LIST OF PANELS

169 PANELS FOUND

P01. Great Minds, Ideas, Events and People: Ideational Scholarship, Empirical Analysis, and Behavior
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Radaelli
J. Kamkhaji
F. Van Esch
ABSTRACT

The ideational turn in policy analysis and comparative political economy has been so successful that today to argue that 'ideas matter' is almost a taken-for-granted proposition. Of course, there are many strands of ideational policy analysis (as shown by a recent special issue of Journal of European Public Policy, 23/3/2016; see also Cairney 2012; Goldstein & Keohane 1993; McNamara 1998), some connected with the theories of policy learning, others more concerned with the diffusion of economic policy paradigms such as 'austerity' (Beland and Cox 2009, Berman 2013; Blyth 2013; Helgadóttir 2016). The data show that the most prominent strand in terms of citation and popularity is the approach inaugurated by Peter Hall in the late 1980s and early 1990s with his seminal studies on the political power of economic ideas (Hall 1989; Hall 1993). However, especially in the strand concerned with policy paradigms, the ideational scholarship has been less successful in finding rigorous answers to questions such as where do ideas come from, what are they exactly, and how do they contribute to policy learning and policy change? This is especially true if we consider the advances made in disciplines like cognitive psychology and experimental-evolutionary economics: how open has been ideational policy analysis to the findings of these disciplines? Or, more pertinently perhaps, how receptive should it be, how much cumulative progress should we seek? One problem with some strands of ideational policy analysis is how close the literature developed within ideational political science has been so far to the findings of other disciplines. Another is that the mechanisms theorized by political scientists are intellectually attractive, they seem to make sense in terms of our understanding of the policy process. Yes when we try to corroborate them with the findings of approaches that look at how people behave in the real world, we do not find the same mechanisms, or we find the mechanisms with a different causal order among the variables (Kamkhaji and Radaelli 2017). With this panel we seek to appraise and discuss research questions on the nature of ‘ideas’ (Parsons 2007), the relationship between ideational research and theories of the policy process (Weible et al 2009; Schmidt 2011), the microfoundations of ideational explanations, the link between paradigm formation and paradigm change (Princen and van Esch 2016), and the identification of explicit mechanisms that bring about policy change. Ideas are often evoked, but rarely approached rigorously in terms of concept formation and micro-foundations. On mechanisms, ideational scholarship points to learning, but it has not been conversant with the recent advances in behavioral sciences on how individuals and organizations really learn. Finally, we wish to discuss the boundaries between ideational and cognitive analysis (Jobert 1989, Muller 1995; 2000; 2005) and whether the latter offers a way forward to policy researchers interested in the role of ideas. References Béland, D. and R.H. Cox (2011) Introduction: Ideas and Politics, in Béland, D. and R.H. Cox (Eds) Ideas and Politics in Social Science Research, Oxford, Oxford University Press. Berman, S. (2012). "Ideational theorizing in the social sciences since "Policy Paradigms, Social Learning and the State"." Governance 26(2): 217-237. Blyth, M. (2013). Austerity: The History of a Dangerous Idea. Oxford, Oxford University Press. Cairney, P. (2012). Understanding Public Policy. Basingstoke, UK, Palgrave Macmillan. Goldstein, J. and R. O. Keohane (1993). Ideas and Foreign Policy. Beliefs, Institutions, and Political Change. Ithaca and London, Cornell University Press. Hall, P. (1989). The Political Power of Economic Ideas. Keynesianism Across Nations. Princeton, Princeton University Press. Hall, P. (1993) ‘Policy paradigms, social learning and the state. The case of economic policy-making in Britain’ Comparative Politics 25(3) April: 275-296. Helgadóttir, O. (2016). "The Bocconi boys go to Brussels: Italian economic ideas, professional networks and European austerity." Journal of European Public Policy 23(3): 392-409. Jobert, B. (1989). "The normative frameworks of public policy." Political Studies 37: 376-386. Kamkhaji, JC and C. M. Radaelli (2017) Crisis, learning and policy change in the European UnionJournal of European Public Policy, 24 5 714-734 McNamara, K. R. (1998). The Currency of Ideas. Monetary Politics in the European Union. Ithaca and London, Cornell University Press. Muller, P. (1995). Les politiques publiques comme construction d'un rapport au monde. La Construction du Sens dans les Politiques Publiques. Débats autour de la Notion de Référentiel. A. Faure, G. Pollet and P. Warin. Paris, L'Harmattan: 153-179. Muller, P. (2000). "L'analyse cognitive des politiques publiques : vers une sociologie politique de l'action publique." Revue française de science politique 50(2): 189-208. Muller, P. (2005). "Esquisse d'une théorie du changement dans l'action publique: Structures, acteurs et cadres cognitifs" Revue française de science politique 55: 155-187. Parsons, C. (2007). How to Map Arguments in Political Science. Oxford, Oxford University Press. Princen, S. and F van Esch (2016) Paradigm formation and paradigm change in the EU Stability and Growth Pact. European Political Science Review, 8:3, 355-375. Schmidt, V.A. (2011) Reconciling ideas and institutions through discursive institutionalism, in Béland, D. and R.H. Cox (Eds) Ideas and Politics in Social Science Research, Oxford, Oxford University Press. Weible, C. M., P. A. Sabatier and K. McQueen (2009). "Themes and variations: Taking stock of the advocacy coalitions framework." Policy Studies Journal 37(1): 121-140.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
P02. Public Policy Transfer: Power, Unconventional Agents, Directions and Translations
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Pal
O. Porto de Oliveira
C. Osorio Gonnet
ABSTRACT

The purpose the Panel is to widen and deepen the debate on international circulation of policy models. Policy transfer is a fast-growing field of research in public policy analysis. The international flow of ideas and instruments is intensifying and becoming more rapid (PECK, 2011). The globalization of NPM (PAL, 2009), the diffusion European Union instruments (HALPERN; GALÈS; BART, 2011; SAURUGGER; SUREL, 2006), and the flow of social policies such as food purchase and conditional cash transfers (MORAIS DE SÁ E SILVA, 2017; OSORIO GONNET, 2018), are examples of the range of topics being explored. The literature has developed rapidly, and is already settling around some conventional assumptions and findings. For example, most work focuses on two possible objects of study: the process itself and its results (DOLOWITZ; MARSH, 2000). There is also general agreement that there are four predominant mechanisms in the diffusion of policies: learning, competition, coercion, and socialization (GRAHAM; SHIPAN; VOLDEN, 2013; SIMMONS; DOBBIN; GARRETT, 2008). Other emergent findings are that politicians learn from other systems and emulate their policies (RICHARD ROSE, 1991), governments compete among themselves to promote the interests of their parties or obtain financial resources, policies are institutionally imposed by means of legal devices that encourage adoption, and communities of experts influence the implementation of public management models. As important as it has been, this work has tended to focus on western liberal-democratic regimes (EU and OECD countries), on North-South or North-North transfers, on a conventional roster of agents and actors, and on fairly conventional power dynamics. If we shift the focus to Southern countries, pay attention to different actors, and view power and translation through a wider lens, we can potentially capture a great deal more about the full range of policy transfer phenomena (PORTO DE OLIVEIRA; PAL, 2018). Southern countries emerged on the policy transfer environment, and they bring new power relations and directions to the field. Power relations can take shape in different forms, from policy imposition to distinct degrees of resistance and bargaining, while adopting a policy. The rise of some Southern governments as policy innovators has not only enhanced South-South transfers, but has also produced new experts in new policy fields, bringing them on to the “global policy market”. Unconventional agents have appeared on the transfer stage, such as foundations, consultants, policy advisory groups and firms. And while transfers have been increasing, it is misleading to see this as a “monocropping process” or convergence. The reality is that different types of translations are necessary in order to adapt policy instruments to meet local context, in terms of political culture, institutions and state capacity. The two previous panels at the Milan and Singapore ICPP Conferences made highly successful contributions to policy transfer research, yielding two edited volumes (HADJIISKY; PAL, WALKER, 2017, and WALKER; BAKER, forthcoming 2020). This panel is another step towards the advance of new frontiers of research on the area. REFERENCES DEZALAY, Y.; GARTH, B. G. La mondialisation des guerres de palais: La restructuration du pouvoir d’État en Amérique Latine, entre noblesse du droit et “chicago boys”. Saint-Amand-Montrond: Éditions du Seuil, 2002. DOLOWITZ, David P.; MARSH, D. Learning from Abroad: The Role of Policy Transfer in Contemporary Policy Making. Governance, v. 13, n. 1, p. 5–24, 2000. GRAHAM, E. R.; SHIPAN, C. R.; VOLDEN, C. The Diffusion of Policy Diffusion Research in Political Science. British Journal of Political Science, v. 43, n. 03, p. 673–701, 2013. HADJIISKY, M.; PAL, L. A.; WALKER, C. Public Policy Transfer: Micro-Dynamics and Macro-Effects. [s.l.] Edward Elgar Publishing, 2017. HALPERN, C.; GALÈS, P. L.; BART, J.-Y. No autonomous public policy without ad hoc instruments, Abstract. Revue française de science politique, v. Vol. 61, n. 1, p. 51–78, 17 fev. 2011. HASSENTEUFEL, P. De la comparaison internationale à la comparaison transnationale: Les déplacements de la construction d’objets comparatifs en matière de politiques publiques. Revue française de science politique, v. 55, n. 1, p. 113, 2005. MORAIS DE SÁ E SILVA, M. Poverty Reduction, Education, and the Global Diffusion of Conditional Cash Transfers. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2017. OLIVEIRA, O. P. DE; PAL, L. A. NEW FRONTIERS AND DIRECTIONS IN POLICY TRANSFER, DIFFUSION AND CIRCULATION RESEARCH: AGENTS, SPACES, RESISTANCE, AND TRANSLATIONS. Revista de Administração Pública, v. 52, n. 2, p. 199–220, abr. 2018. OSORIO GONNET, C. A Comparative Analysis of the Adoption of Conditional Cash Transfers Programs in Latin America. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, p. 1–17, 23 jul. 2018. PAL, L. A. The OECD and Global Public Management Reform. p. 33, 2009. PECK, J. Geographies of policy: From transfer-diffusion to mobility-mutation. Progress in Human Geography, v. 35, n. 6, p. 773–797, dez. 2011. PORTO DE OLIVEIRA, O. International Policy Diffusion and Participatory Budgeting: Ambassadors of Participation, International Organizations and Transnational Networks. [s.l.] Palgrave Mcmillan, 2017. RICHARD ROSE. What Is Lesson-Drawing? Journal of Public Policy, v. 11, n. 1, p. 3–20, 1991. SAURUGGER, S.; SUREL, Y. L’européanisation comme processus de transfert de politique publique. Revue internationale de politique comparée, v. 13, n. 2, p. 179, 2006. SIMMONS, B.; DOBBIN, F.; GARRETT, G. The Global Diffusion of Markets and Democracy. [s.l.] Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008. STONE, D. Think Tanks, Global Lesson-Drawing and Networking Social Policy Ideas. Global Social Policy: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Public Policy and Social Development, v. 1, n. 3, p. 338–360, dez. 2001. WALKER, C., BAKER, T., eds., (forthcoming, 2020). Public Policy Transfer: Actors and Arenas [Working title], Palgrave Macmillan WOODS, N. The Globalizers: The IMF, the World Bank, and Their Borrowers. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2006.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
P03. Knowledge and Non-Knowledge in Theories of the Policy Process
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
D. Dolan
Å. Knaggård
S. Blum
ABSTRACT

The objective of this panel is to assess the state of theoretical, empirical, and methodological scholarship on the role of knowledge (including evidence, facts, and science) and non-knowledge (including values, norms, and emotions) in theories of the policy process. While these concepts have longstanding scholarly relevance, our interest is motivated first by its particular timeliness in face of political developments and scholarly debate on ‘post-truth politics,’ but also evidence-based policymaking. Second, we are interested in exploring these notions in the context of related efforts that aim to incorporate realistic notions of rational and irrational choice in policy process studies (e.g. Cairney & Weible 2017; Jones 2017). Finally, this panel is motivated by the emergence of a vibrant research community aimed at refining theories of the policy process, often with a focus on developing testable hypotheses and more rigorous concept definitions (e.g. Herweg, Zahariadis, & Zohlnhöfer, 2018’s review of the Multiple Streams Framework). However, several critical concepts have received comparatively little attention so far, and in particular, the role of knowledge and non-knowledge in theories of the policy process is rarely put centre stage. Recent studies on argumentative coupling (Blum, 2018), narrative uses of evidence (Schlaufer, 2018), problem brokers (Knaggård, 2015), and others suggest a parallel effort is underway aimed at developing these abstract concepts. This work employs research approaches that embrace the messiness and ambiguity of real-world policy processes, ranging from more positivist to more interpretive approaches. Importantly, these efforts are not mere compliments to approaches aimed at identifying regularities and predicting real-world outcomes, but are essential for rigorous comparative public policy research. With this panel, we seek to bring together recent scholarship interested in conceptual advancement related to ‘knowledge’ and ‘non-knowledge,’ broadly defined, in different theories of the policy process, including established theories like Multiple Streams Framework, Advocacy Coalition Framework, Narrative Policy Framework, Punctuated Equilibrium Theory, and others, or newer alternatives such as Programmatic Actor Framework.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
P05. Taking Stock of Policy Entrepreneurship: Current Trajectories and Future Directions
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Petridou
ABSTRACT

The concepts of policy entrepreneurship and the political entrepreneurs, first explored by Ostrom (1965) and further integrated in the policy process theory of multiple streams by Kingdon (1984/2003) and Zahariadis (see, for example, 2007 and 2014) is not new. In a seminal article published 10 year prior to ICPP4 convening, Mintrom and Norman (2009) outlined a set of directions for the scholarship of policy entrepreneurship, noting that “[f]urther work to integrate policy entrepreneurship into mainstream theorizations of policy change holds the potential of changing our notions of the mainstream itself” (p. 663 A lot has happened since then. Petridou (2014) concluded that policy entrepreneurship is a stand-alone lens which can be used to understand policy change. It has been used in various policy sectors (see for example, David, 2015; Olsson and Hysing, 2012; Petridou and Sparf, 2018) in non-western environments (Hammond, 2013; Meydani, 2015) and in conjunction with social network analysis (Christopoulos, 2006; Christopoulos and Ingold, 2015). The advancement and maturity of the literature on policy entrepreneurship, ten years after the publication of the Mintrom and Norman article, necessitates taking stock and setting an updated research agenda for the future. First, perhaps more attention to policy entrepreneurship as a theoretical framework rather vis-à-vis the policy entrepreneur is needed. Additionally, the conceptual interrelations of entrepreneurship and leadership are not yet exhaustively theorized. What is more, more theoretical work is needed to integrate theories of leadership with those of policy entrepreneurship. A fruitful trajectory along these lines is work on entrepreneurial teams. Making use of formal social network analysis would go a long way towards this especially if the team were large enough spanning a number of organizations. A related trajectory is that of the relationship between policy entrepreneurship on the one hand and power and legitimacy on the other. In conjunction with research at the micro level in the motives of policy entrepreneurs and the kind of profit they seek we stand to gain normative insights the role of entrepreneurial agency as an instrument of political power. What is more, though there has been research regarding supra-national organizations, how can we better understand collective actors as entrepreneurs and what are the mechanisms that foster policy entrepreneurship at the supra-national level? Additionally, the call by Mintrom and Norman (2009) for cross-country research is still relevant. However, what kind of methodological hurdles does this entail? Finally, so far research on entrepreneurship has been gender blind. A particularly fruitful future research agenda would be to interrogate gender aspects of policy entrepreneurship. A few questions that emerge are: are women as likely to behave entrepreneurially as men? Are there certain contextual factors that might hinder or foster policy entrepreneurship among women? Do women policy entrepreneurs employ different strategies, behave differently in networks or have different positions than their male counterparts? What is more, there is room for a feminist analysis of political entrepreneurship. So far and on the face of it, the discourse is quite masculine, especially earlier research of the lone entrepreneur, the larger-than-life figure. How would a gender angle influence the discussion on entrepreneurship and leadership? To paraphrase Mintrom and Norman (2009), if you want to make a splash in the study of policy entrepreneurship, innovative work in the fields of leadership, power, legitimacy and gender would be a great place to continue (Petridou, 2017).

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
P06. Ambiguity and Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Zahariadis
T. Birkland
ABSTRACT

The conditions under which policies are made have changed substantially in recent years. Issues have grown ever more complex and in many cases, from the risks of nuclear energy to the European debt crisis, even experts from the scientific community vehemently disagree about feasible policy options. So it is fair to say that governments often do not understand the problems they have to deal with and they do not know if the policies they choose will actually solve the problems at hand. Furthermore, depending on the policy issue at stake, problem production and (national) problem solving have become disconnected due to Europeanization and globalization. Thus, governments have to act under conditions of ambiguity. What is more, they have little time for their decisions as the economy and society change fast, the media are looking out for new stories and voters are becoming increasingly volatile. Both ambiguity and time constraints make models that see policy-making as an exercise in rational problem-solving highly unconvincing. Conversely, Kingdon’s (1995) Multiple Streams Framework (MSF), developed further by Zahariadis (2014), takes ambiguity and policy-makers' time constraints as starting points of the policy process. Three main areas will be at the focus of this panel/section: (a) Theoretical relevance: Are MSF key concepts theoretically well developed? Can we derive and empirically confirm MSF hypotheses? Which theoretical revisions (if any) are necessary in order to allow the framework to work in comparative or international contexts? Are any theoretical adaptations needed in order to explain the policy process in policy areas that are affected by globalization? Does the MSF "travel" well in developing countries? (b) Empirical application: Can the framework's hypotheses be falsified? How can the key concepts be operationalized? (c) Comparison with other theoretical frameworks: How does the MSF fare in comparison with other theoretical frameworks, like the Advocacy Coalition Framework, the Punctuated Equilibrium lens, Institutional Rational Choice, etc.? Does it fall short when it comes to areas where it is expected to do well?

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
P07. Further Defining the Relevance of Agency in the Policy Process: Theoretical and Empirical Issues
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Hassenteufel
J. Mendez
ABSTRACT

Although by no means the only perspective, in the last decades neo-institutionalist approaches have exerted a great influence in the study of social and political processes. In turn, the comparison of dominant theories of the policy process shows that they mainly focus on the systemic level of analysis. Even if these theories take into account individual actors (for instance policy entrepreneurs in the multiple stream framework or policy brokers in the advocacy coalition approach) or collective agents (for instance interest groups and administrations in the punctuated equilibrium theory), they don’t directly or explicitly address the role of actors in the policy processes. Thus, we find of great scientific relevance to address and specify the different possible types of actors and their respective explanatory relevance for the understanding of policy processes and outcomes. After more than two decades in which structural-centered approaches brought a great deal of the attention in social sciences, more recently the importance of actors has started to reemerge, for instance in revised neo-institutionalist perspectives as well as studies on political leadership, neopopulist leaders or public policy processes. In fact, since several decades ago different authors (Schattschneider; Riker, Neustadt, etc.), have made important contributions for the development of approaches that consider the role of actors and their strategies. However, we believe that both old and new contributions still do not offer a precise enough set of traits of agents´ action as to allow for a systematic comparison of cases in order to develop better ways of analyzing the role of actors for the understanding of policy processes and outcomes.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
P09. Advocacy Coalition Framework: Advancing Theory and Evidence about Phenomena of Policy Processes
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Weible
M. Sotirov
T. Heinmiller
ABSTRACT

GENERAL OBJECTIVES, RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE The policy process is complex requiring theoretical approaches to simplify it, help guide in its study, and offer descriptions and explanations. One such theoretical approach is the Advocacy Coalition Framework (ACF). With about 30 years of conceptual development and research under it, the ACF remains one of the most established and applied theoretical approaches to understanding aspects of the policy process in the world. Applications now span political systems and multiple policy issues where knowledge is accumulating about policy change, learning, and, especially advocacy coalitions. General Objectives The general objectives of this panel is to advance the study of public policy and policy processes by exploring and discussing the variety of ACF scholarship that might span across different country-contexts, span across different topics, use different methods of data collection and analysis, and explore theoretical/conceptual improvements to the framework. The main goal of this effort is to tackle phenomena central to the study of policy process and to make clear how the ACF is making a contribution. Scientific Relevance The general objectives fall at the heart of the study of policy processes. Stated more generally, this includes the phenomenon of political mobilization of people and organizations in what might be called the pressure system to influence government particularly outside of elections, the phenomenon of policy change via outputs of government decision-making venues (possibly regulation, legislation, and many other types), and the phenomenon of adaptation and belief change through learning from information, experiences and other stimuli over time. This panel will tackle these phenomena collectively through four sessions that touches upon methodological innovations, innovative approaches to network analysis, how the ACF integrates with other theoretical approaches, and a focus on theoretical insights on policy change. We also expect this panel to contribute to the ongoing discussion of ACF-related phenomena by its research community. Scientific evidence builds up as networks of scholars work together under a shared vernacular to advance similar research questions and publications build populate the field via journals and publishers. This panel will contribute to this effort by integrating scholars under the same research program toward the goal of scientific advancement.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
P10. Old and New Challenges in Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Weible
L. Chaqués Bonafont
B. Peters
ABSTRACT

Over recent decades, scholars in public policy can argue that the field has evolved over time as it has gone global, theories have proliferated and improved, and methodologies have advanced. Yet, some may look at the field, see its challenges and make claims that the field has plateaued; after all, the questions remain mostly the same about the mechanisms and pathways of policy change, about the relative influence of behavioral and structural explanations of policy change, and about the usefulness of theories comparatively. The spirit underlying this panel and its sessions is to tackle questions about the growth and stagnation of the field of public policy by focusing on three of its most central challenges. The first is integrating behavioral and structural explanation for policy-related choices, the second is explanations for policy change, and the third is the vertical and horizontal portability of theories in comparative research. Session 1. Integrating Behavioral and Structural Explanations for Policy Choices The goal of the first session is to explore the conflict between structure and agency. Such conflict has been endemic in the social sciences, as well as in the study of public policy. Both sides of this debate can make strong cases for the primacy of their form of explanation, but the importance of this challenge appears to be finding ways on integrating these forms of explanation. This integration has become more important in public policy studies with the increasing interest in behavioral policy analysis, as well as behavioral public administration. Although perhaps seen most clearly in the study of policy instruments, e.g. “nudge”, questions about appropriate forms of explanation and policy design touch all aspects of public policy. This session will discuss alternative forms of explanation and design, and how they can be brought together for a more rounded conception of how public policies are formed and how they function. This session welcomes research questions that explore cognitive/mental models of the individual and how such models integrate in different settings. This session embraces different theoretical and methodological approaches to this puzzle, including (but not limited to) interpretive/constructive approaches, traditional frameworks and theories of public policy, and new and different approaches. It also welcomes novel theories and synthesized critiques of the field. Session 2. Policy Change: New Theoretical and Methodological Perspectives The goal of the second session is to explore old and new theoretical and methodological perspectives in the analysis of policy change. In its origins, the study of policy change was mainly about the nature of decision-making. The main goal of the heuristic stage model, incrementalism, or rational choice models was mainly to explain the process of decision-making and the capacity of policy-makers to process information. These studies seek to understand why policies emerge, and how policy actors influence final decisions. One of the main features of this first set of theories was their focus on agency leaving aside institutional factors. A second set of theoretical frameworks was developed to explain agency and decision-making. All these theories, from Kingdon’s Multiple Streams Framework, to the Advocacy Coalition Framework, and the Punctuated Equilibrium Theory are aimed to explain how and why policy change occurs focusing mainly on the role of power, ideas, and framing strategies. In Agendas, Alternatives and Public Policies, Kingdon (1984) argues the selection of policy alternatives (i.e, policy change) occurs as the result of the interaction of three different processes, one connected with ideas, another connected with the functioning of the political system, and a third one connected with problems. In a different fashion, the Advocacy Coalition Framework developed by Sabatier and Jenkins-Smith made a major contribution to the study of the importance of ideas in the process of decision-making. In each policy area one can identify different advocacy coalitions composed by a set of different policy actors that share the same ideas and ways of understanding policy issues. In a different vein, Baumgartner and Jones’s Punctuated Equilibrium Theory stresses most issues follow long periods of policy stability that are abruptly interrupted by sudden changes or punctuations. In their theory, Baumgartner and Jones take into account the interaction between ideas, institutions and flows of information. All these theories of policy change have generated a long number of publications and the development of international research programs like the Comparative Policy Agendas (www.policyagendas.org). However, as John (2017) argues, there have been no major innovations that challenge existing theories, with a few exceptions. Some of these challenges come from the use of alternative methodologies like the comparative method in the study of public policy, others from the development of interpretative public policy, while others are more focused on the current debates in political economy. The goal of this panel is to discuss about these new approaches to policy change and their connection with previous theoretical frameworks from a theoretical and empirical point of view. This session welcomes papers that tackle policy change from old and new perspectives, explore this theme of whether and how the field has advanced in the study of policy change, present this theme via methodological innovations, and offers different epistemological and ontological perspectives. Session 3. Vertical and Horizontal Portability of Policy Theories The goal of this third session is to explore the portability of policy theories in comparative research agendas. Theories are being applied vertically from local to international scales and horizontally across various topics and similar jurisdictions. This raises a host of challenges including how to incorporate context into the theories, what factors explain citizen engagement in the policy process across different political systems, how do interest groups vary in different types of pressure systems as they try to influence public policy, and to what extent do the factors associated with policy change vary across different contexts. All of this raises central questions about what it means to conduct comparative research on public policy. Assuming we need theories to help answer these questions (and many others) within a comparative perspective, do we need new theories, are existing theories effective across different contexts, and what's working and what's not working? The spirit of this session is to focus on the portability of theories and the role of theories in comparative public policy research.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
P11. Policy Networks
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
D. Zaytsev
ABSTRACT

During the last few decades, the interest in policy processes generated a number of formal theoretical explanation. Among them are the Advocacy Coalition framework (Sabatier, Hank Jenkins-Smith 1993), Punctuated equilibrium theory (Frank R. Baumgartner and Bryan D. Jones 1993), Multiple streams approach (Kingdon 1984), Policy styles theories (Richardson et al. 1982), Policy Design & Policy Capacity framework (Howlett et. Al 2018), Pragmatic Approach to Public Policy (Zittoun 2014), and some others. Each of them makes its own unique contributions explaining the multidimensional and complex nature of public policy and policy change. In doing so, they attempt to grasp the multiactor nature of policy-making. Variety of actors in public policy is reflected in such terms as policy communities, policy coalitions, and, finally, policy networks. The results of policy-making are dependent on activity and configuration of such policy networks and various conditions, or factors, that are situational depending on configuration of certain combinations. Social Network Analysis, as a methodological framework, provides us with terms, methods, and quantitative statistical techniques that allow us to model the complicated policy processes for a given policy, and provide an opportunity to and develop theories of policy processes that go above and beyond what other instruments provided. At present time, however, we still lack empirical research - verification and validation of developed theories.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
P12. Non Decision Making and Power
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Neubauer-Shani
O. Shamir
ABSTRACT

In their innovative article “Decisions and Non-decisions: An analytical framework” , Bachrach and Baratz coined the concept of “Non-decision”, defining it as “the practice of limiting the scope of actual decision-making to “safe” issues by manipulating the dominant community values, myths, and political institutions and procedures”(Bachrach and Baratz, 1963: 632). In fact, this concept emerged through trials to theorize power relationship in society, and therefore, Bachrach and Baratz suggested that the politics of Non-decision making is the covert face of power, which is “the less apparent but nonetheless extremely important face of power” (Bachrach and Baratz, 1970:9). They had adopted Schattschneider’s (1960) term “Mobilization of Bias” (a set of dominant beliefs, rituals and institutional procedures that operate systematically and consistently to the benefit of certain persons and groups at the expense of others), in order to explain the manipulation taking place in this process and identified several forms of it. Further to their discussion regarding the latent power in Non-decision making, few researchers (e.g., Marchbank, 1994; Lukes, 2005; Bergqvist, Bjarnegård, and Zetterberg ,2015) have been expanding the literature theoretically and empirically. Some have pointed to the strategies and tactics through which, stakeholders defend the status quo in order to prevent any significant policy change (e.g., Sandberg, 2016), while very few others have suggested different factors resulting in non-decision making, aside from mobilization of bias (e.g., McCalla-Chen, 2000). Additionally, the consequences and implications of such policy are largely ignored theoretically. A considerable part of the case studies that have been conducted, focus on the education field and on the health field, and there are still other policy fields, that have not been receiving attention. Likewise, the scope of countries, which have been researched, is quite limited. No theoretical classifications or generalizations in terms of socio-political context and in terms of policy issues, have been made. Thus, the field remains undertheorized. The objective of the panel is to get a deeper understanding of non-decision making in the broad perspective of public policy process. More specifically, the main question will be why and how policy makers avoid decision making in regard to various policy issues and what are the implications of this kind of policy. The panel will invite papers that will extend and deepen work in the field of non-decision making in terms of theory building, innovating our thinking of non-decision by widening the scope of players (interest groups, bureaucrats and the public), and widening the empirical data.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
P13. Making Sense of (and Through) Policy Theory
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
T. Birkland
H. Colebatch
ABSTRACT

The panel aims to bring authors and readers together in an open exploration of the way in which theory is used in the making and analysis of policy. There are numerous books and journal special issues about policy and theory, but they do not always explain how they see the subject and why they address it in the way they do. In this panel, the authors or editors of selected current texts will be invited to state how they see policy process theory, and how they chose to address it in their book, and a selection of readers, with varying relationships to the policy process and its analysis, will be invited to review these books the ways in which, and the extent to which, they found them useful in advancing their understanding of the policy process. The panel is semi-structured, in that three current books on policy process theory have been identified and their authors/editors have agreed to participate. They are: Paul Cairney (Understanding Public Policy: Theories and Issues – Palgrave Macmillan, 2011) Chris Weible (Theories of the Policy Process, Westview, 4th ed., with Paul Sabatier, 2017) Hal K, Colebatch (Handbook on Policy, Process and Governing, Edward Elgar, with Rob Hoppe, 2018) A diverse panel of readers is now being assembled. The panel can be further diversified by the additional of additional texts on policy theory, or additional readers, or both. The Call for Papers will be used to invite this additional participation.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
P14. Public Policy-Making in Developing Countries
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
K. Saguin
E. Florano
ABSTRACT

The study of public policy is a relatively new discipline, prompted by Lasswell’s call for the establishment of a policy sciences in the 1950s. Various theories, frameworks and models, such as advocacy coalition framework (Sabatier 1988), multiple streams framework (Kingdon 1984), have been constructed to provide analytical rigor to understanding how policies are designed, implemented and evaluated. Much of these explanatory frameworks have policy systems from OECD countries in mind and public policy research in developing countries remain scant. The field of comparative public administration acknowledged the dualism between developed and developing country policy-making, but the field have withered due to decolonization. Other comparative studies appear to compare systems only relative to the US and other OECD countries. In 2006, Colebatch and Radin called for greater scholarly work to challenge whether what we know about policy work holds true in these countries. For instance, the growing South-South policy transfer, although limited, have the potential to unpack the mechanisms behind why policies move from one system to another (Nedley, 2004). Existing public policy research in developing countries point to a pluralized, more contested policy system that may challenge the applicability of existing policy theories. However, there is also evidence of convergence of findings that show the need for nuancing these theories into developing countries. This panel will invite papers that will extend and deepen the work on public policy-making in developing countries in two ways. First, how does existing theories apply to developing countries? These papers need to contribute to theory building and unpack the reasons why might public policy-making in developing countries be different (or the same) with developed countries. The idea is to find ways to advance the external validity of these different theories by identifying way to reconfigure its causal logic, variables, among others. Second, papers are invited that identify frameworks, models and practices that intellectually emerged from developing countries. These papers have to describe and explain why these frameworks can contribute to better understanding how public policy-making happen in developing countries.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY PROCESS THEORIES
P01. Knowledge Policy Dynamics in the Global Context
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Vukasovic
J. Jungblut
M. Chou
ABSTRACT

In light of its increased political salience and strengthened academic interest, the proposed panel builds on the ICPP 2017 panel “Analysing knowledge policy coordination for the 21st century”, and explores the intricate dynamics of knowledge policies in the global context. The panel will utilize the multi-level, multi-actor and multi-issue dimensions of contemporary knowledge governance as the predominant heuristic (Chou, Jungblut, Ravinet, & Vukasovic, 2017). The multi-level dimension—and by extension multi-sited—concerns the relationship between policy processes at various governance levels, from sub-national and national to macro-regional and global. The multi-actor dimension highlights the presence of non-state actors, as well as the fact that the state cannot be considered a unitary actor. The multi-issue dimension relates to the fact governance of knowledge requires collaboration across multiple policy sectors, e.g. higher education, research, trade, migration, security. The panel aims to explore the interactions between the multi-level, multi-actor and multi-issue dimensions of governance in relation to three inter-related phenomena: (1) the travelling, diffusion and translation of policy ideas and instruments, (2) the position of research policy (including major international research funding programmes) in relation to governance of knowledge in particular, and public policy in general, and (3) the increasing role of the regional level in knowledge policy coordination. Given the increased internationalization and transnational cooperation with regard to knowledge policies, which resulted to a certain extent in processes of convergence, the first session will focus on the travelling, diffusion and translation of policy ideas and instruments across / in different contexts. As activities such as international bench-marking, policy forums for exchanges of best or good-practice and active policy coordination lead to increased potential for ideas and policies to travel both horizontally between countries and vertically between different levels of policymaking, the question concerning how these ideas and instruments travel becomes more relevant, offering an interesting framework to study more general processes of how policies and ideas travel in such complex environments (Colyvas & Jonsson, 2011; Czarniawska & Sevón, 1996; Marsh & Sharman, 2009; Strang & Meyer, 1993; Strang & Soule, 1998). In this process. it cannot be assumed that these traveling ideas and instruments are simply copied, but rather that they have to be translated to the local context in order to become implemented. The mechanisms, aims, and instruments for funding research have undergone tremendous change over the past several decades. The no-strings-attached model for funding researchers is long dead, as concepts of efficiency, excellence, impact and relevance have gained importance and shaped policy initiatives. Increased globalization in the context of the knowledge-based economy, has made research more central to the competitive economic interests of the state, but many global social and environmental problems demand cooperative scientific efforts. New actors from outside of academia are entering the research policy area not only as recipients but also as participants in funding decisions. The second session will examine the dynamics of research funding policies in light of this changing context, comparing different countries and governance levels but also looking at the intricate interactions between them as they seek to cooperate as well as to capture resources and results. Policy instruments tend to be structured to the source of their problem definition – be that the scientific community, industry or government – and new policy paradigms for each of these have begun to take shape. The European Research Council has put itself out as a global model for research that is academically determined, excellent and which pushes the frontiers of knowledge. Governmental support for industry-based R&D has gained legitimacy, but often operates under different principles than peer-reviewed tenders. Finally, the concept of ‘grand challenges’ as a societally defined means to frame and fund research that tackles what are often termed ‘wicked problems’ (Rittel & Webber, 1973) transcend national boundaries and traditional actors in the governance of knowledge (Kuhlmann & Rip, 2018; Ulnicane, 2016). The new landscape of research funding policy raises significant questions about the framing, problem definition, actor constellations, implementation, and evaluation of these policies, which will be addressed in this session. The third session will focus on regional level policy coordination, both (1) macro-regional arrangements (e.g. EU, ASEAN, MERCOSUR) and (2) cooperation between a smaller number of geographically proximate countries with economic, political, social and cultural similarities (e.g. Nordic, Benelux, Baltic). It will explore (a) which state and non-state actors are involved in such policy coordination, (b) what kind of issues are subject to regional level policy coordination and how that relate to issues addressed at other governance levels and (c) how regional level policy coordination relates to policy coordination at other governance levels (e.g. how coordination in the Nordic region relates to EU level governance). Furthermore, it will analyse how these characteristics of regional level policy coordination affect integration of these regions. In doing so, it will contribute to emerging literature on comparative regionalism and differentiated integration (Chou & Ravinet, 2015; Holzinger & Schimmelfennig, 2012; Robertson, 2010; Sbragia, 2010; Warleigh-Lack, 2015). Through these three sessions, relying on a common multi-level, multi-actor, and multi-issue governance heuristic and analysing processes in core policy domains for contemporary knowledge societies and economies, the panel aims to contribute to ICPP’s Comparative Public Policy topic (T02). Each session will have a designated discussant who will provide specific comments for each accepted paper as well as more generic reflections on the session as a whole. In consultation with the discussants, the chairs will explore possibilities for publishing most promising papers in a special issue. In order to be selected, the papers will have to have a clear conceptual approach supported by empirical examples, preferably beyond a single case study. References Chou, M.-H., Jungblut, J., Ravinet, P., & Vukasovic, M. (2017). Higher education governance and policy: an introduction to multi-issue, multi-level and multi-actor dynamics. Policy and Society, 36(1), 1-15. doi:10.1080/14494035.2017.1287999 Chou, M.-H., & Ravinet, P. (2015). Governing higher education beyond the state: The rise of ‘Higher education regionalism'. In H. De Boer, D. D. Dill, J. Huisman, & M. Souto-Otero (Eds.), Handbook of Higher Education Policy and Governance (pp. 361-378). London: Palgrave. Colyvas, J. A., & Jonsson, S. (2011). Ubiquity and Legitimacy: Disentangling Diffusion and Institutionalization*. Sociological Theory, 29(1), 27-53. doi:doi:10.1111/j.1467-9558.2010.01386.x Czarniawska, B., & Sevón, G. (Eds.). (1996). Translating organizational change (Repr. ed. Vol. 56 : Organizational theory and research). Berlin: de Gruyter. Holzinger, K., & Schimmelfennig, F. (2012). Differentiated Integration in the European Union: Many concepts, sparse theory, few data. Journal of European Public Policy, 19(2), 292-305. doi:10.1080/13501763.2012.641747 Kuhlmann, S., & Rip, A. (2018). Next-Generation Innovation Policy and Grand Challenges. Science and Public Policy, 45(4), 448-454. doi:10.1093/scipol/scy011 Marsh, D., & Sharman, J. C. (2009). Policy diffusion and policy transfer. Policy Studies, 30(3), 269-288. doi:10.1080/01442870902863851 Rittel, H. J., & Webber, M. (1973). Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Policy Sciences, 4(2), 155-169. doi:10.1007/BF01405730 Robertson, S. L. (2010). The EU, ‘regulatory state regionalism’ and new modes of higher education governance. Globalisation, Societies and Education, 8(1), 23-37. doi:10.1080/14767720903574033 Sbragia, A. (2010). Multi-level governance and comparative regionalism. In M. Zürn, H. Enderlein, & S. Wälti (Eds.), Handbook on Multi-level Governance (pp. 267-278). Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. Strang, D., & Meyer, J. W. (1993). Institutional conditions for diffusion. Theory and Society, 22(4), 487-511. doi:10.1007/bf00993595 Strang, D., & Soule, S. A. (1998). Diffusion in Organizations and Social Movements: From Hybrid Corn to Poison Pills. Annual Review of Sociology, 24(1), 265-290. doi:10.1146/annurev.soc.24.1.265 Ulnicane, I. (2016). Research and innovation as sources of renewed growth? EU policy responses to the crisis. Journal of European Integration, 38(3), 327-341. doi:10.1080/07036337.2016.1140155 Warleigh-Lack, A. (2015). Differentiated integration in the European Union: towards a comparative regionalism perspective. Journal of European Public Policy, 22(6), 871-887. doi:10.1080/13501763.2015.1020837

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P02. Public Policy Challenges and Multi-level Governance in Japan: Sharing Japan’s Experiences as a Forerunner of Emerging Issues
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Kikuchi
ABSTRACT

One of the major objectives of this panel is to bring together scholars and practitioners from diverse public policy fields and countries to explore various policy and management issues in Japan from a comparative perspective. Facing depopulation, population structure change with super aging society, energy transitions after the Fukushima crisis and others, Japan is becoming a “leading-edge” field of various policy and management challenges. As of 2017, more than 27% of whole populations in Japan are 65 years old and above, which is far ahead of any other country in the world. This places Japanese government under heavy policy and financial burden to cover the ever-increasing medical cost, pension, and nursing care and others, while its financial and administrative capacity has been shrinking due to a smaller number of working population. The other example of policy challenge facing Japan is the energy transitions after the Fukushima crisis in 2011. The Fukushima nuclear mishap jolted energy sector and public opinion to expedite the energy transitions to more renewable energy. Yet the technological advancement is still uncertain whether it can be a stable energy source. Japanese government is struggling between competing visions of energy transitions. These challenging policy and management issues are not necessary confined to one single country. But certainly Japan is at the forefront of facing these emerging issues that the rest of the world would face sooner or later. Exploring various policy and management issues in Japan has rich academic and practical insights for other countries and policy fields. The panel aims to offer a valuable opportunity to discuss various policy and management issues in Japan from a comparative perspective. We welcome conceptual, methodological, and empirical contributions about policy and managerial issues in Japan that focus on managerial, organizational, institutional, and specific policy level, as well as case studies with comparative perspective. This panel is hosted and organized by the Public Policy Studies Association Japan (PPSAJ).

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P03. Traditions of Public Administration Research: Should they be Celebrated?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Roberts
E. Charbonneau
C. Eichbaum
ABSTRACT

In his 2014 Braibant lecture (Pollitt, 2015) Christopher Pollitt noted the existence of a multiplicity of administrative traditions, some long-standing but new entrants to the international and comparative conversation, and observed that there was now the potential for that conversation, while difficult, to be a rewarding one. The panel will examine four questions. The first is to consider whether such traditions exist, and the ways in which traditions differ -- such as the range of questions posed, and methods applied. The second question is whether these traditions are likely to persist, or whether they are fading as a result of the "globalization" of the scholarly enterprise -- that is, the homogenizing effects of globalized publishing, conferences, and academic hiring. The third question is whether the fading of traditions, if it is evident, should be regarded as a cause for concern. To put it any other way, should we be pluralists, celebrating diversity in approaches, or should we encourage global convergence? The fourth question: if we aim to be pluralists, how should we advance the conversation proposed by Pollitt in 2014? The panel will aim for gender balance and also representation from at least one major country outside the developed world, such as India. Candler, Gaylord George. 2014. "The Study of Public Administration in India, the Philippines, Canada and Australia: The Universal Struggle against Epistemic Colonization, and Toward Critical Assimilation." Revista de Administração Pública 48 (5):1073-1093. Charbonneau, Étienne, Luc Bernier, and Nicholas Bautista-Beauchesne. 2018. “Punching below its weight: Canadian public administration scholarship on the world stage.” Canadian Public Administration 61 (3): 359–382. Gow, James Ian. 2009. "Evolution of Disciplinary and Paradigms in the Study of Public Administration in Canada." In The Evolving Physiology of Government: Canadian Public Administration in Transition, edited by O.P. Dwivedi, Tim A. Mau and Byron Sheldrick, 40-73. Ottawa, ON: University of Ottawa Press. Pollitt, Christopher. 2015. "Towards a New World: Some Inconvenient Truths for Anglosphere Public Administration." International Review of Administrative Sciences 81 (1):3-17. 0Roberts, Alasdair. 2017. "Our Asian Challenge." Governance 30 (4):537-539.

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P04. Migration and Citizenship: Policies and Research in Global Comparative Perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
Y. Abu-Laban
M. Paquet
E. Tungohan
ABSTRACT

According to figures collected by the United Nations, globally the number of international migrants has grown over the course of the twenty-first century, standing at 244 million in 2015, an increase of 41% from 2000. Likewise, the numbers of forcibly displaced peoples and refugees has also grown over the course of the 2000s, and is higher now than at any time since the end of World War II. Because migration is such an increasingly important feature of all world regions and societies, there is a need for a global comparative perspective to assess the nature of national and regional policy responses and their consequences for migrants and refugees, for civil society organizations representing migrants’ and refugees’ interests, for sending and receiving societies, and for international norms pertaining to human rights and protection. The primary objective of the panel(s) associated with “Migration and Citizenship: Policies and Research in Global Comparative Perspective” is to challenge extant global inequalities in immigration research by enabling, showcasing and sustaining a unique dialogue involving the experiences of countries and regions of both the global North and the global South. Since the end of the 1990s, immigration studies have developed into a considerable field of research in the social sciences. In North America, Australia and Western Europe, the result of this development has been research that often focuses “South-North” migrations and that is concerned with the impact of immigration on host societies in the Global North. Nowhere is this more the case than in political science and in the study of public policy. With notable exceptions, these disciplines rarely engage with work produced by scholars from immigrant-sending countries, or with work that explores the dynamics associated with immigration outside of the global North. Some scholars, in fact, have flagged how existing frameworks, methods, and theories do not account for the specificities of migration trends in the global South. That migration policy studies erroneously assume that most migration follows “a developing-to-developed migration path” or that the same “formalized rights regimes” that exist in the Global North are present in the global South highlights but a few examples of how ideas around migration policy studies are still based on frameworks taken in the global North (seee.g.: Nawyn 2016). As a result, important issues remain unaddressed by political science and policy studies when it comes to immigration. Far from exhaustively, these include: migration regimes of the global south, internal and regional migrations, the social impact of remittance and more, importantly, the consequences of the global North migration regimes on the political context in sending countries. This workshop aims to challenge this silence by asking: i) What are the similar and divergent migration trends, patterns and challenges from a global cross-national perspective? ii) What are the dynamics and structural forces that support the organization and production of current immigration research in political science and policy studies? and iii) What could be the basis for a research agenda for immigration research in political science and policy studies that would consider the global South equally to the global North?

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P07. The Political Economy of Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Vannoni
P. John
ABSTRACT

At its start, the study of public policy lacked unity, reflecting on the nature of the topic itself (John 2003). One major strand focused on the differences across policies: different instruments, different constraints and opportunities etc. The result was a descriptive study of public policy (e.g., policy taxonomies). The other strand was more concerned with the support of specific policies and their evaluation. The goal in this case was more normative, than analytical (Birkland 2015). In the 1970s, public policy students became more concerned with explaining public policy, instead of categorising or evaluating it. Public policy theories started to emerge. Some theories focused on how ideas spread across countries and enter the political agenda (Hall 1993). Others were more concerned with the role of societal actors and their interaction with the public sector (Maass 1951). Others again studied the role of socio-economic change. Despite their focus on explaining public policy, these strands focused on single factors. In the 1990s, the so called ‘synthetic approaches’ emerged, emphasising that ideas, socio-economic factors and policy networks interact with each other and affect policy dynamics: the multiple stream approach (Kingdon 1995), the advocacy coalition framework (Sabatier and Jenkins-Smith 1993) and the punctuated equilibrium theory (Baumgartner and Jones 1993). These approaches have dominated the discipline ever since, despite calls for an institutionalist/comparative turn. In order to move the discipline forward, this panel seeks to capitalise on a recent trend in public policy: the use of economic models and methods that have already been applied to the study of international relations (IR) and comparative politics (John 2018). In the last decades, comparative politics and IR have embraced the use of advanced data gathering methods and statistical models. The use of text data has expanded rapidly in recent years (Gentzkow, Shapiro, and Sinkinson 2011; Lucas et al. 2015), with major examples including the detection of legislative agendas or topics and estimating the ideological positions of parties or single legislators. Attention in this area has recently moved from supervised approaches to unsupervised approaches, most notably machine learning. Also, the use of quasi-experimental research designs, such as natural experiments, instrumental variable approaches, difference-in-difference approaches etc., structural equations and spatial regression models has become common practice in comparative politics and IR . Finally, we have witnessed an increasing use of game theoretic models to drive the study of parties, voting behaviour, conflict and so on. In the past years, some work has started to use these models and methods to study public policy topics. For instance, Bertelli and John (2012) use an economic theory of investment and Monte Carlo simulation to study uncertainty in policy prioritization in the UK. Kreppel and Oztas (2017) use a veto player model to study agenda setting in the EU. König and Mäder (2014) look at policy implementation in the EU with a strategic game between a central monitoring agency and multiple implementers.

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P08. Problem-Solving and Learning in Multilevel Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Thomann
C. Dunlop
ABSTRACT

Multilevel governance is the result of a process in which decision makers shifted competencies away from the nation-state in order to deal with pressing policy challenges that exceed the reach of the central government. As such, multilevel governance is a result of globalization and modernization, based on the assumption of an improved problem-solving capacity. Problem-solving can both be seen as a decision-making mode/process, and as a result of these processes. Trein et al. (2019) define problem-solving as a process through which the policymakers in charge make policies so as to deal with problems that are perceived as important for society by organized groups and/or by policymakers themselves, through the cooperative production of a policy output that is expected to be collectively beneficial in making a contribution to solve the policy problem at stake. The goal of this panel is to collect contributions that provide theoretical and empirical insights on problem-solving in multilevel governance. Recent years have witnessed important theoretical, conceptual and empirical innovations in how we think of problem-solving in multilevel governance. Scholars have moved beyond traditional approaches to thinking of multilevel governance mainly in structural terms and through a command-and-control perspective, as these often cannot explain the distinct workings of multilevel governance in the absence of a clear “shadow of hierarchy”. Moreover, there is a move beyond the assumption that policy adoption is the decisive stage of problem-solving. Instead, there is emphasis on the processes of implementation, evaluation, and problem definition, the patterns and underlying mechanisms of differentiation as well convergence. Scholars increasingly emphasize mechanisms of learning (Dunlop et al. 2018) and experimentalist governance (Sabel and Zeiltin 2010) and link such mechanisms with patterns of policy differentiation (e.g., customization), success, and failure (Dunlop 2017; Thomannn 2019). References Dunlop, C. A. (2017). Policy learning and policy failure: Definitions, dimensions and intersections. Policy & Politics, 45(1), 3-18. Dunlop, C. A., Radaelli, C. M., & Trein, P. (Eds.). (2018). Learning in Public Policy: Analysis, Modes and Outcomes. Springer. Sabel, C. F., & Zeitlin, J. (Eds.). (2010). Experimentalist governance in the European Union: towards a new architecture. Oxford University Press on Demand. Trein, P., Thomann, E. & M. Maggetti (2019). Integration, functional differentiation and problem-solving in multilevel governance: a comparative perspective. Symposium in Public Administration. Thomann, E. (2019). Customized implementation of European Union food safety policy: United in diversity? Palgrave Macmillan, International Series on Public Policy.

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P09. Australia and New Zealand Public Policy in Comparative Perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Newman
B. Coffey
ABSTRACT

As Western industrialized democracies located in the southern hemisphere, Australia and New Zealand are unique entities in the global policy arena. They are the two richest countries in the southern hemisphere as measured by GDP per capita, and they represent two out of only three southern members of the OECD. They have the highest life expectancies, the lowest income inequality, and the highest happiness index of any country in the southern hemisphere. Indeed, in a time when Global South is a term used to represent emerging economies and developing democracies, Australia and New Zealand are uniquely characterised by their status as wealthy and influential southern democracies. Australia and New Zealand face unique policy challenges, but within similar contexts. The economies of both countries depend heavily on primary resource extraction and export, and the fluctuating demands of China and other emerging Asian economies, along with a rethinking of global trade strategies, pose high levels of uncertainty for decision making in a number of policy areas, including industry, military, and research and development. Conservation, biodiversity, and environmental protection remain especially challenging for domestic policy making in these two unique ecosystems, under the looming effects of climate change and the persistent problem of invasive species. On the other hand, both countries are dealing with issues that are also relevant in many other developed democracies. Tension between socially progressive and more conservative voices have revealed a polarised landscape of public opinion on social issues, and policy decisions in a variety of social areas, from immigration to marriage equality, continue to pose significant challenges for decision makers. Shifts in the labour force and in population demographics mean that many social policies, from child care to aged care, are being redesigned. As in other jurisdictions, a decline in many forms of violent crime is concurrent with a dramatic rise in domestic violence, which has created difficulties for policy making in the areas of law enforcement and criminal justice. Australia and New Zealand present a unique opportunity for comparison with the rest of the world. Though small and isolated in relation to other Western democracies, the presence of both unique and common policy issues invites a comparative analysis with other policy making jurisdictions.

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P10. Bad Governance and Public Management Problems in the Developing World: Frameworks, Evidence and Cases
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Andrenacci
M. Barzelay
C. Cervantes-Bautista
ABSTRACT

Governance, in modern states, is problematic, particularly in democratic institutional frameworks. Adding to ‘normal’ difficulties inherent to the complexity of steering multiple sets of institutions within public opinions shifts and legal frameworks boundaries, polities are strained by tensions and conflicts arising from the very nature of economic and social issues. States are under intense and recurrent demands, with limited state capacity and restricted options. Public administration is always under substantial stress and intense pressures. Good and bad government can be understood as “success” in key political arenas, or merely as political survival of a governing coalition. Certainly many -if not all- of these problems are universal, as the present shows with some clarity. But they tend to become more dramatic in countries where life conditions of most citizens are considered either insufficiently decent or too unequal, therefore straining governance to higher levels of conflict, usually within less performant economic systems and lower levels of state autonomy and capacity. The central question the panel wishes papers to address is: Are there public management problems specific to this “developing world”? And if so, what, where and when? The workshop evolves from the interest to continue the discussion started at the 2018 Pittsburgh workshop Bad Governance, State Capacity Deficits and Public Policy Management Problems in Developing Countries: What Do We Know? In that workshop, we received papers dealing with public policy analysis strategies capable of detecting state management issues during the “management-intense” phases of public policy design and implementation; as well as papers studying specific cases of “bad” or “unsuccessful” public management. The rich discussion that ensued dealt with the reasons underlying low performances of state agencies in all sectors and levels of government; low, insufficient or unstable impacts, relative to public and expert expectations; and legally and/or ethically objectionable ways and procedures. Among many political scientists, these governance problems are likely to be attributed to “bad politics”, assuming the public policy process is a somewhat mechanical outcome of political arrangements and decisions. In other cases, they are attributed to “error”, assuming political regimes, governments and governing coalitions, or even specific figureheads, actually plan and implement strategies according to their interests and will. Yet, for researchers interested in the organizational problems of public policy, and the meanders of decision-making and management, a challenging handful of question derives from cases of unsuccessful policies. Classical policy analysis defined “good” governance as timely and cost-efficient solutions to problems (Lasswell, 1951; Lindblom, 1959), although it was soon acknowledged that the very nature of problems -let alone the solutions- vary according to interests and cognitive maps (Wildavsky, 1979). Within the political regimes where policy sciences developed -democracies, or more precisely, “polyarchies” (Dahl, 1971)- a considerable variety of interests and cognitive maps are tolerated, as long as basic sets of rules are respected, essentially: the rights to do politics, to maintain free flows of information, and to avoid excessive concentration of political power. In such regimes, “good” needs to carry an acceptable degree of “common”. Other public policy students directed their attention to “governance” and “state capacity”, as (more or less related) ideas capable of providing frameworks to answer questions about state performances and public policy results. At least since the provoking works of Michael Mann (1997, 1998, 2012 and 2013) comparative studies aimed at resuming Max Weber’s reasoning on states (1977), looking for keys to understand their success and failure as political organizations producing material and symbolic forms of power. If in Mann, infrastructural power is the effective combination of key sources of social power through political means (1997 and 2012), the question is how to get this combination, particularly when it does not seem to come out of contingency. Some of these studies worked on the classical idea of “good government” (Rosanvallon, 2015) or “governance” (Mayntz), in at least two senses: the ways in which policies are conducted in arenas or political regimes where power is not concentrated (Bovens, t'Hart & Peters, 2001; Benz & Papadopoulos, 2006; Peters & Pierre, 2006; all drawing on numerous previous authors); or the ways in which problems affect state performance (Tobelem, 1992; Evans, 1995; Grindle, 1996; ibidem). Most studies in this direction tended to look, at the same time, at institutional and operational, political and administrative dimensions of public policy, and invited to look into (though not necessarily did) the actual implementation processes (Saetren, 2005). On this issue of “public management”, within a relatively abundant literature (see Lynn, 2005 y 2006; and Pollitt & Bouckaert, 2004 y 2009; for general approaches), key debates tended to identify the specificity of public management (Barzelay, 1992); its changes through time (Hood, 1991; Frederickson, 1996); the problems of bureaucratic organizations that are, at the same time, subjects, stake-holders and objects of public policies (Moe, 1989; Olsen, 2005 and 2008); the issue of human resources, public service and civil service (Ingraham, 2005; Derlien & Peters, 2008); or the problem of inadequacy and obsolescence of public policy tools facing rapidly changing public problems (Dror, 2001). Closer to our interests, Bovens, t'Hart y Peters (2001) searched for patterns of success and failure, for selected European countries, in what they labelled governance capacities. Isolating relevant public policy fields where national and European Union collided, they traced the way in which national state agencies intervened. Interestingly, they identified significant asymmetries in the assessment of “success” and “failure” to programmatic achievements (relative to the actual problems policies supposedly attacked) and to political achievements (relative to the perceptions the public had on such “attacks”). “Success” was to be used only if the asymmetry between these two assessments was low enough. Although none of the factors underlying success and failure found were common enough to establish general patterns capable, key factors found were institutional “embeddedness” or propension to negotiation and agreement between different sectors and levels of government (as in Evans, 2005); favourable contingency, as in “solutions finding problems” (Cohen, March & Olsen, 1989); “windows of opportunity (Kingdon, 2010); capacities in civil service (Cohen, 1993); and “advocacy coalitions” (Sabatier, 1998). In the same direction, Martin Painter and Jon Pierre (2015) suggested to speak of policy capacity as the ability to adequately combine classical elements of state capacity, political and administrative, achieving governing capacities. While policy capacities depend on stocks of resources moving in essentially contingent ways, governing capacities generate and accumulate adequate quantities and qualities of resources, controlling flows and pointing them toward desired directions, thus producing the expected outputs and outcomes (Painter & Pierre, 2015: 3-4). The effectiveness of these governing capacities can be measured through performance indicators and normative criteria, and in so doing, research can point to instruments and tools that recurrently (although not systemtically or mechanically) orient flows in successful ways, and can become key support systems for governments. The proposed panel wishes to continue this discussion focusing on cases coming from the developing world, around the following key questions. On what conceptual/normative basis do we speak of good and bad governance, and what is the specific role of public administration in it? Is there specificity in the developing world’s public administration issues, relative to “universal” state management problems? Are there patterns on which comparative studies can shed light, on developing countries public policy issues like inadequate strategic decision-making, or unethical management -corruption, in a wider sense? Are there frameworks of analysis that can be used to understand public administration issues in developing countries, regardless of sectors or political regimes? References Barzelay, Michael (1992): Breaking Through Breaucracy. A New Vision for Managing in Government; Berkeley, University of California Press. Benz, Arthur & Papadopoulos, Yannis (editores) (2006): Governance and Democracy. Comparing national, European and international experiences; Routledge, New York. Benz, Arthur & Papadopoulos, Yannis (2006): "Governance and Democracy: Concepts and Key Issues"; in Benz & Papadopoulos (op. cit.). Bovens, Mark; t'Hart, Peter & Peters, Guy (2001): "Analysing governance success and failure in six European states"; in Bovens, Mark; t'Hart, Peter & Peters, Guy (editores): Success and Failure in Public Governance: A Comparative Analysis; Edward Elgar, Cheltenham-Northampton. Bresser-Pereira, Luiz Carlos (1977): Estado e Subdesenvolvimento Industrializado; Editora Brasiliense, São Paulo. Cohen, Michael; March, James & Olsen, Johan (1972): "A Garbage Can Model of Organizational Choice"; in Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol. 17, N° 1. Cohen, Steven (1993): "Defining and Measuring Effectiveness in Public Management"; in Public Productivity & Management Review, Vol. 17, N° 1. Dahl, Robert (1971): Polyarchy: Participation and Opposition; New Haven-London, Yale University Press. Derlien, Hans-Dietrich & Peters, Guy (2008): The State at Work; Volume 1: Public Sector Employment in Ten Western Countries; Edward Elgar, Cheltenham. Dror, Yehezkel (2001): The Capacity to Govern. A Report to the Club of Rome; Frank Cass, London-Portland. Evans, Peter (1995): Embedded Autonomy: States and Industrial Transformation; Princeton University Press. Ferlie, Ewan; Lynn, Laurence Jr. & Pollitt, Christopher (editors) (2005): The Oxford Handbook of Public Management, Oxford University Press. Frederickson, H. George (1996): "Comparing the Reinventing Government Movement with the New Public Administration"; in Public Administration Review, Vol. 56, No. 3. Grindle, Merilee (1996): Challenging the State. Crisis and Innovation in Latin America and Africa; Cambridge University Press. Hood, Christopher (1991): "A Public Management for All Seasons?"; in Public Administration, Vol. 69. Ingraham, Patricia (2005): "Striving for Balance. Reforms in Human Resources Management"; in Ferlie et altrii (op. cit.). Kingdon, John (1995): Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies; Harper-Collins, Nueva York. Lasswell, Harold (1951): ‘The policy orientation’, in Lerner, Daniel & Lasswell, Harold (editores): The Policy Sciences; Stanford University Press. Lindblom, Charles (1959): “The science of 'muddling through'”; en Public Administration Review Vol. 19, N° 2. Lynn, Laurence Jr. (2005): "Public Management: A Concise History of the Field"; in Ferlie et altrii (op. cit.). Lynn, Laurence Jr. (2006): Public Management: Old and New; New York & London, Routledge. Mann, Michael (1997): The sources of social power. Volume I: A history of power from the beginning to AD 1760; Cambridge University Press [1986]. Mann, Michael (1998): The sources of social power. Volume II: The rise of classes and nation-states, 1760-1914; Cambridge University Press [1993]. Mann, Michael (2012): The sources of social power. Volume III: Global Empires and Revolution, 1890-1945; Cambridge University Press [1993]. Mann, Michael (2013): The sources of social power. Volume IV: Globalizations, 1945-2011; Cambridge University Press. March, James & Olsen, Johan (1989): Rediscovering Institutions: The Organizational Basis of Politics, Free Press, Nueva York. Mayntz, Renate (2006): “Governance en el Estado moderno” [2003]; in POSTData N° 11. Moe, Terry (1989): “The Politics of Bureaucratic Structure”; in Chubb, John & Peterson, Paul (editores): Can the Government Govern?; Brookings Institution Press, Washington DC. Olsen, Johan (2005): "Maybe It Is Time To Rediscover Bureaucracy"; in Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory N° 16. Olsen, Johan (2008): "The Ups and Downs of Bureaucratic Organization"; in Annual Review of Political Science Vol. 11. Painter, Martin y Pierre, Jon (2005): Challenges to State Policy Capacity. Global Trends and Comparative Perspectives; Houndmills, Palgrave-Macmillan. Peters, Guy & Pierre, Jon (2006): "Governance, Accountability and Democratic Legitimacy"; in Benz & Papadopoulos (op. cit.). Pollitt, Christopher & Bouckaert, Geert (2004): Public Management Reform: A Comparative Analysis; Oxford University Press. Pollitt, Christopher & Bouckaert, Geert (2009): Continuity and Change in Public Policy and Management; Edward Elgar, Cheltenham. Rosanvallon, Pierre (2015): Le bon gouvernement; Paris, Seuil. Sabatier, Paul (1998): "The Advocacy Coalition Framework: Revisions and Relevance for Europe", in Journal of European Public Policy, Vol. 5, N° 1. Saetren, Harald (2005): "Facts and Myths about Research on Public Policy Implementation: Out-of-Fashion, Allegedly Dead, But Still Very Much Alive and Relevant"; in Policy Studies Journal, Vol. 33, N° 4. Tobelem, Alain (1992): "Institutional Capacity Analysis and Development Systems (ICADS): Operational Manual"; World Bank LATP Occasional Papers N° 9, Washington DC. Weber, Max (1977): Economía y sociedad. Esbozo de sociología comprensiva [1922]; México, Fondo de Cultura Económica.Wildavsky, Aaron (1979): Speaking Truth to Power: The Art and Craft of Policy Analysis; Little-Brown, Boston.

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P11. Are Public Policies still Public? Questioning the Relationship between the Public and Private Sector in the Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Soriat
O. Provini
ABSTRACT

Research in public policy analysis has shown a reconfiguration of the boundaries between the public and the private sector since the 1980s, which is due to the expansion of liberalization policies, the privatization of public companies or even the advent of management standards within public administrations. The “public” character of public policies has been questioned to the effect that the term “governance” has become a recurrent concept for describing the coproduction of policies by a heterogeneous set of public and private stakeholders (Hyden, 1992 ; Kooiman, 2003).Yet, numerous scholars disprove the idea of the private sector “cannibalizing” the public (Hibou, 2013). The ongoing dynamics would reflect a redefinition of the role of the state rather than provoking its retreat. The decreasing scope of state intervention can instead be considered as a deliberate strategy of adaption to a number of constraints. As a result, new styles of government “by delegation” emerge, whereby the market and the private sector are used as an instrument of a state, whose functions are focused on regulation and incentives (Ansaloni and Smith, 2017). From this point of view, an opposition of the public and private dynamics would be scientifically misleading. Instead, it is crucial to study the intertwining relationships between both sectors. The intention of this panel is to move the debate about transforming borders between the public and private sectors from empirical fields in the “Global North” to “Southern” contexts, where public stakeholders dispose a priori of fewer human, economic and knowledge-based resources. This empirical shift is even more important, as the limited capacities of states – compared to the North – have been interpreted by several scholars as a decline or even an absence of public policies (Chabal & Daloz, 1999 ; Carment et al., 2010). This intertwining between public management and private interests in Southern contexts has been analyzed by scholars dealing with state-building in Africa (Médard, 1990 ; Bayart, 1989). They tend to argue that these boundaries are even more blurred in African contexts (Ferguson, 2006 ; Hibou, 2012; Harrison, 2005 ; Kelsall, 2013).Thus, shifting the focus on the Global South seems relevant to reconsider the frontiers between the private and the public sector, to discuss the results stemming from Northern contexts and to move the historical and sociological trajectory of the state at the center of public policy analysis. Whereas the literature on public policy analysis is tending towards an ever-greater hyperspecialization and to untie its approaches from state sociology (Smyrl, 2002 ; Bezes & Pierru, 2012), we argue that studying the public character of public policies in the Global South is crucial for understanding the long-term transformations of the state (Evans et al., 1985). This panel proposal is part of the research program “Making policies in Africa”, backed by the research laboratory Les Afriques dans le Monde at Sciences Po Bordeaux. However, the panel aims to exceed the initial frame of the project in order to establish new scientific collaborations and to internationalize the exchange on this relevant research question.

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P12. Pushing the Boundaries of Comparative Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
I. Engeli
C. Rothmayr Allison
ABSTRACT

This panel addresses the major challenges for comparative design in public policy analysis today: the strong focus on the usual suspects regarding country and issue selection, the methodological divide between quantitative and qualitative approaches and the availability of comparable data. The aim of the panel is to reflect on the limitations of current practices in policy analysis and discuss innovative ways of pushing methodological and comparative boundaries within the discipline by addressing these three major challenges. Recent research on publication patterns shows the limits of internationalization in top political science journals. Similar patterns can also be observed in public policy journals. Policy Research concentrates repeatedly on a limited number of countries, while others are barely mentioned. There is also an overfocus on a relatively limited number of policy fields that are considered to be politically salient. And even within these fields, some issues still remain largely disregarded. Finally, despite numerous calls for bridging the methodological divide, mixed-methods designs and alternative data collections remain scarce in comparative public policy analysis. These limitations in comparative practices have major implications. It stalls our capacity for cumulative knowledge, theory building and generalization; it also hinders our aim to make better policies; it sends the wrong signal to our student population and early-career scholars about what should be studied; and it makes entry into the field for scholars working on less studied countries or policy issues more challenging. The panel addresses the challenge of how to engage a conversation across sectoral divides and across methodological divides. While the field of comparative policy analysis has been rapidly growing, centrifugal forces pull the field in very different directions. Sectoral, regional and methodological specialization, and theory building vs. policy analysis as advice are all dividing the field in sub-communities. This fragmentation stalls our capacity for cumulative knowledge, theory building and generalization and it lessens the potential impact of policy studies on actual policy-making. This panel proposes to look at these methodological challenges across three main lines of inquiry: 1) How comparative is our comparative perspective and how can we improve the comparative scope of our studies regarding country, sector and issue selection? 2) How can we overcome the challenges of collecting, accessing and using comparable data to build meaningful comparison? 3) How can we bridge methodological divide in our discipline? What role can compound research designs and big data play in order to bridge the divide? The panel is meant to offer a critical forum on discussing how comparative public policy is practiced today by proposing authors to question and challenge the usual patterns of research design and the common strategies for comparative public policy by proposing critical assessments of the current state of practice and by proposing new, innovative strategies in order to increase diversity in case selection and overcome the methodological divide between within comparative public policy studies. As such, the panel aims at exploring new methodological avenues for comparing public policies.

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P13. The Rise of Regulation in Developing and Transitional Countries
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Dussauge
A. Elizondo
L. Martin
ABSTRACT

Over the last two decades, studies of regulation in general, and regulatory agencies and regulatory instruments in particular, have gained currency among international public policy scholars (Baldwin et al., 2010; Levi-Faur, 2011; Lodge and Wegrich, 2012). In developed countries, debates on topics such as regulatory quality, regulatory impact assessments, and the reputation and independence of regulatory agencies are frequent in the literature (Radaelli and De Francesco, 2007; Dunlop and Radaelli, 2016; Bianculli et al., 2015; Coglianese, 2017). Regulation is becoming ever more central to public policymaking in almost any policy area, from competition policy to artificial intelligence, with environmental regulation, industrial safety, utilities regulation and many other policy fields in between. In developing and transitional regions, such as Latin America, these topics have also attracted attention from scholars (González, 2017; Pavón, 2018; Elizondo and Dussauge-Laguna, 2018).Most regulatory debates, however, still focus on questions such as whether the "regulatory state" and "regulatory capitalism" are useful conceptual devices (Jordana and Levi-Faur, 2015); or on whether administrative legacies and political conditions are conducive to credible regulatory arrangements (Lodge et al., 2017). There are still significant concerns over the relationship between regulation and development, either on the effect of regulations on national development, or about how existing institutions condition the development of effective regulations (Dubash and Morgan, 2013; Cunha et al., 2017). At the same time, regulatory innovations, toolkits, and "best practices" are being actively diffused by international organisations and scholars. The design and implementation of regulation and regulatory institutions is particularly challenging in developing and transitional settings due to enduring national features, such as low accountability and trust, widespread corruption and state capture, limited bureaucratic professionalisation, and strong pressures from interest groups. Therefore, certain political and administrative conditions that are present in developed countries, such as the rule of law, regulatory capacity, and high levels of regulatory compliance, may not fully (if at all) exist in developing and transitional countries. This panel seeks to broaden our understanding on how regulation and regulatory institutions are designed and implemented in developing and transitional settings. We want to explore to what extent theoretical and analytical advances in the field of regulation are helpful to explain regulatory transformations in non-developed political systems. Similarly, we also look for ongoing research that contributes to theoretical developments, showing how the study of regulatory experiences in developing countries may inform wider international debates. References: Alejandra Elizondo & Mauricio I. Dussauge-Laguna (2018), La Agencia de Seguridad, Energía y Ambiente: una nueva institución del Estado mexicano, CIDE-ASEA-PIRCE. Andrea C. Bianculli, Xavier Fernández-i-Marin & Jacint Jordan (2015), Accountability and Regulatory Governance, Palgrave. Andrés Pavón (2018), “Agencies’ formal independence and credible commitment in the Latin American regulatory state: A comparative analysis of 8 countries and 13 sectors”, Regulation & Governance, early view. Bruno Queiroz Cunha, Ana Karine Pereira & Alexandre de Ávila Gomide (2017), “State capacity and utilities regulation in Brazil: Exploring bureaucracy”, Utilities Policy, 49. Camilo González (2017), “Measuring and comparing the distribution of decision-making power in regulatory arrangements of the telecommunication sector in Latin America”, Utilities Policy, 49. Cary Coglianese (ed.) (2017), Achieving Regulatory Excellence, The Brookings Institution Press. Claire A. Dunlop & Claudio M. Radaelli (2016), Handbook of Regulatory Impact Assessment, Edward Elgar. Claudio M. Radaelli & Fabrizio de Francesco (2007), Regulatory quality in Europe, Manchester University Press. David Levi-Faur (ed.) (2011), Handbook on the Politics of Regulation, Edward Elgar. Jacint Jordana & David Levi-Faur (2005), “The Diffusion of Regulatory Capitalism in Latin America: Sectoral and National Channels in the Making of a New Order”, The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences. Martin Lodge & Kai Wegrich (2012), Managing Regulation, Palgrave. Martin Lodge, Christian Van Stolk, Julia Batistella-Machado, Daniel Schweppenstedde y Martin Stepanek (2017), Regulation of logistics infrastructure in Brazil, RAND. Navroz K. Dubash & Bronwen Morgan (eds.) (2013), The Rise of the Regulatory State of the South, Oxford University Press. Robert Baldwin, Martin Cave & Martin Lodge (eds.) (2010), The Oxford Handbook of Regulation, Oxford University Press.

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P14. IT-Mediated Platforms and the Public Sector: Applications of Sharing Economy, Block-chains and Crowd-sourcing
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Taeihagh
ABSTRACT

Platforms significantly increase the efficiency and ease of interactions between individuals and groups in society. For instance, crowdsourcing platforms utilise information technology to collect information directly from individuals to solve problems, whereas sharing economy platforms do so to exchange goods and services without requiring the transfer of ownership (Taeihagh 2017a,b). In the public sector, platforms are a way to improve the efficiency and quality of public services and to solve increasingly complex and “wicked” problems that characterise societies today (Head 2008; Hautamäki & Oksanen 2018; Janssen & Estevez 2013; Layne & Lee 2001; Bertot et al. 2010). By leveraging on new technologies such as big data, Internet of Things (IoT) and cloud computing, platforms enable public agencies to derive insights from a critical mass of citizens to improve the design, production and delivery of public services, which are commonly known as co-creation and co-production processes (Voorberg et al. 2015; Bason 2010; Needham 2008; cite). For instance, crowdsourcing platforms can increase citizen participation in policy-making, increase transparency of the policy process, improve policy design and analysis (Prpić et al. 2015; Taeihagh 2017), and strengthen the legitimacy of the government (Christensen et al. 2015). Platforms will play a pivotal role in public sector innovation, but how they are implemented and managed can introduce various risks that may undermine their effectiveness for public service delivery and detriment society as a whole. Some of the risks that arise from using platforms are diminished accountability, inadequate compensation and reduced job security for individuals, widening of the digital divide and inequality, and the potential for crowds to manipulate information and outcomes (Taeihagh 2017b; Loukis et al. 2017). When applied to the public sector, the opening up of citizen’s personal data on platforms raises concerns over privacy and data security (Hautamäki & Oksanen 2018). The effectiveness of platforms may be further undermined by the risk of fragmentation among multiple platforms and the difficulty of designing attractive platforms to attract a sufficient level of citizen participation (Hautamäki & Oksanen 2018; Janssen & Estevez 2013). Some countries may face more challenges than others in building platforms in the public sector, particularly those without strong governance mechanisms and property rights to attract the required capital investments (Taeihagh 2017b). While these issues are being increasingly recognised in the public administration and policy literature, more research is required to evaluate the usefulness of the collected information from platforms and the extent to which these platforms lead to improved public service outcomes (Voorberg et al. 2015), especially if the government aims to deliver all public services through a unified digital platform (Hautamäki & Oksanen 2018). Furthermore, more recently among the various platforms that have proliferated, blockchain-enabled platforms are being experimented with by many governments around the world for public service delivery in areas such as e-voting, digital identity and the recording of legal documents (Cheng et al. 2017; Swan 2015; Wolfond 2017; Hou 2017). Blockchain’s distributed, open and immutable nature offers many benefits for governments, including greater transparency, reduced corruption, greater efficiency and increased citizen participation (Ølnes et al. 2017). For these benefits to materialise, governments need to also guard against emerging risks of blockchain technology, which include security vulnerabilities, privacy concerns, and internal governance challenges that can result in conflicts (Li et al. 2017; Trump et al. 2018; Mattila & Seppälä 2018). In addition, organisational processes in the public sector need to transform to accommodate new infrastructures that support blockchain-enabled applications and platforms, which warrants further research into such organisational and institutional changes in the public administration and policy literature (Ølnes et al. 2017). This panel will present papers that explore the implications of these IT-mediated platforms for the public sector in both developed and developing countries. In light of the above issues, the papers should address the following research questions:· Theoretical, conceptual or empirical studies that evaluate the effects of IT-mediated platform (e.g. crowdsourcing, sharing economy, blockchain) activities on public sector delivery outcomes and analysis of how IT-mediated platform activities affect the perceived political legitimacy or performance of governments in serving the needs of citizens.· Exploration and analysis of the different types of challenges and risks that arise from adoption/implementation of IT-mediated platforms for public service delivery, and possible governance strategies to address these risks.· Analysis of the various roles of different actors in influencing policy outcomes through participation in platforms and at different stages of the policy making process.· Theoretical and conceptual analysis of how IT-mediated platforms contribute to policy learning in order to improve public service delivery.· Exploration and analysis of the different types of platform governance structures in blockchain and their risks and unintended consequences (e.g. coordination challenges) and analysis of the organisational, administrative and institutional transformations in public sector organisations to accommodate blockchain-enabled platforms.· Single and comparative case studies across different countries, sectors and types of IT-mediated platforms (blockchain, sharing economy, crowdsourcing, etc.) References:Bason, C. (2010). The innovation ecosystem. In (Ed.), Leading public sector innovation: Co-creating for a better society. : Policy Press, Retrieved 24 Oct. 2018, from http://policypress.universitypressscholarship.com.libproxy1.nus.edu.sg/view/10.1332/policypress/9781847426345.001.0001/upso-9781847426345-chapter-1. Bertot, J. C., Jaeger, P. T., & Grimes, J. M. (2010). Using ICTs to create a culture of transparency: E-government and social media as openness and anti-corruption tools for societies. Government information quarterly, 27(3), 264-271. Cheng, S., Daub, M., Domeyer, A., & Lundqvist, M. (2017). Using blockchain to improve data management in the public sector. Digital McKinsey Christensen, H. S., Karjalainen, M., & Nurminen, L. (2015). Does crowdsourcing legislation increase political legitimacy? the case of avoin ministeriö in Finland. Policy & Internet, 7(1), 25-45. doi:10.1002/poi3.80 Hautamäki, A., & Oksanen, K. (2018). Digital Platforms for Restructuring the Public Sector. In Collaborative Value Co-creation in the Platform Economy (pp. 91-108). Springer, Singapore. Head, B. W. (2008). Wicked problems in public policy. Public policy, 3(2), 101. Hou, H. (2017, July). The application of blockchain technology in E-government in China. In Computer Communication and Networks (ICCCN), 2017 26th International Conference on(pp. 1-4). IEEE. Janssen, M., & Estevez, E. (2013). Lean government and platform-based governance—Doing more with less. Government Information Quarterly, 30, S1-S8. Layne, K., & Lee, J. (2001). Developing fully functional E-government: A four-stage model. Government information quarterly, 18(2), 122-136. Li, X., Jiang, P., Chen, T., Luo, X., & Wen, Q. (2017). A survey on the security of blockchain systems. Future Generation Computer Systems. Loukis, E., Charalabidis, Y., & Androutsopoulou, A. (2017). Promoting open innovation in the public sector through social media monitoring. Government Information Quarterly, 34(1), 99-109. doi:10.1016/j.giq.2016.09.004 Mattila, J., & Seppälä, T. (2018). Distributed Governance in Multi-sided Platforms: A Conceptual Framework from Case: Bitcoin. In Collaborative Value Co-creation in the Platform Economy (pp. 183-205). Springer, Singapore. Needham, C. (2008). Realising the potential of co-production: negotiating improvements in public services. Social policy and society, 7(2), 221-231. Ølnes, S., Ubacht, J., & Janssen, M. (2017). Blockchain in government: Benefits and implications of distributed ledger technology for information sharing. Ølnes, S., & Jansen, A. (2017, September). Blockchain Technology as s Support Infrastructure in e-Government. In International Conference on Electronic Government (pp. 215-227). Springer, Cham. Prpić, J., Taeihagh, A., & Melton, J. (2015). The fundamentals of policy crowdsourcing. Policy & Internet, 7(3), 340-361. Swan, M. (2015). Blockchain: Blueprint for a new economy. Sebastopol, CA: O'Reilly. Taeihagh, A. (2017a). Crowdsourcing: a new tool for policy-making? Policy Sciences Journal, 50(4):629-647 Taeihagh, A. (2017b). Crowdsourcing, Sharing Economies and Development, Journal of Developing Societies, Vol 33(2): 191–222. DOI: 10.1177/0169796X17710072 Trump, B. D., Wells, E., Trump, J., & Linkov, I. (2018). Cryptocurrency: Governance for what was meant to be ungovernable. Environment Systems and Decisions, 38(3), 426-430. Voorberg, W. H., Bekkers, V. J., & Tummers, L. G. (2015). A systematic review of co-creation and co-production: Embarking on the social innovation journey. Public Management Review, 17(9), 1333-1357. Wolfond, G. (2017). A Blockchain Ecosystem for Digital Identity: Improving Service Delivery in Canada’s Public and Private Sectors. Technology Innovation Management Review, 7(10).

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P15. Comparing Poverty Reduction Strategies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Notten
ABSTRACT

Following an international trend in public policy making, many governments engage in a Poverty Reduction Strategy (PRS) process because they expect / claim that it leads to more poverty reduction than traditional policymaking. A PRS process typically involves creating new governance structures, adopting strategic management practices, and the engagement of more stakeholders at more stages in the policy cycle (Head & Alfort, 2015). PRS’s were first implemented in developing countries by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund as part of a reformed process by which developing countries could qualify for conditional loans and debt relief (Levinsohn, 2003). In 1997, Ireland was the first advanced economy to launch a PRS process, followed by the European Union (EU), the UK and so on (European Commission 2010; Collin 2007; Social Exclusion Unit 2004). PRS’s have been implemented at supra national, national and sub-national levels with the latter also including municipalities. The emphasis on strategic practice and reforming policy-making processes around poverty exemplifies a broader paradigm shift in public governance, viewing improvements in the policy-making process as a solution to tackling wicked problems (Roberts, 2000; Head & Alford 2015). A key characteristic of a wicked problem is that it is impossible to define the problem without delineating already a course of action towards its solution (Roberts, 2000). This also holds for PRS processes, which are seen as the means to improve a policy process that subsequently leads to more poverty reduction. A better process for poverty reduction is seen as key because a broad swath of policies, made and executed by many political executives, their respective ministries and complex delivery systems, influence the prevalence and reduction of poverty. Despite being such a widespread government practice, public policy policy scholars have understudied the role of PRS processes in anti-poverty policymaking and its potential effects on poverty reduction. This panel invites papers that compare PRS’s between jurisdictions with the aim to answer (part of) the question: “Whether, why and how PRSs can lead to more poverty reduction than policymaking without a PRS?”

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P17. Hy-Policies: Policy Transfer, Policy Learning and Hybridization of Policies in different Institutional Contexts.
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Bensa
D. Casal
ABSTRACT

The objective of this panel is to analyze in comparative perspective the processes of policy transfer in different institutional contexts. Our main questions are 1) What are the influence of micro and meso political factors at the decisional stage of the policy transfer process? 2) What domestic factors are involved on the adaptation of policies at the implementation stage? And 3) How and in which cases, the characteristics of the policy transfer process affects its results, generating policy learning, hybridization or innovation. This panel will contribute to the comparative research on public policies in an area of growing interest and complexity, paying special attention to the constraints offered by different political and institutional contexts to its characteristics and outcomes.

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P18. What Does Comparative Policy Analysis Have to Do With the Structure-Institution-Agency Debate?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Bakir
M. Coban
S. Akgunay
ABSTRACT

Comparative policy analysis (CPA) takes into account key structural, institutional and agency-level differences among countries over time in its widely accepted research strategy. This is because interactions among structures (broader material and cultural contexts within which institutions and actors are embedded), institutions (formal and informal rules that inform the actions of actors), and actors (individuals, organizations and/or collective entities) inform CPA. Yet CPA scholars rarely acknowledge, much less explore, such interactions among these interdependent factors. In common parlance, the terms ‘structure’, ‘institution’ and ‘organization’ are often combined and/or conflated. Notwithstanding, it is important to distinguish between them for academic purposes in order to analyze their relationship, interactions and influence. To do so, it is crucial to go beyond ‘context matters’ and to explore some of the interrelated dynamics informing CPA. This is exactly what the panel aims to do. This panel calls for original contributions that shed light on how, where, when and why structural, institutional and agency-level factors inform policy analysis. The goals of this Panel are threefold: (1) to encourage empirical and theoretical interest in the structural, institutional and agency-level factors that inform CPA comparative perspectives, focusing on different levels of analysis, and applying different research methodologies; (2) to build richly contextualized, interdisciplinary and comparative conceptual or theoretical foundations for analysis and research; and (3) to stimulate further comparative empirical policy research that uses original data and focuses on, for example, comparative analysis of countries or cases in the policy domains. This involves examination of the impact of structural, institutional and agency-related factors affecting policy analysis at the national, the supranational, regional, or actor levels of analysis. Given the limited attention paid to the individual and joint effects of structures, institutions and actors on policy analysis, this call for papers is purposefully broad. What is critical is to build bridges between the public policy and institutional scholarship, by using CPA in order to help develop new empirical and/or theoretical insights.

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P19. Causal Claims and Causal inferences in Comparative Policy Analysis
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
I. Geva-May
G. Fontaine
P. Trein
ABSTRACT

Causal claims and inferences have become important criteria for research design and methods in comparative policy analysis (CPA). “Why”-questions are often present in CPA, for instance to address why policies on related policy problems are most similar or most different. Degrees of similar or different causes may be the answer. Yet the concept of causality often remains implicit and scholars conceive it in a different way — either as patterns of regularity, counterfactuals or causal forces— according to their philosophical and scientific ontology. Some argue that explicit causal inferences should be at the core of CPA while others contend that causation is not to be explained but, at best, interpreted.These similarities and discrepancies affect the very theory and practice of CPA, when it comes to address “Why” questions about agenda-setting, policy formulation, adoption, implementation or evaluation. Why does a government put a problem on the agenda? Why is a policy mix preferred to another? Why is a policy adopted or not? Why is there a gap in a policy implementation? Why does a policy produce unexpected outputs or outcomes? Such questions are given a partial treatment by conventional analytical frameworks. For instance, the advocacy coalition framework and the multiple stream approach focus on the agenda-setting, while policy design focuses on the instrumentation; comparative historical analysis and political economy have produced strong theories of policy change, while econometrics has been more thorough to assesspolicies impacts. Yet while the theoretical statement made by these frameworks are conspicuous, their methodological foundations are not always explicit and their procedures often suffer from a lack of transparency.Two logics of causation currently coexist in CPA —probabilistic and deterministic— hence raising a problem of alignment between ontology and methodology at the time of selecting a comparative method for confirming or disconfirming purposes. On one hand, the probabilistic logic has produced theories of causation based on mean causal effects, general trends and symmetric causation, which commands variable-centered research designs for large-n comparisons. On the other hand, the deterministic logic has produced theories of causation based on differences in kind, necessity claims and asymmetric causation, which commands case-based research designs for small-n comparisons and within-case studies. The dilemma extends to the conceptualization of causal conditions (necessity and sufficiency), the status of set membership and even the techniques to measure variations in kind or degree. Whatever their choice, scholars´ research agenda derives from different designs and practices, and ultimately ends up making symmetric or asymmetric causal claims, which produce formal models or causal mechanisms, and so on and so forth. Some may contend that only co-variance in large-n comparisons allows to establish a causal relation in a policy process, or that small-n comparisons are a better way to identify the causal forces at stake in that process. Some may advocate for experiments or quasi-experiments while others would object these as inaccurate for practical or even ethical reasons. Eventually a growing number of comparative policy studies advocate for a multi-method research design. JUNE 25, 4-6 pm - Preconference JCPA Workshop Keynotes on comparative methods: Beryl Radin and Guy Peters (MB 9EG) 6-7 pm - Reception of the JCPA and ICPA - Forum Scholarly Society (MB 9 lobby) JUNE 27, 12:30-2pm - Lunch meeting, Editorial board and Friends of the JCPA and ICPA-Forum (MB 9A) More info

POLICY TOPICS
COMPARATIVE PUBLIC POLICY
P01. Policy, Politics, and Political Regime Around Social Integration of Migrants in Urban China
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. NIU
Z. Lu
ABSTRACT

Policy, politics, and political regime around social integration of migrants in urban China Pu Niu, Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of SheffieldZhen Lu, Department of Urban Studies and Planning, University of Sheffield The objective of this panel is to explore the theoretical understandings of policy practices adopted by Chinese governments to deal with the issue of the integration of migrant populations. Following China's large-scale urbanization in the last 4 decades, more than 230 million rural migrants have moved to cities. This has generated considerable challenges for governments at different scalar levels, in particular local governments, to help them integrate into urban society. To cope with these challenges, governments in China have not only issued numerous national policies/programmes such as urban village regeneration, providing access to public schools for migrant children, and household registration reform; but also implemented political instruments at the micro-level such as public deliberation and consultations, community-level self-governance, and authoritarian discretion during implementation of these projects/policies. These political practices have raised abundant discussion about China's complex urban political-administrative system in terms of policy-making, policy implementation, and policy regimes, and what they mean for the (un-)democratic nature of Chinese governance. It is paramount to reflect upon the grounded experiences around policy making, policy implementation, and other everyday practices adopted by different entities, if we want to grasp the trajectory of urbanisation and integration process of migrant groups in urban China. Current research has provided some angles to review these political practices, for example, He and Warren (2011) proposed the concept of “authoritarian deliberation” to understand the Chinese democratic process and government strategies. Similarly, democratic theorist John Keane’s concept of “phantom democracy” (2017), an authoritarian “post-democratic” system that allows extensive local democratic practices, must be seen as an attempt to gauge the true nature of China’s poltical system. Empirically Beibei Tang (2015), Tang and Dryzek (2014) and Niu and Wagenaar (2018) researched the deliberative system approach to examine the Chinese urban and rural everyday deliberations at grassroot level; and Fulong Wu suggested institutional analysis and developed concept of “urban entrepreneurialism” to understand the policy practices and programmes around rural-urban integration. Meanwhile, in field of social justice, Hyun Bang Shin suggested building alliance between migrants and urban residents as the forward way for all urban inhabitants to achieve “right to the city” in China. Enlightened and encouraged by this research, we believe that the discussions around the integration of migrant populations will make a significant practical and theoretical contribution to an understanding of the policy process in an authoritarian society. More empirical and theoretical discussions are needed, around how do governments, grassroot level regime, and other entities play their roles in integration process of migrants on different levels? Through revisiting and investigating these practices, we can observe how democratic elements, such as public participation, democratic deliberation, and authoritarian discretion, manifest themselves within a political authoritarian setting, such as public participation, democratic deliberation, and authoritarian discretion. This will not only generate more innovative and just urban development policies, but also expand the current theoretical discussion on policy-making and policy implementation in China. In this panel, we invite empirical studies that reveals complexities and challenges in the field of policy making and implementation around migrants' integration; as well as researches about democracy and democratic governance in China, such as rural village/urban communities self-governance, public participation in migrants' issues, and social justice. Reference:He, B. and Warren, M.E., 2011. Authoritarian deliberation: The deliberative turn in Chinese political development. Perspectives on Politics, 9(2), pp.269-289. Keane, J., 2017. When Trees Fall, Monkeys Scatter: Rethinking Democracy in China. In When Trees Fall, Monkeys Scatter: Rethinking Democracy in China (pp. i-176). Niu, P. and Wagenaar, H., 2018. The limits of authoritarian rule: Policy making and deliberation in urban village regeneration in China. Japanese Journal of Political Science. Submitted. Shin, H.B., 2013. The right to the city and critical reflections on China's property rights activism. Antipode, 45(5), pp.1167-1189. Tang, B., 2015. “Not rural but not urban”: Community governance in China's urban villages. The China Quarterly, 223, pp.724-744. Tang, B. and Dryzek, J.S., 2014. Introduction: The continuing search for deliberation and participation in China. Journal of Chinese Political Science, 19(2), pp.109-114.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY, POLITICS AND POLITICAL REGIME
P02. Public Policy and the ‘Policy State’
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
F. Sager
M. Hinterleitner
ABSTRACT

The policy state describes the organization of a state in which policy has become the preferred problem-solving tool of the government. In modern, complex, and fast-changing societies, governments address a large number and variety of problems. As governments undertake more over a broader range of issues, policy infrastructure thickens and permeates almost all areas of social, political, and economic life. This has profound implications for the organization of the state and for democratic politics. Democratic political systems are governed by different forms of rule, of which individual rights, formal political institutions and policy are the most important ones. In the policy state, policy interventions increasingly interfere with individual rights and formal political institutions, throwing into disarray the traditional ordering principles of democratic political systems. Because the policy state motivates an increase in the number and intensity of policy conflicts, it is also one of the main reasons for the current flourishing of more conflictual politics in many democratic systems (see e.g. Orren & Skowronek 2017; Pierson & Skocpol 2007). Research on the policy state in the field of American political development bears particular relevance for the public policy discipline for a number of reasons: First, it adopts a content-free, macro-perspective on policy that is different from the more particularistic and procedural perspectives on specific policies, which are common in the study of public policy. By considering the policy infrastructure in its entirety and interplay, the research on the policy state is able to ask (and answer) questions that do not emerge if there is emphasis on particular policies and their trajectories. Second, research on the policy state invites policy scholars to contribute to important current debates in political science about intensified political conflict. Intensified conflict about policy forces the discipline to reconsider the assumptions about the type of political conflict presupposed in major policy-making and policy-change frameworks. Third, research on the policy state indicates exciting new research opportunities for policy studies as well as potentials for cross fertilization between disciplines. For example, policy scholars can contribute to a better and more comprehensive understanding of policy-centered political conflict, or they can add a comparative dimension to research on the policy state, which has so far only been analyzed in the context of the US. References: - Orren, K. & Skowronek, S. 2017. The policy state: An American predicament. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts - Pierson, P. & Skocpol, T. (eds.). 2007. The transformation of American politics: Activist government and the rise of conservatism. Princeton University Press, Princeton, N.J.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY, POLITICS AND POLITICAL REGIME
P03. Explaining Democratic Backsliding: How Policy Dynamics Structure Politics in Hidden Ways
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Ertugal
H. Bolukbasi
ABSTRACT

This panel seeks to explore how dynamics at the policy level structure politics in backsliding democracies. There are many ways of building competitive authoritarian regimes. Based on the recent vibrant literature, we learn that democracies die increasingly through democratically elected leaders gradually subverting democratic processes themselves. These accounts show us that mechanisms like populism, ‘executive aggrandizement’, media control, court packing, harassment of and/or prosecuting opposition, strategic manipulation of election rules all effectively lead to democratic backsliding (Bermeo, 2016; Levitsky and Way, 2010; Levitsky and Zibblatt, 2018). All of these mechanisms surface at the level of politics, and accordingly, the literature has overwhelmingly focused on the nature and dynamics of politics (and polity). Alongside all these mechanisms at the politics and polity levels, elected leaders engage in radical policy reforms to fulfill electoral populist pledges in certain policy sectors while at the same time gradually alter policies in other sectors to their own advantage beneath the veneer of policy continuity. We know, however, very little about the latter, in particular how incremental under-the-radar policy changes contribute to the politics of backsliding. We draw on two bodies of literature. First, the comparative public policy literature has been booming, producing a great deal of knowledge on the dynamics of the policy process, policy styles and processes of policy change. We know a lot more about policy dynamics through using conceptual tools such as policy capacity, policy density or policy intensity capturing changing dimensions and characteristics of public policies. Yet, how these policy processes (ordinarily seen as ‘effect’) structure politics remains under-researched even though earlier scholars such as E.E. Schattschneider, and more recently leading comparativists Peter Hall and Paul Pierson had convincingly showed how ‘effect becomes cause’. Dynamics involved in policy feedback, policy transfer and policy learning in comparative public policy have enormous potential in revealing the expanded opportunities offered by variegated policy instruments for various mechanisms of democratic backsliding. In this way, the comparative public policy literature promises much in revealing the structuring effects of policies, themselves (re)interpreted, and abused by political leaders. Second, the comparative politics literature has increasingly been focusing on the dynamics of policy and institutional change. In particular, historical institutionalists have been taking seriously the gradual, incremental and easily overlooked changes in the nature of policies and institutions. In doing so, scholars have been identifying not only explicit but also ‘hidden faces’ of change (Mahoney and Thelen, 2010). Processes culminating in democratic backsliding do not always take place out in the open. There are massive hidden changes beneath the façade of ordinary, casual continuity. The literature on comparative politics promises to capture these hidden incremental changes and help us illuminate the politics of who gets what, when and how as policies change, especially in weakly institutionalized environments. This panel aims to develop synergies between the literatures on comparative public policy and comparative politics in order to explore those policy instruments, mechanisms and strategies incumbents use for backsliding that remain under our radars in our own disciplinary silos.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY, POLITICS AND POLITICAL REGIME
P04. Depolarising the Policy Process: How Can Rational Policymaking and Evidence Use Be Achieved in the Face of Polarisation and Populist Pressures?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Parkhurst
K. Quissell
ABSTRACT

The panel will gather conceptual, theoretical, or empirical work that considers how to counter aspects of political polarisation which appear to undermine the ‘rational’ ideal of the policy sciences. Originally championed by Lasswell, the policy sciences were conceptualised as a pragmatic approach to social welfare improvement across populations. The approach was said by Lasswell (1970) to have a ‘problem orientation’ that in many ways relies on a process which allows groups with differing sets of interest to nonetheless define social goals (or make compromises), and subsequently to apply knowledge and evidence in a rigorous manner in order to select courses of policy action most likely to achieve those goals (or most likely to lead to improvements in desired areas). Yet polarised political environments and the rise of populist rhetoric appear to present fundamental challenges to this approach to policymaking. Selecting goals, for instance, may require comprise for ultimate agreement in democratic societies, yet this can be increasingly difficult when polarisation makes agreement impossible. Furthermore, populist rhetoric may often invoke seemingly contradictory values, as populism often is based around identity politics rather than a clear or consistent policy platform (Dennis 1996). The ability to apply evidence to policy needs and to solve policy problems is further threatened in such environments, as polarisation may increase the likelihood for biased uses of evidence as well – through cognitive processes of motivated reasoning or confirmation bias, for example (Parkhurst 2016). It has also been shown that in some settings, publics may actively embrace a leader known to be lying when individuals feel excluded from the political process (Hahl et al 2018). Literature has thus begun to understand some of the cognitive, cultural, or social mechanisms that support features of polarisation and populist ideology. This panel will therefore move the field forward by inviting papers that consider how to address or counter these mechanisms, in order to improve the policy process in ways aligned with the policy sciences approach. Questions covered by papers could include: - What is known about strategies to depolarise political environments? - How do cognitive processes support embrace of populist rhetoric, demonization, or factual manipulation – and what can be done to counter these? - Are there strategies to engage with individuals supporting populist movements to reduce rejection of alternative positions? - How do debiasing efforts work (or not) in polarised or populist environments? - What do different disciplines or fields of work bring to help understand the mechanisms of polarisation as well as possible efforts to counter them (e.g. political psychology, anthropology of ethnicity, etc.)? Other topics related to the key issues of the panel will also be considered. References: Hahl, Oliver, Minjae Kim, and Ezra W. Zuckerman Sivan. 2018. "The Authentic Appeal of the Lying Demagogue: Proclaiming the Deeper Truth about Political Illegitimacy." American Sociological Review no. 83 (1):1-33. doi: 10.1177/0003122417749632. Lasswell, Harold D. 1970. "The Emerging Conception of the Policy Sciences." Policy Sciences no. 1 (1):3-14. Parkhurst, Justin O. 2016. "Appeals to evidence for the resolution of wicked problems: the origins and mechanisms of evidentiary bias." Policy Sciences no. 49 (4):373-393. doi: 10.1007/s11077-016-9263-z. Westlind, Dennis. 1996. The politics of popular identity: understanding recent populist movements in Sweden and the United States. Vol. 89: Lund University Press.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY, POLITICS AND POLITICAL REGIME
P05. Politics and Policymaking in MENA Countries After the Arab Uprisings
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
R. Hoppe
ABSTRACT

The major aim l is to enrich comparative policy studies by throwing light on public policymaking in the Arab world, which so far is hardly visible. The second aim is to explore policymaking practices in extremely uncertain conditions such as post-revolutionary situations in non-democratic states. This exploration may start from two perspectives: first, the influence of contested politics and citizen activism on public policymaking under the new political opportunity structure; and second, policymaking and governing practices embraced by the political élites in response to the Arab Uprisings. The Uprisings shocked the world when the masses broke decades of fear by occupying public squares in many Arab cities, demanding freedom, democracy and justice. This constituted a rupture from the established 'social contract' of the post-colonial modern Arab states. The most apparent demand was the need to transform the governance, and the relationship between the people and their rulers. But the revolutionary moment did not last. Counter-revolutions aiming at reinstating Arab ancienregimes became the norm. Bayat (2017) argues that instead of completing a full-scale revolution, the uprisings appeared to be satisfied by just pressing for reforms for more democracy and social justice. Thus, the Arab uprisings were not a revolution in the sense of rupturing the old political structures, but a 'refolution'. Nevertheless, a new opportunity structure for civil society emerged, partly due to sidelining , elimination or suicide of established political parties. Hence (religious, civil-domestic and externally financed) civil society associations became vehicles for articulating citizen demands to governments. This opened up long suppressed political debates (e.g. about gender and labor issues), and offered some space for novel policy initiatives. One interesting and relevant task would be to develop a taxonomy of roles for civil society associations in influencing public policies under these exceptional conditions, and compare it to standard western models of contested politics and citizen activism, deliberation and participation. Another comparative axis would be to ask whether it is be possible to apply theories about policymaking in stable democratic regimes to post-Arab Uprising states. Would this just lead to concept stretching; and if so, how would the theories have to be amended to analyze policymaking in the Arab world without conceptual 'overstretch', bias and blind spots? It would be interesting to demonstrate where these theories run into problems when applied to unstable and less-than-democratic contexts. E.g., policy process theories from the West all assume that a substantive policyissue logic governs everyday politics; but in unstable democracies, or post-revolutionary situations (like after the Arab Uprisings) there is always a regime logic that may trump issue logic - a form of powering that trumps even policy issue powering. Another potential enriching of comparative policy studies would be to study actual policy formulation and design practices (if any) in Arab states. Instead of incrementalism, or mixed scanning or design by policy-oriented learning (Howlett and Mukherjee, 2014) policy practices may follow other patterns, like constraint dodging and feasibility testing, driven by extreme resource scarcity, sharply circumscribed distributional constraints, and prescribed, inflexible institutional frameworks (Hoppe, in Yassin & Hoppe, 2019).

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY, POLITICS AND POLITICAL REGIME
P01. Policy Change: Revisiting the Past, Analyzing Contemporary Processes and Stimulating Inter-Temporal Comparisons
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Olavarria-Gambi
V. Figueroa Huencho
M. Velasco
ABSTRACT

The panel is aimed to analyze the characteristics or conditions leading to policy changes, considering the institutional context in which it develops. The panel is open to accept proposals of analysis of policy changes occurred in the past, contemporary policy changes and/or inter-temporal comparisons of policy changes. In doing this, the panel seeks to set links to the emerging field of work of “History and Public Policies”. The panel will address questions on whether the way in which problems have been addressed in the past determine how they are faced later, and the role of institutions in policy changes. The analysis focuses on how institutions – formal and/or informal – influence the policy process, on whether types of interchanges among policy actors persist over time and on whether informal institutions shape the way in which formal institutions operate or whether it is the other way around how the policy process develops. According to Capano (2009) the dynamic of policy change may be intrinsically evolutionary or revolutionary, meaning the former a process of continuous adaptation, incremental and gradual nature. Revolutionary policy changes involve breaking with the past and introduction of new solutions to policy problems. Thus, a natural question in this context is how formal and informal institutions relate to evolutionary and revolutionary policy changes. According to the path dependence perspective, history matters because current decisions are dependent of past decisions. Page (2006) points out that the dependence of past decision patterns are the consequence of a perception of higher benefits because of the learning, getting used to it and the cost of change; of self enforcement to maintain a given decision pattern; of a positive feedback gotten from a certain decision; and of the lock in of alternatives way of decision or action. Peters et al. (2005), in turn, argues that formal and informal institutional patterns also change over time and that ideas are very important in explaining institutional changes. This would mean that path dependence perspective would have limited validity in explaining policy changes, especially when these are generated after (formal and/or informal) institutional changes. Given that “historical institutionalism of the polity focuses on analyzing what happened, when and how” (Skocpol 1995: 104), following Peters et al. (2005) the panel will focus on the relationship among institutions, ideas, policy brokers and agencies to analyze the path development of policy changes. Then, the panel seeks to contribute to the understanding of the relationship between institutions and policy change. The panel is aimed at discussing empirical evidence provided by case studies on policy change in different contexts. Although the panel is open to any case, the presentation of case studies from Latin America, East Europe, Africa, Asia and Oceania is highly encouraged. REFERENCES: Capano, Giliberto. 2009. “Understandign Policy Change as an Epistemological and Theoretical Problem.” Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis, Vol.11, Nº1, pp. 7 – 31. Page, Scott. 2005. “An essay on the existence and casuses of path dependence”. Santa Fe Institute of Economics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. Peters, Guy; Jon Pierre y Desmond S. King. 2005. “The Politics of Path Dependency: Political Conflict in Historical Institutionalism”. The Journal of Politics, Vol. 67, Nº4, pp. 1257 – 1300. Chicago, USA: The University of Chicago Press. Skocpol, Theda. 1995. “Why I am an Historical Institutionalist”. Polity, Vol. 28, Nº1, pp. 103 – 106. London, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.

POLICY TOPICS
PUBLIC PROBLEM AND AGENDA SETTING
P02. From Real-World Problems to Political Problems
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
R. Reiter
K. Loer
A. Toeller
ABSTRACT

Problems are conditions that contradict shared normative assumptions of a society. Cases in point are the destruction of biodiversity, heavy air pollution in metropolitan areas, comparably poor medical provision in rural areas, or the discrimination of minorities. Policy scholars have been puzzling on problem definition for decades (Hilgartner and Bosk 1988, Stone 1989, Weiss 1989, Rochefort and Cobb 1993, Birkland 2011, Peters 2018), e.g. addressing in how far the interplay of empirical facets or descriptions, political actors’ interests and ideas affect the selection of a problem as a political problem (Mehta 2011). From our empirical research we are particularly puzzled why there is usually a considerable time-lag between the emergence of real-world-problems (as defined above) and their definition as a political problem (something that must be “fixed”). On the contrary, one can also ask, why (under which conditions) real world problems in the end do become political problems? This is the research question of our proposed panel. The state of the art is impressive on the one hand, but partly focuses on different aspects and partly still lacks clear results. On the one side, we find the two schools of thought which for long have been dominated the debate on the definition of social or political problems: the constructivist (“blaming”, “shaming”) and the realist or conflict-oriented (“politicization”) school of thought. These schools provide partly contradicting answers to the question why certain real world problems can become political problems at all. However, none of these two schools focuses on the timing of problem selection. On the other side, the question of timing has been treated – at least implicitly – by several scholars providing important elements of an anyhow still inconclusive answer. For example, Kingdon in his seminal work (1984) pointed to the role of real world situational events (scandals, accidents, disasters etc.) that are placed on the political agenda although they have been existing before (in a “stream” of latent political problems). He also made a strong point (as Majone had suggested before) that real world conditions, notably the (technical, administrative or political) availability of a solution (see also Peters 2018), may trigger the definition of a political problem at a certain moment in time. In contrast, Hall, and, later, Béland and Cox and their colleagues, emphasized the role of constantly changing ideas thus shaping the circumstances of politics and the sensitivity of politicians for certain real problems at a given moment (Hall 1990, Béland and Cox 2010, 2014, 2016). The proposed panel aims at further exploring these strands of research and at exposing patterns of why (under which conditions) and when real world problems in the end do become political problems?

POLICY TOPICS
PUBLIC PROBLEM AND AGENDA SETTING
P04. Public Procurement: Humdrum Bureaucratic Beast or Vital Instrument for Social Change
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
B. Allen
S. Schwartz
E. Schwartz
ABSTRACT

Public procurement is gaining increasing attention as an instrument for good governance and stability (Arrowsmith and Anderson, 2011; Hughes et al, 2018; Knight et al., 2007). It is used to increase economic efficiency, regulate service delivery relationships (PPPs), encourage sustainable environmental outcomes, expand open contracting to increase transparency, deliver social outcomes and create socially just supply chains. The range of relevant issues is thus quite broad: Procurement agencies in different countries face different combinations of pressures. For example, in some countries, highly centralized austerity programs mandate reduced spending; in other countries, the emphasis is on encouraging innovative forms of cooperation among bidders to improve service delivery. Digitally-enabled marketplaces offer the opportunity for technology to break down barriers to better procurement, making government purchasing needs widely known and thus open to a wider array of potential bidders. Capability with respect to procurement is underdeveloped in how the public sector engages with the private and voluntary and community sectors. Theoretical treatment of these topics is multidisciplinary and ranges from agency theory and transactions cost theory, to regulatory theory, to social justice. In sum, procurement policy and related activity has a significant impact on the public purse and on how effective governments can be at all levels. The objective of this panel is to draw together scholars studying various aspects of public procurement, including procurement and trade, innovative methods of contracting, digitally enabled procurement, sustainability and procurement, participation by small and medium-sized enterprises, big data and procurement, and other related topics.

POLICY TOPICS
PUBLIC PROBLEM AND AGENDA SETTING
P05. Integration of Data and Evidence from a Range of Sources to Inform Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Burgess-Pinto
N. Lamba
ABSTRACT

Increasingly, policymakers, researchers, and planners are recognizing the interconnectedness of social needs at the population level. Accordingly, there is increasing demand for policies that require input from multiple government as well as public sectors. This panel will explore the potential of integrating data and evidence produced in the academic domain and government sectors to inform the policy outcomes of populations at risk of inequities such as children, women, immigrants/refugees, and indigenous groups. Linked administrative data can provide insight into the patterns of government use across sectors; however, these data do not address root causes. Evidence from academic research can help tease out root causes. Together, the two sources of data can inform and support policy changes. The following examples illustrate the potential In one Canadian province, data from the Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Children’s Services were linked to inform the mental health service use patterns of children in care. The policy reform (and funding) resulting from these findings allowed children and youth in care to access mental health services within weeks of being assessed as opposed to months and years. The value of integrating data at the government service level is access to population data. However, the details of the root causes leading to mental health service use among this population is less well understood. This is where academic research on use of mental health services and root causes could enhance analysis and decision making. In the Province of Ontario, the McMaster Health Forum (2016) held public citizen meetings with a view to exploring the integration of person-level data across sectors and reviewed examples of data integration from several countries. It was found that an integrated approach to analysis of data can produce tangible benefits for populations that are often termed “vulnerable” or “high priority” but an overarching policy framework is essential to ensure successful data integration is sustainable over time.

POLICY TOPICS
PUBLIC PROBLEM AND AGENDA SETTING
P01. Politics and Public Administration within Core Executives
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Eichbaum
R. Shaw
ABSTRACT

For Aaron Wildavsky speaking truth to power was essential to the art and craft of the policy advisor. Within Westminster traditions, the notion of a constitutional public service is one in which non-elected policy actors are enjoined to provide free and frank advice, and their political principals to honour a bargain which respects the necessity of that advice, and enables the provision of it. Whether parliamentary or presidential, and whatever the underlying administrative tradition liberal democratic polities place value on advice decision-makers that is both responsive and responsible. Absent the latter one detects, if not the reality, then the risk of politicisation. This panel welcomes papers on any aspect of the confluence between politics and administration in contemporary democratic systems, including the activities and career trajectories of political actors, and particularly within the core executive.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P02. Bureaucratic Influence in Global Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Ege
ABSTRACT

In recent years, scholars have started to increasingly study the role of international and transnational administration in global (public) policy (Stone & Ladi, 2015; Stone & Moloney, 2019). Today, it is an established finding, for instance, that International Public Administrations (IPAs), i.e., the secretariats of international organizations (IOs) that constitute the international counterparts to national administrative bodies, wield independent influence on the development and implementation of public policies (Biermann & Siebenhüner, 2009). Previous research has successfully identified different administrative, political and context-related factors that might enable bureaucratic influence on global policies to occur. However, an integrative approach that allows for the systematic empirical analysis of several explanatory factors under a common theoretical framework has not yet emerged (Eckhard & Ege, 2016). An important reason for this deficit is the dearth of comparative policy studies that would allow researchers to identify and explain variation in bureaucratic influence across policy cases. Against this background, the panel aims to contribute to the current debates on transnational and international public administration as well as global policy, IO policy-making and policy implementation in order to advance the study of the policy impact of international bureaucracies. Starting from the assumption that policy-making is a result of (often strategic) interactions among multiple actors that vary substantially in terms of their policy-making capacities and goals, two major questions emerge that will be addressed in the panel: How can we conceptualize and measure bureaucratic influence on IO policy-making and global public policy (especially across cases)? What are relevant administrative tools and strategies and how are they used to exert policy influence? References: Biermann, F., & Siebenhüner, B. (Eds.). (2009). Managers of Global Change: The Influence of International Environmental Bureaucracies. Cambridge (MA): MIT Press. Eckhard, S., & Ege, J. (2016). International bureaucracies and their influence on policy-making: A review of empirical evidence. Journal of European Public Policy, 23, 960–978. Stone, D., & Ladi, S. (2015). Global Policy and Transnational Administration. Public Administration, 4, 839–855. Stone, D., & Moloney, K. (2019). The Rise of Global Policy and Transnational Administration. In D. Stone & K. Moloney (Eds.), Oxford Handbook on Global Policy and Transnational Administration (pp. 1–25). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P03. Political Leadership in Interactive Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Sørensen
S. Ayres
T. Bentzen
ABSTRACT

As three decades of governance research has demonstrated, the context in which elected politicians perform political leadership is changing. We see a mushrooming of interactive forms of governance such as quasi-markets, partnerships, and networks that bring together political and social actors in a shared attempt to formulate, design and implement public policy and governance (Kooiman, 1993; Rhodes, 1997; Agranoff and McGuire, 2003; Koppenjan and Klijn, 2004; Torfing et al, 2012; Agger et al, 2015). Pluralist and corporatist political theory and research show that it is not a new thing for public authorities to involve relevant and affected actors at different stages in the policy process (Dahl, 1961; Echstein, 1969; Schmitter, 1974; Heclo, 1978; Kingdon, 1984). What is new is, first, that interaction between public and private actors increasingly takes the form of interactive governance rather than lobbyism and interest groups pressure and, second, that interactive forms of governance have become a systematic, required and prescribed activity for public authorities. Hence, interactive forms of governance are key ingredients in most of the governance reforms of last decades although researchers have used a variety of names to describe this phenomenon. Among the most prominent names are New Public Management (Hood, 1991; Osborne and Gaebler, 1993), Network Governance (Kickert, Klijn and Koppenjan, 1997), Joint Up Government (Perri 6, 2004; Hodges, 2012); Collaborative Governance (Agranoff and Mc Guire, 2003), New Public Governance (Osborne, 2010), Multi-level Governance (Bache and Flinders, 2004), and finally Interactive Governance (Torfing et al, 2012). The surge of interactive forms of governances is path breaking because it changes the context in which politicians perform political leadership representative democracies. Hence, as illuminated in several studies, interactive governance tends to recast citizens and stakeholders from objects of government to active participants in policy-making and governance (Klijn and Koppenjan, 2000; Edelenbos, 2005; Sørensen, 2007). Very few studies have analysed the implications of interactive governance for the political leadership of elected politicians (Edelenbos, Klok, and Tatenhove, 2009; Agger and Sørensen, 2014; Ansell and Torfing, 2017; Hertting and Kugelberg, 2018). The metagovernance term developed by governance researchers to signify the role of public authorities in interactive governance holds some promise when it comes to characterizing emerging forms of public administration and governance (Kooiman, 1993; 2003; Jessop, 1998, 2002; Sørensen and Torfing, 2007). Meta-governance refers to leadership as a strategic effort to involve and guide relevant and affected members of society in processes of self-governance (Sørensen and Torfing, 2009). Governance researchers have almost exclusively discussed metagovernance from a managerial perspective, while paying scant attention to the implications of interactive governance for the performance of political leadership among elected politicians. Therefore, we lack a conceptual framework and language for categorizing and analysing the kinds of political leadership that emerge in a context of interactive governance, as well as empirical knowledge about how elected politicians perform political leadership in the age of interactive governance. The scant attention to the role and function of political leadership in interactive governance research is among other things a result of a regretful disconnect between those who study public administration and governance and those who study political leadership. It is a specific purpose and goal of this panel to bring together researchers from these two disconnected research fields. Recent theories of political leadership can not only help to identify key generic features of political leadership (Burns, 2003; Nye, 2008; Kane, Patapan and ‘t Hart, 2009; Helms, 2012, 2016; Rosanvallon, 2011). They also provide important inspiration when it comes to classifying emerging forms of political leadership and current changes in party politics and role perceptions among citizens and politicians (Mair, 2013; Dalton and Welzel, 2014). The panel aims to bring the question of the role of politicians in interactive governance onto the research agenda, and bring together papers that shed theoretical and/or empirical light on the conditions for exercising political leadership in the age of interactive governance. What barriers and dilemmas do politicians operating at different levels of governance face in their performance of political leadership? What leadership styles emerge in the context of interactive governance, and how does interactive governance influence the way politicians operate and communicate with citizens and other societal actors? How do emerging political leadership styles affect the legitimacy and effectiveness of representative democracy, and to what extent and how do these political leadership styles affect the stability and robustness of representative democracy? References: Agger, A., Damgaard, B., Krogh, A.H. and Sørensen, E. (Eds) (2015), Collaborative governance and Public Innovation in Northern Europe, London: Bentham Press. Agger, A., and Sørensen, E. (2014), “Designing collaborative policy innovation: Lessons from a Danish municipality”, in C. Ansell and J. Torfing (Eds), Public Innovation through Collaboration and Design, New York: Routledge, pp.188-208. Agranoff, R., and McGuire, M. (2003), “Inside the matrix: Integrating the paradigms of intergovernmental and network management”, International Journal of Public Administration, 26(12), pp. 1401-1422. Ansell, C., and Torfing, J. (2017), “Strengthening political leadership and policy innovation through the expansion of collaborative forms of governance”, Public Management Review, 19(1), pp. 37-54. Bache, I., and Flinders, M. (Eds) (2004), Multi-Level Governance, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Burns, J.M. (2003), Transformative leadership, New York: Harper and Row. Dahl, R.A. (1961), Who Governs? Democracy and Power in an American City, New Haven: Yale University Press.Dalton, R., and Welzel, C. (Eds) (2014), The Civic Culture Transformed: From Allegiant to Assertive Citizens, New York: Cambridge University Press. Echstein, H. (1969), “Pressure Group Politics”, Journal of Medical Education, 35(11), pp. 1069-1082. Edelenbos, J. (2005), “Institutional Implications of Interactive Governance: Insights from Dutch Practice”, Governance, 18(1), pp. 111-134. Edelenbos, J., Klok, P. J., and van Tatenhove, J. (2009), “The Institutional Embedding of Interactive Policy-making: Insights from a Comparative Research based on Eight Interactive Projects in the Netherlands”, The American Review of Public Administration, 39(2), pp. 125-148. Heclo, H. (1978), “Issue networks and the executive establishment”, in A. King (Ed.), The New American Political System, Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, pp. 87-124. Helms, L. (2012), “Conclusion”, in L. Helms (Ed), Poor Leadership and Bad Governance, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 195-204. Helms, L. (2016), “Democracy and innovation: from institutions to agency and leadership”, Democratization, 23(3), pp. 459-477. Hertting, N., and Kugelberg, C. (Eds) (2018), Local Participatory Governance and Representative Democracy. Institutional Dilemmas in European Cities, London: Routledge. Hodges, R. (2012), “Joined-Up Government and the Challenges to Accounting and Accountability Researchers”. Financial Accountability & Management, 28, pp. 26–51. Hood, C. (1991), “A public administration for all seasons?”, Public Administration, 69(1), pp. 1-19. Jessop, B. (1998), The Rise of Governance and the Risk of Failure: The Case of Economic Development, UNESCO no.155, Oxford: Blackwell Publishers. Jessop, B. (2002), The Future of the Capitalist State, Cambridge: Polity Press. Kane, J., Patapan, H. and ‘ Hart, P. (Eds) (2009), Dispersed Democratic Leadership. Origins, Dynamics and Implications, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Kingdon, J.W. (1984), Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies, Boston: Little Brown.Kickert, W., Klijn, E.H., and Koppenjan, J. (1997), Managing Complex Networks, London: Sage. Kooiman, J. (1993), Modern Governance: New Government Society Interactions, London: Sage. Kooiman, J. (2003), Governing as Governance, London: Sage. Klijn, E. H., and Koppenjan, J. (2000), “Interactive decision making and representative democracy”, in Van Heffen, O., Kickert, W.J.M. and Thomassen, J.J.A. (Eds), Governance in Modern Society, Dordrecht: Kluwer pp. 109-134. Koppenjan, J., and E.H. Klijn (2004), Managing Uncertainties in Networks, New York: Routledge. Mair, P. (2013), Ruling the Void. The Hollowing of Western Democracy, London: Verso. Nye, J. (2008), The Powers to Lead, Oxford: Oxford University Press.Osborne, D., and Gaebler, T. (1993), Reinventing Government: How the Entrepreneurial Spirit is Transforming the Public Sector, Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. Osborne, S. (2010), The New Public Governance?, New York: Routledge. Perri 6 (2004), “Joined-Up Government in the Western World in Comparative Perspective: A Preliminary Literature Review and Exploration”, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 14 (1), pp. 103-138.Rhodes, R.A.W. (1997), Understanding Governance, Buckingham: Open University Press. Rosanvallon, P. (2011), Democratic Legitimacy: Impartiality, Reflexivity, Proximity, Princeton: Princeton University Press. Schmitter, P.C. (1974), Still the Century of Corporatism?, The Review of Politics, 36 (1), pp. 85-131. Sørensen, E., and Torfing, J. (2007), Theories of Democratic Network Governance, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. Sørensen, E. (2007), “Public management as metagovernance”, in G. Gjelstrup and E. Sørensen (Eds), Public Administration in Transition, Copenhagen: DJOEF Publishers, pp.83-106. Sørensen, E., and Torfing, J. (2009), “Enhancing Effective and Democratic Network Governance through Metagovernance”, Public Administration, 87(2), pp. 234-258. Torfing, J., Peters, B.G., Pierre, J., and Sørensen, E. (2012), Interactive Governance: Advancing the Paradigm, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P04. Combining Instruments in Formulating Policies: Why and How Decision-makers Set up Policy Instruments’ Mixes
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Lippi
G. Capano
ABSTRACT

The panel discusses the process of selection of policy instruments, seen from the decision-makers point of view. The sequence of actions, thinking, ideas, resources, and institutional arrangements frame how the decision makers perception and their decisional premises when choosing which policy instruments should be adopted- Thus, an evergreen question in policy formulation is “how and why policy-makers set up policy mix of instruments and thus which kind of different criteria of choice they adopt in the light of different contextual factors. This question raised up in policy formulation literature as prominent field of study since the 1990s thanks to the relevance assigned by a number of studies (Voss& Simmons (2014); Ingold, & Metz, (2014); Béland & Howlett (2015); Walgrave & Dejaeghere (2017); Capano and Lippi (2017), but only recently scholars devoted increasing attention more on the process of assembling and combining instruments than on the nature and the configuration of policy mix. This is to say that instruments’ selection is still a partially unexplored topic. And this “unexplored topic” can be extended to classical issues in policy studies ranging from agenda setting to decision making and related dynamics between technical effectiveness and social acceptance of tools. In sum, the topic grasps the missing link between formulation and decision making, but it is also open to other phases. Hence, the panel is committed to address three streams of debate: 1. The first one concerns the scientific relevance of the assemblage process as a micro focus in itself, as subject for discussion and theoretical thinking. It pertains the analysis of the sequence by which decision-makers decide to set together different elements to pursue the end of a ‘good choice’, namely the suitable policy mix. 2. The second one focuses on the process of selection and assemblage looking either at the policy process as a whole or at single stages (policy formulation, decision making and implementation). A specific role is also played by evaluation in influencing instruments choice, and here there is room for further analysis of evaluation during the policy process. 3. The third one affects the driving factors influencing the selection ranging from (i) agency (political aims, political career, bounded rationality and different trade-offs), (ii) institutional frames (norms & regulation, institutional setting and cultures, organizational routines etc.), (iii) structural factors (economic and political climate, etc.).

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P05. Governance and State Capacity in the Age of Innovation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Cavalcante
G. LOTTA
K. Bersch
ABSTRACT

At the end of the twentieth century, reformist processes spread over many countries aimed at undertaking changes in the state apparatus in order to make it more efficient, drawing on practices originating in private organizations. This movement, well known as New Public Management (NPM), obtained quite different outcomes, which have been explained by the diversity and complexity of the goals, as well as by the pre-existing institutional framework in the countries that influence the scope of the desired structural changes. It is undeniable that these reforms, throughout the years, have evolved and incorporated new principles and guidelines. However, major contemporary reforms continue to employ the fundamental logic of NPM, in part because of the challenges more radical change would generate. It is also noteworthy that, given the high transaction costs and disappointing outcomes of such reforms, governments have begun to focus their efforts on pragmatic strategies of incremental changes, that is, micro-improvements or innovations in processes and services that increasingly play a central role in the public sector. In the current age of innovation, governments focus on improving public deliveries, in a fast and effective way, in the midst of considerable economic, social, political and technological changes; increasing expectations and demands for high-quality services to citizens; enhanced demands for transparency; and budget constraints. Additionally, the challenges of multijurisdictional issues as well as complexity and uncertainty (wicked problems) require adaptive, multidimensional, and intertemporal responses of the public officials. In such a context, two interrelated issues stand out in the contemporary public policy debate: governance and state capacities. Both, although broad and complex research agendas, are crucial for advancing the understanding of how the public sector currently are operating and innovating in the policymaking. Governance is probably the most emblematic feature of current public management. In different arrangements, it manages to aggregate significant trends of the post New Public Management (Cavalcante, 2017). As stated by Menicucci and Gontijo (2016, p.17): “the term has a very heterogeneous form, entrepreneurial governance, cooperative governance, good governance, participatory governance, local governance, and sociopolitical governance, among others [...] in general, governance refers to the redefinition and expansion of the forms of relationship between the State and society or between government, private agents and society, having as a distinct aspect the relational dimension” (2016, p. 17). The emergence, diffusion and increasing use of the concept are due to processes of transformation in different types of organization. In this sense, the proliferation of meanings and uses of the term governance among academics and practitioners is associated with at least three main aspects: i) overcoming the unique responses to public issues typical of the traditional bureaucratic management; ii) growing perception of the complexity of problems, possibilities of solution and meanings of performance and accountability in the public administration; iii) negative effects of NPM reforms which led governments to rethink their intra and intergovernmental coordination strategies and their forms of articulation with the private and nongovernmental sectors. The idea of governance gains strength by being associated with innovation in the forms of integration, coordination and articulation of governmental activities. These institutional arrangements (formal and informal) organize the relational dynamics between the multiple actors involved in the policymaking in order to produce the necessary capacities for the policy effective implementation (Capano, Howlett, Ramesh, 2014). The field of study addresses, precisely, this relationship between state capacities and policymaking. State capacities is, at the same time, a prominent topic in the research agenda of policy analysis (Cingolani, Thomsson and Crombrugghe, 2015) as well as a critical element for fostering social, economic, environmental outcomes of the public sector (Rothstein, 2011; Fukuyama, 2014). It is closely related to the concept of effectiveness, that is, the translation of the government ability to mobilize multiple resources to achieve organizational goals (Christensen and Gazley, 2008). In this sense, the issue appears as a source of strengthening government performance, shaping policy implementation and its final outputs. Despite the issue’s multidisciplinary status, more recently, the discussion of state capacities has reached a prominent position within the many dimensions of governance (Cingolani, 2013). Thus, the focus rests on analyses that seek to understand how these capacities, i.e., one or a combination of dimensions of state power (political, economic, administrative, innovative, etc.) are built in a governance context. In addition, other scholars aim to identify and measure government capacity deficits of the policy and decision making processes in the different combinations of possible modes of governance - hierarchy, market and networks (Howlett and Ramesh, 2015). Therefore, the research questions that this panel addresses are: how have governments innovated in terms of capacity building and governance arrangements to deal with current and dynamic challenges? What management trends are incorporated into policymaking in the Age of Innovation? What skills and competences are required to build capacity in the state bureaucracy? How have governments been investing in generating examples of good practices of innovation in public policies in the governance context?

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P06. Defining and Measuring the Impact of “Digital Transformation” on Policymaking
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Clarke
J. Craft
E. Lindquist
ABSTRACT

Digital technologies are framed both as disruptive forces straining traditional governance approaches, and as powerful tools that will bolster policy capacity to address fast moving, complex policy challenges. In response significant budgetary and organizational resources are now directed to the goal of “digital transformation” in governments across the globe. However, the concept of “digital transformation” remains nebulous. In particular, with the bulk of research on digital era governance focused on public management reforms and service delivery, the implications of digital disruption for policy formulation and government policy capacity are little understood. Researchers have not systematically compared how new digital policy instruments and approaches, such as design thinking, big data analytics, and machine learning are being integrated into today’s policy processes, nor how digital policy instrument selection and constituencies vary across administrations, by policy sector, and over time. Moreover, despite global enthusiasm for digital governance, it is unclear to what extent governments are willing and able to “transform” how they design policy, and how advances (or setbacks) in digital policy capacity could be measured in support of robust cross-country comparisons. Is “digital transformation” more smoke than fire, merely editing the policy process at the margins? Alternatively, if the policy process is indeed transforming in the digital age, what does this transformation consist of, how does it compare across different administrations, and what does it imply for the policy capacity of today’s governments? This panel probes these empirical gaps in order to add rigour to the discussions of digital transformation that increasingly punctuate today’s public sector renewal agendas. Adopting a comparative lens, papers will respond to the following questions: “To what extent and in what ways are specific digital technologies and the broader digital context of governing affecting today’s policy processes?” and “How can digital policy capacity be measured and compared across jurisdictions and over time?” The panel will confront current enthusiasm for digital era governance with established literatures on policy design and policy capacity, while offering comparative perspectives and evaluative frameworks that governments can use to drive and monitor progress as they work to integrate digital tools and approaches into their policy work.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P07. Information Sources, Processing and Use in Policy Formulation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
D. Aubin
E. Montpetit
ABSTRACT

How do policymakers gather, process and use information in policy formulation? Information is a critical resource in policy formulation, notably in highly technical, educated and democratically accountable societies. Information, defined as knowledge about a problem and possible solutions, is a prerequisite to governmental action. Information in policy-making contexts can be contested, making governmental action all the more complex (Montpetit, 2016). Information can also reveal new dimensions of problems, further complexifying policy-making, but also opening possibilities for innovative governmental action. As argued by Baumgartner and Jones (2015) “Information is at the core of politics” and a prime driver of policy stability and change. Digging in an issue is deemed to reveal its multiple dimensions and call for more state intervention (e.g. poverty alleviation). Technological developments and innovations, and their commercial applications, also challenge existing laws and regulations, sometimes making them outdated. Public policy needs adaptations when problems are shifting and technology evolves. Within a policy subsystem, information comes from various sources in the policy advisory system, that is the “interlocking set of actors and organizations, with a unique configuration in each sector and jurisdiction, that provides recommendations for action to policymakers” (Craft & Wilder, 2015). Both public officials and external actors (e.g. consultants, scientists, NGOs, media or think tanks) produce and provide information and advice to the politicians and independent regulatory authorities. Information available within governments remains the main source that public officials use (Aubin & Brans, 2018). It takes the form of implementation reports, legal documents, monitoring database, proceedings from consultation procedures, etc. The shift from government to governance must not hide the importance of in-house information in policy formulation. Collected from various public and private sources, information is processed and used in various ways by policymakers. Information use has two dimensions: (1) to enlighten and guide the decisionmaking process towards ‘fit’ regulations; and (2) legitimize the decision. To be turned into usable knowledge, information is sorted, classified, and analyzed. Process information becomes policy advice, that is advice about “clarifying the problem, identifying alternative course of action and systematically determining the optimal response” (Colebatch et al., 2010: 13; see also Halligan, 1995: 139). Advises either remain internal documents, but they can also be formalized (e.g. impact assessments). Impact assessments constitute both a statement about the process, but also a legitimation effort. For this panel, we invite papers on the sources of information, on its processing by policy-makers and on its use and translation into public policy. Although the analysis of information use is still in its infancy, it gave rise to several theorization attempts, for instance those evolving around policy learning (Dunlop & Radaelli, 2017), policy networks (Leifeld & Schneider, 2012), and knowledge utilization (Weiss, 1980; Landry et al., 2001). Even if they are still in a description phase, research on policy advice (Craft & Wilder, 2017), policy work (Colebatch et al., 2010), as well as policy expertise (Weible, 2008) can be used as well. The papers will address the issue of information use in policy formulation in any policy system and level of authority. They can deal with the formulation of both primary and secondary law and concern policy-making as well as regulatory governance. We hope to attract papers that theorize the relationship between information and policy-making, as well as present empirically grounded research on the topic. It is expected from the contributors that they apply a relative degree of formalization. The methods can be both qualitative and quantitative, but the papers must explicitly refer to the methods followed and the tools used for data analysis. Scholarly work that applies innovative methods is welcomed. Reference list Aubin, David, Brans, Marleen, 2018. Policy advisory styles in the francophone Belgian civil service. International Review of Administrative Sciences, preview. Baumgartner, Franck R., Jones, Bryan D., 2015. The politics of information. Problem definition and the course of public policy in America. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago. Colebatch, Hal K., Hoppe, Robert, Noordegraaf, Mirko (Eds.) 2010. Working for Policy. Amsterdam University Press, Amsterdam. Craft, Jonathan, Wilder, Matt, 2017. Catching a second wave: Context and compatibility in advisory system dynamics. Policy Studies Journal 45, 215-239. Dunlop, Claire A., Radaelli, Claudio M., 2017. Learning in the bath-tub: the micro and macro dimensions of the causal relationship between learning and policy change. Policy and Society 36, 304-319. Halligan, John, 1995. Policy advice and the public service, in: Peters, B.G., Savoie, D.J. (Eds.), Governance in a changing environment. McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal and Kingston, pp. 138-172. Landry, Réjean, Amara, Nabil, Lamari, Moktar, 2001. Utilization of social science research knowledge in Canada. Research Policy 30, 333-349. Leifeld, Philip, Schneider, Volker, 2012. Information exchange in policy networks. American Journal of Political Science 56, 731-744. Montpetit, Eric, 2016. In defense of pluralism: Policy disagreement and its media coverage. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Weiss, Carol H., 1980. Knowledge creep and decision accretion. Knowledge 1, 381-404. Weible, Christopher, 2008. Expert-based information and policy subsystems: A review and synthesis. Policy Studies Journal 36, 615-635.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P08. Policy Actors and Instruments
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Clavier
M. Jegen
R. Lecler
ABSTRACT

The study of policy instruments has offered a new starting point for the study of policy-making, outside of a more traditional focus on policy content or policy actors. As tools of government (Hood, 1986), they allowed to focus on policy styles and policy design, questioning the coherence between policy objectives and the means to achieve them (Howlett, 2001; Rayner & Howlett, 2009). As technologies of government embodying particular ideas about problems and the role of the State, they also offered a different lens to make sense of policy change (Lascoumes & Le Galès, 2007). For all its shift in perspective, though, the focus on policy instruments inexorably brings research back to the usual suspects, i.e. actors, interests, ideas and broader institutions, as instruments are inherently political. The most salient case in point is the emergence of the concept of “instrument constituencies” in recent literature. Concerned with the “supply side of policy-making” (Simons & Voß, 2018), instrument constituencies are the communities of actors existing for and because of particular policy instruments. Instrument constituencies could provide answers to how solutions are matched to policy problems (Béland & Howlett, 2016). This panel proposes to question the nexus between policy instruments and policy actors in the policy-making process, including but not limited to instrument constituencies. The puzzle here is that of how the practices of a set of actors influence and are influenced by instruments. This calls for an exploration of, for instance, how sets of actors shape, manipulate, or are constrained by instruments; the debates that occur among sets of actors promoting an instrument; the conflicts between sets of actors promoting different instruments; the resources and power relationships underlying such disputes; the transformations of instruments and their actors across time or along the stages of the policy process; the practices of collaboration between state and private actors working with a particular instrument.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P09. Public Policy for Emerging and Disruptive Technologies: Governing Big Data, Artificial Intelligence, Robotics, and More
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Lindquist
J. Lewis
G. Mikolaczak
ABSTRACT

The objectives of this panel are to 1) generate discussion surrounding the policy implications from a range of emerging technologies, from the benign, to the truly life changing and potentially lethal, 2) discuss potential policy models and frames to best understand and explore these technologies from the policy perspective, and 3) discuss governance frames, and 4) generate topics and issues for future discussion, research and collaboration. The scientific relevance for this topic is significant as technologies always outpace public policy or governance considerations. What are the implications, or perhaps opportunities, from this situation? The context for the topic is all encompassing in that technologies connect communities and nations. Are traditional intergovernmental perspectives capable of transitioning to governance structures appropriate for emerging technologies? Theoretically, this topic can be placed squarely in the policy process literature, across multiple theories and frameworks. Moe specifically, what is the relationship between emerging and disruptive technologies and the definition of solutions to social problems. As a relatively new public policy issue, we are unclear if there is a state of the art. Or is there nothing new in this topic? Should policy scholars build on the existing STS literature in an effort to develop integrative models or theories? Is the existing literature on STS, which is more sociology derived, appropriate for policy studies of emerging technologies? On the opposite side, what is the STS literature missing from a policy perspective? All of these questions are ripe for discussion and development at the ICPP.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P10. Collaborative Governance as a Bridge Between Public Policy and Public Administration
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Lahat
N. Sher-Hadar
ABSTRACT

Collaborative governance arrangements are becoming more familiar as a policy tool that can better cope with the challenges of the current era (Ansell, Sørensen & Torfing 2017; Emerson et al., 2012, 2015; Kekez, Howlett & Ramesh, in process). The term “collaborative governance” refers to specific features of formal, long-term, consensual arrangements involving different stakeholders to promote public policies or programs (Ansell & Gash, 2008). While many use the term “collaborative governance,” some refer to it in the same manner as other practices, such as cooperation and coordination (O'Flynn, 2009). However, using these terms interchangeably masks the unique characteristics of collaborative governance. Collaborative governance is a formal arrangement of consensual and reciprocal practices that involves various stakeholders who engage in more profound, diverse and lasting collaborations and that demand mutual contributions and shared responsibilities. Thus, while there is a growing interest in collaborative governance arrangements as a possible tool that can be added to the range of instruments used by governments, we still need to investigate its contribution, features, and outcomes, as well as when and where it has added value in comparison to other tools, and when it does not. We claim that one of the reasons for the growing interest in collaborative governance is its ability to serve as a bridge between public policy and public administration. While there is an obvious connection between the two, in many cases, both in theory and practice, these streams diverge from one another (Lahat, 2017; Moynihan & Soss, 2014). Policies focus more on the processes, the definitions of public problems and their solutions regarding diverse populations and on the interaction between different actors, while public administration emphasizes the role of the organizational structures and human resources that can achieve these goals. In recent decades, the public policy literature has emphasized the role of different voices in the policy process as an intrinsic feature. By the same token, the public administration literature discusses the next generation of administrative models in the post-NPM era, focusing especially on the need to enhance collaboration and trust. In this context, collaborative governance arrangements can be perceived as a bridge that connects the two. It facilitates the organizational structures that promote insightful dialogue between different stakeholders, including the construction, definition and legitimization of social problems and their solutions.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P11. Politics and Policy in Metropolitan Context: Actors, Narratives and Instruments
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Ndong-Etroit
J. Chauvel
ABSTRACT

Several institutional reforms around the world have built new metropolitan governments in the past decades (Brenner, 2004). Those metropolitan governments have various shapes according to national, cultural, political, institutional backgrounds. Despite these differences, there are three dominant models of metropolitan government: the reform school, the public choice school and the new regionalism. In fact, we have moved from theories advocating cooperation between main cities and their peripheries, to a reformist movement that defends competition between municipalities and efficiency that better pull them up (Tomàs, 2013). And finally the third theory considers as ineluctable "the creation of large polycentric urban areas with high mobility of citizens and products, or post metropolis" (Soya, 2000). This theory based on an intermediate principle between the reformists and the public choice theory, proposes to go beyond the institutional aspect (Douay, 2010) by focusing on the role of actors’ networks that participate in “regional coalitions” (Mitchell-Weaver & Al, 2000). Considering, as Lefèvre argues, that political actors can play an active role in metropolitan governance to find solutions to local economical, social, political, and environmental issues (Lefèvre, 1998). This panel tends to explore the impact of politics on two aspects of metropolitan governments : the institutional construction (of a public policies' space) and the link between planning or transport policies through urban projects (more coordination between various actors without institutional reform) and institutional policies oriented towards bigger simplification, better coordination of private and public actors involved in metropolitan governance.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P12. Instruments of Social-welfare Provision
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Shockley
ABSTRACT

This panel seeks to understand the panoply of instruments for providing social welfare in a comparative and historical perspective. Many years ago, Esping-Anderson (1990) asserted that modern welfare states “are now predominantly occupied with the production and distribution of social well-being” (p. 1). Though much research remains to understand the policy process, social policymaking is obviously the most common instrument of social-welfare provision. Yet, other instruments are being recognized, such as social entrepreneurship, public-private partnerships, and social movements. Prior research has also examined the intersection of public administration and nongovernmental organizations and the shared responsibilities of modern welfare states and “third parties” (Salamon, 1995; Savas, 2000 ), this panel seeks to analyze both intra-governmental (i.e., occurring within government) and extra-governmental (i.e., occurring outside government) instruments of social-welfare provision. State capacity is a germane issue in that a government’s capacity to provide social welfare determine at least in part the policy instruments available to it. The social innovations behind social-welfare provision and the effective conduct of social policy presume a certain level of institutional development and state capacity that varies greatly from state to state. To provide welfare for its citizens through intra-governmental instruments such as public policymaking, a state needs policy capacity enabled through the development of its governance institutions. Indeed, the modern state with robust policy capacity has been the primary source of social innovation in developed societies for most of the twentieth century through today. Yet, when a society has feeble governance institutions and limited policy capacity, more extreme and unpredictable forms of social innovation such as social movements or even revolution can arise. One of the more striking developments of the late twentieth century has been the rise of social entrepreneurship. If a government’s policy capacity is limited but it has a functionally viable institutional foundation, even if inchoate, social entrepreneurship can serve as a source of extra-governmental social innovation (Shockley & Frank, 2011).

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P13. The construction of Policy Solution: The Hidden Face of the Governmental Policy Formulation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Zittoun
F. Fischer
ABSTRACT

David Rochefort and Roger Cobb published an edited book in 1993 titled "The Politics of Problem Definition: Shaping the Policy Agenda" which is used as a major reference in all Textbooks and Handbooks on Public Policy. Drawing on the studies undertaken by Cobb and Elder, the “first systematic scholarly assessment of the pre-decisional component of the policy process” (Jones, 2016), Rochefort and Cobb focused on the problem definition process. This involves defining the meaning of a social situation, its implication, its urgency, and also who or what was to blame for the situation. They proposed to study the “problem definition” phenomenon from both political and policymaking perspectives, to map out the most frequently employed [definitions] by problem definers and to analyze the scenarios by which definitions are build and crumble” (p. 4). Despite the focus on issues and problems, however, an enigmatic paradox persists, namely the neglect of problem solutions. Jordan and Turnpenny (2015) refer to the policy formulation stage and the choice of solutions as the most neglected phase of the policy cycle. In this regard, the question of how a solution is defined remains underdeveloped, if not altogether missing from policy research. That is, how solution definitions are constructed, how a solution succeeds or fails to attract the attention of governmental decision-makers is in need of investigation. If most policy studies have shown that problems are social constructions that actors in the policy process create, then it is equally important to consider this perspective for the construction of solutions. Following Kingdon, who argued that solutions and problems are not inherently interrelated, there is then no reason to assume that the problem definition necessarily carries over to the development of policy solution. But the means by which policymakers in the policy formulation process construct, define, build agreements and impose policy solutions remains poorly understood in the policy literature. If the problem is considered as construction, a large part of the literature considers the policy solution as an instrument which already exists and just has to be chosen by government. But how is a policy solution defined and given meaning to attract government attention? How is the policy instrument constructed? How does an instrument become the “relevant and appropriate” solution to a problem? How and why do actors decide to accept and support a policy solution? How is the competition between different policy proposals supported by different coalitions before one is selected?

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY FORMULATION, ADMINISTRATION AND POLICYMAKERS
P01. Policy Implementation Arrangements: Organizational, Structural and Managerial Aspects
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
F. Sager
A. Gofen
ABSTRACT

Since the groundbreaking argument made by Pressman and Wildavsky (1973) about implementation as a separate component of public policy, numerous studies have focused on varied aspects of implementation arrangements, which ultimately allocate the position of different implementing agents in policy-delivery: either at the central government, in two-tier agencies, in street-level management or at the direct-delivery phase (e.g., Bardach 1977; Gassner and Gofen 2018; Weimer and Vining 2011). Either as formally designed or as exercised on-the-ground, the organization, structure and management of policy implementation define roles, allocate resources, facilitate relationships, and distribute decision power for the various implementing agents. Hence, implementation arrangements are of fundamental importance not only for policy outputs and outcomes, but also for the ways through which government is experienced and perceived by citizens. Moreover, implementation arrangements are definitely not 'fire and forget.' Rather, they require active maintenance, continuing reconsideration and on-going tuning to local circumstances because “[e]ven the most robust policy—one that is well designed to survive the implementation process—will tend to go awry” (Bardach 1977, 5). Although implementation refers to all the activities executed by all levels of administration in all types of public organizations in order to carry out a formal policy decision (O’Toole 1986), three rather distinct perspectives guide its rich and varied scholarship: Within a top-down perspective, studies focus on the linkages between agencies and organizations at the local level as the main contribution for implementation success (Elmore 1979; Pressman and Wildavsky 1973; Sabatier 1986). Within a bottom-up perspective, studies focus on the actions of the staff engaged in direct-delivery, who adjust implementation efforts to the dynamic, unexpected, and ever changing street-level context (Gofen 2013; Lipsky 1980; Maynard-Moody and Musheno 2003). Within public management perspective, studies focus on managerial functions, such as the translation of political decisions (e.g., Lynn et al. 2000), co-production (e.g., Alford 2002; Bovaird 2007), and upwards communication of ideas (e.g., Floyd and Wooldridge 1992). Committed to theoretical and methodological pluralism, this panel welcomes papers that apply a wide range of approaches. Papers can focus on implementation arrangements as a theoretical framework, and address such questions as how to conceptualize and measure implementation arrangements and how to define its analytic dimensions. Papers can refer to various aspects of implementation arrangements, including organizational, structural and managerial, and address them as the dependent variable as well as the independent variable. By encompassing contributions from various policy fields, diverse organizational settings and different theoretical frameworks, this panel attempts to bridge areas of explorations which are less likely to interact. Specifically, the aim of this panel is threefold. First, we seek to allow a more nuanced conceptualization of implementation arrangements, including their components and dimensions. Second, we aim to enable a wide-ranging discussion of the ways through which implementation arrangements both influence and influenced by additional aspects of the policy domain. Lastly, we strive to facilitate an opportunity for scholars who study policy implementation from different perspectives correspond and further develop a comprehensive approach to implementation research.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY IMPLEMENTATION
P03. Open Government: Participation, Inclusion and Impact
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Gintova
M. Francoli
ABSTRACT

Governments and policy makers around the world are initiating and implementing open government initiatives. Governments which are signatories to the Open Government Partnership (OGP) commit to making government more inclusive, responsive and accountable (OGP 2018). As a term, open government is now used to describe a wide range of goals and functions, including making government data publicly available, improving the delivery of public services and encouraging public participation in government decision-making (Clarke and Francoli 2014). As a member of the OGP, Canada has developed an open government policy framework and commitment to impact change. However, to this day, the major focus remains on making government data publicly available, while implementation of other open government initiatives, including public participation commitments lag behind (Clarke and Francoli 2014, 2017; Roy 2016). Other countries, such as the USA, Australia and New Zealand experience similar challenges (Evans and Campos 2013; Price 2017; Stewart 2018). It is important to understand challenges that governments face in order to engage the public in a meaningful way. However, the analysis of these challenges should be complemented by practical solutions on how governments can foster public participation and inclusion. This panel will explore the future of public participation and inclusion initiatives within an open government agenda, and help to drive government action. Specifically, the panel will discuss trends and developments (or lack of) in advancing opportunities for public participation, and implications for policy-making. References: Clarke, Amanda and Mary Francoli. 2017. “Digital Government and Permanent Campaigning” in Permanent Campaigning in Canada edited by Alex Marland, Anna Esselment, and Thierry Giasson. 241–258. Vancouver: UBC Press. Clarke, Amanda and Mary Francoli. 2014. “What’s in a name? Questioning the homogeneity of ‘open government’ programs across seven countries”, Journal of e-Democracy and Open Government. 6(1): 248-266. Evans, Angela M. and Adriana Campos. 2013. Open government initiatives: Challenges of citizen participation. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management. 32(1): 172-185. Open Government Partnership. 2018. “What Is the Open Government Partnership.” Accessed October 13, 2018. http://www.opengovpartnership.org/about Price, Steven. 2017. “New Zealand End-Of-Term Report 2014–2016”. Accessed October 13, 2018. https://www.opengovpartnership.org/documents/new-zealand-end-of-term-report-2014-2016 Roy, Jeffrey. 2017. “Digital government and service delivery: An examination of performance and prospects”. Canadian Public Administration. 60(4): 538–561. Stewart, Daniel. 2018. “Australia Mid-Term Report 2016-2018.” Accessed October 13, 2018. https://www.opengovpartnership.org/report/australia-mid-term-report-2016-2018-year-1

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY IMPLEMENTATION
P05. Governance of Intersectoral Policies with the Population: Illusions and Reality
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
F. Bravo Cruz
P. Smits
ABSTRACT

Crowdsourcing, citizen panel, world cafe are all methodologies to foster a direct involvement of citizens into public decisions. Some countries encourage digital participation at the stage of agenda settings, as some western government did through the e-government move. Latin American countries encouraged wide on-site population design of public policies and citizen accountability in the monitoring of policy implementation with participatory institutions such as councils and conferences (Isunza Vera & Gurza Lavalle,2010; Cruz & Daroit, 2017). Initiatives multiplies, with their load of disappointments and complexities regarding how to keep mechanisms time efficient for the population and for managers and policy makers (Cunill-Grau, 2014). Arnstein long mentioned weaknesses and lack of authenticity in participatory process (Arnstein, 1969). Challenges to keep both voices in balance, the voice of policy makers and the voice of the population, are numerous. Methodology-wise, one needs to capture precise information from the population that can bring up generic comments. Also, the question of best instruments to enable authentic participation of the population is relevant (Halpern, Lascoumes, Le Galès, 2014). Value-wise, one has to combine potentially divergent set of opinions from the population and from decision-makers. Ethically-wise, great care has to be taken for prevention of the cooptation of the population by interest groups defending one agenda, etc. We propose to host researchers interested in intersectoral public policy governance, especially those converging interest in both participatory and multi-sectoral experiences. Hence, this panel aims at recognizing complex state tactics (Smits et al 2016; Smits 2018, Cruz & Daroit, 2017a) responding to population demands. We intend to generate debate around empirical and/or theoretical advances with respect to structural/cognitive/ethical aspects of governing intersectoral policies with the population, sharing arguments on new axis for research. Scholars with supportive and critical experience are welcome. We will prioritize papers on review, multiple cases and comparatives cases, intriguing or disturbing single case study are also welcome. Therefore, the indicative panel questions are: Which are the conditions (i.e. structures, practices and values) to enable governance of intersectorial policies with the population (i.e. arenas, morphologies and instruments that are entailing transversally the public action among societal groups and government agencies, autonomous actors in binding institutional environment)? At the policy design stage, who is able to participate? Why? How? Where, in which settings, are complex policies proposals being designed with or for the population? How are these hybrid arenas among population, public servants and politicians being organized? Which kind of instruments are being mobilized to link actors and projects from multiple sectors, institutions and branches? Which kind of relations are produced among the actors involved in intersectoral management policies? How? Which results have risen up from the mobilization of the population in intersectoral initiatives? What theories are informative to understand the governance of intersectoral policies with the population? References: Arnstein, S.R. (1969) A Ladder of Citizen Participation. Journal of the American Institute of Planners. 35(4), 216-224 Cruz, F. N. B., & Daroit, D. (2017). Das vias para o desenvolvimento democrático: regimentos internos de conselhos de políticas públicas como instrumentos de ação pública transversal e participativa." GIGAPP ESTUDIOS. V. 66-72, p. 231-254. Cruz, F. N. B., & Daroit, D. (2017a). Dos nexos efêmeros ao fazer estado: ensaio sobre transversalidade em conferências nacionais de políticas públicas. NAU Social, 8(15). Cunill-Grau, N. (2014). La intersectorialidad en las nuevas políticas sociales: Un acercamiento analítico-conceptual. Gestión y política pública, 23(1), 5-46. Isunza Vera, E., & Gurza Lavalle, A. (2010). La innovación democrática en América Latina: tramas y nudos de la representación, la participación y el control social. Centro de Investigaciones y Estudios Superiores en Antropología Social (CIESAS). Halpern, C., Lascoumes, P., & Le Galès, P. (2014). L'instrumentation de l'action publique: controverses, résistances, effets. Presses de Sciences Po. Smits, P., Préval, J., & Denis, J. L. (2016). Prendre en compte la santé dans les politiques publiques. Étude d’un régime de gouvernementalité au Québec. Sciences sociales et santé, 34(2), 45-70. Smits, Therrien MC, Touati N., Denis JL. (2018) A Complexity Case Study: The Implementation of an Interministerial Policy — A View from Within Government. Journal on Policy and Complex Systems, V. 4(1).

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY IMPLEMENTATION
P06. Politics of Street-Level Organizations: Between Market, Mobilizations and the State
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Miaz
S. Tomkinson
ABSTRACT

Michael Lipsky’s street-level bureaucracy theory, and the following research tradition that examined the role of implementation agents, transformed the way policy scholars examine public organizations (Portillo and Rudes, 2014). Research in diverse policy domains illustrated the importance of these agents’ discretion, judgment, power and autonomy for policy implementation contrary to the lowest level policy space they are considered to occupy (Brodkin, 1997; 2011; Brodkin and Marston, 2013; Chiarello, 2015; Dubois, 1999; Evans, 2010; Hill, Hupe and Buffat 2015; Maynard-Moody and Musheno, 2003; Miaz, 2017a; Spire, 2007; Tomkinson, 2018; Watkins-Haye, 2009; Zacka, 2017). While the street-level bureaucracy theory continues to point out to the political consequences of administrative discretion in an empirically grounded manner (Brodkin, 2012) theoretical and political transformations raise some questions regarding its explanatory power. First, some authors argue that the focus on the discretionary power of implementation agents limits the scope of analysis to the individual level and perpetuates the attention on agents’ control (Maynard-Moody and Musheno, 2003 and 2012; Maynard-Moody and Portillo, 2010). Instead they suggest focusing on institutional norms, reframing of agents’ judgments and actions through agency and pragmatic improvisation. Second, with new modes of governance, non-profit and market actors have also gained the role of implementation agents (Fyall, 2017). However, as Brodkin states it well, “the world that gave rise to street-level bureaucracies has been transformed. The public sector no longer dominates policy delivery as it once did. Contracting and privatization have reshaped the organizational landscape, creating new, mixed forms of provision and complex delivery arrangements. Today, policy delivery occurs not only through public bureaucracies, but also through nonprofit organizations, for-profit firms, and mixed public–private arrangements.” (Brodkin 2012, 944) Taking into account this transformation, Brodkin proposes to broaden our approach to analyze what she calls “street-level organizations” to take into account the increasing number of non-State actors are now involved in policy implementation. For instance, non-profit or activist organizations can have a policy-making role and work like street-level organizations through their participation in the process of selecting the beneficiaries of public action (Weill 2014) or through their own selecting practices in providing legal help to migrants and asylum seekers (Miaz 2017b; Pette 2014). These actors may be auxiliaries of the state to which this latter has delegated implementation tasks, but they may also be actors replacing or complementing the state (receiving funds for their action), or even contesting state practices, for example in providing legal help to claim or protect their rights. References Brodkin, Evelyn Z., 1997, “Inside the welfare contract: Discretion and accountability in state welfare administration,” Social Service Review, 71, pp. 1-33. Brodkin, Evelyn Z., 2011, “Policy Work: Street-Level Organizations Under New Managerialism,” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, Supplement 2, 21, pp. 253-277. Brodkin, Evelyn Z., 2012, “Reflections on Street-Level Bureaucracy: Past, Present, and Future,” Public Administration Review, 72, 6, pp. 940-949. Brodkin, Evelyn Z. and Gregory Marston (eds.), 2013, Work and the Welfare State. Street-Level Organizations and Workfare Politics, Washington, DC, Georgetown University Press. Chiarello, Elizabeth, 2015, “The War on Drugs Comes to the Pharmacy Counter: Frontline Work in the Shadow of Discrepant Institutional Logics,” Law & Social Inquiry, 40, 1, pp. 86-122. Dubois, Vincent, 2010, The Bureaucrat and the Poor. Encounters in French Welfare Offices, 1st Edition, Aldershot, Ashgate. Evans, Tony, 2010, Professional Discretion in Welfare Services: Beyond Street-Level Bureaucracy, Farnham, Ashgate. Fyall, Rachel, 2017, “Nonprofits as Advocates and Providers: A Conceptual Framework,” Policy Studies Journal, 45, 1 pp. 121-143. Hupe, Peter, Michael Hill and Aurélien Buffat, 2015, Understanding Street-Level Bureaucracy, Chicago, University of Chicago Press. Maynard-Moody, Steven and Michael Musheno, 2003, Cops, Teachers, Counselors. Stories from the Front Lines of Public Service, Ann Arbor, University of Michigan Press Maynard-Moody, Steven and Michael Musheno, 2012, “Social Equities and Inequities: Street-Level Workers as Agents and Pragmatists,” Public Administration Review, 72, S1, 2012, pp. 16-23. Maynard-Moody, Steven and Shannon Portillo, 2010, “Street-Level Bureaucracy Theory,” in Robert Durant (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of American Bureaucracy, New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 252-277. Miaz, Jonathan, 2017a, “From the Law to the Decision: The Social and Legal Conditions of Asylum Adjudication in Switzerland,” European Policy Analysis, 3, 2, pp. 372-396. Miaz, Jonathan, 2017b, « Qui peut rester et qui doit partir ? Les frontières au prisme des usages sociaux du droit d’asile en Suisse », trajectoires, Hors série 3, online version, https://journals.openedition.org/trajectoires/2398. Pette, Mathilde, 2014, « Associations: les nouveaux guichets de l’immigration ? Du travail militant en préfecture », Sociologie, 5, 4, pp. 405-421. Portillo, Shannon and Danielle S. Rudes, 2014, “Construction of Justice at the Street Level,” The Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 10, pp. 321-334. Spire, Alexis, 2007, « L’asile au guichet. La dépolitisation du droit des étrangers par les agents de préfecture », Actes de la Recherche en sciences sociales, 169, pp. 30-47. Tilly, Charles, 1995, « Contentious Repertoires in Great Britain, 1758-1834”, in Mark Traugott (ed.), Repertoires and Cycles of Collective Action, Durhan (N. C.), Duke University Press, pp. 15-42. Tomkinson, Sule, 2018, “Who are you afraid of and why? Inside the Black Box of Refugee Tribunals”, Administration publique du Canada, 61, 2, pp. 184-204. Watkins-Haye, Celeste, 2009, The New Welfare Bureaucrats. Entanglements of Race, Class, and Policy Reform, Chicago, University of Chicago Press. Weill, Pierre-Edouard, 2014, « Quand les associations font office de street-level bureaucracy. Le travail quotidien en faveur de l’accès au droit au logement opposable », Sociologie du travail, 56, 3, pp. 298-319. Zacka, Bernardo, 2017, When the State Meets the Street. Public Service and Moral Agency, Harvard University Press.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY IMPLEMENTATION
P07. Policies for Rural Poverty Alleviation in the 21st Century: New Challenges and Possibilities
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Thakur
ABSTRACT

Poverty is still a major issue in the policy agenda. According to the most recent estimates, in 2015, almost 750 million people in the world lived on less than a $1.90 a day. The majority of the global poor live in rural areas, are poorly educated, employed in the agricultural sector, and under 18 years of age. Policies to reduce rural poverty have been implemented over the last decades in several countries through a broad mix of strategies and policy tools. There is a general consensus that these policies have contributed to social and economic inclusion, creating alternatives for poor families and communities, as well as promoting economic development. Despite the progress made, troubling signs are emerging as the pace of poverty reduction is slowing. Furthermore, fast economic and technological transformations in the world economy, rapid expansion of multinational agribusiness complexes in Latin America and Africa, and new demands derived from the impact of climate change, stablished a new set of challenges for policy makers involved in rural poverty alleviation policies. As the strategic importance of rural poverty alleviation policies became acknowledged, there also remains many new issues and important questions that need to be addressed, such as: Are there different ways to define and measure rural poverty in different contexts? What conditions, causal mechanisms or different modes of rural poverty might be identified both historically and in the present? Are there important changes in these mechanisms? Why the decline in rural poverty has slowed in recent years? Are there new important behavioral or institutional issues that should inform the design of a new generation of rural poverty alleviation policies? How should we decide about the proper policy strategies and the policy tools that should be adopted to reduce rural poverty? How these choices should be guided by the new demands related to environmental sustainability, equal rights, labor rights, population health, among others? What do rural poverty alleviation mean for the development processes in different political, institutional and cultural contexts? Can strategies adopted in the developed world inform new demands for rural poverty alleviation in the developing world (or vice-versa)? How rural poverty alleviation policies should address multi-level governance issues? What are the best arrangements for stakeholder participation in promoting sustainable solutions for rural poverty alleviation? How to evaluate the role of firms/NGOs in the creation and capture of business/social value in alignment with rural poverty alleviation policies? What are the drivers, the impact and the risks of adopting new technologies and innovative business models as part of the strategy for rural poverty alleviation? How new logistics solutions and innovative business models can contribute to rural alleviation policies in the developing world? This panel is aimed at contributing to the recent debate on new challenges and possibilities related to rural poverty alleviation policies in the developing world (Latin America, Africa, Middle-East, Eastern Europe and Asia). We are interested in analytical papers, case studies and assessments regarding new modes of governance, the choice and adoption of technological innovations, new business models, and new monitoring and evaluating strategies, especially those aimed to reduce income and categorical inequalities as well as promoting environmental sustainability.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY IMPLEMENTATION
P08. Uncertainty - a Certainty in Policy Implementation?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
T. Eule
F. Infantino
ABSTRACT

If the only thing that is certain is that nothing is certain - what does that mean for public administration? This panel seeks to further our understanding of the role of uncertainty in public administration, with a particular focus on policy implementation. Many studies point to the existence of vague rules, ambiguous political messages, ever-changing structures and responsibilities as well as precarious funding. Uncertainty affects all levels, from policy making to organisations and individuals throughout government. Furthermore, we know that bureaucrats on all levels of public administration retain their autonomy through ambivalences created in the interstices between policy and practice. Finally, uncertainty is of particular relevance as it poses a significant challenge to more rational models of public policy in general and policy implementation in particular.In this panel, we invite contributions that seek to unpack this further. We are particularly interested in uncertainty as an organizing principle, in the sense that it leads to organization and structuring. If uncertainty is a relatively stable given in organizations, then it should not only have disruptive, but also stabilising and transformative effects. Delving further into this seems particularly relevant during times of seemingly continuous crises, austerity measures, and policy innovation. Understanding uncertainty as an organizing principle might help us in understanding logics beyond certain events and cross-sectional perspectives.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY IMPLEMENTATION
P02. Advancing Thinking on Policy Tools: A Research Agenda
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Howlett
G. Capano
ABSTRACT

Thinking about policy tools has changed over the past few years as a new emphasis has been placed on tools such as nudging, co-production and a variety of digital tools such as crowd-sourcing and Big Data analysis. These developments have challenged existing models and practices and it is time to review theory and modelling around policy tools in light of these new efforts. This set of panels will examine early models and modes of thinking about policy tools in light of case studies and comparative work dealing with a variety of new actions in this field. These include macro-level practices and analyses of tools including thinking about "meta tools" like The relationship between tools and “platforms”: that is, specific kinds of ‘meta-tools’ which are open-ended and multi-functional and provide the foundation for the use of other more directed tools, and presentation and analysis of existing and new empirical evidence on administrator, public and political behaviour around choices of policy tools. And they include meso-level studies of policy mixes including related issues in their evolution such as sequencing, layering, stretching and patching as well as studies focusing on the nature and uses of “procedural tools” and their role in policy designs and problems around tools like information provision and public participation. And they will also include papers dealing with more micro-level developments including problems and thinking around implementation such as tool calibrations, their design implications and how they affect policy change and Tool 'volatility' – that is, the likelihood and ease with which a tool can be gamed/violated by targets or implementors and its design implications, as well as studies focusing on the nature of the mechanisms that tools activate in order to affect target behaviour: that is, why tools actually 'work' and why they are complied with.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P03. The Design of Policy, Governance and Public Service
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. van Buuren
J. Lewis
B. Peters
ABSTRACT

Shrinking resources, discontented electorates and complex problems of the last decade have prompted the public sector to look for new ways of governing, and developing and delivering public services. In this effort, design has been heralded as a central concept to innovate public policy, service delivery and its governance. Design is seen as a means to improve people- or user-centeredness, which in a co-productive or co-creative way bridges the gap between public policies, services and citizens’ needs and expectations, and environmental challenges (Thorpe & Gamman, 2016; Thomas & Grace, 2008; Junginger, 2014; Mulgan, 2014, Sangiorgi, 2015). To facilitate such a design approach, all kinds of ‘learning-by-doing’ methods (e.g. design experiments, living labs, and collaborative design sessions) are rapidly gaining popularity in public administration (Bason, 2017), in order to co-create value with involved stakeholders and in particular service users to strengthen the people-orientation in public policy and services and collectively solve complex challenges (Howlett, 2014). Although the notion of public administration as a design science is certainly not new (Simon, 1971; Miller, 1984; Shangraw & Crow, 1997; Meyer, 2005), there is much that we do not know about the application of design-oriented methods to public policy, governance, management and services. Further, the contribution of design as a co-production strategy within public sector contexts needs further debate (Bason 2010, 2017). The rise of living labs, field labs and pilot programs in which all kinds of (participatory) design methods are applied, illustrates the increasing attention for this exploratory and experimental style of policy-making, governance and public service delivery. However the public context in which design-thinking is applied, also raises serious dilemmas and questions (Hillgren et al. 2011). Hence, this panel is dedicated to exploring the principles, methodological underpinnings, challenges and practices of applying design-oriented approaches to the field of public policy and governance. In particular, the panel seeks to explore how design-led approaches contribute on the one hand, to policy and governance innovations (design of policy), and on the other hand, the extent to which a design approach is an effective way to generate more rigorous insights into practices of public policy and governance. The latter element embodies important questions about the effective application of design-thinking methods, their methodological rigor and their applicability as scientifically valid methods to enhance our empirical knowledge of real-world problems. . Therefore, this panel seeks to contribute to the following questions: How can the methodological rigor and replicability of design methodologies in public management and policy environments be enhanced; What are theoretical and empirical conditions that support the effective application and integration of (collaborative) design-led approaches within public sector and government; What is the value (in terms of legitimacy, creativity and problem-solving capacity) and ultimately the impact of design-led approaches (e.g. policy labs; living labs and other innovative methods) to value creation in public policy and governance (health care, culture, education, social interventions, transportation, safety etc.); What limitations and routes for improvement of design-led approaches can be determined for the innovation of public policy and wider institutional change?

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P04. Resilience, Adaptability and Transformability in Public Policies and the Co-evolving Dynamics of Organizations
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
R. Pinheiro
M. Young
M. Frigotto
ABSTRACT

In the last decade or so, there has been a growing awareness among policy makers and academics alike about the importance of investigating the role that complex, adaptive systems play in policy processes (Room 2011, Morcöl 2012, Geyer and Cairney 2015). Applying a complex systems model to policy requires going beyond the macro and understanding also the dynamics of the actors and organizations that receive, (re-)produce and translate policy. Systems theorists have long argued that analytical reductionism has led to a simplification of how social, technological, cultural and ecological systems interact in non-linear ways to produce unpredicted events that cause societal disruption and turmoil, what some have termed ‘black swans’, as well as ‘wicked problems’ that confound simple, temporal or spatially bounded solutions. Given recent turbulent events and uncertainty-raising problems such as the global financial crisis, Brexit, social media’s legitimacy issues, the EU’s migration crisis and the rise of political populism and post-truth politics, it is thus timely to inquire about the degree to which policy making and policy makers take into account the complex foundations of both the problems and policy solutions, as well as the co-evolutionary nature of the self-organising systems and the organizations that compose them (e.g. in the realms of health, education, finance, environment, media) from within which these events incubate. Disruptive events call for change in public policies and in the actors producing and receiving public policies (e.g. organizations, communities, individuals), in terms of anticipating, reshaping and overcoming the effects emanating from these events. On the reverse side of the same coin, disruptive events also threaten society and the survival of the institutions (order, logics, behaviour) that ground it. Hence, they also suggest a need for supporting societal robustness and uninterrupted functioning. In a systems’ thinking perspective, this call for change and persistence can be understood in terms of resilience. Resilience is the capacity of a system to absorb disturbance and reorganize while undergoing change so as to still retain functioning and guarantee survival. Within a resilience framework, change can take the form of adaptability or transformability depending on the scope and the impact of change. Adaptability is the capacity to modify and adjust the system to respond to disturbances, while transformability is the capacity to change the system into a different one if disturbances make the current one unsustainable. Both these strategies allow the system to survive, however, they impact very differently on the society and the organizations, individuals and communities within it. This panel will investigate how policy can directly and indirectly (though metagovernance of institutional and individual actors) combine and remain open to adaptability, transformability and resilience. The overarching hypothesis has two parts: one, the prevailing linear models of public policy are not adequate to deal with the complex nature of contemporary policy problems and the organizations and systems in which they arise; and two, that by drawing on complex systems theory (in this case through the concept of resilience) new insights and models of policymaking can be developed that more effectively address those shortcomings. We envision addressing the following thee aspects of this challenge in the panel’s sessions: Focusing on the macro level, and exploring adaptability, transformability and resilience within policy frameworks and the policy making process; Exploring the conceptual and theoretical tools available to social scientists to both assess and comprehend the phenomena of adaptability, transformability and resilience (as well as the complex interplay between the three) at the macro (policy), meso (organisations) and micro (individual agents) levels; Investigating the empirical manifestations (evidence) of the tripartite phenomenon of adaptability-transformability-resilience at the macro, meso and/or micro levels. The panel addresses recent calls to bring together a multiplicity of scholarly communities (inter-disciplinary dialogue) in addressing complex problems facing contemporary societies. References Geyer, R., and Cairney, P. (2015). Handbook on complexity and public policy: Edward Elgar Publishing. Morçöl, G. (2013). A Complexity Theory for Public Policy, New York & London: Taylor & Francis. Room, G. (2011). Complexity, Institutions and Public Policy: Agile Decision-making in a Turbulent World, Cheltenham and Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P05. Advancing the Policy Design Framework
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
B. Peters
G. Fontaine
ABSTRACT

Advancing the Policy Design Framework The 1980s shift from social theory to policy design has provided comparative policy analysis with an encompassing framework bridging research and practice. From then on, theories of the policy design have combined models of causation, intervention and evaluation with theories of policy formulation, implementation and evaluation. Four foregrounding theories of the policy design have emerged based on different ontologies, which are summarized below. The neopositivist approach continues the analysis and modelization in the tradition of main stream political science, using intensively cost-benefit analysis and econometrics, semi-experiments, time-pooled series and formal process tracing. It focuses on program design and law-like theories aimed at explaining policy change, implementation styles, government efficiency, policy coherence and congruence and instruments constituency through policy mixes, portfolios or bundles. From that standpoint, scholars treat actors´ values and preferences, State′s capacity, regulation, spaces and administrative structures as independent variables of policy design. The realist agenda deals with governance interplays as a result of the transformation of the State and the relationships between the government, non-State actors, international organizations and local communities. It conceives policy design essentially as a combination of actors, social values and instruments according to a logic of appropriateness, or perhaps a strictly political logic. Scholars intend to explain policy implementation in actual situations, therefore instrumentation is essentially context-dependent. They treat policy instruments as institutions enjoying a certain autonomy from individual and collective actors. Most recent research underlines the role of ideas in institutional change and it reckons that policy change is produced by complex causal mechanisms articulating ideas, interests and institutions that cannot be treated as independent variables. The analytical school put actors´ perceptions, representations and interpretations at the core of policy design. It considers policy design a contingent process in which problems and solutions are socially constructed. Initially scholars addressed the problem of disconnected cognitive levels and maps between policy “designers”, implementors and target groups. From that standpoint, policy design was above all a way to make actors do something they would not do otherwise, using policy instruments to influence their behavior towards compliance. Research then focused on how policy design shapes the social construction of a policy′s target population, according to their identity and power. This lead to a theory of “degenerative policy design” which underlined framing and translation as a way to correct the unbalanced relationships between the administration, the experts and the public. Further research addressed the drivers of change in target populations and how the status of targeted actors could evolve. Most recent research from this tradition deals with the “design talk” in the process of governing, which refers to policy design as a framing activity in the practice and analysis of policy. The reflexivist approach initially contributed to research on policy design with a taxonomy opposing “reasoned consensus” to positivism, social engineering and relativism. Reasoned consensus could be reached either by dismissal (e.g. the accommodation of truth to power) or by critical enlightenment, aimed at correcting the systematic communication distortions created by power relationships, through dialectics, the equalization of capacities, holistic experimentation and institutional innovation like mediation and broad scale discursive exercises. From that standpoint, policy design is an emancipatory strategy in the power relationships opposing the State to non-State actors. Later on these scholars embraced the “argumentative turn” and the introduction of the critical theory in public administration and planning. Against the hegemony of instrumental rationality in social sciences, they advocate for a cognitive approach to the policy process, consistent with the theory of rational-critical communication. This implies a preference for heuristic, deliberative analysis and thick descriptions of historical events. Eventually the focus on the relationship between policy design and the sociological locus of the researcher derived in theories of participatory problem-solving, deliberation and practice. Our panel seeks to engage in a dialogue between these four schools of thought, in order to advance the policy design framework. The following questions may be addressed as guidelines for the discussion: Who is involved in a policy design?How are complex and wicked problems addressed in a policy design?How does a policy design deal with contingency?How are policy instruments selected and combined in a policy design? We also look forward to discussing the methodological challenges raised by the foregrounding theories of the policy design. In particular, we wonder how scholars combine research and practice in their professional context. The participants may contribute to the discussion with an 8000 word paper based on a within-case study or cross-case comparison of small-n or large-n scale. Theoretical and methodological papers are welcome as long as they are grounded in empirical research

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P06. Trends in University Funding Policies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Bouchard St-Amant
ABSTRACT

Public universities fulfill multiple functions. They provide teaching, professional training, advisement on policy and they produce research. From a funding perspective, they are peculiar creatures. They are largely subsidized through taxes, leading governments to ask them for accountability. At the same time, their expertise should lead them to choose how they allocate their research and teaching funds. This leaves very little room for governments to have their say on the way universities spend the money they receive. As an indirect steering mechanism, governments usually rely on a funding rule to allocate funds to each university. For instance, the provinces of Ontario, Québec and Manitoba (Canada) tie most of the provincial funding to student enrollment. In Norway and in Germany, funding is instead tied to graduation rates or other « performance » measures. Finally, in some (usually smaller) jurisdictions, funding is not tied to any measure, but is rather given in a lump-sum fashion. The design of these funding rules generates incentives for universities to change their practices. By increasing the component of a funding rule tied to a given outcome, universities are indirectly steered into increasing that outcome. On the upside, enrollment-based rules may encourage universities to increase enrollment, completion-based rules may increase graduation rates and unconditional transfers may provide no incentives to universities. These upsides, however, can be conflicting and may not be the sole outcomes. For instance, universities may increase their efforts to recruit from other universities, reduce requirements for graduation or, in the case of unconditional transfers, reduce their teaching or research output. Depending on the formulas, universities may also change the proportion of funds they dedicate to research activities. This panel is about the study of the impact of funding formulas: comparative analysis, studies of the latest reforms, statistical analysis and other forms of study on the topic are more than welcome.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P07. Making ‘Credible’ Knowledge for Policy: the Politics (and Practice) of Expertise
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Papanastasiou
C. Hurl
ABSTRACT

Public policy scholarship has developed a rich and diverse literature on processes of international policy transfer and translation, and associated global networks of policy experts and institutions. However, while the impact and implementation of powerful forms of knowledge such as benchmarks, best practices, league tables, and impact assessments have received a great deal of scholarly attention, less attention has been paid to the ways these forms of knowledge are actually generated by those we call policy ‘experts’. Drawing from recent debates in Science and Technology Studies (STS), the governmentalities literature, and research on epistemic communities, this panel looks at the making of knowledge for policy. It will explore the way that policy experts package and circulate knowledge in making a case for various policy priorities and agendas, and investigate how this knowledge is embedded in particular professional practices and political technologies. Recognising that policy experts generate policy knowledge in contrasting ways, that they draw on diverse techniques and tools, and that their work is visible to differing degrees, we ask: How do experts work to generate credibility in the policy-making process, to what extent is their authority contested, and what kinds of political dynamics does this expose? The panel embraces studying policy experts in their full diversity, including those working in government, international organisations, management consultancies, think tanks, and professional service firms. Key references Clarke, J., Bainton, D., Lendvai, N., Stubbs, P. (2015) Making Policy Move: Towards a politics of translation and assemblage. Bristol: Policy Press. Dolowitz, D. P., & Marsh, D. (2000). Learning from Abroad: The Role of Policy Transfer in Contemporary Policy-Making. Governance, 13(1), 5-23. Espeland, W.N. & Sauder, M. (2007). Ranking and Reactivity: How Public Measures Recreate Social Worlds. American Journal of Sociology, 113(1), 1-40. Kornberger, M. & Carter, C. (2010). Manufacturing Competition: How Accounting Practices Shape Strategy Making in Cities. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 23(3), 325-249. Larner, W. & Laurie, N. (2010). Travelling technocrats, embodied knowledges: Globalising privatisation in telecoms and water, Geoforum, 41, 218–226. Schwartz-Shea, P. (2014). Judging Quality: Evaluative Criteria and Epistemic Communities. In D. Yanow & P. Schwartz-Shea (Eds.), Interpretation and Method: Empirical Research Methods and the Interpretive Turn (pp. 120–146). New York: M.E. Sharpe. Shore, C. & Wright, S. (2011). Introduction. Conceptualizing Policy: technologies of governance and the politics of visibility. In C. Shore, S. Wright & D. Pero (Eds.), Policy Worlds: Anthropology and the Analysis of Contemporary Power. New York: Bergahn Books. Sturdy, S., Freeman, R., & Smith-Merry, J. (2013). Making Knowledge for International Policy: WHO Europe and Mental Health Policy, 1970–2008. Social History of Medicine, 26(3), 532–554.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P08. Fiscal Governance: an International Perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Mou
M. Atkinson
ABSTRACT

Citizens, journalists and academics can often be heard worrying about the tendency of governments to run deficits and accumulate debt. After all, unlike most organizations, governments often have very significant borrowing capabilities. To reduce the temptation to fund current spending via long term borrowing, many countries, states and provinces have adopted rules that impose limits on debts or deficit spending. In Canada, the United States and other developed countries, the most popular of these rules requires governments to balance their budgets either annually, or over a relatively short time frame. In developing countries, debt limits are commonly employed as fiscal rules. Although the presence of stringent fiscal rules is generally associated with lower deficits and debts, the process of implementing fiscal rules has drawn criticism and suspicion. Fiscal rules are not always well conceived. Sometimes governments do not follow their own rules, sometimes they change the rules so that they can be in compliance, and sometimes they develop accounting practices that allow them to skirt the rules. The effectiveness of rules depends on: 1) their design, and 2) the fiscal governance regime in which they work. Getting the rules right is important, but whether rules work in the way they were intended also requires a set of norms and institutions that commit decision makers to maintain fiscal accountability. This panel will compare the experience of different countries and sub-national entities in developing and applying fiscal rules. Whether fiscal rules can be effectively employed in multi-level governance settings is of particular interest to those concerned with the financial vulnerability of local and regional governments. The objective of the panel is to understand whether and how a fiscal governance regime centered on fiscal rules can help governments manage debts, foster norms of fiscal sustainability and meet the accountability expectations. The research questions that the panel will focus on include: 1. What is the experience of different countries in controlling debts? 2. What is the experience of different countries in creating and applying fiscal rules? 3. How can rule-based fiscal governance be made more effective? 4. How can the measurement and evaluation of fiscal governance be improved? Fiscal sustainability should be of concern to citizens in every country, but significant disagreements exist regarding the dangers of indebtedness and the perils of austerity. A consideration of fiscal rules can reveal different norms and expectations regarding fiscal governance and the readiness of governments to use rules to guide decision making. Lessons learned from those with extensive experience can be shared widely to improve the design and implementation of rules, ensure budgets are sustainable, and strengthen norms of fiscal accountability. This panel discussion can also help researchers to exchange ideas and learn from each other the methods of measuring and evaluating fiscal governance.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P09. Citizens and Evidence-Based Policy Making: Perfect Couple or Strange Bedfellows?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
V. Pattyn
P. Bundi
ABSTRACT

Policy evaluations and other research activities generate information that can be used in order to improve public policies, which is commonly captured under the (rational) label of evidence-based policy making (EBP). However, there is ample empirical evidence that the use of such information is not systematic and often politicized. Moreover, the generation of evidence is dominated by elites, such as experts, academics, evaluators or public servants, and rarely includes the involvement of citizens. This is rather surprising as citizens are often the main beneficiary group of public policy and their beliefs and opinions define the political framework of public measures. It can even be argued that the involvement of citizens has the potential of overcoming the classic tension between democracy and technocracy in public policy making. In research on evaluation, the involvement of citizens has been discussed in frameworks coined as Democratic Evaluation (MacDonald 1993), Transformative Participatory Evaluation (Cousins and Whitmore 1998) or Deliberative Democratic Evaluation (House/Howe 1999), which promise to be more inclusive, and foster participation and collaboration. Still, despite the existence of such frameworks, the systematic involvement of citizens in evidence creation seems to be rather exception than rule (Halachmi & Holzer 2010). How can we explain this discrepancy, and what are strategies to make research and evaluation processes more democratic? This panel gathers theoretical, conceptual, and empirical contributions that deal with the relationship between citizens, evidence and public policy, with the aim to enhance our understanding of how citizens’ claims are mobilized in evidence and how such evidence is utilized in public policy settings. We conceive the panel as a forum to exchange comparative research experience and case studies about this issue, and welcome contributions relating to different policy domains, institutional settings and countries. In the panel, we approach ‘evidence’ in a comprehensive way: papers can focus on any kind of evidence, such as policy evaluations, research reports, etc. Research questions can tackle any aspect of the ‘evidence lifecycle’ and can relate to the agenda-setting of involving citizens in evidence generation; the actual methods to involve citizens in evidence creation; and the (mis)use and influence of citizen input in evidence generation. Potential questions of interest can include (but are not limited to): 1. Which institutional settings foster or impede the involvement of citizens in evidence generation? Do we see differences across administrative cultures, or across policy fields? 2. How can scholars institutionalize democratic processes in policy evaluations and research so that evidence is based on a valid and reliable judgement of public policies with evaluation and research methods that rely on citizen input? 3. What are the potential and limitations of evidence that relies on citizen input for public policy making? To what extent can citizen-based evidence approaches overcome the technocracy-democracy tension that characterizes the evaluation field and can inclusive evidence approaches serve accountability and policy learning purposes?

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P10. Governing Complex Problems: Issues of Uncertainty, Time, Scale and Transformation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Hurlbert
C. Camillo
M. Fulton
ABSTRACT

Although one of the oldest activities of the human race, governance has never been more complex or difficult (Dahlstrom et al. 2011). Governance arrangements effectively determine how decisions are made in society, how resources are distributed, which problems are solved and how, and, to some extent, how various voices are heard. Definitions of governance vary, but many refer to formal and informal rules, the interactions among formal and informal institutions, the political, legal, social, economic and administrative institutions that develop, manage, and distribute societal goods (water, health services, employment benefits, recognize some human rights, and not others) involving public, private, and civil society organizations that practice and implement norms, programmes, regulations, and laws. 21st Century problems are increasingly complex, wicked problems that defy complete definitions, for which there is not always one definite, accepted, immediate or ultimate solution. Often one problem is a symptom of another problem (Rittel and Weber, 1973). Uncertainty, unknown unknowns, and residual risk (the threat remaining after all efforts to identify and eliminate risk have been made) can be a barrier to evidence based policy and decision making. Normative judgments can be involved in these determinations. Risks may vary along spatial scales in relation to both human and natural systems with differing vulnerability and exposure in different areas and communities; Risks may vary in relation to current and future risks (with some events being slow onset, or chronic (drought and migration), some conflicts being covert, and other acute shocks or conflicts (extreme events of fire, flood, or security). Risks may cascade through sectors, regions, countries (such as the financial collapse of 2008, or potential for multi-bread basket failures as a result of ENSO events of drought, civil war) and there will be winners and losers both within and between countries. The working hypothesis of governance research is that some governance arrangements are better than others at solving the problems facing a society. Traditional governance distinctions have focussed on formal and largely binary institutional structures—e.g., bicameralism versus unicameralism; presidential verses parliamentarism; proportional representation versus plurality. For governance theorists, these macro distinctions are important but no longer sufficient.A new set of distinctions have been including adaptive governance, collaborative cross-scale governance (Bodin 2017), inclusive governance, polycentric governance, multi-level, or global governance. They have been developed in close proximity to the complex problems of risk and uncertainty that they are intended to address. How best to respond to complex problems, what are the best governance arrangements, how these governance arrangements can be assessed and measured, becomes pressing social, academic and political questions. Do specific governance frameworks apply depending on the nature, sector, magnitude or some other feature of the complex problems, or depending on the demands of the citizenry? Do measures of good governance align with the framework of governance? Are measures of good governance, including procedural, capacity, output measures, or dimensions of corruption, economic, political, democratic, or representative best in relation to the nature of the complex problem? How best can the frameworks and the measures be studied and analyzed? This panel will explore theoretically and empirically what are the best frameworks of governance, and how governance might be studied, and evaluated.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P11. Advancing the Understanding of Evidence Use in Public Policymaking – Insights from Multiple Conceptual Approaches
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Parkhurst
K. Oliver
P. Cairney
ABSTRACT

The panel will gather papers that attempt to further our understanding of the processes, mechanisms, or normative concerns involved in the use of evidence to inform policymaking. It specifically will call on authors using novel conceptual or methodological approaches to the study of evidence use in policy making, rather than seeking additional case studies using existing methods. The ideas of ‘evidence based’ or ‘evidence informed’ policymaking are now well established in most public policy sectors. Indeed, there has been a tremendous proliferation of work related to evidence use, including multiple international conferences focussed on evidence use now regularly held. Yet only a small percentage of work under this heading explicitly tries to apply concepts, theories, or methods from the social and political sciences to understand the nature of evidence use processes. Those works which have studied evidence use from a more conceptually developed position have also taken a number of different approaches. Examples include application of: ideational theories to consider how evidence constructions link to policy ideas (Smith 2013); critical discourse analysis to see how evidence is constructed and framed in relation to political ideologies (Parkhurst 2012); cognitive psychological insights to consider bias in individuals’ understanding of evidence (Cairney 2016, Parkhurst 2017); bounded rationality concepts to consider policymaker choice realities (Cairney 2016); social network analysis to look at who is involved in evidence use and their relationsihps (Oliver and Faul 2018); institutional analysis to study the structures and rules that shape evidence use (Parkhurst, Ettelt, and Hawkins 2018); or Science and Technology Studies approaches considering the performative nature of science advice in shaping boundaries of science-policy interaction (Hoppe 2010). We posit that there will likely be other ways to provide useful insights into the study of evidence use for policy which draw on these and other novel conceptual, theoretical or methodological approaches. This panel will thus aim to invite scholars who are trying to push the boundaries of knowledge around evidence use in one or more ways, informed by broader concepts and theories, or by applying new methods to the questions. The panel will ultimately enable a discussion between scholars interested in this area to think about which approaches, theories, or methods are helpful for which questions in the realm of understating evidence use in public policymaking. References: Cairney, Paul. 2016. The politics of evidence-based policymaking. London: Palgrave Pivot. Hoppe, Robert. 2010. "From “knowledge use” towards “boundary work”: sketch of an emerging new agenda for inquiry into science-policy interaction." In Knowledge democracy. Consequences for science, politics and media, edited by Roel in t Veld, 169-186. Heidelberg: Springer. Oliver, Kathryn, and Moira V Faul. 2018. "Networks and network analysis in evidence, policy and practice." Evidence & Policy: A Journal of Research, Debate and Practice no. 14 (3):369-379. Parkhurst, Justin. 2017. The politics of evidence: from evidence based policy to the good governance of evidence. Abingdon: Routledge. Parkhurst, Justin, Stefanie Ettelt, and Benjamin Hawkins, eds. 2018. Evidence use in health policy making: an international public policy perspective. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan. Parkhurst, Justin O. 2012. "Framing, ideology and evidence: Uganda’s HIV success and the development of PEPFAR’s ‘ABC’ policy for HIV prevention." Evidence and Policy no. 8 (1):19-38. Smith, Katherine. 2013. Beyond evidence based policy in public health: The interplay of ideas. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P12. Evaluating Performance-based Financing in Health
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Nazar
M. Davidson
A. Nandi
ABSTRACT

Performance-based financing (PBF) continues to grow in popularity as a method to finance health care systems and development aid projects. Both the World Bank and World Health Organization offer guidance on designing and implementing PBF programs, and the World Bank-managed Health Results Innovation Trust Fund has committed US$385.6 million to results-based financing programs, in addition to US$2 billion in loan financing.[i] Performance-based financing is a term for supply-side results-based financing: “a form of incentive where health providers are, at least partially, funded on the basis of their performance to meet targets or undertake specific actions.”[ii] Proponents argue that PBF can achieve fast improvements in service coverage and efficiency, and some reviews suggest that overall this is the case.[iii] However, the quality of evidence is still weak.[iv] Few studies of PBF health programs have rigorously evaluated impacts on health and equity outcomes for affected populations. Significant research gaps exist: what are the impacts of PBF on aspects of health care quality that are difficult to measure with short-term quantitative indicators? What perverse incentives can be created by PBF schemes and how can they be monitored and mitigated? How does PBF measure up compared to other health care improvement measures also associated with PBF, such as increased funding, training and/or flexibility for providers? What is the evidence for the long-term effects of PBF in health programs?[v] A wider question that may also be informed by population-level impact evaluation is how PBF programs are interacting with efforts to implement universal health coverage in developing countries.[vi] Research Question: · How can the effectiveness of performance-based financing models for health outcomes be evaluated? Objectives: · Bring together contributions from researchers who have or are carrying out evaluations of the health outcomes of PBF programs in the health sector, in developing or high-income countries, using quantitative, qualitative or mixed methods. · Provide a forum to discuss work in progress in this area and proposals for future research directions · Establish where data collection needs to be improved to make impact evaluation possible · Overall, develop consensus on the quality of evaluation still needed in the area of PBF and on action needed from program implementers to facilitate rigorous evaluation [i] RBF Health. (2014) “Mission.” https://www.rbfhealth.org/mission[ii] World Health Organization. (2018). “Performance-based Financing.” http://www.who.int/health_financing/topics/performance-based-financing/en/[iii] Suthar et al. “Performance-based financing for improving HIV/AIDS service delivery: a systematic review.” BMC Health Services Research (2017) 17:6; Grittner A. “Results-based financing: Evidence from performance-based financing in the health sector.” German Development Institute discussion paper, June 2013. [iv] Turcotte-Tremblay et al. “Does performance-based financing increase value for money in low- and middle- income countries? A systematic review.” Health Economics Review (2016) 6:30; Grittner A. “Results-based financing: Evidence from performance-based financing in the health sector.” German Development Institute discussion paper, June 2013. [v] Grittner A. “Results-based financing: Evidence from performance-based financing in the health sector.” German Development Institute discussion paper, June 2013. [vi] Soucat et al. “Pay-for-Performance Debate: Not Seeing the Forest for the Trees.” Health Systems & Reform, 3:2, 74-79.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P13. Comparative perspectives on energy and adaptation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Jegen
ABSTRACT

This panel seeks to stimulate discussion on adaptation policy research by addressing and updating epistemological and methodological issues surrounding adaptation policy effectiveness. How do we know we are producing effective adaptation policy? What are the risks that adaptation initiatives produce promising policy outputs but which fail to translate into effective policy outcomes? Significantly, this panel is co-chaired by political scientists as well as climate science researchers at Ouranos, a consortium on regional climatology and adaptation based in Montreal, who are particularly interested in bringing together research addressing adaptation policy from a science-policy nexus perspective. The issue of adaptation policy effectiveness looms large. Despite rising on the climate change political agenda, adaptation policy research continues to struggle with what adaptation is, how it can be measured and hence insights into how adaptation can be scaled-up—referred to as the “dependent variable problem” (Dupuis and Biesbroek, 2013; Howlett and Cashore, 2009; Purdon and Thornton, In Press). While the adaptation literature has developed important analytical tools for understanding different facets of adaptation—including concepts such as sensitivity, adaptive capacity/resilience and vulnerability (Burton et al., 2002; Holling, 1973; Keim, 2008)—daunting questions emerge about what this means in practical terms of preparing for future climate change. Without improving our understanding about constitutes adaptation, it is difficult to differentiate effective adaptation initiatives from those that are maladaptation or merely greenwashing (Ayers and Dodman, 2010). Almost ten years ago, Dessai et al. (2009) argued, however, that an exclusive focus on climate modeling was flawed and urged a focus on developing adaptation policy in the face of deep uncertainty and a lack of predictive power. Arguably, the current consensus is that a focus on policy outputs is a more promising research strategy than a focus on policy outcomes (Bernstein and Cashore, 2012; Biesbroek et al., 2018). For example, in a widely used definition, adaptation is described as “[t]he process leading to the production of outputs in forms of activities and decisions taken by purposeful public and private actors at different administrative levels and in different sectors, which deals intentionally with climate change impacts, and whose outcomes attempt to substantially impact actor groups, sectors, or geographical areas that are vulnerable to climate change” (Dupuis and Biesbroek, 2013: 1480, emphasis added). Yet sophisticated climate science modeling efforts at various scales might be expected to inform the allocation of resources and planning for adaptation, especially as modeling capacity improves (Hertel and Lobell, 2014; Kahil et al., 2015). Research organizations such as Ouranos as well as CGIAR have pioneered such research in adaptation and food security (Hannart and Naveau, 2018; Mapfumo et al., 2017; Nelson et al., 2009; Thornton et al., 2018). New organizational forms such as “boundary organizations” also attempt to bring together scientists and policy-makers in order to improve the exchange of information, policy learning and decision-making processes (Lemos et al., 2014; O'Mahony and Bechky, 2008). What impact might recent developments in public policy, organizational management and climate science have for the prospect of crafting more effective adaptation policy?

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P14. Public Policy and its Impact on the Health-related Sustainable Development Goals: Enactment, Enforcement, Effectiveness, and Equity
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Nandi
ABSTRACT

Public policies feature prominently as potential solutions to and the “means of implementation” for achieving the health-related Sustainable Development Goals. As the former Secretary General Ban Ki-moon remarked, “With the right policies, adequate and fairly distributed funding, and a relentless resolve to deliver to those who need it most – we can and will make a life-changing difference for current and future generations.” But, which policies are the “right” policies? Public policies are constantly evolving, both within and across countries, and the rigorous evaluation of policy reforms can generate causal evidence on the effect of a particular program or policy and can help assess if the intervention was effective (or not). As evidence builds incrementally, we can synthesize findings and generate timely and actionable evidence for improving population health and mitigating health inequalities. Major gaps exist, however, in our understanding of how public policy impacts population health and health inequality. First, there are critical data gaps, in terms of the legislative reforms that have been recently enacted, the enforcement of these reforms, and the health outcomes plausibly affected. Second, we often lack information on the effectiveness of different policy interventions, or “natural experiments”, particularly those implemented at scale (e.g., nationally). Recent growth in the application of quasi-experimental methods for impact evaluation, coupled with qualitative methods for monitoring and evaluation, could enhance our understanding of the consequences of specific policy reforms in terms of their health effects, as well as their influence on gender and social inequalities in health. Third, impact evaluation of public policies remains a black box, and we frequently lack information on specific mechanisms of action. Fourth, the cost-effectiveness of distinct policy reforms is usually unknown, and this information could inform evidence-based policymaking. The objective of this panel is to identify solutions for addressing these gaps.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P15. Policy Evaluation and Policy Process Studies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Vecchi
H. Kudo
B. Dente
ABSTRACT

Following the debate developed in Singapore 2017, the objective of the panel is to develop stronger relations between evaluation research and public policy analysis (Geva-May and Pal; Weiss; Vedung; Peters). The aim is to help evaluation researches in taking advantage from the studies of the policy process to improve their use by decision-makers. In the last decades, evaluation scholars devoted strong emphasis and efforts in the debate about methodologies; the discussions concerning qualitative and quantitative approaches appear now passed, with efforts to deal with the complexity of policies using mixed methods. In any case, the policy evaluation literature – both oriented to policy making and to knowledge development - seems to lack, often, systematic connections and exchanges with the researches of the different policy analysis fields; for example, the studies devoted to the analysis of policy learning, policy change, policy design and instruments, and policy implementation. With the aim to develop a fruitful integration between these two sides, the panel wants to deeper themes that can be eventually discussed in different sessions. In particular, the objective is to analyze a) the connection between evaluation researches and policy learning, analyzing the relation among experts and decision-makers; b) the progress of the debate on evidence-based policy making; c) the use of big data in evaluation researches.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DESIGN, POLICY ANALYSIS, EXPERTISE AND EVALUATION
P01. Narrative Policy Discourse
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Miller
J. Dodge
ABSTRACT

Why is narrative analysis important in the study of public policy? One good answer is that policy goals are contestable and the facts of the matter are contestable. Narrative analysis can reveal schisms, competing world views, and pluralistic competition in policy discourse. This panel seeks to highlight the dynamics of narrative struggle for meaning capture in policy discourse. Alternatively, in what conditions do narratives not compete for dominance? -- possibly in situations where facts are stable and goals are widely shared, or in authoritarian regimes unaccustomed to pluralistic democracy.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P02. Making Sense of Complex Policy Worlds Using Interpretive Methods
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Brown
M. Orsini
W. Sarah
ABSTRACT

There is increasing recognition that policy institutions are complex and studying structure and culture on their own is not enough – scholars need to understand the totality of the ‘policy world’ within which agents operate. The concept of a policy world draws on Shore and Wright (2011) who saw policies as having complex ‘social lives’ and ‘agency’, both shaped by interactions with actors and agents as well as shaping them (3). It also draws on Glynos and Howarth (2007) who see policies enacted within a policy regime as well as within an established system of social and political practices. As such, policy worlds are at heart radically contingent and open up ambiguous spaces in which actors and agents compete for influence. Mainstream scientific methods are often reductionist, subordinating real-world complexity. If we are to be able to make sense of complex policy worlds, policy analysis needs to embrace the larger context, including the political. Interpretive methods provide the means required to delve into the complex, mediated and ambiguous realities within which policies are developed and implemented. Interpretivist scholars are interested in the practical ways that policy practitioners recognise and manage the complexity that confronts them. As such, much interpretive analysis concentrates on close, micro-level interactions and contextualised self-interpretations. The challenge is to scale up established interpretive methodologies to make sense of ‘policy worlds’ in ways that consider the complexities at a larger scope of policy analysis, but which still express the variety of conflicting interpretations of actors. References: Glynos, Jason, and David R. Howarth. 2007. Logics of critical explanation in social and political theory. Vol. 26. New York, NY: Routledge. Shore, Cris, and Susan Wright. 2011. "Conceptualising Policy: Technologies of Governance and the Politics of Visibility." In Policy worlds: anthropology and the analysis of contemporary power, edited by Cris Shore, Susan Wright and Davide Però, 1-25. New York: Berghahn Books.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P03. Climate Change and the Future of Democracy I
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
R. Boullosa
ABSTRACT

Climate change raises massive challenges not only to environmental policy and law but also to the democratic process in which such policy and law are enacted and implemented. These challenges can be divided into several groups in two dimensions. One dimension is a spatial unit of political community: we can distinguish between national, regional, and global levels. The other concerns types of climate policy, the most relevant one among which is a distinction between mitigation and adaptation. These two dimensions help us to understand and assess the burgeoning literature on democracy in the context of climate change. In the past three decades, many authors have emphasized the significance of citizens’ deliberation on this problem and participation in their society’s political processes in attempting to reduce various forms of environmental degradation including climate change. One feature of these authors’ approach is thus to largely focus on the national level of democratic decision making. Yet climate change is obviously a global problem in that no one on the globe can circumvent its adverse impacts, and so we should not dismiss global or regional level of decision making. Another feature of the current literature is to concentrate on mitigation, reflecting the mitigation-oriented tendency of conventional climate policies. Despite numerous efforts of mitigation made by international community and some societies therein, however, greenhouse gas emissions have been so far steadily increasing rather than declining. Also, it is very uncertain, to say the least, whether the emissions will be effectively reduced in the near future. Therefore, we need to consider not merely mitigation policy but also adaptation policy. Still other problem with the existing literature is that researchers have paid scant attention to the question of how citizens’ collective deliberation and decision can deal with the long-term character of climate change. Given the undeniable fact that it is difficult, if not impossible, for many of us to seriously concern about the wellbeing of remote future generations who will come into existence long after we die, it is an immense challenge to design democratic processes in which citizens, their representatives, and experts could adequately address temporally far-reaching environmental problems such as climate change. Keeping these gaps in the literature in mind, this panel aims to address two groups of research questions. First, what shape would democratic processes catering to the need for effective mitigation make, given predictable long-term impacts of climate change? What role could citizens and experts play in such processes? How would global, regional, and national levels of democracy interface with one another? Second, if the current attempts of mitigation did not successfully stabilize the earth temperature, what political process could we design to adapt to dangerous climate change? Would we have a new, innovative, and active form of democracy? Or, would we be forced to compromise democracy for the sake of human survival and security?

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P04. Post-Truth and Alternative Facts: What Role for Critical Policy Research?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
F. Fischer
D. Torgerson
ABSTRACT

Post-truth and “Alternative facts” have become a noticeable feature of politics and public policy. Scientists have stepped out in the March for Science to assert that alternative facts have no place in science. Scholars have sought to understand whether alternative facts influence public opinion and in what ways. Critical Policy Studies can contribute by asking a different set of questions about truth and alternative facts and the role that they play in politics and public policy debates. Namely: what do alternative facts do? Do post-truth politics affect the relation between knowledge and power and if so, how? How do alternative facts shape policy discussions and ultimately policy formulation? Critical and deliberative policy scholars have long challenged empiricist and technocratic assumptions that policy analysis should strive to separate “facts” from values, ideas and meaning in order to provide politics with an allegedly objective, solid and neutral knowledge base. Post-truth politics challenges interpretive researchers to become clearer on how and why facts matter, even as they continue to challenge these mainstream assumptions. For instance, one interesting commentary on Donald Trump’s post-truth politics asserts that if we focus on what is true versus what is not true we will miss the point. That is so because the use of alternative facts reveals a much deeper problematic: alternative facts are about claiming the authority to determine what is truth and what is reality, and especially troubling, regardless of any connection to verifiable evidence or experience. What are the chances of and the challenges for interpretive, pragmatist and deliberative approaches in policy analysis concerning these developments?

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P05. Foundational Works in Public Policy Studies: Harold D. Lasswell
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Seguin
N. Turnbull
G. Lachapelle
ABSTRACT

Harold D. Lasswell is a founding scholar of public policy studies. The programme of policy sciences he developed in the 1940s and 1950s is widely regarded as the founding act of the field. The seven-stage policy process he conceptualized in 1956 subsequently led to a number of models, with the five-stage policy cycle still in use today in spite of successive waves of criticism. His lifelong commitment to interdisciplinarity has become a major concern in contemporary political science. And recently, his work even found echoes in unexpected quarters such as Science & Technology Studies. However, Lasswell’s work has influenced quite different trajectories in policy studies and the legacy of his thought is unclear. On the one hand, it is analytical in important respects, for example in the stages model of the policy process and the scientific conception of problem solving in public policymaking. But on the other hand, critical policy analysts have drawn on Lasswell’s concern for human values and his origins in American pragmatist philosophy to build upon his ideas to develop a more process-oriented, interpretive vision of policymaking that is opposed to positivist and analytical frameworks in policy theory. Given these alternative uses of Lasswell’s thought, and set in the larger context of the retreat from government to governance, this is a good time to evaluate the work of this founding scholar in order to determine the relevance of his ideas and to reflect upon the trajectory of the policy sciences. The aim of the panel is to revisit Lasswell in order to deepen our understanding of his work and testify to its enduring influence, even for those who seek to distance themselves from his approach(es). More specifically, our goals are to: Situate his work in the historical context of pragmatism and behavioralism in the United States. Re-examine or critically re-evaluate his key works and studies. Assess which aspects of his work remain relevant for the study of contemporary political phenomena. Further develop his ideas for the theory and practice of public policy, for instance the use of the hard sciences in policy analysis, the problem orientation, and the divide between academia and policy practice. Apply his categories and insights in studies in many subfields of political science such as public policy studies, policy sciences, political power, political communication and propaganda, political psychology, and political theory.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P06. Think Tank Discourse and Political Change: Strategies, Identities, and Shifting Political Tides
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Landry
M. Gonzalez Hernando
ABSTRACT

Scholarly work on think tanks – or policy institutes – has integrated important insights from the argumentative turn literature (e.g. Fischer 1991, 1993). Research on think tanks has also advanced our understanding of their social embeddedness (e.g. Medvetz 2012; Stone 2007), their connections to specific allies (e.g. Plehwe 2014), and the part they play in discourse coalitions and other policy formations (e.g. Pautz 2012; Plehwe 2017). Drawing on these ideas, current scholarship has also analyzed how think tanks react discursively to events that challenge dominant policy paradigms (Hernando, Pautz, and Stone 2018). We believe that this integration of research on think tanks, networks, discourse production, and policy environments is encouraging and should be sustained. It should also be harnessed to better understand how think tanks with different interests, allies, and political identities adapt to the reconfiguration of national and transnational political landscapes. Conceivably, these changes may move debates away from traditional think tank concerns (e.g. economic policy, international relations) towards new priorities (e.g. multicultural politics, migration policy) and reorganize the fault lines by which think tanks identify political allies and potential funders. Moreover, the reliance of think tanks on the political environment may go beyond policy preferences and extend to changes in the authority of expert discourse in the public sphere as well as to the opportunities and constraints these changes can entail (cf. Drezner 2017). As think tanks become involved in contentious or polarized political debates, they can gain new allies but risk devaluating their own credibility (Rich 2004). Likewise, the general value attributed to policy expertise can shape incentives for developing analytical capabilities and choosing dissemination strategies. A better understanding of how think tanks from the left, right, and center contribute to shifting political realities and navigate their consequences (e.g. through agenda setting, argumentation, network building, workshopping, or dissemination) will allow us to gleam at how strategies and political identities mediate think tank behavior within dynamic policy environments. Drezner, Daniel W. 2017. The ideas industry. New York: Oxford University Press. Fischer, Frank. 1991. “American Think Tanks: Policy Elites and the Politicization of Expertise.” Governance 4(3): 332–353. Fischer, Frank. 1993. “Policy Discourse and the Politics of Washington Think Tanks.” In The Argumentative turn in policy analysis and planning, eds. Frank Fischer and John Forester. Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press, p. 21–42. Hernando, Marcos Gonzalez, Hartwig Pautz, and Diane Stone. 2018. “Think tanks in ‘hard times’ – the Global Financial Crisis and economic advice.” Policy and Society 37(2): 125–139. Medvetz, Thomas. 2012. Think tanks in America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Pautz, Hartwig. 2012. Think tanks, social democracy and social policy. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire; New York: Palgrave Macmillan. Plehwe, Dieter. 2017. “The Politics of Policy Think-Tanks: organizing expertise, legitimacy and counter-expertise in policy networks.” In Handbook of critical policy studies, eds. Frank Fischer et al. Cheltenham; Northampton: Edward Elgar Publishing, p. 358–379. Plehwe, Dieter. 2014. “Think tank networks and the knowledge–interest nexus: the case of climate change.” Critical Policy Studies 8(1): 101–115. Rich, Andrew. 2004. Think tanks, public policy, and the politics of expertise. Cambridge; New York: Cambridge University Press. Stone, Diane. 2007. “Recycling bins, garbage cans or think tanks? Three myths regarding policy analysis institutes.” Public Administration 85(2): 259–278.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P07. Policy Narratives and Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Shanahan
M. Jones
T. Birkland
ABSTRACT

The import of the study of narratives rests on the idea that we are homo narrans, who not only use but need narrative to make meaning of the world around us. Narratives both reflect and shape who we are. While the study of narratives reaches back for centuries, the systematic study of policy narratives is relatively new. As such, the power of policy narratives is a phenomenon in policy process and policy analysis research that is growing in popularity. From the 1990s to now, policy narrative scholars have been intrigued with understanding the role of policy narratives at all points in the policy process. The arc of these scholarly works have engendered a range of epistemological approaches, from interpretive and contextually based (e.g., discursive politics) to the more quantitatively oriented (e.g., Narrative Policy Framework). In turn, the accompanying assortment of narrative methodologies has been used in the analysis of a broad array of substantive public policies at multiple scales (micro, meso, macro) and in a variety of contexts. This diversity of approaches and policy domains has produced conceptions of policy narratives that invoke varied theoretical and philosophical traditions as well as different operational protocols. In short, there is a plethora of approaches to the study of policy narratives, but we are all working on understanding the power of narratives in the policy process. The main objective of the Policy Narratives and Public Policy panel is to have papers that clearly articulate a theoretical framework, their narrative data, and the analytical procedures (qualitative, quantitative, mixed). The goal is to gather together scholarly works that are centered on how narratives shape public policy design, processes, and outputs, across different policy contexts. All methodologies and approaches are welcome as well as are all substantive policy foci.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P08. Critical Urban Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Joy
R. Vogel
ABSTRACT

There is a serious gap between the policy problems faced by 21st century cities and their proposed solutions, which are often small-scale, siloed and unsustainable. Paradoxically, as cities face the pressures of poverty, unemployment, social and physical infrastructure degradation, and pollution, they are being lauded by other scales of government for their resilience and innovation in solving wicked policy problems. Critical urban theory and study, situated in the fields of urban geography and politics and exemplified in the seminal texts Cities for People, Not for Profit: Critical Urban Theory and the Right to the City (Brenner et al, 2012) and Critical Urban Studies: New Directions (Davies and Imbroscio, 2010) highlight the failures and inadequacies of neoliberal urban policy and austerity programs characteristic of advanced capitalism. But what is to be done about it? While there may be instances of progressive policy experiments as well as cases of an emerging politics, on the whole, cities today lack progressive politics, visions, agendas, revenue sources, governance processes, implementation protocols, and enforcement mechanisms to address growing social, political, and economic problems. The tension between problems, solutions, and expectations in status quo urban policy making begs the question: is there a progressive policy alternative for cities that promotes equity, democracy, sustainability, and justice? It is now time for scholars to move beyond critiques of neoliberalism to offer a better future for those who live and work in the city. The objective of this panel on Critical Urban Policy is to examine how policy theory and research can support this agenda. We anticipate that the panel will explore, through both conceptual and empirical analyses, how policy theory and research can contribute insight on: the values and principles that define progressive urban policy; the tactics progressive leadership, movements, and coalitions can use to bring progressive alternatives onto the policy agenda; the design of progressive policy visions, agendas, and action plans; the institutional arrangements required to implement, anchor and nurture a progressive city; and how we might evaluate progressive city policy and engage in ongoing learning and critique.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P09. Emotions, Narratives and Policy Change
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Burlone
A. Mevellec
ABSTRACT

This panel builds on the recent work stemming from the emotional turn that considers emotions as a promising angle of analysis for the renewal of policy research. Although emotions are not totally absent from the policy analysis classics, they are commonly understood as a limit to individual rationality. Adopting a different standpoint, our panel postulates that emotions (both positive and negative ones) are rather integral to rationality and, by extension, are agents of policy change. Moreover, emotions are embedded in policy discourses. If emotions play this central role in policy making, how can they then be captured in policy research? This panel proposes that narrative analysis is well equipped to do so because of its attention to the structure and content of language, the latter being one vehicle for the expression of emotions. If some policy scholars have promoted policy narratives as keys to understand the policy process, only a few have studied their emotional structure, although latent in any policy narrative. On the other hand, emotion studies, an expanding research field across social sciences, have not paid great attention to public policy processes. This panel aims at contributing to both literature by questioning the role of emotions for policy analysis methodologically, theoretically and empirically. Our panel is guided by the following research questions: 1) From a methodological perspective, how can narrative analysis reveal the role of emotions (how to locate emotions from the lexical sources? How to document emotions? How to classify emotions?)? 2) From a theoretical perspective, how can a focus on emotions complement theoretical approaches to public policy (are emotions direct or indirect influences of problems framing or are they frames themselves? What influence do emotions have on other policy processes such as individual or collective behaviors, information processing or solution developments?)? 3) From an empirical perspective, how do emotions participate in the transformation of public policy (what kinds of emotions are involved? What spectra do they cover? How and by whom do they manifest themselves?)? By taking stock of the role of emotions for policy analysis, this panel will expand our understanding of the different forces at work in the policy process and explore how turning to the emotional structure of policy discourses can enriched narrative analysis itself. By doing so, this panel provides an opportunity to assess the relevance of the emotional turn for policy studies.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P10. War On Expertise – War On Culture: Understanding the Expert-Culture Boundary in Current Policy Controversies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
K. Cada
A. Durnová
E. Hejzlarová
ABSTRACT

We live in times in that being in a rage with expertise is a legitimate political stance (Higgins 2016). While expertise has been an inherent part of modern policymaking, it has recently raised waves of criticism because of ideological biases, rent-seeking behavior or contradictions between science as theory and science as practice. The June 2016 Brexit vote was repeatedly cited as an illustration of the dichotomy between ‘the people’ versus ‘experts’. The underlying argument of that dichotomy was that knowledge is placed in the hand of experts who should or need to, persuade the public. Other political events have been evaluated through the perspective of a public that seems get in the way of expert’s knowledge. The analysis of Donald Trump’s victory reflected this trend as it was attributed to his image as the anti-expertise, anti-establishment guy among the candidates.However, Cramer (2016) points out that people’s distrust to experts is embedded in broader contours of a clash between proponents of liberal cosmopolitanism and defenders of socially conservative values and that we can understand these trends as “a retro reaction by once-predominant sectors of the population to progressive value change” (as argue Inglehart and Norris 2016). Liberal democratic political order has been indeed criticized for having induced divides and political controversies in modern societies (Boltanski and Chiapello 2005, Brown 2015, Hochschild 2016, Seymour 2014). For some, the liberal values realize a long-held dream: they can determine the course of their lives, they can live their sexual identity freely, and they can alter political decisions through protest. For others, these values are the twilight of civilization, because they can no longer understand its social structure: they want clear identities restored, with distinct hierarchies enabling them to follow socially and culturally prescribed patterns. We argue that policy expertise needs to be seen as part of these culture wars and suggest this panel to address policy controversies in their cultural context, to examine roles of moral values and expertise and to study lessons which can be drawn from these controversies for policy studies. We intend to explore links between culture and policy expertise which is very often overlooked in traditional policy analysis (with exception Douglas and Wildavsky 1983, Fischer 2009 or Schram 2012). Policy expertise on topics such as family, sexuality, migration, or climate change steps in the terrain of everyday moralities, frustrations, desires, and emotions. It prompts us to reconsider the position of policy expertise within the current deliberative systems (see Parkinson, Mansbridge 2012), the way how policy expertise is communicated and epistemic authority of policy expertise itself. Echoing critical policy studies, the panel advances an interpretive understanding of ‘culture’; as a dynamic site of meanings, narratives, and discursive practices that are negotiated to legitimize or abandon particular values and beliefs in a society. The panel aims to develop a deeper understanding of narratives, meanings, and discursive practices, through that citizens articulate the various contestations in diverse policy fields such as education, sexuality, family, migration, ethnicity, health or environmental policies. At the same time, the panel wants to use these examples to further conceptualize ‘culture war’ and to further the understanding of the culture-expertise boundary. References: Cramer, Katherine J. 2016. The Politics of Resentment: Rural Consciousness in Wisconsin and the Rise of Scott Walker. Chicago, London: The University of Chicago Press. Inglehart, Ronald, & Norris, Pippa 2016. Trump, Brexit, and the rise of populism: Economic have-nots and cultural backlash. HKS Faculty Research Working Paper Series. Boltanski, Luc, and Eve Chiapello. 2005. "The new spirit of capitalism." International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society 18 (3-4):161-188.Brown, Wendy. 2015. Undoing the demos: Neoliberalism's stealth revolution: MIT Press.Douglas, M., Wildavsky, A. 1983. Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technological and Environmental Dangers. Berkeley, Los Angeles: University California Press. Fischer, F. 2009. Democracy and Expertise: Reorienting Policy Inquiry. Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press. Higgins, Kathleen. 2016. "Post-truth: a guide for the perplexed." Nature 540 (7631):9-9. Hochschild, Arlie Russell. 2016. Strangers in their own land: Anger and mourning on the American right: New Press, The.Parkinson, John & Mansbridge, Jane. 2012. Deliberative Systems: Deliberative Democracy at the Large Scale. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Seymour, Richard. 2014. "Against austerity." University of Chicago Press Economics Books.Schram, S. F. 2012. The Deep Semiotic Structure of Deservingness: Discourse and Identity in Welfare Policy. In Fischer, F., Gottweis, H. (Eds.): The Argumentative Turn Revisited: Public Policy as Communicative Practice. Durham, London: Duke University Press.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P12. Roundtable - The Critical Lasswell? Critical Policy Studies and Lasswell’s Policy Sciences
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Seguin
ABSTRACT

Although Harold D. Lasswell is widely recognized as having been the chief advocate for a policy focus in the social sciences, the significance of his ‘policy sciences’ proposal remains controversial. Are the policy sciences just an arsenal of technocratic decision techniques based in systems analysis and game theory? Does Lasswell, as often alleged, simply usher us into a ‘brave new world of scientism’? Or does he, to the contrary, provide the basis for ‘critical policy science’? What, in any case, do we make of the fact that Lasswell’s famously ‘mystifying intellectual history’ includes a focus on key figures in the emergence of critical inquiry? Should we, furthermore, take seriously his explicit claim that the policy sciences carry a commitment to democracy? Lasswell has been portrayed as promoting an ‘elitist’ conception of democracy that merely upholds the status quo of liberal democracy. Yet, what of notes in his work supporting not only democratic government, but also the democratization of society? Are there indications of a more participatory approach? Could Lasswell even be counted as a forerunner of deliberative democracy? Questioning Lasswell’s policy sciences along such lines, this roundtable will focus particularly on the import of his approach for critical policy studies. Does he offer no more than a cautionary tale of what is to be avoided? Or does Lasswell’s approach to policy inquiry contain features that can help to clarify the purpose and agenda of critical policy studies and, perhaps, even contribute to its development? Chair: Eve Seguin, Université du Québec à Montréal, Canada. Participants: Rosana Boullosa, Universidade de Brasília, Brazil. ‘The concept of “public” in the policy orientation: a critical look at Dewey's influence on Lasswell.’ Jennifer Dodge, State University of New York at Albany, USA. ‘Anticipating the future in the context of oppression.’ Douglas Torgerson, Trent University, Canada. ‘“Critical policy science”: method and politics.’ Philippe Zittoun, Université de Lyon, France. ‘The two Lasswells.’

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P14. Critical Policy Studies and the Politics of Oppression
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Dodge
K. Braun
ABSTRACT

A foundational project of critical policy studies is to examine and challenge dominant public policy narratives, discourses, and stories, aiming to uncover sources of oppression and offer alternative conceptualizations of policy and policy processes that might create liberation and freedom. Organized by the Co-Editors of Critical Policy Studies, the objective of this panel is to contribute to understanding current shifts toward the politics of oppression and exclusion seen in public policy in many parts of the world today. In India, for instance, the government has been cracking down on university researchers who practice dissent. In the US, the Trump administration has implemented draconian policies toward immigrants, separating families at the border many of whom have yet to be reunited. Other examples abound. We invite empirical articles examining contemporary forms of oppression and exclusion exercised through public policy and/or on struggles against them, as well as theoretical and methodological articles about different approaches to critical policy studies that illuminate these processes. Recently, critical approaches that have emphasized the significance of struggles over meaning, values and the construction of identities and differences have come under suspicion of having, willingly or unwillingly, neglected “hard” macro-social cleavages, socio-economic power relations and/or objective problems and thereby contributed to the rise of oppressive and exclusionary politics.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P15. Varieties of Behavioural Public Policy: Modes, Manifestations and Political Consequences of a Global Discourse
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Strassheim
ABSTRACT

Over the past decade behavioural public policy has spread inter- and transnationally. The OECD concluded that behavioural insights in public policy seem to ‘have taken root in many ways across many countries around the world and across a wide range of sectors and policy areas’. The World Bank, the European Commission and the United Nations are developing behavioural interventions in a wide variety of policy areas. While the US, the UK and Singapore are among the forerunners, behavioural public policies can nowadays be found across Western Europe, Central America, Asia, Africa and the Middle East. Behavioural public policy includes all means and modes of public policy aiming at influencing individual or collective behaviour by using insights from behavioural economics, behavioural sciences, psychology or neurosciences. This entanglement of scientific and political claims, of analysing and governing behaviour is a common feature of all forms of behavioural public policy. In behavioural public policy, expertise has become an essential resource for governing as it is supposed to establish and provide both the scientific evidence and political legitimacy for the behavioural change agenda. Beyond this common denominator, however, the landscape of behavioural public policy is extremely diverse. The spectrum of policy instruments is large, including efforts to reduce the cognitive burden on citizens, education programmes for decisions under risks, techniques of social norms marketing, and behaviourally informed regulations. Today, many behavioural designs are commonplace: the rearrangement of food in cafeterias; graphic warnings on cigarette packages; the fly in the urinal – these and other interventions have become part of everyday life. The banality of some of these interventions suggests that the discourse on behavioural public policy, its institutional and material manifestations are already more widespread than it might seem. Despite an ever-growing amount of literature, however, there are only few systematic studies on the discursive and institutional modes of behavioural public policy across jurisdictions and policy areas, the causes for its inter- and transnational spread as well as its influence and political implications. This panel aims at bringing together empirically and conceptually rich studies focusing mainly - but not exclusively - on the following questions: How can we explain the inter- and transnational variety of behavioural public policy? What are the discursive and institutional mechanisms leading to the proliferation and professionalization of behavioural expertise across countries and policy areas? How can we conceptualize and study the interlinkages between behavioural sciences and public policy? How does the spread of behavioural public policy change the modes of regulation and the mix of public policy instruments? What are the consequences for political discourses on social progress and the relationship between the state and its citizens? The panel is open for papers from different disciplinary backgrounds such as interpretive policy analysis, comparative public policy, administration studies or science & technology studies; comparative studies across countries, levels or policy areas are especially welcome.

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P16. Exploring Nexus Problems: Critical Perspectives on the Problems of Policy Interdependencies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Strassheim
R. Korinek
ABSTRACT

Since the World Economic Forum in 2011 at the latest, the interdependencies between policy fields are perceived as a core challenge for public policy and governance. At the nexus between seemingly unrelated areas such as food, water, energy, and mobility, actors are confronted with multiple interdependencies leading to complex problems of knowledge exchange and coordination. Under the conditions of climate change, decreasing stocks of natural resources or the loss of biodiversity, ‘policy silos’ are opened. Formerly separated departments, policy coalitions, policy procedures or material flows are increasingly interlinked. For some years now, new institutional formats of policy coordination and expertise emerge that bring together administrative authorities, interest groups, think tanks and scientific actors. These new coordinative formats – e.g. participatory foresight procedures, policy assessments, multistakeholder initiatives, and transdisciplinary platforms – aim at addressing the challenges of nexus problems. Yet, their capacity to produce both effective and democratically legitimate knowledge and policies to deal with interdependencies has been questioned. Moreover, some argue that these new coordinative formats are based on very different political, epistemological and ontological understandings of how to cope with nexus problems. In some of these arrangements the very definition of problems and solutions at the nexus is subject to debates and deliberation procedures; they are open to varying or even contradictory concepts, methods and problem-solving strategies. Others combine the rigidity of methodologically ‘sound’ assessments and foresight procedures with the openness of a public dialogue on alternative policy pathways. In even more exclusive arrangements, the epistemic frame is highly focused on specific causal models and methods such as randomized controlled trials (RCTs) while the range of participants is limited to experts and specialists. It seems that the landscape of networks and arrangements at the nexus has become extremely diverse. This panel aims at bringing current research on policy interdependencies into dialogue with critical perspectives on both nexus problems and nexus arrangements. We welcome papers from different conceptual angles and methodological backgrounds focusing mainly (but not exclusively) on the following core questions: How can we describe and compare different discourses and discursive logics related to the nexus between policy areas? What are the institutional arrangements and actor constellations addressing nexus challenges? In what ways is policy expertise produced and legitimized at the nexus? How can we conceptualize and study the social and material interlinkages at the nexus? What are the consequences of different modes of nexus coordination for democratic deliberation, participation, responsibility, public acceptance or accountability? What are the methodological implications of nexus problems for public policy research?

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P17. Democratic Experimentation and Public Policies in Latin America: Challenges and Perspectives
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Andion
L. Secchi
R. Lima Moraes
ABSTRACT

This panel seeks to discuss – from a theoretical and empirical point of view – the phenomenon of democratic experimentation (Bohman, 2004, Knight & Johnson, 2007, Ansell, 2012) in Latin American countries, from a critical perspective of public policy research. In Latin American region there is a visible tradition in studies and practices on public policies from new perspectives and experimentations. These tradition puts light in "bottom-up" policy design processes, democratic participation and the influence of various actors in the design and implementation of public policy (Avritzer, 2012; Almeida, Cayres e Tatagiba, 2015; Borba e Lucchman, 2017; Moraes e Andion, 2018). After the re-democratization wave in Latin America countries, many of the constitutional and regulatory frameworks encourage the promotion of the design, formulation and implementation of public policies with civil society agents, thereby strengthening systems of deliberative democracy. However, we have recently seen the potential return of more authoritarian regimes of government, with antidemocratic discourses and refractory to participation. In this new scenario, there is the need and urgency to discuss and reconsider the processes of democratic experimentation in Latin America and its relationship with public policies. This panel thus aims to broaden the understanding of the scope and limits of new democratic experiments to advance and create new agendas in the debate of public policies in Latin America. In particular, we are interested in exploring new theoretical-analytical perspectives inaugurated by the "argumentative turn" (Fischer, 2012) that rely on post-positivist approaches and develop argumentative, critical, constructivist, or pragmatist analyzes of public policies (Shields, 2008; Fischer, 2012; Secchi, 2016). This involves better understanding the relationship between public policy and the political system and examining not only the effects of public policies and programs, but also their presuppositions and processes, from a bottom-up logic. The objective of this panel is also to stimulate new approaches aimed at overcoming the dichotomy between “policy analysis” and “policy studies”, thereby widening the debate in the field of public policy research in Latin America and allowing to look at public policies as “public actions”, that involves several actors beyond government (Lascoumes & Le Galès, 2012; Cefaï, 2017). In this perspective of shared governance (Osborne, 2003) we are interested in discussing more deeply the determinants and effects of the processes of "democratic experimentation" on public policies in Latin American countries, given the present sociohistorical context. It is a question of exploring the scope and limits of public action networks or epistemic communities that are formed around public issues in public arenas in order to reinforce the dynamics of democratic experimentation, public inquiry and participatory governance (Dewey, 1927; Smiley, 1999; Fung & Wright, 2003; Fung, 2006; Cefai, 2017).

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P19. Decolonizing Critical Policy Research: Moving Towards Producing Relevant and Reliable Knowledges
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
B. Ahmed
ABSTRACT

Through prominent social movement work led by Indigenous, Black, subaltern and feminist organising, (and amplified by/documented through social media,) we have come to witness a rich breadth of anti-colonial, and critical public policy analysis that was formerly situated at the margins of policy studies. While the former voices and knowledges have always existed ontologically, policy studies as a disciplinary body did not engage them at the center, dismissing these alternative ontologies, ways of knowing and knowledges. Due to the denial of meaningful methodological engagement with these epistemic and ontological groups, their intersectional locations, as well as their distinct knowledge traditions, the production of both 'relevant' and ‘reliable’ new knowledge in policy studies has suffered. Whereas the production of knowledge about marginalised, racialized and colonised peoples by outsider ‘experts’ and/or using methods which are foreign to them has evidently shown to produce harm and problematic outcomes in much of the literature, such practices still persist. What has to happen to address the former challenge? What changes ought to occur in policy studies research approaches for greater engagement with theories, methodological approaches and voices that span beyond the Eurocentric ones? Which practices may stay, which must change, and what will compel such changes? Taking as a premise that further harm towards racialized, colonised and marginalised peoples globally is unacceptable, this session calls for papers which identify and critically engage with existing challenges with respect to the production of new knowledges in policy studies, when addressing policy research from both critical and anti-colonial methodological lenses. This session calls for papers which highlight research designs / frameworks that can guide policy researchers when creating new knowledges, which serve rather than harm marginalized communities. The session is additionally calling for papers which draw attention to policy research frameworks that are rooted in knowledge traditions that extend beyond the dominant ones. Research Questions for this session are as following: What does decolonising critical policy studies research require? What does undoing harmful dominant practices of knowledge production look like? Which practices have to emerge? Which practices have to discontinue? What are examples of policy research done from a critical and anti-colonial standpoint?

POLICY TOPICS
POLICY DISCOURSE AND CRITICAL POLICY RESEARCH
P01. Developing Dynamic Models for Coexistence and Collaboration
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Park
R. Minhyo Cho
A. Pramusinto
ABSTRACT

Through policy process, it is important to coordinate well and cooperate among policy actors to be successful policy outcome. However it is hard for each policy actor to collaborate each other under complex and competitive environment. But we can find many successful collaboration policy case as well as conflict cases in real world. Many public policies have been made to solve these conflict problems to be better society but these policies also has been raised many new social conflicts in our society. Ostrom (1998) poses the question: “How can contemporary social sciences explain the ubiquitous empirical evidences of effective collective actions in our history and life.” Axelrod (1984) began his well known book by asking when a person will cooperate, rather than act selfishly, in an on going interaction with another person. Many scholars have been studying general theories or models for collaboration. But it is too hard to find general theories or model to fit each countries or policy areas. How do various policy actors cope with and coordinate in conflict situations and do collaborative governance in when faced with organizationally fragmented but highly interrelated policy arenas in each countries with wich context? This panel aims to investigate the various mechanisms, model for collaboration and conflict resolution within several interrelated policy arenas in various countries. We need to explore and develp meso-level model and framework for collaboration and conflict resolution in considering countries contextual factors. From each countries' case studies and comparative studies of collaboration models, we can develop meso-level regional collabortive model and mechanism such as East Aisa Collabortive model, Latin America Collaborative model, and West Eurepean collaborative model. In addition we have change to expolore general collaborative mechanism or framework to collaborative studies.

POLICY TOPICS
INTEREST GROUPS, BUSINESS, NETWORKS AND GOVERNANCE
P03. Political Economy of Natural Resources: Modes of Governance and Local Dynamics
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Chailleux
P. Wokuri
ABSTRACT

Pushing back limitation and critics linked to the intensive exploitation of Nature, most of the States on the planet continuously open new spaces to the exploitation of natural resources based on a consensus on commodities, the renewal of extractive practices, their acceptance and justification (Svampa, 2016; Bebbington, Bury, 2016; Huber, 2009). This trend toward dodging environmental issues with ecological modernization epitomizes the Hotelling’s rule (Hotelling, 1931) about the scarcity rent in the exploitation of non-renewable natural resources: producers of natural resources respond to price incentives to develop new exploration and new exploitation of scarce resources, leading in the case of oil for example to periods of high price followed by sudden drops when new sources are discovered. Jointly, the injunction to energy and ecological transition commits local territories toward landplaning disputes and national states to implement conservative policies to preserve natural resources, plan their exploitation, accommodate various actors and in some case adapt to climate change and ecological crisis. This transition was accompanied with a redefinition of the relevant scales of State intervention (Cowel et al., 2017; Poupeau, 2014; Cacciari, 2015). Politics and policies at different scales have thus a core role in orienting the economy, especially in a context of transition. Those adjustments between contradictory interests call toward a set of questions. 1. Modes of structuration of natural resources governance: varieties of extractivism? Natural resources are subjects of international trades generating huge benefits, but various political theories show national resource curse at the political, economic or social levels. Heavy tendencies display confined processes favoring exploiting companies and politico-economic alliances, described under the vocabulary of Latin-American extractivism (Gudynas, 2009; Bebbington and Bury, 2016; Abraham and Murray, 2015), American iron triangles (Heclo, 1978), Canadian staple theory (Hessing and Howlett, 1996; Howlett, 2008; Fortin and Fournis, 2014), European institutional regime of resources (Varone, Nahrath and Gerber, 2007), or through quiet politics (Culpepper, 2011). Whereas these approaches outline stability dynamics of extraction, we think that a closer look at potential changes processes is needed. These changes could be explained by critical junctures (Acemoglu and Robinson, 2012), policy window (Kingdon, 1984) or political opportunity structures (Kitschelt, 1986). Furthermore, those theories struggle to compare natural resources’ governance styles at the national, regional or sectorial levels. Although researches on the Anthropocene (Bonneuil and Fressoz, 2012), or the Capitalocene (Moore, 2017), underline global destructive dynamics, we can wonder, following Hall and Soskice (2001), about the existence of a variety of extractivism given national and regional characteristics and the modes of structuration and coordination of the natural resources production. Beyond national specificities, this variety of extractivism could be related to a broad range of elements: different forms of political machinery or collective capability from one commodity to another (Mitchell, 2011), different statehoods models (Joppke, 1992) different governing modes (self-governing by authority, by provision or through enabling , Bulkeley and Kern, 2012) or productive models(Boyer and Freyssenet,2000) of extraction The panel wished to open the black box of those modes of structuration to highlight the architecture and the parameters of change and continuity. Do national political styles of extraction exist? Is the variable politics playing a major role in the trajectory of those modes of structuration or a minor role as some Latin American works demonstrated (Gonzales-Espinoza, 2012)? Can we observe articulations between macro regimes of accumulation and sectorial dynamics of extraction? What are the roles of the different actors mobilized? 2. Natural resources local and national policies and politics Political economy called for a focus on political structures of the economy to outline how economic structures are in fact determined by the interplays of various actors in more or less confined arenas. An important piece of literature (Boyer, 2015) stressed the role of the central state in determining economic policies, while other researchers also underlined inter sectorial differences (Jullien and Smith, 2008; 2014). However, the focus on national scales side-lined the particular dynamics of the local scale in the actual determination of situated economic activities. Moreover, those works mostly focused on the structuration of an industry without a specific interest for the context of transition and resources scarcity. Various works on natural resources at the local scale underline the disputes between bigger exploitations and mobilizations to protect the local environment (Bebbington and Bury, 2016). Local territories are at the same time the necessary resources to the exploitation projects and a constraint to their implementation. In that sense, local territories are able to redefine at the same time the meaning, the shape and the content of those projects, calling for a focus on conviction mechanisms of actors and the construction of critical discourses (see Chailleux and Hourcade, forthcoming on local energy policies). In those researches, the role of the local environment and the injunction to transition are presented in great details (Cointe, 2016; Cacciari and Fournier, 2015), but most of time they failed to catch the articulation between the political structures of a given industry and its local implementation. Works in political ecology and geography underlined for the last 15 years the necessity to understand the politics of scale (Marston, 2000; Huber, Emel, 2009; Gorg, 2007), that is the ability of specific actors to build the territorial scale the more supportive of their project. However, the literature on multilevel governance is divided between those supporting the opportunity for dominated actors to gain lever through decentralization of decision (Le Galès, 2003) and others claiming that this is only a new form for the central state to legitimate its action (Brenner, 2004). More emphasis is needed on the power relations around extraction at the local scale to identify rule makers and rule takers (Streeck and Thelen, 2005), the intensity and influence of social movements mobilization (Boudet and McAdam, 2012) or the potential power of weak interests (Kastner, 2017; Trumbull, 2012). The panel wishes to question, on the one hand, the instruments of the “territorialization” (downscaling) of natural resources exploitation projects (how authoritative, participative, evaluative or compensatory procedures work? In what frame and parameters?). We aim to better understand how policymaking shapes the exploitation of natural resources in a given space. On the other hand, the panel wishes to question the impacts of this territorialization on a given industry (what is the role of local history and geography? What is the place of local actors? What degree of mobilization following which criterion? What is the impact of contention? What kind of knowledge is produced, mobilized and legitimized?). We aim there to explain the ability of local actors to translate national/global policies and projects, especially in regard with the injunction of transition. The panel will favor proposals using comparative method in order to underline similarities and differences between local territories, countries, regions and economic sectors. Comparisons between the Global North and South will be particularly welcome. References Abraham, Y.-M. et Murray, D. (2015), Creuser jusqu’où?, Ecosociété Acemoglu, D. and Robinson J.A, (2012). Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity and Poverty, London, Profile Books Bebbington, Bury (2016) Subterranean struggles, University of Texas Press Bonneuil, C. et Fressoz, J.-B. (2013) L’évènement anthropocène, Points Boyer, R., et Freyssenet M.(2000), Les modèles productifs. La Découverte Brenner N., (2004) New State Spaces: Urban Governance and the Rescaling of Statehood, Oxford/New York, Oxford University Press. Bulkeley, H. and Kern, K., (2006). Local Government and the Governing of Climate Change in Germany and the UK, Urban Studies, 43(12), pp. 2237-2259. Cacciari J, Fournier P., 2015, « La "transition énergétique" pour une ancienne commune du charbon. Entre impératif et opportunisme politique » dans Zélem M-C. et Beslay C. Sociologie de l'énergie. Gouvernance et pratiques sociales, Paris, CNRS éditions, 149-156. Cacciari, J. (2014) "L’impératif de « transition énergétique » comme double peine pour un territoire de la production énergétique soumis à reconversion", Vertigo, 14 (3). Cointe, B., 2016, « Le tarif d’achat photovoltaïque comme outil d’innovation territoriale : l’exemple des Fermes de Figeac » [VertigO] La revue électronique en sciences de l’environnement, 16(1). Cowell R. et al. (2017) “Sub-national government and pathways to sustainable energy”, Environment and Planning C, 35(7): 1139-1155 Culpepper, 2011, Quiet politics, Cambridge University Press Fortin, M.-J., Fournis, Y. (2014) « Vers une définition ascendante de l’acceptabilité sociale : les dynamiques territoriales face aux projets énergétiques au Québec », Natures Sciences Sociétés, vol. 22 / 3, p. 231‑239. González-Espinosa, A. (2012). Chapitre 10 / La gauche et la continuité du projet extractiviste. Bolivie, Équateur, Venezuela. Dans O. Dabène, La Gauche en Amérique latine, 1998-2012 (pp. 335-365). Paris: Presses de Sciences Po (P.F.N.S.P.). Gudynas E. (2009) « Diez tesis urgentes sobre el nuevo extractivismo : contextos y demandas bajo el progresismo sudamericano actual », in Jürgen Schludt et al., Extractivismo, política y sociedad, Quito, CAAP/Claes, p. 187-225 Hall et Soskice, 2001, Varieties of capitalism, Oxford University Press Heclo, H. (1978) « Issue network and the executive establishment », in Anthony King. The New American Political System, American Entreprise Institute, Washington DC. Hessing, M. Howlett, M. (1996) Canadian natural resource and environmental policy, UBC Press Hotelling, H. (1931). "The Economics of Exhaustible Resources". J. Political Econ. 39 (2): 137–175. Huber, (2009) Energizing historical materialism: Fossil fuels, space and the capitalist mode of production. Geoforum 40(1): 105-115. Huber, Emel, 2009, « Fixed minerals, scalar politics: the weight of scale in conflicts over the `1872 Mining Law' in the United States”, Environment and Planning A, 41: p.371-388 Joppke C. (1992), “Nuclear Power Struggles after Chernobyl: The Case of West Germany “, West European Politics, vol. 13, n°2, pp. 178-191. Kastner L., (2017), From Outsiders to Insiders: A Civil Society Perspective on EU Financial Reforms Journal of Common Market Studies, pp. 1–19 Kitschelt H. (1986) « Political opportunity structures and political protest: anti-nuclear movements in four democracies », British Journal of Political Science, vol. 16, n°1, pp. 57-85. Kingdon J.(1984), Agendas, Alternatives and Public Policies, London, Scott Foreman & Co. Lahiri-Dutt (dir.), 2014 The Coal Nation: Histories, Ecologies and Politics of Coal in India, Surrey, Ashgate, 318 p. Laigle L. (2013). "Pour une transition écologique à visée sociétale", Mouvements 75, 3, 135-142. Le Galès, P. (2003) Le retour des villes européennes. Sociétés urbaines, mondialisation, gouvernement et gouvernance, Paris, Presses de Sciences Po. McAdam, D., Boudet, H., (2012), Putting Social Movements in their Place. Explaining Opposition to Energy Projects in the United States, 2000–2005, Cambridge Studies in Contentious Politics Mitchell T., (2013), Carbon democracy: political power in the age of oil, London, Verso Moore, (2017) “World Accumulation and Planetary Life, or, Why Capitalism will not Survive Until the 'Last Tree is Cut'”, Progressive Review 24(3), p.176-202 Poupeau F.M., 2014. Central‐Local Relations in French Energy Policy‐Making: Towards a New Pattern of Territorial Governance. Environmental Policy and Governance 24, 3, 155-168. Rubbers, 2013 « Les sociétés africaines face aux investissements miniers », Politique africaine 2013/3 (N° 131), p. 5-25 Streeck W. and Thelen K.(dir.) (2005), Beyond Continuity. Institutional Change in Advanced Political Economies, Oxford University Press Trumbull G.(2012) Strength in numbers: the political power of weak interests, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press Svampa, M. (2016) « Reconfiguration du clivage Nord-Sud et géographie de l’ « extraction » », Alternatives Sud, 23(2). Varone, F., Nahrath, S., Gerber, J.-D. (2008) « Régimes institutionnels de ressources et théorie de la régulation », Revue de la régulation, vol. 2.

POLICY TOPICS
INTEREST GROUPS, BUSINESS, NETWORKS AND GOVERNANCE
P04. Consultants as Policy Actors
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Hurl
M. Rönnblom
T. Mitander
ABSTRACT

Across the globe, the use of private consultants in the public sector has grown exponentially over the last three decades, and the public sector is one of the most important markets for the large consultancy firms in terms of profit. This has potentially far-reaching implications for established democratic orders in terms of transparency, trust and legitimacy. Yet, the scholarly work that explicitly focus on the political effects of enlisting private consultants within the public sector remain remarkably scarce. It is only during the last few years that scholarly attention has been turned towards private policy consultants. In this research the main argument has been that governance today calls for new understandings of how policy advice is ‘arranged’ in a policy advisory system with less clear boundaries between such dichotomies as public and private. The term policy consultants denote a broader category of actors whose expertise directly rivals that of traditional bureaucrats in many ways. As such, they indicate a new modality of consultancy which the growing research indicates as particularly important for further studies, however, so far, the existing literature has remained quite descriptive and focused on isolated cases. The ambition of this panel is to gather together scholars with an interest in policy consultants and to advance the theoretical understanding and the empirical work on the role of policy consultants in public policy. The panel will revolve around the broad research question: What is the role and influence of policy consultants in contemporary democracies? The panel welcomes both theoretical and empirical contributions to broaden our understanding of this question. ReferencesBeveridge, Ross. 2012. “Consultants, depoliticization, and arena shifting in the policy process: privatizing water in Berlin.” Policy Sciences 45(1): 47-68. Craft, Jonathan. 2013. “Appointed Political Staffs and the Diversification of Policy Advisory Sources: Theory and Evidence from Canada.” Policy and Society 32(3): 211–23. Craft, Jonathan, and Michael Howlett. 2012. “Policy Formulation, Governance Shifts and Policy Influence: Location and Content in Policy Advisory Systems.” Journal of Public Policy 32(2): 79–98. Hodge, Graeme and Diana Bowman. 2006. “The ‘consultocracy’: The business of reforming government.” In Graeme Hodge (Ed.), Privatization and Market Development. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar. Howlett, M., and A. Migone. 2013. “Policy Advice through the Market: The Role of External Consultants in Contemporary Policy Advisory Systems.” Policy and Society 32(3): 241–54. Howlett, Michael, and Andrea Migone. 2013a. “Searching for Substance: Externalization, Politicization and the Work of Canadian Policy Consultants 2006-2013.” Central European Journal of Public Policy 7(1): 112–33. ———. 2013b. “The Permanence of Temporary Services: The Reliance of Canadian Federal Departments on Policy and Management Consultants.” Canadian Public Administration 56(3): 369–90. ———. 2014. “Assessing Contract Policy Work: Overseeing Canadian Policy Consultants.” Public Money & Management 34(3): 173–80. Howlett, Michael, Andrea Migone, and Seck L. Tan. 2014. “Duplicative or Complementary? The Relationship between Policy Consulting and Internal Policy Analysis in Canadian Government.” Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique 47(1): 113–134. Howlett, Michael, and Adam M. Wellstead. 2011. “Policy Analysts in the Bureaucracy Revisited: The Nature of Professional Policy Work in Contemporary Government.” Politics & Policy 39(4): 613–33. Jupe, Robert and Warwick Funnell. 2015. “Neoliberalism, consultants and the privatization of public policy formulation: The case of Britain’s rail industry,” Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 29: 65-85. Kirkpatrick, Ian et al. 2018. “The Impact of Management Consultants on Public Service Efficiency.” Policy & Politics. Leys, Colin. 1999. “Intellectual Mercenaries and the Public Interest: Management Consultants and the NHS.” Policy & Politics, 27(4): 447–65. Martin, J. 1998. Reorienting a Nation: Consultants and Australian Public Policy. Aldershot: Ashgate. Saint-Martin, Denis. 2013. “Making Government More ‘Business-Like’: Management Consultants as Agents of Isomorphism in Modern Political Economies.” In John Mikler (Ed.), The Handbook of Global Companies. West Sussex: Wiley-Blackwell. Saint-Martin, Denis. 2000. Building the New Managerialist State. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Veselý, Arnošt. 2013. “Externalization of Policy Advice: Theory, Methodology and Evidence.” Policy and Society 32(3): 199–209.

POLICY TOPICS
INTEREST GROUPS, BUSINESS, NETWORKS AND GOVERNANCE
P05. Barriers and Enablers of a Transformation to a Circular Economy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Leipold
F. Gale
ABSTRACT

There is a pressing need to move to more sustainable production and consumption systems (Meadows et al., 2004; Jackson 2006; WBCSD, 2010; Markard et al., 2012; Dietz & O’Neill 2013). To address this need, two of the world’s economic and political powers, China and the EU, have developed political strategies to introduce the ‘Circular Economy’ (European Commission 2015; Circular Economy Promotion Law of the People’s Republic of China 2008). These strategies describe the circular economy as a new paradigm that implies a complete ‘transformation’ of the economy and, subsequently, the society in these regions. The realization of this transformation will have large impacts on the global economy, and, thus, on how world politics is to be governed, with the recent Chinese waste import ban being a first indication of such impacts (Reuters 2017). Despite its global political relevance, an exponentially growing literature is focusing mostly on the technical and business aspects of the circular economy (Ghisellini 2016). While interesting business and technical answers are provided to the major question posed—what are the barriers and enablers to this transformation?—the political, institutional, and social barriers and enablers of such transformations have so far received much less attention. We believe that by shedding light on the political and governance struggles over this transformation paradigm and the resulting policy-making, much can be learned regarding its potential global effects. On that basis, this panel aims to initiate a structured discussion of this new economic model from social, political, legal and governance perspectives and identify commonalities and differences across cases to generate joint lessons learned. Specific aspects that will be discussed include: barriers and enablers identified by business and civil society stakeholders, scholars and policy makers; socio-economic dynamics resulting from circular economy strategies; regulatory and governance challenges and trade-offs emerging from subsequent changes in supply chains and production and consumption processes; different conceptualizations of the circular economy; policy instruments for a circular economy.

POLICY TOPICS
INTEREST GROUPS, BUSINESS, NETWORKS AND GOVERNANCE
P07. Facilitating Citizen Engagement in Public-policy Making
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Bherer
H. Christensen
ABSTRACT

Facilitation is a general term used to indicate an interaction where someone helps someone else or a group of people to accomplish something by assisting them to share knowledge and resources amongst themselves. It includes two kinds of facilitation. The first is more minimalist where facilitation means supporting citizen initiatives by giving a little helping hand. In this kind of arrangement, facilitators support self-organized actions while remaining outside actors in the bottom-up initiatives they contribute to. The second form of facilitation concerns facilitating public engagement processes. Facilitators are public participation professionals who are in charge of the design, implementation and hosting of participatory processes. Facilitation is understood as a top-down action where one set of people invite others into an open-ended forum in order to help them interact. However, the two kinds of facilitation have been rarely compared in order to develop a global approach of facilitation. Furthermore, although there is growing research on the role of facilitation in public policy-making processes in very different fields (theory of organization, local governance, public deliberation, innovation policy, collaboration, etc.), these different fields rarely speak to each other. The objective of this panel is to start a discussion between several academic approaches to better understand the challenges of facilitation. We will look especially at papers regarding 1) the job of facilitation and its professionalization process (the art and craft of facilitation); 2) the methods and practical challenges to include citizens; 3) the ethical concerns that guide facilitation. Understanding facilitation is important because it is increasingly being used by governments to involve citizens in public decision-making. The first type of facilitation raises the question of how direct citizen action interacts with state institutions because citizens accomplish public projects instead of the state. In the second type of facilitation, the main issue is how facilitators negotiate fair and open participatory arrangements with their sponsors.

POLICY TOPICS
INTEREST GROUPS, BUSINESS, NETWORKS AND GOVERNANCE
P08. The Implications of Business Involvement in Peace and Sustainability, in the Context of Planetary Resource Limits
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Ralph
O. Borja
L. Hancock
ABSTRACT

This panel aims to analyse the key research, practical and policy/governance issues related to the promotion of business roles in peace and sustainability, in the context of planetary resource limits and overconsumption. Business (small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs), social entrepreneurs and corporations), is perceived as an important partner in the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), and increasingly in peace efforts. The ‘Business for Peace’ (B4P) field (or Peace Through Commerce, Entrepreneurship for Peace) analyses business implementation of conflict-sensitive business practices (do-no-harm approach) (International Alert 2005), and support for structural peacebuilding (e.g. creating jobs, supporting good governance) and peacemaking (e.g. contributing to conflict resolution, social cohesion) (Miklian et al. 2018; Ford 2015). B4P supports SDG 16: peace, justice and strong institutions. B4P is increasingly considered in relation to Countering Violent Extremism (CVE) (Sharland, Grice and Zeiger 2017), and new areas such as renewable energy technology development (Ralph and Hancock 2018). Business links to inter-faith/cultural understanding are also explored (Global Compact and UN Alliance of Civilizations 2009). The key research question is: what are the public and private policy and governance requirements for facilitating best-practice Business for Peace initiatives and networks at the local, national and international levels? Further, how do we responsibly take this B4P agenda forward while avoiding the promotion of corporate power and interests, and a global political economy which ignores significant challenges from the centrality of economic growth and consumerism overstepping planetary resource limits? Can we hypothesise that with greater support, employees and owners in SMEs and social enterprises (as well as corporations) could contribute more to local peace, social cohesion and sustainability efforts (Ismail and Nusrat 2014; Banfield, Gündüz and Killick 2006)? And finally, that the different contributions of various sectors and types/sizes of business could be better understood, and targeted towards local needs, revealing more innovative approaches aligned to each firm’s strengths? References Banfield, J., C. Gündüz, N. Killick (2006). Local Business, Local Peace: the Peacebuilding Potential of the Domestic Private Sector, London: International Alert.Ford, J. (2015) Perspectives on the Evolving “Business and Peace” Debate, Academy of Management Perspectives 29, 4, 451–460. Global Compact, UN Alliance of Civilizations (2009) Doing Business in a Multicultural World, New York, https://www.unglobalcompact.org/docs/news_events/9.1_news_archives/2009_04_07/DBMW_Final_Web.pdf. International Alert (2005) Conflict-sensitive Business Practice: Guidance for Extractive Industries, London: International Alert. Ismail, O., R. Nusrat (2014) Exploring the potential of the private sector to contribute to peacebuilding in Pakistan, London: International Alert. Miklian, J., P. Schouten, C. Horst, Ø.H. Rolandsen (2018) Business and Peacebuilding: Seven Ways to Maximize Positive Impact, Oslo: PRIO. Ralph, N., L. Hancock (2018) Exploring the Role of Alternative Energy Corporations in Ethical Supply Chains and Corporate Peacebuilding, Global Governance 24: 81-102. Sharland, L, T. Grice, S. Zeiger (2017) Preventing and countering violent extremism in Africa: The role of the mining sector, Australian Strategic Policy Institute, Australia.

POLICY TOPICS
INTEREST GROUPS, BUSINESS, NETWORKS AND GOVERNANCE
P01. Public Policies in Federal and MLG Systems
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
W. Renzsch
ABSTRACT

This rather open panel will address questions of conflict and co-operation within federal and multi-level political systems. All federal and multi-level systems are marked by specific kinds of conflict/competition and cooperation. Dual systems tend to be more competitive while interlocking systems tend to more cooperative structures, in particular when the legal framework (constitution) requires cross-level cooperation. The cooperative relations between the levels of government can be regulated by negotiation and bargaining (e.g. US, Canada), or be required by law (e.g. Germany, EU), or by a mix of both. Supreme Courts or Constitutional Courts may play the role of an arbiter in such systems. The proposed panel is open to address issues of joint decision making across the levels of government, and will focus on different types like consultation, negotiation, cooperative or one-sided decisions. Beside the decision-making processes themselves further issue can be: Intergovernmental fiscal relations: Does the political system provide for revenue sharing, for independent fiscal resources or a mixture of both? Are there dependencies between the levels (e.g. the dependence to the EU from the member states), can one level impose fiscal burdens on the other (e.g. welfare benefits regulated by the federal level but implemented and paid for by the sub-national level)? Who decides in which way about fiscal equalization? Education/Science/Research: In most federal/ML-systems the lower/sub-national level of governance is responsible for education, science and research. However, in some systems the national level is entitled (or at least tries) to define national standard. Does the upper level have legal rights which can be enforced? Do the members of the sub-national level cooperate among themselves and with the national level? Is the federal level entitled to finance education, science and research provided by the sub-national level? To which degree does the upper level (including the Commission in the case of the EU) control and steer science and research by a “golden reign”? Domestic Security: Criminal behaviour reaches from petti thefts to international organized crime. It is a challenge for all levels of government. What are the relations between the “ordinary” authorities and federal authorities or intergovernmental bodies (like OLAF in the EU)? Further areas of intergovernmental areas like environmental policies, regional economic promotion, welfare provisions, agriculture … can be added. Suggestions are welcome.

POLICY TOPICS
FEDERALISM AND MULTI-LEVEL GOVERNANCE
P02. Subnational and Metropolitan Governance in the World: Innovations and Perspectives
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Araújo Fernandes
D. BANDEIRA COELHO
S. Araújo
ABSTRACT

The purpose of the panel is to discuss the governance of subnational spaces and more especially of Metropolitan Governance in the world. The main idea is to develop a debate that points out social and political aspects that influence the decision-making processes in the Governance of Metropolitan areas, given the complexity that metropolitan cities have in terms of more recent topics of interest, such as urban mobility, sustainability and environmental conservation, heritage and tourism, intelligent public services such as city sourcing. At the same time it becomes important to observe the regional and federative institutional aspects, the set of rules, that mark these processes of metropolitan governance in several countries from the federative structure of Government. It is believed here that the federative design greatly influences metropolitan governance and may hinder or facilitate metropolitan governance. What is observed in the world are the formation of sectoral common models, as is the case in some sectors such as transportation, infrastructure and housing, but at the same time there are particular traits that often represent innovative policies of governance metropolitan areas, which makes its diffusion more intense a fact, especially in developing countries. Different nations with different federative designs and different socioeconomic patterns have a dynamic of emulation and adaptation in the forms of urban governance based on their reality. The international case studies of the federative structures that make up the metropolitan governance in the world allow the mapping of these patterns and innovative differences, thus, it is possible to point out current diagnoses as well as future directives regarding metropolitan governance and the consolidation of a new institutional framework modeled by the different forms of federalism observed internationally. It is therefore intended that the panel contribute to the enrichment of this important research and work agenda for both academics and policy makers.

POLICY TOPICS
FEDERALISM AND MULTI-LEVEL GOVERNANCE
P03. Counterbalancing Autonomy through Joint-Policy Action in Federal and Multilevel Contexts
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
T. Fenwick
D. Béland
ABSTRACT

The goal of this panel is to explore both theoretically and empirically how we can reconcile the need for ‘coordination’ (to solve complex policy problems), with group and unit ‘autonomy’, within federal and multilevel governance systems. We know the potential for autonomy, be it from the majority, or another level of government, is challenged in old and emerging federal systems by the need for (vertical and horizontal) coordination. We also know that increasing or decreasing autonomy is a risk factor throughout diverse and complex contexts. For Robert Dahl (1986, 114), the standard definition of a federal democracy “is a system in which some matters are exclusively within the competence of certain local units—cantons, states, provinces—and are constitutionally beyond the scope of the authority of the national government; and when certain other matters are constitutionally outside the scope of the authority of the smaller units” (emphasis added). While this underlying logic explains both the purpose and practice of federalism in many of our federations, our central question is: Does it still hold true for contemporary federal systems and their societies, and if not, why? Reconciling federalism’s potential to offer multiple levels of government, and territorial groups, self-rule within their jurisdictions, with the context of contemporary policy challenges, has been relatively understudied. Empirically as scholars of federalism, we know that increasing, or decreasing levels of autonomy is a risk factor throughout diverse and complex contexts in both old and emerging federations. We need, however, to deepen our understanding of how we can operationalize ‘autonomy’ in multilevel systems, or at least promote its potential, in practice, without exacerbating the risks and challenges that such promotion may provoke. We suggest that federalism and multi-level contexts require diverse mechanisms that can both promote and counter-balance autonomy as a means to developing effective forms and procedures for democratic cooperation. It is of utmost importance that we analyse and explain why some federations generate cooperative behaviour, thus generating both democratic stability and progressive policy outcomes, while others generate instability by transforming states (provinces) into dissenters, rivals, and even challengers of national policy objectives. One easily forgets that the origins of federalism were to force people and groups who would prefer not to sit down together, to come to the table in order to compromise, and to collaborate for the sake of the collective good; be it security-, economically-, or welfare-oriented.

POLICY TOPICS
FEDERALISM AND MULTI-LEVEL GOVERNANCE
P04. Examining Indigenous “Treaty Federal” Institutions (in Canada and Abroad)
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Spitzer
ABSTRACT

Since 1995, when Prime Minister Jean Chretien’s federal Liberal government released its “Inherent Right Policy,” declaring Canada’s intention to cooperate with Indigenous groups to implement their “existing aboriginal and treaty rights” guaranteed in the constitution’s Section 35, the landscape of Indigenous governance in Canada has transformed. Leaving behind not just the colonial strictures of the Indian Act but also the familiar framework of conventional federalism and the universalist norms of public government, more than 20 Indigenous self-governments have come into being, along with numerous Indigenous “claims co-management boards” and other shared-rule and multilevel Indigenous-governance institutions. These are, arguably, cases of “treaty federalism” – of governance institutions, grounded in modern treaties and Indigenous rights, that provide Indigenous peoples with measures of self-rule, shared-rule, or both, in either territorial or non-territorial domains. In Canada, treaty-federal subunits govern at least certain dimension of the lives of thousands of Indigenous citizens, make decisions affecting thousands more non-Indigenous Canadians, and span millions of square kilometres of territory. And they are just the beginning: In Canada, approximately 90 more Indigenous self-governments are presently under negotiation. Meanwhile, in other “advanced democracies” with Indigenous minorities, such as Norway, Sweden, and Finland, “treaty federal” institutions are also under development. In otherwise-unitary states these involve radical constitutional reconfigurations. Some Fennoscandic “treaty federal” institutions would appear quite familiar to North American scholars; others are highly distinctive. And yet, in all advanced democracies, the vast majority of scholarship on Indigenous governance still cleaves to the same themes it pursued decades ago – the challenges of identifying and implementing Indigenous rights, the failures of settler states to address historical and present injustice, and so forth. There has been almost no concerted study of the new wave of Indigenous treaty-federal institutions – of their structures and functions, practices and procedures, successes and failures. Similarly, there has been little or no study of the interaction of these institutions with other state entities – with central and provincial/territorial governments, businesses, civil society, and so forth. These areas are ripe for examination. Questions might be asked about citizen participation, representation, satisfaction and legitimacy. How happy are Indigenous citizens with their new self-governments? How do they interact with their representatives and give voice to their concerns and opinions? What are their voting patterns? Questions might be asked about the behavior of political actors. How do treaty-federal representatives behave? Have political factions developed? Who runs for, and wins, office – are they young or old, men or women, traditionalists or modernists, etc.? Questions might be asked about bureaucracy and administration. How have these self-governments been staffed? Have they developed a cadre of Indigenous bureaucrats? Are they dependent on outside, non-Indigenous bureaucratic expertise? Are there conflicts between the political and bureaucratic classes? Have administrations adapted to Indigenous values and behavioral styles, or have those styles bent to bureaucratic habits? Questions might be asked about funding and economic self-determination. Have self-governments developed an economic base, or are they dependent on outside monies? How do they raise and spend revenue? How do they balance decisions concerning industrial development with other social and environmental concerns? Questions might be asked about rights and constitutional relationships. Have non-Indigenous residents been accommodated within new Indigenous self-governments? How have non-Indigenous governments interacted with the new Indigenous self-governments to address conflicts or issues of mutual concern? What is the working relationship between provincial/territorial governments and Indigenous self-governments? These questions are hardly exhaustive. They are, however, a place to begin, in an area of inquiry that is long overdue.

POLICY TOPICS
FEDERALISM AND MULTI-LEVEL GOVERNANCE
P07. Experiences and Reflections Towards Collaborative Governments: Challenges of Metropolitan Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Izquierdo Reyes
J. Martínez Delgado
D. Gomez Alvarez
ABSTRACT

The expansion of the large cities that converge in a region over the decades has allowed for the compacting of a metropolis, in which various municipalities converge that are unified in practice in the provision of public and private services to the population that resides in Therefore, it is a challenge to coordinate, finance and regulate them. This branch of public finance is important in its theorization, study, and analysis in order to understand the implementation of policies that allow the financing of public projects and programs in these cities. The economy evolves in an accelerated way in its new forms of association and presence, both in the physical and digital world, which increases and scales new possibilities of interaction in the provision of services that test their regulation. Therefore, the present study proposal aims to reflect on whether these changes can affect the revolution in the public finances of cities, in a context of metropolis- (big and expansive) urban cities and governance. Some of the main reflections of the document are: Where do we start? What is the status of public finance instruments and their coordination at the subnational level? Public finances in urban areas are sustainable to provide the goods and public services? What fiscal coordination instruments would finance the works and infrastructure of the metropolis in a sustainable manner? Disruptive ideas of financing and capitalization in the private sphere can be viable in urban cities? Where are the finances and coordination of public finances directed? The main objective from this panel, is discuss during the ICPP 2019 in Montreal about those challenges in the real economy with these new players (sharing economy Startup´s) in market, in urban areas and how the local governments could take those innovations tools. To provide better public and private goods improving citizen´s life. This panel could be an interesting opportunity to discuss this topic with students, academics and practitioners coming from the different contexts and regions around the world.

POLICY TOPICS
FEDERALISM AND MULTI-LEVEL GOVERNANCE
P01. Agent-Based Models in Public Policy Research: Perspectives and Issues
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Asquer
I. Krachkovskaya
ABSTRACT

Since Shelling’s ‘segregation model’ in the early 1970s, the use of a computational approach to simulate the interactions between a number of agents gained attention in many social science areas. Bordering contemporaneous developments in game theory, the emergence of agent-based models (ABMs) opened up novel theoretical and methodological perspectives to the understanding of various social processes. The approach gained steam in the following decades, when opportunities arose from increased computational power that became conveniently available. The launch of specialised venues like the Journal for Artificial Societies and Simulation and of resources like Leigh Tesfatsion’s web site. Yet, the impact of ABM on social science research – from economics to sociology to public policy – has been relatively modest so far. Within public policy, some ABM studies have been made in such areas as, for example, land use (Matthews et al 2007), urban planning (Ligmann-Zielinska and Jankowski 2007), income tax evasion (Bloomquist 2006), financial regulation (Krachkovskaya and Asquer 2015), terrorism (Elliot and Kiel 2004), and transport (Maggi and Vallino 2016). By and large, however, the ABM approach has not really delivered any significant advance in theorising the policy process, and its impact on policy advice and practice has been similarly rather modest. This panel aims to address the question of how ABMs can help advance public policy research and theory. The panel will welcome papers that: a) Provide a review and critical appraisal of ABMs in public policy research and theory;b) Use ABMs in original public policy research;c) Discuss theoretical and methodological issues for advancing the use of ABMs in public policy research;d) Discuss the use of ABMs in policy advice and practice. Papers may be either theoretical or empirical. Theoretical papers may discuss the limitations and weaknesses of ABMs, and the reasons why the ABM approach has not been strongly related to public policy frameworks and scholarly traditions so far. Empirical papers may present original studies that use ABMs for analysing public policy issues and/or producing policy advice or evaluations. References: Krachkovskaya, I., & Asquer, A. (2015). Do Central Counterparts Improve the Stability of Derivatives Market? Some Evidence from an Agent-Based Model. CeFiMS Research Paper DP136 (https://www.cefims.ac.uk/research/). Bloomquist, K. M. (2006). A comparison of agent-based models of income tax evasion. Social Science Computer Review, 24(4), 411-425. Elliott, E., & Kiel, L. D. (2004). A complex systems approach for developing public policy toward terrorism: an agent-based approach. Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, 20(1), 63-68. Ligmann-Zielinska, A., & Jankowski, P. (2007). Agent-based models as laboratories for spatially explicit planning policies. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 34(2), 316-335. Maggi, E., & Vallino, E. (2016). Understanding urban mobility and the impact of public policies: The role of the agent-based models. Research in Transportation Economics, 55, 50-59. Matthews, R. B., Gilbert, N. G., Roach, A., Polhill, J. G., & Gotts, N. M. (2007). Agent-based land-use models: a review of applications. Landscape Ecology, 22(10), 1447-1459.

POLICY TOPICS
METHODOLOGIES
P02. Case-Oriented and Set - Theoretic Approaches to Comparative Policy Analysis
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Thomann
V. Pattyn
S. Verweij
ABSTRACT

The policy process is characterized by a considerable degree of complexity regarding institutional settings, actor and preference constellations, policy goals, contents, and tools. Simultaneously, there is a practical demand for better knowledge of “what works” in public policies and under what conditions or in what contexts. In order to better match methods with theories and empirical realities, the analysis of public policies faces several challenging tasks (Brans and Pattyn 2017). First, it needs to model the complexity that characterizes the policy process and trace the underlying mechanisms. Second, comparative policy analysis detects regularities and achieves a modest degree of generalization. Finally, comparative policy analysis often deals with small or intermediate numbers of cases. Case-oriented and set-theoretic approaches to comparative policy analysis, such as Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA), Coincidence Analysis (CNA), explanatory typologies, and comparative process tracing, are designed to address these challenges. Situated within a “critical realist” paradigm of social research (Gerrits and Verweij 2013), they model different aspects of causal complexity, such as configurations of different factors leading to policy outputs or outcomes, equifinality (multiple configurations can result in the same outcome), contextual contingencies, and causal asymmetry. Moreover, they can be applied within a variety of small-N or large-N research approaches to evaluate as well as generate theories through a combination of systematic comparison with targeted in-depth case studies (Thomann and Maggetti 2017). As interactive and iterative methods, they also lend themselves to interpretative comparative analysis (Brans and Pattyn, 2017). Set-theoretic and case-oriented methods are increasingly common in comparative policy analysis (see e.g. Rihoux et al. 2011; Thomann 2019), particularly in policy implementation and evaluation research (Gerrits and Verweij 2018; Pattyn et al. 2017). This panel gathers both theoretical, conceptual, and empirical contributions that deal with the state of the art of case-oriented and set-theoretic approaches and illustrate their potential and limitations to contribute to the theory and practice of policy analysis. References Brans, M., & Pattyn, V. (2017). Validating methods for comparing public policy: Perspectives from academics and “pracademics”. Introduction to the Special Issue. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice 19(4): 303-312. Gerrits, L., & Verweij, S. (2013). Critical realism as a meta-framework for understanding the relationships between complexity and qualitative comparative analysis. Journal of Critical Realism 12(2): 166-182. Gerrits, L., & Verweij, S. (2018). The evaluation of complex infrastructure projects: a guide to qualitative comparative analysis. Edward Elgar Publishing. Pattyn, V., Molenveld, A., & Befani, B. (2017). Qualitative Comparative Analysis as an Evaluation Tool: Lessons From an Application in Development Cooperation. American Journal of Evaluation, DOI:1098214017710502. Rihoux, B., Rezsöhazy, I., & Bol., D. (2011). Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) in Public Policy Analysis: An Extensive Review. German Policy Studies 7(3): 9-82. Thomann, E. (2019). Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) as an approach to Comparative Policy Analysis. In: Handbook of Methodology for Comparative Policy Analysis. Edward Elgar (Editors Guillaume Fontaine and B. Guy Peters). Thomann, E., & M. Maggetti (2017). Designing Research with Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA): Approaches, Challenges, Tools. Sociological Methods & Research, DOI: 10.1177/0049124117729700.

POLICY TOPICS
METHODOLOGIES
P03. Advancing Relational Policy Analysis
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Wolf
K. Bartels
ABSTRACT

As humans, as cultures, and as humanity we confront relentless challenges—experienced in everyday ephemeral moments and as pervasive environmental crises or manifestations of fragile economies and democracies. These challenges, and how we encounter them, play out in a dynamic, interdependent, relational space. It is a space that people make together and that remakes them. Relationality provides people a sense of how their lives are going, while also offering resources to glance forward to what may plausibly be—informed by experience—in order to act as if it were the case, and thereby increase the chance of it actually being the case. Therefore, relational policy analysis, most simply stated, accepts relationality as a key characteristic of our contemporary condition and seeks to reconfigure the policy process accordingly. The intention is to advance governance toward more sustainable futures. For much of human history, the relationality of people and the world has been conceived as philosophically foundational. The concept is retained in numerous indigenous concepts, such as kotahitanga for Māori, meaning unity or oneness, or the Andean concept pacha as a totality of being that overcomes space and time. The Western tradition sought to prioritise substantive entities over relationships, and static being over fluid becoming. This view continues to heavily influence the practice of policy analysis, the recognised shortcomings of which have motivated a stream of study of relational approaches to policy analysis. Of particular note is work in deliberative policy analysis, critical policy studies, practice theory, relational process ontology, policy networks and systems thinking. On the one hand, relational approaches reflect the everyday realities of people—citizens and professionals alike—who endeavour to create better futures in a complex and uncertain world. On the other hand, much scholarship stops short of fully synthesising lessons for how relational ideas might be more easily and more sustainably practiced. The time is ripe, therefore, for fresh consideration of the lessons to date from theoretical discussions and empirical case studies (in interpretive and action-research forms). Depending on one’s perspective, a relational approach either complements or supplants analytical approaches based on technical, ‘evidence-based’ responses to decision making under uncertainty with the practical, experiential and practice wisdom honed through interactions and embedded in common sense. The aim of this panel is to advance the theory–practice interface in relational policy analysis. The intention is to focus on the practice of methodologies that are helpful in honing citizens’ and practitioners’ everyday capacities for anticipating futures and creating desirable pathways to realise them. Taking relationality centrally means embracing the dualities of subjectivity and objectivity, interdependence and autonomy and (re)conceiving policy analysis as a situated, embodied, and unfolding practice. Such a ‘turn’ is truly radical—both in the sense of breaking with accepted ways of thinking and in pointing to the fundamental nature of human experience and sensemaking.

POLICY TOPICS
METHODOLOGIES
P01. How Much Does State Architecture Matter for Feminist Policy Outputs?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Haussman
J. Fabian
ABSTRACT

Feminist social scientists have been grappling with the question of whether particular forms of state architecture (federal vs. unitary; centralized women’s policy agencies [WPA] or not) produce better policy results for women in different policy areas. This question has been taken up by various feminist political scientists and policy analysts, including McEwen and Moreno (2005); Chappell (2002); McBride and Mazur (2010); Krook and Mackay (2011); Haussman, Sawer and Vickers (2010); Lombardo, Meier and Verloo (2009); Roth (2008); Outshoorn and Kantola (2007); Van der Vleuten (2007), Freidenvall (2019) and MacRae and Weiner (2017). For example, many studies theorize that a strong WPA network, closely tied to the central government, achieved gender equality objectives. Some, such as Collier (2010) and Grace (2018) have shown that in federal states, regional governments enact and implement good policies in policy areas such as child care and employment equity.. Most studies also theorize that a leftist government is necessary but not sufficient for good outcomes for diverse groups of women. But more recent research suggests that there are different kinds of leftist governments and that which kind is in power matters. The papers in this panel will explore what we know about relations between state architecture including age and type of federation, level and type of goverment in relation to policy outcomes that to benefit women of majority populations or of diverse minorities.

POLICY TOPICS
GENDER, DIVERSITY AND PUBLIC POLICY
P03. Feminist Governance in the 21st Century
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Paterson
F. Scala
L. Smith
ABSTRACT

With many post-industrial democracies undergoing dramatic shifts to the right, a few states, such as Canada, New Zealand, and Iceland, for example, stand out on the world stage for their explicit commitment to progressive, specifically feminist, politics. Indeed, the Prime Ministers in these countries have expressly committed to improving the lives of women and marginalized groups through their established feminist policy agendas. While these developments appear promising, the literatures on state feminism, state engagement, and feminist public administration remind us of the potential contradictory effects that result when states take up and deploy feminist knowledge. Towards this end, the objectives of this panel (which is one of two proposed panels on feminist governance and policy) are as follows: to explore the factors that have contributed to the re-emergence of feminism as a political force; to investigate and unpack what feminism means in these contexts and how it is practiced; to explore how feminist knowledges are taken up and deployed by governments and its effects; to understand how feminist mobilization is resisting populist forces

POLICY TOPICS
GENDER, DIVERSITY AND PUBLIC POLICY
P04. The Financial Security of Older Women from a Life-Course Perspective
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Harding
S. Bezbaruah
ABSTRACT

Asia is ageing at an unprecedented rate. By 2050, 1.3 billion people in the region will be 60 years and older (UNESCAP, n.d.). The majority of this older population will be female, which raises major concerns about the financial security of older women. Existing global evidence suggests that older women have lower levels of income and higher levels of poverty. These gender inequalities in later life are the cumulative outcome of gender-based disadvantages in social and economic opportunities throughout women’s lives. The rapid pace of ageing in Asia compared to Western Europe (to illustrate, while the transition from an ageing to aged society took 115 years in France, it will only take 19 years in Singapore)(Kinsella and Phillips, 2005) creates a unique challenge. Furthermore, compared to European countries, many countries in Asia will experience ageing at a much earlier stage of development. Governments do not have the "luxury of time" to respond to the policy implications of gendered ageing patterns, and immediate action is required. A first step towards this is a comprehensive assessment of the financial security of women in Asia. There has been substantial research on the policy implications of ageing in Asia (Abeykoon et al., 2017; Arifin and Ananta (eds), 2009; Lee (ed), 2008; Phillips, 1998, Torres and Samson (eds), 2014), but the gendered dimensions have been relatively under-explored. Research on gender and ageing tends to focus on healthcare, family or well-being (Devasahayam (ed), 2014; Dzung, 2014; Ofstedal et al., 2003; Mehta (ed), 1997; Schröder-Butterfill, 2004; Vlachantoni and Falkingham, 2011) and less on financial security. The importance of the life-course approach (Elder et al., 2003; Hatch,2000), or recognising that women's status in later life is the product of gender inequalities throughout their lives is also less studied. Utilising a life-course approach to policy would require a shift from viewing older women as a discrete target group, to incorporate women of all ages, and target key points in women's lives at which women are most 'at risk' of becoming financially insecure. The objective of this panel is to focus attention on the factors influencing the financial security of older women in Asia, compare women’s experiences of financial insecurity in Asia with other regions, and underline the need for policies that integrate a life-course approach. The main research question is: what are the main factors that cause women's financial insecurity in old age? The other questions that the panel seeks to address include but are not limited to: Is the life-course approach useful for understanding women's financial security in old age? What are the similarities and differences between older women’s experiences of financial security across different regions of the world? What policy interventions are required to alleviate women's financial insecurity in old age? What policies are being implemented in different regions in the world? Are there any best practices from other regions that can be replicated in Asia? What is the impact of gendered norms on women's financial security in old age? Which factors that influence women's financial security can be addressed at a regional level, while others require country level initiatives? Which is the most urgent issue relating to the financial security of older women? References: Abeykoon, A., Murat, N., Rocas, G. and Naraval, A.C. (eds). (2017). Ageing: Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia and Cambodia: Demographic transitions, policy and programmatic responses. Selangor: International Council on Management of Population Programmes (ICOMP). Arifin, Evi Nurvidya and Ananta, Aris (eds). (2009) Older Persons in Southeast Asia: An Emerging Asset Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies. Devasahayam, Theresa W. (eds). (2014). Gender and Ageing: Southeast Asian Perspectives. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies. Dzung, N.G.T. (2014). Elderly people in Vietnam: some issues of concern from family and gender perspectives. In Torres, A.T. and Samson, L.L. (eds). Aging in Asia-Pacific: Balancing the State and the Family. Quezon City: Philippine Social Science Council, pp. 195-208. Elder, Glen H., Johnson, Monica Kirkpatrick and Crosnoe, Robert. (2003). “The emergence and development of life-course theory,” in Mortimer, Jeylan T. and Shanahan, Michael J. (eds), Handbook of the Life Course. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers. Hatch, Laurie Russell. (2000). Beyond Gender Differences: Adaptation to Aging in Life Course Perspective. London: Taylor and Francis. Kinsella, Kevin and Phillips, David Rosser (2005). “Global aging: the challenge of success.” Population Bulletin, 60, no. 1. Phillips, David Rosser (1998). Aging in the Asia-Pacific Region: Trends and Policy Implications. APIAS Working Paper Series No. 5. Retrieved from Lingnan University website: http://commons.ln.edu.hk/apiaswp/7/ Lee, Hock Guan (ed). (2008) Ageing in Southeast and East Asia: Family, Social Protection and Policy Challenges Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies. Mehta, Kalyani (ed). (1997) Untapped Resources: Women in Ageing Societies Across Asia. Singapore: Times Academic Press Ofstedal, Mary Beth, Reidy, Erin and Knodel, John. Gender Differences in Economic Support and Well-Being of Older Asians, PSC Research Report, Report No. 03-540, 2003, November. Schröder-Butterfill, Elisabeth. “Inter-generational family support provided by older people in Indonesia,” Ageing and Society, 24, no. 4, 2004: 497-530. Torres, A.T. and Samson, L.L. (eds). (2014) Aging in Asia-Pacific: Balancing the State and the Family. Quezon City: Philippine Social Science Council. UNESCAP. n.d. Ageing in Asia and the Pacific: Overview. Bangkok: UNESCAP. Vlachantoni, A and Falkingham, J. (2011). Exploring gender and pensions in Japan, Malaysia and Vietnam. CRA Discussion Paper no. 1101, February. Southampton: University of Southampton, Centre for Research on Ageing, p. 20.

POLICY TOPICS
GENDER, DIVERSITY AND PUBLIC POLICY
P06. Gender, Diversity, and Representation of Target Groups in Public Policy-Making/Implementing Venues
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
V. Illesinghe
W. Cukier
E. Roach
ABSTRACT

Objectives and scientific relevance: Embedded within the question of which problems or issues are gaining attention, are the related questions: who are the target groups, and how are they represented in policy-making venues and affected by policy implementation? Public policy-making and their implementation is not always fair or equitable- some policies exclude target group that are more likely to benefit from them and give benefits to certain groups more so than others. Representation and meaningful engagement of diverse and marginalized groups such as, women, LGBTQ people, racialized groups, Indigenous people, and persons with disabilities can shape policy issues and solutions. The Diversity Institute is organizing a panel discussion to explore ways of entrenching gender and diversity within institutions, governing structures, and organizations within the context of existing power and gender imbalances that traditionally exclude marginalized groups and their interests from public policy venues. The broad aim of this panel is to understand the ways in which institutions and organizational structures exclude some target groups and their interests in policy-making and policy implementation in these settings. This panel will be organized into two sessions, one focusing on the representation and differential treatment of diverse and marginalized groups such as, women, LGBTQ people, and racialized groups in various settings across the world, and one aimed at understanding how change can be brought about in institutional frameworks and organizational structures for more equitable representation of such groups. We will examine diverse policy-making and implementing venues such as political institutions, local governance structures, schools, and academia as well as several target groups including women and LGBTQ groups in developed and developing countries. The question of target group representation can be explored from an institutional approach or critical perspective. While some argue that powerful actors or strong advocacy /interest groups can increase representation of target groups in policy venues, others believe that institutions constrain actors' choices and actions. From an institutionalist perspective, representation could be made better and more effective by changing institutional laws and norms. This view could be challenged from a critical policy perspective; arguing that all decision-making is subject to biases, issue framing, and social constructions of target groups which are unlikely to be influenced by legislation. Theoretical and empirical works that have looked at existing laws, frameworks, and practices, discussed their strengths and limitations, and proposed solutions that apply to diverse settings are included.

POLICY TOPICS
GENDER, DIVERSITY AND PUBLIC POLICY
P09. 'Doing' Feminist Policy Analysis: Canadian and Comparative Case Studies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
F. Scala
S. Paterson
ABSTRACT

Feminist policy studies is a broad field ranging from analysis of substantive issue areas to those addressing the micro-dimensions of policy processes and outcomes. Borrowing heavily from but also challenging critical policy studies, feminist policy studies has resulted in an impressive range of theoretical and methodological frameworks designed to expose the ubiquity of gender in policy processes and outcomes. As part of a broader feminist project, feminist policy analysis is concerned with the mechanisms through which power is developed and maintained in all aspects of the policy process, including problem definition, policy formulation and policy implementation (Bacchi, 1999: Marshall, 1999). As Marshall explains (1999:59), feminist critical policy analysis “directly questions the entire policy analysis process, from the formation of research questions to the development and use of methodology to the analysis and write-up of results. It assumes that policymakers (i.e., the state) will act in ways to sustain and build dominance in society”. Recognizing differences among women, feminist critical policy analysis also makes social location, including in intersecting factors, such as gender, race, class, ability, sexuality and gender identity and expression relevant and central to policy theory, inquiry and practice. The panel, the second of two panel proposals on feminist governance and policy (see Feminist Governance in the 21st Century), builds on this work by directly engaging with feminist critical policy analysis through case studies on policy issues in different country settings. Individually and together, the case studies will advance theory-building in feminist policy studies as well as provide insights on the benefits and challenges of ‘doing’ feminist policy analysis as both research and practice.

POLICY TOPICS
GENDER, DIVERSITY AND PUBLIC POLICY
P03. Designing Effective Policies to Trigger Technological Innovation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Sewerin
T. Schmidt
M. Howlett
ABSTRACT

Technological innovation is considered a key lever for tackling persistent and complex societal problems, such as the transition to low-carbon energy technology in order to mitigate climate change or fostering medical innovation to tackle persistent health challenges. Also, technological innovation is a key driver behind the competition between states and world regions for industry leadership in future lead technologies, such as the EU’s policy strategy to catch up with East Asia in energy storage technologies (Beuse et al. 2018). While it is well established in the literature that public policy has a strong influence on technological change (e.g., Mowery 1983, Mazzucato 2015), how to design effective policies for steering technological innovation remains a central challenge for policy design and policy designers at all levels of policy-making. While the older literature on policy effectiveness related to technological innovation revolved around questions of instrument choice (i.e., what is the best instrument to foster innovation) (e.g., Carley 2011), more recent empirical investigations have turned attention instead to investigating the effect of policy design choices on lower levels of abstraction (i.e., the calibration and settings of policy instruments) (Howlett & Lejano 2012). At the same time, the ‘new’ policy design literature (Howlett 2014; Peters et al. 2018) has called for greater attention to questions of designing, i.e. the processes that lead to the adoption, implementation and subsequent evaluation and (potential) reform. Studying technology-related policies offers the opportunity to engage with important questions regarding design and designing: I. Technologies can be differentiated along the types of capabilities needed to master innovation: they can be simple or complex in terms of their inherent design and they can be simple or complex in terms of their manufacturing (Schmidt & Huenteler 2016; Huenteler et al. 2016). This conceptualisation of technology-complexity, however, is just beginning to gain traction in empirical policy analysis (e.g., Schmidt & Sewerin 2018). Yet, effective policy design, i.e. the identification of policy design elements that foster technological innovation, requires a solid understanding of technology-complexity. Also, policy design has to address the problem of lock-in of technology choices (Hoppmann et al. 2013; Sandén & Azar 2005; Schmidt et al. 2016) while balancing general uncertainty about technologies’ future development (Hoppmann et al. 2014). Thus, questions of effective policy design, i.e. finding the best policy instrumentation and design, remain pertinent. II. Designing technology-related policies also involves potentially very conflictual policy-making processes: emerging or sufficiently developed technologies can pose a direct threat to powerful incumbents, impeding the political feasibility of policy action. Crucially, these threats to incumbents often are policy-induced, i.e. are feedback effects of previous policy decisions (Schmidt & Sewerin 2017; Meckling et al. 2015) Yet, the role of actors and agency in such long-term policy feedback loops is not well established, particularly since the role of actors and agency in the initial designing of technology-specific policies and the feedback effects of policy-induced technological change on politics are seldom studied systematically. Since public policy plays a huge role for technological change, the field of technology-related policy is particularly suited to study the relationship between agency in the designing of policies and policy-induced real-world changes. Overall, policy design and designing in the field of technology policy is far from routine, making it a fascinating area of investigation for researchers interested in effective policy design. (See the Call for Papers for more specific research questions we’re interested in.) Literature · Beuse, M., Schmidt, T. S., & Wood, V. (2018). A “technology-smart” battery policy strategy for Europe. Science, 361(6407), 1075-1077. · Carley, S. (2011). The era of state energy policy innovation: A review of policy instruments. Review of Policy Research, 28(3), 265-294. · Hoppmann, J., Peters, M., Schneider, M., & Hoffmann, V. H. (2013). The two faces of market support—How deployment policies affect technological exploration and exploitation in the solar photovoltaic industry. Research Policy, 42(4), 989-1003. · Hoppmann, J., Huenteler, J., & Girod, B. (2014). Compulsive policy-making—The evolution of the German feed-in tariff system for solar photovoltaic power. Research policy, 43(8), 1422-1441. · Howlett, M., & Lejano, R. P. (2013). Tales from the crypt: The rise and fall (and rebirth?) of policy design. Administration & Society, 45(3), 357-381. · Howlett, M. (2014). From the ‘old’ to the ‘new’ policy design: design thinking beyond markets and collaborative governance. Policy Sciences, 47(3), 187-207. · Huenteler, J., Schmidt, T. S., Ossenbrink, J., & Hoffmann, V. H. (2016). Technology life-cycles in the energy sector—Technological characteristics and the role of deployment for innovation. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 104, 102-121. · Mazzucato, M. (2015). The entrepreneurial state: Debunking public vs. private sector myths (Vol. 1). Anthem Press. · Meckling, J., Kelsey, N., Biber, E., & Zysman, J. (2015). Winning coalitions for climate policy. Science, 349(6253), 1170-1171. · Mowery, D. C. (1983). Economic theory and government technology policy. Policy sciences, 16(1), 27-43. · Peters, B. G., Capano, G., Howlett, M., Mukherjee, I., Chou, M. H., & Ravinet, P. (2018). Designing for Policy Effectiveness: Defining and Understanding a Concept. Cambridge University Press. · Sandén, B. A., & Azar, C. (2005). Near-term technology policies for long-term climate targets—economy wide versus technology specific approaches. Energy policy, 33(12), 1557-1576. · Schmidt, T. S., & Huenteler, J. (2016). Anticipating industry localization effects of clean technology deployment policies in developing countries. Global Environmental Change, 38, 8-20. · Schmidt, T. S., & Sewerin, S. (2017). Technology as a driver of climate and energy politics. Nature Energy, 2(6), 17084. · Schmidt, T. S., & Sewerin, S. (2018). Measuring the temporal dynamics of policy mixes–An empirical analysis of renewable energy policy mixes’ balance and design features in nine countries. Research Policy. · Schmidt, T. S., Battke, B., Grosspietsch, D., & Hoffmann, V. H. (2016). Do deployment policies pick technologies by (not) picking applications?—A simulation of investment decisions in technologies with multiple applications. Research Policy, 45(10), 1965-1983.

POLICY TOPICS
SCIENCE, INTERNET AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY
P04. Governing Artificial Intelligence and Autonomous Systems
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Taeihagh
ABSTRACT

Rapid technological advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Autonomous Systems (AS) are beginning to revolutionise all aspects of society today. AI and AS have been developed in various domains to accrue productivity gains as well as other societal benefits, ranging from search algorithms for online advertising (Goodfellow et al. 2016), signal processing (Karaboga et al. 2014), credit scoring (Tsai & Wu 2008; Brown & Mues 2012), medical diagnosis (Russell & Norvig 2016; Amato et al. 2013), autonomous vehicles in transportation (Fagnant & Kockelman 2015; Milakis et al. 2017; Taeihagh & Lim 2018), robotic assistants in healthcare (Stahl and Coeckelbergh 2016) to lethal autonomous weapon systems in the military (Krishnan 2016). These developments threaten to outpace the regulatory responses of governments around the world, which must grapple with the increasing magnitude and speed of these transformations. While the societal benefits of AI and AS have been widely acknowledged by governments, scholars and the general public (Buchanan 2005; Taeihagh & Lim 2018; Ramchurn et al. 2012), a large body of literature has highlighted many potential unintended consequences that can arise from the incautious and misguided adoption of these new technologies. New risks include and are not limited to unemployment (Acemoglu & Restrepo 2018; Frey & Osborne 2017; Peters 2017; Osoba & Welser IV 2017), safety risks (Taeihagh & Lim 2018; Kalra & Paddock 2016), privacy risks (Russell et al. 2015; Lim & Taeihagh 2018; Litman 2017), liability risks (Marchant & Lindor 2012; Čerka et al. 2015; Taeihagh & Lim 2018) and inequality (Makridakis 2017; Taeihagh & Lim 2018; Acemoglu & Restrepo 2018), which require appropriate governance mechanisms to be mitigated. However, governments face challenges regulating new technologies due to insufficient information on industry developments, technological and regulatory uncertainties, coordination challenges between multiple regulatory bodies (Guihot et al. 2017), as well as the opacity of the underlying technology (Scherer 2016), which render traditional policy instruments ineffective and necessitate the use of more nuanced approaches to govern AI and AS. The urgency for and the challenges of governing AI and AS have been highlighted in recent studies (Arkin 2009; Simshaw et al. 2015; Guihot et al. 2017; Scherer 2016; Krishnan 2016; Taeihagh & Lim 2018; Lim & Taeihagh 2018) and require further exploration. In light of these issues, several key research questions have yet to be answered in the literature:· What are the types of unintended consequences and risks that can arise from the adoption of AI and AS in different domains? (e.g. ICT, transport, energy, public sector, healthcare, water management etc.)?· How can risks and uncertainties arising from the use of AI and AS be effectively managed and governed?· How can AI and AS be responsibly deployed by the public administrators? · What are the implications of AI and AS on incumbent industries and how can the relationship between these technologies and incumbent industries be reconciled?· Theoretical, conceptual and empirical approaches to understand new and unconventional regulatory approaches, governance strategies, institutions and discourses to govern risks arising from the adoption of AI and AS. · What types of standards or guidelines have been developed in industry and governments to manage the risks and uncertainties stemming from the adoption of AI and AS? · How are risks from the adoption of AI and AS allocated among different stakeholders vertically through the value chain (manufacturers, third-party service providers, consumers) and horizontally across different domains (transport, healthcare, financial sector, public agencies, ICT, education etc.)?· Single and comparative case studies of governance responses across different countries, regions and domains to address the risks arising from AI and AS adoption. References: Acemoglu, D., & Restrepo, P. (2018). Artificial Intelligence, Automation and Work (No. w24196). National Bureau of Economic Research. Amato, F., López, A., Peña-Méndez, E. M., Vaňhara, P., Havel, J., Sánchez, C. L., ... & Dridi, I. (2013). 1. Artificial neural networks in medical diagnosis. Journal of Applied Biomedicine, 11(2), 47-113. Arkin, R. (2009). Governing lethal behaviour in autonomous robots. Chapman and Hall/CRC. Brown, I., & Mues, C. (2012). An experimental comparison of classification algorithms for imbalanced credit scoring data sets. Expert Systems with Applications, 39(3), 3446-3453. Buchanan, B. G. (2005). A (very) brief history of artificial intelligence. Ai Magazine, 26(4), 53. Čerka, P., Grigienė, J., & Sirbikytė, G. (2015). Liability for damages caused by artificial intelligence. Computer Law & Security Review, 31(3), 376-389. Fagnant, D. J., & Kockelman, K. (2015). Preparing a nation for autonomous vehicles: opportunities, barriers and policy recommendations. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 77, 167-181. Frey, C. B., & Osborne, M. A. (2017). The future of employment: how susceptible are jobs to computerisation?. Technological forecasting and social change, 114, 254-280. Goodfellow, I., Bengio, Y., Courville, A., & Bengio, Y. (2016). Deep learning (Vol. 1). Cambridge: MIT Press. Guihot, M., Matthew, A. F., & Suzor, N. P. (2017). Nudging Robots: Innovative Solutions to Regulate Artificial Intelligence. Vand. J. Ent. & Tech. L., 20, 385. Kalra, N., & Paddock, S. M. (2016). Driving to safety: How many miles of driving would it take to demonstrate autonomous vehicle reliability? Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 94, 182-193. Karaboga, D., Gorkemli, B., Ozturk, C., & Karaboga, N. (2014). A comprehensive survey: artificial bee colony (ABC) algorithm and applications. Artificial Intelligence Review, 42(1), 21-57. Krishnan, A. (2016). Killer robots: legality and ethicality of autonomous weapons. Routledge. Lim, H. S. M., & Taeihagh, A. (2018). Autonomous Vehicles for Smart and Sustainable Cities: An In-Depth Exploration of Privacy and Cybersecurity Implications. Litman, T. (2017). Autonomous vehicle implementation predictions. Victoria, Canada: Victoria Transport Policy Institute. Marchant, G. E., & Lindor, R. A. (2012). The coming collision between autonomous vehicles and the liability system. Santa Clara L. Rev., 52, 1321. Makridakis, S. (2017). The forthcoming Artificial Intelligence (AI) revolution: Its impact on society and firms. Futures, 90, 46-60. Milakis, D., Van Arem, B., & Van Wee, B. (2017). Policy and society related implications of automated driving: A review of literature and directions for future research. Journal of Intelligent Transportation Systems, 21(4), 324-348. Osoba, O. A., & Welser IV, W. (2017). The Risks of Artificial Intelligence to Security and the Future of Work. Santa Monica, Calif.: RAND Corp, 7. Peters, M. A. (2017). Technological unemployment: Educating for the fourth industrial revolution, Educational Philosophy and Theory, 49:1, 1-6. Ramchurn, S. D., Vytelingum, P., Rogers, A., & Jennings, N. R. (2012). Putting the'smarts' into the smart grid: a grand challenge for artificial intelligence. Communications of the ACM, 55(4), 86-97. Russell, S., Dewey, D., & Tegmark, M. (2015). Research priorities for robust and beneficial artificial intelligence. Ai Magazine, 36(4), 105-114. Russell, S. J., & Norvig, P. (2016). Artificial intelligence: a modern approach. Malaysia; Pearson Education Limited,. Scherer, M. U. (2015). Regulating artificial intelligence systems: Risks, challenges, competencies, and strategies. Harv. JL & Tech., 29, 353. Simshaw, D., Terry, N., Hauser, K., & Cummings, M. L. (2015). Regulating healthcare robots: Maximizing opportunities while minimising risks. Rich. JL & Tech., 22, 1. Stephan, K. D., Michael, K., Michael, M. G., Jacob, L., & Anesta, E. P. (2012). Social implications of technology: The past, the present, and the future. Proceedings of the IEEE, 100(Special Centennial Issue), 1752-1781. Taeihagh, A., & Lim, H. S. M. (2018). Governing autonomous vehicles: emerging responses for safety, liability, privacy, cybersecurity, and industry risks. Transport Reviews, 1-26. Tsai, C. F., & Wu, J. W. (2008). Using neural network ensembles for bankruptcy prediction and credit scoring. Expert systems with applications, 34(4), 2639-2649.

POLICY TOPICS
SCIENCE, INTERNET AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY
P05. “Hello, IT... Have You Tried Turning it Off and On Again?” – Big Data Challenges for Political Science
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
R. Jasmin
W. Drews
H. Lee
ABSTRACT

One of the latest digital innovation to enter the political arena is big data, i.e. the computational and analytic processes keyed to large quantities of information about citizens, politicians, parties as well as policies and policy processes compiled from multiple sources and by various advanced computational methods. Web-based platforms, online services and social media have fundamentally impacted upon political processes and behaviour. Since the Arab Spring, there is no doubt that they are key to mobilizing political activists, but also facilitate both conventional and unconventional forms of participation, such as e-Voting and e-Petitions. The vast possibilities of online communication change and shape political participation as they are becoming strategic means to influence policy-making by groups and individuals alike. Moreover, mobilisation and interest aggregation create new types of individual and collective (political) actors who increase the pool of participants in policy-making processes. This raises questions as to how web-based platforms, online services and social media can meet and enhance democratic demands such as transparency, accessibility and equality. Additionally, governments, administrations, political institutions and actors make increasing use of ICT to embrace new online services (such as e-Taxing), to facilitate internal processes or to increase transparency via open-data and open-government. Political parties and candidates, too, compete fiercely in the online sphere which subsequently transforms into an arena where elections, especially in the U.S. but also in Europe, and referenda, such as Brexit, may be decided. Thus, governments’ and politicians’ actions are increasingly driven by digitalisation, social computing and the data harvested online. It is crucial to identify the key techniques and features of these new modes of governing, policy-making and electioneering and investigate their implications for societies at large, not to forget privacy issues of big data analytics in policy making. Finally, all of these political events, processes and activities produce massive amounts and different types of data that can be wrangled, traced, combined and analysed via advanced computational methods. During the last ten years, new techniques to collect and analyse (behavioural) data have enriched political science massively. Moreover, through computer science and computational social science, we also get access to data and information that was not available in systematic fashion before, e.g. by methods to transform (un-)structured text into machine-readable and analysable data. Furthermore, we can use a broad array of computational methods, including big data analytics, knowledge representation, machine learning or deep learning. Thus, technological progress also opens up room for new insights in old information or phenomena by pre-processing and analysing them in a new fashion. The panel seeks to promote a theoretically informed and empirically sound discussion along these strands of reflection: the value of big data for studying politics, policy-making and political behaviour but also the impacts of computational methods on the discipline of political science. To that end, it welcomes papers dealing with the potentialities and limitations of using massive-scale datasets in political science from a broad array of methodological lenses, in different contexts, or fluidly across the online-offline-boundary.

POLICY TOPICS
SCIENCE, INTERNET AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY
P06. ICT and Public Policies: Managing Technological Change in the Public Sector
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Vecchi
G. Misuraca
M. Righettini
ABSTRACT

The panel aims at exploring the wide implications of technological change within two broad areas of investigation such as public policy and public sector organizations. The first theme looks at policy processes or at specific stages such as formulation, decision making, implementation or evaluation. Here, the focus will be on the role of ICT and technology in shaping and influencing actors’ interaction in specific policy fields. For example, the role of experts’ knowledge in policy design and implementation, based on the capacity of technology use (e.g. big data, ICT implementation, etc.), is an emerging issue which the workshop ideally aims to address, with particular attention on policy learning literature. Other contributions might build on the multi-level governance perspective to explore the implications that multi-layered policy arenas do have on policy outcomes: To what extent complex implementation structures represent a hurdle for technological innovation policies or, conversely, whether effective change is more likely to be developed from the bottom up is nowadays a crucial research dilemma. The second one concerns the way in which the adoption of ICT solutions reshapes the structure of bureaucracies, the centralizing and decentralizing strategies of national states and how these cope with sub-national governmental actors. The panel is organized and looks for both theoretical and empirical contributions. From the methodological point of view, the workshop organizers are committed to host papers adopting different methods ranging from small-N qualitative case studies to large-N quantitative analysis. Depending on the homogeneity of the contribution, the organizers are willing to submit special issue or edited book proposals. They also make available a position of third co-chair to scholars interested in building a network on the issues of technological impact on Public Administration and Public Policy. PS prof. Sehl Mellouli (sehl.mellouli@fsa.ulaval.ca) is part of the proposing team.

POLICY TOPICS
SCIENCE, INTERNET AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY
P08. The Design and Organisation of Innovation Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Kopp
I. Brass
ABSTRACT

‘Innovation’ is a trending concept among entrepreneurs and policymakers alike, particularly given the complex problems governments are facing today. However, how do governments actually think about and enact innovation policy that supports science, engineering, and technological advancements? When addressing complex challenges such as climate change, sustainable urban development, or the fourth industrial revolution, how do governments design policies and organise their activity to encourage the adoption of technologies such as renewable energy, smart transport, or the Internet of Things, while also mitigating the (unintended) socio-economic consequences of these disruptive innovations? Taking into account that the socio-technical dimension of innovation includes a large variety of stakeholders, who do governments engage with closely to ensure that innovation strategies are achieved in order to support a responsible adoption of disruptive technologies, furthering public value? Governments have a set of tools at hand to guide innovation (e.g. innovation agencies, delivery units, policy mixes, etc.), yet which instruments and mechanisms are the most successful ones to address these complex issues? Hence, the central question on which this panel will focus is how innovation policy is governed to support desired engineering, scientific, and technological advancements. Innovation policy has most often been studied by looking at questions of policy design that define the overall principles of governance towards socio-technological advancements. However, the way complex problems need to be tackled differs from past experiences, as the state and its policies are developing into a central node in the innovation network (Mazzucato 2017). Similarly, the way public administration scholars have investigated governance challenges, in general, and innovation policy, in particular, can be intensified by looking at the complex policy problems that socio-technical innovations as responses to wicked problems pose today, for instance regarding connected autonomous vehicles (Brass et al. 2017) or the Internet of Things (Brass 2018). Organising innovation, i.e. implementing innovation policies, also demands an understanding of the topology of innovation networks and the challenges that come with it, such as the coordination of stakeholders, also beyond public agencies (Peters 2015, Bouckaert et al. 2010, Braun 2008, Alexander 1993), coordination and innovation within the public sector itself (Pollitt 2003, Christensen & Leagreid 2007, de Vries et al. 2016, Bekkers et al. 2011, Karo & Kattel 2018), or the deployment of particular mechanisms and instruments (Smits & Kuhlmann 2004, Howlett et al. 2006). By addressing these challenges of both design and organisation of innovation policies that have the ambition to bring new technologies into established areas, the panel aims at highlighting best practice and suboptimal examples from which we can learn. In turn, a part of this endeavour also aims at understanding the boundaries of innovation policy, i.e. addressing the challenges innovation policy and its organisation face. Bibliography: Alexander, E.R. (1993). Interorganizational Coordination: Theory and Practice. Journal of Planning Literature, 7(4), 328-340. Bekkers, V., Edelenbos, J. & Steijn, B. (2011). Innovation in the Public Sector. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave. Bouckaert G., Peters, G. & Verhoest K. (2010). The Coordination of Public Sector Organizations. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave. Brass, I.C., Carr, M., Tanczer, L., Maple, C. & Blackstock J. (2017). Unbundling the Emerging Cyber-Physical Risks in Connected and Autonomous Vehicles. In Connected and Autonomous Vehicles: The Emerging Legal Challenges. London, UK: Pinsent Masons. Brass, I.C. (2018). Standardising IoT Security: Implications for Digital Forensics. Digital Forensics Magazine 35, 44-48. Braun, D. (2008). Organising the Political Coordination of Knowledge and Innvoation Policies. Science and Public Policy, 35(4), 227-239. Christensen, T. & Lægreid, P. (2007). The Whole-of-Government Approach to Public Sector Reform. Public Administration Review, 67(6), 1059-1066. De Vries, H., Bekkers, V., & Tummers, L. (2016). Innovation in the Public Sector: A Systematic Review and Future Research Agenda. Public Administration, 94(1), 146-166. Howlett, M., Kim, J. & Weaver, P. (2006). Assessing Instrument Mixes through Program- and Agency-Level Data: Methodological Issues in Contemporary Implementation Research. Review of Policy Research, 23(1), 129-151. Karo, E. & Kattel, R. (2018). Innovation and the State: Towards an Evolutionary Theory of Policy Capacity. In X. Wu, M. Howlett, & M. Ramesh (Eds.), Policy Capacity and Governance (pp. 123–150). Cham, CH: Palgrave. Mazzucato, M. (2017). Mission-Oriented Innovation Policy: Challenges and Opportunities (Working Paper No. 2017–01). London, UK: UCL Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose. Peters, B. G. (2015). Pursuing Horizontal Management: The Politics of Public Sector Coordination. Lawrence, USA: University Press of Kansas. Pollitt, C. (2003). Joined-up Government: a Survey. Political Studies Review, 1, 34-49. Smits, R. & Kuhlmann, S. (2004). The Rise oif Systemic Instruments in Innovation Policy. International Journal of Foresight and Innovation Policy 1(1), 4-32.

POLICY TOPICS
SCIENCE, INTERNET AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY
P02. Understanding Power in Energy Policymaking
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Rinscheid
M. Jegen
ABSTRACT

Securing energy supplies while limiting the environmental consequences of energy production and use is a major challenge for today’s energy systems. As a result, energy policy has risen to the top of national and global political agendas, and many countries are transitioning their energy systems. Historically, energy transitions are complex, protracted and path-dependent processes that are mostly opportunity-driven (by price or technological innovation). By contrast, the transitions that are now called for are problem-driven, seeking to attain a low-carbon future. Climate scientists call for ‘rapid decarbonization’ of energy systems, the latest IPCC report even requires the transformation of the world economy within a few years to avoid most serious damage. The report concludes that rapid change is technically possible, but politically unlikely. In the same vein, policy analysts bemoan a lack of progress in climate and energy policymaking. To be successful, comprehensive energy transitions require that powerful political opposition be overcome. But although there is agreement that these processes require a balance of the interests of various stakeholders in light of different energy policy targets (economic and ecological sustainability, energy justice), the politics of energy transitions remain poorly understood. The focus of this panel is on concepts of power in energy policymaking. Who are the powerful public and private stakeholders? Where are power asymmetries? How do they delay or even stop energy transition processes? Are there power brokers? Even though these are “classical” political science questions, they have a specific relevance in the energy sector where the cost of structural change is concentrated mainly on a small number of actors whose structural position is pivotal in capitalist economies (e.g., electric utilities, oil corporations). Because the power distribution among participants in the policy process shapes societal responses to climate challenges, an improved understanding of power relations and resources can contribute to better assess the political feasibility of policies aimed at accelerating low-carbon transitions. By bringing together scholarship on power in energy policymaking, this panel seeks to disentangle why rapid climate action is unlikely and how it might become more likely. The concentration of power is not constant across time and space, and the successful exercise of power depends on factors such as institutions and agency. This provides fertile ground for comparative studies on the role of power in energy policymaking.

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P03. The Politics of Business in Sustainability Transformations
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Leipold
ABSTRACT

With growing economies, environmental impacts grow. In times where the effects of the impacts increasingly threaten or undermine people’s livelihoods through floods, droughts or plastic pollution, a growing number of policy-makers, activists and scholars ask how we can limit the biophysical impacts of our economy. Although this question is by no means new, the debate about this question has changed during the last decade. Earlier debates propagated CSR initiatives and environmental certification that businesses could pursue ‘on top’ of their usual business model. In the last decade, the ‘greening’ of the economy is increasingly portrayed as opportunity to innovate and change their entire business model to become global ‘frontrunners’ and standard setters. In the EU, some of the most prominent environmental and industrial policy debates are based on this framing, e.g. debates about a circular economy, a bioeconomy or a transition to renewable energy. In these debates, ‘green’ businesses are often described as crucial ‘first movers’ or ‘entrepreneurs’ who should actively shape processes to foster sustainability transformations. Under the framework of the SDGs, these debates have gained additional momentum. A number of scholarly works deals with the role of businesses in policy processes. These stretch across many fields and include environmental policy processes. Yet, this changing role of businesses in environmental policy debates has not been scrutinized systematically across different policy processes so far. This panel aims to kick off a debate among scholars from various areas of environmental policy who cast a critical view on the role and engagement of businesses. It is interested in empirical analyses as well as theory building efforts related to this topic and particularly appreciates interdisciplinary research efforts. Potential research topics include: the evolving nature of governance for sustainability transformation beyond CSR; the nature and significance of partnerships between business and non-governmental actors; business discourses and agency in governance for sustainability transformations; the diversity of theoretical approaches and terminology used to describe the engagement of businesses in sustainability transformations; the legitimacy of business actors in policy processes for sustainability transformations; the extent to which environmental policies strengthening opportunity-seeking have resulted in behavioral change on the part of corporate actors; the impact of business narratives and activities on the initiation of policy processes for sustainability transformations. The key scientific relevance of the panel lies in the limits and possibilities of business actors in sustainability governance; the evolving relationships between business, non-state actors and governments in sustainability governance; and the opportunities to chart and evaluate the contours and direction of contemporary sustainability governance arrangements.

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P07. Development Policy at the Crossroad: What Really Matters for Sustainable Progress?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Grimm
J. Corredor Jimenez
ABSTRACT

The panel aims at revisiting the variety of development strategies and approaches while specifically contrasting international organizations and donor involvement with bottom-up entrepreneurial activities in developing countries. It invites for papers, which describe, assess and evaluate the impact of foreign, top down involvement as well as entrepreneurial bottom-up initiatives preferably in countries and regions of the Global South. The panel further aims at contributing to a vivid discussion about the advantages and drawbacks of classical top-down and alternative bottom-up development approaches. In this context, entrepreneurship is defined in a broader sense referring to start-up activity as well as forms of local, autochthonous capacity building. In 1980, the Brandt Report North-South: A Programme for Survival advocated for the urgent implementation of an emergency program for the Global South that implied monetary transfers but more importantly transfers of knowledge, energy, technology and overall a “massive transfer of resources”. Indigenous technological capacities should be increased through education, and “(…) health care, social development and economic progress must advance interdependently if we are to attain our objectives for the year 2000”. Not only did hunger, global poverty and the number of armed conflicts increase since the Brandt Report was published, but also does Climate Change increasingly put pressure on public policy. We regard the Sustainable development Goals as a continuation of the recommendations made by the Brandt Commission, which illustrate that a sustainable form of progress is still at the core of international development policy. Our panel discussion puts capacity building at national level and local community level into the focus of the discussion. We will address the aforementioned issues in three parts. Firstly, we aim at assessing why past development strategies led to the unsatisfying policy outcomes (Sachs 2018). Secondly, we will analyze what factors contribute to an unsuccessful development policy and give examples of strategies we consider potentially more adequate. We argue that building upon the structures of local institutions and existing ideas within communities can be successful alternatives to top-down approaches. In this context, entrepreneurial activity has proven to be a successful accelerator of local capacity building as it increasingly promotes social and environmental outcomes. We believe that it can contribute to a sustainable progress and the implementation of international climate and sustainability goals (Farinelli et al. 2011). In a third part, we invite participants to discuss about the role of public policy for sustainable development and local capacity strengthening.

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P08. The Politics of Carbon Pricing
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
E. Lachapelle
ABSTRACT

Carbon pricing is often identified as an effective means of reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions at lowest cost. Yet despite endorsement from a broad range of international organizations (e.g. OECD, World Bank, IMF), think tanks and economists of various political orientation, application of this approach continues to be limited in terms of the number of jurisdictions that have formally adopted carbon pricing, sectors covered by the policy, and in the level or stringency of the carbon price. Scholarly attention has focussed mostly on the optimal design of carbon pricing instruments, as well as the political obstacles toward implementing this policy tool. Much less research examines the factors that facilitate the implementation of carbon pricing, or the features that might enhance its durability over time. In this context, the objective of this panel is to bring together scholars from around the world to reflect on and discuss the politics of carbon pricing across jurisdictions, with an emphasis on identifying best practices from international experience and research, as well as drawing lessons from policy failures and carbon price reversals that have occurred across multiple jurisdictions in recent months and years. Key themes in this endeavour include the identification of strategies to overcome political and social opposition to carbon pricing, advanced strategies for communicating benefits to a polarized public, and strategies for enhancing the durability of carbon pricing over time. These strategies might include policy design characteristics around incidence, price escalators, and revenue use ; policy framing, labelling, and packaging ; policy sequencing and coalition building ; as well as advanced strategies for communicating the effectiveness of carbon pricing that involve framing, counter framing, narration, and use of different messengers. Moving beyond the obstacles facing optimal carbon pricing toward a focus on identifying strategies for implementation in a second-best setting is important for several reasons. First, carbon pricing is being considered by a large number of countries as a means of implementing targets submitted as national contributions to the Paris Agreement, yet it has also become a hotly contested political issue with several high profile reversals (e.g. Australia, Ontario) offering insight into the strategies actors have used to defend and repeal this policy tool. Insight into what works and doesn’t is crucial for governments looking to implement carbon pricing at home. Second, the amount of solid theoretical and empirical work on carbon price politics has increased in recent years, yet this research has for the most part focused on obstacles to optimal design and conducted on single case studies, with fewer studies looking at strategies to overcome these obstacles and even fewer taking an international or comparative approach. Third, much potential exists to develop more theoretical accounts of climate policy implementation and durability, by mobilizing existing theories of the policy process and behavioural public policy. The panel will thus help foster dialogue and learning among scholars working in a variety of jurisdictions, while allowing for an initial stock taking of findings from this literature to identify what works and doesn’t across space and time, with more careful attention to theorizing how and why carbon pricing might overcome political and popular resistance.

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P09. Urban Environmental Governance and Policy in Metropolises of the Global South
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
K. Frey
J. Gutberlet
P. JACOBI
ABSTRACT

Metropolises in the Global South face complex, multifaceted challenges in the search for more liveability and sustainable development paths. Besides the currently dominant global environmental agenda with its focus on climate change, biodiversity, environmental security, and sustainable lifestyles, there are still more basic urban matters in the Global South that need attention, above all concerning urban services and infrastructure in the field of water, sanitation and waste, but also related to poor housing conditions, transportation, public health and education and organized crime. Not surprisingly, the metropolises of the Global South perform poorly in the UN-Habitat prosperity index (UN-Habitat, 2015; Nagendra et al., 2018). Considering (1) that global sustainability depends necessarily on sustainable transformation of the cities in the Global South, where most of the future increases of resource and energy consumption, and of greenhouse gas emissions will take place, (2) the fact that most of the research on urban sustainability is shaped and dominated by scholars from the Global North (Nagendra et al. 2018), and (3) that urban development strategies in the Global South have typically followed blueprints and standard solutions from northern countries and international development agencies, frequently contributing to environmental degradation, undermining actively local control and capacity, and suppressing alternative development paths in accordance with local conditions and potentialities (Korten, 2006) , and (4) that in the context of the developing world the claim for social inclusiveness is paramount (Gupta & Vegelin, 2016), this panel aims at exploring alternative, situated Global South-specific approaches to urban sustainable development from governance and policy perspectives (Lawhon et al, 2017) in view of the complex everyday challenges posed to meeting the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and the New Urban Agenda (NUA). Thus, the main research questions guiding the papers and discussions in this panel are the following: What are the particularities of practices in urban environmental governance and policy in metropolises of the Global South? Is there a distinct Global South approach and situated context of urban environmental governance and policy arising? Are there proper conceptual approaches in the field of environmental governance and public policy in line with these particular challenges of Global South metropolises? Starting from the hypotheses that there is the need for an appropriate Southern approach on environmental governance and public policy in the Global South in order to arrive at a more comprehensive view of the possibilities of global sustainability and of viable, alternative, socially sensitive and environmentally oriented policy strategies in metropolises of the Global South, the panel intends to bring together papers involving: Theories and concepts on environmental governance and public policy from a specific Global South perspective, including theoretical concerns related to democracy, participation, (environmental) policy analysis, social inclusion, social and environmental justice. Methodological approaches on public policies and policy analysis related to metropolises in the Global South Case studies and comparative studies (South-South or North-South) on innovative policy and governance experiences in Global South metropolises. Theoretical discussions on the praxis of southern city governance and policy making. References Gupta, J. & Vegelin, C. (2016). Sustainable development goals and inclusive development. Int Environ Agreements, 16: 433-448 Korten, D.C. (2006). The great turning: From empire to earth community. Bloomfield, San Francisco: Kumarian Press, Berrett-Koehler Publishers. Lawhon, M.; Nilsson, D. Silver, J.; Ernstson, H. & Lwasa, S. (2017) Thinking through heterogeneous infrastructure configurations. Urban Studies, 55 (4): 720 – 732 Nagendra, H.; Bai, X.; Brondizio, E.S & Lwasa, S. The urban South and the predicament of global sustainability. Nature Sustainability, v.1, 341-349. UN-Habitat (2015). The City prosperity initiative. 2015 Global City Report.

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P10. Policy Integration for Boundary-Spanning Policy Problems: Climate Change Mitigation and Adaptation Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
R. Biesbroek
A. Lesnikowski
D. Henstra
ABSTRACT

Mitigating climate change and adapting to its impacts requires coordinated responses across different administrative levels, policy fields, and sectors. As in other complex policy fields, coordinating policy efforts is critical to avoid fragmentation, duplication, problem displacement, high transaction costs and policy over- or under-reaction. In many countries, the State plays a critical leadership role in coordinating climate policy efforts and integrating climate change into bureaucratic and institutional structures to ensure timely and effective outcomes. Policy coordination and integration has several dimensions, including horizontal (between different departments, agencies or sectors), vertical (between different administrative levels), and diagonal (between different departments across different levels). However, States have responded differently to the governance challenge climate change poses. Whereas some have chosen a strong “mainstreaming” approach, whereby climate policy is integrated within existing structures and programs, others have created dedicated institutions to coordinate responses across levels and sectors. Recently, several novel, hybrid modes of governance have emerged that cross-cut traditional scales and policy fields, and involve diverse non-state actors. Despite the role that policy integration processes play in climate action, there are few comprehensive studies that examine systematically how coordination and integration is taking place. Rather than critically engaging with existing theories to better understand why and how coordination and integration works, the climate change scholarship tends to use these concepts as descriptive tools to explain the structure of governing environments in which policy action takes place, vaguely referencing a lack of coordination as a barrier to successful climate policy actions and/or as a normative goal. More rigorous and theory-driven empirical assessment of policy coordination and integration across government levels, policy fields, and sectors is needed.

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P11. The Role of Public Environmental Policy in Governing Global Interlinkages
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Lenschow
J. Newig
E. Challies
ABSTRACT

This panel aims to add a public policy perspective to the literature global environmental governance and impacts of globalization. We are particularly interested in the governance of the environmental implications of global interconnections, such as commodity chains or global production networks. While the global environmental governance literature tends to focus on the global commons, particular global interconnections mean that localized human activity (production or consumption) can have repercussions in distant places across the globe. In line with literatures on global social-ecological systems, we describe such phenomena as ‘telecoupling’ (Liu et al. 2013; Friis and Nielsen 2017) – though papers using alternative concepts are welcome – and point to significant challenges for environmental governance (Lenschow et al. 2016; Eakin et al. 2017). First, there is the problem of scale, as neither local nor global governance capture the specific flows connecting distant places. Second, there is the issue of transparency, as distant implications of local actions may not be visible (as they are locally contained) or easily traceable due to complex global production and trading networks. Third, there is the issue of cross-sectoral impacts escaping classical issue-focused global environmental governance arrangements. Attempts to study, and indeed to govern, globally interconnected phenomena and their often-local environmental impacts have remained relatively isolated (Dauvergne and Clapp 2016). Different strands of academic literature have analyzed global connections and their environmental implications, as well as institutional arrangements, agencies and actors to govern the global environment. Two relevant strands stand out in particular (Biermann et al. 2009; Pattberg and Widberg 2015): One strand focusses on global governance arrangements and the prospect of an encompassing authoritative international environmental organization. This work does not capture specifically interconnected relations, however. The other strand focusses on transnational private and multi-stakeholder arrangements, zooming in on relevant, but often isolated governance measures largely “beyond the state”. On the practical level, an authoritative global governance structure seems only a distant option, while many private and multi-stakeholder initiatives encounter problems of accountability and limited effectiveness. This panel will address the challenges of governing globally interconnected – ‘telecoupled’ – phenomena and discuss questions such as: 1. Given the multitude of private and multi-stakeholder initiatives on the one hand, and their limited effectiveness on the other, what could be the role of public policy therein? How could private governance of complex global commodity chains and public governance approaches be better coordinated? What role does (or could) public policy play to co-ordinate, harmonize or orchestrate existing international private environmental standards? 2. What kinds of institutions could manage social and environmental trade-offs across multiple scales? What role does (or could) national public policy play in addressing the distant effects (cross-border externalities) of corporate activities. How might flow-based and place-based (jurisdictional) approaches be coordinated? 3. How do we explain the selective uptake of specific distant impacts (e.g. deforestation) in governance initiatives, while other impacts (e.g. the loss of access to land and water of local populations) are disregarded? How might environmental impacts that are masked and often ignored be addressed between distant places?

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P15. Climate Policies: The Role of Preferences and Perceptions
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Pianta
A. Rinscheid
ABSTRACT

The latest Special Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change places strong emphasis on the importance of ambitious public policies for the decarbonization of our economies. While a considerable body of research on the effectiveness and ‘optimal design’ of public policies to reach the goals of the Paris Climate Agreement already exists, we still know much less about public perceptions and policymakers’ preferences toward different policy options, and how these are shaped. However, when gauging the political feasibility of different decarbonization pathways, public perceptions and preferences are a crucial factor. Against this background, this panel aims at furthering our understanding of citizens’ and policymakers’ appetite for public policies that contribute to the decarbonization and increased environmental sustainability of our societies. Prior studies have already shown that specific policy design features can have an important impact on citizens’ policy preferences, and that socio-psychological and contextual factors like policy endorsements by visible political actors can influence public opinion and policy attitudes, especially in contexts where political polarization is high and/or environmental and energy policies are perceived as particularly controversial. Given the pace required to avert irreversible harmful changes to the Earth’s climate, the determinants of perceptions and preferences toward ambitious climate policies deserve further investigation. For instance, research on climate policy preferences has to date underinvestigated the dynamics of preference change in competitive elite environments, as well as the factors that drive pro-climate policy preferences in light of issue competition. Other important research avenues concern the identification of factors that influence the salience of climate change as a public policy problem, also considering the potential trade-offs of climate policies with other policies. Moreover, in light of the urgency of actions required to meet climate goals, the temporal dimension of policy preferences gains in importance. Reaching a deeper understanding of preferences and public opinion regarding climate policies, of their distribution across time and space, and of mechanisms of preference formation and change, can give crucial insights into the feasibility of different pathways to decarbonization. We encourage work that examines climate policies, but also welcome contributions focusing on perceptions and preferences in the context of sectoral public policies with a nexus to climate change – e.g. agriculture, energy, transportation. Importantly, the panel gives particular importance to interdisciplinary dialogue. We welcome empirical studies employing different approaches and methodologies. Apart from perspectives rooted in public opinion and elite studies, behavioral sciences can provide useful insights into mechanisms of preference formation and heterogeneities in perceptions of public policies.

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P16. The Role of Public Policymaking in the Termination of Unsustainable Technologies, Products, and Practices
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Rinscheid
ABSTRACT

Since the 1970s, humankind annually consumes more natural resources than the planet can regenerate. Despite important technological advances in some areas, current ways of doing business are environmentally unsustainable, and the consequences of interlinked processes such as climate change, ocean acidification, deforestation, and environmental pollution could have dramatic impacts for live on Earth. Importantly, a sustainability transformation of the world’s economies requires environmentally unsustainable technologies, products, and practices to be terminated. A focus on the termination of technologies, products, and practices has recently emerged in the technology and innovation studies literature, where these phenomena are described as “phase-out”, “exnovation”, or “creative destruction” (Heyen et al. 2017; Kivimaa & Kern 2016; Turnheim & Geels 2012). Public policy scholars, on the other hand, have paid scant attention to these problems. This is unfortunate because there is not only wide consensus that public policies are necessary to govern societies into an era of environmental sustainability, but also an apprehension among policy practitioners and stakeholders that strategies to overcome political barriers to termination are urgently needed. In no other area than in the context of climate change is the necessity of termination more obvious. The Paris climate agreement aims at limiting anthropogenic global warming to well below 2° Celsius compared to pre-industrial levels. This means that 80 percent of the world's coal reserves, a third of oil reserves, and 50 percent of gas reserves must remain in the ground (McGlade & Ekins 2015). However, various studies point to “alarming inconsistencies” between climate targets and public policies enacted so far (Rockström et al. 2017, 1269). In particular, meeting the agreed climate targets means that carbon-based technologies, products, and practices need to be terminated timely (Pfeiffer et al. 2018), which requires “dedicated and well-designed policies” (Edenhofer et al. 2018, 1). Yet, instead of terminating unsustainable technologies, most governments engage in policy layering by implementing support schemes for sustainable technologies, while avoiding to dismantle existing fossil fuel systems (Stokes & Breetz 2018).On the other hand, examples of successfully steered phase-outs exist, such as the Canadian province of Ontario, which became the first North American jurisdiction to terminate electricity generation based on coal-fired power plants in 2014. The problem of terminating environmentally unsustainable technologies, products, and practices is often boundary-spanning and relevant not only for the energy sector, but also for transportation, agriculture and forestry, and a wide range of industrial sectors. What is needed is a more systematic assessment of the factors that determine the success or failure of termination policies, including a focus on how the design of public policies and policy instruments influences their acceptance among voters and businesses, the configuration of policies as part of entire transformation policy mixes, political opportunity structures, and policy feedbacks. References: Edenhofer, O., Steckel, J.C., Jakob, M., and Bertram, C., 2018. "Reports of coal’s terminal decline may be exaggerated", Environ. Res. Lett. 13 024019.Heyen, Dirk A., Hermwille, L., and Wehnert, T., 2017. "Out of the comfort zone! Governing the exnovation of unsustainable technologies and practices", Gaia 26, 4, pp. 326-331. Kivimaa, P., and Kern, F., 2016. "Creative destruction or mere niche support? Innovation policy mixes for sustainability transitions", Research Policy 45, 1, pp. 205-217.McGlade, C., and Ekins, P., 2015. "The geographical distribution of fossil fuels unused when limiting global warming to 2 degrees Celsius", Nature 517, 7533, pp. 187-190.Pfeiffer, A., Hepburn, C., Vogt-Schilb, A., and Caldecott, B., 2018. "Committed emissions from existing and planned power plants and asset stranding required to meet the Paris Agreement", Environ. Res. Lett. 13, 054019.Rockström, J., Gaffney, O., Rogelj, J., Meinshausen, M., Nakicenovic, N., and Schellnhuber, H. J., 2017. "A Roadmap for Rapid Decarbonization", Science 355, 6331, pp. 1269-1271.Stokes, L.C., and Breetz, H.L., 2018. "Politics in the U.S. energy transition: Case studies of solar, wind, biofuels and electric vehicles policy", Energy Policy 113, pp. 76--86.Turnheim, B. and Geels, F.W., 2012. "Regime destabilisation as the flipside of energy transitions: Lessons from the history of the British coal industry (1913 – 1997)", Energy Policy 50, pp. 35-49.

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P17. Contested Knowledge and Expertise in Sustainability Politics
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
U. Zeigermann
M. Böcher
ABSTRACT

In an era of digitalization and climate change, new questions are revolving around the issue of knowledge and expertise in sustainability politics. The emergence of new information and communications technologies (ICTs) and increasing skepticism in (scientific) experts have fundamentally changed the dynamics of knowledge production and circulation in society: Established knowledge and academic research on the environment and climate is questioned beyond the necessary critical debate of scientific evidence (“Fake News”, “Fake Science”, “The Death of Expertise” Nichols, 2017). At the same time, information based on personal experience and opinion can be widely disseminated through social media and increasingly influences policy processes. What are the consequences of these developments for political decision-making and for the analysis of public policies? Traditionally, research on the role of knowledge for public policies has focused on tensions between the role of experts and democratic decision-making processes. This panel seeks to provide a platform to challenge, update and adapt well-established theories and approaches focusing on sustainability politics. The high level of complexity, uncertainty and urgency pertaining to sustainability policy in times of climate change emphasizes the importance of analyzing and rethinking the implications of contested knowledge and expertise in sustainability politics. Political decision-makers depend more than ever on expert knowledge to make informed decisions on critical and interdependent phenomena affecting global sustainable development within the ecological planetary boundaries. While scientists are, however, often contradicting each-other and providing vague information based on their research, other actors are offering alternative explanations and simple solutions for environmental problems, mostly reflecting their subjective understanding of the situation. Who is considered to be an expert on sustainability and how are diverse ‘experts’ interacting with political decision-makers (e.g. role of professionals vs. laypersons as policy entrepreneurs)? Which knowledge is used and how in sustainability politics (e.g. role of transdisciplinary global networks in sustainability governance)? What are the consequences for sustainability policy, at different levels? This panel aims to deepen the debate on how contested knowledge and expertise is affecting sustainability politics. It is open to theoretical, empirical and methodological papers in order to advance our understanding on the production, integration and use of scientific evidence versus perceived realities in public policy processes on complex and urgent questions related to sustainability.

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P19. Beyond Typologies: Innovation in the Study of Environmental Policy Instruments
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Rayner
M. Hurlbert
I. Mukherjee
ABSTRACT

The objective of this panel is to bring together scholars working in a variety of methodological traditions and jurisdictions to learn from each other about new ways of conceptualizing environmental policy instruments. Ultimately, the goals are to move the study of environmental policy instruments beyond the traditional typologies and to cross fertilize two research agendas that are currently somewhat disconnected: the study of the relationship between policy instruments and governance modes; and the study of the effectiveness of different instruments and instrument mixes. Perhaps more so than in other policy sectors, environmental policy has often been rather simply characterized as the adoption (or failure to adopt) certain kinds of of policy instruments. From “licensing and permitting” to standard setting, from carbon taxes to output-based allowances there has been an almost universal tendency to focus on solutions rather than problems and to group these solutions in rather simple ways using familiar typologies. Two, largely unrelated, developments are pushing students of environmental policy beyond these classification exercises. One is the attempt to explain instrument choice and the persistence of particular instruments as the product of particular governance arrangements; the other is the study of the effectiveness of instruments in actually improving environmental quality or mitigating damage. In both cases, researchers have been pushed to think about policy instruments differently. In the former case, for example, by considering how notionally similar instruments may behave very differently in different institutional contexts; in the latter case, in considering how similar instruments may differ across dimensions such as intensity or density. Many of the more vexing questions raised by treating policy instruments this way – uncertainty about the dependent variable, vagueness about units of analysis, competing conceptualization of dimensions – have received careful treatment in studies from which researchers working in one field could learn from the other how to advance their own research agenda and even hold out the possibility of a synthesis of output and outcome based studies of environmental policy instruments.

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P20. Sustainable Development, Environment Governance and Urban Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
I. Sodhi
L. Ching
M. Dixit
ABSTRACT

3.5 billion People, half of the world’s population, live in urban areas. In the coming decades, 95 percent of urban expansion will take place in the developing world. By 2050, the urban population is expected to reach 6.5 billion. Cities occupy just 3 percent of the Earth’s land but account for 60 to 80 percent of energy consumption and 75 percent of carbon emissions. In 1990, there were 10 cities with 10 million inhabitants or more; by 2014, the number of “mega-cities” had reached 28, home to a total 453 million people. Sustainable development cannot be achieved without significantly transforming the way we build and manage our urban spaces. According to Brundtland Commission in its 1987 report “Our Common Future”, “Sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present, without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.” Since the Brundtland Report, the concept of sustainable development has developed beyond the initial intergenerational framework to focus more on the goal of "socially inclusive and environmentally sustainable economic growth. Probably most of the major environmental problems of the next century will result from the continuation and sharpening of existing problems that currently do not receive enough political attention. The most emerging issues are climate changes, freshwater scarcity, deforestation, and fresh water pollution and population growth. These problems are very complex and their interactions are hard to define. It is very important to examine problems through the political, cultural, social-economic and technological system. Even the interconnections between environmental problems are now better known, we still lack exact information on how the issues are linked, on what degree they interact and what are the most effective measures. Questions in respect to environment, sustainable development and urban policy arising are: 1. How increasing urbanization is affecting environment? 2. Whether expanding urbanization is one of the reasons for climate change? 3. Whether developing countries are formulating effecting policies for urban development to check environment governance? 4. How sustainable development could help in environment governance in cities? 5. How ICT could be applied for environment governance in cities leading to sustainable development? There is complete eradication of habitats as an outcome of urbanization and native species are pushed out of cities. Activities in cities release a wide range of emissions into the environment including carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, ozone, sulfur oxides, nitrogen oxides, lead, and many other pollutants. Pollutants are often dispersed across cities. Burying tremendous amounts of waste in the ground at municipal and industrial dumps is posing a threat to human life and health. In respect to environment, sustainable development stands for: to promote development without causing harm to the environment, to make use of environmentally friendly practices, and to minimize the depletion of natural resources. The goal of environmental sustainability in cities is to conserve natural resources and to develop alternate sources of power while reducing pollution and harm to the environment.

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P21. Engaging Communication for a Sustainable Future: From Commitment to Concrete Action
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Tremblay
ABSTRACT

Since the first awakenings of environmental consciousness in the public sphere and the questioning of endless economic growth raising the alarm about the Earth’s non-infinite resources (Carson, 1962; Club of Rome, 1972), as well as the international recognition of the definition of sustainable development (Brundtland Report, 1987), major global events have reinforced the urgency of acting to ensure a sustainable future on Earth. In addition, regulations and national awareness-raising campaigns have been planned. Laws have been put in place. Research groups and programs have been created to respond to a growing demand for knowledge on these issues. More recently, the historic Paris Agreement on climate change (COP21, 2015), the UN Sustainable Development Goals calling for action in every part of the world (2016) , and, a few weeks ago, the urgent warning raised by the world’s leading climate scientists about irreversible damage that will occur in years from now if we do not take action (IPCC Special Report, 2018), all share the same dramatic message: unprecedented and immediate changes are needed. However, studies on communication practices in sustainable development have shown a slow progression by communication professionals. Public commitments have brought together communicators from many fields around the importance of promoting the values ​​of sustainable development in their activities, but today's issues call for accountability and action. Governments need to act. Effective public policies should be implemented. And communication is central. All at once engaging, active, dialogical, and participatory, communication for sustainable development requires solid roots that are both practical and conceptual. After 30 years, what are its major achievements?

POLICY TOPICS
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT, ENVIRONMENT AND POLICY
P01. Public Policy Approaches to Protecting and Enhancing Minority Rights
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Moreno
N. Perry
ABSTRACT

The proposed panel seeks to achieve three key objectives: · Identify topical areas where the design and implementation of different policy approaches can advance equal rights and opportunities for minority and other marginalized populations; · Highlight topical areas where existing policy approaches are currently hindering the equal rights of minority and other marginalized populations directly or indirectly; and · Explore different methodological approaches to systematically learning about the approaches that countries or other polities take to strengthening equal rights and opportunities for minority and other marginalized populations. There has long been international agreement on the importance of extending equal rights and opportunities to groups that have been historically marginalized. Seventy years ago, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights guaranteed equal rights regardless of “race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other status.” More recently, United Nations member countries unanimously committed through the Sustainable Development Goals to “leave no one behind,” while more targeted international treaties like the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities have underscored the need to address barriers to equal rights faced by specific groups in detail. At the same time, marginalized groups such as migrants, refugees, and LGBTQ populations continue to face legal and practical constraints around the world. To better understand how rights for minority and other marginalized groups can be advanced or constrained, it is critical to analyze how policy approaches at different levels function: In what settings do countries or other polities guarantee equal rights or prohibit discrimination on the basis of disability, migration status, sexual orientation and gender identity, or other grounds? To what extent do common legal or policy provisions include or exclude minority and other marginalized groups, thus enhancing or endangering their rights? How can these provisions be leveraged to advance equal rights and opportunities for these groups in practice? This panel will be chaired by researchers from the WORLD Policy Analysis Center (WORLD) at the University of California Los Angeles. WORLD is committed to strengthening equal rights and opportunities worldwide by (1) identifying the most effective policy approaches for improving individual wellbeing and enabling countries to thrive, with a focus on the worst-off; (2) improving the quantity and quality of globally comparative data on laws and policies that work to support equal rights and opportunities, especially for marginalized populations; and (3) working in partnership to advance evidence-based improvements in countries worldwide. The panel will focus primarily on methodological and empirical approaches to understanding which marginalized groups have their rights alternatively enhanced or constrained by laws or policies worldwide, what approaches – national or otherwise – are being implemented in relevant policy domains, and to what extent these policies can advance equality for the world’s most historically marginalized groups.

POLICY TOPICS
INEQUALITIES AND PUBLIC POLICY
P02. Addressing Food and Nutrition Disparities Through Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Mah
M. Ferguson
A. Thow
ABSTRACT

Diet-related causes are the leading preventable risk factor for death and disability globally, and the opportunity to consume a healthy diet is unequally shared. The escalation in diet-related diseases in the 20th and 21st centuries reflects a population nutrition transition, with a rapid rise in noncommunicable diseases and obesity as societies, economies, and environments transform. Food and beverages that are energy dense and nutrient poor have become widely available, and industry consolidation in food production, processing, distribution, and retailing have altered people’s participation and power in the food system, from producers to consumers. Many of these changes have accompanied a shift to residence in urban environments, and a widening gap exists in optimizing food and nutrition for rural and remote populations, as well as low income communities. Alongside overconsumption, inadequate caloric and nutrient intake has persisted worldwide. This has created an unprecedented mixed state of diet-related poor health worldwide, termed the ‘double burden’ of malnutrition. The United Nations proclaimed 2016-2025 a Decade of Action on Nutrition, linked to the Sustainable Development Goals, to recognize this profound challenge. The aim of this panel is to interrogate the tensions in policy formulation, implementation, and evaluation for contemporary food and nutrition inequities, with a focus on increasing access to affordable healthy food across the population. The papers in this session will include, but will not be limited to, the following debates: · Problematization of food insecurity as an issue of economic versus geographic access · Framing of nutrition policies and the relative responsibilities of individual, state, and market · Implementation of intersectoral action for food system transformation, including the role of business in promoting healthy diets · Food and the intersection of public and private spheres · Authority and accountability for food in an era of networked governance · Evaluating natural policy experiments in food and nutrition · Food policy practices: meaning-making among diverse actors in food and nutrition policy and advocacy · Enshrining the right to food, food sovereignty, and Indigenous food systems in public policy · Where food policy meets food law: regulatory frameworks and inequalities

POLICY TOPICS
INEQUALITIES AND PUBLIC POLICY
P03. Migration and Health: Global Journeys Through Policy and Practice
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Wylie
L. Wylie
ABSTRACT

High numbers of people moving around the globe has drawn attention to migrant needs across a range of areas. In recent years, hundreds of thousands of refugees have arrived in host countries across the world, often in communities that have not experienced high levels of immigration before. The ability and willingness of these countries to address the needs of newcomers are being challenged on a number of fronts. Migrant families face a wide range of challenges along the journey as well as during the transition to life in the host community. Reasons for leaving their home countries are varied, but many newcomers have experienced traumatic circumstances including exposure to war, violence, extreme poverty, natural disasters, religious persecution, and political repression. The resettlement process of finding housing, suitable employment, entering the school system, and learning the language of the host country add new challenges for this population. In addition, migrants are increasingly encountering attitudes of discrimination and exclusion. These pre-migration and settlement experiences coupled with difficulties in acculturation to a new country can lead to severe and long-lasting health issues. There is growing recognition and concern regarding the health care needs of refugees and recent immigrants, given the high levels of trauma and stress people have experienced, combined with the lower access and utilization of many health services. The policies that lead to migration, direct the journey, and shape the settlement process effect all aspects of the experiences of migrants. These policies perpetuate inequities and social exclusion in a multitude of ways, in all aspects of the lives of migrating people. Examples include access to health and social care, housing, education, as well processes of gaining legal formal status, or recognition of education or professional experience in the receiving country. These all have a profound impact on the health of migrant and their families. This panel will focus on the global, regional and national policy contexts that shape the everyday experiences of health and health care of migrating people and families.

POLICY TOPICS
INEQUALITIES AND PUBLIC POLICY
P01. The Resurgence of Economic Nationalism vs. "Progressive" Trade Agenda: Issues and Strategies
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Paquin
ABSTRACT

Since 2017, the Government of Canada is promoting a “progressive” agenda in international trade. Canada is indeed officially encouraging a more equitable, “middle-to-lower-class” centered approach to world trade and regional trade. To implement such an approach, Canada is trying to include new social and environmental dispositions to it free-trade agreements. The Canadian government hopes to reform commercial treaties on a number of aspects, such as working conditions, environmental protection, gender equality, and the rights of First Nations. This “progressive” trade agenda was, for instance, among the themes of the Canadian G7 Summit held in 2018. Yet, this agenda clashes with the rise of populism and the resurgence of economic nationalism around the globe. Besides, it also clashes with some of the trade practices of Canada itself. Shortly after President Donald Trump entered office for example, a presidential decree was signed which ended the United States’ participation in the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP). This treaty (not devoid of nationalist motivations in the first place) was notably devised as a counterweight against China and was signed in 2015 by twelve countries in Asia and the Pacific, including Canada and the US, which together represented 40% of the world’s GDP. Following the withdrawal of the US, Canada partook in new discussions with the ten other partners of the original agreement to conclude a new “Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP) including additional exceptions on culture, intellectual property, and foreign investment. On the other hand, Canada’s wish to conclude such a multilateral deal also reflected its own, strategic commercial repositioning toward Asia in reaction to the rise of American protectionism, a repositioning which can help explain some of its contradictory positions on the environment, the rights of First Nations, and the Trans-Mountain pipeline project. During the first months of its presidency moreover, Trump imposed a renegotiation of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), presented as the “worst trade deal of all time,” on its Canadian and Mexican partners. It should be recalled, however, that this is not the first time that Canada and the world have to face the US’ protectionist inclinations. In the early and mid-1980s, the Reagan administration (1981-1989) considered the trade practices of Japan, Europe and the “Asian Tigers” as detrimental to the US economy. Harsh criticisms were also addressed to Mexico, China and NAFTA during the presidential elections which saw Bill Clinton (1992) and Barack Obama (2007) elected to the White House. The words of Clinton’s adversary, Ross Perot, who evoked the “giant sucking sound” of jobs leaving for Mexico, or the words of Obama himself who described NAFTA as “unjust” for workers and as having never benefited the US, were still resonating during the last presidential campaign. Canada’s “progressive” agenda, besides, is reminiscent of the Clinton administration’s which insisted on reopening NAFTA to include parallel agreements on working standards and the environment. On the other side of the Atlantic, on June 23rd, 2016, a slight majority of British citizens voted in favor of the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union. Following this referendum, the British government currently headed by Theresa May adopted an aggressive posture by promoting the UK’s complete withdrawal from both the EU’s Customs Union and Single Market, and by prioritizing new “bilateral” negotiations with Commonwealth countries, notably. Despite the positive discourses of Canadian Prime Minister Trudeau, German Chancellor Merkel, or French President Macron, pessimism with regards to free trade is palpable everywhere. Paradoxically we are witnessing a communist dictatorship, of which a large part of the economy is dependent on state corporations and public investment, become one of the most important proponents of free trade. Chinese President Xi Jinping, indeed, presented himself as a fervent advocate of globalization and trade liberalization in its opening speech at the 2017 World Economic Forum in Davos. According to him, “globalization has powered global growth and facilitated movement of goods and capital, advances in science, technology and civilization, and interactions among peoples.” Other world leaders, such as Japan’s Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, opted for a low-profile approach and prioritized direct bilateral contacts with the new American President to remind him of the economic and security interest linking their countries. In any case however, “national” interests now seem to override liberal principles. In this context, Canada’s “progressive” agenda seems to clash with the increasingly nationalist and protectionist turn that characterizes international political economy since 2008. The objective of this conference is to take stock of the true meaning of such an agenda, and of the ways in which the resurgence of economic nationalism – in the US, Europe and Asia – is forcing Canada and other industrialized countries to rethink their commercial strategies. These issues will be addressed from different angles – theoretical, historical, commercial, fiscal, legal, political, diplomatic, military, environmental, and social – by foremost experts from Quebec, Canada, the US, Europe and Asia. This conference is thus meant to be on of the first meeting points for academics working on international trade and economic nationalism, in a context where it has become impossible to invoke one without invoking the other.

POLICY TOPICS
GLOBAL POLICY
P02. Bridging Science and Diplomacy in Global Policymaking
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Ravinet
M. Young
C. Sá
ABSTRACT

The notion of “science diplomacy” has gained increasing political and scientific attention. But, in spite of this interest in academia and politics, there is not a shared definition or conceptualisation of the term. “Science diplomacy” might appear as a catchy label referring to the multi faceted interplay between science and diplomacy, and consequently to the multiple patterns of articulation between science policy and foreign policy. The now classical distinctions of Diplomacy for Science, Science for Diplomacy, and Science in Diplomacy were developed in a Royal Society report from 2010. More recently, there have been attempts to revisit these types by, for example, focusing more pragmatically on the interplay of national, transnational, and global needs and interests (Gluckman et al 2017). The S4D4C project in its state-of-the-art report distinguishes between the explicit discourse of science diplomacy and the set of practices that fall at the interface between science, science policy and foreign policy, which may or may not be given the official label of science diplomacy (Rungius et al 2018). An on-going Canadian research program is examining some of these practices through the lens of theories of the policy process, elucidating the range of actors and ideas involved in science diplomacy (Sá et al 2018). Research into the topic in Europe has intensified with the EU having funded three Horizon 2020 projects, beginning with EL-SCID in 2016 and S4D4C and InsSciDE in 2017. In this panel we ask: How can we better understand and conceptualize the practice of science diplomacy using public policy tools and approaches? There is still a large overarching policy question regarding how science diplomacy actually works. What are the processes of science diplomacy? How can it be theorized? Does each type of science diplomacy require separate theorization or is there a common thread that can be found? Who counts as a science diplomat? What are the roles of different actors in science diplomacy? How do scientists and diplomats interact? What are the interfaces between the two? How do the different logics of science and diplomacy conflict and get resolved? How does scientific knowledge make its way into diplomacy and foreign policy? Public policy research offers a set of approaches and tools that are extremely relevant to make sense of the development of science diplomacy: - Questioning policy sectors: Science diplomacy questions the boundaries, interfaces and frictions between distinct policy sectors (science policy and foreign policy). - Questioning complex policymaking: Many global policy challenges are becoming more complex and global in nature and call for more coordinated and science-driven solution. - Questioning the evolving role of the national policy state: the development of science diplomacy does not mean the decline of the state. It can also be understood as a policy of constructing soft power, and re-negotiating the role of the state in transnational multilevel governance. - Questioning the growing diversity and hybridity of policy actors: Science diplomacy challenges the traditional role of the diplomat, opening possibilities for non-officials and IOs to function in diplomatic processes. “This panel is organised in the framework of the S4D4C project, which has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 770342. The papers presented reflect only the authors’ view, and the Research Executive Agency is not responsible for any use that may be made of the information it contains.”

POLICY TOPICS
GLOBAL POLICY
P03. Private Governance and Public Policy in Global Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
B. Eberlein
J. Marques
V. Schneider
ABSTRACT

This panel proposes to investigate the changing interaction of private and public actors in global governance arrangements from a perspective of political contestation. The past two decades have seen a tremendous proliferation of non-state regulatory initiatives, schemes and organizations to govern business conduct andthe social and environmental conditions of global production (Abbott & Snidal, 2009; Bartley, 2007; Vogel, 2010). Mostly characterized as transnational private regulation or governance (Bartley, 2007; Graz & Nölke, 2008), these schemes range in institutional character from industry codes of conduct to multi-stakeholder and hybrid institutions, such as the Ethical Trading Initiative or the Forest Stewardship Council. They address issue areas as diverse as agricultural and forestry practices (Auld, 2014; Cashore et al., 2004; Grabs, 2018), financial reporting (Buthe & Mattli, 2011), labour standards (Fransen, 2011), and carbon markets (Green, 2010). While earlier scholarship looked to these non-state arrangements to fill governance gaps left by governments perceived as absent or failing (Cashore et al., 2004; Scherer & Palazzo, 2011), there is an emerging consensus in the literature that governments and public policy remain central to the success or failure of private governance arrangements (Locke, 2013; Toffel et al., 2015). Recent scholarship has begun to foreground the private-public regulatory nexus (Knudsen & Moon, 2017)and the prominent role of governments(Bartley, 2014); and it has started to conceptualize and investigate patters of interaction between public and private actors (Bartley, 2011; Eberlein et al., 2014; Green & Auld, 2017; Gulbrandsen, 2014). However, the extant literature has tended to adopt a problem-solving, “collaboration narrative” perspective (Coen & Pegram, 2015, p. 418)or a functional, “market-based” approach examining the demand and supply of private governance. Such a lens neglects important questions concerning the political nature of the phenomenon, particularly the political interests and strategies that inform the engagement of public and private actors, as well as political conflicts that often result. We therefore propose to focus on the following research question: how does “politics” or political contestation, i.e. the political interests, strategies and conflicts of the public and private parties involved, affect the regulatory outcomes and impact of public-private interaction? We know little about which combinations of public and private engagement may generate larger public-interest contributions, and, in particular, what role political contestation and conflict play in determining the trajectory and results of public-private interaction.We do know that governments decide to support, adopt, or counter-act private governance initiatives and organizations not only based on considerations of policy efficiency; they also follow political calculus, which, we hypothesize, often reflects the influence of domestic industry or other organized interests. For example, there is increasing evidence that governments in the Global South seek to reassert control over Northern production and sustainability standards that potentially hamper their domestic industries, from an industrial policy perspective (Giessen et al., 2016; Schleifer, 2015). Corporations, for their part, engage in private regulatory arrangements to manage material and reputational risk, often as a response to social pressure by NGOs and consumers (Matten & Moon, 2008). Yet - neglected by the literature that has dominated the study of the political role of business under the label of Political Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) - there are strong barriers to corporate engagement with the public good, primarily corporate motivation (profit), ability (regulatory capacity) and the complexity of global governance (organizational uncertainty). Scholarship on private governance and Political CSR has yet to incorporate the basic corporate political interest that shape and sometimes curb or inhibit public regulation. In sum, our panel offers to advance research on the intersection of private governance and public policy, by examining the political dynamics, interests, and strategies of the public and corporate parties involved. Our focus is on how these operate in different regional or issue contexts to promote or inhibit the governance ofcross-border business conduct for the public good. References: Abbott, K.W. & Snidal, D. (2009). The Governance Triangle: Regulatory Standards Institutions and the Shadow of the State. In W. Mattli & N. Woods (Eds.), The Politics of Global Regulation (pp. 44-88). Princeton: Princeton University Press.Auld, G. (2014). Constructing Private Governance: The Rise and Evolution of Forest, Coffee, and Fisheries Certification: Yale University Press.Bartley, T. (2007). Institutional Emergence in an Era of Globalization: The Rise of Transnational Private Regulation of Labor and Environmental Conditions. American Journal of Sociology, 113(2), 297-351. Bartley, T. (2011). Transnational Governance as the Layering of Rules: Intersections of Public and Private Standards. Theoretical Inquiries in Law, 12(2). Bartley, T. (2014). Transnational governance and the re-centered state: Sustainability or legality? Regulation & Governance, 8(1), 93-109. Buthe, T., & Mattli, W. (2011). The new global rulers: The privatization of regulation in the world economy. Princeton N.J.: Princeton University Press.Cashore, B., Auld, G., & Newsom, D. (2004). Governing through markets: Forest certification and the emergence of non-state authority. New Haven: Yale University Press.Coen, D., & Pegram, T. (2015). Wanted: A Third Generation of Global Governance Research. Governance, 28(4), 417-420. Eberlein, B., Abbott, K. W., Black, J., Meidinger, E. E., & Wood, S. (2014). Transnational Business Governance Interactions: Conceptualization and Framework for Analysis. Regulation & Governance, 8(1), 1-21. Fransen, L. (2011). Corporate Social Responsibility and Global Labor Standards: Firms and Activists in the Making of Private Regulation New York: Routledge.Giessen, L., Burns, S., Sahide, A., & Wibowo, A. (2016). From governance to government: The strengthened role of state bureaucracies in forest and agricultural certification. Policy and Society, 35(1), 71-89. Grabs, J. (2018). Assessing the institutionalization of private sustainability governance in a changing coffee sector. Regulation and Governance. doi:10.1111/rego.12212. Graz, J.-C., & Nölke, A. (2008). Transnational private governance and its limits. LondonNew York: London : Routledge, 2008.Green, J. F. (2010). Private Standards in the Climate Regime: The Greenhouse Gas Protocol. Business and Politics, 12(3), 1-37. Green, J. F., & Auld, G. (2017). Unbundling the regime complex: the effects of private authority. Transnational Environmental Law, 6(2), 284. Gulbrandsen, L. H. (2014). Dynamic governance interactions: Evolutionary effects of state responses to non-state certification programs. Regulation & Governance, 8(1), 74-92. Knudsen, J. S., & Moon, J. (2017). Visible Hands: Government Regulation and International Business Responsibility. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Locke, R. (2013). The Promise and limits of private power promoting labor standards in a global economy. New York: Cambridge University Press.Matten, D., & Moon, J. (2008). "Implicit" and "Explicit" CSR: A Conceptual Framework for A Comparative Understanding of Corporate Social Responsibility. The Academy of Management Review, 33(2), 404. Scherer, A. G., & Palazzo, G. (2011). The New Political Role of Business in a Globalized World: A Review of a New Perspective on CSR and its Implications for the Firm, Governance, and Democracy. Journal of Management Studies, 48(4), 899-931. Schleifer, P. (2015). Private Governance Undermined: India and the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil. Global Environmental Politics, 16, 38-58. Toffel, M. W., Short, J. L., & Ouellet, M. (2015). Codes in context: How states, markets, and civil society shape adherence to global labor standards. Regulation & Governance, 9(3), 205-223. Vogel, D. (2010). The Private Regulation of Global Corporate Conduct - Achievements and Limitations. Business & Society, 49(1), 68-87.

POLICY TOPICS
GLOBAL POLICY
P04. The Framing of War against Terrorism in Sub-Saharan Africa: The Interplay Game of Security Ideas between Global and Regional Actors
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Manga
J. Keutcheu
ABSTRACT

How do antiterrorism policies look like in Sub-Saharan Africa? What is the policy content of the framed responses to terrorist threats in the Sahel and Lake Chad? In the current context of globalization, it becomes quite impossible to avoid questions centered around the importation, as well as, the exportation of political models in public policy analysis. For decades now, analysis of policy transfers have become so expanded that it is more and more common to talk about a field of "policy transfer studies"(Marsh and Dolowitz, 2000). Even though nothing has sound in the Continent as a scientific time success of the politics of transfer after the "democratization era" in Africa. Indeed, Africa has been one of the main destinations of the transfer of political models, especially through international cooperation for development, IMF Structural Adjustment Programs, the fight against poverty, climate change, the protection of environment, education, health, etc. In turn, globalization has created increased interdependency between national and global levels. It interconnects countries and environments through various means and regimes. Moreover, the complexity of threats, their liability and multiple presence have called for global policies. These have given rise to international models of public policies in almost all domains of the international political life as listed above. Importation and exportation of models of public policies necessarily create interactions between actors, norms, ideas and ideologies. But if the years 1990s have witnessed a lot of scientific works on the politics of transfer, nothing has demonstrated a specific africanist interest dedicated to transfer's phenomenon such as implant, implantation, transposition, circulation, lesson-drawing, learning or learning process), as well as convergence such as “diffusion, generalization, harmonization”. The question here is not to know if such preoccupations are relevant or not. Instead, the idea is to see how from the above mentioned notions of “circulation or lesson-drawing and learning process”, responses against terrorism in Africa are framed.

POLICY TOPICS
GLOBAL POLICY
P01. Can SDG 3 "Ensuring Healthy Lives and Promoting Well-Being for All Ages" Be Achieved?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Haussman
C. Mavrot
ABSTRACT

The United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDG’s) replaced the Millennium Development Goals (MDG’s) as of 2015, and the SDG implementation time frame runs until 2030. Unlike the MDG’s, the SDG framework has a stand-alone “health” platform, encompassing parts of previous MDG’s and including some new goals. Previous goals rolled into the SDG’s include: reduction of maternal, newborn and child deaths, and reduction of diseases such as hepatitis, malaria and HIV/AIDS; and ensuring universal access to reproductive and sexual health-care services. It is clear that those who framed the SDG’s were informed by studies conducted by governments and ngo’s as to processes for ensuring better health, particularly in the Global South. Thus, SDG 3 also incorporates working on: improved mental health; strengthening the prevention of substance abuse, halving the number of global injuries and deaths from road accidents; achieving universal health insurance coverage, access to quality essential health-care services and to safe, effective, quality and affordable essential medicines and vaccines; substantially reducing the number of illnesses and deaths from hazardous chemicals and air, water and soil pollution; strengthening the WHO Framework convention’s implementation on tobacco control; providing access to affordable essential medicines and vaccines (including allowing developing countries to bypass the TRIPS regime of the DOHA WTO round reducing access to these); increasing health financing and the recruitment, training and retention of the health workforce in the Global South; and strengthen the capacity of countries, especially in the Global South, for early warning, risk reduction and management of national and global health risks (http://www.who.int/topics/sustainable-development-goals/targets). In this turning point between the two sets of international development goals, the Research Committee 25 of the International Political Science Association aims to review the current challenges associated with the issue of sustainable global health.

POLICY TOPICS
HEALTH POLICY
P02. Health Policy and the Dynamics of Centralization and Decentralization
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
K. vrangbaek
G. Marchildon
P. Martinussen
ABSTRACT

Striking the right balance between centralization and decentralization in health systems has been on the agenda for a number of years (Saltman et al 2007, Pollitt 2007, Greer 2016, Marchildon and Bossert 2018). The debate is relevant in all health systems including federalist states such as Canada, Germany and Spain and unitary states in the Nordic region. The core of the debate is how to balance a variety of governance objectives with developments in technology and practices of health care delivery. Specific health related issues include the determination of optimal unit sizes given the population health care needs and the advances in technology and professional practice. Aging populations and growing numbers of people with chronic care needs may lead to strategies of decentralization to local communities. Advances in telemedicine can support this process. On the other hand, innovations in sophisticated diagnostic and treatment technology may require centralization as they need a high level of professional expertise and larger populations to be clinically and economically viable. However, (de)centralization debates also involve political issues about the balance between various societal objectives and governance concerns. And decisions about (de)centralization have implications for power and accountability structures, and for the local economy and sense of security. Centralization is often associated with benefits of scale, tighter economic control, better coordination, clearer accountability relationships, and the ability to impose geographical equity as well as develop and enforce standards (Pollitt 2007). In contrast, decentralization is often seen as a vehicle for achieving operative efficiency through higher agility in decision processes and better adjustment to local conditions and preferences. Other arguments for decentralization include the opportunity for competition for personnel and investments, and a more transparent link between service levels and taxation. Taken together this can lead to more local level innovation. Decentralization is also seen as a way to promote democratic participation and accountability due to shorter principal-agent relationships and more transparency. Democratic participation tends to strengthen legitimacy and can serve as education for aspiring politicians. Finally, in some countries, decentralization can be a relevant and necessary strategy to handle internal tensions, including secessionist movements, and avoid disintegration (Greer 2016; Marchildon and Bossert 2018). In sum, the tension between centralization and decentralization in health care touches upon a number of core concepts and debates in public policy studies. This panel aims to explore historical and recent developments in the dynamics of health policy in regards to (de)centralization of health systems and organizations. We invite studies of policy processes leading to (de)centralization reforms including the aims and political dynamics behind the reforms. Secondly, we want to focus on the governance tools that are used to achieve vertical and horizontal coordination in different health systems. We want to explore the configuration of multi-level governance in different health care systems and to look at evidence for benefits and drawbacks of different arrangements. References: · Saltman, RB, Bankauskaite, V & Vrangbæk, K (eds) 2007, Decentralization in Health Care: Strategies and outcomes. European Observatory on Helath Systems and Policies Series, McGraw-Hill, Maidenhead & New York.· Pollitt, C. (2007). Decentralization: A Central Concept in Contemporary Public Management. I: Ewan Ferlie, Laurence E. Lynn Jr., and Christopher Pollitt: The Oxford Handbook of Public Management. Oxford University Press. (pp.371-397). in the Oxford Handbook of Public Management. · Greer, S. (2016). Intergovernmental governance for health: federalism, decentralization and communicable diseases. In Greer, S. L., Wismar, M., Figueras, J. (2016). Strengthening Health System Governance. Better policies, stronger performance. Open University Press. McGraw-Hill Education. Maidenhead Berkshire England.· Marchildon, GP, & Bossert TJ (eds) 2018. Federalism and Decentralization in Health Care: A Decision Space Approach. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

POLICY TOPICS
HEALTH POLICY
P04. Participation, Conflict and Negotiation
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Ferdinand
M. Kelaher
ABSTRACT

Over the past few decades, interest has grown in the decentralisation of health governance as well as in related fields such as education and justice (Atkinson, Medeiros, Oliveira, & de Almeida, 2000; Morgan, 2005; Stenson, 2005). This shift has been enacted through a reduction in rigid hierarchical structures, increasing partnerships with civil society and the involvement of an increased variety of non-governmental actors. Such expansion of decision-making processes inevitably brings with it the possibility of conflict and necessitates the management of such. Potvin (2007) thus envisages participatory approaches in health as an interconnected network of negotiations where actors strive to recruit others to their perspectives, which may be fundamentally mutually incompatible. Health policy development and priority setting involve a series of reactions to this complexity to either minimise, deny, or productively engage with this conflict. Inappropriate responses to conflict may lead to entrenched resistance or stakeholder disengagement; increased understanding of effective ways of managing heterogenous viewpoints, on the other hand, can lead to increased acceptance and legitimacy of the final product.

POLICY TOPICS
HEALTH POLICY
P05. Adapting, Transferring and Reframing Policy: The Role of Evidence
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Ferdinand
M. Kelaher
ABSTRACT

The field of comparative policy analysis responds to the need of policymakers to be ‘systematic, evidence-based, transparent, efficient and accountable (Geva-May et al, 2018).’ Comparative health policy analysis and its practical counterpart, policy exchange, have been increasingly common since the Second World War, driven by improved communication and more tightly interwoven global governance and policy (Dolowitz and Marsh, 1996). It is unquestionable that policymakers and analysts are continuously learning from health policy implemented elsewhere. Nevertheless, there continue to be gaps regarding precisely what information is utilised and in what way when the decision is made to draw on policy from one context for the purpose of application in another (Wolf and Baehler, 2018). Understanding what constitutes evidence from the point of view of policymakers and how this evidence is utilised is essential to undertaking effective research in this field. That is, better insight into decision-making processes will help to ensure the appropriate placement and relevance of evidence intended to guide good practice in policy development.

POLICY TOPICS
HEALTH POLICY
P06. The Global Quest for Universal Health Coverage
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
F. Toth
M. Castelli
ABSTRACT

The literature on Universal Health Coverage (UHC) addresses various themes: access to essential health care, population coverage, the package of benefits to which the population is entitled, protection from the economic and social consequences of illness [Stuckler et al. 2010]. All these themes can be analyzed from different theoretical and empirical perspectives. Therefore, UHC ends up being a concept that is not only multidimensional but also multidisciplinary. Over the last fifteen years, authoritative international bodies, including the United Nations, the World Health Organization, the World Bank, the OECD and the European Commission, have officially committed to achieving universal health coverage [WHO 2010; United Nations 2015; European Commission 2017]. In line with this commitment, many national governments – across the continents – have promoted reforms to expand health insurance coverage or to make it more generous [Lagomarsino et al. 2012; Boerma et al. 2014; Cotlear et al. 2015; Dmytraczenko and Almeida 2015]. Universal coverage can be pursued by different paths and through many diverse health financing arrangements [Savedoff et al. 2012] and fully achieving UHC is all but impossible for any country [Kutzin 2013]. All national governments face trade-offs and must make choices regarding different elements of ‘health coverage’ [WHO 2010]: the proportion of the population covered; the range of services to be made available; the share of the total costs the individual patients have to pay (user charges). Moreover, plenty of evidence shows the importance of addressing a wide range of different social determinants of health in order to improve access to health services and the overall health status of the population. The proposed panel will provide an opportunity to discuss the various facets and dimensions of UHC, both as empirical studies as well as theoretical studies. The panel especially welcomes papers with a comparative perspective, in order to discuss if and how different countries could learn from each other and to offer a contribution to the policy, societal and academic debates concerning health systems developments in their path towards universal health coverage. Papers focused on both developed and developing countries are welcome. References:- Boerma T, Eozenou P, Evans D, Evans T, Kieny MP, Wagstaff A. Monitoring Progress towards Universal Health Coverage at Country and Global Levels. PLoS Med. 2014; 11:1-8. - Cotlear D, Nagpal S, Smith O, Tandon A, Cortez R. Going Universal: How 24 Developing Countries Are Implementing Universal Health Coverage Reforms from the Bottom Up. Washington, DC: The World Bank; 2015. - Dmytraczenko T, Almeida G. Toward Universal Health Coverage and Equity in Latin America and the Caribbean. Washington, DC: The World Bank; 2015.- European Commission. European Pillar of Social Rights. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union; 2017.- Kutzin J. Health financing for universal coverage and health system performance: concepts and implications for policy. Bulletin of the World Health Organization. 2013; 91: 602-11.- Lagomarsino G, Garabrant A, Adyas A, Muga R, Otoo N. Moving towards universal health coverage. Health insurance reforms in nine developing countries in Africa and Asia. The Lancet. 2012; 380:933-43. - Savedoff WD, de Ferranti D, Smith AL, Fan V. Political and economic aspects of the transition to universal health coverage. The Lancet. 2012; 380: 924-32.- Stuckler D, Feigl AB, Basu S, McKee M. The political economy of universal health coverage. Montreux: First Global Symposium on Health Systems Research; 2010. - United Nations. Transforming our World: the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. New York: Resolution adopted by the General assembly; 2015- WHO (2010), Health systems financing: the path to universal coverage, Geneva: World Health Organization.

POLICY TOPICS
HEALTH POLICY
P07. Measuring the Effectiveness of Anti-Doping Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
B. Stoffel
L. Duncan
A. Nandi
ABSTRACT

The objective of this panel is to understand the approaches to measure the effectiveness of anti-doping policy, including the reasons to support them and the critiques to these approaches. Current international anti-doping policy is one of the most important international sport policies. It is designed to prevent, deter and detect the use of performance-enhancing substances in sports. Despite prohibition and efforts by governments and anti-doping agencies to curb it, doping remains a prevalent practice in competitive sports. The numbers of adverse analytical findings, i.e. a report by an accredited laboratory that a prohibited substance has been found in a sample, have been increasing over the last decade, from 1.08% in 2008 to 1.6% in 2016 (see WADA 2016 Anti-Doping Testing Figures, Executive Summary, p. 2).Yet research indicates actual prevalence in elite sport to be much higher (between 14% and 39% according to de Hon et al. 2015; around 50% according to Ulrich et al. 2018).This panel will thus address a fundamental question: How can we measure the effectiveness of anti-doping policy? That is, what methods and measurements should be used to understand the impact of anti-doping policy as well as the underlying rationale for such policies? The continued prevalence of doping in elite sport, along with alleged inefficiencies in catching dopers and numerous doping controversies (BACLO in the United States, state sponsored doping in Russia, etc.), have prompted critical assessments by scholars across disciplines challenging current anti-doping efforts. One critical perspective emphasizes a need to depart from doping as a problem of cheating individuals and instead focus on the contextual influences on athlete attitudes to performance-enhancing drugs in sport, along with anti-doping policy’s deficiencies in addressing these influences (e.g., Koller 2008). These authors often attribute doping to sports culture, a lack of knowledge, as well as a general “laissez-faire approach” (Mazanov et al. 2015:218). They argue that anti-doping policy is in tension with the normalisation of doping in sports (Mazanov et al. 2015; Mazanov et al. 2014; Smith et al. 2010). A second perspective views the lack of properly targeted education as one of the main shortcomings in anti-doping policy (e.g., Patterson et al. 2016). It sees doping as a gateway problem, where athletes’ willingness to dope increases where they are already engaging in legal performance enhancement, e.g. in the form of nutritional supplements (Backhouse et al. 2013; Ntoumanis et al. 2014). Finally, according to a third perspective, current anti-doping policy must be rejected altogether. These scholars argue that doping should either be legalised (Savulescu 2015), or that a less intrusive approach such as harm reduction is warranted (Kayser and Tolleneer 2017, Beamish 2013, Kirkwood 2009). These critics point towards numerous challenges in anti-doping policy. One challenge is to establish the fundamental rationale for anti-doping policy. Another is to better understand what anti-doping policy should achieve, how the effectiveness of anti-doping policy should be studied and what exactly should be measured. Yet another challenge is to understand how findings from such studies can be applied to better serve the goals of anti-doping policy. References:Backhouse, Susan (2013), L. Whitaker, and A. Petróczi, Gateway to doping? Supplement use in the context of preferred competitive situations, doping attitudes, beliefs, and norms, Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports 23, 2013:244–252.Beamish, Rob (2013), Olympic Ideals versus the Performance Imperative: The History of Canada’s Anti-Doping Policies, in Lucie Thibault and Jean Harvey (ed.), Sport Policy in Canada, Ottawa: University of Ottawa Press, 2013:217–242.de Hon, Olivier (2015), Harm Kuipers and Maarten van Bottenburg, Prevalence of Doping Use in Elite Sports: A Review of Numbers and Methods, Sport Medicine 45, 2015:57–69.Koller, Dionne L. (2008), From Medals to Morality: Sportive Nationalism and the Problem of Doping in Sports, Marquette Sports Law Review 19, 2008:91–124.Kayser, Bengt (2017), and Jan Tolleneer,Ethics of a relaxed antidoping rule accompanied by harm-reduction measures, Journal of Medical Ethics 43, 2017:282–286.Kirkwood, Ken (2009), Considering Harm Reduction as the Future of Doping Control Policy in International Sport, Quest 61, 2009:180–190.Mazanov, Jason (2015), Dennis Hemphill, James Connor, Frances Quirk, and Susan H. Backhouse, Australian athlete support personnel lived experience of anti-doping, Sport Management Review 18, 2015:218–230.Mazanov, J. (2014), S. Backhouse, J. Connor, D. Hemphill, and F. Quirk, Athlete support personnel and anti-doping: Knowledge, attitudes, and ethical stance, Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sport 24, 2014:846–856.Ntoumanis, Nikos (2014), Johan Y. Y. Ng, Vassilis Barkoukis, and Susan Backhouse, Personal and Psychosocial Predictors of Doping Use in Physical Activity Settings: A Meta-Analysis, Sports Medicine 44, 2014:1603–1624.Patterson, Laurie B. (2016), Susan H. Backhouse, and Patrick J. Duffy, Anti-doping education for coaches: Qualitative insights from national and international sporting and anti-doping organisations, Sport Management Review 19, 2016:35–47.Smith, Aaron C.T. (2010), Bob Stewart, Sunny Olivier-Bennetts, Sharyn McDonal, Lyngley Ingerson, Alastair Anderson, Geoff Dickson, Paul Emery, and Fiona Graetz, Contextual influences and athlete attitudes to drugs in sport, Sport Management Review 13, 2010:181–197.Ulrich, Rolf (2018), Harrison G. Pope Jr., Léa Cléret, Andrea Petróczi, Tamás Nepusz, Jay Schaffer, Gen Kanayama, R. Dawn Comstock, and Perikles Simon, Doping in Two Elite Athletics Competitions Assessed by Randomized-Response Surveys, Sports Medicine 48, 2018:211–219.

POLICY TOPICS
HEALTH POLICY
P08. Collaborative Governance and Health Inequities: Perspectives from Low- and Middle-Income Countries
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Van Belle
ABSTRACT

BackgroundWith the SDG of Universal Health Coverage, captured by "leaving no one behind", there is a renewed impetus to work collaboratively at the local level. Public and private providers could work jointly to improve the performance of fragmented urban health systems and to improve referral for maternal care. Collaboration across sectors may, for instance, attenuate the triple burden of disease and contribute to implement tobacco control policies at district level. Collaboration between health facilities and the police may to strengthen integrated service networks for victims of sexual violence. Schools and youth services working together may deliver stigma free health services for adolescents. Community-based organisations and health managers and providers may engage in joint priority-setting and better align health services to citizens’ and communities’ needs. Research questionHow do collaborative governance arrangements impact on existing health inequities in LMIC? ObjectivesThis session aims at showcasing examples from recent empirical fieldwork in LMIC of a renewed impetus in improved collaborative governance within the broader goal of achieving universal health coverage and to explore how these formal and informal governance arrangements and practices at the level of the local (health) system might impact on accountability towards the poorest or most vulnerable groups (indigenous groups, socially excluded, single households, people with disabilities, the poorest,..), who cannot easily claim nor enforce accountability. Scientific relevanceAny policy, programme (or applied research) intervention to advance universal health coverage has to pass the litmus test of its impact on health (and broader) inequities. The aim is to explore empirical examples and then discuss, on the basis of the papers, which mechanisms are at work, in which context and why. The panel will end with making the case for innovative research methods (such as realist evaluation, qualitative comparative analysis,…) which allow for the building of causal pathways.

POLICY TOPICS
HEALTH POLICY
P09. Public Policy and Payment for Performance Programs (P4P/PBF) in Health: in High-, Middle- and Low-Income Countries
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
F. SADDI
S. Peckham
L. Gautier
ABSTRACT

Co-organized with Dr. Nick Turnbull (University of Manchester) GENERAL OBJECTIVES: The objective of this panel is to discuss studies applying Public Policy theories and related theories and concepts in Health System Research to study the design/formulation and/or implementation processes of pay for performance programs (P4P) – also known as performance-based financing (PBF) - in health policy in high-, middle- and low-income countries, focused either on theoretical or empirical approaches, as case or comparative study. RESEARCH QUESTIONS: In what ways diverse Public Policy elements/ aspects/ dynamics/ processes related to policy (re)design/(re)formulation and implementation of P4P/PBF programs can affect health system performance and/or building blocks in countries adopting varied models of primary health care (PHC), which are at distinct stages of development? What are the main actors involved in policy (re)design/ (re)formulation? How international organizations, national policymakers and stakeholders, policy brokers, entrepreneurs (diffusion), and consultants have influenced the policy-making process? What types of policy learning and policy feedback have been taking place at both the design/ formulation and implementation levels? To what extent policy (re)design/ (re)formulation have taken into consideration implementation failures and involved national/local government actors, communities of knowledge and front-line health workers? What are the main policy and performance drivers/mechanisms that have characterized the implementation of P4P/PBF and how differently or commonly have they impacted health systems in high-, middle- and low-income countries? How motivations, behaviours and discretionary decisions/power have varied in contexts with distinct organizational capacities, in different stages of development of a culture of monitoring and evaluation at both the policy-making and implementation levels? If/how unintended consequences or political paradoxes such as gaming, cheating and spillover effects have characterized those processes? SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE: Public Policy theories and analysis are relevant to uncover the policy and political dynamics of (re)design/ (re)formulation and implementation processes of rational-based programs such as P4P/PBF. This is because Public Policy offers some key concepts and methods/approaches for understanding why/how different and similar policy and political processes affects health systems performance and/or building blocks. However, and despite the spread of P4P/PBF on the globe, Public Policy theories and analytical approaches have been little (or practically not) employed in the analyses of P4P/PBF in various countries and comparatively (especially). In general, studies tend to focus mainly, albeit differently, on outcome analyses. In high-, middle-, and low-income countries, there are few (or no) publications focusing on the design/formulation of pay for performance programs, so that we do not analytically and in a systematized way know how the design / formulation of P4P/PBF varies and can be compared within different contexts and models of PHC. As far as the implementation process is concerned, there is still a research gap and especially (but not only) in high- and middle-income countries. In low-income countries adopting PBF, and despite the diversity of methods and types of qualitative and system analysis, elements / concepts of Public Policy have been privileged by few studies. P4P/PBF programs have been interrupted in countries such as Scotland, Mali and Mozambique, and presents a risk of discontinuity in others (as in England). Its continuity in countries like Brazil and scale-up in Zimbabwe occurs at a time where there is still a gap in comparative knowledge from other cases considered both as success and failures cases. We argue that the non- or low-use of Public Policy theories delays this process of learning/ transference of comparative knowledge. Public Policy could contribute to speed-up, in a comprehensive way, the opening of the so-called "black box" of P4P/PBF, highlighting how policy drivers or mechanisms could, in an inter-related way, contribute (or not) to the sustainable development or scale-up of P4P/PBF.

POLICY TOPICS
HEALTH POLICY
P10. Why Health Reforms Fail (and Sometimes Succeed): Applying Public Administration Theory to Policy Implementation of Health Reforms with a focus on Low and Middle-Income Countries
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Fox
R. Gore
W. Feng
ABSTRACT

Policy studies are replete with examples of unintended consequences and policy failure and yet the causes of implementation failure have been under-researched. Why do good ideas fail in practice? While the topic of policy change is a widely researched area in public policy and political science, the literature on what happens next, in other words on implementation, is more sparse. Once a policy is adopted, it becomes the domain of public administrators and of less potential interest to public policy. Yet, literature on bureaucratic politics suggests that policymaking continues during policy implementation and that policies continue to evolve as they are put into practice. Meanwhile, in the field of health policy, literature on “implementation science” is rising in prominence. However, this literature is more focused on program implementation and the dissemination and scalability of effective interventions at a community level than on policy implementation and the diffusion of effective policies to populations and representative bodies. For instance, how do we scale universal health coverage and effectively regulate drug companies as opposed to how do we replicate this community-based intervention to promote weight loss and reduce pre-diabetes? Whereas program implementation requires knowledge of management and organization theory, policy implementation necessarily requires knowledge of public administration theories.

POLICY TOPICS
HEALTH POLICY
P12. Pandemie policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Zittoun
S. AILANE
ABSTRACT

XXXXXXXXXXX

POLICY TOPICS
HEALTH POLICY
P01. How the EU Border Regime Transforms Global Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
O. Yusuf
M. Manga
ABSTRACT

GENERAL OBJECTIVE The main objective is to focus and take stock of ground-breaking research on varied public policy responses which is impacted and influenced by the EU Border regime policy, also exploring the public policy analysis and development process through coalition building, consensus rallying, enquiry and collaboration, to make visible the vibrant state of public policy making. RESEARCH QUESTIONS What new policy engagements and possible phenomena are shaped and created between various public policy actors as a result of the EU Border regime? How does the EU Border regime shape, transform and influence global public policy making process? How does the EU border regime shape relations between the states, citizens and noncitizens? SCIENTIFIC RELEVANCE In this era of unparalleled and unprecedented scale of economic globalization, this panel will contribute to an informed public debate around issues of migration policy and the resultant effects on development policy, welfare policy and economic policy. It will create a deep voice to open up new and fresh scholarly frontiers on the future of Migration management in the EU, America and Africa. It will also establish a much needed interdisciplinary dialogue between migration studies, public policy, sociology, infrastructure studies, and the fields of architecture and design. I foresee that this will foster interdisciplinarity, transdisciplinarity and academic exchange beyond conventional formats and provide new theoretical avenues for other key global issues.

POLICY TOPICS
FOREIGN POLICY
P01. Contested Boundaries in Food and Agricultural Governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
J. Candel
A. Farsund
ABSTRACT

Food governance under conditions of globalization and limited resources from the global to the local level is becoming a menacing policy challenge. Related implications affect established policy paradigms within agriculture and food policy, but also policy areas traditionally separated from food and agricultural policy. Organizations that originally dealt with agricultural or food policies are reframing their focus to expand to interconnected, separately governed issues, such as climate change and sustainable development. Similarly, civil society organizations and multinational corporations in the food sector are increasingly co-producing public services. These developments challenge established analytical concepts in political science, e.g., the distinction between public and private becomes increasingly opaque through public-private partnerships with ensuing challenges to decision-making procedures and the categorization of stakeholders, and to traditional concepts such as accountability, transparency, and representation. Similarly, the boundaries of international regimes are becoming blurred, with, for example, the Sustainable Development Goals merging norms from climate, environmental, food and human rights regimes, setting the scene for future contestation of competences and resources. Two recent debates in the food governance scholarship that we are particularly interested in and that bear relevance to the broader policy sciences are those on post-exceptionalism and food policy integration. The post-exceptionalism hypothesis refers to an expected ‘partial transformation in which an exceptionalist policy sector [e.g., agriculture] has not been completely ‘normalized’ and in which old and new ideas, institutions, interests and policy instruments coexist.’ (Daugbjerg and Feindt, 2017: 1573) Although this hypothesis is intuitively appealing, so far few empirical investigations have been carried out. Food policy integration refers to recent attempts of governments across levels to develop distinctive food policies and institutions and/or integrate food-related concerns across sectors and levels (Candel and Pereira, 2017). Given the variety in governments’ challenges, policy styles and political preferences, we expect differences in policy design and implementation as well as in how broader food politics play out (cf. Sonnino et al., 2018). In addition, studies of food policy integration have given rise to more fundamental theoretical and methodological innovations with regard to how to conceptualize and assess policy integration in the first place. References: - Candel JJL and Pereira L. (2017) Towards integrated food policy: Main challenges and steps ahead. Environmental Science & Policy 73: 89-92. - Daugbjerg C and Feindt PH. (2017) Post-exceptionalism in public policy: transforming food and agricultural policy. Journal of European Public Policy 24: 1565-1584. - Sonnino R, Tegoni CLS and De Cunto A. (2018) The challenge of systemic food change: Insights from cities. Cities.

POLICY TOPICS
OTHER SECTORIAL POLICY
P02. Public Financial Management Policies: Issues of Taxation, Budgeting and Public Debt Management
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
I. Krachkovskaya
A. Asquer
ABSTRACT

Public financial management policies play a crucial role in nowadays economies and operation of governments. The effective management of public finances affects the financial sustainability of government activities and programmes and often dictates formidable constraints to the making of public policies in areas from health to education, from welfare to pensions (Guthrie et al 2005, Allen et al 2013). In addition, the management of public finances provides policy tools such as the use of taxation (and subsidies) to discourage (or encourage) the choices of individuals and firms alike. A decade after the 2008-9 Financial Crisis, many countries in the world still struggle to get their fiscal house in order. Massive public intervention to salvage the financial system resulted in increased amounts of sovereign debt up to levels that most countries had never experienced before. Austerity measures led to cuts of public spending and a renewed attention to enlarging the tax base, tackling profit shifting, and fighting tax evasion (Cangiano et al 2013). Within such environment, citizens and policy advisors call for even more stringent controls on the management of public financial monies (Heald and Hodges 2015, Oulasvirta and Bailey 2016). This paper aims to address the question of what are the reasons and effects of public financial management policies in the various areas of taxation, budgeting and public debt management. The panel will welcome papers that: a) Provide a review and critical appraisal of public financial management policies especially in the aftermath of the 2008-9 Financial Crisis;b) Explain public financial management policies that have been implemented especially over the last decade, also in comparative perspective;c) Discuss the role of ideology, domestic politics, international and super-national organisations, and financial markets in the design of public financial management policies;d) Discuss policy advice and practitioners’ perspectives on contemporary public financial management issues. Papers may be either theoretical or empirical. Theoretical papers may explain features of the public financial management policy process and policy decisions, especially taking into account conditions that arise from the domestic environment, the international environment, and contingent economic and financial situations. Empirical papers may present original studies of public financial management policies, also in comparative perspective. References: Allen, R., Hemming, R., & Potter, B. (Eds.). (2013). The international handbook of public financial management. Springer. Cangiano, M. M., Curristine, M. T. R., & Lazare, M. M. (2013). Public financial management and its emerging architecture. International Monetary Fund. Guthrie, J., Humphrey, C., Jones, L. R., & Olson, O. (Eds.). (2005). International public financial management reform: progress, contradictions, and challenges. IAP. Heald, D., & Hodges, R. (2015). Will “austerity” be a critical juncture in European public sector financial reporting?. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 28(6), 993-1015. Oulasvirta, L. O., & Bailey, S. J. (2016). Evolution of EU public sector financial accounting standardisation: critical events that opened the window for attempted policy change. Journal of European Integration, 38(6), 653-669.

POLICY TOPICS
OTHER SECTORIAL POLICY
P03. Theorizing Internationalization of Higher Education - A Policy Approach
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Tamtik
R. Trilokekar
ABSTRACT

Research Question: What theoretical and conceptual approaches from policy studies help unpack the internationalization of higher education as public policy? “Internationalization is seen as one of the major forces impacting and shaping higher education in the 21st century” (Knight, 2008, ix). It has become a tool in addressing complex policy issues such as aging demographics, attracting talent and pursuing technological innovations. There are overwhelming amount of policy documents guiding internationalization activities at local, regional and global levels (European Commission, 2013; OECD, 2016). While practice is booming, theorizing is lacking. Internationalization of higher education is commonly understood as a processfocusing on motivations and rationales (e.g. Altbach & Knight, 2007; Knight, 2008), challenges and consequences (Knight, 2015) and management and stakeholder experiences (Guo & Guo, 2017; Bedenlier et al., 2018). However we propose to speak of internationalization of higher education as a core area of public policyengaging and impacting all levels of government, involving a wide range of policy actors and cutting across a diverse range of policy sectors, education, economy, immigration, trade, foreign relations, research & innovation, to name just a few. We argue that as public policy internationalization of higher education is fundamentally challenging the traditional roles, responsibilities and relationships between the different levels of governments, introducing a new network of policy actors and changing the roles, purposes and functions of the (higher) education sector. However, missing in the current literature is a policy perspective to analyze the formation, implementation, appropriation and impact of the internationalization of higher education. This panel provides an opportunity for scholars of public policy and/or higher education to examine the internationalization of higher education using rich theoretical and conceptual frameworks from policy studies. We are interested in understanding local meanings of internationalization policies while simultaneously recognizing the influence of transnational policy networks (Ball, 1998; Ball et. al, 2017; Rizvi & Lingard, 2010). Diem & Young (2015) emphasize the importance of examining policies within their historical, social, economic, cultural, and political contexts, recognizing that these contexts produce particular “local” versions of policy (Ozga, 2005, 207, see also Taylor, 1997; Vidovich, 2007). We want to give credence to scholars like Vidovich (2007) in “removing policy from its pedestal” and in our policy analysis of internationalization of higher education explicitly linking, “the ‘bigger picture’ of global and national policy contexts to the ‘smaller pictures’ of policies and practices” within provinces, local communities and institutions (p. 285). In doing so, while maintaining and ascribing a role for the government as more than just “an actor among actors”, we want to examine the multiplicity of actors that shape internationalization of higher education policy that have become central to the study of governance. We find Howlett, et als. (2009) three core dimensions of public policy a particularly useful framework to highlight different elements of internationalization as public policy: 1) policy subsystems- policy actors who interact to determine the content and process of public policy making; 2) institutional regimes- structures and institutions that serve to constrain and influence these actors efforts; and 3) policy paradigms- ideas and knowledge that inform their deliberations and actions. References: Altbach, P. G., & Knight, J. (2007). The internationalization of higher education: Motivations and realities. Journal of studies in international education, 11(3-4), 290-305. Ball, S. (1998). Big Policies/Small World: An Introduction to International Perspectives in Education Policy. Comparative Education, 34 (2): 119–130. Ball, S, C. Junemann, D., Santori (2017). Edu.net. Globalisation and Education Policy Mobility. London: Routledge. Bedenlier, S., Kondakci, Y., & Zawacki-Richter, O. (2018). Two decades of research into the internationalization of higher education: Major themes in the journal of studies in international education (1997-2016). Journal of Studies in International Education, 22(2), 108-135. Diem, S. & Young, M. D. (2015). Considering critical turns in research on educationalleadership and policy. International Journal of Educational Management, 29 (7), 838 – 850. European Commission. (2013). Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions. European higher education in the world. Retrieved on September 25, 2014 from http://www.nuffic.nl/bibliotheek/European-higher-education-in-the-world.pdf. Guo, Y., & Guo, S. (2017). Internationalization of Canadian higher education: discrepancies between policies and international student experiences. Studies in Higher Education, 42(5), 851-868. Howlett, M., Perl, A., & Ramesh, M. (2009). Studying Public Policy: Policy Cycles and Policy Subsystems. Toronto: Oxford University Press. Knight, J. (2015). Internationalization: A decade of changes and challenges. International Higher Education, (50). Knight, J. (2008). Higher education in turmoil: The changing world of internationalization. Sense Publisher: Chicago.Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) (2016).Education at a Glance 2016: OECD Indicators, OECD Publishing, Paris.Retrieved fromhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1787/eag-2016-en Ozga, J. (2005). Modernizing the education workforce: a perspective from Scotland. Educational Review, 57 (2), 207-219. Rizvi, F. & B. Lingard (2010).Globalizing Education Policy. New York: Routledge. Taylor, S. (1997). Critical Policy Analysis: exploring contexts, texts and consequences. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education, 18 (1) 23- 34. Vidovich, L. (2007). Removing policy from its pedestal: some theoretical framings and practical possibilities. Educational Review, 59 (3), 285-298.

POLICY TOPICS
OTHER SECTORIAL POLICY
P04. Urban Transformations Due to Tourism: Contradictions and Controversies, Government and Local
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Velasco
R. Herrero López
J. Ruano
ABSTRACT

Urban centers receive a large part of world tourist flow and their importance as focal points of tourism continues to grow (Page, 1995; Hall & Page, 2003). In countries with a long urban history, tourism use and viewing tend to concentrate on the historical spaces of these cities (Ashworth & Tunbridge, 1990; Valenzuela & Hidalgo, 2010). Tourism is repeatedly cited as a factor of stress, although its actual impact is not adequately calibrated. The deployment of tourism on urban space is characterized by its spatial selectivity. Many of the problems associated with tourism are linked to these areas of concentration where we can find a series of processes related to tourism (Haley, Snaith & Miller, 2003; Füller & Michel, 2014). These problems could be labeled as gentrification, expansion of commercial franchises, homogenization and banalization of public space, social rejection to the presence of certain types of businesses and visitors, saturation of infrastructures and public space, theming... and others that may indicate that the tourism carrying capacity is being overwhelmed (Ashworth & Page, 2011). Taking into account both traditional and innovative perspectives such as the controversy approach and the relational theory (Jóhannesson, Ren & van der Duim, 2015), we are interested on discourse, practices and public policies that are being designed to diminish the negative effects of tourism saturation, favor the development of tourism in other parts of urban space, and provide instruments for improving the decision making process (Russo & Richards, 2016). The background is a reflection on tourism policy, so far an ill developed field in the area of public policy analysis (Bramwell & Sharman, 1999; Kerr, 2003; Church, 2004; Pforr, 2006; Bramwell & Meyer, 2007; Dredge, & Jenkins, 2007; Hall, 2010). The aim of this panel is (1) to explore the dynamics of urban tourism policies in an effort to gain a more systematic understanding of the arena and (2) to expand the network of scholars who study urban tourism policy in order to further understanding of comparative public policy.

POLICY TOPICS
OTHER SECTORIAL POLICY
P05. Agriculture Policies and Food Security in Developing Countries
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Goliaya
R. Kapila
ABSTRACT

Food security is top priority on the global policy agenda. It is the primary justification for all governments involved in agriculture. Demand for food is increasing with increasing populations and gain wealth to purchase more varied and resource-intensive diets there for food insecurity remains a complex and multidimensional global issue, relating to food availability, access to affordable food, the effective use of food by people, and the stability of these elements over time. In contemporary globalized world, food insecurity in one region can have widespread political and economic ramifications also. It is one person in five in the developing countries is undernourished. Every day, some 26,000 children die from conditions related to hunger and malnutrition – half of them before their fifth birthday. It requires transformative action, embracing the principles of sustainability and tackling the root causes of poverty and hunger to leave no one behind. Agriculture is a key sector for the achievement of many UN Sustainable Development Goals, which aim to end poverty and hunger and promote prosperity and people’s wellbeing. Sustainable food and agriculture have great potential to address many of our challenges, serving up affordable, nutritious food, strengthening livelihoods. In developing countries agriculture needs governmental support through viable, sustainable agricultural policies to ensure food security. Developing nations also face difficulties of agricultural adjustment, policies are traced to the complex and sometimes contradictory relations between the state and farmers concerning access to agricultural resources. The aim of this panel is to discuss agricultural policies and their implications for food security and also to discuss and explore options for devising a comprehensive policy framework able to address food security challenges in developing countries. Objectives of the Panel: 1. Discuss the state intervention through agricultural policies to ensure Food security in developing countries. 2. Discuss and explore options for devising a comprehensive policy framework which is able to address food security challenges, 3. Examine the Commitment and strategies of developing countries for the attainment of sustainable development goals to ensure sustainable food security. 4. Understand a self-reliant and sustainable agriculture adaptive to climate change and responsive to farmers' needs 5. Analyze the impact of global agricultural trade policies on domestic agriculture and food security. 6. Suggest sustainable agricultural policies and practice to ensure food security and improve financial condition of farmers. Scientific relevancy In contemporary world increasing population is threat to food security. Poverty, hunger and malnutrition is major problem in developing countries. Marginalization of agricultural economy and adverse agricultural policies are responsible for increasing farmer’s suicides. The solution of these problems passing through sustainable agriculture practices. UN Sustainable Development Goals and governmental intervention through sustainable agricultural policies are need of hour to ensure food security and human dignity.

POLICY TOPICS
OTHER SECTORIAL POLICY
P06. Financial and Economic Policy-Making in Times of Crisis: Responses to the Great Financial Crisis Across the World
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Kolopp
U. Lepont
P. Zittoun
ABSTRACT

Ten years after the collapse of Lehman Brothers, where do we stand in terms of our academic understanding of the policy responses to the Great Financial Crisis? The issue of policy change after the crisis has focused much of the attention of public policy scholars, and elicited an intense academic debate. The severity of the crash, its worldwide repercussions, and its dramatic impact on economic activity were seen by many as promising radical change, away from austerity politics and financial self-regulation. In the early 2010s, however, scholars began addressing the non-linear relations between financial shock and radical change: they discussed the “resilience” and entrenchment of (neo)liberalism (Crouch 2011; Schmidt and Thatcher 2013; Blyth 2013), elaborated on the “status quo crisis” (Helleiner 2014), and shifted their investigations “from the question of what was changing to the question of whyso little change had taken place” (Mayntz 2012). Others pointed out that, even though change wasn’t comprehensive, it certainly was substantive in some areas. They emphasized how post-crisis financial regulation became more politicized, and how its reach extended (Helleiner and Pagliari 2010; Quaglia 2012); stressed the build-up of international and EU regulatory capacities (Quaglia 2014); showed how quantitative easing radically transformed the parameters of central banking (Claveau, Dietsch and Fontan 2018). These works provide invaluable perspectives on the conditions and modalities of post-crisis policy change, but they somewhat shifted our scholarly attention away from the very process of policymaking during and after the crisis. As a consequence, we know very little about how government and policy experts concretely coped with this unexpected event of global proportions, which arguably shook their assumptions, beliefs, and policy routines. This panel aims to map out government reactions to the 2007-2008 crisis across the world, with a focus on economic and financial policy responses (for a first approach, see Bermeo and Pontusson 2012). Its underlying assumption is that the processes, modalities and intensity of post-crisis policy change vary across issues, national contexts and policy levels (domestic, international, European). As such, the panel aims to move beyond the focus on policy outcomes (i.epolicy change and/or policy inertia) that characterizes much of the existing public policy literature on the financial crisis, and it invites papers that examine the actual processof policymaking during and in response to the Great Financial Crisis. This calls for the close examination and comparison of the politics, actors and processes of reform and/or of non-reform across cases and countries. Which policy actors were involved in crisis management and regulatory reforms? How did they build coalitions to promote certain policy agendas? Were these coalitions stable across time and issues? To what extent did they articulate different policy levels (domestic, international, European)? To what extent was the crisis used to promote new or old policy agendas? What are the specificities of decision-making in times of crisis, when pressures to “act fast” are felt exceptionally strongly? This panel invites papers examining the financial and economic policymaking process during and after the financial crisis from a variety of theoretical perspectives, but grounded in thorough empirical research. Single-case studies and comparative approaches are both welcome. Ultimately, the aim of this panel is to bring together scholars from different countries and theoretical approaches to assess and discuss what kind of insights the analysis of government reactions to the 2007-2008 financial crisis has to bring to the field of public policy analysis, and to open up new areas for future research.

POLICY TOPICS
OTHER SECTORIAL POLICY
P01. Digital Innovations: Blended and Experiential Learning Strategies in Public Policy Programs
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
N. Turnbull
V. Dinica
ABSTRACT

Digital devices, softwares and apps have been increasingly used in public policy programs across the world, over the past decade. However, little is yet known regarding their effectiveness in delivering key learning objectives and skills, such as developing critical thinking skills, creative thinking skills, verbal and oral communication skills, teamwork and peer persuasion skills. Are they also able to help learners develop a wider range of skills that are highly desirable among employers and within society at large? How do digital technologies perform in terms of efficiency, by considering the time involved in student preparation relative to gains? There are very high demands on the learners’ time and many strategies involving the use of digital technologies require significant front-end preparation. At the same time, experiential learning often involves allocation of roles to students, and a sustained engagement of learners. This is the case with with 'blended learning' and 'experiential learning' strategies (involving stakeholder-based and/or problem-solving approaches). This can be challenging, as compulsory attendance is a policy being increasingly abandoned by universities worldwide. The panel aims to explore and synthesise the strengths and weaknesses of deploying digital technologies in relation to a range of key learning objective in public policy programs, particularly as part of blended learning and experiential learning strategies.

POLICY TOPICS
TEACHING PUBLIC POLICY AND PEDAGOGY
P03. The Case-Study as a Tool for Public Policy Teaching and Learning
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Jordan
A. Thind
ABSTRACT

Case-studies are a valuable tool for teaching and learning and enable students to apply their knowledge and skills to a range of real world situations; to learn through practice; and reflect and participate in peer leaning, often with experts providing context and help with situating the problem. In public policy related teaching and learning, case-studies can help ready students for the unpredictable nature of policy problems and policy making and enable them to consider and negotiate problems and policy options with key interest groups of different positions and influence. Case-studies expose students of public policy to a wide range of issues that, when worked through, can contribute to workforce ‘readiness’ for a wide range of public policy roles and experiences. Case-studies are also useful tools for experiential learning. According to Kolb (1984), and later described by (Fenwick, 2001), in experiential learning “…new knowledge and skills are achieved through confrontation among concrete experience, reflective observation, abstract conceptualization, and subsequent experimentation” or put more simply, education “grounded in experience” and “complemented by reflection” (Kreber, 2001, p.218). The case-study is a tool that can facilitate the transition between each of these phases (Fenwick, 2001; Kreber, 2001), though it should be noted that the real world ‘learning’ gained will depend on the way in which the case-study is facilitated in the learning environment, and the balance and interaction between experience, reflection and prior and developing knowledge. Public policy can be ‘messy’ and does not follow a set of predicted or predictable stages of development. And while case-studies can be useful for shifting typical university teaching from the traditional ‘abstract conceptualisation’ to ‘concrete experience’ (Kreber, 2001, p.220), for a case-study to successfully provide ‘concrete experience’ in public policy, it needs to reflect real-world experience, and any attempt to formulate solutions to set problems will fall short of experiential learning. This presents some unique challenges to case-study teaching in the field of public policy. This panel would like to explore how case-studies in public policy teaching address these challenges. The objective of this session are fourfold. The first objective is to identify the range of approaches for using case-studies in public policy related teaching and learning. These could include individual or team based, simulations or role play, etc. The second is to determine which public policy related learning outcomes are best suited to these different modes, and content. For example, what are best suited for evidence evaluation and synthesis? Stakeholder engagement? Policy development? Policy evaluation? etc. The third is to identify the ways in which case-studies used in public policy teaching and learning can be evaluated – for specific knowledge and practice (or competency) based learning outcomes. The fourth is, to explore the range of structures and compositions of public/private public policy case-study repositories for use in teaching and learning and to identify elements of these that support quality public policy teaching and learning. References: Kolb, D.A. (1984) Experiential Learning. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1984. Fenwick, T. (2001) Experiential Learning: A Theoretical Critique from Five Perspectives Information Series No. 385: 1-74. ERIC Clearinghouse on Adult, Career, and Vocational Education, Columbus, OH. Kreber, C. (2001) Learning experientially through case studies? A conceptual analysis. Teaching in Higher Education, 6 (2):217-228.

POLICY TOPICS
TEACHING PUBLIC POLICY AND PEDAGOGY
P04. APSA-Innovation in Pedagogy and Curriculum
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
S. Smith
ABSTRACT

This panel brings together scholars with many years of experience in curriculum development in schools of public policy. The panel chair is Steven Rathgeb Smith, of the American Political Science Association and Georgetown University. In addition, Professor Peter John of Kings College London will give a presentation entitled, “Teaching the Political Economy of Public Policy.” He will discuss the development of his problem centred syllabus about using the tools of political economy to address key public problems of the world today. He can also discuss his online quiz with learning materials that aims to skill up students in these basic skills. The second presentation is by Professor Rachel Laforest who will give a presentation entitled, “Designing a Competency-based Curriculum for Policy Studies. The field of policy studies is changing and the pace of change is staggering. With technological advances, new knowledge is constantly being created — how you know is more important than what you know. We need to prepare our students for success in this new collaborative, dynamic, technologically driven, flexible 21 st century environment. Professor Laforest’s presentation details the restructuring of the Queens University MPA curriculum to use competencies as a frameworks. In the third presentation, Professor Kent Weaver of Georgetown University will give a presentation entitled, “Curated Cases as a Teaching Tool.” Teaching cases are an important pedagogic tool in many professional education programs. But case teaching is often discouraged by a paucity of published cases on topics that the instructor wants to cover. This paper outlines how instructors can assemble materials from multiple sources to create "curated cases" with a much lower time commitment than what is required to create formal written cases.

POLICY TOPICS
TEACHING PUBLIC POLICY AND PEDAGOGY
P01. Building Digital Public Governance, Transforming Administrative Culture
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Smorgunov
J. Lewis
E. Gorbak
ABSTRACT

This panel is organized jointly the IPSA RC 48 - Administrative Culture. The introduction of digital technologies in public governance and policy is accompanied by debates about the benefits, challenges and risks of the digital world. Contemporary digital governance requires adaptability, mobility, flexibility, sensitivity and speed of response to emerging issues. All this requires transformations in the sphere of public administrative culture. It incorporates data-driven requirements, including principles of collaboration, transparency and openness, innovation and co-production. At the same time, digital technologies exacerbated the problems of surveillance and control from above, giving rise to popular anxiety about ‘Big Brother’ (after George Orwell), the ‘Panopticon’ (after Jeremy Bentham), or the All-Seeing Eye (after an ancient image). The danger to freedom and privacy and the cell-phone technology caused a control response from below (‘sousveillance’), itself creating a threat to integration and coordination of efforts in public space. Discussions on freedom, domination and intervention are accompanied by hope for a conflict-free strategy for the interaction of digital governance-citizen relationship based on cooperation, transparency and honesty, which are based on digital technology’s algorithms. Many are convinced that algorithmic governance will remove the dangers of inefficiency and mistrust by putting a share of responsibility on impersonal procedures. Historically, the transformation of public policy in the era of the digital revolution in the 21st century is already restrained by the traditions laid down by the practice of the implemented e-government, in which considerable attention is paid to services, information and reactive behavior. E-government becomes "narrow" for evolving digital technology, providing new opportunities for public administration and politics, not only in form but also in content and culture. At the same time, the movement for "e-government 3.0" is gaining momentum, which breaks old habitual forms of interaction between the state and society. Some researchers say that, apparently, it is necessary to abandon the adjective "electronic" in describing the structure and activity of state bodies and to talk either simply about "government 3.0" or to focus on its new mechanisms and the culture of interaction with citizens, using the term "citizen-centric-government". This transition is connected with the technological and political basis of modern structures of coordination of interaction. In particular, it should be noted the notion of "platform", which acquires not only the importance of an open and neutral means of communication, but also a public basis for the formation of new administrative culture. In the process of transforming e-government from portals to platforms, the political nature of the possible use of the state as a platform was manifested. A narrowly technological approach to platforms allowed only to improve the efficiency of service delivery. A broader interpretation spoke of a change in the ideology of public policy, which began to be characterized by such features as the orientation toward citizens inclusion, the cooperation of the main stakeholders in the development of public decisions, the discursive practice of setting the agenda, and so on. And here collaboration may now lead to a new role of the state: a state that rather enables and empowers the social creation of value by its citizens. It protects the infrastructure of P2P cooperation and the creation of commons and of collaborative administrative culture. In the process of critically examining the possibilities of digital ICTs that have arisen in the course of the post-industrial (fourth) revolution, two main questions arise, to which optimists and pessimists respond in different ways. The first question touches on the problem of the depth of the transformation of technology: How revolutionary are the new ICTs, so that it can be said about their fundamental difference from the previous media and communication? The second question is related to the first and concerns the revolutionizing influence of ICT on political practice and relations: Do new ICTs require new policies and governance? Is there something radically new in this process of the digitalization of public space? Under these conditions, the question arises of how the administrative culture of public governance is transformed under a digitalization of society and politics. Can we just talk about its adaptation to the changing requirements of digitalization? Or do we observe a kind of digital governance and policy that radically changes the principles, methods, attitudes and norms of administrative activity? What is this policy of digital governance and how does digital culture shape its administrative culture? What role do the processes of learning to act and interact (both within the administrative bodies and among them and the citizens) on the basis of cooperation, reciprocity and mutual responsibility play in this process of forming / adapting the administrative culture?

POLICY TOPICS
OTHER
P03. Social Policy Instruments Beyond the ‘Three Worlds’: Substantive Findings, Conceptual Issues and Methodological Challenges
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
H. Bolukbasi
K. Oektem
ABSTRACT

Over the past two decades or so, many countries in the Global South have radically transformed their social protection systems. In some cases, this transformation entailed a massive expansion of new policy instruments, such as conditional cash transfers, and a simultaneous retrenchment of older instruments that we now label ‘social policy by other means’ or the ‘hidden welfare state’. Furthermore, in key social policy areas, such as pensions and health, countries introduced far-reaching reforms that helped them make headways towards achieving the goal of universal social protection coverage enshrined in the Sustainable Development Goals. At the same time, however, these reforms often also meant a severe retrenchment of social rights for citizens who had traditionally been protected by the social security system. This janus-faced transformation of social protection systems in many areas of the Global South has led to a new scholarly interest in social policies beyond the ‘three worlds of welfare capitalism’. The ‘geography of comparative welfare state research’ (Hort, 2005) has clearly shifted from the ‘eighteen to twenty rich capitalist countries’ in the OECD area (Esping-Andersen, 1994: 713) to a more diverse set of countries including parts of Latin America, East Asia and Africa (Huber and Niedzwiecki 2015). As a result, accounts of the emergence, expansion and reform of social policies in the Global South have proliferated. Scholars have produced authoritative accounts in particular of developments in Latin America and East Asia. Today, we know far more about social policy beyond the three worlds. Yet, we believe that the study of Southern social policy has more to offer than just provide insights into Southern social policy. We believe that existing scholarship on the ‘three worlds’ has the potential to transplant classic methodologies, concepts and theories used in comparative social policy to the study of these new areas. The classics grew out of the study of the ‘three worlds’, which were at that time seen as the most advanced social protection systems in the world. The methodologies and measurements used to study these worlds have been devised with the goal of understanding Northern welfare states. The concepts they used grew out of an attempt at making sense of dynamics in classic welfare states. For example, the Swedish case, viewed widely as the ideal-typical welfare state, has had an outsize influence in shaping the research agenda. It remains an open question whether and to what extent these measurements, concepts and theories that have been developed for the study of the classic welfare states really allow us to understand the new cases and thus help us make valid comparisons between old and new ‘worlds’.

POLICY TOPICS
OTHER
P04. Harm Reduction, Public Policy, and Moral Controversy: Principle and Practice
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Klein
G. Johnson
ABSTRACT

Harm reduction is a public policy approach that seeks to reduce the harmful risks and consequences of controversial behaviours without moral condemnation or legal prohibition of the behaviour itself. It originated in the context of grassroots activism and local public health practice related to drug policy. While harm reduction may defy precise definition as a public policy approach, its concept components include value neutrality as to the underlying behaviour; humanism and non-punishment, valuing pragmatism over symbolism, and positive construction of the subject as a full citizen with rights, responsibilities and dignity. The language and concepts of harm reduction are increasingly being mobilized in higher reaches of policymaking and law, in a variety of domains. Harm reduction is most visibly reflected in higher levels of state and international policy in relation to drugs (most notably in relation to the opioid crisis and to cannabis legalization), but it is also increasingly used in policy and advocacy in relation to other areas, including, sex work, abortion, tobacco, mental health, and physician-assisted dying, among others. In light of this rapid scaling-up, this panel seeks to describe and define how harm reduction is variously understood in policy discourse across these domains and institutions, to examine its normative bases and limitations, and to consider its promise and risks as a public policy paradigm.

POLICY TOPICS
OTHER
P05. Roundtable on the Contributions of Professor Richard Rose to Public Policy
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
B. Peters
R. Rose
ABSTRACT

Professor Rose is the recipient of the IPPA Lifetime Achievement Award for 2019. This panel will be a roundtable to discuss his various contributions to public policy studies. The participants are : - Richard Rose, University of Strathclyde - Claudio Radaelli, University College London - Marleen Brans, KU Leuven - Claire Dunlop, University of Exeter

POLICY TOPICS
OTHER
P06. Publication Strategies: A Conversation with the Editors
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Bellodi
ABSTRACT

This Roundtable is organised by Early Career Network Speakers: Isabelle Engeli, editor of the European Journal of Political Research (Wiley-Blackwell) Iris Geva-May, founding editor-in-chief of Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis (Routledge) Michael Howlett, editor-in-chief of Policy Sciences (Springer Science), editor of Comparative Public Policy (Cambridge University Press), co-editor of Policy & Society (Taylor & Francis) and co-editor-in-chief of Policy Design & Practice (Taylor & Francis) Michael Jones, editor-in-chief of Policy Studies Journal (Wiley-Blackwell) Peter John, senior editor of Journal of Public Policy (Cambridge University Press) Claudio Radaelli, editor-in-chief of the International Review of Public Policy (OpenEdition)

POLICY TOPICS
OTHER
P07. IPPA Best Book Award
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Skogstad
ABSTRACT
—
POLICY TOPICS
OTHER
C01. Social Policy Design
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Ramesh
ABSTRACT

The module offers a critical introduction to essential concepts, approaches, and analytical tools in social policy, with emphasis on developing country contexts. The objective is to improve social policies through better design based on understanding of both the innate problem and the context in which it exists. Adopting a problem-solving approach, we will explore policy strategies for addressing social problems. We will focus on the context of social policies, and the forms in which they are delivered and financed.

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
C02. Policy Change: Populism as a Case of Tectonic Change?
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Pal
ABSTRACT

The turbulence of the last decade, particularly its manifestation in “populism,” has challenged many of our theories of policy-making and policy change, which typically rest on gradualist foundations. Agenda-setting takes place in an ordered way, even under the assumptions of the multiple streams approach. Analysis is driven by empirical evidence and (mostly) rational debate. Implementation is conducted by trusted state and non-state actors, according to principles of efficiency and feasibility. Populist movements, demands, and governments have up-ended normal policy-making: agendas are crowded with unexpected and (for many) unwelcome priorities; analysis is displaced by emotion and experts mocked; and state agencies and organs are deeply distrusted. The workshop is organized around three themes. The first is populism itself as a phenomenon–what does it mean, what are its contours, and what challenges does it pose to “normal” policy-making in liberal democratic systems? The second is theories of policy change and how well they equip us to understand the change that is tectonic, not incremental. The third is the impact of populism on policy making, both in terms of processes and agendas. Are the impacts visible, are they minor or major, and will they last? Participants are encouraged to discuss their own work as it bears on any of these themes. They will be invited to submit short (100 word) abstracts for circulation before the workshop.

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
C03. The Politics of Policymaking, a Pragmatist Construcvist Approach
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Zittoun
ABSTRACT

The course proposed to examin the main research question, concepts and theory elements of a construcvist and pragmatist approach to study empirically the Policy Process. Inspired by Pragmatist Philosophy (Dewey, James), by Pragmatist Sociology (Boltanski, Latour) and by the linguistic Turn in Social Sciences, this approach proposes to observe the policymakers "in action" involved in the policy process to impose a policy solution in the policy process and to understand it as a political activities. This approach proposes to take into account the cognitive skill and the discursive capacity of the stakeholders and the policymakers not only to define a wicked problem but also to transform it as treatable problem which can be solved and to match it to a policy solution. Ref. P. Zittoun, "The political process of Policymaking, a pragmatist approach on public policy"

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
C04. Deliberative Policy Analysis and the Argumentative Turn
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
F. Fischer
ABSTRACT

This half day course presents the history and development of the argumentative turn in public policy, including the numerous related developments over the 25 years. As a challenge to the dominant (neo)positivist approach to policy studies, the topics range from Habermas’s critical theory of communication action, Foucault’s discursive politics, Toulmin’s argumentation theory and rhetorical analysis, discourse coalitions, deliberative democracy, participatory governance, participatory research and local knowledge, among others. The discussion then turns to an examination of the reflexive epistemological foundations upon which the approach rests, social constructivism and interpretive social science in particular. Moving from epistemology to methodology, the method of deliberative policy analysis is presented, along with various institutional innovations that have accompanied it. The uses of the perspective for policy studies generally are illustrated through a comparison with the advocacy coalition theory. Finally, the course concludes with one or two specific case studies related to participatory governance, discursive politics and deliberative policy analysis.

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
C05. An Introduction to the Narrative Policy Framework
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
M. Jones
E. Shanahan
T. Birkland
ABSTRACT

The Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) is a systematic approach to narrative policy analysis that allows both qualitative and quantitative methodologies. While developed only in 2010, the NPF has seen rapid adoption, appearing in academic journals such as Critical Policy Studies, Policy Sciences, the Policy Studies Journal, as well as being featured in Paul Sabatier’s and now Chris Weible’s classic Theories of the Policy Process, 3rd & 4th editions. This lecture offers a three-hour rendering of the NPF with the aim of providing students both breadth and depth sufficient to begin to apply the framework within their own research. Topics covered include an overview of the framework, experimental NPF applications, content analysis, and the NPF, as well as qualitative methods and the NPF. The lecture culminates in an opportunity for students to actively engage some of the NPF’s commonly employed methodologies.

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
C06. Objectivity and Subjectivity in Policy Research
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
A. Wolf
ABSTRACT

Scientific evidence (the ‘gold-standard’ for which is the randomised-control trial), analyses of big data or costs and benefits and actuarial models and other similar approaches occupy a privileged position in the policy decision-making environment due to arguments for the superiority of ‘objective’ methods. This course starts with a critical examination of that claim to privilege and exposes some often overlooked limitations and ambiguities associated with it. Yet even if subjectivity is inevitable, some hold that its exercise should be restricted to the political or decision-making process. Accordingly, the course next turns to a critical examination of subjectivity in policy research and the tensions researchers may experience when it comes to exercising their subjective judgment in an inhospitable environment. The prospective comparative case study exemplifies methodologically the interaction of subjectivity and objectivity in policy-relevant research. In this type of casework, a researcher uses existing policy experiences as ‘sources’ to develop hypothetical pictures of future improved outcomes in a ‘target’ situation to which lessons from the sources have been applied (Wolf & Baehler, 2018). The success of the method hinges on the researcher’s ability to judge what is relevant, to gain new ideas worth thinking further about, to integrate a wide range of their own and others’ experiences and so on. This method illustrates the subjective exercise of abduction and phronesis in research. Participants will workshop how their judgment is already, and could or should be, employed in their current research. Additional methods will be introduced according to participants’ interests. Reference: Wolf, A., & Baehler, K., (2018). Learning transferable lessons from single cases in comparative policy analysis. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice, 20 (4), pp. 420–434

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
C07. Agenda Setting and Interest Groups
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
L. Chaqués Bonafont
ABSTRACT

This workshop provides a general overview of the current state of agenda setting theory. The first part of the session reviews the most influential approaches to the study of agenda setting, from the policy streams, punctuated equilibrium and policy advocacy coalition frameworks. The goal is to compare how these approaches explain agenda dynamics from a critical perspective. From here, the workshop explores the applicability of these approaches across political venues, countries, time and levels of governance. The last part of the workshop offers a general overview of the different methodological approaches to the study of agenda setting. The course is offered to Master and PhD students willing to develop agenda setting research.

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
C08. Analyzing Policy Elites
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Hassenteufel
ABSTRACT

The aim of this course is to show how it is empirically possible to analyze the key role of collective actors structured around a policy change program (“programmatic actors”) in the policy process. The proposed method (used in different empirical cases in Europe, in the USA, in Latin America, in Japan…) combines different methods from the sociology of elites (positional, reputational, relational and decisional methods) and public policy analysis (cognitive and decision analysis). It enables groups of relevant elites to be identified, their degree of cohesion to be analyzed, and the power they exert through their capacity to impose the public action programs they support to be understood. Once the trajectories of these actors have been analyzed, a more endogenous explanatory framework for the transformation of public policies can be provided.

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
C09. Qualitative Interview of Policymakers
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
P. Zittoun
ABSTRACT

This workshop proposes to discuss and to train participants to the art and craft of qualitative interview of Policymakers. After discussing on the epistemologic and the methodological biaises of the Qualitiative Interview, the workshop proposes different practical exercices for participants to learn how to proceed. Ref. Becker Howard, Tricks of the Trade: How to Think about Your Research While You're Doing It, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1998

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
C10. Historical Institutionalist Approaches to Understanding Policy Development and Change
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Skogstad
ABSTRACT

This workshop examines the current state of research by historical institutionalist scholars to explain policy change and development over time. It gives primary attention to theorizing regarding how antecedentpolicy choices affect subsequent policy development through self-reinforcing and self-undermining mechanisms of policy feedback. Under exploration are the interactive effects of policy feedback mechanisms and the broader institutional and ideational context of policy development.

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
C11. Policy Instruments: what they are, how they are selected, what effects they drive
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
G. Capano
ABSTRACT

Policy instruments have become a fundamental topic in public policy. Policy instruments are the way through which governments do their job to steer policies and are the means through which they try to change the performance of existing policies. The relevance of policy instruments (in every stage of the policy-making) has progressively been recognized, above all because policy instruments represent one of the main research questions to which policy scholars address their investigations. This workshop will focus on and collectively discuss the following issues: the types of instruments that governments have at their disposal for doing their job; why and how policy-makers decide to adopt specific policy instruments and not others; the complex question of the policy effects and of the performance of the adopted instruments

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
C12. Global Policy and Transnational Administration
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
D. Stone
K. Moloney
ABSTRACT

This workshop provides a public administration and policy studies perspective on our emergent transnational public sector. One objective is to stretch public administration concepts familiar to the domestic space to understand the administrative life within transnationally-administered spaces. For example, this includes questions about the interaction of global public good with administrative sovereignty, administrative law, evaluation, and accountability. Another objective is to advance and extend the existing tool-box of policy concepts and theories into new domains of policy making beyond the state to consider: the policy entrepreneurship of international associations; the financing and delivery of public goods and services by global public-private partnerships, the international policy coordination roles of trans-governmental networks, the fast growing new breed of so-called ‘informal’ international organisations like the G20, and the accountability, administrative law, and whistleblowing challenges of international organizations. Participants in this half day workshop will develop a greater appreciation of how policy studies and public administration are moving away from foundations in ‘methodological nationalism’ to the development of approaches and conceptsthat capture the dynamics of the growing global public sector through incorporation of ‘methodological transnationalism’ in our analysis.

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
C13. Policy instruments and governance
VIEW
PANEL CHAIR(S)
C. Halpern
ABSTRACT

The aim of the proposed workshop is to use policy instruments as an organizing concept, which allows to focusing attention on the process of instrumentation, namely, the set of problems posed by the choice and use of instruments (techniques, methods of operation, devices) that allow government policy to be made material and operational (Lascoumes, Le Galès 2007). This approach enables a new important set of questions to be posed in regards to evolving forms of governance within different political systems. It questions the work done on the uses of statistics, indicators and other ranking tools (Power 1997; Espeland, Mitchell, 2008) and their effects, which are sometimes analysed in terms of “new bureaucratic revolutions” (Espeland, Sauder, 2007; Galès, Scott, 2008). Admittedly, the diffusion of such techniques, at least for the last thirty years, constitutes a fundamental trend in the restructuring of policies and governance in a number of national contexts. In relationship with the diffusion of neoliberal ideas, it also resulted into the adoption of specific instruments aimed at organizing competition, performance and sanction. Yet the sociology of numbers argues that such developments are not exclusively related to neo-liberal dynamics, but rather to the changes resulting from the rise of new technologies (computing, communication, big data). Moreover, Weberian sociologists suggest that the introduction of such techniques often results from the quest, by administrative elites, for renewed policy capabilities (Bezes et al. 2018) or in a context in which classic forms of political regulation have failed. This workshop aims at bringing together scholars currently conducting research on policy instruments in different national contexts to examine the link between policy instrument and governance. Proposals linking the analysis of a specific case study with theoretical and / or methodological thoughts are encouraged.

POLICY TOPICS
Preconference
No panel matches your filters.