam forced migration, human trafficking, The Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, 1951 Refugee Convention and its 1967 Protocol, The 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons, the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness, and UN Convention on the Rights of the Child
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The kafala system is the main policy by which the Arab Gulf States control immigration and migrant workers post-entry. While there is extensive political debates on the human rights abuses that migrant workers often confront in the Gulf, much of academic scholarship about this cluster of states that together form the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) tends to emphasize the exclusionary practices of this policy, often highlighting the ‘exceptionality’ of the Gulf’s immigration policy regimes. It is true that the Gulf’s migration narrative is exceptional given that over half of these states populations (with the exception of Saudi Arabia) are temporary migrant workers with no path towards naturalization, this paper argues that the kafala system itself is not exceptional. To make this point, I explore the various institutional and non-institutional actors and elements that together form an assemblage of noncitizenship, thus challenging what scholars have conventionally conceived of as a cohesive system of managing transnational movement.
This paper suggests that the Kafala system, like most migration regimes in large migrant-receiving regions in the Global North, is characterized by the differential inclusion of mobile bodies. In addition, I explore the multiplication of borders that takes place once the geographic borders have been crossed. In so doing, our analysis transcends the binary of citizen/non-citizen to explore the ethnic, gendered, and classed borders that shape the varied experiences of people living in the Gulf. Finally, this theoretical contribution seeks to intervene in extant understandings of migration and citizenship regimes outside of the Global North, underscoring the regional and international factors that inform the Gulf countries immigration policies and their implications on migrant lives by situating them within a transnational and international context.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
There is a connection between developed nations panic about migration flow and the increasing span and comprehensiveness of migration management. That connection locates the increasing comprehensiveness of migration management not on the wellbeing of the migrants but on the welfare of citizens. As Geiger and Pecoud (2013, 19) argues “[t]he government of international migration and the treatment of foreign populations working and living within nation-states must therefore be understood as a form of governmentality that aims first and foremost for the preservation of the status and welfare of citizens”. Thus, one can argue that the need to support a focus on border control, coercion and exclusion with heavily funded campaigns, projects, development aids, etc does not deviate from the rationality that is inherent in the statal paternalistic watch over its citizens. That will hypothesize that an immigration stringent country is a citizen catering country. Using the history (1998 – 2018) of social provision for citizens and immigration regulations in Finland and South Africa, I critically examine the discourse of a caring state in a context of increasing hostility towards the foreign other on the one hand, and a shrinking social policy on the other. In the ensuing melee of losses and gains, the wellbeing of citizens vs migrants are bargaining chips for populist gains, migrants become pawns in a politics of divide and rule, even as the state welcomes deserving migrants as new citizens.
Reference:
Geiger, Martin, and Antoine Pecoud, eds. 2013. Disciplining the Transnational Mobility of People. London, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Ombudsmen as a Soft/Human Security Policy Agent in Migration Issues (European North Area Case)
Around Barents and Baltic Seas Russia occupies a pivotal position in the path of East-West migrations, sharing borders with a key destination Nordic/Baltic states, (by water) with some West European countries. Migration issues are one of conceptualized via soft[1] and/or human security approaches[2]. The European Union pursues its policies mostly through «soft security» mechanisms, like European Neighbourhood Policy (ENP), Northern Dimension (ND) and «Eastern Partnership» (EP). The Russian cooperation with North Europe is developing in framework of Council of the Baltic Sea States (CBSS), institutions under the Barents Euro-Arctic Region (BEAR) and the Nordic Council of Ministers (NCM) activity, whose agenda initiatives is of applied character where social issues are prevailing. CBSS currently is concentrating on the issues of common interests (economic cooperation, environment, energy, education) and “slightly” avoiding the conflict issues (human rights, for example). Border Guards developed a modern formation in charge of a significant stretch of EU’s external frontier, the service is positioned to become a crucial part of the Schengen area’s protection against illegal and/or irregular migration[3]. Civil society organizations and think-tanks as well as Ombudsmen are deeply involved in the protection of rights of immigrants.
On the economic side, the EU-Russian governmental relations are controversial in issues of asses to trade, development of energy export corridors and on the prospects for increasing investments in (border) regions. At the same time this proximity of Russia’s North-western regions to Europe and the EU accession of Nordic & Baltic States, are by some perceived as an obstacle, rather than a benefit to their economic development, political profile and regional security. Nevertheless, common concern is irregular and/or illegal migration (especially female and youth, incl. trafficking in Human being). Policy debates on illegality in the immigration and employment of migrants are typically based on simple conceptual dichotomies, for instance “legal/illegal”, “regular/irregular”, “authorized/unauthorized” or “documented/undocumented”. However, the legal frameworks that govern the immigration, residence and employment of migrants in most destination countries are typically quite intricate. This means that, in practice, it is “spaces of (il)legality” that are created. The spaces of (il)legality are contested, particularly where complex immigration laws collide with flexible labour markets[4]. With normative and structural discourse analysis methodology we are going to analyze ongoing situation reflected in Ombudsman’s activity in number of states in area.
[1] Rothschild E. What is Security? // Daedalus. - 1995. - Summer. - P. 53-98
[2] Сhen, Lincoln C. Human Security: Concepts and Approaches // Common Security in Asia: New Concepts of Human Security / Matsumae, Tatsuro and Chen, Lincoln C. (eds.). - Tokyo, 1995. P. 139.
[3]Definitions used by European Ombudsmen and their opinions towards issues are given in the brochure: Protection the Human rights of irregular migrants: the role of National Human Rights Structures. – Council of Europe & University of Padua, 2009.
[4] World Migration Report 2008. Chapter 8. IRREGULAR MIGRATION, by Graziano Battistella, Director, Scalabrini International Migration Institute, Rome, Italy. URL: http://www.iom.int/jahia/webdav/site/myjahiasite/shared/shared/mainsite/published_docs/studies_and_reports/WMR2008/Ch8_WMR08.pdf (accessed: 2011 February)
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The vast majority of democratic theory assumes the need for widespread political participation. The right to vote constitutes the most essential political right but in the era of migration the idea of universal suffrage is far from being realized.
The Grand Duchy of Luxembourg within its current borders is the result of 19th century diplomacy. In the space of less than 150 years the population of this state more than doubled - largely attributable to immigration. Today, 48% of the population are foreigners. The history of the creation of the Grand Duchy and the Law on Luxembourg Nationality are closely intertwined – the latter having undergone several changes – reflecting historic circumstances. The evolution of the Law on Luxembourgish Nationality and the discussions around “what constitutes a Luxembourger” illustrate the changes in perception of “Luxembourg nationality”. The underlying fundamental question is whether naturalization is the mid – or endpoint of successful integration into the host society.
In this paper we will outline the different phases of the Luxembourg Law on Nationality, starting with the period of the French civil Code and ending with the current amendments of the naturalization law.
This paper reflects the relation between migration and changes in the naturalization law in Luxembourg. The authors show how successive Luxembourgish governments have accommodated citizenship rights of foreign nationals, but are constrained by political groups defending national preferences. Overall, Luxembourg can be described as an immigration success story, facing the future challenge of accommodating all groups living in Luxembourg.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Human mobility creates significant challenges both to sending and receiving contexts. The human mobility in the Mediterranean since the 1990s has attracted significant attention from academics as well as policy-makers. The recent migration flows from Syria have enlarged the scale of the challenge as the numbers have increased significantly. Given such a mobile region, it is important to analyze the changes to the legal frameworks governing citizenship and naturalization procedures and the factors that impact the direction of these changes in the Northern Mediterranean. Integration of immigrants is an important area and the policies and laws that are in place in the receiving countries determine the extent to which non-citizens can have access to rights. This paper examines the citizenship law and discourse in the northern Mediterranean countries (Italy, Spain, Greece and Turkey) over the last decade of increased human mobility. There is today a recognition that these countries have become receiving countries. The aim of the paper is to investigate the impact of political parties and election campaigns, judiciary, civil society and media on debates and changes to the citizenship law (in particular to naturalization policies and patterns). In each context there are pro- as well as anti-immigration movements, rights-based and needs-based NGOs in addition to immigrant associations. The politicization of migration and the use of immigration and refugees as an issue in election campaigns also differs. Given this diversity, it is important to evaluate the direction of change and the factors which bring about change in these northern Mediterranean countries. The EU-level response to such human mobility will also be incorporated into the research as to whether there is a potential to develop collaborative responses to increased human mobility without over-burdening these immediate receivers of immigrants and refugees. This research is significant as citizenship policy can be seen as a tool for the incorporation of immigrants and naturalization can encourage the public to recognize immigrants as their equals and develop a shared sense of belonging which is important for democratic ethos. The paper argues that although there is path dependency in the way citizenship laws change, there can be unexpected results at times of critical junctures. Public debate on the issue and civil society pressure in attempting to incorporate immigrants into political community seem to be the most important factors influencing change, yet politicization of the issue may not always result in favorable outcomes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The dynamics of complex (international) migration situation in the EU and its neighborhood after 2010, with the peak in 2015–2016, has attracted much attention in the Union itself and in the region. This was mainly in relation to increasing migratory flows towards Europe that were defined as forced, mixed or irregular (categories treated separately). The scale of the discussed phenomenon in 2014–2018 can be approximated by selected indicators provided by different actors. UNHCR reported there were more than million sea arrivals across the Mediterranean to Europe in 2015 and 5.1 thousand people considered ‘dead’ or ‘went missing’ in 2016; Frontex informed about 1.8 detected cases of illegal crossing of the EU’s external borders between border crossing points in 2015, and EASO/Eurostat indicated the number of 1.3 million non-EU asylum applicants in the EU member states in both years of 2015–2016 peak. As a result, the concept of migration and refugee crisis in the media narrative, political discourse and research began to be widely used in Europe and beyond. The crisis and its consequences exposed the need for a far-reaching reform of EU’s migration, asylum and border management policy. This was reflected in the Commission's communication on the European Agenda on Migration (EAM) from May 2015 and since then it has been repeated in its implementation reports. In December 2018, the European Commission in its recent progress report under the EAM stated that the EU and its Member States had established a comprehensive approach to migration management and related challenges, composing of three core action elements, encompassing action with partners outside the EU, at EU’s external borders and inside the EU. However, at the same time, the report stressed that “it is time to move away from temporary internal border controls and ad hoc migration management, towards sustainable solutions”.
This paper presents and discusses the migration and asylum situation in the EU in the context of the migration and refugee crisis and the EU’s policy in this field. It focuses on the analysis of the implementation of the European Agenda on Migration since 2015 and its effectiveness, as well as on the analysis of the direction of EU’s policy reforms in the area of migration, asylum and management of external borders. The author’s aim is to explore how the migration policy agenda resulting from the EAM was developed and implemented; who were the main stakeholders and what was their involvement, and finally, to what extent the EAM’s implementation was successful and corresponded to the MLG concept. To address these questions, the paper refers to the results of the author's research conducted at the Collegium of Socio-Economics of SGH Warsaw School of Economics.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Brazil's National Transport Infrastructure Department, DNIT, founded in 2001, is a federal agency that manages Brazil's waterways, roadways, and railways, as well intermodal facilities, river and lake ports. Currently, DNIT is responsible for managing approximately 52,000 km of roads, 300 km of railroads and 20,000 km of waterways.
Amongst DNIT´s competencies lays the complex responsibility of expropriating lands and displacing people in order to increase or improve Brazilian´s road network. When expropriation affects regular landowners, national laws assure their rights to property by means of expropriation procedures. However, when it affects people who do not have legal or customary tenure of houses or land they inhabit or utilize, the law does not guarantee any compensation.
It is important to highlight that the Brazilian housing deficit and the lack of land regularization often result in a high number of irregular and precarious settlements including the occupation of public road protection zones. Prior to 2009, DNIT’s default policy towards those vulnerable affected families occupying irregular areas of interest was to displace them by offering an insufficient cash compensation or even no compensation at all. However, as the Brazilian democratic institutions became more solid, DNIT was impelled to rethink its policy and started to assure social rights granted by the Federal Constitution or in International Treaties complies with.
Consequently, the department started to collect data on the displaced families and to get better understanding of their social and economic characteristics. Nevertheless, the data collected was scattered among the local offices throughout Brazil and had never been processed and analyzed before. Therefore, this paper aims to present, for the first time, the quantitative and qualitative data of 15 different infrastructure projects carried out by DNIT, which displaced over 2,500 squatters and encroachers since 2013.
The proposed paper will contribute to the Migration and Citizenship: Policies and Research in Global Comparative Perspective panel since it will shed light on unfulfilled questions regarding the oustees, such as occupation length, education level, family structures, cultural values, employment, and householder’s genders.
A structured diagnosis is the first step to a clear understanding of the context of these informal occupations. This will enable DNIT to start planning effective compensation frameworks considering not only financial aspects but also historical, cultural and structural features.
The Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (IDMC), the world's official source of data on internal displacement, claim that it is still not possible to cover displacement associated with development projects in global figures yet. Thus, these data can also contribute to international research regarding internal displacements.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Authors: Michael McCormack (presenting) and Jody Heymann
Economic push and pull factors remain one of the major forces contributing to migration flows around the world today. Economic migrants of all skill levels, occupations and industries apply for temporary work visas in search of better opportunities in nations with strong labor markets. The significant demand for domestic work in countries in the Global North and the Global South has made it a substantial share of migrant labor flows in today’s global economy. It is also well documented that migrant workers in this occupation are especially vulnerable to exploitation, mistreatment and social exclusion.
This paper examines how the gendered nature of domestic work is embedded within the work permit regulations for immigrant workers in domestic work occupations. Using new comparative law and policy data on migration from the 150 most-populous UN member states created at the WORLD Policy Analysis Center at the University of California Los Angeles, we examine differences in the protections and conditions of domestic work permits versus general work permits and those permits more likely to be filled by men. This data provides evidence of how the opportunities of marginalized groups are curtailed through the terms and conditions of work permits specific to domestic workers across 20 countries within the 150 countries in the database. Among those countries with work permits specific to domestic work, domestic work permits are more restrictive in regard to renewability, lengths of validity, and are more likely to place restrictions on changing terms of employment. Restrictions on family reunification for domestic work permit holders were common. Comparisons between conditions of domestic work between the Global North and Global South will also be explored. More equitable conditions between work permits regardless of gender composition will be essential to reducing inequality among marginalized populations across all regions.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
EU internal migration is mainly regulated by Directive 2004/38/EC, so called the Citizenship Directive. This European Directive allows all nationals from the 28Th Member States to move and reside within the territory of other Member States. This freedom of movement can be nevertheless limited by the host Member States, when there is a threat to their public policy. There is no European definition of this threat and Member States retain the freedom to determine the requirements of public policy and public security in accordance with their needs, which can vary from one Member State to another and from one period to another. This multiplicity of national definitions generates diverse and divergent responses to migration issues. There is a clear need for a common perspective. And the EU citizenship, that unites all the nationals of the 28th Member States, seems powerless against the reluctance of the Member States to give up their sovereignty on these key issues. EU citizenship does not mean automatically equal treatment for EU migrants within the territory of the European Union. The paper proposes to examine the difficulties of agreeing on common grounds regarding migration key issues. This lack of will is even present into a very integrated regional organization such as the European Union. It is a fight between Member States’ sovereignty and a common migration policy. It will also address the question of the helplessness of a common Citizenship. Are there some migration issues that cannot be the subject of a common policy? Or is there a future for an European public policy?
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the wake of ongoing migration crises and debates, Nawyn (2016) urges migration scholars to question whether their theoretical presuppositions capture the full complexity of migration as it is experienced today. Likewise, Dauvergne (2016) has pointed to a “policy paralysis in immigration regulation” under which our current guiding conceptual narratives of economics and human rights have been inadequate in providing solutions to the globe’s most pressing migration problems. From this, Dauvergne suggests the need for re-imagining immigration in a way that re-orients us to value “immigration for reasons that are not economic, and [advocate] on the basis of reasons that are not rights” (2016, p. 205). These critiques align with those made by scholars of care ethics, who have voiced concerns regarding the primacy of economics in our politics and the limitations of human rights frameworks to bring about justice (Tronto, 2013).
Grounded first in the Canadian context, this paper will present the theoretical argument that care ethics provides a plausible framework from which to re-imagine immigration politics, shifting our focus to the relational elements of immigration. Fundamentally, this requires recognition of interdependency of both sending and receiving countries, in the Global North and Global South, that is grounded in a contextual sensitivity that resists abstracting away from the lives of individual migrants, a responsiveness that is attentive to the needs and stories of migrants as they express them, and for states to take responsibility for and recognise the consequences of their political and policy choices (Hankivsky, 2004).
To begin to realize this project, we need to extend our care ethics and beyond the context of a caring state in which members care for each other (Tronto, 2013), to come to understand citizenship and migration statuses more broadly as tools used by the state to set limits on caring obligations (Sharma, 2006). It will therefore be suggested that re-imagining of immigration grounded in care ethics is an imagining which must take its cue from movements which resist the ways nation states and global systems convince us that “you can’t have affective ties at a global level” (Jefferies, 2015), despite the numerous other ways globalization ties us together. It therefore requires the fore-fronting of new, or previously marginalized, narratives that allow for a new imagining of migration in a way that transcends divisions and provides the basis for the deconstruction of structures that seek to maintain them.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
There is an increasing interest in examining the gendered and racial aspects linked with the immigration policies of the Global North, yet, so far, research in analyzing immigration policies of the Global South and the vulnerabilities of migrated impoverished racialized women to the Global South is scant. Namely, Bangladeshi migrated women as domestic workers to the United Arab Emirates (UAE) often encountered physical and sexual violence by their employers. Many such women have returned to Bangladesh and also faced challenges to be accommodated in the society. Although some migration groups demanded better laws to ensure the safety of these workers, the government of UAE is reluctant to address this issue. Bangladeshi Government also provides minimum support to these victims. Despite the frequent news of violence against domestic workers in the UAE, many Bangladeshi women still eager to migrate to the UAE, and the Bangladeshi government also encourages such immigration. While before the 1980s., Bangladeshi women hardly worked in the public sectors, a significant change has occurred since the period. Globalization, industrialization, urbanization, modernization, and women’s economic empowerment discourses are linked with a remarkable number of women working in the public sectors. The lack of job opportunity and low wages often push impoverished Bangladeshi women to move to other countries. As the immigration systems of the Global North mainly focus on skilled and educated workers, the only option has left for these impoverished and illiterate women to go somewhere in the Global South. Middlemen generally send these domestic workers to the UAE without ensuring the minimum safety and security. Lack of the Government’s surveillance on the immigration business in Bangladesh is also connected with these women’s suffering. So, impoverished Bangladesh women’s migration to the Global South is a complex issue, which needs an urgent examination. First, this paper draws on academic literature on immigration policies and the gap in academic literature. Second, the political history of migration of impoverished Bangladesh women to the UAE will be discussed. Finally, this paper focuses on stories of such women, published on online news after 2005, because these marginalized women's stories will tell all relations of subordination, including gender, racial, and class subordination.
This paper is relevant to the panel “T02P04 / Migration and Citizenship: Policies and Research in Global Comparative Perspective” because it examines the gap of studying the political history of women’s migration to the Global South to the Global South. Further, it addresses how race, class, and gender categories complicate the experiences of female migrant domestic workers in the Global South. As the panel aims to bridge the dialog between the scholars of the Global South and the Global North, this paper could contribute to the bridging.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Between 2007 and 2013, more than 64,000 migrants crossed irregularly the Israeli-Egyptian border, among which more than 90% Sudanese and Eritrean asylum seekers. This phenomenon, a side effect of increasing anti-migration policies in Western Europe and North America pushing refugees toward new exodus routes, was responded by the toughening of Israeli border control and by the institutionalization of an asylum system designed to produce non-refugees. Since then, Israeli repressive policy interrupted the entry of new African migrants and pushed half of this population to leave. Therefore Israel, established as a safe haven for Jewish refugees and claiming to be “the only democracy in the Middle-East”, came to the forefront of deterrence policies against asylum seekers.
The proposed paper offers an empirically-based analysis of the transformations in the asylum policy, while revealing the particularities of the Israeli trajectory in global context. Drawing on interviews with actors of the Israeli asylum system and on a critical reading of official documents, I show how the introduction and bureaucratization of asylum procedures and refugee determination mechanisms, with the involvement of the UNHCR and foreign governments from Western Europe and North America, have yielded the simultaneous criminalization of most asylum seekers as “infiltrators”.
While showing how the Israeli policy is entangled with processes of asylum restriction and anti-immigration measures characteristic of the Global North, I will emphasize 1) that anti-immigration policies and technologies are translated into vernacular terms and rationales, bearing the imprint of a longer biopolicial history of Zionist statecraft; and 2) the importance of challenging the conception of Israel as a “Villa in the jungle” or as an “Island surrounded with Arab barbarism” through transforming the comparative perspective. While scholars usually compare Israel only with states from the Global North, I would like to ask- what can we learn from comparing the Israeli policy toward asylum seekers with neighboring countries and with other countries in the Middle East? Such a comparative perspective can shed new light over the Israeli “asylum crisis”, over official and unofficial modes of inclusion and exclusion, over the way Israeli policy deals with domestic law and international conventions, and over the role of and relations with international organisms like UNHCR and foreign governments.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
How do African Union policies address the question of irregular migration within the Continent? Does the AU have a Framed policy of the fight irregular migration in Africa?
Migrations as well as other issues of security, development and peace have appeared as crucial issues of the African Union (AU) since 2013. The fact that such questions have led to the emergence of new policy tools such as action’s plans for migrations, Agendas 2063, it possible to deduce that the governance of critical issues within the Continent is given more attention.
For what concerns migration, the Political Action Plans (2013-2018), (2018-2027) says a lot about the policy framework of migrations in Africa with a lot being said about the different types, less is said about the legal instruments which clearly address the issue.
Indeed, an analysis of the policy framework raise two major limits: the concerns the nature of instruments and the degree of sanction. Institutions are the main focus, and as well, the study of such policies of AU may help to raise two problems: the question of the nature of instruments of regulation, and of their enforcement. When this comes to specific domain of migrations such as Smuggling, human trafficking, modern slavery, the focus is on the protection of human rights of categories without addressing responsibilities. So the aim of this proposal is to apprehend the body of policies related to the AU’s governance of irregular migrations in Africa focusing on AU’s elaborated instruments as well as international treaties signed by members’ States. By doing so the project seeks to highlight the backdrop for a further comprehensive policy of irregular migration as a tool for the governance of the phenomenon in Africa.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
As the migration policy domain becomes more complex, diverse, and transnational, understanding the actors, institutions, ideas, intentions, and discourses shaping migration cannot be conceptualized as being shaped solely by the migrant receiving developed countries.
Based on a desk review of information gathered from academic publications, government reports, and grey literature, this paper describes the temporary migration experiences and trajectories of Sri Lankans, from a migrant sending country’s perspective. It aims to compare the Sri Lankan experience with the global context and the prevailing assumptions about labor migration.
The body of literature on international migration from Sri Lanka is largely dominated by studies of temporary labor migration.[i] Majority of these works focus on drivers of migration, remittances sent back home, health and social consequences of migration, and domestic economic impacts. International regulations and memorandum of understanding between countries guide temporary labor migration, a national policy provides an overarching framework for monitoring, evaluating and regulating agencies that train workers, and the Bureau of Foreign Employment regularly publishes comprehensive data on its outcomes.[ii] Although temporary labor migration, from a global context, is understood as a feminized and unskilled migration pathway from developing-to-developed countries, the Sri Lankan experience no longer aligns with this trend. The migration of more than 200,000 Sri Lankans for work each year, predominantly to the Gulf Corporation Countries, has changed from a feminized unskilled labour supply to a male skilled worker scheme. The migration of females for work reduced from 70% in 1986 to less than 50% in 2010.[iii] Creating opportunities for domestic female labour and reporting on the effects on children left behind have helped in discouraging women with young children from seeking foreign employment since 2010. Temporary labor migration in this context is not only shaped by economic factors but policies that have responded to domestic needs and taken the social and health implications of female migration into consideration. The widely held political-economist views about the drivers of migration from developing-to developed countries would fall short in fully understanding the migration trends and trajectories in this setting.
In terms of the current structuration of migrant studies, this highlights an important conceptual disconnect. Migrant receiving countries concerned with filling labor market needs tend to examine migration policy from a gender-neutral political-economic lens. The same lens is often being applied to migrant sending countries focusing on the share of remittances sent/brought back home. Understanding the dynamic and context specific ways in which migration pathways diverge, and the factors that drive those policies requires a cross-border in-depth look at the migration policy domain. Frameworks taken in the global North and studies that are structured upon them can fail to achieve this goal.
Works cited:
[i] Warnasuriya D, Gamage P (2014). Labor migration in Sri Lanka select annotated bibliography, Colombo, Sri Lanka: Institute of Policy Studies.
[ii] International Organization of Migration (2018). Migration Governance Profile: The Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri Lanka.
[iii] Ministry of foreign employment promotion and welfare (2013) Migration Profile Sri Lanka. Colombo, Sri Lanka: Institute of Policy Studies.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Revision of the refugees and migration literature shows very few forced or displaced skilled
migration context and even less attention paid on the academicians trajectories. It is difficult
the find the sensitivity for highly skilled migration in the `displaced or forced` migration
theory. Further there is still not enough in their work-related acculturation or changes in their
job related well-being except for the occasional statistics on refugee breakdown of
employment in the host countries or financial studies where most of the literature focus on
economic income and inequality or sectoral discrimination issues.
The difficulty of obtaining data either qualitative or quantitative (Tigau, 2019) for field
research is the main reason behind the gap in the literature of highly skilled displaced
migration. This is very related to humanitarian approach during refugee registration
procedures where applicants’ human capital and skills are not the main case (DeVoretz et al. ,
2004).
According to Patrick and Steichen (2014), immigrants who arrived from 2000 onwards to
France, fared badly for first few years because of restrictions on foreign nationals working in
public sector, stringent requirements for certain jobs and occupational barriers. Here it is
important to mention Afonso`s (2016) typology of EU academic markets, were France is
categorized as close job market for foreigners.
Many refugee scientists are experiencing high level of unemployment and their skills are
significantly ignored. They are often facing under-employment or employed by low-skilled
jobs in host countries. The longer they experience under-employment, the more they lose self-
esteem and so as a result they lose their vocational attachment.
Through the project, I aim to create awareness by discussing recently arrived displaced
scientist’s labor market integration testimonies in France. This research focus on PAUSE
emergency program laurates as highly skilled displaced scientist and their potential
contribution to France economy by examining their labor market integration trajectories.
The main issues of labor market integration will be discussed from their job satisfaction, their
career plan, employment related plans, overall life satisfaction perception, difficulties to settle
down, overcome strategies against perceived difficulties for future employment, the personal
characteristics of experienced difficulties, attachment to workplace, testimonies of working
conditions, attractive factors to work in France, return intentions, life well-being, and some
similar sub-topics of work related acculturation.
To develop attractive policies which motivates highly skilled displaced migrants to stay in
France, it is important to understand trajectories of high skilled forced migrants (journalist,
artists, intellectuals, academicians etc) from the beginning of their journey (Simon, Steichen,
2014). To do it in-depth interview “Tell me your story” is conducted with displaced scientists
who are currently PAUSE emergency program laureates in France.
Based on the analysis of difficulties and overcome strategies identified during interview, this
papers aims to provide two types of recommendations as such; policy level recommendations
and recommendations for further research.
This research has three main parts as follow: theoretical discussion of highly skilled displaced
migration (HSDMs) and trajectories and narratives of HSDMs in France and discussion with
recommendations.
Keywords: Highly skilled displaced migration, academic unemployment, refugees’ labor
market integration, deskilling, reskilling, life well-being, job satisfaction work acculturation
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
This paper explains the current position of humanitarianism with regard to refugees in the Member States (MS) of the European Union (EU). It argues that the Member States´ adopted interpretations of the principles of solidarity and responsibility to protect (R2P) exclude refugees. The principle of solidarity is interpreted as sharing the refugees´ burden, among the Member States, associated with the arrival of refugees.[1] The paper assumes sharing the burden as the internal dimension of solidarity. Moreover, the external dimension of solidarity assumed as solidarity with the refugees is overlooked by the Member States. The paper argues that solidarity with refugees would be a human-centred approach of the external dimension of solidarity. Similarly, the Member States interpret the principle of R2P as the external dimension. This may allow intervention in a sovereign state on humanitarian grounds, while people fleeing war zones and seeking asylum in the Member States are presumed outside of the principle of R2P.[2] The paper further argues that the Member States have also an obligation to protect war-displaced refugees at home. It implies that the protection of refugees at home is the home-based approach of internal dimension of R2P. The Member States´ non-compliance of refugee protection under solidarity and R2P is due to limited interpretation of both humanitarian norms. This results in disregard of home-based and human-centred application of the humanitarian norms. Therefore, the paper argues for refugees´ inclusion in the humanitarian regimes through a broader interpretation of the principles of solidarity and R2P. It reasons that, following a human centre approach, solidarity should be read as a humanitarian responsibility to protect refugees (HRPR). Similarly, following a home-based approach, R2P should also be read as a humanitarian responsibility to protect refugees. This provides a common ground for refugees´ protection between R2P and asylum (Panebianco & Fontana 2005). The paper is divided into three parts: part one provides a theoretical review of the principle of solidarity; part two elaborates R2P; whereas, part three clarifies elusiveness around allocation of humanitarian responsibility between the EU and its Member States and highlights why the Member States have a greater humanitarian responsibility to protect refugees.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
For decades, in Canada we have been talking about models of integration of minorities and especially migration. It is argued that there is a British "communitarian" model of "multiculturalism" in which Canada is identified; a civic French model focused on national identity and an American model of "melting pot".
Using comparative policies in West Europe and North America, it is shown that these so-called "models" are far from reflecting reality and have become simplistic and grotesque concepts. Societies have changed and studies on each country have challenged these assumptions, for example Glazer & Moynihan (1970) have shown that the idea of the "melting pot" is misleading.
Beyond these fixed and deterministic models, countries set up policies with similar challenges of globalization, economic and discursive. Meanwhile, we immigrants face similar issues of integration as well as exclusion.
In addition, conservative political discourses at the international level have had a major impact on national policies and the negative perception of migration. Simplistic solutions like walls claim to substitute immigration policies. Even international cooperation on the subject is poorly perceived as evidence of the Marrakesh Declaration (UN, 2018).
Societies around the world have a great deal of religious, cultural and racial diversity in which a new form of citizenship is defined (Kymlicka, 1996). The challenge for societies is to deal with laws and institutions for all citizens, not to seek an ideal model or to demonize it. In this sense, there is a need to design public policies that focus on social justice, the equity of rights and the inclusion of all citizens. We propose a Southern perspective, particularly of Latin America, in order to establish a dialogue (indispensable but absent) between North and South. Sometimes migration policies fail by factors related to the North-South divide (Castles, 2004). On the one hand, this dialogue must focus on equitable development and North-South cooperation. On the other hand, policies must be part of the Western tradition of thought and values, such as hospitality and universal peace (Kant), mutual recognition (Taylor, 1991) and right of asylum (Derrida).
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The “refugee crisis” has been one of the European Union’s most decisive challenges. It has caused major internal disputes and led to a de-facto suspension of Dublin and partly also of Schengen. A truly European approach most certainly would have prevented the influx of refugees from becoming such a severe challenge. However, several member states have opposed distributing asylum seekers across the Union and by doing so obstructed a joint European solution. We argue that some kind of European refugee distribution mechanism (RDM) will be needed in order to sustainably solve the crisis – at least to complement any other possible approach.
Against this backdrop, our paper asks why certain member states reject the establishment of a permanent European refugee distribution mechanism.
To answer our research question, we start by summarizing the attempts the EU has made to manage the refugee crisis. We point out why these steps, while eventually mitigating the crisis in the short-term, do not represent sustainable solutions. In order to detect the factors which have prevented the introduction of an RDM, we derive five hypotheses, which are subsequently tested by applying a fuzzy set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA). We find that any combination of a low share of Muslims, a low degree of EU integration, i.e. the presence of opt-outs or a recent membership, a weak economic performance or/and a high impact of the migration crisis in 2015 sufficiently explains a member state’s rejection of a permanent distribution mechanism. Further, having a small Muslim population is almost a necessary condition for a members state’s opposition. In contrast to past research, our findings show that the strength of EU sceptic forces in the national context cannot be considered as a systematic cause of member states rejecting the distribution of refugees among the Union’s members.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Lately, the focus of international migration has turned both to the Central American issue as to Venezuelan migration in Latin-America. This intraregional migration leads us to rethink the frames from which we analyze south-south migration and the policies implemented by receiving countries. Many questions rise from this issue: should we adopt a migration management approach? Should we consider the migration development duo in our public policies? Should we think it from a local governance perspective? And so on.
While trying to solve some of these questions, and as a result of a doctoral research held from 2014 to 2018 in Colombia, this paper focuses on the migration development debate that has been covering a lot of literature in the migration academic issues but also as a matter of political and public debates from the North. Taking the model of the IOM for return migration management we seek to analyze what is its impact on national policies, we take Ecuador and Colombia as cases to compare from a convergence perspective (Knill, 2005) the issue, approaching it from the South (Delgado Wise, 2018). We conclude that this model is based on an economic approach to migrants rather than a human one which has to consider embeddedness (Van Houte & Davids, 2014) in a reintegration line when it comes to referring to migrants but also to formulate projects and programs that aim not only the migrant as an economic agent but also as a human of rights. Reintegration must take place in the family, in the psychosocial aspect and in the political one, not just in income generation. We invite academics and politicians to rethink the frames from which we formulate policies, taking into account the bias of national methodology approaches and starting to think more globally in a transnational context where local governance is key to this reintegration process.
References
Delgado Wise, R. (2018). On the Theory and Practice of Migration and Development: A Southern Perspective. Journal of Intercultural Studies, 39(2), 163–181. https://doi.org/10.1080/07256868.2018.1446669
Knill, C. (2005). Introduction : Cross-national policy convergence : concepts , approaches and explanatory factors, 12(March), 764–774. https://doi.org/10.1080/13501760500161332
Van Houte, M., & Davids, T. (2014). Moving Back or Moving Forward? Return Migration, Development and Peace-Building. New Diversities, 16(2), 71–87.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The phenomenon of migration has been recorded to be a part of human history. Over the years, scholars have averred that people migrate for different reasons. While some do so for economic reasons and in search of greener pastures, others do so to escape either the wrath of the society or the government owing from their actions and way of life. This phenomenon is not restricted to gender and age, as both males and females, old and young, engage in this act. Of late, it has been discovered that there is a huge desire of youths, including those who have jobs, to exit the country, thereby leading to a massive emigration of youths out of Nigeria. Although it is an undeniable fact that the economy of the country is in shambles, which leads to a desire to search for greener pastures elsewhere, the trend in the youths’ desire and rush to leave Nigeria transcends this sole reason. The belief among the youths that a good life exists only outside of Nigeria and they must leave the country’s shores has emerged as a youth culture. This study therefore critically delved into the reasons for this emerging culture, using failed migrants who have attempted to emigrate via the Sahara and the Mediterranean into Europe. Conclusively, it suggested pragmatic ways to dissuade youths from this act and harnessing the technological innovation brought to fore by Social Media which has been a veritable avenue in job creation in this epoch. A field ethnography method and archival technique was adopted. The data collected was thematically analyzed in relation to the crux of the study. The findings from the study are expected to raise issues that will foster a debate among scholars on youth migration and postulate ways of discouraging this phenomenon in Nigeria.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Migration in the Southern African region has a long and complex history (Crush et al., 2005). However, South Africa continues to attract a significant number of migrants from the Southern African region and beyond (Crush et al., 2005). Similarly, countries like Botswana and Namibia are destinations of choice. Concerning South Africa, migration and immigration increases to the country have attracted a dynamic response from the state, just as it has raised debate in the public and political spheres. A clear indication of this, are the changes in immigration policy, which demonstrates a departure from what can be considered as an apartheid inspired immigration policy up to the about 2002 to the current state, which is based on the benefit that migrants or immigrants should bring to the country (Peberdy, 2009). Indeed, there is wealth of literature which has interrogated the South African immigration policies and dynamics, but the focus has tended to be more on the implications on xenophobia. As a result, there is limited research which has examined the selectivity of the South African immigration policy (which amounts to the creation of South Africa as a `gated community`), and the implications of this on the unwanted classes of migrants. This paper, therefore examines the implications and ramifications of South Africa`s immigration policy on the unwanted classes of migrants, by responding to the following questions; are the trends similar to the fortification of European Union (EU) borders against migrants from Africa? What are the differences if any? What are the contradictions and challenges given the drive for regionalism in Africa?
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In 2015 and 2016, Germany received 1.2 Mio refugees. Accordingly, the schemes for registering, housing, feeding, providing health care to refugees, administrating their asylum procedures and so on, reached their limits. This so-called “refugee crisis” (see Bogumil et al. 2018) drew the scholarly attention to a number of particularities of German refugee policy, especially the division of labor in German federalism (Lautenbach 2015). In Germany, most aspects of migration policy are regulated at the federal level. Yet, since in German federalism the 16 German states have the duty to implement most federal laws, they exert considerable discretion by doing so. This again results in a remarkable diversity in policy implementation. Yet, publications so far have highlighted only very specific aspects of Länder refugee policies (e.g. Schammann 2015; Hörisch 2018), or they have given some overview (Münch 2016; 2017) but did not provide systematic empirical data for all Länder (but see Reiter & Töller 2019). This paper first discloses the remarkable diversity of refugee policies in German Länder by giving fresh empirical data with regard to three core areas: the provision of financial support, housing and health provision to refugees; the procedures for obtaining a protection status; and the implementation of the residence act with regard to the voluntary return or deportation of persons for whom neither protection nor toleration can be provided. Second the paper asks if in this context diversity is a good thing. Since other relevant debates, such as migration studies or the debate on German federalism (e.g. Sack & Töller 2018) fail at offering criteria for evaluating this normative question, we draw on the debate on “Immigration Federalism”. This debate has evolved in order to understand developments in the US American, Canadian and Australian migration policy since the 2000nds (Spiro 2001; Gulasekaram & Ramakrishnan 2015). We argue that albeit there are relevant differences between these federal systems and Germany, the debate has a high potential to help us evaluate federal diversity as we find it in German refugee policy. Drawing on Spiro (2001) we distinguish three issue areas which match well with the three areas which we have addressed before: immigration rights (access to social rights), immigration benefits (acquisition of a status e.g. political asylum); and immigration enforcement (e.g. border control and deportation). We apply two criteria, first, the criterion of equal treatment and second, the criterion of adequate accomplishment of tasks to these three issue areas and come up with a rather critical evaluation of federal diversity in German refugee policy, yet with differences between the issue areas.
More generally we think that such an institutionalist perspective paying attention to state structure as a factor in shaping relevant policies in immigrant-receiving countries can be a useful way to contribute to a global research agenda for immigration research.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In 2016, the Turkish academic field is at the forefront of the sociopolitical upheavals in Turkey. Symbolized by the petitionAcademics for Peace, the social movement led mainly by academics militates for the cessation of interventions by the Turkish army targeting the areas of eastern Anatolia populated mainly by the Kurdish people. The petition also aims to publicize the many human rights violations and international treaties signed by Turkey relating to torture and other forms of "unconventional" violence. Following legal proceedings by the Turkish authorities against the university, one of the preferred solutions for them will be the choice of exile. Especially since the movement of Turkish academicians had been supported through a petition emanating this time from academics from Western Europe on January 18th, 2016. This petition is going to condition the two great trajectories chosen by the Turkish academics, choosing France or Germany as the main land of asylum. Thus, the research project will have the ambition to focus primarily on the multiplicity of social determinants to restore complexity around the conditions of exile of Turkish academics. Continuing by linking these paths of exile and the establishment of a comparative typology of different reception measures specifically set up for "intellectuals". Thus, the research project has the ambition to be interested in the multiplicity of social determinants to restore the complexity surrounding the conditions of exile Turkish academics. The objectification of these exile journeys will involve the establishment of a comparative typology of the various reception measures specifically set up for "intellectuals" in France and Germany.
The methods used may vary: especially interviews with Turkish nationals but also with those who manage these programs and initiatives. A prosopography of successful candidates may be relevant. The characteristics of those who have not been so, focusing on the criteria of acceptance. And in the case of a research project, the evolution over 2 years, it is essential to focus on the evolution within French and German universities and centers and the degree of integration and adaptation of the selected sample. Observation too can be a relevant tool. The subject is current and there is no shortage of conferences and seminars specifically devoted to this. In addition, archives can be very useful including archives dealing with scientists struggling with political power, totalitarian governments. They present important data and can be objects of possible comparisons.
The expected results obviously relate to the very relevance of the comparison. Do the German and French initiatives go in the same direction or do they differ? In one case or the other, it is necessary to note the causes of such similarity or divergence, that they are explained by sociology, sociohistory, geopolitics, among others. It is then a question of comparing the different trajectories over a minimum period of 2 years.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Migration of youth in Africa is an emerging and growing phenomenon which, until recently, has received little attention in the extant literature. The bulging youth population in the region, accompanied by limited economic opportunities for the youth cohort, has spurred massive migration among this demographic group. Zimbabwe is one such country currently in the grip of a youth bulge and a serious migration of the youth to neighbouring countries and beyond. The country has an estimated population of 3 million people living in South Africa alone and the majority of them are young people. Though mobility is a fundamental human activity and a very vital component of developing human capital, reports suggest that host nations are reaching a breaking point; therefore a solution to abate this drift of young people should be sought. The harnessing of the demographic dividend through investing in the youth is one such solution high on the policy agenda of many African governments to deal with this trend. While welcoming the importance of such policy interventions, the paper argues that lack of political will, under-funding of youth programmes, and marginalisation of the youth in decision making, among a host of other issues, vitiate against any prospect of improving the conditions of the youth in Zimbabwe. This study, in contributing to the growing debate on youth vulnerability and migration in Africa, examines the link between youth empowerment and migration, and explores the youth migration trends in Southern Africa taking experiences from Zimbabwe. The study, based on an empirical study on youth empowerment programmes in Zimbabwe and secondary data collated on youth migration in Southern Africa, presents comprehensive perspectives on the complexities related to youth migration in connection to their vulnerability, and also appraises youth investment discourse of the African Union as a solution to youth migration.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Migration is a global phenomenon and globalization has created widespread opportunities for migrants to migrate to all corners of the world. Research on migration has focused on migrants from the Global South moving to the advanced economies in the Global North and South-South migration has been neglected. This paper aims to address this gap by presenting the case of South-South migration in the South Asian region.
United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime claims people from South Asia are the most mobile people when it comes to migration (UNODC, 2007), contribute about 15 percent to the global migrant stock (including refugees and asylum seekers) and receive about 20 percent of total global migrant remittances (World Bank, 2015). This region encompasses the four top-ten migrant source countries (India, Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan) and two of the top-ten largest migration corridors (India-Bangladesh and Afghanistan-Pakistan). Moreover, the grey literature assumes that there are a significant number of illegal migrants living and working in this region because of poor regulation policies and lax enforcement. No travel documents are required for movements between India and Nepal or India and Bhutan, distorting the real picture of trans-border migration.
Given the regions’ importance and contribution in the global migrant labour market and economy, it is important to better understand the policies and programs directly or indirectly impacting migration in this region. It is also important to clarify how regional policies interact with policy developments in Northern recipient countries. For example, reform to immigration policies in the USA and Europe (de Hass et. al., 2018) has restricted prospective migrants and discouraged chain migration (Krikorian, 2017). Moreover, the ‘Nation without violators’ campaign in Saudi Arabia, enforcement of the Sponsorship Scheme in the United Arab Emirates and Qatar, and forcible return from several countries have pressured labour migrants to return to their home countries.
Similarly, the Colombo Process and the Abu Dhabi Dialogue (ADD) are regional networks advocating on behalf of migration management issues in this region and a few of other neighbour Global South countries. Therefore, heeding the call of the Colombo Process and Abu Dhabi Dialogue, there is an urgent need in South Asia to reduce the cost of migration, ensure fair and regular migration, and secure effective utilization of remittances.
This paper will conduct an analysis of the major policies and programs impacting migration in the South Asian region to identify pragmatic solutions to the following issues:
a) Ensuring safe, decent and reliable migration opportunities in the South Asian region; and
b) Ensuring better management of migrant remittances
The outcome of this research paper will be a set of recommendations to encourage safe, orderly and regular migration in this region.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) is a relief and human development agency, providing education, healthcare, social services and emergency aid to over five million Palestinian refugees living in Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, the West Bank & the Gaza Strip. The agency was established by the UN in 1949 as a temporary response to the plight of approximately three quarters of a million Palestinians who became refugees following the 1948 Arab Israel war.
In the succeeding decades, the UNRWA played a significant role in the drama of the Middle East conflict. As this drama has unfolded, the future of the Agency has been the subject of debate in the international community as well as among political scientists and negotiators. This discussion was renewed in 1993 after the Oslo Accords, which were signed by Israel and the Palestinian Liberation Organization. It was further intensified with the concomitant collapse of the Oslo negotiations process and the onset of the second Intifada in September 2000. Following the Trump’s administration recent announcement to cut its fund to UNRWA (nearly $300 million a year), and the state of Israel National Security Council decision of Jan 2019 that revoked the permits allowing UNRWA schools to operate in Jerusalem, the spotlight is once again focused on the agency which becomes, as a result of the conflict and Gaza blockade, an instrumental lifeline for refugees and non refugees alike.
In the context of this renewed interest in UNRWA as well as recent attacks by the Israeli government and funding cuts by the US, the objective of this paper is to assess such policy responses and examine its ramifications for the 5 million refugees living in UNRWA fields of operations. The paper will also assess the impact of these moves on reaching a future settlement to the Palestinian refugee question within the context of UN Resolution 194 (III) of December 1948 and in line with the international norms pertaining to human rights and refugee protection.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
While the experiences and identities of refugees are multiple and complex, dominant representations at the media, in politics and policies tend to reinforce stereotypes of identity, gender, etc. These common perceptions of social reality tend to create stereotypes and to then stigmatise : refugee men are often perceived as a "threat" and women as "vulnerable".
"Otherisation", criminalisation and victimisation are thus often the three modes under which the collective imaginary, dominant in politics and in the media, represents refugees in general. The result is a series of more controlling and administrative policies, rather than humanitarian - a boundary that is becoming increasingly blurred, as "any policy of assistance is simultaneously an instrument of control" (AGIER, 2008, p.24).
In the face of their victimisation, de-humanisation or criminalisation, over which refugees themselves have no say, it is expected of them an incapacity to act, the loss of their agency, the impossibility to see among refugees any form of political organisation, any development of individual and / or collective strategies to confront the constraints imposed by exile. On the contrary, it is possible to observe many initiatives of political, humanitarian, associative or commercial nature, or simply individual or collective strategies to cope with refugeness. Since 2011, despite the difficulties and increasing pressure on refugees, Syrians living in Turkey and Jordan have developed new social structures based on family, friendship, professional or religious ties. These are often informal networks that already existed in Syria or were created in exile.
But if refugees are just nameless victims, with no history, no voice and who are only entitled only to a humanitarian protection, how these initiatives can persist? Or, if they are simply threatening men or passive women who lack the power to act, how are they able to develop different forms of action in exile, even in the face of coercitive policies ?
This study aims to question how refugees develop individual or collective strategies under contraint. What are the forms of these strategies? What are the social practices and institutional frameworks leading refugees to develop these actions? It is a matter of studying the agency of refugees but without neglecting the structures and mechanisms shaping their actions. It is an opportunity to study the process unfolding these "actions" by which refugees, here agents, construct and transform themselves in exile, without neglecting the violence that they may suffer in this process.
The question of the agency of refugees, their strategies, is crucial to understand the State and the implementation of public policies, based on categories artificially created. It questions not only the categories assigned to people fleeing their countries, but it also challenges the same borders that constitute the State - here physical boundaries that refugees must overcome but also symbolic ones. The use of the word agency in this study intends to break with the postulate of a passive refugee, who is only a subject of humanitarian aid and who submits him/herself to a host State as a guest, undesired, without resisting or transforming her/his reality in exile. It is also an opportunity to question the term refugee itself in order to find a subject in exile, while simultaneously debating the presuppositions of the State, such as borders and citizenship. In order to analyse this process, this study is based on a series of semi-structured interviews with Syrians in Turkey and Jordan. The interviews were conducted in several cities, with different profiles in 2016 and 2017. This methodology is complemented with a more anthropological / ethnological approach.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The estimated one million Rohingyas, a Muslim minority group from the Rakhine state of Myanmar, are not recognized by the Government of Myanmar, which considers them illegal immigrants from Bangladesh instead. The large scale violence against them in 2012 and 2015 has forced them flee to neighbouring states of Southeast Asia and Bangladesh as refugees. Most of them are now living in refugee camps in Bangladesh.
International response to the violence against Rohingyas was initially mixed as governments were trying to support the peaceful transition to democracy from military rule in Myanmar but in recent years, criticisms have been scaled up from all directions, including the United Nations while several states have imposed sanctions. Recently, ASEAN member states have publicly called on Myanmar to hold those responsible for the Rohingya crisis accountable and to start the repatriation process from Bangladesh.
An analysis of this humanitarian crisis highlights how mass displacement caused by conflicts and violence is a defining feature of the contemporary world and a major cause of human insecurity. This paper analyses the response of the international community to the Rohingya humanitarian crisis. Based on the framework of migration governance, it stresses the importance of cooperation between different stakeholders to address this humanitarian emergency given its profound impact in local stability and regional security, besides human security. A qualitative approach is adopted for this research which analyses studies centred around internal aspects of the crisis and its humanitarian dimension, in order to reconceptualise migration regional governance studies.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Since 2015, Germany has implemented quite a number of legal changes concerning the countries’ asylum and integration policy. In this context, particularly one significant policy change can be identified: The division of asylum seekers in those with a “good perspective to remain in Germany” and those with a “bad perspective to remain in Germany”, both of which are linked to specific opportunities for integration or the lack thereof. While asylum seekers with a “good perspective to remain” are granted access to particular integration tools, like language courses and training assistance, those with a “bad perspective to remain” are prohibited from working, and denied access to formal education. Whether someone has a good or a bad “perspective to remain” (German: “Bleibeperspektive”) depends on his/her country of origin. Implemented with the asylum package 1 (“Asylpaket 1”) in October 2015, the concept “Bleibeperspektive” is quite new and has not made it to the academic agenda yet. Before its implementation, the access to the integration tools mentioned above depended on the outcome of a persons’ individual asylum procedure. Therefore, refugees in the status “asylum seeker”, meaning people whose asylum procedure has not been completed yet, did not have access to the integration tools in general. Furthermore, there were no work and training bans for asylum seekers from specific countries of origin. Bringing forward the decision over a refugees’ integration chances to the time of his/her asylum procedure, and linking it to his/her country of origin, is a major policy change that might fit into Peter Halls category of third order change (Hall 1993). While a principle of equal treatment was in force before the implementation of “Bleibeperspektive”, asylum seekers’ access to integration and social participatory chances became selective and unequal afterwards. This policy change happened mostly outside of the public and academic perception. By first describing “Bleibeperspektive”, placing it into Halls’ categorization, and putting it into an historical and discursive context, the paper contributes to research on integration and asylum policy in Germany and fills a significant research gap. As the topic has not been scientifically explored yet, attempts to explain the emergence of “Bleibeperspektive” need to draw on previous research from the broader field of policy analysis and test its applicability. That is why the paper discusses how existing theoretical approaches from the field of policy analysis can contribute to an analysis of "Bleibeperspektive" and explain the emergence of this specific policy change in a second step.
In conclusion, the paper does not only offer brand-new information on a far-reaching policy change in Germanys’ asylum- and integration policy, but also adds to existing research by giving perspectives for the analysis of up-to-date policy change in a complex policy field which has not been sufficiently researched so far.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Recent events and the rise of Islamophobia across much of the West and Europe in particular have led to evolving patterns in exclusion. For a long time now, immigration from the global South has been used by the far right and nationalist movements as a threat to a fantasised autochthonous and indigenous population, whose very survival is at stake. This has even been argued more recently to be a case of reverse colonialism, where those once colonised now acted as coloniser. In post-racial societies, this reactionary development has necessitated contortions from the far right, which has had to adapt its discourse to its new context.
In this paper, we aim to explore the way the far right has attempted to use successfully some liberal tropes to defend its illiberal project, and how this played out in different national context. Focusing particularly on what has been termed homonationalism by Jasbir Puar, this paper seeks to understand how the far right has attempted use gay rights and equality, once reviled enemies, against what it posed as ‘Muslim immigration’. This is puzzling, particularly considering the pronatalist position of the far right, and how they have excluded and attacked homosexuals based on their allegedly anti-family and anti-children stance.
By examining this strategy based on the enemy of my enemy is my friend, we aim to demonstrate that the liberal approach to gay rights by anti-immigration groups could evolve and become anchored in an illiberal project, where gay rights are only defended for racist reasons and are thus subject to only tenuous and superficial support. To do so, we will build on the framework developed by Aurelien Mondon and Aaron Winter on liberal and illiberal articulations of Islamophobia, which argues that the use of once progressive tropes, such as gay rights, but also women’s rights, secularism and free speech, has become a key strategy to push Islamophobic agendas, as it has allowed actors to dissociate themselves from the traditional extreme right.
The empirical material will be the intersecting representations of anti-immigration and Islamophobic discourse and gay equality issues in the public sphere. Particularly, reports, statements by gender lobbies and Churches, party and interest group campaign material, and general documentation of any related issues by both gender rights and immigrant rights groups will be under study. The context of study is particularly the immigration from the Middle East following the Arab Spring to Central and Western Europe. Hence, its context is mainly states such as Hungary, France, and the UK. Yet, it also presents and relates to empirical evidence from a variety of other European contexts within its general conceptual scope.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this paper is to identify the major issues and gaps in the literature pertaining to international migration, with special attention to the contributions of political scientists to the field of policy studies. Since the end of the 1990s, migration studies has grown as a field, and has been populated by both more comparative, and relatedly policy-relevant, research. However, as we will demonstrate through a recent review of the literature, this work has for the most part focused on countries of the global north, particularly in Europe, North America and Australasia. In particular, we address a tendency to focus on issues from within a framework that veers from an emphasis on integration (of welcomed migrants) and control (of unwanted migrants) in these locales, with only sporadic attention to ethics and colonial legacies. By attending to an empirical analysis of recent research trends with respect to both global and regional migration dynamics and refugee settlement, our paper probes the consequences of this gap in the literature when it comes to the global South. We assess the ethical implications of having such a limited research focus and reflect on issues of knowledge construction and power.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The recent ‘refugee crisis’ emerging from the Middle East, has given rise to questions concerning gender relations by global south scholars about these communities. The emerging inequalities have often been analyzed through a gendered lens with a specific concentration on women’s sexuality. Through a postcolonial perspective, this paper will focus on the Yazidi community in Iraq as a means of expanding our understanding of gendered based violence by focusing on land dispossession, social reproduction, and displacement. In order to further examine issues of sexual slavery and child marriage, this paper will contextualize these issues in the broader political and social context within the global south and in relation to the global north. By specifically focusing on the Yazidi community in Iraq, this paper will unpack women’s positionality beyond their framing as merely victims of sexual violence that dominates the discourses of the ‘refugee crisis’. This paper will do so by situating the changing gender relations within the brutality utilized by state making/unmaking as strategies of terror and land disposition that are both new and continuous - through capitalism, imperialism, and gendered violence. This paper seeks to advance a methodological contribution to migration studies by focusing specifically on the Yazidi community’s experiences of gendered based violence that are intimately connected to land dispossession and displacement in the global south.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Southeast Asia’s response to forced migration is reflective in the enforcement gaps noted in its prevention measures and protection mechanisms for stateless, refugee and non-refugee, children against human trafficking. The Hague Process on Refugees and Migration Foundation Handbook describes the term ‘forced migration’ as the movement of people ‘in which an element of coercion predominates’. The aim of this research is to examine the ASEAN Intergovernmental Commission on Human Rights, and proffer recommendations for change in its ten Member States approach to forced migration and the protection of stateless children against human trafficking. Within the ASEAN Charter States, only Cambodia, East Timor, and the Philippines have ratified the 1951 Refugee Convention. None of the ASEAN States have ratified the 1954 UN Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons Convention or the 1961 UN Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness. Yet, research shows that in Southeast Asia, forced migrating stateless children are trafficked through either a source, transit, or destination State and the incredulous crime encroaches upon cultural, economic, social, political, civil, and human rights.
Keywords: ASEAN Charter States: Bangladesh, Brunei, Burma, Cambodia, East Timor, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Mongolia, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, and Viet Nam forced migration, human trafficking, The Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, 1951 Refugee Convention and its 1967 Protocol, The 1954 Convention relating to the Status of Stateless Persons, the 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness, and UN Convention on the Rights of the Child
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The kafala system is the main policy by which the Arab Gulf States control immigration and migrant workers post-entry. While there is extensive political debates on the human rights abuses that migrant workers often confront in the Gulf, much of academic scholarship about this cluster of states that together form the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) tends to emphasize the exclusionary practices of this policy, often highlighting the ‘exceptionality’ of the Gulf’s immigration policy regimes. It is true that the Gulf’s migration narrative is exceptional given that over half of these states populations (with the exception of Saudi Arabia) are temporary migrant workers with no path towards naturalization, this paper argues that the kafala system itself is not exceptional. To make this point, I explore the various institutional and non-institutional actors and elements that together form an assemblage of noncitizenship, thus challenging what scholars have conventionally conceived of as a cohesive system of managing transnational movement.
This paper suggests that the Kafala system, like most migration regimes in large migrant-receiving regions in the Global North, is characterized by the differential inclusion of mobile bodies. In addition, I explore the multiplication of borders that takes place once the geographic borders have been crossed. In so doing, our analysis transcends the binary of citizen/non-citizen to explore the ethnic, gendered, and classed borders that shape the varied experiences of people living in the Gulf. Finally, this theoretical contribution seeks to intervene in extant understandings of migration and citizenship regimes outside of the Global North, underscoring the regional and international factors that inform the Gulf countries immigration policies and their implications on migrant lives by situating them within a transnational and international context.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
There is a connection between developed nations panic about migration flow and the increasing span and comprehensiveness of migration management. That connection locates the increasing comprehensiveness of migration management not on the wellbeing of the migrants but on the welfare of citizens. As Geiger and Pecoud (2013, 19) argues “[t]he government of international migration and the treatment of foreign populations working and living within nation-states must therefore be understood as a form of governmentality that aims first and foremost for the preservation of the status and welfare of citizens”. Thus, one can argue that the need to support a focus on border control, coercion and exclusion with heavily funded campaigns, projects, development aids, etc does not deviate from the rationality that is inherent in the statal paternalistic watch over its citizens. That will hypothesize that an immigration stringent country is a citizen catering country. Using the history (1998 – 2018) of social provision for citizens and immigration regulations in Finland and South Africa, I critically examine the discourse of a caring state in a context of increasing hostility towards the foreign other on the one hand, and a shrinking social policy on the other. In the ensuing melee of losses and gains, the wellbeing of citizens vs migrants are bargaining chips for populist gains, migrants become pawns in a politics of divide and rule, even as the state welcomes deserving migrants as new citizens.
Reference:
Geiger, Martin, and Antoine Pecoud, eds. 2013. Disciplining the Transnational Mobility of People. London, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Ombudsmen as a Soft/Human Security Policy Agent in Migration Issues (European North Area Case)
Around Barents and Baltic Seas Russia occupies a pivotal position in the path of East-West migrations, sharing borders with a key destination Nordic/Baltic states, (by water) with some West European countries. Migration issues are one of conceptualized via soft[1] and/or human security approaches[2]. The European Union pursues its policies mostly through «soft security» mechanisms, like European Neighbourhood Policy (ENP), Northern Dimension (ND) and «Eastern Partnership» (EP). The Russian cooperation with North Europe is developing in framework of Council of the Baltic Sea States (CBSS), institutions under the Barents Euro-Arctic Region (BEAR) and the Nordic Council of Ministers (NCM) activity, whose agenda initiatives is of applied character where social issues are prevailing. CBSS currently is concentrating on the issues of common interests (economic cooperation, environment, energy, education) and “slightly” avoiding the conflict issues (human rights, for example). Border Guards developed a modern formation in charge of a significant stretch of EU’s external frontier, the service is positioned to become a crucial part of the Schengen area’s protection against illegal and/or irregular migration[3]. Civil society organizations and think-tanks as well as Ombudsmen are deeply involved in the protection of rights of immigrants.
On the economic side, the EU-Russian governmental relations are controversial in issues of asses to trade, development of energy export corridors and on the prospects for increasing investments in (border) regions. At the same time this proximity of Russia’s North-western regions to Europe and the EU accession of Nordic & Baltic States, are by some perceived as an obstacle, rather than a benefit to their economic development, political profile and regional security. Nevertheless, common concern is irregular and/or illegal migration (especially female and youth, incl. trafficking in Human being). Policy debates on illegality in the immigration and employment of migrants are typically based on simple conceptual dichotomies, for instance “legal/illegal”, “regular/irregular”, “authorized/unauthorized” or “documented/undocumented”. However, the legal frameworks that govern the immigration, residence and employment of migrants in most destination countries are typically quite intricate. This means that, in practice, it is “spaces of (il)legality” that are created. The spaces of (il)legality are contested, particularly where complex immigration laws collide with flexible labour markets[4]. With normative and structural discourse analysis methodology we are going to analyze ongoing situation reflected in Ombudsman’s activity in number of states in area.
[1] Rothschild E. What is Security? // Daedalus. - 1995. - Summer. - P. 53-98
[2] Сhen, Lincoln C. Human Security: Concepts and Approaches // Common Security in Asia: New Concepts of Human Security / Matsumae, Tatsuro and Chen, Lincoln C. (eds.). - Tokyo, 1995. P. 139.
[3]Definitions used by European Ombudsmen and their opinions towards issues are given in the brochure: Protection the Human rights of irregular migrants: the role of National Human Rights Structures. – Council of Europe & University of Padua, 2009.
[4] World Migration Report 2008. Chapter 8. IRREGULAR MIGRATION, by Graziano Battistella, Director, Scalabrini International Migration Institute, Rome, Italy. URL: http://www.iom.int/jahia/webdav/site/myjahiasite/shared/shared/mainsite/published_docs/studies_and_reports/WMR2008/Ch8_WMR08.pdf (accessed: 2011 February)
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The vast majority of democratic theory assumes the need for widespread political participation. The right to vote constitutes the most essential political right but in the era of migration the idea of universal suffrage is far from being realized.
The Grand Duchy of Luxembourg within its current borders is the result of 19th century diplomacy. In the space of less than 150 years the population of this state more than doubled - largely attributable to immigration. Today, 48% of the population are foreigners. The history of the creation of the Grand Duchy and the Law on Luxembourg Nationality are closely intertwined – the latter having undergone several changes – reflecting historic circumstances. The evolution of the Law on Luxembourgish Nationality and the discussions around “what constitutes a Luxembourger” illustrate the changes in perception of “Luxembourg nationality”. The underlying fundamental question is whether naturalization is the mid – or endpoint of successful integration into the host society.
In this paper we will outline the different phases of the Luxembourg Law on Nationality, starting with the period of the French civil Code and ending with the current amendments of the naturalization law.
This paper reflects the relation between migration and changes in the naturalization law in Luxembourg. The authors show how successive Luxembourgish governments have accommodated citizenship rights of foreign nationals, but are constrained by political groups defending national preferences. Overall, Luxembourg can be described as an immigration success story, facing the future challenge of accommodating all groups living in Luxembourg.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Human mobility creates significant challenges both to sending and receiving contexts. The human mobility in the Mediterranean since the 1990s has attracted significant attention from academics as well as policy-makers. The recent migration flows from Syria have enlarged the scale of the challenge as the numbers have increased significantly. Given such a mobile region, it is important to analyze the changes to the legal frameworks governing citizenship and naturalization procedures and the factors that impact the direction of these changes in the Northern Mediterranean. Integration of immigrants is an important area and the policies and laws that are in place in the receiving countries determine the extent to which non-citizens can have access to rights. This paper examines the citizenship law and discourse in the northern Mediterranean countries (Italy, Spain, Greece and Turkey) over the last decade of increased human mobility. There is today a recognition that these countries have become receiving countries. The aim of the paper is to investigate the impact of political parties and election campaigns, judiciary, civil society and media on debates and changes to the citizenship law (in particular to naturalization policies and patterns). In each context there are pro- as well as anti-immigration movements, rights-based and needs-based NGOs in addition to immigrant associations. The politicization of migration and the use of immigration and refugees as an issue in election campaigns also differs. Given this diversity, it is important to evaluate the direction of change and the factors which bring about change in these northern Mediterranean countries. The EU-level response to such human mobility will also be incorporated into the research as to whether there is a potential to develop collaborative responses to increased human mobility without over-burdening these immediate receivers of immigrants and refugees. This research is significant as citizenship policy can be seen as a tool for the incorporation of immigrants and naturalization can encourage the public to recognize immigrants as their equals and develop a shared sense of belonging which is important for democratic ethos. The paper argues that although there is path dependency in the way citizenship laws change, there can be unexpected results at times of critical junctures. Public debate on the issue and civil society pressure in attempting to incorporate immigrants into political community seem to be the most important factors influencing change, yet politicization of the issue may not always result in favorable outcomes.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
The dynamics of complex (international) migration situation in the EU and its neighborhood after 2010, with the peak in 2015–2016, has attracted much attention in the Union itself and in the region. This was mainly in relation to increasing migratory flows towards Europe that were defined as forced, mixed or irregular (categories treated separately). The scale of the discussed phenomenon in 2014–2018 can be approximated by selected indicators provided by different actors. UNHCR reported there were more than million sea arrivals across the Mediterranean to Europe in 2015 and 5.1 thousand people considered ‘dead’ or ‘went missing’ in 2016; Frontex informed about 1.8 detected cases of illegal crossing of the EU’s external borders between border crossing points in 2015, and EASO/Eurostat indicated the number of 1.3 million non-EU asylum applicants in the EU member states in both years of 2015–2016 peak. As a result, the concept of migration and refugee crisis in the media narrative, political discourse and research began to be widely used in Europe and beyond. The crisis and its consequences exposed the need for a far-reaching reform of EU’s migration, asylum and border management policy. This was reflected in the Commission's communication on the European Agenda on Migration (EAM) from May 2015 and since then it has been repeated in its implementation reports. In December 2018, the European Commission in its recent progress report under the EAM stated that the EU and its Member States had established a comprehensive approach to migration management and related challenges, composing of three core action elements, encompassing action with partners outside the EU, at EU’s external borders and inside the EU. However, at the same time, the report stressed that “it is time to move away from temporary internal border controls and ad hoc migration management, towards sustainable solutions”.
This paper presents and discusses the migration and asylum situation in the EU in the context of the migration and refugee crisis and the EU’s policy in this field. It focuses on the analysis of the implementation of the European Agenda on Migration since 2015 and its effectiveness, as well as on the analysis of the direction of EU’s policy reforms in the area of migration, asylum and management of external borders. The author’s aim is to explore how the migration policy agenda resulting from the EAM was developed and implemented; who were the main stakeholders and what was their involvement, and finally, to what extent the EAM’s implementation was successful and corresponded to the MLG concept. To address these questions, the paper refers to the results of the author's research conducted at the Collegium of Socio-Economics of SGH Warsaw School of Economics.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Brazil's National Transport Infrastructure Department, DNIT, founded in 2001, is a federal agency that manages Brazil's waterways, roadways, and railways, as well intermodal facilities, river and lake ports. Currently, DNIT is responsible for managing approximately 52,000 km of roads, 300 km of railroads and 20,000 km of waterways.
Amongst DNIT´s competencies lays the complex responsibility of expropriating lands and displacing people in order to increase or improve Brazilian´s road network. When expropriation affects regular landowners, national laws assure their rights to property by means of expropriation procedures. However, when it affects people who do not have legal or customary tenure of houses or land they inhabit or utilize, the law does not guarantee any compensation.
It is important to highlight that the Brazilian housing deficit and the lack of land regularization often result in a high number of irregular and precarious settlements including the occupation of public road protection zones. Prior to 2009, DNIT’s default policy towards those vulnerable affected families occupying irregular areas of interest was to displace them by offering an insufficient cash compensation or even no compensation at all. However, as the Brazilian democratic institutions became more solid, DNIT was impelled to rethink its policy and started to assure social rights granted by the Federal Constitution or in International Treaties complies with.
Consequently, the department started to collect data on the displaced families and to get better understanding of their social and economic characteristics. Nevertheless, the data collected was scattered among the local offices throughout Brazil and had never been processed and analyzed before. Therefore, this paper aims to present, for the first time, the quantitative and qualitative data of 15 different infrastructure projects carried out by DNIT, which displaced over 2,500 squatters and encroachers since 2013.
The proposed paper will contribute to the Migration and Citizenship: Policies and Research in Global Comparative Perspective panel since it will shed light on unfulfilled questions regarding the oustees, such as occupation length, education level, family structures, cultural values, employment, and householder’s genders.
A structured diagnosis is the first step to a clear understanding of the context of these informal occupations. This will enable DNIT to start planning effective compensation frameworks considering not only financial aspects but also historical, cultural and structural features.
The Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (IDMC), the world's official source of data on internal displacement, claim that it is still not possible to cover displacement associated with development projects in global figures yet. Thus, these data can also contribute to international research regarding internal displacements.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Authors: Michael McCormack (presenting) and Jody Heymann
Economic push and pull factors remain one of the major forces contributing to migration flows around the world today. Economic migrants of all skill levels, occupations and industries apply for temporary work visas in search of better opportunities in nations with strong labor markets. The significant demand for domestic work in countries in the Global North and the Global South has made it a substantial share of migrant labor flows in today’s global economy. It is also well documented that migrant workers in this occupation are especially vulnerable to exploitation, mistreatment and social exclusion.
This paper examines how the gendered nature of domestic work is embedded within the work permit regulations for immigrant workers in domestic work occupations. Using new comparative law and policy data on migration from the 150 most-populous UN member states created at the WORLD Policy Analysis Center at the University of California Los Angeles, we examine differences in the protections and conditions of domestic work permits versus general work permits and those permits more likely to be filled by men. This data provides evidence of how the opportunities of marginalized groups are curtailed through the terms and conditions of work permits specific to domestic workers across 20 countries within the 150 countries in the database. Among those countries with work permits specific to domestic work, domestic work permits are more restrictive in regard to renewability, lengths of validity, and are more likely to place restrictions on changing terms of employment. Restrictions on family reunification for domestic work permit holders were common. Comparisons between conditions of domestic work between the Global North and Global South will also be explored. More equitable conditions between work permits regardless of gender composition will be essential to reducing inequality among marginalized populations across all regions.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
EU internal migration is mainly regulated by Directive 2004/38/EC, so called the Citizenship Directive. This European Directive allows all nationals from the 28Th Member States to move and reside within the territory of other Member States. This freedom of movement can be nevertheless limited by the host Member States, when there is a threat to their public policy. There is no European definition of this threat and Member States retain the freedom to determine the requirements of public policy and public security in accordance with their needs, which can vary from one Member State to another and from one period to another. This multiplicity of national definitions generates diverse and divergent responses to migration issues. There is a clear need for a common perspective. And the EU citizenship, that unites all the nationals of the 28th Member States, seems powerless against the reluctance of the Member States to give up their sovereignty on these key issues. EU citizenship does not mean automatically equal treatment for EU migrants within the territory of the European Union. The paper proposes to examine the difficulties of agreeing on common grounds regarding migration key issues. This lack of will is even present into a very integrated regional organization such as the European Union. It is a fight between Member States’ sovereignty and a common migration policy. It will also address the question of the helplessness of a common Citizenship. Are there some migration issues that cannot be the subject of a common policy? Or is there a future for an European public policy?
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
In the wake of ongoing migration crises and debates, Nawyn (2016) urges migration scholars to question whether their theoretical presuppositions capture the full complexity of migration as it is experienced today. Likewise, Dauvergne (2016) has pointed to a “policy paralysis in immigration regulation” under which our current guiding conceptual narratives of economics and human rights have been inadequate in providing solutions to the globe’s most pressing migration problems. From this, Dauvergne suggests the need for re-imagining immigration in a way that re-orients us to value “immigration for reasons that are not economic, and [advocate] on the basis of reasons that are not rights” (2016, p. 205). These critiques align with those made by scholars of care ethics, who have voiced concerns regarding the primacy of economics in our politics and the limitations of human rights frameworks to bring about justice (Tronto, 2013).
Grounded first in the Canadian context, this paper will present the theoretical argument that care ethics provides a plausible framework from which to re-imagine immigration politics, shifting our focus to the relational elements of immigration. Fundamentally, this requires recognition of interdependency of both sending and receiving countries, in the Global North and Global South, that is grounded in a contextual sensitivity that resists abstracting away from the lives of individual migrants, a responsiveness that is attentive to the needs and stories of migrants as they express them, and for states to take responsibility for and recognise the consequences of their political and policy choices (Hankivsky, 2004).
To begin to realize this project, we need to extend our care ethics and beyond the context of a caring state in which members care for each other (Tronto, 2013), to come to understand citizenship and migration statuses more broadly as tools used by the state to set limits on caring obligations (Sharma, 2006). It will therefore be suggested that re-imagining of immigration grounded in care ethics is an imagining which must take its cue from movements which resist the ways nation states and global systems convince us that “you can’t have affective ties at a global level” (Jefferies, 2015), despite the numerous other ways globalization ties us together. It therefore requires the fore-fronting of new, or previously marginalized, narratives that allow for a new imagining of migration in a way that transcends divisions and provides the basis for the deconstruction of structures that seek to maintain them.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
There is an increasing interest in examining the gendered and racial aspects linked with the immigration policies of the Global North, yet, so far, research in analyzing immigration policies of the Global South and the vulnerabilities of migrated impoverished racialized women to the Global South is scant. Namely, Bangladeshi migrated women as domestic workers to the United Arab Emirates (UAE) often encountered physical and sexual violence by their employers. Many such women have returned to Bangladesh and also faced challenges to be accommodated in the society. Although some migration groups demanded better laws to ensure the safety of these workers, the government of UAE is reluctant to address this issue. Bangladeshi Government also provides minimum support to these victims. Despite the frequent news of violence against domestic workers in the UAE, many Bangladeshi women still eager to migrate to the UAE, and the Bangladeshi government also encourages such immigration. While before the 1980s., Bangladeshi women hardly worked in the public sectors, a significant change has occurred since the period. Globalization, industrialization, urbanization, modernization, and women’s economic empowerment discourses are linked with a remarkable number of women working in the public sectors. The lack of job opportunity and low wages often push impoverished Bangladeshi women to move to other countries. As the immigration systems of the Global North mainly focus on skilled and educated workers, the only option has left for these impoverished and illiterate women to go somewhere in the Global South. Middlemen generally send these domestic workers to the UAE without ensuring the minimum safety and security. Lack of the Government’s surveillance on the immigration business in Bangladesh is also connected with these women’s suffering. So, impoverished Bangladesh women’s migration to the Global South is a complex issue, which needs an urgent examination. First, this paper draws on academic literature on immigration policies and the gap in academic literature. Second, the political history of migration of impoverished Bangladesh women to the UAE will be discussed. Finally, this paper focuses on stories of such women, published on online news after 2005, because these marginalized women's stories will tell all relations of subordination, including gender, racial, and class subordination.
This paper is relevant to the panel “T02P04 / Migration and Citizenship: Policies and Research in Global Comparative Perspective” because it examines the gap of studying the political history of women’s migration to the Global South to the Global South. Further, it addresses how race, class, and gender categories complicate the experiences of female migrant domestic workers in the Global South. As the panel aims to bridge the dialog between the scholars of the Global South and the Global North, this paper could contribute to the bridging.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Between 2007 and 2013, more than 64,000 migrants crossed irregularly the Israeli-Egyptian border, among which more than 90% Sudanese and Eritrean asylum seekers. This phenomenon, a side effect of increasing anti-migration policies in Western Europe and North America pushing refugees toward new exodus routes, was responded by the toughening of Israeli border control and by the institutionalization of an asylum system designed to produce non-refugees. Since then, Israeli repressive policy interrupted the entry of new African migrants and pushed half of this population to leave. Therefore Israel, established as a safe haven for Jewish refugees and claiming to be “the only democracy in the Middle-East”, came to the forefront of deterrence policies against asylum seekers.
The proposed paper offers an empirically-based analysis of the transformations in the asylum policy, while revealing the particularities of the Israeli trajectory in global context. Drawing on interviews with actors of the Israeli asylum system and on a critical reading of official documents, I show how the introduction and bureaucratization of asylum procedures and refugee determination mechanisms, with the involvement of the UNHCR and foreign governments from Western Europe and North America, have yielded the simultaneous criminalization of most asylum seekers as “infiltrators”.
While showing how the Israeli policy is entangled with processes of asylum restriction and anti-immigration measures characteristic of the Global North, I will emphasize 1) that anti-immigration policies and technologies are translated into vernacular terms and rationales, bearing the imprint of a longer biopolicial history of Zionist statecraft; and 2) the importance of challenging the conception of Israel as a “Villa in the jungle” or as an “Island surrounded with Arab barbarism” through transforming the comparative perspective. While scholars usually compare Israel only with states from the Global North, I would like to ask- what can we learn from comparing the Israeli policy toward asylum seekers with neighboring countries and with other countries in the Middle East? Such a comparative perspective can shed new light over the Israeli “asylum crisis”, over official and unofficial modes of inclusion and exclusion, over the way Israeli policy deals with domestic law and international conventions, and over the role of and relations with international organisms like UNHCR and foreign governments.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
How do African Union policies address the question of irregular migration within the Continent? Does the AU have a Framed policy of the fight irregular migration in Africa?
Migrations as well as other issues of security, development and peace have appeared as crucial issues of the African Union (AU) since 2013. The fact that such questions have led to the emergence of new policy tools such as action’s plans for migrations, Agendas 2063, it possible to deduce that the governance of critical issues within the Continent is given more attention.
For what concerns migration, the Political Action Plans (2013-2018), (2018-2027) says a lot about the policy framework of migrations in Africa with a lot being said about the different types, less is said about the legal instruments which clearly address the issue.
Indeed, an analysis of the policy framework raise two major limits: the concerns the nature of instruments and the degree of sanction. Institutions are the main focus, and as well, the study of such policies of AU may help to raise two problems: the question of the nature of instruments of regulation, and of their enforcement. When this comes to specific domain of migrations such as Smuggling, human trafficking, modern slavery, the focus is on the protection of human rights of categories without addressing responsibilities. So the aim of this proposal is to apprehend the body of policies related to the AU’s governance of irregular migrations in Africa focusing on AU’s elaborated instruments as well as international treaties signed by members’ States. By doing so the project seeks to highlight the backdrop for a further comprehensive policy of irregular migration as a tool for the governance of the phenomenon in Africa.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
As the migration policy domain becomes more complex, diverse, and transnational, understanding the actors, institutions, ideas, intentions, and discourses shaping migration cannot be conceptualized as being shaped solely by the migrant receiving developed countries.
Based on a desk review of information gathered from academic publications, government reports, and grey literature, this paper describes the temporary migration experiences and trajectories of Sri Lankans, from a migrant sending country’s perspective. It aims to compare the Sri Lankan experience with the global context and the prevailing assumptions about labor migration.
The body of literature on international migration from Sri Lanka is largely dominated by studies of temporary labor migration.[i] Majority of these works focus on drivers of migration, remittances sent back home, health and social consequences of migration, and domestic economic impacts. International regulations and memorandum of understanding between countries guide temporary labor migration, a national policy provides an overarching framework for monitoring, evaluating and regulating agencies that train workers, and the Bureau of Foreign Employment regularly publishes comprehensive data on its outcomes.[ii] Although temporary labor migration, from a global context, is understood as a feminized and unskilled migration pathway from developing-to-developed countries, the Sri Lankan experience no longer aligns with this trend. The migration of more than 200,000 Sri Lankans for work each year, predominantly to the Gulf Corporation Countries, has changed from a feminized unskilled labour supply to a male skilled worker scheme. The migration of females for work reduced from 70% in 1986 to less than 50% in 2010.[iii] Creating opportunities for domestic female labour and reporting on the effects on children left behind have helped in discouraging women with young children from seeking foreign employment since 2010. Temporary labor migration in this context is not only shaped by economic factors but policies that have responded to domestic needs and taken the social and health implications of female migration into consideration. The widely held political-economist views about the drivers of migration from developing-to developed countries would fall short in fully understanding the migration trends and trajectories in this setting.
In terms of the current structuration of migrant studies, this highlights an important conceptual disconnect. Migrant receiving countries concerned with filling labor market needs tend to examine migration policy from a gender-neutral political-economic lens. The same lens is often being applied to migrant sending countries focusing on the share of remittances sent/brought back home. Understanding the dynamic and context specific ways in which migration pathways diverge, and the factors that drive those policies requires a cross-border in-depth look at the migration policy domain. Frameworks taken in the global North and studies that are structured upon them can fail to achieve this goal.
Works cited:
[i] Warnasuriya D, Gamage P (2014). Labor migration in Sri Lanka select annotated bibliography, Colombo, Sri Lanka: Institute of Policy Studies.
[ii] International Organization of Migration (2018). Migration Governance Profile: The Democratic Socialist Republic of Sri Lanka.
[iii] Ministry of foreign employment promotion and welfare (2013) Migration Profile Sri Lanka. Colombo, Sri Lanka: Institute of Policy Studies.
CO-AUTHORS
ABSTRACT
Revision of the refugees and migration literature shows very few forced or displaced skilled
migration context and even less attention paid on the academicians trajectories. It is difficult
the find the sensitivity for highly skilled migration in the `displaced or forced` migration
theory. Further there is still not enough in their work-related acculturation or changes in their
job related well-being except for the occasional statistics on refugee breakdown of
employment in the host countries or financial studies where most of the literature focus on
economic income and inequality or sectoral discrimination issues.
The difficulty of obtaining data either qualitative or quantitative (Tigau, 2019) for field
research is the main reason behind the gap in the literature of highly skilled displaced
migration. This is very related to humanitarian approach during refugee registration
procedures where applicants’ human capital and skills are not the main case (DeVoretz et al. ,
2004).
According to Patrick and Steichen (2014), immigrants who arrived from 2000 onwards to
France, fared badly for first few years because of restrictions on foreign nationals working in
public sector, stringent requirements for certain jobs and occupational barriers. Here it is
important to mention Afonso`s (2016) typology of EU academic markets, were France is
categorized as close job market for foreigners.
Many refugee scientists are experiencing high level of unemployment and their skills are
significantly ignored. They are often facing under-employment or employed by low-skilled
jobs in host countries. The longer they experience under-employment, the more they lose self-
esteem and so as a result they lose their vocational attachment.
Through the project, I aim to create awareness by discussing recently arrived displaced
scientist’s labor market integration testimonies in France. This research focus on PAUSE
emergency program laurates as highly skilled displaced scientist and their potential
contribution to France economy by examining their labor market integration trajectories.
The main issues of labor market integration will be discussed from their job satisfaction, their
career plan, employment related plans, overall life satisfaction perception, difficulties to settle
down, overcome strategies against perceived difficulties for future employment, the personal
characteristics of experienced difficulties, attachment to workplace, testimonies of working
conditions, attractive factors to work in France, return intentions, life well-being, and some
similar sub-topics of work related acculturation.
To develop attractive policies which motivates highly skilled displaced migrants to stay in
France, it is important to understand trajectories of high skilled forced migrants (journalist,
artists, intellectuals, academicians etc) from the beginning of their journey (Simon, Steichen,
2014). To do it in-depth interview “Tell me your story” is conducted with displaced scientists
who are currently PAUSE emergency program laureates in France.
Based on the analysis of difficulties and overcome strategies identified during interview, this
papers aims to provide two types of recommendations as such; policy level recommendations
and recommendations for further research.
This research has three main parts as follow: theoretical discussion of highly skilled displaced
migration (HSDMs) and trajectories and narratives of HSDMs in France and discussion with
recommendations.
Keywords: Highly skilled displaced migration, academic unemployment, refugees’ labor
market integration, deskilling, reskilling, life well-being, job satisfaction work acculturation
EXPORT PDF (FULL)